Intrasession reproducibility of RNFL thickness measurements using SD-OCT in eyes with keratoconus

[The effect of keratoconus-associated refractive errors on the results of tomographic methods of studying the posterior structures of the eye]

PURPOSE

The study assesses the potential influence of refractive errors in keratoconus (KC) on the results of tomographic methods of studying the structures of the posterior eye segment.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The study included 30 patients with bilateral stabilized KC of stages I-IV in classification by M. Amsler. Spherical and cylindrical components of refractions were determined using automatic refractometry, keratometry measurements - based on scanning keratotopography with Scheimpflug analyzer. Aberrometry was performed to evaluate corneal wave front according to the following parameters: root mean square for lower order aberrations (RMS LOA), root mean square for higher order aberrations (RMS HOA), vertical trefoil, vertical coma, horizontal coma and spherical aberrations. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) and laser confocal scanning ophthalmoscopy (HRT 3) data was used in morphometric analysis of the optic nerve head and peripapillary retina. The following morphometric parameters were analyzed: optic nerve head (ONH) area, optic disc cup area, optic disc cup volume, ratio of optic disc cup area to ONH area, neuroretinal rim area, neuroretinal rim volume, peripapillary retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness. All studies were performed first without correction, and 30 minutes after installing customized scleral hard contact lenses (SHCL).

RESULTS

Compensation of the refractive errors characteristic for KC was achieved as expected with contact correction. OCT revealed a general trend for reduction in the area and volume of the optic disc cupping, ratio of area to volume of the optic disc cupping, as well as an increase in other parameters. As such, with correction the values for area and volume of the neuroretinal rim according to OCT were 2.2 and 13%, HRT 3 - 18 and 51.6%; comparable increase in mean RNFL thickness - 2.8 and 28.5%, respectively (p<0.001). According to HRT 3 data, the area and volume of optic disc cupping statistically significantly decreased (by 21 and 28%, respectively), while OCT showed statistically significant decrease only in cupping area (by 5.7%). The ratio of cupping to ONH area decreased by 6.6 and 23% relative to the initial data obtained with OCT and HRT 3, respectively. Significant decrease in ONH area amid SHCL correction was observed only with HRT 3. The revealed changes in morphometric parameters were analyzed using the fundamental principles of physiological optics. Changes in interference pattern and, consequently, morphometric parameters of structures of the eye fundus in KC are of multifactorial nature, and are mostly associated with refractive and wave artefacts occurring when the rays pass through the irregular corneal surface and cannot be optically compensated by the device. The use of SHCL as means for making the optic system relatively regular can significantly decrease the artefacts in morphometric measurements.

CONCLUSION

The results obtained in this study demonstrate the practicality of tomographic examination in KC with contact correction. The optimal choice is custom-fit SHCL, which along with proper correction of refractive errors also ensures stable position of the lens on the cornea. In standard examination specialists should take into account the «false» decrease in parameters of the peripapillary retinal nerve fiber layer and increase in ONH cupping.

Differences in Mean Values and Variance in Quantitative Analyses of Foveal OCTA Imaging

PURPOSE

Multiple approaches for quantifying parameters such as vessel density (VD) and vessel length density (VLD) in optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) en-face segmentations are currently available. While it is common knowledge that data gathered from different methods should not be directly compared to each other, a comparison of the different methods can help to further the understanding of differences between different methods of measurement. Here we compare a common method of semiautomatically quantifying VD and VLD with an automated method supplied by the manufacturer of an OCTA device and report on differences in performance in order to probe for and highlight differences in values gathered by both methods.

METHODS

OCTA was performed using the swept source PLEX Elite 9000 device, software version 2.0.1.47652 (Carl Zeiss Meditec Inc., Dublin, CA, USA). Scans of 3 mm × 3 mm from healthy volunteers centred on the fovea were acquired by a well-trained certified ophthalmologist. Scans with a signal strength of 8 out of 10 or higher were included. Quantitative parameters of the 3 mm × 3 mm cube scans were automatically generated and segmented into superficial capillary plexus (SCP) and deep capillary plexus (DCP) layers using layer segmentation produced by the instrument software and prototype analysis VD quantification software (Macular Density v.0.7.1, ARI Network Hub, Carl Zeiss Meditec Inc., Dublin, CA, USA) supplied by the manufacturer. An alternative approach of quantitative analysis of VD and VLD was performed manually with ImageJ (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland, USA), as previously reported. VD was assessed as the ratio of the retinal area occupied by vessels. VDL was measured as the total length of the skeletonised vessels using 1-pixel centre line extraction of the blood vessels.

