Empirical therapy for nonhospitalized patients with community-acquired pneumonia. Study Group of General Practitioners

Suspected community-acquired pneumonia in an ambulatory setting (CAPA): a French prospective observational cohort study in general practice

Background:

Few studies have addressed the pragmatic management of ambulatory patients with suspected community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) using a precise description of the disease with or without chest X-ray (X-ray) evidence.

Aims:

To describe the characteristics, clinical findings, additional investigations and disease progression in patients with suspected CAP managed by French General Practitioners (GPs).

Methods:

The patients included were older than 18 years, with signs or symptoms suggestive of CAP associated with recent-onset unilateral crackles on auscultation or a new opacity on X-ray. They were followed for up to 6 weeks. Descriptive analyses of all patients and according to their management with X-rays were carried out.

Results:

From September 2011 to July 2012, 886 patients have been consulted by 267 GPs. Among them, 278 (31%) were older than 65 years and 337 (38%) were at increased risk for invasive pneumococcal disease. At presentation, the three most common symptoms, cough (94%), fever (93%), and weakness or myalgia (81%), were all observed in 70% of patients. Unilateral crackles were observed in 77% of patients. Among patients with positive radiography (64%), 36% had no unilateral crackles. A null CRB-65 score was obtained in 62% of patients. Most patients (94%) initially received antibiotics and experienced uncomplicated disease progression regardless of their management with X-rays. Finally, 7% of patients were hospitalised and 0.3% died.

Conclusions:

Most patients consulting GPs for suspected CAP had the three following most common symptoms: cough, fever, and weakness or myalgia. More than a third of them were at increased risk for invasive pneumococcal disease. With or without X-rays, most patients received antibiotics and experienced uncomplicated disease progression.

Defining disease heterogeneity to guide the empirical treatment of febrile illness in resource poor settings

BACKGROUND

Malaria incidence is in decline in many parts of SE Asia leading to a decreasing proportion of febrile illness that is attributable to malaria. However in the absence of rapid, affordable and accurate diagnostic tests, the non-malaria causes of these illnesses cannot be reliably identified. Studies on the aetiology of febrile illness have indicated that the causes are likely to vary by geographical location within countries (i.e. be spatially heterogeneous) and that national empirical treatment policies based on the aetiology measured in a single location could lead to inappropriate treatment.

METHODS

Using data from Vientiane as a reference for the incidence of major febrile illnesses in the Lao People's Democratic Republic (Laos) and estimated incidences, plausible incidence in other Lao provinces were generated using a mathematical model for a range of national and local scale variations. For a range of treatment protocols, the mean number of appropriate treatments was predicted and the potential impact of a spatially explicit national empirical treatment protocol assessed.

FINDINGS

The model predicted a negative correlation between number of appropriate treatments and the level of spatial heterogeneity. A spatially explicit national treatment protocol was predicted to increase the number of appropriate treatments by 50% for intermediate levels of spatial heterogeneity.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that given even only moderate spatial variation, a spatially explicit treatment algorithm will result in a significant improvement in the outcome of undifferentiated fevers in Laos and other similar resource poor settings.

Cost-effectiveness of empirical prescribing of antimicrobials in community-acquired pneumonia in three countries in the presence of resistance

OBJECTIVES

To assess the cost-effectiveness of empirical outpatient treatment options for community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) in France, the USA and Germany, representing high, moderate and low antimicrobial resistance prevalence, respectively.

METHODS

A decision analytic model was developed for mild-to-moderate CAP outpatient treatment. Treatment algorithms incorporated follow-up after treatment failure due to resistance or other reasons. First-line treatment included moxifloxacin, beta-lactams, macrolides or doxycycline; second-line treatment used a different antimicrobial class. Country-specific resistance and co-resistance prevalences to first- and second-line therapy for the major CAP pathogens were derived from surveillance studies. Clinical failure rates due to antimicrobial-susceptible and -resistant pathogens were obtained from the literature or estimated. Total costs were estimated using standard sources and a third-party payer perspective. Outcome measures included first-line clinical failures avoided, second-line treatments avoided and hospitalizations avoided. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were calculated.

RESULTS

First-line moxifloxacin treatment followed by co-amoxiclav dominated all other treatments in France, the USA and in Germany for all outcome measures. Sensitivity analyses maintained moxifloxacin dominance in France and the USA but affected ICERs in some cases in Germany.

CONCLUSIONS

Antimicrobial resistance/spectrum have a significant impact on outcomes and costs in empirical outpatient CAP treatment. Despite low acquisition costs for generic antibiotics, first-line treatment effective against the major CAP pathogens, including strains resistant to other antimicrobials, resulted in better clinical outcomes in all countries and lower treatment costs for all.

