Prospective quantification of near work using the experience sampling method

INTRODUCTION

The assessment of individuals' near work by survey methods is challenging. The feasibility of the Experience Sampling Method to quantify daily visual tasks was evaluated.

METHODS

Twenty-one subjects were randomly paged five times per day for 6 days. When paged, the subjects dialed into a telephone survey to report the nature, duration, and working distance of their visual activity at the time of the page.

RESULTS

The overall response rate was 81.3% (512/630 pages). The individual response rates varied from 6.7% to 100% (median, 86.7%). Responses were grouped into 11 categories/activities for ease of analysis. Of 506 responses, the most common activity category was "distance tasks," which included driving and walking (N = 92). Other common responses included computer use (N = 68), reading (N = 66), household tasks, e.g., cleaning, cooking, and showering (N = 64), and watching television (N = 61). Activities with a mean distance < or =26 inches (arm length) were combined as near-work responses and accounted for 54.3% (258/475) of all responses.

CONCLUSION

A modification of the Experience Sampling Method can be used to obtain a "real-time" sampling of visual activities.

The repeatability of corneal thickness measures

PURPOSE

To compare the repeatability of three measures of corneal thickness: Orbscan Slitscan pachymetry, ultrasound pachymetry, and optical pachymetry.

METHODS

Twenty normal subjects were tested on three occasions. Two occurred on the same day and the third was on a different day at approximately the same time of day as one of the first two visits. Central corneal thickness of the right eye was measured with a Haag-Streit optical pachymeter, a Humphrey Model 855 ultrasound pachymeter, and the Orbscan system. Day-to-day and same-day repeatability was assessed by calculating the difference between the values from two visits and determining the mean difference, the SD, and the 95% limits of agreement (LoA) (LoA = mean +/- 1.96 SD).

RESULTS

Mean (+/- SD) central corneal thickness as measured by each instrument was as follows: 539 +/- 33 microm for optical pachymetry, 542 +/- 33 microm for ultrasound pachymetry, and 596 +/- 40 microm for Orbscan pachymetry. For day-to-day comparisons, optical pachymetry showed the poorest repeatability with 95% LoA of -61 to +32 microm. Ultrasound pachymetry showed better repeatability with 95% LoA of -22 to +24 microm. The Orbscan showed the best repeatability centrally with 95% LoA of -10 to +17 microm. Peripheral Orbscan pachymetry was less repeatable than that measured centrally but still more repeatable than central optical pachymetry. Similar results were found with same-day comparisons.

CONCLUSION

The Orbscan system is the most repeatable technique for measuring corneal thickness but shows a significant bias toward greater corneal thickness measures than both ultrasound and optical pachymetry.

Overnight orthokeratology

PURPOSE

Orthokeratology is defined as the temporary reduction in myopia by the programmed application of rigid gas-permeable contact lenses. New reverse geometry contact lens designs and materials have led to a renewed interest in this field. The purpose of this study is to assess visual, refractive, topographic, and corneal thickness changes in subjects undergoing overnight orthokeratology.

METHODS

Ten myopic subjects (mean age, 25.9+/-3.9 years) were recruited for a 60-day trial of overnight orthokeratology using reverse geometry rigid contact lenses. After commencing lens wear, subjects were examined on days 1, 7, 14, 30, and 60 at several times throughout the day. High- and low-contrast logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) visual acuity, monocular subjective refraction, autorefraction, autokeratometry, corneal topography, corneal thickness, and slit lamp examinations were performed at each session.

RESULTS

Eight subjects completed the study. Both high- and low-contrast uncorrected visual acuity improved significantly by day 7. The mean change in uncorrected high contrast visual acuity at day 60 was -0.55+/-0.20 logMAR (mean at day 60, -0.03+/-0.16; Snellen equivalent, 20/19). The mean change in uncorrected low-contrast visual acuity at day 60 was -0.48+/-0.26 logMAR (mean at day 60, +0.22+/-0.23; Snellen equivalent, 20/33). The mean subjective refraction and autorefraction were significantly reduced from baseline at day 60 (mean change in subjective refraction, +1.83+/-1.23 D; mean change in autorefraction, +0.64+/-0.52 D). Corneal topography showed significant central flattening (mean change in apical radius, +0.20+/-0.9 mm; mean change in shape factor, -0.11+/-0.18 at day 60). The central cornea also showed significant thinning (mean change, -12+/-11 microm at day 60). All visual, refractive, and topographic outcomes were sustained over the course of an 8-h day.

CONCLUSIONS

Overnight orthokeratology is an effective means of temporarily reducing myopia. The possible mechanism of corneal remodeling through central corneal thinning is discussed.