RESULTS

We report differences in standard deviation (SD) in OCTA parameters obtained using different methods. The standard deviation of VD and VLD measurements was statistically significantly different in VD of 3 mm × 3 mm DCP (p = 0.009), VLD of 3 mm × 3 mm SCP (p = 0.000), and VLD of 3 mm × 3 mm DCP (p = 0.021). No statistically significant differences were found in VD of 3 mm × 3 mm SCP (p = 0.128) or VLD of 3 mm × 3 mm SCP (p = 0.107).

CONCLUSIONS

As expected, we were able to demonstrate significant differences in quantitative OCTA parameters gathered from the same images using different methods of quantification. Values gathered using different methods are not interchangeable. In scientific studies and in situations where long-term follow-up is necessary, the same device and the same method of quantification should be used to maintain retrospective comparability of measurements.

Recombinant Human Nerve Growth Factor (Cenegermin)–Driven Corneal Wound Healing Process: An Evidence-Based Analysis

Purpose: To evaluate anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) to detect the wound healing process as per monitoring the effectiveness of cenegermin to treat moderate to severe neurotrophic keratoplasty.

Methods: A retrospective chart review was realized to identify patients treated with cenegermin at the Clinica Oculistica, University of Genoa, Italy. All patients underwent careful examinations at baseline and follow-up visits. AS-OCT scans centered on the minimum corneal thickness (CT) area were always performed. We compared findings of AS-OCT with the findings from the slit-lamp examination. A linear regression analysis was used to evaluate factors associated with corneal healing. A further analysis, including a control group treated with 50% autologous serum (AS), was done to investigate and compare the efficacy of cenegermin.

Results: Data from 16 eyes were studied. The average patients' age was 60.9 ± 21.1 years; five (31.2%) eyes experienced persistent epithelial defect and 11 (68.8%) eyes had neurotrophic corneal ulcer. The average reepithelialization time was 3.9 ± 0.5 weeks in the cenegermin group versus 5.9 ± 1.9 weeks in the AS group (p < 0.01). The AS‐OCT scans revealed an average CT at the thinnest point of 276.3 ± 74.1 μm before treatment with an average increase of 176.5 ± 60.3 μm at the end of the cenegermin treatment (B = −0.15; p = 0.035). The AS-OCT percentage increase in corneal thickness between the two groups was statistically significant (p < 0.02).

Conclusion: Understanding the cascade of events involved in the nerve growth factor–driven corneal wound healing process is clinically meaningful for the clinician. AS-OCT is an effective tool for systematic anterior segment imaging, allowing the detailed detection of the front-to-back layered corneal structure for quantitative analysis and monitoring of the healing process.

The link between Keratoconus and posterior segment parameters: An updated, comprehensive review

Keratoconus (KCN) has been typically known as a disorder with effects limited to the cornea. Because of this viewpoint, less attention has been devoted to its effects on the posterior segment structures. We aimed to provide a comprehensive review of the literature to understand the potential link between KCN and posterior segment structures and their functions. It is clear from the extensive evidence in the literature that KCN can be associated with morphological and functional changes in different parts of the posterior segment. It is worth noting that anatomical changes have been not only noted in several layers of the retina but also in the optic nerve head and the choroid. Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain this observation, including incidents induced by oxidative stress in keratoconic corneas and retinal adaptions to the distorted image that lands on the retina. Consequently, when KCN has been diagnosed, it seems practical to consider assessing the retinal and choroidal profile using optical coherence tomography and potentially functional abnormalities through electrophysiology procedures.

