Quality and Outcome Assessment for Surgery

ABSTRACT

This forum summarizes the proceedings of the joint European Surgical Association (ESA)/American Surgical Association (ASA) symposium on Quality and Outcome Assessment for Surgery that took place in Bordeaux, France, as part of the celebrations of the 30th anniversary of the ESA. Three presentations focused on a) the main messages from the Outcome4Medicine Consensus Conference, which took place in Zurich, Switzerland, in June 2022, b) the patient perspective, and c) benchmarking were hold by ESA members and discussed by ASA members in a symposium attended by members of both associations.

Stenting in Malignant Biliary Obstruction

Decompression of the biliary system in patients with malignant biliary obstruction has been widely accepted and implemented as part of the care. Despite a wealth of literature, there remains a significant amount of uncertainty as to which approach would be most appropriate in different clinical settings. This review covers stenting of the biliary system in cases of resectable or palliative malignant biliary obstruction, potential candidates for biliary drainage, technical aspects of the procedure, as well as management of biliary stent dysfunction. Furthermore, periprocedural considerations including proper mapping of the location of obstruction and the use of antibiotics are addressed.

Comparison Costs of ERCP and MRCP in Patients with Suspected Biliary Obstruction Based on a Randomized Trial

BACKGROUND

The optimal management of patients with suspected biliary obstruction remains unclear, and includes the possible performance of magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP) and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP).

OBJECTIVES

To complete a cost analysis based on a medical effectiveness randomized trial comparing an ERCP-first approach with an MRCP-first approach in patients with suspected bile duct obstruction.

METHODS

The management strategies were based on a medical effectiveness trial of 257 patients over a 12-month follow-up period. Direct and indirect costs were included, adopting a societal perspective. The cost values are expressed in 2012 Canadian dollars.

RESULTS

Total per-patient direct costs were Can$3547 for ERCP-first patients and Can$4013 for MRCP-first patients. Corresponding indirect costs were Can$732 and Can$694, respectively. Causes for differences in direct costs included a more frequent second procedure and a greater mean number of hospital days over the year in patients of the MRCP-first group. In contrast, it is the ERCP-first patients whose indirect costs were greater, principally due to more time away from activities of daily living. Choosing an ERCP-first strategy rather than an MRCP-first strategy saved on average Can$428 per patient over the 12-month follow-up duration; however, there existed a large amount of overlap when varying total cost estimates across a sensitivity analysis range based on observed resources utilization.

CONCLUSIONS

This cost analysis suggests only a small difference in total costs, favoring the ERCP-first group, and is principally attributable to procedures and hospitalizations with little impact from indirect cost measurements.

Hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery workforce in Canada

This article characterizes the Canadian hepato-pancreato-biliary (HPB) surgery workforce (demographics, practice patterns, career satisfaction, education and recruitment plans). This information will serve as a baseline for future national comparisons, allow informed workforce planning and facilitate mathematical modelling of the HPB workforce in Canada.

McGill Brisbane Symptom Score for patients with resectable pancreatic head adenocarcinoma

AIM: To evaluate the ability of the McGill Brisbane Symptom Score (MBSS) to predict survival in resectable pancreatic head adenocarcinoma (PHA) patients.

METHODS: All PHA patients (n = 83) undergoing pancreaticoduodenectomy at the McGill University Health Center, Quebec between 1/2001-1/2010 were evaluated. Data related to patient and cancer characteristics, MBSS variables, and treatment were collected; univariable and multivariable survival analyses were performed. We obtained complete follow-up until February 2011 in all patients through the database of the provincial health insurance plan of Quebec. The unique health insurance numbers of these patients were used to retrieve information from this database which captures all billable clinical encounters, and ensures 100% actual survival data.

RESULTS: Median survival was 23 mo overall: 45 mo for patients with low MBSS, 17 mo for high MBSS (P = 0.005). At twelve months survival was 83.3% (95%CI: 66.6-92.1) vs 58.1% (95%CI: 42.1-71.2) in those with low vs high MBSS, and24 mo survival was 63.8% (95%CI: 45.9-77.1) and 34.0% (95%CI: 20.2-48.2) respectively. In the multivariate Cox model (stratified by chemotherapy), after addition of clinically meaningful covariates, MBSS was the variable with the strongest association with survival (HR = 2.63; P = 0.001). Adjuvant chemotherapy interacted with MBSS category such that only high MBSS patients accrued a benefit. In univariate analysis we found a lower mortality in high MBSS but not low MBSS patients receiving adjuvant chemotherapy. This interaction variable, on Cox model, resulted in an adjusted mortality HR for the high MBSS (compared to low MBSS) of 4.14 (95%CI: 1.48-11.64) without chemotherapy and 2.11 (95%CI: 1.06-4.17) with chemotherapy.

CONCLUSION: The MBSS is a simple prognostic tool for resectable PHA. Preoperative categorization of patients according to the MBSS allows effective stratification of patients to guide therapy.

Pancreatic cancer and predictors of survival: comparing the CA 19-9/bilirubin ratio with the McGill Brisbane Symptom Score

INTRODUCTION

Few tools predict survival from pancreatic cancer (PAC). The McGill Brisbane Symptom Score (MBSS) based on symptoms at presentation (weight loss, pain, jaundice and smoking) was recently validated. The present study compares the ability of four strategies to predict 9-month survival: MBSS, carbohydrate antigen 19-9 (CA 19-9) alone, CA19-9-to-bilirubin ratio and a combination of MBSS and the CA19-9-to-bilirubin ratio.

METHODOLOGY

A retrospective review of 133 patients diagnosed with PAC between 2005 and 2011 was performed. Survival was determined from the Quebec civil registry. Blood CA 19-9 and bilirubin values were collected (n = 52) at the time of diagnosis. Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves were used to determine a cutoff for optimal test characteristics of CA 19-9 and CA19-9-to-total bilirubin ratio in predicting survival at 9 months. Predictive characteristics were then calculated for the four strategies.

