Paramagnetic rims are a promising diagnostic imaging biomarker in multiple sclerosis

Understanding multiple sclerosis as a disease spectrum: above and below the clinical threshold

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Research in multiple sclerosis (MS) has long been predicated on clinical groupings that do not reflect the underlying biologic heterogeneity apparent within patient populations. This review explicates the various levels of explanation through which the spectrum of disease is described and investigated both above and below the clinical threshold of detection, as framed by the topographical model of MS, to help advance a cogent mechanistic framework.

RECENT FINDINGS

Contemporary evidence has amended the view of MS as consisting of sequential disease phases in favor of a spectrum of disease with an admixture of interdependent and dynamic pathobiological axes driving tissue injury and progression. Recent studies have shown the presence of acute and compartmentalized inflammation and mechanisms of neurodegeneration beginning early and evolving throughout the disease continuum. Still, the gap between the understanding of immunopathologic processes in MS and the tools used to measure relevant molecular, laboratory, radiologic, and clinical metrics needs attention to enable better prognostication of disease and monitoring for changes along specific pathologic axes and variable treatment outcomes.

SUMMARY

Aligning on a consistently-applied mechanistic framework at distinct levels of explanation will enable greater precision across bench and clinical research, and inform discourse on drivers of disability progression and delivery of care for individuals with MS.

Multiple Sclerosis: Clinical Update and Clinically-Oriented Radiologic Reporting

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory disease of the nervous system. MR imaging findings play an integral part in establishing diagnostic hallmarks of the disease during initial diagnosis and evaluating disease status. Multiple iterations of diagnostic criteria and consensus guidelines are put forth by various expert groups incorporating imaging of the brain and spine, and efforts have been made to standardize imaging protocols for MS. Emerging ancillary imaging findings have also attracted increasing interests and should be sought for on radiologic examination. In this paper, the authors review the clinical guidelines and approach to imaging of MS and related disorders, focusing on clinically impactful image interpretation and MR imaging reporting.

Emerging imaging markers in radiologically isolated syndrome: implications for earlier treatment initiation

The presence of central nervous system lesions fulfilling the criteria of dissemination in space and time on MRI leads to the diagnosis of a radiologically isolated syndrome (RIS), which may be an early sign of multiple sclerosis (MS). However, some patients who do not fulfill the necessary criteria for RIS still evolve to MS, and some T2 hyperintensities that resemble demyelinating lesions may originate from mimics. In light of the recent recognition of the efficacy of disease-modifying therapy (DMT) in RIS, it is relevant to consider additional imaging features that are more specific of MS. We performed a narrative review on cortical lesions (CL), the central vein sign (CVS), and paramagnetic rim lesions (PRL) in patients with RIS. In previous RIS studies, the reported prevalence of CLs ranges between 20.0 and 40.0%, CVS + white matter lesions (WMLs) between 87.0 and 93.0% and PRLs between 26.7 and 63.0%. Overall, these imaging findings appear to be frequent in RIS cohorts, although not consistently taken into account in previous studies. The search for CLs, CVS + WML and PRLs in RIS patients could lead to earlier identification of patients who will evolve to MS and benefit from DMTs.

Paramagnetic rim lesions and the central vein sign: Characterizing multiple sclerosis imaging markers

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Paramagnetic rims and the central vein sign (CVS) are proposed imaging markers of multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions. Using 7 tesla magnetic resonance imaging, we aimed to: (1) characterize the appearance of paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs); (2) assess whether PRLs and the CVS are associated with higher levels of MS pathology; and (3) compare the characteristics between subjects with and without PRLs in early MS.

METHODS

Prospective study of 32 treatment-naïve subjects around the time of diagnosis who were assessed for the presence of PRLs and the CVS. Comparisons of lesion volume and macromolecular pool size ratio (PSR) index, a proxy of myelin integrity, between PRLs and non-PRLs, and CVS-positive and CVS-negative lesions were carried out. Differences in clinical/demographic characteristics between patients with PRLs and those without were tested.

RESULTS

Fifteen subjects had ≥1 PRL for a total of 36 PRLs, of which two-thirds had a full rim. PRLs predicted a larger lesion size and decreased PSR signal. Lesion volume and presence of cervical spine lesions were significantly different between subjects with PRLs and those without, although neither remained significant after adjusting for multiple comparisons. One hundred and eighty-one lesions with CVS were identified with no differences between CVS-positive and CVS-negative lesions in volume (p = .27) and PSR values (p = .62).

