Persistent HIV-1 transcription during ART: time to reassess its significance?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Despite suppressive antiretroviral therapy (ART), HIV-1 reservoirs persist and reignite viral replication if therapy is interrupted. Persistence of the viral reservoir in people with HIV-1 (PWH) is the main obstacle to an HIV-1 cure. The reservoirs are not transcriptionally silent, and viral transcripts can be detected in most ART-treated individuals. Here, we review the recent progress in the characterization of persistent HIV-1 transcription during ART.

RECENT FINDINGS

Evidence from several studies indicates that, although cell-associated unspliced (US) HIV-1 RNA is abundantly expressed in ART-treated PWH, intact full-length US transcripts are rare and most US RNA is derived from defective proviruses. The transcription- and translation-competent defective proviruses, previously considered irrelevant, are increasingly being linked to residual HIV-1 pathogenesis under suppressive ART. Recent data suggest a continuous crosstalk between the residual HIV-1 activity under ART and the immune system. Persistent HIV-1 transcription on ART, despite being mostly derived from defective proviruses, predicts viral rebound upon therapy interruption, suggesting its role as an indicator of the strength of the host antiviral immune response that is shaping the viral rebound.

SUMMARY

In light of the recent findings, the significance of persistent HIV-1 transcription during ART for the long-term health of PWH and the cure research should be reassessed.

Early elevated IFNα is a key mediator of HIV pathogenesis

BACKGROUND

A complete understanding of the different steps of HIV replication and an effective drug combination have led to modern antiretroviral regimens that block HIV replication for decades, but these therapies are not curative and must be taken for life. "Elite controllers" (ECs) is a term for the 0.5% of HIV-infected persons requiring no antiretroviral therapy, whose status may point the way toward a functional HIV cure. Defining the mechanisms of this control may be key to understanding how to replicate this functional cure in others.

METHODS

In ECs and untreated non-EC patients, we compared IFNα serum concentration, distribution of immune cell subsets, and frequency of cell markers associated with immune dysfunction. We also investigated the effect of an elevated dose of IFNα on distinct subsets within dendritic cells, natural killer cells, and CD4+ and CD8 + T cells.

RESULTS

Serum IFNα was undetectable in ECs, but all immune cell subsets from untreated non-EC patients were structurally and functionally impaired. We also show that the altered phenotype and function of these cell subsets in non-EC patients can be recapitulated when cells are stimulated in vitro with high-dose IFNα.

CONCLUSIONS

Elevated IFNα is a key mediator of HIV pathogenesis.

IFNα induces CCR5 in CD4+ T cells of HIV patients causing pathogenic elevation

BACKGROUND

Among people living with HIV, elite controllers (ECs) maintain an undetectable viral load, even without receiving anti-HIV therapy. In non-EC patients, this therapy leads to marked improvement, including in immune parameters, but unlike ECs, non-EC patients still require ongoing treatment and experience co-morbidities. In-depth, comprehensive immune analyses comparing EC and treated non-EC patients may reveal subtle, consistent differences. This comparison could clarify whether elevated circulating interferon-alpha (IFNα) promotes widespread immune cell alterations and persists post-therapy, furthering understanding of why non-EC patients continue to need treatment.

METHODS

Levels of IFNα in HIV-infected EC and treated non-EC patients were compared, along with blood immune cell subset distribution and phenotype, and functional capacities in some cases. In addition, we assessed mechanisms potentially associated with IFNα overload.

RESULTS

Treatment of non-EC patients results in restoration of IFNα control, followed by marked improvement in distribution numbers, phenotypic profiles of blood immune cells, and functional capacity. These changes still do not lead to EC status, however, and IFNα can induce these changes in normal immune cell counterparts in vitro. Hypothesizing that persistent alterations could arise from inalterable effects of IFNα at infection onset, we verified an IFNα-related mechanism. The protein induces the HIV coreceptor CCR5, boosting HIV infection and reducing the effects of anti-HIV therapies. EC patients may avoid elevated IFNα following on infection with a lower inoculum of HIV or because of some unidentified genetic factor.