[Results of optical coherence tomography of the retina and optic nerve in keratoconus]

The article reviews the results of optical coherence tomography (OCT) of the retina and optic nerve in patients with keratoconus (KC). This research direction is premised by the possibility that changes in the retina and optic nerve are associated with KC, as well as the potential influence of significant changes in axial eye length, disorders of corneal refraction and increased level of aberrations on the quality of visualization of these ocular structures. Results of the conducted studies were conflicting, but in all they indicated a possibility of OCT findings to be altered in KC patients. Therefore, the question of changing the parameters for OCT of the retina and optic nerve requires further investigation. The main problem that needs solving with evidence based medical research can be phrased as follows: are the changes in OCT findings observed in KC patients the consequence of changes in the retina and optic nerve associated with this disorder, or potential effect of aberrations and irregular astigmatism on the quality of visualization of the studied structures?

Analysis of the Peripapillary and Macular Regions Using OCT Angiography in Patients with Schizophrenia and Bipolar Disorder

PURPOSE

To measure RNFL and vasculature around the optic disc and in the macula in patients with schizophrenia (SZ) and bipolar disorder (BD) using optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA).

METHODS

24 eyes of patients with SZ and 16 eyes of patients with BD as well as 30 eyes of healthy subjects were examined with OCTA. The radiant peripapillary capillary (RPC) density and RNFL thickness were measured in the peripapillary area. Moreover, macular thickness and vessel density were measured in both superficial and deep layers.

RESULTS

Significantly decreased values of vessel density in the macular deep vascular complex were found in the eyes of patients with SZ, compared to BD and the control group. The macular thickness in the whole vascular complex and in the fovea was significantly lower in SZ and BD group than in the control group. The radiant peripapillary vascular density and RNFL thickness were similar across groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The retinal microvascular dysfunction occurs in the macula in patients with SZ and BD, but not around optic disc. OCTA can become an essential additional diagnostic tool in detection of psychiatric disorders.

Biomarkers for Nonexudative Age-Related Macular Degeneration and Relevance for Clinical Trials: A Systematic Review

TOPIC

The purpose of the review was to identify structural, functional, blood-based, and other types of biomarkers for early, intermediate, and late nonexudative stages of age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and summarize the relevant data for proof-of-concept clinical trials.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

AMD is a leading cause of blindness in the aging population, yet no treatments exist for its most common nonexudative form. There are limited data on the diagnosis and progression of nonexudative AMD compared to neovascular AMD. Our objective was to provide a comprehensive, systematic review of recently published biomarkers (molecular, structural, and functional) for early AMD, intermediate AMD, and geographic atrophy and to evaluate the relevance of these biomarkers for use in future clinical trials.

METHODS

A literature search of PubMed, ScienceDirect, EMBASE, and Web of Science from January 1, 1996 to November 30, 2020 and a patent search were conducted. Search terms included "early AMD," "dry AMD," "intermediate AMD," "biomarkers for nonexudative AMD," "fundus autofluorescence patterns," "color fundus photography," "dark adaptation," and "microperimetry." Articles were assessed for bias and quality with the Mixed-Methods Appraisal Tool. A total of 94 articles were included (61,842 individuals).

RESULTS

Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography was superior at highlighting detailed structural changes in earlier stages of AMD. Fundus autofluorescence patterns were found to be most important in estimating progression of geographic atrophy. Delayed rod intercept time on dark adaptation was the most widely recommended surrogate functional endpoint for early AMD, while retinal sensitivity on microperimetry was most relevant for intermediate AMD. Combinational studies accounting for various patient characteristics and machine/deep-learning approaches were best suited for assessing individualized risk of AMD onset and progression.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review supports the use of structural and functional biomarkers in early AMD and intermediate AMD, which are more reproducible and less invasive than the other classes of biomarkers described. The use of deep learning and combinational algorithms will gain increasing importance in future clinical trials of nonexudative AMD.

Influences of Central Bouquet Alterations on the Visual Outcome in Eyes Receiving Epiretinal Membrane Surgery

Background: Previous studies have shown that epiretinal membranes (ERMs) may be associated with abnormal outer retinal anatomy. However, long-term morphological and functional results of pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) with ERM and internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling in eyes with central bouquet (CB) alterations have not yet been investigated. Methods: In a retrospective, consecutive study all patients underwent best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) testing and spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) before and after a mean of 20 months (range 3–70 months) postoperatively. CB abnormalities and ERMs were classified according to Govetto’s staging systems. Results: Of the 67 eyes, 22 (34%) showed CB abnormalities at baseline. The mean BCVA increased from 0.42 at baseline to 0.20 LogMAR at final follow-up (p < 0.001). Neither ERM stage (p = 0.06) nor CB stage (p = 0.939) at baseline were significant predictors of vision improvement following surgery. Conclusions: Our results show that baseline BCVA, but not classification of CB changes and ERM at baseline, seems to be a useful predictor for functional outcomes following PPV with ERM and ILM peeling in the long-term.

