Health economic analysis of the Swedish neonatal metabolic screening programme. A method of optimizing routines

Newborn screening by tandem mass spectrometry for medium-chain Acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency: a cost-effectiveness analysis

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether newborn screening by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) for medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (MCADD) is cost-effective versus not screening and to define the contributions of disease, test, and population parameters on the decision.

METHODS

A decision-analytic Markov model was designed to perform cost-effectiveness and cost-utility analyses measuring the discounted, incremental cost per life-year saved and per quality-adjusted life-year saved of newborn screening for MCADD compared with not screening. A hypothetical cohort of neonates made transitions among a set of health states that reflected clinical status, morbidity, and cost. Outcomes were estimated for time horizons of 20 and 70 years. Probabilities and costs were derived from a retrospective chart review of a 32-patient cohort treated over the past 30 years at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, clinical experience with MCADD patient management, patient-family interviews, cost surveys, state sources, and published studies. In addition to older patients who came to medical attention by symptomatic presentation, our patient group included 6 individuals whose MCADD had been diagnosed by supplemental newborn screening. Estimates of the expected net changes in costs and life expectancy for MCADD screening were used to compute the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios. Sensitivity analyses were performed on key input variables, and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were computed through second-order Monte Carlo simulations.

RESULTS

In our base-case analysis over the first 20 years of life, the cost of newborn screening for MCADD was approximately 11,000 dollars(2001 US dollars; 95% CI: <0-33,800 dollars) per life-year saved, or 5600 dollars (95% CI: <0-17,100 dollars) per quality-adjusted life-year saved compared with not screening. Over a 70-year horizon, the respective ratios were approximately 300 dollars (95% CI: <0-13,000 dollars) and 100 dollars (95% CI: <0-6900 dollars). The results were robust when tested over plausible ranges for diagnostic test sensitivity and specificity, MCADD prevalence, asymptomatic rate, and screening cost.

CONCLUSIONS

Simulation modeling indicates that newborn screening for MCADD reduces morbidity and mortality at an incremental cost below the range for accepted health care interventions. At the 70-year horizon, the model predicts that almost all of the additional costs of screening would be offset by avoided sequelae.

Secondary analysis of economic data: a review of cost-benefit studies of neonatal screening for phenylketonuria

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To estimate the net financial benefit of neonatal screening for phenylketonuria (PKU): by a simple pooling of cost data from the literature; and by a more complex modelling approach.

DESIGN

A systematic literature review was conducted to identify papers containing data on the monetary costs and benefits of neonatal screening for PKU. The methodological quality of the studies was appraised, and data were extracted on resource use and expenditure. Monetary data were converted to common currency units, and standardised to UK incidence rates. Net benefits were calculated for median, best case and worst case scenarios, and the effect of excluding poor quality studies and data was tested. The net benefit was also estimated from a model based on data from the literature and assumptions appropriate for the current UK situation. Extensive sensitivity analysis was conducted.

MAIN RESULTS

The direct net benefit of screening based on the median costs and benefits from the 13 studies identified was 143,400 Pounds per case detected and treated (39,000 Pounds and 241,800 Pounds for worst case and best case scenarios respectively). The direct net benefit obtained by the modelling approach was lower at 93,400 Pounds per case detected and treated. Screening remained cost saving under sensitivity analysis, except with low residential care costs (less than 12,300 Pounds per annum), or very low incidence rates (less than 1 in 27,000).

CONCLUSIONS

The economic literature on PKU screening is of variable quality. The two methods of secondary analysis lead to the same conclusion: that neonatal PKU screening is worthwhile in financial terms alone in the UK, and that it justifies the infrastructure for collecting and testing neonatal blood samples. This result cannot necessarily be extrapolated to other countries.

Health economic analysis of the neonatal screening program in Japan

In Japan, a nationwide mass screening system for neonatal metabolic diseases was established in 1977. This system consisted of screening programs for five main congenital metabolic diseases, including phenylketonuria (PKU). To evaluate the efficiency of the mass screening system, a cost-benefit analysis of the screening program for PKU (as a typical case in Japan) was carried out. The costs of the detection and the treatment program were compared with the projected benefit (avoided costs) that results from prevention of the mental retardation associated with the disorders due to PKU. Costs and benefits were discounted at an annual rate of 7%. Assuming that the incidence of PKU was 1/80,500 and the total number of infants screened was 1.2 million, net benefits for the screening program were $283,000, and the cost-benefit ratio was 1:2.5. The sensitivity analysis for the incidence of PKU showed that the cost-benefit ratios exceeded one.