ETC Model: How One Small Dialysis Organization Is Navigating Uncharted Policy Waters

The ETC model proposes to increase access to home dialysis and transplant for patients with ESRD. Implementation of this model is happening while many dialysis organizations are still suffering the far-reaching effects of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. In addition, the model has the potential to negatively affect small and independent dialysis organizations disproportionately. It incentivizes home dialysis over transplant and promotes development of new home dialysis programs, rewards achievement over improvement, and places an excessive burden on small and independent dialysis organizations. Advantages of the program include the focus on self-care as an acceptable alternative to home dialysis for some patients and the potential for some organizations to make improvements in care with increased reimbursements. The authors hope that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services will address many of these concerns in updated rulemaking and guidance.

Projected impact of the proposed "bundled" ESRD payment system on a small dialysis organization

Payment for outpatient hemodialysis services is currently made by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on a per-treatment basis using a partially "bundled" composite rate adjusted for geographic and patient characteristics, plus a separately billable portion for medications and services not included in the bundle. In response to concerns over rising costs of the End-Stage Renal Disease Program, and specifically the increasing use of erythropoiesis-stimulating agents, Congress has mandated a new, more inclusive prospective payment system, in which current composite rate services, separately billable medications, and dialysis-related laboratory services will be included in a single payment. It is expected that the so-called bundle will apply a geographic wage adjuster and patient-specific case-mix factors to a base rate to calculate a per-patient, per treatment payment unit. We have modeled the proposed bundle and entered clinical and financial data for 118 Medicare patients dialyzed at a suburban dialysis center in New York State during 2006. Under the proposed bundled system, we stand to lose as much as $118,000 per year in revenue, and we find the case-mix adjusters appear to be poor predictors of our actual costs. We conclude that the proposed bundle places the small dialysis provider at significant financial risk.

Reversible seizures and mental status changes in a dialysis patient on isoniazid preventive therapy

OBJECTIVE

To report a case of reversible seizures and mental status changes in a dialysis patient given preventive isoniazid therapy.

CASE SUMMARY

A 66-year-old woman on continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) was given isoniazid prophylaxis following a purified protein derivative (PPD) reaction greater than 20 mm in duration. Oral administration of isoniazid 300 mg/d was started and four days later she was admitted to the hospital for confusion, lethargy, and focal seizures that began 24 hours after initiation of therapy. All medications were discontinued with the exception of oral pyridoxine 50 mg/d. Dialysis was withheld to determine if the seizures were medication induced rather than uremia related. Seizures and mental status changes were reversed with pyridoxine. Dialysis was restarted after the symptoms resolved.

CONCLUSIONS

Preventive therapy against tuberculosis with isoniazid should be stressed throughout the medical community. Isoniazid has adverse effects including hepatitis and peripheral neuropathy (common) and convulsions (rare). Our experience suggests that additional supplementation with pyridoxine 50 mg/d should be given routinely to prevent adverse reactions in uremic patients.

Membranes nephropathy associated with renal cell carcinoma. Evidence against a role of renal tubular or tumor antibodies in pathogenesis

A patient with the nephrotic syndrome due to membranous nephropathy was found to have renal cell carcinoma. Since membranous nephropathy in patients with malignancies has been attributed to a tumor antigen-antibody complex form of glomerulonephritis, an attempt was made to implicate tumor antigens and/or renal tubular epithelial antigens in the pathogenesis of membranous nephropathy in our patient with renal cell carcinoma. Antibodies directed against tumor antigens and renal tubular antigens and renal tubular eipthelial antigens were sought in his serum and in eluates of his glomeruli; no such antibodies were found. The concurrence of the two renal lesions may have been fortuitous in this patient. However, their association temporally suggests that they were related, and our immunologic studies demonstrate that tumor antigen-antibody complexes are not invariably involved in the pathogenesis of malignancy-associated membranous nephropathy.

Renal failure after open heart surgery

One hundred fifty of 490 patients undergoing open heart surgery had renal failure attributable to cardiopulmonary bypass. In 69, serum creatinine concentrations did not exceed 2 mg/dl and returned to normal by the fourth postoperative day. In 60 patients, serum creatinine attained levels between 2 and 5 mg/dl, oliguria did not develop, and recovery of renal function occurred within 4 to 37 days. Serum creatinine increased to levels exceeding 5 mg/dl in 21 patients, 11 of whom were oliguric. Despite dialysis, 14 of these patients died from cardiac causes or sepsis. Prolonged cardiopulmonary bypass time, hypotension, oliguria, low output syndrome, and hemoglobinemia during open heart surgery correlated with the development of renal failure postoperatively. Although severe renal failure was an uncommon complication after open heart surgery, its occurrence carried a grave prognosis.

The influence of diabetes and hypertension on the results of coronary revascularization

The effects of diabetes and hypertension on the early postoperative course of patients undergoing coronary revascularization were studied by reviewing the records of 177 patients operated upon in 1972. There were 121 nondiabetic, nonhypertensive; 32 hypertensive; ten diabetic; and 14 diabetic-hypertensive patients. The incidence of postoperative low cardiac output, renal insufficiency and arrhythmia was significantly higher in the hypertensive patient. Operative mortality ranged from 0 in diabetic patients, to 0.8 per cent in nondiabetic, nonhypertensives, to 7.1 per cent in diabetic-hypertensives and 12.5 per cent in hypertensive patients, suggesting an increased risk for the hypertensive patient. The one- to two-year follow-up results documented symptomatic improvement in 90.7 per cent of patients with little adverse effect apparent from diabetes or hypertension. Pre- and postoperative coronary angiography was carried out in 103 patients between 1968 and 1973 with a mean elapsed time between operation and postoperative angiogram of 9.3 months. The progression of atherosclerosis was graded on a 0-4 basis in both grafted and ungrafted coronary arteries. While hypertension appeared to contribute to disease progression, the incidence of vein graft and internal mammary artery bypass occlusion was not significantly affected by either diabetes or hypertension. This study has shown that while hypertension contributes to increased morbidity and mortality in the early postoperative period and an increased rate of progression of atherosclerosis, neither diabetes nor hypertension appeared to influence the one- to two-year results of coronary revascularization.