The vascular densities of the macula and optic disc in normal eyes from children by optical coherence tomography angiography

PURPOSE

This study aims to describe the variation and characteristics of vessel density (VD) of the macula and optic disc in the normal eyes of children.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study where subjects aged 5-18 years with normal eyes were enrolled. The macula and optic disc were scanned by optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA). The influences of age, gender, and axial length (AL) on VD were analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 71 normal eyes from 71 subjects were enrolled. For the macula, the mean VD of fovea, parafovea, and perifovea at superficial retina and deep retina were 20.1%, 50.2%, 49.4%, 36.1%, 53.9%, and 48.1%, respectively. The mean foveal avascular zone (FAZ) was 0.277 mm². For optic disc, the mean VD of radial peripapillary capillary (RPC) and inside-disc areas were 51.8% and 51.7%, respectively. Significant differences were found between the superior-hemi and inferior-hemi VD of the superficial retinal parafovea, deep retinal perifovea, and perifovea. The fovea VD of the superficial and deep retina and FAZ areas were different between genders. The inside-disc VD was positively correlated with AL, while other VDs had no significant correlation with age and AL.

CONCLUSIONS

The parafovea VD of the superficial retina, parafovea, and perifovea of the deep retina had superior-hemi VD; boys had a higher fovea VD and smaller FAZ area than those of girls, the macular VD and peripapillary RPC density were steady for 5-18 year-olds. This study provided useful information for furthering the understanding of the development mode of vessel in children and the OCTA clinical applications in children.

Macular thicknesses in patients with keratoconus: An optical coherence tomography study

Background: Keratoconus, a corneal ectasia associated with thickness and structural changes, has been reported to co-exist with posterior segment ocular conditions. However, very few studies have reported on macular thicknesses in individuals with keratoconus.Aim: The aim of this study was to investigate macular thicknesses in participants with keratoconus.Setting: This study was conducted at the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN).Methods: A comparative cross-sectional research design was used. The sample consisted of 88 participants with 44 each in the control and keratoconus (15, 11 and 18 with mild, moderate and severe keratoconus, respectively) groups. Macular thicknesses were obtained with the Fourier-domain Optovue iVue100 optical coherence tomographer using the nine Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study sectors. Data were analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics.Results: Overall, the mean macular thicknesses were comparable among the control and three keratoconus groups (p ≥ 0.199). The mean central foveal thickness was greater in the severe keratoconus group (259 µm) than the other three study groups that showed similar measurements (247 µm – 248 µm). The central fovea was thinnest followed by the perifovea and parafovea in all four study groups. The mean thickness in the nasal and temporal quadrants of the parafovea and perifovea was thickest and thinnest, respectively, in all four study groups.Conclusion: Macular thicknesses via optical coherence tomography in individuals with keratoconus and controls are similar with thickness differences that are clinically insignificant. Consequently, macular thicknesses should be included in the preoperative assessment of individuals with keratoconus awaiting corneal transplantation to assess the integrity of the retina prior to surgery.

Retinal nerve fibre layer and ganglion cell complex thickness in patients with keratoconus