CONCLUSIONS

PRLs, but not CVS-positive lesions, are larger and have lower myelin integrity. Our findings indicate that PRLs are associated with higher levels of lesion-specific pathology prior to the start of disease-modifying therapy.

Cervical spinal cord susceptibility-weighted MRI at 7T: Application to multiple sclerosis

BACKGROUND

Susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI) has been extensively studied in the brain and in diseases of the central nervous system such as multiple sclerosis (MS) providing unique opportunities to visualize cerebral vasculature and disease-related pathology, including the central vein sign (CVS) and paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs). However, similar studies evaluating SWI in the spinal cord of patients with MS remain severely limited.

PURPOSE

Based on our previous findings of enlarged spinal vessels in MS compared to healthy controls (HCs), we developed high-field SWI acquisition and processing methods for the cervical spinal cord with application in people with MS (pwMS) and HCs. Here, we demonstrate the vascular variability between the two cohorts and unique MS lesion features in the cervical cord.

METHODS

In this retrospective, exploratory pilot study conducted between March 2021 and March 2022, we scanned 12 HCs and 9 pwMS using an optimized non-contrast 2D T2*-weighted gradient echo sequence at 7 tesla. The overall appearance of the white and gray matter as well as tissue vasculature were compared between the two cohorts and areas of MS pathology in the patient group were assessed using both the magnitude and processed SWI images.

RESULTS

We show improved visibility of vessels and more pronounced gray and white matter contrast in the MS group compared to HCs, hypointensities surrounding the cord in the MS cohort, and identify signal changes indicative of the CVS and paramagnetic rims in 66 % of pwMS with cervical spinal lesions.

CONCLUSION

In this first study of SWI at 7T in the human spinal cord, SWI holds promise in advancing our understanding of disease processes in the cervical cord in MS.

Susceptibility-based imaging aids accurate distinction of pediatric-onset MS from myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein antibody-associated disease

BACKGROUND

Myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) antibody-associated disease (MOGAD) and pediatric-onset multiple sclerosis (POMS) share clinical and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) features but differ in prognosis and management. Early POMS diagnosis is essential to avoid disability accumulation. Central vein sign (CVS), paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs), and central core lesions (CCLs) are susceptibility-based imaging (SbI)-related signs understudied in pediatric populations that may help discerning POMS from MOGAD.

METHODS

T2-FLAIR and SbI (three-dimensional echoplanar imaging (3D-EPI)/susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI) or similar) were acquired on 1.5T/3T scanners. Two readers assessed CVS-positive rate (%CVS+), and their average score was used to build a receiver operator curve (ROC) assessing the ability to discriminate disease type. PRLs and CCLs were identified using a consensual approach.

RESULTS

The %CVS+ distinguished 26 POMS cases (mean age 13.7 years, 63% females, median EDSS 1.5) from 14 MOGAD cases (10.8 years, 35% females, EDSS 1.0) with ROC = 1, p < 0.0001, (cutoff 41%). PRLs were only detectable in POMS participants (mean 2.1±2.3, range 1-10), discriminating the two conditions with a sensitivity of 69% and a specificity of 100%. CCLs were more sensitive (81%) but less specific (71.43%).

CONCLUSION

The %CVS+ and PRLs are highly specific markers of POMS. After proper validation on larger multicenter cohorts, consideration should be given to including such imaging markers for diagnosing POMS at disease onset.

Reliability of paramagnetic rim lesion classification on quantitative susceptibility mapping (QSM) in people with multiple sclerosis: Single-site experience and systematic review

BACKGROUND

Recent developments in iron-sensitive MRI techniques have enabled visualization of chronic active lesions as paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs) in vivo. Although PRLs have potential as a diagnostic and prognostic tool for multiple sclerosis (MS), limited studies have reported the reliability of PRL assessment. Further evaluation of PRL reliability, through original investigations and review of PRL literature, are warranted.

