A revisionist replicon model for higher eukaryotic genomes

The replicon model devised to explain replication control in bacteria has served as the guiding paradigm in the search for origins of replication in the more complex genomes of eukaryotes. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, this model has proved to be extremely useful, leading to the identification of specific genetic elements (replicators) and the interacting initiator proteins that activate them. However, replication control in organisms ranging from Schizosaccharomyces pombe to mammals is far more fluid: only a small number of origins seem to represent classic replicators, while the majority correspond to zones of inefficient, closely spaced start sites none of which are indispensable for origin activity. In addition, it is apparent that the epigenetic state of a given sequence largely determines its ability to be used as a replication initiation site. These conclusions were arrived at over a period of three decades, and required the development of several novel replicon mapping techniques, as well as new ways of examining the chromatin architecture of any sequence of interest. Recently, methods have been elaborated for isolating all of the active origins in the genomes of higher eukaryotes en masse. Microarray analyses and more recent high-throughput sequencing technology will allow all the origins to be mapped onto the chromosomes of any organism whose genome has been sequenced. With the advent of whole-genome studies on gene expression and chromatin composition, the field is now positioned to define both the genetic and epigenetic rules that govern origin activity.

Promiscuous initiation on mammalian chromosomal DNA templates and its possible suppression by transcription

The Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) origin consists of many inefficient initiation sites scattered throughout a 55-kb intergenic spacer, with the ori-beta, ori-beta', and ori-gamma subregions being preferred. To test for the presence of genetic replicators within these subregions, fragments containing ori-beta, ori-beta', or, as a negative control, a fragment from the DHFR gene that never initiates in loco were placed at ectopic chromosomal positions. Two-dimensional gel analysis demonstrates that initiation occurs in all three fragments, including the fragment from the gene, and appears to occur at different positions within each fragment in different cells in the population. However, initiation is not detectable in the adjacent, transcribed, neomycin-resistance marker. When a cosmid containing an active DHFR gene was inserted into an ectopic chromosomal site, initiation could no longer be observed in the body of the gene, but was clearly evident in the transcriptionally-silent bacterial vector sequences. In the thirteen independent chromosomal positions into which the four different constructs were inserted, initiation occurred in early S-phase. Since these loci necessarily had to be permissive for transcription of the neo(r) marker or DHFR gene used to select transfectants, it is possible that early-firing origin activity and local transcription are somehow linked. In total, these data suggest that potential initiation sites are distributed at very frequent intervals in the mammalian genome, with usage being regulated both positively and negatively by local transcription.

The matrix attachment region in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase origin of replication may be required for local chromatid separation

Centered in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase origin of replication is a prominent nuclear matrix attachment region (MAR). Indirect lines of evidence suggested that this MAR might be required for origin activation in early S phase. To test this possibility, we have deleted the MAR from a Chinese hamster ovary variant harboring a single copy of the dihydrofolate reductase locus. However, 2D gel replicon mapping shows that removal of the MAR has no significant effect either on the frequency or timing of initiation in this locus. Rather, fluorescence in situ hybridization studies on cells swollen under either neutral or alkaline conditions show that deletion of the MAR interferes with local separation of daughter chromatids. This surprising result provides direct genetic evidence that at least a subset of MARs performs an important biological function, possibly related to chromatid cohesion and separation.

The dihydrofolate reductase origin of replication does not contain any nonredundant genetic elements required for origin activity

The Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) origin of replication consists of a broad zone of potential initiation sites scattered throughout a 55-kb intergenic spacer, with at least three sites being preferred (ori-beta, ori-beta', and ori-gamma). We previously showed that deletion of the most active site or region (ori-beta) has no demonstrable effect on initiation in the remainder of the intergenic spacer nor on the time of replication of the DHFR locus as a whole. In the present study, we have now deleted ori-beta', both ori-beta and ori-beta', an 11-kb region just downstream from the DHFR gene, or the central approximately 40-kb core of the spacer. The latter two deletions together encompass >95% of the initiation sites that are normally used in this locus. Two-dimensional gel analysis shows that initiation still occurs in the early S phase in the remainder of the intergenic spacer in each of these deletion variants. Even removal of the 40-kb core fails to elicit a significant effect on the time of replication of the DHFR locus in the S period; indeed, in the truncated spacer that remains, the efficiency of initiation actually appears to increase relative to the corresponding region in the wild-type locus. Thus, if replicators control the positions of nascent strand start sites in this complex origin, either (i) there must be a very large number of redundant elements in the spacer, each of which regulates initiation only in its immediate environment, or (ii) they must lie outside the central core in which the vast majority of nascent strand starts occur.

Amplification of the human dihydrofolate reductase gene via double minutes is initiated by chromosome breaks

DNA sequence amplification is one of the most frequent manifestations of genomic instability in human tumors. We have shown previously that amplification of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene in Chinese hamster cells is initiated by chromosome breaks, followed by bridge-breakage-fusion cycles that generate large intrachromosomal repeats; these are ultimately trimmed by an unknown process to smaller, more homogenous units manifested as homogenously staining chromosome regions (HSRs). However, in most human tumor cells, amplified DNA sequences are borne on unstable, extrachromosomal double minutes (DMs), which suggests the operation of a different amplification mechanism. In this study, we have isolated a large number of independent methotrexate-resistant human cell lines, all of which contained DHFR-bearing DMs. Surprisingly, all but one of these also had suffered partial or complete loss of one of the parental DHFR-bearing chromosomes. Cells in a few populations displayed what could be transient intermediates in the amplification process, including an initial HSR, its subsequent breakage, the appearance of DHFR-containing fragments, and, finally, DMs. Our studies suggest that HSRs and DMs both are initiated by chromosome breaks, but that cell types differ in how the extra sequences ultimately are processed and/or maintained.

