Prediction of Aquatic Toxicity of Benzene Derivatives to Tetrahymena pyriformis According to OECD Principles

Development of reliable quantitative structure-toxicity relationship models for toxicity prediction of benzene derivatives using semiempirical descriptors

The Health and environmental hazards of benzene and nitrobenzene (NB) derivatives have remained a topic of interest of researchers. In silico methods for prediction of toxicity of chemicals have proved their worth in accurate forecast of environmental as well as health toxicity and are strongly recommended by regulatory authorities. Two quantitative structure-toxicity relationship (QSTR) models explaining Scenedesmus obliquus toxicity trends among 39 benzene derivatives and Tetrahymena pyriformis toxicity of 103 NB and 392 benzene derivatives are developed using semiempirical quantum chemical parameters. The best constructed QSTR models have good fitting ability (R² = 0.8053, 0.7591, and 0.8283) and robustness (Q²_LOO = 0.7507, 0.7227, and 0.8194; Q²_LMO = 0.7338, 0.7153, and 0.8172). The external predictivity of all the models are quite good (R²_EXT = 0.8256, 0.9349, and 0.8698). Electronegativity, Cosmo volume, total energy, and molecular weight are responsible for the increase and decrease of toxicity of benzene derivatives against S. obliquus while electronegativity, electrophilicity index, the heat of formation, total energy, hydrophobicity, and cosmo volume are responsible for modulation of toxicity of NB and benzene derivatives toward T. pyriformis. These models fulfill the requirements of all the five OECD principles.

Can the Monte Carlo method predict the toxicity of binary mixtures?

Risk assessment of toxicants mainly is a result of experiments with single substances. However, toxicity in natural ecosystems typically does not result from single toxicant exposure but is rather a result of exposure to mixtures of toxicants. It is not surprising a mixture of toxicity is a subject of eco-toxicological interest for several decades. A quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR)-based approach is an attractive approach to assessing the joint effects in the binary mixtures. The validity of the proposed approach was demonstrated by comparing the predicted values against the experimentally determined values. Simplified molecular input-line entry system (SMILES) is used for the representation of the molecular structures of components of two-component mixtures to build up QSAR. The SMILES-based models are improving if the Monte Carlo optimization aimed to define 2D-optimal descriptors apply the so-called index of ideality of correlation (IIC), which is a mathematical function of both the correlation coefficient and mean absolute error calculated for the positive and negative difference between observed and calculated values of toxicity. The average statistical quality of these models (for the validation set) is n=25, R²=0.95, and RMSE=0.375.

QSAR analysis of the acute toxicity of avermectins towards Tetrahymena pyriformis

Avermectins have been effectively used in medicine, veterinary medicine, and agriculture as antiparasitic agents for many years. However, there are still no reliable data on the main ecotoxicological characteristics of most individual avermectins. Although many QSAR models have been proposed to describe the acute toxicity of organic compounds towards Tetrahymena pyriformis (T. pyriformis), avermectins are outside the applicability domain of these models. The influence of the molecular structures of various organic compounds on the acute toxicity towards T. pyriformis was studied using the OCHEM web platform (https://ochem.eu). A data set of 1792 toxicants was used to create models. The QSAR (Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship) models were developed using the molecular descriptors Dragon, ISIDA, CDK, PyDescriptor, alvaDesc, and SIRMS and machine learning methods, such as Least Squares Support Vector Machine and Transformer Convolutional Neural Network. The HYBOT descriptors and Random Forest were used for a comparative QSAR investigation. Since the best predictive ability was demonstrated by the Transformer Convolutional Neural Network model, it was used to predict the toxicity of individual avermectins towards T. pyriformis. During a structural interpretation of the developed QSAR model, we determined the significant molecular transformations that increase and decrease the acute toxicity of organic compounds.

Computational identification of chemical compounds with potential anti-Chagas activity using a classification tree

Chagas disease is endemic to 21 Latin American countries and is a great public health problem in that region. Current chemotherapy remains unsatisfactory; consequently the need to search for new drugs persists. Here we present a new approach to identify novel compounds with potential anti-chagasic action. A large dataset of 584 compounds, obtained from the Drugs for Neglected Diseases initiative, was selected to develop the computational model. Dragon software was used to calculate the molecular descriptors and WEKA software to obtain the classification tree. The best model shows accuracy greater than 93.4% for the training set; the tree was also validated using a 10-fold cross-validation procedure and through a test set, achieving accuracy values over 90.5% and 92.2%, correspondingly. The values of sensitivity and specificity were around 90% in all series; also the false alarm rate values were under 10.5% for all sets. In addition, a simulated ligand-based virtual screening for several compounds recently reported as promising anti-chagasic agents was carried out, yielding good agreement between predictions and experimental results. Finally, the present work constitutes an example of how this rational computer-based method can help reduce the cost and increase the rate in which novel compounds are developed against Chagas disease.