RESULTS

Of the four strategies, the one with the greatest negative predictive value was the MBSS: negative predictive value (NPV) was 90.2% (76.9-97.3%) and the positive likelihood ratio (LR) was the greatest. The ability of CA 19-9 levels alone, at baseline, to predict survival was low. For the CA19-9-to-bilirubin ratio, the test characteristics improved but remained non-significant. The best performing strategy according to likelihood ratios was the combined MBSS and CA19-9 to the bilirubin ratio.

CONCLUSION

CA19-9 levels and the CA19-9-to-bilirubin ratio are poor predictors of survival for PAC, whereas the MBSS is a far better predictor, confirming its clinical value. By adding the CA19-9-to-bilirubin ratio to the MBSS the predictive characteristics improved.

Randomised clinical trial: MRCP-first vs. ERCP-first approach in patients with suspected biliary obstruction due to bile duct stones

BACKGROUND

The preferred initial investigation with either magnetic resonance (MRCP) or endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) in patients with suspected biliary obstruction remains controversial in many clinical settings.

AIM

To assess the effectiveness of an initial MRCP vs. ERCP in the work-up of patients at moderate likelihood of a suspected biliary obstruction.

METHODS

Patients with an unconfirmed benign biliary obstruction, based on laboratory and ultrasound findings, were randomised to an ERCP-first or MRCP-first strategy, stratified by level of obstruction. The primary outcome was the occurrence of a disease or procedure-related bilio-pancreatic adverse events within the next 12 months. Secondary outcomes were the number of subsequent bilio-pancreatic procedures, duration of hospitalisation, days away from activities of daily living (ADL), quality of life (SF-36) and mortality.

RESULTS

We randomised 126 patients to ERCP-first and 131 to MRCP-first (age 54 ± 18 years, 62% female, 39% post-cholecystectomy). In follow-up, 18/126 (14.3%) ERCP-first and 25/131 (19.1%) MRCP-first patients experienced a procedure- or disease-related complication (P = 0.30) (disease-related in 13 and 18 patients, and procedure-related in 5 and 7 patients respectively). A cause of biliary obstruction was found in 39.7% vs. 49.6% of patients (P = 0.11). Sixty-six (50%) patients in the MRCP-first group ended up avoiding an ERCP in follow-up. ERCP-first and MRCP-first patients were away from usual activities for 3.4 ± 7.7 days and 2.0 ± 4.8 days respectively (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

A strategy of MRCP-first decreased the need for subsequent MRCPs, but not complications. Further study is required to define factors influencing the eventual use of MRCP vs. ERCP in appropriately selected patients (ClinicalTrial.gov: NCT01424657).

Hepatitis C infection and hepatocellular carcinoma in liver transplantation: a 20-year experience

BACKGROUND

Hepatitis C infection (HCV) and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), the two main causes of liver transplantation (LT), have reduced survival post-LT. The impact of HCV, HCC and their coexistence on post-LT survival were assessed.

METHODOLOGY

All 601 LT patients from 1992 to 2011 were reviewed. Those deceased within 30 days (n = 69) and re-transplants (n = 49) were excluded. Recipients were divided into four groups: (a) HCC-/HCV-(n = 252) (b) HCC+/HCV- (n = 58), (c) HCC-/HCV+ (n = 106) and (d) HCC+/HCV+ (n = 67). Demographics, the donor risk index (DRI), Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) score, survival, complications and tumour characteristics were collected. Statistical analysis included anova, chi-square, Fisher's exact tests and Cox and Kaplan-Meier for overall survival.

RESULTS

Groups were comparable with regards to baseline characteristics, but HCC patients were older. After adjusting for age, MELD, gender and the donor risk index (DRI), survival was lower in the HCC+/HCV+ group (59.5% at 5 yrs) and the hazard ratio (HR) was 1.90 [95% confidence interval (CI),1.24-2.95, P = 0.003] and 1.45 (95% CI, 0.99-2.12, P = 0.054) for HCC-/HCV+. HCC survival was similar to controls (HR 1.18, 95% CI, 0.71-1.93, P = 0.508). HCC+/HCV- patients exceeded the Milan criteria (50% versus 31%, P < 0.04) and had more micro-vascular invasion (37.5% versus 20.6%, P = 0.042). HCC+/HCV+ versus HCC+/HCV- survival remained lower (HR 1.94, 95% CI, 1.06-3.81, P = 0.041) after correcting for tumour characteristics and treatment.

CONCLUSION

HCV patients had lower survival post-LT. HCC alone had no impact on survival. Patient survival decreased in the HCC+/HCV+ group and this appears to be as a consequence of HCV recurrence.

IDEAL framework for surgical innovation 2: observational studies in the exploration and assessment stages

The IDEAL framework describes the stages of evaluation for surgical innovations. This paper considers the role of observational studies in the exploration and assessment stages. At the exploration stage, the surgical intervention is usually more widely used, and observational studies should collect prospective data from multiple surgeons, deal with factors such as case mix and learning, and prepare for a definitive evaluation at the next stage of assessment. Although a randomised controlled trial is preferable, a high quality observational study would be acceptable if a randomised trial is not feasible or, on rare occasions, deemed unnecessary.

Recurrence of non-invasive intraductal papillary municious neoplasm seven years following total pancreatectomy

INTRODUCTION

Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm is an increasingly recognized disease with varying premalignant potential and unclear incidence, characterized by a mucin-producing epithelium and dilation of the pancreatic duct.

PRESENTATION OF CASE

We present the first documented case of distant intestinal intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm recurrence following total pancreatectomy for side-branch non-invasive borderline malignant intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm.

DISCUSSION

We review the current literature in order to try and answer important questions regarding our ability to predict intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm recurrence, our understanding of the potential for recurrence and what follow-up should be recommended to properly monitor recurrence after a benign, albeit borderline malignant, side-branch lesion resection.

CONCLUSION

Our case report confirms that the low risk classification of an intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm lesion even after total pancreatectomy does not always predict recurrence and that definitive prognostic factors of recurrence in the setting of non-invasive disease have yet to be identified. A vigilant long-term approach to follow-up may thus be required even in low risk cases.

