Prevalence of intratumoral regulatory T cells expressing neuropilin-1 is associated with poorer outcomes in patients with cancer

[Figure: see text].

Neuropilin-1: a checkpoint target with unique implications for cancer immunology and immunotherapy

Checkpoint blockade immunotherapy established a new paradigm in cancer treatment: for certain patients curative treatment requires immune reinvigoration. Despite this monumental advance, only 20%–30% of patients achieve an objective response to standard of care immunotherapy, necessitating the consideration of alternative targets. Optimal strategies will not only stimulate CD8⁺ T cells, but concomitantly modulate immunosuppressive cells in the tumor microenvironment (TME), most notably regulatory T cells (T_reg cells). In this context, the immunoregulatory receptor Neuropilin-1 (NRP1) is garnering renewed attention as it reinforces intratumoral T_reg cell function amidst inflammation in the TME. Loss of NRP1 on T_reg cells in mouse models restores antitumor immunity without sacrificing peripheral tolerance. Enrichment of NRP1⁺ T_reg cells is observed in patients across multiple malignancies with cancer, both intratumorally and in peripheral sites. Thus, targeting NRP1 may safely undermine intratumoral T_reg cell fitness, permitting enhanced inflammatory responses with existing immunotherapies. Furthermore, NRP1 has been recently found to modulate tumor-specific CD8⁺ T cell responses. Emerging data suggest that NRP1 restricts CD8⁺ T cell reinvigoration in response to checkpoint inhibitors, and more importantly, acts as a barrier to the long-term durability of CD8⁺ T cell-mediated tumor immunosurveillance. These novel and distinct regulatory mechanisms present an exciting therapeutic opportunity. This review will discuss the growing literature on NRP1-mediated immune modulation which provides a strong rationale for categorizing NRP1 as both a key checkpoint in the TME as well as an immunotherapeutic target with promise either alone or in combination with current standard of care therapeutic regimens.

Neuropilin-1 Amplifies Regulatory T cell Function in Human Cancer

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) maintain peripheral tolerance but also contribute to cancer progression by dampening anti-tumor immunity. Knocking out neuropilin-1 (NRP1) on murine Tregs attenuates tumor growth by rendering intratumoral Tregs non-suppressive. Whereas NRP1 is constitutively expressed on all mouse Tregs, NRP1 is infrequently expressed on Tregs in the peripheral blood of healthy humans. We hypothesized that (1) NRP1 expression is upregulated in cancer patients, (2) NRP1 marks highly suppressive human Tregs, and (3) sustained Treg activation initiates NRP1 expression.

NRP1+ Tregs are enriched in tumors across numerous cancer types but largely devoid in non-cancerous inflamed and healthy tissues. Intratumoral NRP1 expression negatively correlates with disease-free survival in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC; p = 0.03; Hazard ratio = 5.4). Intratumoral NRP1+ Tregs upregulate a suppressive module indicated by co-expression of TIGIT, CCR8, and multiple TNF receptor super family members. Correspondingly, NRP1+ Tregs potently suppress CD8+ T cell proliferation in vitro, which can be disrupted with NRP1-specific blockade. Furthermore, Treg activation in vitro drives NRP1 expression, and sustained TCR signals are required to maintain NRP1 expression.

We conclude that NRP1+ Tregs are selectively enriched in human cancer and oppose anti-tumor immunity. Therefore, destabilizing intratumoral Tregs using NRP1 blockade may complement other T cell therapies such as anti-PD1 blockade.

Abstract TMIM-063: TARGETING NEUROPILIN-1+ T REGULATORY CELLS IN PATIENTS WITH HIGH GRADE SEROUS OVARIAN CANCER DECREASES TREG-SPECIFIC SUPPRESSION OF CD8+ T CELLS

Regulatory T cells (Treg) are a subpopulation of CD4+ T cells that suppress autoimmune responses, but also prevent clearance of tumors and chronic viral infections. In high grades serous ovarian cancer, a higher frequency of tumor infiltrating (TIL) Treg are associated with poor prognosis, but mechanisms governing the suppressive activity of TIL Treg in this context are limited. Our group has recently described a signaling axis through neuropilin-1 (NRP1) on TIL Treg in murine models of cancer that promotes the survival and suppressive function of Treg. When NRP1 is specifically knocked out on murine TIL Treg, there is reduced tumor growth and increased survival similar to the complete knockout of TIL Tregs, however, without death from overt autoimmunity. Thus, NRP1 is a viable target to specifically reduce TIL Treg suppressive function in the tumor microenvironment (TME), ultimately leading to increased anti-tumor immunity without adverse events. Given the importance of NRP1+ TIL Treg in murine cancer models, we sought to understand the role of NRP1 on TIL Treg from patients with high grade serious ovarian cancer.

Surface and total NRP1 expression was assessed by flow cytometry on CD4+CD25+CD127loFOXP3+ Treg from healthy donor PBL and ovarian cancer TIL or ascites fluid. Total NRP1 was expressed on a median of 1.8% (interquartile range [IQR]: 0.69% to 4.8%) of Treg from healthy donors compared with a median of 66% (IQR: 28% to 90%; p<0.001) and 82% (IQR: 38% to 99%; p=0.004) of Treg from ovarian TIL and ascites, respectively. Surface NRP1 was detected on 0.1% (IQR: 0% to 1%) of Treg in PBL from healthy donors, compared with 11.1% (IQR: 1.1% to 60%; p=0.01) on ovarian TIL and 82% (IQR: 14% to 82%; p=0.0015) on ascites. Further, in comparing expression of NRP1 on Treg from benign ovarian disease and malignant ovarian tumors, there was a trend toward increased NRP1 expression on Tregs from malignant disease (median 9.3% versus 54.5%, respectively; p=0.044). Finally, NRP1+ TIL Treg isolated from primary tumors or ascites fluid were capable of suppressing CD8+ T cell proliferation in a dose-dependent manner and suppression was abrogated by addition of an anti-NRP1 antibody.

In summary, both surface and total NRP1 are expressed more frequently on Treg from TIL and ascites fluid compared to Treg from healthy donor PBL and NRP1+ Tregs in the TME are more suppressive compared to NRP1- Tregs. NRP1 is a viable target to reduce Treg suppressive function in ovarian cancer tumors, which can be immunologically ““cold””. This could ultimately lead to increased CD8+ T cell infiltration and function in these patient tumors, which could then increase responsiveness to anti-PD1 as it relies upon CD8 T cell infiltration to be effective.

Citation Format: Anthony R. Cillo, Christopher A. Chuckran, Mengting Liao, Francesmary Modugno, Robert Edwards, Lan Coffman, Dario A.A. Vignali, Tullia C. Bruno. TARGETING NEUROPILIN-1+ T REGULATORY CELLS IN PATIENTS WITH HIGH GRADE SEROUS OVARIAN CANCER DECREASES TREG-SPECIFIC SUPPRESSION OF CD8+ T CELLS [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 12th Biennial Ovarian Cancer Research Symposium; Sep 13-15, 2018; Seattle, WA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Clin Cancer Res 2019;25(22 Suppl):Abstract nr TMIM-063.