Economic evaluation of an extended acellular pertussis vaccine program for adolescents in Québec, Canada

OBJECTIVE

Pertussis is a frequent cause of cough illness in adolescents. In Canada, immunization against pertussis in public programs has been restricted to children under 7 years of age. The purpose of this analysis was to estimate the health and economic impact of an additional booster dose of the acellular vaccine in adolescents in Québec.

METHOD

We performed a cost-effectiveness analysis, based on a predictive spreadsheet dynamic model following a cohort of 90,929 adolescents in Québec from the age of 14 years over a 10-year period from the Québec Ministry of Health (MOH) and societal (SOC) perspectives. The model was used to compare costs (2003 values) and benefits of an adolescent vaccination program (AVP), including a diptheria, tetanus, and acellular pertussis (dTacp) vaccine administered at age 14 years, with current practice.

RESULTS

From the MOH perspective, a booster vaccination of dTacp at age 14 years via the AVP would produce a yearly additional expected cost of Can dollars 1.06 per adolescent with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of Can dollars 480 per pertussis case avoided based on a 10-year period. When outcomes are discounted at 3%, the ICER rises to Can dollars 527 per discounted pertussis case avoided. From the SOC perspective, the AVP would cost Can dollars 0.83 per adolescent per year with an additional cost per avoided pertussis case of Can dollars 377 (Can dollars 414 per additional discounted case of pertussis avoided). Over the 10-year period, 2012 non-discounted cases of pertussis would be prevented with approximately two hospital admissions averted.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that administering a booster dose of dTacp at age 14 years to replace the diptheria and tetanus vaccination will slightly increase the economic burden from MOH and SOC perspectives; however, the number of pertussis cases and the number of hospital admissions will decrease.

Epidemiological survey on incidence and treatment of community acquired pneumonia in Italy

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To estimate annual incidence of community acquired pneumonia (CAP) in an Italian general population sample.

DESIGN AND PARTICIPANTS

Two hundred and eighty-seven family practitioners (64.6% of those selected) recorded suspected or ascertained CAP cases for 1 year. Information on smoking habit, respiratory symptoms and signs, co-morbidity, antibiotic and corticosteroid therapy, hospitalization, mortality and recovery were obtained.

RESULTS

Six hundred and ninety-nine case forms were collected (53.1% females, mean age 59.6+/-19.5, 20.6% smokers). CAP incidence rates per 1000 population were: 1.69 in men vs. 1.71 in women; 2.33 in the North vs. 1.29 in the Centre-South of Italy; between 0.73 in 14-, and 3.34 in 64+year-old subjects. Main symptoms and signs were cough (73.3%), crackles (72.8%), dullness (57.3%), asthenia (53.4%). 59.5% of subjects had concurrent diseases, mostly cardiac and respiratory. 77.2% of cases had chest X-ray (with parenchymal density in 90.6%). Phlegm microbiological examination was performed in 12.8% of cases. First choice antibiotics were cephalosporins (45.8%), macrolides (20.2%), other beta-lactams (18.6%), and fluoroquinolones (12.2%). Rates of hospitalization and of mortality were 31.8% and 6.0%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study confirmed that the annual CAP incidence rate in the general population of South Europe is about 2 per 1000 population and showed a wide choice of antibiotic treatment.

Economic evaluation of an extended acellular pertussis vaccine programme for adolescents in Ontario, Canada

PURPOSE

Pertussis is a frequent cause of cough illness in adolescents. In Canada, until recently immunization against pertussis in public programmes has been restricted to children under the age of 7. The purpose of this analysis was to estimate the health and economic impact of an additional booster dose of the acellular vaccine in adolescents in Ontario.

METHODS

We performed a cost effectiveness analysis, based on a predictive spreadsheet dynamic model following a cohort of 144,000 adolescents in Ontario from the age of 12 years over a 10-year-period from the Ontario Ministry of Health (MoH) and societal perspectives. The model was used to compare costs and benefits of a combined vaccination programme (CVP) including tetanus, diphtheria, and acellular pertussis (dTacp) administered at age 12, compared to current practice.