The quality of research synthesis in surgery: the case of laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer

BACKGROUND

Several systematic reviews and meta-analyses populate the literature on the effectiveness of laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer. The utility of this body of work is unclear. The objective of this study was to synthesize all such systematic reviews in terms of clinical effectiveness, to appraise their quality, and to determine whether areas of duplication exist across reviews.

METHODS

Systematic reviews comparing laparoscopic and open surgery for colorectal cancer were identified using a comprehensive search protocol (1991 to 2008). The primary outcome was overall survival. The methodological quality of reviews was appraised using the Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) instrument. Abstraction and quality appraisal was carried out by two independent reviewers. Reviews were synthesized, and outcomes were compared qualitatively. A citation analysis was carried out using simple matrices to assess the comprehensiveness of each review.

RESULTS

In total, 27 reviews were included; 13 reviews included only randomized controlled trials. Rectal cancer was addressed exclusively by four reviews. There was significant overlap between review purposes, populations and, outcomes. The mean AMSTAR score (out of 11) was 5.8 (95% CI: 4.6 to 7.0). Overall survival was evaluated by ten reviews, none of which found a significant difference. Three reviews provided a selective meta-analysis of time-to-event data. Previously published systematic reviews were poorly and highly selectively referenced (mean citation ratio 0.16, 95% CI: 0.093 to 0.22). Previously published trials were not comprehensively identified and cited (mean citation ratio 0.56, 95% CI: 0.46 to 0.65).

CONCLUSIONS

Numerous overlapping systematic reviews of laparoscopic and open surgery for colorectal cancer exist in the literature. Despite variable methods and quality, survival outcomes are congruent across reviews. A duplication of research efforts appears to exist in the literature. Further systematic reviews or meta-analyses are unlikely to be justified without specifying a significantly different research objective. This works lends support to the registration and updating of systematic reviews.

Unresectable pancreatic adenocarcinoma: do we know who survives?

BACKGROUND

This study attempts to define clinical predictors of survival in patients with unresectable pancreatic adenocarcinoma (UPA).

METHODS

A retrospective study of 94 consecutive patients diagnosed with UPA from 2001 to 2006 was performed. Using data for these patients, a symptom score was devised through a forward stepwise Cox proportional hazards model based on four weighted criteria: weight loss of >10% of body weight; pain; jaundice, and smoking. The symptom score was subsequently validated in a distinct cohort of 32 patients diagnosed with UPA in 2007.

RESULTS

In the original cohort, the overall median survival was 9.0 months (95% confidence interval [CI] 7.6-10.4). This altered to 10.3 months (95% CI 6.1-14.5) in patients with locally advanced disease, and 6.6 months (95% CI 4.2-9.0) in patients with distant metastasis. Median survival was 14.6 months (95% CI 13.1-16.1) in patients with a low symptom (LS) score and 6.3 months (95% CI 4.1-8.5) in patients with a high symptom (HS) score. A total of 73% of LS score patients survived beyond 9 months, compared with only 38% of HS score patients (P<0.001). The discrimination of the LS score was greater than that of any conventional method, including imaging. The validation cohort confirmed the discriminative ability of the symptom score for survival.

CONCLUSIONS

A simple and clinically meaningful point-based symptom score can successfully predict survival in patients with UPA.

No surgical innovation without evaluation: the IDEAL recommendations

Surgery and other invasive therapies are complex interventions, the assessment of which is challenged by factors that depend on operator, team, and setting, such as learning curves, quality variations, and perception of equipoise. We propose recommendations for the assessment of surgery based on a five-stage description of the surgical development process. We also encourage the widespread use of prospective databases and registries. Reports of new techniques should be registered as a professional duty, anonymously if necessary when outcomes are adverse. Case series studies should be replaced by prospective development studies for early technical modifications and by prospective research databases for later pre-trial evaluation. Protocols for these studies should be registered publicly. Statistical process control techniques can be useful in both early and late assessment. Randomised trials should be used whenever possible to investigate efficacy, but adequate pre-trial data are essential to allow power calculations, clarify the definition and indications of the intervention, and develop quality measures. Difficulties in doing randomised clinical trials should be addressed by measures to evaluate learning curves and alleviate equipoise problems. Alternative prospective designs, such as interrupted time series studies, should be used when randomised trials are not feasible. Established procedures should be monitored with prospective databases to analyse outcome variations and to identify late and rare events. Achievement of improved design, conduct, and reporting of surgical research will need concerted action by editors, funders of health care and research, regulatory bodies, and professional societies.

Evaluation and stages of surgical innovations

Surgical innovation is an important part of surgical practice. Its assessment is complex because of idiosyncrasies related to surgical practice, but necessary so that introduction and adoption of surgical innovations can derive from evidence-based principles rather than trial and error. A regulatory framework is also desirable to protect patients against the potential harms of any novel procedure. In this first of three Series papers on surgical innovation and evaluation, we propose a five-stage paradigm to describe the development of innovative surgical procedures.

Challenges in evaluating surgical innovation

Research on surgical interventions is associated with several methodological and practical challenges of which few, if any, apply only to surgery. However, surgical evaluation is especially demanding because many of these challenges coincide. In this report, the second of three on surgical innovation and evaluation, we discuss obstacles related to the study design of randomised controlled trials and non-randomised studies assessing surgical interventions. We also describe the issues related to the nature of surgical procedures-for example, their complexity, surgeon-related factors, and the range of outcomes. Although difficult, surgical evaluation is achievable and necessary. Solutions tailored to surgical research and a framework for generating evidence on which to base surgical practice are essential.

Preoperative alpha-fetoprotein slope is predictive of hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

Liver transplantation (LT) offers a possible cure for patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) and cirrhosis. However, tumour progression while on the waiting list and tumour recurrence after LT are common. The prognostic significance of various pre- and postoperative variables were investigated in regard to tumour recurrence, with an emphasis on the slope of preoperative serum alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) levels. patients and

METHODS

Data from 48 patients who had HCC diagnosed preoperatively and underwent LT at the McGill University Health Centre (Montreal, Quebec) were reviewed retrospectively, and possible risk factors for tumour recurrence were examined.