Dispersive initiation of replication in the Chinese hamster rhodopsin locus

Several higher eukaryotic replication origins appear to be composed of broad zones of potential nascent strand start sites, while others are more circumscribed, resembling those of yeast, bacteria, and viruses. The most delocalized origin identified so far is approximately 55 kb in length and lies between the convergently transcribed dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) and the 2BE2121 genes on chromosome 2 in the Chinese hamster genome. In some of our studies, we have utilized the rhodopsin origin as an early replicating internal standard for assessing the effects of deleting various parts of the DHFR locus on DHFR origin activity. However, it had not been previously established that the rhodopsin locus was located at a site far enough away to be immune to such deletions, nor had the mechanism of initiation at this origin been characterized. In the present study, we have localized the rhodopsin domain to a pair of small metacentric chromosomes and have used neutral/neutral 2-D gel replicon mapping to show that initiation in this origin is also highly delocalized, encompassing a region more than 50 kb in length that includes the nontranscribed rhodopsin gene itself. The initiation zone is flanked at least on one end by an actively transcribed gene that does not support initiation. Thus, the DHFR and rhodopsin origins belong to a class of complex, polydisperse origins that appears to be unique to higher eukaryotic cells.

DNA replication during amplification of the C3 puff of Rhynchosciara americana initiates at multiple sites in a 6 kb region

Two independent two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis methods have been used to map the origin of replication that directs amplification of the C3 DNA puff of Rhynchosciara americana. The results of neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel electrophoresis show that DNA replication initiates at multiple sites in a zone of at least 6 kb situated immediately upstream from the promoter of the main transcription unit of this puff. The complementary neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel electrophoresis technique shows that, within the initiation zone, forks move in both directions. In contrast, unidirectional fork movement away from the initiation zone is observed at the ends of the region, implying that it is the only place in the amplified region of the C3 puff where initiations occur. Since the initiation zone coincides with the region that is most highly amplified, amplification of the C3 puff probably occurs by an onion skin-type mechanism.

Physical and genetic mapping of mammalian replication origins

The neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel electrophoretic techniques are sensitive physical mapping methods that have been used successfully to identify replication initiation sites in genomes of widely varying complexity. We present detailed methodology for the preparation of replication intermediates from mammalian cells and their analysis by both neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel approaches. The methods described allow characterization of the replication pattern of single-copy loci, even in mammalian cells. When applied to metazoans, initiation is found to occur at multiple sites scattered throughout zones that can be as long as 50 kb, with some subregions being preferred. Although these observations do not rule out the possibility of genetically defined replicators, they offer the alternative or additional possibility that chromosomal context may play an important role in defining replication initiation sites in complex genomes. We discuss novel recombination strategies that can be used to test for the presence of sequence elements critical for origin function if the origin lies in the vicinity of a selectable gene. Application of this strategy to the DHFR locus shows that loss of sequences more than 25 kb from the local initiation zone can markedly affect origin activity in the zone.

Radiation down-regulates replication origin activity throughout the S phase in mammalian cells

An asynchronous culture of mammalian cells responds acutely to ionizing radiation by inhibiting the overall rate of DNA replication by approximately 50% for a period of several hours, presumably to allow time to repair DNA damage. At low and moderate doses, this S phase damage-sensing (SDS) pathway appears to function primarily at the level of individual origins of replication, with only a modest inhibition of chain elongation per se. We have shown previously that the majority of the inhibition observed in an asynchronous culture can be accounted for by late G1cells that were within 2-3 h of entering the S period at the time of irradiation and which then fail to do so. A much smaller effect was observed on the overall rate of replication in cells that had already entered the S phase. This raised the question whether origins of replication that are activated within S phase per se are inhibited in response to ionizing radiation. Here we have used a two-dimensional gel replicon mapping strategy to show that cells with an intact SDS pathway completely down-regulate initiation in both early- and late-firing rDNA origins in human cells. We also show that initiation in mid- or late-firing rDNA origins is not inhibited in cells from patients with ataxia telangiectasia, confirming the suggestion that these individuals lack the SDS pathway.

Attachment to the nuclear matrix mediates specific alterations in chromatin structure

The DNA in eukaryotic chromosomes is organized into a series of loops that are permanently attached at their bases to the nuclear scaffold or matrix at sequences known as scaffold-attachment or matrix-attachment regions. At present, it is not clear what effect affixation to the nuclear matrix has on chromatin architecture in important regulatory regions such as origins of replication or the promoter regions of genes. In the present study, we have investigated cell-cycle-dependent changes in the chromatin structure of a well characterized replication initiation zone in the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain of the methotrexate-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell line CHOC 400. Replication can initiate at any of multiple potential sites scattered throughout the 55-kilobase intergenic region in this domain, with two subregions (termed ori-beta and ori-gamma) being somewhat preferred. We show here that the chromatin in the ori-beta and ori-gamma regions undergoes dramatic alterations in micrococcal nuclease hypersensitivity as cells cross the G1/S boundary, but only in those copies of the amplicon that are affixed to the nuclear matrix. In contrast, the fine structure of chromatin in the promoter of the dihydrofolate reductase gene does not change detectably as a function of matrix attachment or cell-cycle position. We suggest that attachment of DNA to the nuclear matrix plays an important role in modulating chromatin architecture, and this could facilitate the activity of origins of replication.

Distal sequences, but not ori-beta/OBR-1, are essential for initiation of DNA replication in the Chinese hamster DHFR origin

In the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase replication initiation zone, the ori-beta locus is preferred over other start sites. To test the hypothesis that ori-beta contains a genetic replicator, we restored a deletion in the 3' end of the DHFR gene with a cosmid that provides the missing sequence and simultaneously knocks out the downstream ori-beta locus. Replication initiates normally in ori-beta knockout cell lines, and the DHFR domain is still synthesized in early S phase. However, initiation is completely suppressed in the starting deletion variant lacking the 3' end of the gene. We conclude that ori-beta does not contain an essential replicator, but that distant sequence elements have profound effects on origin activity in this locus.

