The influence of otitis media with effusion on middle-ear impedance estimated from wideband acoustic immittance measurements

Wideband Absorbance Predicts the Severity of Conductive Hearing Loss in Children With Otitis Media With Effusion

OBJECTIVES

The objectives of the present study were to investigate the relationship between wideband absorbance (WBA) and air-bone gap (ABG) in children with a conductive hearing loss (CHL) due to otitis media with effusion (OME) and determine the accuracy of WBA to predict the magnitude of ABGs.

DESIGN

This was a prospective, cross-sectional study involving a control group of 170 healthy ears from 130 children (mean age 7.7 years) and a CHL cohort of 181 ears from 176 children (mean age 5.9 years) with OME. The CHL cohort was divided into three groups: CHL1, CHL2, and CHL3 defined by mean ABG (averaged across 0.5 to 4 kHz) of 16 to 25 dB, 26 to 35 dB, and 36 to 45 dB, respectively. WBA was measured at frequencies from 0.25 to 8 kHz at ambient pressure.

RESULTS

WBA was significantly reduced between 0.25 and 5 kHz for all CHL groups. The difference in WBA at 1 to 4 kHz between the control and CHL groups increased with increasing ABG. The predictive accuracy, as indicated by area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) of WBA, increased with increasing ABG. The AUROC for WBA at 1.5 kHz was 0.86 for the CHL1, 0.91 for the CHL2, and 0.93 for the CHL3 group. The AUROCs for WBA averaged across 0.5 to 4 kHz were 0.88, 0.93, and 0.94 for the CHL1, CHL2, and CHL3 groups, respectively. Linear regression analyses showed significant negative correlations between WBA 0.5-4 k and ABG 0.5-4 k . The regression model (ABG 0.5-4 k = 31.83 - 24.08 × WBA 0.5-4 k ) showed that WBA 0.5-4 k predicted ABG 0.5-4 k with high accuracy. Comparison of predicted and actual WBA on a different group of subjects revealed that at an individual level, the model predicted ABG between 16 and 35 with greater precision.

CONCLUSIONS

There were significant strong correlations between WBA and ABG such that WBA decreased with increasing ABG. WBA demonstrated good discrimination accuracy with AUROC exceeding 0.88 for the 0.5 to 4 kHz and 1 to 4 kHz frequency bands. The WBA test holds promise for determining the severity of CHL in children with OME.

The influence of tympanic-membrane orientation on acoustic ear-canal quantities: A finite-element analysis

Assuming plane waves, ear-canal acoustic quantities, collectively known as wideband acoustic immittance (WAI), are frequently used in research and in the clinic to assess the conductive status of the middle ear. Secondary applications include compensating for the ear-canal acoustics when delivering stimuli to the ear and measuring otoacoustic emissions. However, the ear canal is inherently non-uniform and terminated at an oblique angle by the conical-shaped tympanic membrane (TM), thus potentially confounding the ability of WAI quantities in characterizing the middle-ear status. This paper studies the isolated possible confounding effects of TM orientation and shape on characterizing the middle ear using WAI in human ears. That is, the non-uniform geometry of the ear canal is not considered except for that resulting from the TM orientation and shape. This is achieved using finite-element models of uniform ear canals terminated by both lumped-element and finite-element middle-ear models. In addition, the effects on stimulation and reverse-transmission quantities are investigated, including the physical significance of quantities seeking to approximate the sound pressure at the TM. The results show a relatively small effect of the TM orientation on WAI quantities, except for a distinct delay above 10 kHz, further affecting some stimulation and reverse-transmission quantities.