RESULTS

Univariate analysis revealed a positive correlation between the preoperative AFP slope and vascular invasion (P = 0.045), total tumour diameter at explant (P = 0.040), Cancer of the Liver Italian Program score (P = 0.017) and recurrence-free survival (P = 0.028). Of the preoperative variables examined, only the preoperative AFP slope was identified as an independent predictor of tumour recurrence by multivariate analysis. Receiver operating characteristic analysis showed that the best discriminant cut-off value, calculated as the value of the maximized likelihood ratio, was preoperative AFP slope greater than 50 microg/L per month. At this cut-off, sensitivity was 36%, and specificity was 97%. Patients with a preoperative AFP slope greater than 50 microg/L per month had a much worse one-year recurrence-free survival rate than those with a preoperative AFP slope 50 microg/L per month or less (40% versus 90%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the preoperative AFP slope is an important predictor of HCC recurrence after LT and should be examined in future studies of patients receiving LT for HCC.

Evaluating Surgical Outcomes

The study of outcomes has become essential for guiding quality of-care assessment and for clinical research. In this article, the properties and process of patient outcomes measurement are described. The limitations of traditional outcomes are discussed and contrasted with the emerging concept of "patient-centered"outcomes, measured by validated instruments to assess the effects of surgical interventions on health-related quality of life, functional status, pain, and patient satisfaction. The strengths and weaknesses of several measurement tools used in the surgical literature are evaluated. Finally, the authors introduce "composite outcomes" as a reflection of the multidimensional nature of modern patient care.

Nonoperative imaging techniques in suspected biliary tract obstruction

Evaluation of suspected biliary tract obstruction is a common clinical problem. Clinical data such as history, physical examination, and laboratory tests can accurately identify up to 90% of patients whose jaundice is caused by extrahepatic obstruction. However, complete assessment of extrahepatic obstruction often requires the use of various imaging modalities to confirm the presence, level, and cause of obstruction, and to aid in treatment plan. In the present summary, the literature on competing technologies including endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP), percutaneous transhepatic cholangiopancreatography (PTC), endoscopic ultrasound (EUS), intraductal ultrasonography (IDUS), magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP), helical CT (hCT) and helical CT cholangiography (hCTC) with regards to diagnostic performance characteristics, technical success, safety, and cost-effectiveness is reviewed. Patients with obstructive jaundice secondary to choledocholithiasis or pancreaticobiliary malignancies are the primary focus of this review. Algorithms for the management of suspected obstructive jaundice are put forward based on current evidence. Published data suggest an increasing role for EUS and other noninvasive imaging techniques such as MRCP, and hCT following an initial transabdominal ultrasound in the assessment of patients with suspected biliary obstruction to select candidates for surgery or therapeutic ERCP. The management of patients with a suspected pancreaticobiliary condition ultimately is dependent on local expertise, availability, cost, and the multidisciplinary collaboration between radiologists, surgeons, and gastroenterologists.

The impact of thymoglobulin on renal function and calcineurin inhibitor initiation in recipients of orthotopic liver transplant: a retrospective analysis of 298 consecutive patients

BACKGROUND

Renal dysfunction remains the Achilles' heel of calcineurin inhibitor (CI)use. The purpose of this study was to assess our institutional, renal-sparing strategy using thymoglobulin (TMG) in recipients of orthotopic liver transplants.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of data from 298 adult recipients who were transplanted between 1991 and 2002. The patients were divided into two groups: those induced with TMG (group 1) and those that were not treated with this agent (group 2). A subgroup analysis was performed of patients with baseline serum creatinine values above 1.5 mg/dL (group 1A received TMG; group 2A did not). All patients received tacrolimus or cyclosporine (CyA) maintenance immunosuppression.

RESULTS

Indications and demographics were similar between the two groups. Although there was no difference in patient and graft survivals, there was a statistically significant benefit in the rejection-free graft survival at 1 year for group 1 (51% vs 39%; P =.02). Furthermore, serum creatinine at 6 months was lower for group 1, despite a similar baseline creatinine. Subgroup analysis for patients with baseline abnormal serum creatinines showed that group 1A displayed an improved rejection-free graft survival at 1 month but not at 1 year.

CONCLUSIONS

Thymoglobulin induction therapy may allow a delay in the initiation of CI therapy without compromising patient and graft survival, while preventing early rejection, even among patients with baseline renal dysfunction.

The impact of thymoglobulin on renal function and calcineurin inhibitor initiation in recipients of orthotopic liver transplant: a retrospective analysis of 298 consecutive patients

BACKGROUND

Renal dysfunction remains the Achilles' heel of calcineurin inhibitor (CI)use. The purpose of this study was to assess our institutional, renal-sparing strategy using thymoglobulin (TMG) in recipients of orthotopic liver transplants.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of data from 298 adult recipients who were transplanted between 1991 and 2002. The patients were divided into two groups: those induced with TMG (group 1) and those that were not treated with this agent (group 2). A subgroup analysis was performed of patients with baseline serum creatinine values above 1.5 mg/dL (group 1A received TMG; group 2A did not). All patients received tacrolimus or cyclosporine (CyA) maintenance immunosuppression.

RESULTS

Indications and demographics were similar between the two groups. Although there was no difference in patient and graft survivals, there was a statistically significant benefit in the rejection-free graft survival at 1 year for group 1 (51% vs 39%; P =.02). Furthermore, serum creatinine at 6 months was lower for group 1, despite a similar baseline creatinine. Subgroup analysis for patients with baseline abnormal serum creatinines showed that group 1A displayed an improved rejection-free graft survival at 1 month but not at 1 year.

CONCLUSIONS

Thymoglobulin induction therapy may allow a delay in the initiation of CI therapy without compromising patient and graft survival, while preventing early rejection, even among patients with baseline renal dysfunction.

Leukoreduction and acute rejection in liver transplantation: An interim analysis

BACKGROUND

Little is known about the effect of blood transfusions and leukoreduction on acute rejection in liver transplantation. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of leukoreduction on the occurrence of early rejection episodes in liver transplantation.