Normal aging effects for frequency doubling technology perimetry

PURPOSE

To determine the influence of normal aging on contrast sensitivity for frequency doubling technology (FDT) perimetry.

METHODS

Contrast sensitivity measures were obtained for frequency-doubled stimuli (0.25 cycles per degree sinusoidal gratings undergoing 25 Hz counterphase flicker) at 17 target locations (4 per quadrant plus the central 5 degrees ) using a prototype of the Welch Allyn (Skaneateles, NY)/Humphrey Systems FDT perimeter (Humphrey Systems, Dublin, CA). A total of 407 normal subjects (761 eyes) between the ages of 15 and 85 years were tested.

RESULTS

Between the ages of 15 and 60 years there was an approximately linear decrease in contrast sensitivity of 0.6 dB per decade. After the age of 70, there was a slightly greater sensitivity loss with age. There were no meaningful differences in sensitivity loss as a function of age for different visual field locations. A small but consistent reduction in contrast sensitivity (approximately 0.7 dB) was found at all visual field locations for the second eye tested that may be due to a central adaptation process.

CONCLUSIONS

Normal aging effects for FDT perimetry are similar to those obtained for conventional automated perimetry, except that the FDT perimetry aging effects do not appear to be eccentricity dependent. These normative data provide a basis for establishing a statistical analysis procedure and probability plots for FDT perimetry.

Visual performance after photorefractive keratectomy with a 6-mm ablation zone

PURPOSE

To prospectively examine the effect of photorefractive keratectomy with a 6-mm ablation zone on best-spectacle-corrected visual performance.

METHODS

A prospective study was conducted of 164 eyes of 164 patients with an average (+/-SD) of -4.02 +/- 1.74 diopters (range, -0.63 to -8.38 diopters spherical equivalent). Best-spectacle-corrected high-contrast and low-contrast visual acuity (18% Weber contrast) was measured with both natural and dilated pupils. Patients were tested preoperatively and at 3, 6, and 12 months after photorefractive keratectomy. Photorefractive keratectomy was performed with an argon fluoride excimer laser. Fifty-five eyes of 55 patients also underwent astigmatic keratotomy.

RESULTS

Twelve months after photorefractive keratectomy, best-spectacle-corrected high-contrast visual acuity with natural pupils showed no significant change from preoperative values; mean (+/-SD) change was 0.004 +/- 0.10 logMAR (t = 0.45, P = .65). Best-spectacle-corrected low-contrast visual acuity with natural pupils was significantly reduced compared to baseline; mean (+/-SD) change was 0.04 +/- 0.13 logMAR (t = 3.3, P = .001). The low-contrast loss was larger (1.5 lines) with dilated pupils; mean (+/-SD) change was 0.13 +/- 0.15 logMAR (t = 9.31, P < .001). Greater losses in dilated low-contrast visual acuity were associated with concurrent astigmatic ketatotomy (t = 2.28, P = .025) and corneal haze of grade 1 or greater (t = 2.71, P = .005).

CONCLUSIONS

Reductions in visual performance occur after photorefractive keratectomy with a 6-mm zone. These changes are greatest for low-contrast visual acuity with dilated pupils. Corneal haze and concurrent astigmatic keratotomy are associated with greater losses in low-contrast visual acuity. Best-spectacle-corrected low-contrast visual acuity is a sensitive measure for evaluating visual performance after refractive surgery.

What is low vision? A re-evaluation of definitions

PURPOSE

To re-evaluate definitions of low vision, visual impairment, and disability.

METHODS

We review current definitions of legal blindness and low vision and how these definitions are variably based on disability or impairment. We argue for a definite distinction being made between criteria for visual impairment and visual disability, low vision being defined as the presence of a visual impairment that results in a disability. Visual impairment is defined according to population norms and a statistical cut-off is used. Visual disability is defined by consideration of the level of visual measures which result in measurable or reportable disability. We consider the evidence that contrast sensitivity should be a criterion for visual disability in addition to visual acuity and visual field.

CONCLUSIONS

According to the current information, we define visual impairment as best monocular or binocular visual acuity <(worse than) 6/7.5, total horizontal visual field <146 degrees (Goldmann III-4e) or <109 degrees (III-3e), and contrast sensitivity <1.5 (PelliRobson); we define visual disability as best monocular or binocular visual acuity <6/12 or contrast sensitivity <1.05.

The repeatability of automated and clinician refraction

PURPOSE

Auto-refractors are used as a starting point for clinicians' refractions and in studies of refractive error. We investigated the repeatability of the Hoya AR-570 and clinician refraction.