RESULTS

From the MoH perspective, booster vaccination of dacpT at 12 years via the CVP would produce a yearly additional expected cost of CAD $0.52 per adolescent in Ontario with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of CAD $168 per pertussis case avoided based on a 10-year-period. If outcomes are discounted at 3%, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio rises to $188/discounted pertussis case avoided. From the societal perspective, the CVP would be cost saving CAD $858,106 at 10 years for the cohort. Over the 10-year-period, more than 4400 cases of pertussis would be prevented with approximately 50 hospital admissions averted.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that administering a booster dose of dTacp at 12 years of age to replace diphtheria and tetanus vaccination at 14 years may reduce the economic burden of pertussis treatment in the long term at a reasonable cost.

Appropriate antibiotic utilization in seniors prior to hospitalization for community-acquired pneumonia is associated with decreased in-hospital mortality

BACKGROUND

We analysed the association of mortality and prescription of antibiotics prior to hospitalization for community-acquired pneumonia.

METHODS

We used administrative data (hospital abstracts, physician claims, prescriptions) for seniors (age 61 years and over) for Alberta, Canada from 1 April 1994 to 31 March 1999.

RESULTS

Hospitalization of 21 191 seniors occurred during the study period. In about 43% of hospitalizations (n = 9034), a physician was consulted prior to hospital admission. Antibiotics were dispensed to 31% of those with a prior physician visit and in about 72%, the antibiotic choice was deemed appropriate. The odds for mortality were significantly decreased in those with prior physician visits (OR = 0.87, P < 0.01), with any antibiotic prescription (OR = 0.66, P < 0.0001), and with an appropriate antibiotic (OR = 0.68, P = 0.03). The choice of an appropriate antibiotic as opposed to an inappropriate antibiotic resulted in a 2.6% absolute and 38% relative mortality reduction.

CONCLUSION

Choosing an appropriate outpatient antibiotic in accordance with published expert opinion guidelines compared with inappropriate antibiotic prescriptions decreased hospital mortality in patients subsequently hospitalized for community-acquired pneumonia.

Do guidelines for community-acquired pneumonia improve the cost-effectiveness of hospital care?

There is growing pressure to demonstrate the value of practice guidelines. We have reviewed the evidence that guidelines for the treatment of community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) change current practices and that the standardization of practices reduces costs and/or improves outcome. The most obvious barrier to implementation of the guidelines is lack of knowledge about their content; equally important are the attitudes and behavior of professionals, patients, and their caregivers. Guidelines may improve the outcome of CAP, provided that there is an association between variations in outcome and some specific processes of care. Conversely, when there is no such relationship, guidelines may reduce the cost of care without having an adverse effect on outcome. The cost-effectiveness of CAP guidelines in an individual hospital depends on the systems that are available to identify patients with CAP and to measure the processes of care. There is good evidence that following the recommendations of the CAP guidelines does improve the cost-effectiveness of care and, therefore, that an audit of CAP may be worth the effort.

Importance of atypical pathogens of community-acquired pneumonia

The atypical clinical presentation of patients with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) was first recognized and reported by astute clinicians 50 years ago. The cause of pneumonia in this group eventually was shown to be Mycoplasma pneumoniae. More recently, Chlamydia pneumoniae also has been recognized as a cause of CAP. Legionella has been lumped together with M. pneumoniae and C. pneumoniae because of its antimicrobial susceptibility pattern. This group of organisms is susceptible to the macrolides, tetracycline, and the newer fluoroquinolones. However, Legionnaires' disease frequently presents a more acute clinical picture than either mycoplasmal or chlamydial infections. Recent data suggest that in the Medicare population hospitalized with pneumonia, morbidity and mortality can be decreased if initial therapy includes coverage for atypical pathogens (i.e., macrolides or fluoroquinolones). Unfortunately, few studies use culture methodology for atypical pathogens. Future studies of the efficacy of macrolide or fluoroquinolone therapy for CAP should include aggressive diagnostic studies for M. pneumoniae, C. pneumoniae, and Legionella species.

Managing community-acquired pneumonia. Factors to consider in outpatient care

Most patients with community-acquired pneumonia are treated as outpatients, and choice of therapy is usually empirical because the etiologic agent is unknown. Therapy should include coverage for both typical and atypical organisms. In geographic areas with highly resistant S pneumoniae, one of the newer fluoroquinolones should be considered, since resistance to penicillin is associated with cross-resistance to macrolides and tetracyclines. Once-daily dosing should be given strong preference because more frequent dosing results in poor compliance, which may lead to inadequate therapy and increased resistance. At present, the duration of therapy should probably be no less than 7 days. Patients should be categorized for mortality risk with objective scoring methods, and the need for hospitalization should be decided accordingly. Greater use of observational and intermediate-care beds is encouraged, as is improved utilization of pneumococcal vaccine.