METHODS

In 1999, mandatory leukoreduction was implemented in our program. Data from 339 consecutive liver transplant recipients were analyzed with attention to the time period as a proxy for leukoreduction, the number of transfusions, the wait list status, the hepatitis B or C status, the recipient age, and the type of immunosuppression.

RESULTS

Using an early (6-month) rejection-free graft survival model, we observed that introduction of leukoreduction was independently associated with fewer rejection episodes (P =.001). Despite the lower rejection rate, due to a regimen of tacrolimus and antithymocyte globulin, the effect of implementation of leukoreduction remained significant (P =.021).

CONCLUSION

The use of leukoreduction is associated with fewer early rejections, irrespective of the type of immunosuppression. These data support an exploration of the immunomodulatory effect of leukoreduction.

Diagnosis and management of cholecystitis and cholangitis

Cholelithiasis is a prevalent condition in Western populations. Most cases are asymptomatic but complications can occur. Acute cholangitis, cholecystitis, and gallstone pancreatitis are the most common biliary tract emergencies and are usually caused by biliary calculi. Whenever possible, acute cholecystitis should be treated with early LC. AAC is an uncommon condition usually affecting patients with significant comorbidities. Treatment is usually with percutaneous cholecystostomy, which often is also the only required therapy. Endoscopic drainage is the preferred form of biliary decompression in acute cholangitis and these patients should subsequently undergo elective LC unless unfit for surgery. Effective and optimal management of biliary tract emergencies relies on close cooperation between gastroenterologist, surgeon, and radiologist.

Do biliary endoprostheses decrease biliary complications after liver transplantation?

AIM

Most technical complications after orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) are related to the biliary tree. This report reviews the role of routine intraoperative placement of stents to reduce biliary complications.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 396 consecutive OLTs. We reviewed rates of biliary complications after hepaticojejunostomy (HJA) as well as following choledochocholedochostomy (CCA) groups: "experimental" group (routine intraoperative biliary stenting, last 10 months), "recent" control group (nonstented, previous 10 months), "historical" control group (prior to that period of time).

RESULTS

All groups were matched for donor/recipient characteristics and for graft cold/warm ischemia time. The overall prevalence of biliary complications was 30.7% after CCA versus 35% after HJA. In the experimental group 21 patients had a 4.8% biliary complication rate compared to the recent control and historical groups, where biliary complication rates were 30% and 32.6%, respectively (P <.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The intraoperative use of biliary stents is feasible and appears to decrease the rate of biliary complications. These results support the need for a prospective randomized trial.

Palliation of malignant biliary obstruction: a prospective trial examining impact on quality of life

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic decompression is used for palliation of patients with malignant biliary obstruction. Little is known of its effect on quality of life. The aims of this study were to determine clinical characteristics that have the greatest adverse impact on quality of life in patients with malignant biliary obstruction, and to quantify changes in the quality of life of patients with malignant biliary obstruction after successful decompression with a plastic stent.

METHODS

Patients with malignant biliary obstruction without liver metastases considered nonsurgical candidates and referred to a tertiary university medical center for palliative endoscopic decompression were sequentially enrolled in this prospective cohort study. The SF-36 Health Survey questionnaire at baseline and 1 month after stent insertion was used to quantify quality of life. Results were correlated to clinical and laboratory parameters. Multivariate analyses were carried out to determine independent predictors of baseline quality of life and improvement after stent insertion.

RESULTS

Fifty patients (20 men, 30 women; mean [SD] age 72.6 [10.6] years) with a mean weight of 62.4 (12.9) kg and mean body mass index of 23.4 (4.3) kg/m(2) were enrolled. Two thirds had a distal malignant lesion, 12.5% had mid bile duct obstruction, and the rest either hilar or intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma. At baseline, 70% complained of pruritus and 98% were jaundiced (mean total bilirubin 15 [7] mg/dL). Mean duration of symptoms before decompression was 23 (25) days. Weight loss, and elevated bilirubin level had the greatest impact on baseline quality of life domains in both univariate and multivariate analysis. After biliary drainage, complete follow-up information was available for 51% of the initial cohort. Among these 26 patients, a 33% improvement in bilirubin level was documented in 84% of patients and was associated with significant improvements in social function (relative risk = 0.11; 95% CI [0.03, 0.19]) and mental health (relative risk = 0.036; 95% CI [0.011, 0.08]). A baseline bilirubin of greater than 14 mg/dL was associated with lack of improvement in social function at 1-month follow-up (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Weight loss and hyperbilirubinemia are strongly predictive of poor quality of life before endoscopic decompression. Successful biliary drainage after stent insertion is associated with improvements in quality of life, although this is less true among patients with a baseline bilirubin over 13 mg/dL. These results may lead to better selection of patients for palliative biliary decompression and require prospective validation.

Elevation of CA-125 level is due to abdominal distension in liver transplantation candidates

BACKGROUND

CA (cancer antigen) 125 is a serologic marker used in the monitoring of ovarian cancer. Elevated levels are also reported in cirrhosis. We evaluated the range of serum CA 125 levels seen before and after liver transplantation, and examined possible factors associated with CA 125 elevation.

METHODS

We examined prospectively 57 consecutive patients with cirrhosis who underwent liver transplantation. CA 125 levels were also measured in two patients with polycystic liver disease.

RESULTS

The mean serum CA 125 level before transplantation was 352+/-549 u/ml, compared with 46+/-49 u/ml after transplantation (P<0.001). Multivariate analysis identified the degree of ascites as the only significant predictive variable of preoperative CA 125 level. In five patients who underwent abdominal paracentesis, the mean ascites CA 125 level (951+/-322 u/ml) was higher than that of the serum (619+/-290 u/ml) (P<0.003). In 16 hepatectomy specimens, the grade of staining for CA 125 was 0.8+/-1.4 for the mesothelium of patients with a normal serum CA 125 level, compared with 1.5+/-1.1 in patients with elevated serum levels (P=0.37). Two patients with severe abdominal distension due to polycystic liver disease but without ascites had elevated serum CA 125 levels.