Wideband frequency impedance for diagnosis of ossicular chain abnormality

BACKGROUND

The accurate estimation of the ossicular chain abnormalities using existing functional examinations has been difficult.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to verify the accuracy of preoperative diagnosis of ossicular chain abnormalities using a wideband frequency impedance (WFI) meter, which can measure the dynamic characteristics of the middle ear.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Retrospective cohort study. Fourteen ears of patients with ossicular chain abnormalities that were definitively diagnosed surgically were included in this study. The following data were collected for each participant: sound pressure level (SPL) curve measured using the WFI meter and a sweep frequency impedance (SFI) meter, WFI measurements plotted on the resonance frequency (RF)-ΔSPL plane, distribution map of the dynamic characteristics of the middle ear, preoperative audiometry results, and the definitive surgical diagnosis.

RESULTS

The SPL curve obtained using the WFI meter had lesser noise than that obtained using the SFI meter. The distribution map revealed that the ossicular chain separation range and ossicular chain fixation range were completely separated. The hearing data tended to be poor in cases with small ΔSPL.

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

WFI can potentially enhance the accuracy of SFI. In addition, it can also be used for the classification of ossicular chain separation and fixation as well as the quantification of fixation in cases of ossicular chain anomalies that cannot be diagnosed using conventional tests.

Conductive Hearing Loss Estimated From Wideband Acoustic Immittance Measurements in Ears With Otitis Media With Effusion

OBJECTIVES

Previous work has shown that wideband acoustic immittance (WAI) is sensitive to the volume of effusion present in ears with otitis media with effusion (OME). Prior work also demonstrates that the volume of the effusion appears to drive, or at least play a significant role in, how much conductive hearing loss (CHL) a child has due to a given episode of OME. Given this association, the goal of this work was to determine how well CHL could be estimated directly from WAI in ears with OME.

DESIGN

Sixty-three ears from a previously published study on OME (ages 9 months to 11 years, 2 months) were grouped based on effusion volume (full, partial, or clear) determined during tympanostomy tube placement surgery and compared with age-matched normal control ears. Audiometric thresholds were obtained for a subset of the 34 ears distributed across the four groups. An electrical-analog model of ear-canal acoustics and middle-ear mechanics was fit to the measured WAI from individual ears. Initial estimates of CHL were derived from either (1) average absorbance or (2) the model component thought to represent damping in the ossicular chain.

RESULTS

The analog model produced good fits for all effusion-volume groups. The two initial CHL estimates were both well correlated (87% and 81%) with the pure-tone average hearing thresholds used to define the CHL. However, in roughly a third of the ears (11/34), the estimate based on damping was too large by nearly a factor of two. This observation motivated improved CHL estimates.

CONCLUSIONS

Our CHL estimation method can estimate behavioral audiometric thresholds (CHL) within a margin of error that is small enough to be clinically meaningful. The importance of this finding is increased by the challenges associated with behavioral audiometric testing in pediatric populations, where OME is the most common. In addition, the discovery of two clusters in the damping-related CHL estimate suggests the possible existence of two distinctly different types of ears: pressure detectors and power detectors.

Comments on forward pressure and other reflectance-based quantities for delivering stimuli to the ear

The forward pressure has been proposed as an "optimal" reflectance-based quantity for delivering stimuli to the ear during evoked otoacoustic-emission measurements and audiometry. It is motivated by and avoids detrimental stimulus-level errors near standing-wave antiresonance frequencies when levels are adjusted in situ. While enjoying widespread popularity within research, the forward pressure possesses certain undesirable properties, some of which complicate its implementation into commercial otoacoustic-emission instruments conforming to existing international standards. These properties include its inability to approximate the total sound pressure anywhere in the ear canal and its discrepancy from the sound pressure at the tympanic membrane, which depends directly on the reflectance. This paper summarizes and comments on such properties of the forward pressure. Further, based on previous published data, alternative reflectance-based quantities that do not share these properties are investigated. A complex integrated pressure, with magnitude identical to the previously proposed scalar integrated pressure, is suggested as a suitable quantity for avoiding standing-wave errors when delivering stimuli to the ear. This complex integrated pressure approximates the magnitude and phase of the sound pressure at the tympanic membrane and can immediately be implemented into standardized commercial instruments to take advantage of improved stimulus-level accuracy and reproducibility in the clinic.