METHODS

Eighty-six subjects, aged 11 to 60 years, were recruited by mailing inquiries to 500 randomly selected patients who had received recent examinations at the University of California Optometric Eye Center. Contact lens wearers, patients with best corrected visual acuity worse than 20/30 in either eye, and patients with a history of diabetes were excluded. Each subject was examined by two clinicians during one visit. The first clinician obtained five auto-refractor readings for each eye (which were later averaged), performed a balanced subjective refraction (with spherical masking lenses in the phoropter), and repeated the automated refractor measurements. This protocol was then repeated by the second clinician. Clinicians were randomized with regard to testing order and masked to automated refractor results, each other's refractions, and previous spectacle prescriptions.

RESULTS

To quantify repeatability, we used mixed model analyses of variance to estimate the appropriate variance components while accounting for the correlation among, for example, repeated measurements of the same eye. Astigmatic data were analyzed by converting into Fourier form: two cross-cylinders at axis 0 degrees (J0) and axis 45 degrees (J45). For mean spherical equivalent, the average difference between five averaged automated refractor readings, taken by two different optometrists, was +0.02 D (95% limits of agreement = -0.36 to +0.40 D). The average difference between the two optometrists' subjective refractions was -0.12 D (95% limits of agreement = -0.90 to +0.65 D). The 95% limits of agreement for the automated refractor were about half those of the clinician for both astigmatic terms (J0 and J45) and for all comparisons.

CONCLUSIONS

Automated refraction is more repeatable than subjective refraction and therefore more appropriate for studies of myopia progression.

Repeatability of visual acuity measurement

PURPOSE

This study investigates features of visual acuity chart design and acuity testing scoring methods which affect the validity and repeatability of visual acuity measurements.

METHODS

Visual acuity was measured using the Sloan and British Standard letter series, and Landolt rings. Identifiability of the different letters as a function of size was estimated, and expressed in the form of frequency-of-seeing curves. These functions were then used to simulate acuity measurements with a variety of chart designs and scoring criteria.

RESULTS

Systematic relationships exist between chart design parameters and acuity score, and acuity score repeatability. In particular, an important feature of a chart, that largely determines the repeatability of visual acuity measurement, is the amount of size change attributed to each letter. The methods used to score visual acuity performance also affect repeatability.

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible to evaluate acuity score validity and repeatability using the statistical principles discussed here.

Improvements in clinical and functional vision and perceived visual disability after first and second eye cataract surgery

AIMS

To determine the improvements in clinical and functional vision and perceived visual disability after first and second eye cataract surgery.

METHODS

Clinical vision (monocular and binocular high and low contrast visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and disability glare), functional vision (face identity and expression recognition, reading speed, word acuity, and mobility orientation), and perceived visual disability (Activities of Daily Vision Scale) were measured in 25 subjects before and after uncomplicated cataract surgery (10 first eye surgery and 15 second eye surgery) and in 10 age matched controls.

RESULTS

Significant improvements were found after surgery in clinical and functional vision and perceived visual disability. Greater improvements were found after first eye surgery than after second eye surgery. However, first eye surgery did not return all scores to age matched normal levels. There were significant improvements in several of the tests measured after second eye surgery, and all postoperative values were similar to those from age matched normals.

CONCLUSIONS

Significant improvements in clinical, functional, and perceived vision are obtained by cataract surgery. The improvements in objective measures of functional vision found in this study support previous findings of improvements in patients' perceived functional vision. In addition, these data provide support to the necessity of second eye surgery in some patients to improve certain aspects of visual function to age matched normal levels.

Evaluating the value of low-vision services

BACKGROUND

Low-vision care is a widely accepted and valued service provided by many optometrists. As in other areas of health care, evaluation of the outcome of low-vision care is increasingly necessary so it can be properly positioned in the health care delivery system.

METHODS

This article reviews the literature relating to the prevalence of low vision, its impact on affected individuals, and how low-vision intervention affects those with visual impairments. This review considers the ways in which the impact of low-vision care has been evaluated.

RESULTS

The existing literature demonstrates that low-vision intervention can be highly valued by low-vision patients and can have a significant impact on an individual's daily life and activities. Evaluating this impact is a significant challenge-particularly if the goal is to gauge the outcome of low vision care as broadly as possible.

CONCLUSIONS

Evaluation of health-related quality of life is a desirable option for evaluation of outcomes, and the application of quality of life instruments to the visually impaired population is necessary. There remain unresolved issues of optometric research that need to be addressed.