METHODS

A single-center cohort study was conducted to evaluate the inter-rater reliability of PRL identification on quantitative susceptibiltiy mapping (QSM) in 10 people with MS, 5 people with clinically isolated syndrome, and 5 healthy controls. An additional systematic literature search was then conducted of published PRL reliability data, and these results were synthesized.

RESULTS

In the single-center study, both inter-rater and intra-rater reliability of per-subject PRL number were at an "Excellent" (intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 0.901 for both) level with only 2-years lesion classification experience. Across the reported literature values, reliability of per-lesion rim presence was on average "Near perfect" (for intra-rater; Cohen's κ = 0.833) and "Substantial" (for inter-rater; Cohens κ = 0.687), whereas inter-rater reliability of per-subject PRL number was "Good" (ICC = 0.874). Only 4/22 studies reported complete information on rater experience, rater level of training, detailed PRL classification criteria, and reliability cohort size and disease subtypes.

CONCLUSION

PRLs can be reliably detected both at per-lesion and per-subject level. We recommend that future PRL studies report detailed reliability results, including rater experience level, and use a standardized set of reliability metrics (Cohen's κ or ICC) for improved comparability between studies.

Differential diagnosis of suspected multiple sclerosis: an updated consensus approach

Accurate diagnosis of multiple sclerosis requires careful attention to its differential diagnosis-many disorders can mimic the clinical manifestations and paraclinical findings of this disease. A collaborative effort, organised by The International Advisory Committee on Clinical Trials in Multiple Sclerosis in 2008, provided diagnostic approaches to multiple sclerosis and identified clinical and paraclinical findings (so-called red flags) suggestive of alternative diagnoses. Since then, knowledge of disorders in the differential diagnosis of multiple sclerosis has expanded substantially. For example, CNS inflammatory disorders that present with syndromes overlapping with multiple sclerosis can increasingly be distinguished from multiple sclerosis with the aid of specific clinical, MRI, and laboratory findings; studies of people misdiagnosed with multiple sclerosis have also provided insights into clinical presentations for which extra caution is warranted. Considering these data, an update to the recommended diagnostic approaches to common clinical presentations and key clinical and paraclinical red flags is warranted to inform the contemporary clinical evaluation of patients with suspected multiple sclerosis.

Radiologically Isolated Syndrome and the Multiple Sclerosis Prodrome in Pediatrics: Early Features of the Spectrum of Demyelination

Radiologically isolated syndrome refers to the clinical scenario in which individuals have imaging concerning for multiple sclerosis and would otherwise satisfy radiographic dissemination in space criteria, but do not have any attributable signs or symptoms. Radiologically isolated syndrome has been increasingly recognized in the pediatric population and it is understood certain individuals will transition to a formal diagnosis of multiple sclerosis over time. This review aims to outline the available data within this unique population including the diagnostic criteria, epidemiology, risk factors associated with transitioning to multiple sclerosis, and the current therapeutic landscape. Radiologically isolated syndrome will also be positioned within a broader spectrum of demyelinating disease as recent data has pointed towards a likely prodromal phase that precedes a first clinical event and diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Characterizing the radiographic features, clinical symptoms, and biomarkers that constitute this prodromal phase of multiple sclerosis would help identify patients who may most benefit from early intervention in the future.

Iron Rim Lesions as a Specific and Prognostic Biomarker of Multiple Sclerosis: 3T-Based Susceptibility-Weighted Imaging

This study aimed to identify the clinical significance of iron rim lesions (IRLs) in distinguishing multiple sclerosis (MS) from other central nervous system (CNS) demyelinating diseases, determine the relationship between IRLs and disease severity, and understand the long-term dynamic changes in IRLs in MS. We retrospectively evaluated 76 patients with CNS demyelinating diseases. CNS demyelinating diseases were classified into three groups: MS (n = 30), neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder (n = 23), and other CNS demyelinating diseases (n = 23). MRI images were obtained using conventional 3T MRI including susceptibility-weighted imaging. Sixteen of 76 patients (21.1%) had IRLs. Of the 16 patients with IRLs, 14 were in the MS group (87.5%), indicating that IRLs were significantly specific for MS. In the MS group, patients with IRLs had a significantly higher number of total WMLs, experienced more frequent recurrence, and were treated more with second-line immunosuppressive agents than were patients without IRLs. In addition to IRLs, T1-blackhole lesions were observed more frequently in the MS group than in the other groups. IRLs are specific for MS and could represent a reliable imaging biomarker to improve the diagnosis of MS. Additionally, the presence of IRLs seems to reflect more severe disease progression in MS.