DISCUSSION

CA 125 concentration is elevated in the majority of patients with cirrhosis and normalizes after liver transplantation. It is a reflection of the abdominal distention seen in these patients. Therefore, an elevation in CA 125 should not be considered a contraindication to liver transplantation in the absence of evidence of malignancy.

Laparoscopic fundoplication: a model for assessing new technology in surgical procedures

BACKGROUND

Surgical success has traditionally been judged from the surgeon's perspective. A more complete evaluation of outcome incorporates the patient's, surgeon's, and payor's perspectives. Because gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is primarily a quality-of-life (QOL) problem, the evaluation of laparoscopic fundoplication (LF) is a useful model for evaluating outcomes from these 3 perspectives.

METHODS

Between 1995 and 2000, 74 patients underwent primary LF for GERD. In addition to undergoing physiologic testing, 63 patients (85%) were evaluated with use of a disease-specific health-related QOL scale (GERD-HRQL), scored from 0 (no symptoms) to 45 (incapacitating symptoms). Thirty-three patients also completed a generic QOL questionnaire (SF-12), in which patient satisfaction was scored from 1 (very satisfied) to 5 (very dissatisfied). Preoperative and postoperative data were compared with use of the Wilcoxon signed rank test or the paired t test.

RESULTS

The median GERD-HRQL score improved from 18 to 0 at 2 years postoperation (P <.01). The median satisfaction score improved from 5 to 1 (P <.01). The SF-12 summary scores also improved after 6 weeks postoperatively (P <.05). The mean +/- SD lower esophageal sphincter pressure rose from 7.3 +/- 4 mm Hg preoperatively to 17.5 +/- 6 postoperatively (P <.01), and the mean percentage of time that the esophagus was exposed to a pH of less than 4 declined from 14.7% +/- 12% to 1.1% +/- 2% (P <.01). The median operative time was 110 minutes, which declined with experience with the procedure (P <.01). Median postoperative stay was 2 days.

CONCLUSIONS

In evaluating the outcomes of a new procedure, 3 overlapping points of view were addressed: the patient's (QOL, satisfaction), the surgeon's (physiologic changes), and the payor's (operating room time, hospital stay). With use of this framework, we found that LF for GERD improves QOL, corrects the physiologic abnormalities, and is associated with short hospitalization and operating time that declines with experience with the procedure.

Successful outcome after transplantation of a donor liver with focal nodular hyperplasia

Because of the increasing gap in the number of patients awaiting organ transplantation and the supply of organ donors, reevaluation of donor criteria is an important issue in clinical transplantation. It has become necessary to make maximal use of the currently available donor pool. We describe a case of successful orthotopic liver transplantation in a 57-year-old man with Laënnec's cirrhosis using a liver containing an 8-cm focal nodular hyperplasia (FNH) lesion involving segments II and III and the caudate lobe. The donor liver was procured from a 46-year-old woman declared brain dead after a subarachnoid hemorrhage. Definitive pathological diagnosis was made at laparotomy by obtaining a Tru-cut (Allegiance Health Care Inc, Toronto, Ontario, Canada) core biopsy specimen. The recipient operation was performed uneventfully except for bleeding from the biopsy site. The patient did well postoperatively and was discharged on tacrolimus, mofetil mycophenolate, and prednisone therapy. He continues to thrive 2(1/2) years posttransplantation with no change in the size of the lesion. In well-selected donors, FNH should not be a contraindication for use in transplantation. However, FNH must be differentiated from hepatocellular adenoma. Although FNH has a benign course with little propensity for bleeding and almost no malignant potential, hepatic adenoma is reported to have a 15% to 33% chance of bleeding and rupture with a well-documented potential for neoplastic degeneration, making the liver unsuitable for donation.

Rejection of pig liver xenografts in patients with liver failure: implications for xenotransplantation

The pathophysiological state of rejection in liver xenotransplantation is poorly understood. Data from clinical pig liver perfusion suggest that pig livers might be rejected less vigorously than pig hearts or kidneys. Pig livers used in clinical xenoperfusions were exposed to blood from patients with liver failure. We have shown in an animal model that transplant recipients with liver failure are less capable of initiating hyperacute rejection of a xenografted liver than a healthy transplant recipient. The goal of this report is to examine the pathological characteristics of pig livers used in 2 clinical pig liver perfusions and combine this information with in vitro studies of pig-to-human liver xenotransplantation to determine whether the findings in the perfused pig livers could be explained in part by the diminished capacity of the patient with liver failure to respond to xenogeneic tissue. Pathological analysis of the perfused pig livers showed immunoglobulin M deposition in the sinusoids with little evidence of complement activation. Our in vitro studies showed that serum from patients with liver failure caused less injury to pig liver endothelium than serum from healthy subjects. Serum from patients with liver failure had similar levels of xenoreactive antibodies as serum from healthy humans. Incubation of serum from patients with liver failure with pig hepatic endothelial cells generated less iC3b, Bb fragment, and C5b-9 than serum from healthy subjects. We conclude that the altered injury in the perfused pig livers can be attributed to the relative complement deficiency that accompanies liver failure.

Clinical benefit of neoral dose monitoring with cyclosporine 2-hr post-dose levels compared with trough levels in stable heart transplant patients

BACKGROUND

Based on the excellent correlation between cyclosporine A 2-hr postdose blood levels (C2) and the area under the concentration versus time curve, we evaluated the clinical benefit of Neoral dose monitoring with C2 compared trough levels (C0) in stable heart transplant patients.

METHODS

We studied 114 stable adult patients followed at the heart transplant clinic, who were >1 year after surgery. In May 1996 (period 1, follow-up 10+/-4 months), Neoral dose monitoring was based on C2 (300-600 ng/ml); while in May 1997 (period 2, follow-up 10+/-2 months), it was based on C0 (100-200 ng/ml). Cyclosporine A levels were measured by an enzyme multiplied immunologic technique. Clinical benefit was defined by the absence of acute rejection, no mortality, no fall in left ventricular ejection fraction >10%, and no increase in serum creatinine >10% (compared with baseline).