[AI-based QSAR Modeling for Prediction of Active Compounds in MIE/AOP]

Toxicity testing is critical for new drug and chemical development process. A clinical study, experimental animal models, and in vitro study are performed to evaluate the safety of a new drug. The limitations of these methods include extensive time for toxicity testing, an ethical problem, and high costs of experimentation. Therefore computational methods are considered useful for estimating chemical toxicity. In silico toxicity prediction is one of the toxicity assessments that uses computational methods to predict and stimulate the toxicity of chemicals. In silico study aims to contribute to effective development of new drug and chemical design. In this study, quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) models will be used to predict toxicities based on chemical structural parameters. Because toxicities are complicated physiological phenomena, a similar toxicity expression might cause a different pathway. Also, since many drugs with unknown mechanisms of actions are available, the application of artificial intelligence (AI)-which uses sophisticated algorithms- is increasingly used to predict toxicities. Recently, the QSAR model was applied to determine complex relations between chemical structures and toxicities. However, accuracy of QSAR for toxicity prediction remains an important issue. International competitions funded by public institutions can address this issue. Two important toxicity challenges were organized in the past decade; this article presents issues of toxicity based on these challenges.

Predictive models in ecotoxicology: Bridging the gap between scientific progress and regulatory applicability-Remarks and research needs

This paper concludes a special series of 7 articles (4 on toxicokinetic-toxicodynamic [TK-TD] models and 3 on quantitative structure-activity relationship [QSAR] models) published in previous issues of Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management (IEAM). The present paper summarizes the special series articles and highlights their contribution to the topic of increasing the regulatory applicability of effect models. For both TK-TD and QSAR approaches, we then describe the main research needs. The use of TK-TD models for describing sublethal effects must be better developed, particularly through the improvement of the dynamic energy budget (DEBtox) approach. The potential of TK-TD models for moving from lower (molecular) to higher (population) hierarchical levels is highlighted as a promising research line. Some relevant issues to improve the acceptance of QSAR models at the regulatory level are also described, such as increased transparency of the performance assessment and of the modeling algorithms, model documentation, relevance of the chosen target for regulatory needs, and improved mechanistic interpretability. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2019;00:000-000. © 2019 SETAC.

Use of the index of ideality of correlation to improve models of eco-toxicity

Persistent organic pollutants are compounds used for various everyday purposes, such as personal care products, food, pesticides, and pharmaceuticals. Decomposition of considerable part of the above pollutants is a long-time process. Under such circumstances, estimation of toxicity for large arrays of organic substances corresponding to the above category of pollutants is a necessary component of theoretical chemistry. The CORAL software is a tool to establish quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSARs). The index of ideality of correlation (IIC) was suggested as a criterion of predictive potential of QSAR. The statistical quality of models for eco-toxicity of organic pollutants, which are built up, with use of the IIC is better than statistical quality of models, which are built up without use of data on the IIC.

Prediction of aquatic toxicity of benzene derivatives using molecular descriptor from atomic weighted vectors

Several descriptors from atom weighted vectors are used in the prediction of aquatic toxicity of set of organic compounds of 392 benzene derivatives to the protozoo ciliate Tetrahymena pyriformis (log(IGC50)^-1). These descriptors are calculated using the MD-LOVIs software and various Aggregation Operators are examined with the aim comparing their performances in predicting aquatic toxicity. Variability analysis is used to quantify the information content of these molecular descriptors by means of an information theory-based algorithm. Multiple Linear Regression with Genetic Algorithms is used to obtain models of the structure-toxicity relationships; the best model shows values of Q²=0.830 and R²=0.837 using six variables. Our models compare favorably with other previously published models that use the same data set. The obtained results suggest that these descriptors provide an effective alternative for determining aquatic toxicity of benzene derivatives.

Machine learning-based models to predict modes of toxic action of phenols to Tetrahymena pyriformis

The phenols are structurally heterogeneous pollutants and they present a variety of modes of toxic action (MOA), including polar narcotics, weak acid respiratory uncouplers, pro-electrophiles, and soft electrophiles. Because it is often difficult to determine correctly the mechanism of action of a compound, quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) methods, which have proved their interest in toxicity prediction, can be used. In this work, several QSAR models for the prediction of MOA of 221 phenols to the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena pyriformis, using Chemistry Development Kit descriptors, are reported. Four machine learning techniques (ML), k-nearest neighbours, support vector machine, classification trees, and artificial neural networks, have been used to develop several models with higher accuracies and predictive capabilities for distinguishing between four MOAs. They showed global accuracy values between 95.9% and 97.7% and area under Receiver Operator Curve values between 0.978 and 0.998; additionally, false alarm rate values were below 8.2% for training set. In order to validate our models, cross-validation (10-folds-out) and external test-set were performed with good behaviour in all cases. These models, obtained with ML techniques, were compared with others previously reported by other researchers, and the improvement was significant.