Lagging-strand, early-labelling, and two-dimensional gel assays suggest multiple potential initiation sites in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase origin

There is general agreement that DNA synthesis in the single-copy and amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) loci of CHO cells initiates somewhere within the 55-kb spacer region between the DHFR and 2BE2121 genes. However, results of lagging-strand, early-labelling fragment hybridization (ELFH), and PCR-based nascent-strand abundance assays have been interpreted to suggest a very narrow zone of initiation centered at a single locus known as ori-beta, while two-dimensional (2-D) gel analyses suggest that initiation can occur at any of a large number of potential sites scattered throughout the intergenic region. The results of a leading-strand assay and two intrinsic labelling techniques are compatible with a broad initiation zone in which ori-beta and a second locus (ori-gamma) are somewhat preferred. To determine how these differing views are shaped by differences in experimental manipulations unrelated to the biology itself, we have applied the lagging-strand, ELFH, neutral-neutral, and/or neutral-alkaline 2-D gel assays to CHOC 400 cell populations synchronized and manipulated in the same way. In our experiments, the lagging-strand assay failed to identify a template strand switch at ori-beta; rather, we observed a gradual, undulating change in hybridization bias throughout the intergenic spacer, with hybridization to the two templates being approximately equal near a centered matrix attachment region. In the ELFH assay, all of the fragments in the 55-kb intergenic region were labelled in the first few minutes of the S phase, with the regions encompassing ori-beta and ori-gamma being somewhat preferred. Under the same conditions, neutral-neutral and neutral-alkaline 2-D gel analyses detected initiation sites at multiple locations in the intergenic spacer. Thus, the results of all existing replicon-mapping methods that have been applied to the amplified DHFR locus in CHOC 400 cells are consistent with a model in which two somewhat preferred subzones reside in a larger zone of multiple potential initiation sites in the intergenic region.

Mapping replication origins by neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel electrophoresis is a sensitive physical mapping technique that has been successfully used to unambiguously identify replication initiation sites in genomes of widely varying complexity in vivo. The technique exploits the fact that restriction fragments containing different classes of replicative intermediates (single forks, initiation bubbles, or termination structures) migrate to different and characteristic positions in agarose gels. The replication pattern of any region of interest can then be determined by sequential hybridization with appropriate radioactive probes from that region.

S phase damage sensing checkpoints in mammalian cells

Mammalian cells have evolved multiple responses for dealing with DNA damage. One response is to acutely downregulate DNA synthesis at the initiation step. Essentially nothing is known about the initial signal that activates this SDS pathway or the macromolecules involved in transducing the signal into the final inhibitory step at origins. Determining whether any radiation induced changes in known proteins involved in cell cycle regulation or in other signal transduction pathways are primary or secondary responses to DNA damage constitutes a major challenge to identifying members of the pathway. It may turn out to be easier to identify the final mediator in the pathway, namely the protein(s) whose interaction with origins is ultimately affected by radiation. Hopefully, mutations in SDS genes in genetically tractable systems such as S cerevisiae or Schizosaccharomyces pombe will allow the identification of homologous genes in mammals. Most tumour cells are TP53 negative, and yet it is not clear that TP53 status influences radiation sensitivity. The SDS pathway may therefore represent an important protective mechanism that stands in the way of effective tumour cell killing by radiation therapy. It is hoped that an understanding of this pathway will provide opportunities for developing novel antineoplastic targets and/or radiation sensitizers.

The dual effect of mimosine on DNA replication

The plant amino acid, mimosine, is an extremely effective inhibitor of DNA replication in mammalian cells, but the mechanism by which this inhibition is achieved is unknown. The drug has been proposed either to inhibit initiation at origins of replication or to inhibit chain elongation by lowering nucleotide pool levels. In an attempt to determine which mode of action is correct, we have analyzed its effects on SV40 DNA replication. Using a two-dimensional gel replicon mapping technique, we show that mimosine completely inhibits incorporation of [3H]thymidine into viral DNA, but only after approximately 4 h. Qualitative analysis of replication intermediates during this interval suggests that the drug partially inhibits both initiation and elongation, and pulse-chase experiments support this contention. The drug has no effect when added directly to an SV40 in vitro replication extract. However, extracts prepared from cells pretreated with mimosine are compromised in their ability to support replication in vitro in the presence of a full complement of nucleotides. Thus, although mimosine may alter nucleotide pool levels in vivo, it also appears to affect one or more essential replication proteins.

A p53-independent damage-sensing mechanism that functions as a checkpoint at the G1/S transition in Chinese hamster ovary cells

In response to a moderate dose of radiation, asynchronous mammalian cell populations rapidly and transiently down-regulate the rate of DNA synthesis to approximately 50% of preirradiation values. We show here that only half of the reduction in overall replication rate can be accounted for by direct inhibition of initiation at origins in S-phase cells. The other half results from the operation of a newly defined cell cycle checkpoint that functions at the G1/S transition. This checkpoint senses damage incurred at any time during the last 2 hr of G1 and effectively prevents entry into the S period. The G1/S and S-phase checkpoints are both p53-independent and, unlike the p53-mediated G1 checkpoint, respond rapidly to radiation, suggesting that they may represent major damage-sensing mechanisms connecting the replication machinery with DNA repair pathways.

Cloning and characterization of Chinese hamster p53 cDNA

We have cloned and sequenced Chinese hamster p53 cDNA and have compared the p53 sequence in different Chinese hamster cell lines to several relevant phenotypes. Our results indicate that a mutation in CHO cells that changes Thr211 to Lys211 abrogates the ability to arrest in G1 and apparently renders cells capable of amplifying DNA. However, this mutation has no effect on the G2 checkpoint or on acute down-regulation of DNA replication after a radiation challenge.