RESULTS

During period 1, Neoral dose, cyclosporine A, C0 and C2, and serum creatinine, decreased by 26, 56, 45, and 2.3%, respectively. At the end of period 2, the same variables increased by 24, 56, 38, and 10%, respectively (P<0.0001). The incidence of acute rejection was similar (period 1: 0.87%, period 2: 0.96%). The left ventricular ejection fraction (initial/final) remained stable (period 1: 57+/-91%/58+/-13%, period 2: 59+/-11d/58+/-10%). Mortality did not differ (period 1: 7.9%, period 2: 9.6%). A clinical benefit was observed in 69.3% of the patients during period 1 vs. 43.3% of the patients during period 2 (P<0.00001).

CONCLUSIONS

In stable heart transplant patients, a greater clinical benefit was observed when Neoral dose monitoring was performed according to C2, compared with C0.

Short-term outcomes in open vs. laparoscopic herniorrhaphy: confounding impact of worker's compensation on convalescence

Over a 28-month period, 123 patients with a unilateral inguinal hernia were recruited into a randomized controlled trial comparing open herniorrhaphy (OH) to laparoscopic inguinal herniorrhaphy (LH). The primary end point was duration of convalescence. Sixty-five patients underwent OH and 58 underwent LH. Both groups were well matched for all baseline parameters, although LH patients anticipated a shorter convalescence than OH patients (14.3 +/- 9.4 days vs. 18.5 +/- 10.8 days; P = 0.021). The median duration of hospital stay was one day in both groups. No difference was observed in the duration of convalescence (LH 9.8 +/- 7.4 days; OH 11.6 +/- 7. 7 days) across groups. However, when the data were analyzed after removing patients receiving disability ("worker's") compensation (21 patients), patients undergoing LH recovered on average 3 days faster (LH 7.8 +/- 5.6 days; OH 10.9 +/- 7.5 days; P = 0.02). Patients not receiving worker's compensation appear to have a shorter convalescence after LH compared to OH. Disability compensation is a major confounding variable in determining convalescence and needs to be controlled for in any future trial design.

Comparison of neoral dose monitoring with cyclosporine through levels versus 2-hr postdose levels in stable liver transplant patients

BACKGROUND

We reported that cyclosporine 2-hr postdose levels (C2) correlate better with the AUC0-4 hr than trough levels (C0) in heart transplant patients receiving Neoral.

METHODS

We compared Neoral dose adjustment with C0 (group 1: 100-200 ng/ml) vs. C2 (group 2: 700-1000 ng/ml; group 3: 300-600 ng/ml) in 35 stable adult patients >1 year after liver transplantation. The AUC0-4hr was calculated, and simultaneous blood samples were obtained to measure calcineurin inhibition. Clinical benefit was defined as the absence of rejection and no increase in serum creatinine at the 7-month follow-up.

RESULTS

C2 correlated better with the AUC0-4 hr than C0 (r=0.92 vs. r=0.40). Neoral dose increased by 17% and 39% in groups 1 and 2, and decreased by 18% in group 3 (P=0.002 vs. group 1 and P=0.0004 vs. group 2). Serum creatinine increased by 2.1% and 16% in groups 1 and 2, and decreased by 5.1% in group 3 (P=0.006 vs. group 2). A clinical benefit was observed in 37.5%, 23%, and 82% of patients in groups 1, 2, and 3 (P=0.03 vs. group 1 and P=0.01 vs. group 2). Calcineurin inhibition was similar in all groups at 2-hr (44+/-17%, 39+/-30%, and 44+/-35%), in spite of different Neoral doses (2.9+/-0.9, 4.0+/-1.8, and 2.6+/-1.3 mg/kg/day) and C2 (857+/-226, 922+/-274, and 588+/-274 ng/ml).

CONCLUSIONS

C2 correlated better with the AUC0-4 hr than C0. Neoral dose monitoring with a C2 range of 300-600 ng/ml resulted in a lower dose and greater clinical benefit compared to C0 or a higher C2 in stable liver transplant patients. The correlation between calcineurin inhibition and clinical events deserves further research.

Evolving management of mild-to-moderate gallstone pancreatitis

The objective of this study was to describe recent trends in the management of mild-to-moderate gallstone pancreatitis and assess patient outcomes. Acute gallstone pancreatitis has traditionally been managed with open cholecystectomy and intraoperative cholangiography during the initial hospitalization. The popularization of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) and laparoscopic cholecystectomy has made a reassessment necessary. Two consecutive time periods were retrospectively analyzed: prior to laparoscopic cholecystectomy (prelaparoscopic era [PLE]) and after the diffusion of laparoscopic cholecystectomy (laparoscopic cholectomy era [LCE]). There were 35 patients in the PLE group and 58 in the LCE group. LCE patients waited 37.1 +/- 63 days from admission until cholecystectomy, compared to 9.8 +/- 14.8 days in the PLE group (P = 0.04). Biliary-pancreatic complications occurred in 24% of LCE patients and only 6% of PLE patients (P = 0.05), nearly always while they were awaiting cholecystectomy (P = 0.009). Patients in either time period who underwent cholecystectomy with intraoperative cholangiography developed less pancreatic-biliary complications than those who underwent ERCP prior to cholecystectomy, with or without sphincterotomy. Delaying the interval from pancreatitis to laparoscopic cholecystectomy beyond historical values is associated with a greater risk of recurrent biliary-pancreatic complications, which are not prevented by the use of ERCP. Early cholecys tectomy with intraoperative ductal evaluation is still the approach of choice.

Development of a model for training and evaluation of laparoscopic skills

BACKGROUND

Interest in the training and evaluation of laparoscopic skills is extending beyond the realm of the operating room to the use of laparoscopic simulators. The purpose of this study was to develop a series of structured tasks to objectively measure laparoscopic skills. This model was then used to test for the effects of level of training and practice on performance.