Relationship between paramagnetic rim lesions and slowly expanding lesions in multiple sclerosis

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) markers for chronic active lesions in MS include slowly expanding lesions (SELs) and paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs).

OBJECTIVES

To identify the relationship between SELs and PRLs in MS, and their association with disability.

METHODS

61 people with MS (pwMS) followed retrospectively with MRI including baseline susceptibility-weighted imaging, and longitudinal T1 and T2-weighted scans. SELs were computed using deformation field maps; PRLs were visually identified. Mixed-effects models assessed differences in Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score changes between the group defined by the presence of SELs and or PRLs.

RESULTS

The median follow-up time was 3.2 years. At baseline, out of 1492 lesions, 616 were classified as SELs, and 80 as PRLs. 92% of patients had ⩾ 1 SEL, 56% had ⩾ 1 PRL, while both were found in 51%. SELs compared to non-SELs were more likely to also be PRLs (7% vs. 4%, p = 0.027). PRL counts positively correlated with SEL counts (ρ= 0.28, p = 0.03). SEL + PRL + patients had greater increases in EDSS over time (beta = 0.15/year, 95% confidence interval (0.04, 0.27), p = 0.009) than SEL+PRL-patients.

CONCLUSION

SELs are more numerous than PRLs in pwMS. Compared with either SELs or PRLs found in isolation, their joint occurrence was associated with greater clinical progression.

Present and future of the diagnostic work-up of multiple sclerosis: the imaging perspective

In recent years, the use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the diagnostic work-up of multiple sclerosis (MS) has evolved considerably. The 2017 McDonald criteria show high sensitivity and accuracy in predicting a second clinical attack in patients with a typical clinically isolated syndrome and allow an earlier diagnosis of MS. They have been validated, are evidence-based, simplify the clinical use of MRI criteria and improve MS patients' management. However, to limit the risk of misdiagnosis, they should be applied by expert clinicians only after the careful exclusion of alternative diagnoses. Recently, new MRI markers have been proposed to improve diagnostic specificity for MS and reduce the risk of misdiagnosis. The central vein sign and chronic active lesions (i.e., paramagnetic rim lesions) may increase the specificity of MS diagnostic criteria, but further effort is necessary to validate and standardize their assessment before implementing them in the clinical setting. The feasibility of subpial demyelination assessment and the clinical relevance of leptomeningeal enhancement evaluation in the diagnostic work-up of MS appear more limited. Artificial intelligence tools may capture MRI attributes that are beyond the human perception, and, in the future, artificial intelligence may complement human assessment to further ameliorate the diagnostic work-up and patients' classification. However, guidelines that ensure reliability, interpretability, and validity of findings obtained from artificial intelligence approaches are still needed to implement them in the clinical scenario. This review provides a summary of the most recent updates regarding the application of MRI for the diagnosis of MS.

What is the potential of paramagnetic rim lesions as diagnostic indicators in multiple sclerosis?

INTRODUCTION

In multiple sclerosis (MS), paramagnetic rim lesions (PRLs) on MRI identify a subset of chronic active lesions (CALs), which have been linked through clinical and pathological studies to more severe disease course and greater disability accumulation. Beside their prognostic relevance, increasing evidence supports the use of PRL as a diagnostic biomarker.

AREAS COVERED

This review summarizes the most recent updates regarding the MRI pathophysiology of PRL, their prevalence in MS (by clinical phenotypes) vs mimicking conditions, and their potential role as diagnostic MS biomarkers. We searched PubMed with terms including 'multiple sclerosis' AND 'paramagnetic rim lesions' OR 'iron rim lesions' OR 'rim lesions' for manuscripts published between January 2008 and July 2022.

EXPERT OPINION

Current research suggests that PRL can improve the diagnostic specificity and the overall accuracy of MS diagnosis when used together with the dissemination in space MRI criteria and the central vein sign. Nevertheless, future prospective multicenter studies should further define the real-world prevalence and specificity of PRL. International guidelines are needed to establish methodological criteria for PRL identification before its implementation into clinical practice.