Composite patterns in neutral/neutral two-dimensional gels demonstrate inefficient replication origin usage

The neutral/neutral two-dimensional (2-D) gel replicon mapping technique has been used to great advantage to localize and characterize origins of replication. Interestingly, many yeast origins display a composite pattern consisting of both a bubble arc and a single-fork arc. Moreover, in every instance in which neutral/neutral 2-D gels have been used to analyze origins in higher eukaryotic cells, two or more adjacent fragments display these composite patterns. We believe that composite patterns signal inefficient origin usage in yeast cells because the replicators in question are not active in every cell cycle and in higher eukaryotic replicons because initiation sites are chosen from among many potential sites lying within a zone. However, others have suggested that the single-fork arcs in these composite gel patterns arise from nicking activity that converts replication bubbles to branched structures that comigrate with bona fide single forks. Here, we have used three different replicon mapping strategies to show that broken simian virus 40 replication bubbles trace unique arcs that are clearly distinguishable from classic, intact single forks. Thus, it is likely that composite 2-D gel patterns represent origins that are inefficiently utilized.

Characterizing replication intermediates in the amplified CHO dihydrofolate reductase domain by two novel gel electrophoretic techniques

Using neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional (2-D) gel techniques, we previously obtained evidence that initiation can occur at any of a large number of sites distributed throughout a broad initiation zone in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. However, other techniques have suggested a much more circumscribed mode of initiation in this locus. This dichotomy has raised the issue whether the patterns of replicating DNA on 2-D gels have been misinterpreted and, in some cases, may represent such noncanonical replication intermediates as broken bubbles or microbubbles. In an accompanying study (R. F. Kalejta and J. L. Hamlin, Mol. Cell. Biol. 16:4915-4922, 1996), we have shown that broken bubbles migrate to unique positions in three different gel systems and therefore are not likely to be confused with classic replication intermediates. Here, we have applied a broken bubble assay developed from that study to an analysis of the amplified DHFR locus in CHO cells. This assay gives information about the number and positions of initiation sites within a fragment. In addition, we have analyzed the DHFR locus by a novel stop-and-go-alkaline gel technique that measures the size of nascent strands at all positions along each arc in a neutral/neutral 2-D gel. Results of these analyses support the view that the 2-D gel patterns previously assigned to classic, intact replication bubbles and single-forked structures indeed correspond to these entities. Furthermore, potential nascent-strand start sites appear to be distributed at very frequent intervals along the template in the intergenic region in the DHFR domain.

Sequence and context effects on origin function in mammalian cells

Jacob and Brenner proposed a model for control of DNA replication in which a trans-acting initiator protein binds to a cis-acting replicator to effect initiation of nascent DNA chains at a fixed locus. Although replicators have been identified in prokaryotic and simple eukaryotic genomes, it has been much more difficult to demonstrate their presence in mammalian chromosomes. Owing to the lack of genetic approaches for identifying mammalian replicators, investigators have directed attention to localizing nascent strand start sites, which should lie close to replicators. Toward this end, a variety of clever techniques have been invented for analyzing replication intermediates, but only rarely have more than one of these techniques been applied to a single locus. However, virtually all have been used to analyze the dihydrofolate reductase locus in CHO cells. The picture that has developed in this locus is that initiation can occur at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout a broad zone, but somewhat more frequently near two sites that may correspond to true genetic replicators. Furthermore, it appears that local transcriptional activity, as well as appropriate torsional stress (as imparted by local attachment to the nuclear matrix), may have profound effects on origin activity.

Mimosine targets serine hydroxymethyltransferase

The plant amino acid, mimosine, is an extremely effective inhibitor of DNA replication in mammalian cells (Mosca, P. J., Dijkwel, P. A., and Hamlin, J. L. (1992) Mol. Cell. Biol. 12, 4375-4383). Mimosine appears to prevent the formation of replication forks at early-firing origins when delivered to mammalian cells approaching the G1/S boundary, and blocks DNA replication when added to S phase cells after a lag of approximately 2.5 h. We have shown previously that [3H]mimosine can be specifically photocross-linked both in vivo and in vitro to a 50-kDa polypeptide (p50) in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. In the present study, six tryptic peptides (58 residues total) from p50 were sequenced by tandem mass spectrometry and their sequences were found to be at least 77.5% identical and 96.5% similar to sequences in rabbit mitochondrial serine hydroxymethyltransferase (mSHMT). This assignment was verified by precipitating the [3H]mimosine-p50 complex with a polyclonal antibody to rabbit cSHMT. The 50-kDa cross-linked product was almost undetectable in a mimosine-resistant CHO cell line and in a CHO gly- cell line that lacks mitochondrial, but not cytosolic, SHMT activity. The gly- cell line is still sensitive to mimosine, suggesting that the drug may inhibit both the mitochondrial and the cytosolic forms. SHMT is involved in the penultimate step of thymidylate biosynthesis in mammalian cells and, as such, is a potential target for chemotherapy in the treatment of cancer.

Origins of replication and the nuclear matrix: the DHFR domain as a paradigm

The eukaryotic genome appears to be organized in a loopwise fashion by periodic attachment to the nuclear matrix. The proposal that a chromatin loop corresponds to a functional domain has stirred interest in the properties of the DNA sequences at the bases of these loops, the matrix-attached regions (MARs). Evidence has been presented suggesting that certain MARs act as boundary elements isolating domains from their chromosomal context. MARs have also been found in the vicinity of promoters and enhancers and they could act by displacing these cis-regulatory elements into the proper nuclear subcompartment. Attachment to the matrix might also play a role in DNA replication. A large body of evidence indicates that replication occurs on the nuclear matrix. This implies that any DNA sequence will be attached to the matrix at a certain time during the cell cycle. This transient mode of attachment contrasts with the proposed permanent attachment of origins of DNA replication with the nuclear matrix. While some data exist that support this suggestion, the current lack of understanding of the mammalian replication origin precludes definitive conclusions regarding the role of MARs in the initiation process.

Yeast and mammalian replication intermediates migrate similarly in two-dimensional gels

In the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, DNA replication initiates at specific, discrete chromosomal locations. At each initiation site, a single small replication bubble is generated, which subsequently expands at Y-like replication forks. We wanted to know whether other eukaryotic organisms utilize similar initiation mechanisms. For this purpose, replication intermediates (RIs) from three different organisms (Schizosaccharomyces pombe, Chinese hamster and human) were mixed individually with RIs from S. cerevisiae and then subjected to two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis under conditions known to resolve molecules having different structures. All of the RIs detected by the hybridization probes we used for each organism migrated nearly identically to specific RIs of similar size from S. cerevisiae, implying that the detected RIs from all the studied organisms have very similar structures and may therefore employ the same basic initiation mechanism.

The Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase origin consists of multiple potential nascent-strand start sites

Previous two-dimensional gel replicon-mapping studies on the amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain in CHOC 400 cells suggested that replication can initiate at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout a 55-kb region lying between two convergently transcribed genes. It could be argued that this unusual distributive initiation mode is unique to amplified chromosomal loci. In this paper, we report the first application of the two-dimensional gel techniques to the analysis of a single-copy locus in mammalian cells. Results obtained with both synchronized and exponentially growing CHO cells suggest that (i) initiation can also occur at any of a large number of sites distributed throughout the intergenic region in the nonamplified DHFR locus, (ii) initiation is confined to the first 2 to 2.5 h of the S period, and (iii) initiation occurs only in a fraction of the DHFR loci in each cell cycle.

On the nature of replication origins in higher eukaryotes

Establishing whether DNA replication in higher eukaryotic cells is regulated by genetic replicators has been one of the more challenging problems in cell biology. Several important replicon-mapping techniques have been developed in the past decade that have opened up new windows on replication origins. In the past few years, the application of these strategies has identified a large number of origins in a variety of different loci and organisms. Comparison of sequence motifs and chromosomal milieu, as well as genetic manipulation, should begin to uncover the secrets of these illusive regulatory elements.

Proximal and long-range alterations in chromatin structure surrounding the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase promoter

The chromatin structure of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene was examined by DNA/protein cross-linking, chemical DNA methylation, and micrococcal nuclease digestion. The 5' promoter region of the gene displays two nucleosome-free zones (-550 to -300 and -150 to +100 bp relative to the ATG codon), each of which contains a number of micrococcal nuclease-hypersensitive sites. Regions upstream from the distal hypersensitive zone (-900 to -550 bp), downstream from the proximal hypersensitive zone (+100 to +400 bp), and between these two zones (-300 to -150 bp) appear either to be more than 80% histone-free or to contain histones whose globular domains have lost most of their contacts with DNA. Overall, a broad zone extending from -4300 to +4700 bp is altered relative to bulk chromatin, and within this region there are positioned nucleosomes and/or nucleosome-free zones in which the DNA appears to interact with a number of different non-histone proteins. By comparison, the chromatin in the 3' end of the gene (including the right end of the 5th intron and the 6th exon) contains randomly positioned nucleosomes, and its structure is intermediate between that of the 5' end of the gene and a downstream matrix attachment region that contains regularly organized chromatin. A 2.3 kb zone in the central part of the 5th intron reveals some features similar to the 5' end of the gene, suggesting a hitherto unrecognized functional role.

Mimosine, a novel inhibitor of DNA replication, binds to a 50 kDa protein in Chinese hamster cells

We recently demonstrated that the plant amino acid, mimosine, is an extremely efficacious inhibitor of DNA replication in mammalian cells [P. A. Dijkwel and J. L. Hamlin (1992) Mol. Cell. Biol. 12, 3715-3722; P. J. Mosca et al. (1992) Mol. Cell. Biol. 12, 4375-4383]. Several of its properties further suggested that mimosine might target initiation at origins of replication, which would make it a unique and very useful inhibitor for studying the regulation of DNA synthesis. However, mimosine is known to chelate iron, a cofactor for ribonucleotide reductase. Thus, the possibility arose that mimosine functions in vivo simply by lowering intracellular deoxyribonucleotide pools. In the present study, we show that, in fact, it is possible to override mimosine inhibition in vivo by adding excess iron; however, copper, which is not a substitute for iron in ribonucleotide reductase, is equally effective. Evidence is presented that mimosine functions instead by binding to an intracellular protein. We show that radiolabeled mimosine can be specifically cross-linked to a 50 kDa polypeptide (termed p50) in vitro. Binding to p50 is virtually undetectable in CHO cells selected for resistance to 1 mM mimosine, arguing that p50 is the biologically relevant target. p50 is not associated with the cellular membrane fraction and, hence, is probably not a channel protein. Furthermore, the binding activity does not vary markedly as a function of cell cycle position, arguing that p50 is not a cyclin. Finally, both iron and copper are able to reverse the mimosine-p50 interaction in vitro, probably explaining why both metal ions are able to overcome mimosine's inhibitory effect on DNA synthesis in vivo.

Replication initiation sites are distributed widely in the amplified CHO dihydrofolate reductase domain

In previous studies, we utilized a neutral/neutral two-dimensional (2-D) gel replicon mapping method to analyze the pattern of DNA synthesis in the amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of CHOC 400 cells. Replication forks appeared to initiate at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout the 55 kb region lysing between the DHFR and 2BE2121 genes, and subsequently to move outward through the two genes. In the present study, we have analyzed this locus in detail by a complementary, neutral/alkaline 2-D gel technique that determines the direction in which replication forks move through a region of interest. In the early S period, forks are observed to travel in both directions through the intergenic region, but only outward through the DHFR gene. Surprisingly, however, replication forks also move in both directions through the 2BE2121 gene. Furthermore, in early S phase, small numbers of replication bubbles can be detected in the 2BE2121 gene on neutral/neutral 2-D gels. In contrast, replication bubbles have never been detected in the DHFR gene. Thus, replication initiates not only in the intergenic region, but also at a lower frequency in the 2BE2121 gene. We further show that only a small fraction of DHFR amplicons sustains an active initiation event, with the rest being replicated passively by forks from distant amplicons. These findings are discussed in light of other experimental approaches that suggest the presence of a much more narrowly circumscribed initiation zone within the intergenic region.