METHODS

Forty-two subjects (6 each of surgical residents PGY1 to PGY5, 6 surgeons who practice laparoscopy and 6 who do not) were evaluated. Each subject viewed a 20-minute introductory video, then was tested performing 7 laparoscopic tasks (peg transfers, pattern cutting, clip and divide, endolooping, mesh placement and fixation, suturing with intracorporeal or extracorporeal knots). Performance was measured using a scoring system rewarding precision and speed. Each candidate repeated all 7 tasks and was rescored. Data were analyzed by linear regression to assess the relationship of performance with level of residency training for each task, and by ANOVA with repeated measures to test for effects of level of training, of repetition, and of the interaction between level of training and repetition on overall performance. Student's t test was used to evaluate differences between laparoscopic and nonlaparoscopic surgeons and between each of these groups and the PGY 5 level of surgical residents.

RESULTS

Significant predictors of overall performance were (a) level of training (P = 0.002), (b) repetition (P < 0.0001), and (c) interaction between level of training and practice (P = 0.001). There was also a significant interaction between level of training and the specific task on performance scores (P = 0.006). When each task was evaluated individually for the 30 residents, 4 of the 7 tasks (tasks 1, 2, 6, 7) showed significant correlation between PGY level and score. A significant difference in performance scores between laparoscopic and nonlaparoscopic surgeons was seen for tasks 1, 2, and 6.

CONCLUSIONS

A model was developed to evaluate laparoscopic skills. Construct validity was demonstrated by measuring significant improvement in performance with increasing residency training, and with practice. Further validation will require correlation of performance in the model with skill in vivo.

Predictors of post-ERCP complications in patients with suspected choledocholithiasis

BACKGROUND AND STUDY AIMS

Determinants of complications after endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) have not yet been completely characterized.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Data were collected from an endoscopic database. Univariate analysis and multivariate logistic regression analysis were used to generate the best model of independent predictors of post-ERCP pancreatitis.

RESULTS

The database included 1239 ERCP examinations carried out to investigate suspected choledocholithiasis over a five-year period. From these, 45 patients who developed post-ERCP complications were compared to a random sample of 486 patients who had undergone an uncomplicated ERCP for suspected choledocholithiasis. Univariate analysis demonstrated significant differences between the two patient groups for the following factors: age, using a cut-off point of 59 years (27% vs. 51%, P = 0.002), pancreatic channel opacification (73% vs. 58%, P = 0.05), and absence of common bile duct stones (41% vs. 24%, P = 0.03). Using multivariate logistic regression, the best model for predicting post-ERCP pancreatitis in patients undergoing sphincterotomy included age under 59 years (P = 0.04), and absence of a common bile duct stone (P = 0.004). The model yielded probabilities of developing post-sphincterotomy pancreatitis that ranged from 2.8% if no predictor was present, to 27% when both predictors were present. Among patients in whom a sphincterotomy was not performed, the only significant independent predictor found was pancreatic channel opacification (P = 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Age under 59 years, pancreatic channel opacification, and an absence of common bile duct stones at ERCP are all independent predictors of post-ERCP pancreatitis.

Two-hour cyclosporine level determination is the appropriate tool to monitor Neoral therapy

To assess the safety profile of Neoral dose adjustment using cyclosporine (CsA) trough levels (C0) compared with levels obtained 2 h after the morning dose (C2), 30 stable adult heart transplant patients 1 yr or more after surgery were converted from Sandimmune to Neoral. After a baseline visit (before conversion), initial follow-up included two visits (2 and 4-6 wk after conversion). After the first visit, patients were randomized to Group I (C0: 100-200 ng/ml) or Group II (C2: 200-400 ng/ml). Abbreviated pharmacokinetics were obtained for the estimation of the AUC0-4 h. Renal function was assessed by serum creatinine and the cimetidine-modified creatinine clearance. C2 correlated better than C0 with the AUC0-4 h (r = 0.91 vs. 0.63). Initial Neoral dose (mg/kg/d) was similar in both groups (2.8 +/- 0.5 and 2.8 +/- 0.8), and was lower in Group II at the second visit (2.0 +/- 0.7 vs. 3.0 +/- 0.6, p = 0.0001). C2 levels decreased in Group II from 912 +/- 438 to 555 +/- 271 ng/ml (p = 0.01), without evidence of acute rejection on endomyocardial biopsies. After the second visit,-both groups were monitored with C2, and the range was increased to 300-600 ng/ml. At the last visit (additional follow-up of 5 +/- 1 months), Neoral dose (mg/kg/d) was reduced to 2.0 +/- 0.3 in Group I (p < 0.001) and 1.8 +/- 0.4 in Group II. Serum creatinine was lower in Group II at the second visit (138 +/- 59 vs. 168 +/- 37 mumol/L, p = 0.01) and was similar in both groups at the last visit. Neoral dose reduction based on C2 levels was not associated with acute rejection. The better correlation with the AUC0-4 h suggests that C2 may be more reliable than C0 for Neoral dose adjustment.

Successful treatment of post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorder with interferon-alpha and intravenous immunoglobulin

We report on the use of interferon-alpha (INF-a) and high-dose non-specific intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) in 2 patients (a 60-yr-old female and a 65-yr-old male) who developed post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD) 2 and 8 months after heart and liver transplantation, respectively. Both patients had received immunosuppression with ATG, CsA, azathioprine, and prednisone. The first patient did not receive additional immunosuppression with biological agents. The second patient developed 3 steroid-resistant acute rejection episodes requiring OKT3 (cumulative dose 100 mg) and ATG (cumulative dose 3450 mg). The first patient presented with nodules involving the liver, spleen, lungs and nasophar, ynx. The second patient presented with subcutaneous and liver nodules, as well as pert-portal and para-aortic lymphadenopathies. The histological diagnosis was diffuse B-cell PTLD in both patients. Despite reduction of immunosuppression, a progression of lesions was observed in both patients over 5 months and 2 months, respectively. The first patient received INF-alpha (2 x 10(6) IU, s.c. 3 times/wk) and IVIg (0.5 g/kg i.v. every 15 d) for.4 months, while the second patient received the same therapy for 12 and 7 months, respectively. Complete disappearance of all lesions was observed after 3 months of therapy in the first patient and after 7 months of therapy in the second patient, as assessed by CT scan. PTLD remains in remission 47 and 33 months after therapy, respectively. Our preliminary results suggest that the combination of INF-alpha and IVIg can be an effective therapy for PTLD which does not respond to reduction of immunosuppression.