Background: Keratoconus, a corneal ectasia, is associated with corneal thinning and altered optical media. Consequently, assessment of the visual field, optic nerve head and intraocular pressure measurements may be challenging in patients with keratoconus. Few studies have investigated posterior segment variables including the retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) and ganglion cell complex (GCC) thickness in patients with keratoconus.Aim: To investigate RNFL and GCC thickness in patients with keratoconus.Methods: A comparative quantitative research design was used. The sample consisted of 56 participants (28 with mild, moderate or severe keratoconus, and 28 controls) who accessed the optometry clinic at the University of KwaZulu-Natal. There was an equal distribution of male (n = 14) and female (n = 14) participants in the keratoconus and control groups. Most participants were black (n = 34) or Indian (n = 18). Corneal power and refractive error were assessed with the Oculus Keratograph and subjective refraction respectively. The iVue-100 optical coherence topography device was used to measure RNFL and GCC thickness. Data were analysed by descriptive and inferential statistics.Results: The mean global RNFL thickness was slightly higher in the control group than the keratoconus group for the right (106 µm vs. 99 µm) and left (103 µm vs. 98 µm) eyes but these differences were not significant (p ≥ 0.057). For all RNFL quadrants, slightly lower mean RNFL measurements were found in the keratoconus group. The mean GCC thicknesses were marginally higher (3 µm – 6 µm) in the control group.Conclusion: The RNFL and GCC thickness differences between patients with keratoconus and controls are not clinically significant. Therefore, abnormally reduced RNFL and GCC thickness measurements in patients with keratoconus warrant further investigation for other pathologies specifically glaucoma.

Variability in Spectral-Domain Optical Coherence Tomography over 4 Weeks by Age

PURPOSE

To quantify variation in spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) measures of total retinal thickness (top of inner limiting membrane to top of retinal pigment epithelium, RPE) and RPE thickness measures over a 4-week period and by age.

METHODS

A total of 76 volunteers aged 40-85 years were seen at three visits over 4 weeks. Two Topcon SD-OCT scans were taken at each visit. Following grid re-centration, total retinal and RPE thickness were determined in nine subfields. Multilevel modeling was used to quantify variance between scans and by age.

RESULTS

In the central circle, mean total retinal thickness was 237.9 µm (standard deviation, SD, 23.5 µm) and RPE thickness was 46.0 µm (SD 5.3 µm). Intraclass correlation coefficient in the central circle was 0.988 for total retinal thickness and 0.714 for RPE thickness. Pairwise measures taken within 4 weeks were strongly correlated (p > 0.95). Within-subject variation of total retinal thickness increased significantly with age. Subjects in the oldest age group had significantly increased among- and within-subject variability in measures of RPE thickness.

CONCLUSIONS

Correlation between retinal thickness measures was very high (>0.95) over a period of 4 weeks with small changes likely due to variation in measurement. Increasing variability in total retinal and RPE thickness measures with age suggest that the use of more and/or higher quality images to calculate mean thickness to reduce variability may benefit the study of these measures in older persons. This may also impact sample size calculations for future studies of SD-OCT measures in older adults.

Reproducibility of disc and macula optical coherence tomography using the Canon OCT-HS100 as compared with the Zeiss Cirrus HD-OCT

PURPOSE

In a clinical setting, the usefulness of optical coherence tomography (OCT) is strongly dependent on reproducibility of the measurement. The aim of the present study was to evaluate macula and optic disc measurement reproducibility with the new spectral-domain OCT (SD-OCT) from Canon (Canon OCT-HS100) and to compare reproducibility and obtained measurements with the Zeiss Cirrus HD-OCT.

METHODS

Macula and optic disc parameters from the right eyes of 31 subjects were obtained twice with both instruments. Interoperator reproducibility was evaluated by use of the coefficient of repeatability (CR), and the obtained measurements were compared between the instruments.

RESULTS

No difference in interoperator reproducibility could be found when comparing the 2 instruments and reproducibility ranged from 3.94% to 12.77% for optic disc parameters and from 1.19% to 3.54% for macula parameters. The lowest reproducibility was found for cup volume and vertical cup/disc ratio with both instruments. For all macula and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness measurements, there was a statistical difference when comparing the 2 instruments, except for RFNL measurements of the superior quadrant, with the Canon OCT-HS100 always evaluating the thickness to be thicker; however, the 2 instruments correlated well.

CONCLUSIONS

The Canon OCT-HS100 is a reproducible instrument that matches the Zeiss Cirrus HD-OCT well. It remains to be evaluated how sensitive the Canon OCT-HS100 is to detect small subtle changes in optic disc parameters and macular nerve fiber layer thickness. Furthermore, due to the differences in thickness estimation, it is important to emphasize that SD-OCTs are not interchangeable.