Radiation effects on DNA synthesis in a defined chromosomal replicon

It has recently been shown that the tumor suppressor p53 mediates a signal transduction pathway that responds to DNA damage by arresting cells in the late G1 period of the cell cycle. However, the operation of this pathway alone cannot explain the 50% reduction in the rate of DNA synthesis that occurs within 30 min of irradiation of an asynchronous cell population. We are using the amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain in the methotrexate-resistant CHO cell line, CHOC 400, as a model replicon in which to study this acute radiation effect. We first show that the CHOC 400 cell line retains the classical acute-phase response but does not display the late G1 arrest that characterizes the p53-mediated checkpoint. Using a two-dimensional gel replicon-mapping method, we then show that when asynchronous cultures are irradiated with 900 cGy, initiation in the DHFR locus is completely inhibited within 30 min and does not resume for 3 to 4 h. Since initiation in this locus occurs throughout the first 2 h of the S period, this result implies the existence of a p53-independent S-phase damage-sensing pathway that functions at the level of individual origins. Results obtained with the replication inhibitor mimosine define a position near the G1/S boundary beyond which cells are unable to prevent initiation at early-firing origins in response to irradiation. This is the first direct demonstration at a defined chromosomal origin that radiation quantitatively down-regulates initiation.

A general protocol for evaluating the specific effects of DNA replication inhibitors

Inhibitors of DNA replication in mammalian cells are of great interest because of their potential use in chemotherapy and in cell synchronizing protocols in the laboratory. We have used a combination of isotopic labelling protocols and a two-dimensional gel replicon mapping procedure to determine the specific effects of five different replication inhibitors in cultured cells. Utilizing this protocol, we show that hydroxyurea, aphidicolin, and cytosine arabinoside, three known chain elongation inhibitors, are rather ineffective at preventing fork progression even at relatively high concentrations. In contrast, two related compounds that have been suggested to be G1/S inhibitors (mimosine and ciclopyrox olamine [CPX]) actually appear to inhibit initiation at origins. One of these agents (CPX) appears also to inhibit replication in yeast, opening the possibility that the gene encoding the target (initiator?) protein can first be identified in yeast by genetic approaches and can then be used to isolate the mammalian homologue.

Sister chromatid fusion initiates amplification of the dihydrofolate reductase gene in Chinese hamster cells

We have utilized a dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) probe in combination with selected probes from other positions along the 2q chromosome arm in a two-color fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis of early DHFR gene amplification events in CHO cells. These studies show clearly that the most frequent initiating event is the formation of a giant inverted duplication, resulting from chromosome breakage and terminal fusion or a reverse unequal sister chromatid exchange. The dicentric chromosomes thus formed initiate bridge/breakage/fusion cycles that appear to mediate subsequent amplification steps to higher copy number.

Initiation of replication in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase domain

Two-dimensional (2-D) gel analysis of replication intermediates in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase domain has suggested that nascent chains can initiate at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout a approximately 50 kb "initiation locus" (although the level of initiation detected at any given site within this region was relatively low). This result contrasts markedly with data from an in vitro strand switching assay suggesting that > 80% of initiations occur within a single 500 bp fragment lying within the initiation locus. In an effort to reconcile these two disparate views of the initiation reaction, we have questioned the validity of our 2-D gel data in several ways. We show here that: 1) the number of replication bubbles detected in the DHFR locus in the early S period is markedly increased when the cells are released from a synchronizing agent that inhibits initiation per se, rather than from aphidicolin, which is a chain elongation inhibitor; 2) initiation in the DHFR domain occurs only during the first 90 min of the S period, as would be expected of an early-firing origin; 3) a pulse of 3H-thymidine moves through the structures observed on 2-D gels with the kinetics expected of bonafide replication intermediates; and 4) preparations of replication intermediates that are subsequently analyzed on 2-D gels appear, by electron microscopy, to represent the typical theta structures and single-forked molecules expected of bidirectional origins of replication; no unusual structures (e.g., microbubbles) were seen.

The plant amino acid mimosine may inhibit initiation at origins of replication in Chinese hamster cells

An understanding of replication initiation in mammalian cells has been hampered by the lack of mutations and/or inhibitors that arrest cells just prior to entry into the S period. The plant amino acid mimosine has recently been suggested to inhibit cells at a regulatory step in late G1. We have examined the effects of mimosine on cell cycle traverse in the mimosine [corrected]-resistant CHO cell line CHOC 400. When administered to cultures for 14 h after reversal of a G0 block, the drug appears to arrest the population at the G1/S boundary, and upon its removal cells enter the S phase in a synchronous wave. However, when methotrexate is administered to an actively dividing asynchronous culture, cells are arrested not only at the G1/S interface but also in early and middle S phase. Most interestingly, two-dimensional gel analysis of replication intermediates in the initiation locus of the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain suggests that mimosine may actually inhibit initiation. Thus, this drug represents a new class of inhibitors that may open a window on regulatory events occurring at individual origins of replication.

Mammalian origins of replication

It has been almost twenty-five years since Huberman and Riggs first showed that there are multiple bidirectional origins of replication scattered at approximately 100 kb intervals along mammalian chromosomal fibers. Since that time, every conceivable physical property unique to replicating DNA has been taken advantage of to determine whether origins of replication are defined sequence elements, as they are in microorganisms. The most thoroughly studied mammalian locus to date is the dihydrofolate reductase domain of Chinese hamster cells, which will be used as a model to discuss the various methods of investigation. While several laboratories agree on the rough location of the 'initiation locus' in this large chromosomal domain, different experimental approaches paint different pictures of the mechanism by which initiation occurs. However, a variety of new techniques and synchronizing agents promises to clarify the picture for this particular locus, and to provide the means for identifying and isolating other origins of replication for comparison.