CONCLUSIONS

Early control of IFNα is essential for better prognosis of HIV-infected patients.

IFNα induces CCR5 in CD4+ T-cells, causing its anti- HIV inefficiency and its subsequent pathogenic elevation, partially controlled by anti-HIV therapy

Like EC, we find that ART-treated patients control serum IFNα concentration and show few immune cell alterations enabling a healthy but fragile medical status. However, treatment interruption leads to elevated IFNα reflecting virus production indicating that like EC, ART does not achieve a virological cure. The immune system becomes overwhelmed by multiple immune cell abnormalities as found in untreated patients. These are chiefly mediated by elevated IFNα inducing signaling checkpoints abnormalities, including PD1, in cytotoxic immune cells. Importantly, during acute infection, elevated IFNα correlated with HIV load and we found that IFNα enhances CCR5, the HIV coreceptor in CD4+ T-cells, impairing its anti-viral response and accounting for the pathogenic vicious cycle: HIV → IFNα ↗ → infected CD4+ T-cells ↗ →HIV ↗. This study opens immunotherapeutic perspectives showing the need to control IFNα in order to convert ART patients into EC.

Early Elevated IFNα Identified as the Key Mediator of HIV Pathogenesis and its low level a Hallmark of Elite Controllers

Advances in HIV therapy came from understanding its replication. Further progress toward "functional cure" -no therapy needed as found in Elite Controllers (EC)- may come from insights in pathogenesis and avoidance by EC. Here we show that all immune cells from HIV-infected persons are impaired in non-EC, but not in EC. Since HIV infects few cell types, these results suggest an additional mediator of pathogenesis. We identify that mediator as elevated pathogenic IFNα, controlled by EC likely by their preserved potent NK-cells and later by other killer cells. Since the earliest days of infection predict outcome genetic or chance events must be key to EC, and since we found no unique immune parameter at the onset, we suggest a chance infection with a lower HIV inoculum. These results offer an additional approach toward functional cure: a judicious targeting of IFNα for all non-EC patients.

[Hurdles to HIV cure. Part 2 : ongoing HIV replication despite therapy]

The antiretroviral therapy (ART) has proven its effectiveness in improving the life expectancy of people infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Based on the inhibition of HIV replication, ART ensures the reduction of plasma viral load to undetectable levels on long-term. Unfortunately, once ART is interrupted, the viral load rises up. Consequently, the therapy remains not curative. The reasons for this failure lie in the presence of latent reservoirs of the virus and/or the presence of ongoing replication, responsible for the persistence of the virus. This ongoing replication despite ongoing therapy has been demonstrated in sanctuary sites where the penetration of antiretroviral drugs is suboptimal. Moreover, some treatment intensification studies, mostly through addition of an integrase inhibitor, transiently resulted in increases in HIV replication by-products, highlighting that such strategies could reduce ongoing replication. Although the debate is still open, confirming the presence of this ongoing replication and finding strategies to eliminate it would be part of the key to a cure for HIV.

[Hurdles to HIV cure. Part 1 : the latent reservoirs]

The human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), responsible for acquired immunodeficiency syndrome or AIDS, is a major public health problem. In Belgium, 2 to 3 new cases are diagnosed every day. Since the advent of combined antiretroviral treatments in 1996, the life expectancy and quality of life of infected patients have greatly improved. However, to date there is no cure for HIV. Individuals infected with HIV must remain on antiretroviral treatment for life. One of the reasons for the difficulty in finding a cure for HIV is that the virus can remain in a latent form, i.e. dormant, in some of the cells it infects. These latent reservoirs are not recognized by the immune system and can reactivate and thus restart the infection if the patient stops the treatment. These latent reservoirs are therefore a major obstacle to cure HIV and a great deal of research is being conducted by the scientific community to find an eradication strategy. In this article, we will present the different characteristics of these latent reservoirs and the different strategies put in place to identify and eliminate them.