Initiation of DNA replication in the dihydrofolate reductase locus is confined to the early S period in CHO cells synchronized with the plant amino acid mimosine

In previous studies, we used two complementary two-dimensional gel electrophoretic methods to examine replication intermediates in the 240-kb amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of methotrexate-resistant CHOC 400 cells (J. P. Vaughn, P. A. Dijkwel, and J. L. Hamlin, Cell 61:1075-1087, 1990). Surprisingly, in both asynchronous and early-S-phase cultures, initiation bubbles were detected in several contiguous fragments from a previously defined 28-kb initiation locus. However, because of the low levels of bubblelike structures observed on gels, it has been suggested that these structures might represent artifacts, possibly unrelated to replication per se. In this study, we have achieved much more synchronous entry into S phase by using a novel inhibitor and have isolated replication intermediates by a new procedure that largely eliminates branch migration and shear. Under these conditions, we find that (i) the relative number of bubblelike structures detected in fragments from the initiation locus is markedly increased, (ii) bubbles are detected at multiple sites scattered throughout the region lying between the DHFR and 2BE2121 genes, and (iii) bubbles appear and disappear in this region with the kinetics expected of an early-firing origin. These data strengthen the proposal that in vivo, initiation can occur at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout a broad zone in the DHFR domain.

Activation of a mammalian origin of replication by chromosomal rearrangement

The methotrexate-resistant Chinese hamster cell line DC3F/A3-4K (A3/4K) contains at least two prominent dihydrofolate reductase amplicon types. The type I amplicons, constituting approximately 80% of the total, are at least 650 kb in length, but the endpoints have not yet been characterized. The type II sequences represent approximately 20% of amplicons, are 450 kb in length, and are arranged as alternating head-to-head and tail-to-tail repeats. In previous studies on the CHOC 400 line, in which the amplicons are much smaller, a replication initiation locus (ori-beta/ori-gamma) has been shown to reside downstream from the dihydrofolate reductase gene. In a more recent study on the larger amplicons of A3/4K cells, we detected an additional initiation locus (ori-alpha) lying approximately 240 kb upstream from ori-beta/ori-gamma. Interestingly, in vivo labelling experiments suggested that replication forks diverge from ori-alpha only in the downstream direction. This finding suggested either that ori-alpha is a unidirectional origin or that a terminus lies immediately upstream from ori-alpha. However, in this study, we show that ori-alpha is actually very close to the head-to-head palindromic junction sequence between the minor type II amplicons in A3/4K cells; furthermore, ori-alpha is active in the early S period in the type II amplicons but not in the larger type I sequences that lack this palindromic junction. This is the first direct demonstration in mammalian cells that a cryptic origin can be activated by chromosomal rearrangement, presumably by deleting negative regulatory elements or by creating a more favorable chromosomal milieu for initiation.

Mapping of replication initiation sites in mammalian genomes by two-dimensional gel analysis: stabilization and enrichment of replication intermediates by isolation on the nuclear matrix

Two complementary two-dimensional gel electrophoretic techniques have recently been developed that allow initiation sites to be mapped with relative precision in eukaryotic genomes at least as complex as those of yeast and Drosophila melanogaster. We reported the first application of these mapping methods to a mammalian genome in a study on the amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of the methotrexate-resistant CHO cell line CHOC 400 (J.P. Vaughn, P.A. Dijkwel, and J.L. Hamlin, Cell 61:1075-1087, 1990). Our results suggested that in this 240-kb domain, initiation of nascent DNA strands occurs at many sites within a 30- to 35-kb zone mapping immediately downstream from the DHFR gene. In the course of these studies, it was necessary to develop methods to stabilize replication intermediates against branch migration and shear. This report describes these stabilization methods in detail and presents a new enrichment protocol that extends the neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel mapping method to single-copy loci in mammalian cells. Preliminary analysis of replication intermediates purified from CHO cells by this method suggests that DNA synthesis may initiate at many sites within a broad zone in the single-copy DHFR locus as well.

Origins of replication: timing and chromosomal position

Several new methods have been used to localize replication initiation sites in mammalian chromosomes. The results of these studies argue strongly for the presence of defined sequence elements that function much like the origins in the genomes of simple microorganisms. However, relatively disparate results from in vivo and in vitro studies suggest that initiation reactions in mammalian chromosomes may have unique features, possibly related to a more complicated chromosomal architecture.

Repetitive sequence elements in an initiation locus of the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain in CHO cells

We have previously demonstrated that one of the replication initiation loci in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of Chinese hamster cells contains a repeated sequence that is enriched in the early-replicating fraction of the Chinese hamster genome. Here we present the sequence of the initiation locus, identify the relevant repeated element, and show that, while this element is enriched in early-replicating DNA, its synthesis is not confined to early S.

Replication initiates in a broad zone in the amplified CHO dihydrofolate reductase domain

We have used two complementary two-dimensional gel electrophoretic methods to localize replication inititation sites and to determine replication fork direction in the amplified 240 kb dihydrofolate reductase domain of the methotrexate-resistant CHO cell line CHOC 400. Surprisingly, our analysis indicates that replication begins at many sites in several restriction fragments distributed throughout a previously defined 28 kb initiation locus, including a fragment containing a matrix attachment region. Initiation sites were not detected in regions lying upstream or downstream of this locus. Our results suggest that initiation reactions in mammalian chromosomal origins may be more complex than in the origins of simple microorganisms.

Replication forks are associated with the nuclear matrix

It has been proposed that DNA in eukaryotic cells is synthesized via replication complexes that are fixed to a proteinaceous nuclear matrix. This model has not been universally accepted because the matrix and its associated DNA are usually prepared under hypertonic conditions that could facilitate non-specific aggregation of macromolecules. We therefore investigated whether different ionic conditions can significantly affect the association of nascent DNA with the nuclear matrix in cultured mammalian cells. Matrices were prepared either by a high salt method or by hypotonic or isotonic LIS extraction. Chromosomal DNA was subsequently removed by digestion with either DNAse I or EcoRI. With all methods of preparation, we found that newly synthesized DNA preferentially partitioned with the nuclear matrix. Furthermore, when the matrix-attached DNA fraction was analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, we found that it was markedly enriched for replication forks. We therefore conclude that attachment of DNA to the matrix in the vicinity of replication forks is not induced by conditions of high ionic strength, and that replication may, indeed, occur on or near the skeletal framework provided by the nuclear matrix. From a practical standpoint, our findings suggest a strategy for greatly increasing the sensitivity of two important new gel electrophoretic methods for the direct mapping of replication fork movement through defined chromosomal domains in mammalian cells.

Multiple origins of replication in the dihydrofolate reductase amplicons of a methotrexate-resistant chinese hamster cell line

We recently showed that replication initiates in the early S period at two closely spaced zones in the 240-kilobase (kb) dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) amplicon of the methotrexate-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell line CHOC 400. Both of these initiation loci (ori-beta and ori-gamma) have previously been cloned in a recombinant cosmid. In this study, we identified a third early-firing initiation locus (ori-alpha) in the much larger DHFR amplicon of the independently isolated methotrexate-resistant Chinese hamster cell line DC3F-A3/4K (A3/4K). We describe the molecular cloning of this newly identified locus and demonstrate by chromosomal walking that ori-alpha lies approximately 240 kb upstream from ori-beta. Using overlapping cosmid clones for more than 450 kb of DNA sequence from this region of the DHFR domain, we have monitored the replication pattern of the amplicons in synchronized A3/4K cells. These studies suggest that ori-alpha, ori-beta, and ori-gamma are the only early-firing initiation sites in this 450-kb sequence. In addition, we have been able to roughly localize the termini between ori-alpha and ori-beta and between ori-alpha and the next origin in the 5' direction. Thus, we have now isolated the equivalent of three early-firing replicons (including their origins) from a well-characterized chromosomal domain. With these tools, it should be possible to determine those properties that are shared by the origins and termini of different replicons and which are therefore likely to be functionally significant.

Early dihydrofolate reductase gene amplification events in CHO cells usually occur on the same chromosome arm as the original locus

We used fluorescence in situ hybridization to examine the products of early DNA sequence amplification events in CHO cells. Nine independent populations of cells were selected for resistance to 0.4 microM methotrexate (MTX), and mitotic chromosome spreads were hybridized to a mixture of cloned cosmids representing approximately 273 kb of contiguous DNA sequence from the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) locus. Of the nine populations, eight contain cells that have amplified the DHFR domain. Cells in the remaining population displayed only the two single-copy loci on chromosomes 2 and Z2. Of the eight amplificants, one carries amplified DHFR genes on chromosome 2, six on chromosome Z2, and one on an unidentified chromosome. Some cultures carry additional amplified genes on other chromosomes, probably resulting from bridge/breakage/fusion cycles or translocations. In six of the eight amplificants, both single-copy parental loci are detected at their original positions, and amplicon clusters are situated at least 50 megabases (Mb) away on the same chromosome arm, often at the termini. Amplification occurred at or close to the original site of the DHFR gene in only one population. Our results are not consistent with models in which initial amplification events occur by over-replication of the parental locus followed by recombination in loco. Because amplified DHFR sequences occur most often on the same chromosome arm as the parental DHFR gene but at a considerable distance from it, our results are most compatible with either sister chromatid exchange between widely separated sites or with a form of conservative intrachromosomal duplication analogous to transposition in bacteria.

Identification and characterization of a gene that is coamplified with dihydrofolate reductase in a methotrexate-resistant CHO cell line

As part of an effort to characterize the spatial and functional relationships among genetic elements within the amplified dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain in Chinese hamster cells, we have used a variation of the differential hybridization approach to identify cDNA clones whose genes are coamplified with DHFR in the methotrexate-resistant cell line, CHOC 400. Our initial screen was successful in isolating both DHFR and non-DHFR cDNAs. One of the non-DHFR cDNA clones, 2BE2121, hybridizes on Northern (RNA) blots to abundant 1,200- and 1,500-nucleotide (nt) transcripts which differ in the lengths of their 3' untranslated regions. The clone 2BE2121 contains a 789-nt open reading frame but does not appear to be related to any members of the protein or nucleic acid sequence databases. A second larger non-DHFR cDNA, II-19-211, was isolated that is transcribed from the same gene as 2BE2121 but contains only a small carboxyl-terminal portion of the open reading frame. II-19-211 may, therefore, represent either a splicing intermediate or an mRNA transcribed from a cryptic intragenic promoter. Hybridization to cosmids from the DHFR domain shows that 2BE2121 is encoded by a gene approximately 34 kilobases (kb) long. The 5'-most genomic fragment is less than 4 kb from an interamplicon junction. The 3' end of the 2BE2121 gene lies approximately 75 kb downstream from the DHFR gene and approximately 25 kb downstream from the proximal replication initiation site, and the transcriptional polarity is opposite to that of the leading strand of replication. Thus, both the DHFR and 2BE2121 genes are exceptions to the theory that transcription proceeds in the same direction as the leading strand of the replication fork.

High-resolution mapping of replication fork movement through the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain in CHO cells by in-gel renaturation analysis

Utilizing an in vivo labeling method on synchronized cultures, we have previously defined a 28-kilobase (kb) replication initiation locus in the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain of a methotrexate-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell line (CHOC 400) (N. H. Heintz and J. L. Hamlin, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:4083-4087, 1982; N. H. Heintz and J. L. Hamlin, Biochemistry 22:3552-3557, 1983; N. H. Heintz, J. D. Milbrandt, K. S. Greisen, and J. L. Hamlin, Nature [London] 302:439-441, 1983). To locate the origin of replication in this 243-kb amplicon with more precision, we used an in-gel renaturation procedure (I. Roninson, Nucleic Acids Res. 11:5413-5431, 1983) to examine the labeling pattern of restriction fragments from the amplicon in the early S phase. This method eliminates background labeling from single-copy sequences and allows quantitation of the relative radioactivity in individual fragments. We used this procedure to follow the movement of replication forks through the amplicons, to roughly localize the initiation locus, and to estimate the rate of fork travel. We also used a slight modification of this method (termed hybridization enhancement) to illuminate the labeling pattern of smaller restriction fragments derived solely from the initiation locus itself, thereby increasing resolution. Our preliminary results suggest that there are actually two distinct initiation sites in the amplicon that are separated by approximately 22 kb.