Interocular differences in visual function in normal subjects

A commonly used clinical technique for determining whether visual function is abnormal, particularly when a patient is suspected of having unilateral or asymmetric disease, is to compare the visual function of the 'suspect' eye to that of the normal eye. This assumes that in normal patients visual function in each eye is equal and that this symmetry is maintained with age. To determine the extent of normal symmetry for clinical measures of visual function, we assessed high and low contrast visual acuity, letter contrast sensitivity and motion sensitivity (Dmin) in both eyes of a group of 91 subjects spanning an age range of 21 to 82 years. For the whole group the interocular differences in sensitivity for each of the tests approximated a Gaussian distribution. The results demonstrate that interocular differences should exceed more than 0.16 and 0.17 logMAR (approximately 2 lines) for high and low contrast visual acuity respectively, before patients can be considered to be outside the range of normality. For the Pelli-Robson Chart, interocular differences must exceed 0.23 log CS (1.5 triplets, 4.5 letters) and for Dmin, more than 0.35 log minarc for the differences to be considered abnormal. For low contrast letter visual acuity, there was a trend for the absolute interocular differences to increase significantly with age, but asymmetry remained relatively constant for the other visual measures.

Effect of a cataract simulation on clinical and real world vision

AIMS/BACKGROUND

Many reports have indicated that some patients with cataract can retain good visual acuity but complain of significant visual problems. This is the first in a series of papers trying to determine what causes these symptoms and whether other clinical tests can predict the real world vision loss.

METHODS

The effect of a cataract simulation with a similar angular distribution of light scatter as real cataract on clinical (visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and disability glare) and real world vision (face recognition, reading speed, and mobility orientation) was investigated.

RESULTS

The simulation had a relatively small effect on visual acuity (6/6 with the simulation), but much larger effects on contrast sensitivity and low contrast acuity with and without glare. The simulation had no effect on high luminance and high contrast real world tasks, such as mobility orientation in room light and optimal reading speed. A small, but significant deterioration was found for the slightly lower contrast task of face and expression recognition. However, under low luminance conditions, substantial defects in mobility orientation were obtained (despite 6/6 acuity).

CONCLUSIONS

Although the relative effect of the cataract simulation on acuity and contrast tasks is not typical of the average cataract, it can be found in those cataract patients with visual problems despite good visual acuity. This corroborates the suggestion that it is large amounts of wide angle light scatter (forward and/or backward) which are at least partly responsible for visual disability in cataract patients with good visual acuity. A patient's reported visual disability may depend on the percentage of time he or she spends under low contrast and/or low luminance conditions, such as walking or reading in dim illumination, and walking or driving at night, in fog, or heavy rain.

Reading and eye movements in age-related maculopathy

Reading characteristics were studied in age-related maculopathy (ARM) by monitoring eye movement patterns as subjects read word charts and text charts that contain a wide range of print sizes. Eye movements were monitored with an infrared scleral reflection device and subjects were tested over a wide range of chart luminances. In normal subjects, as print size approaches threshold, reading speed slows mainly because of a decrease in fixation rate, whereas regressive saccades remain infrequent. There is little change in the ratio of number of letters read per forward saccade. With decreased luminance, there is a decreased reading acuity but the relation between reading speed and the size of print relative to the threshold size remains relatively constant. Subjects with ARM show similar fixation rates to normals, but they average fewer letters per forward saccade and make more frequent regressions. ARM subjects are more likely to have reading performance strongly affected by luminance. The number of letters per forward saccade can show a strong dependence on luminance, whereas fixation rates remain relatively unchanged. It is proposed that reduced reading performance in ARM is predominantly the result of a reduced perceptual span, with poor oculomotor control playing a secondary role. Optimal print size may be best predicted from letter chart acuity (r = 0.70) or word reading acuity (r = 0.69). Word reading acuity is the best predictor of peak reading speed (r = -0.74), whereas peak reading speed is poorly correlated with contrast sensitivity (r = 0.26) and scotoma area (r = -0.42).

Changes in the lower displacement limit for motion with age

Previous studies have alleged that the ability to perceive motion remains constant with age. We investigated the effect of age on minimum displacement thresholds using computer-generated random dot stimuli in 91 healthy, visually normal subjects (age range 21-82 years). High and low contrast visual acuity and letter contrast sensitivity were also tested. We found that minimum displacement thresholds increased significantly at a rate of 0.07 log min arc per decade (approximately 17%). The relationship between age and performance was very similar for all visual tests.

Low vision magnifiers--their optical parameters and methods for prescribing

Information provided by manufacturers of low vision magnifiers is usually insufficient to allow the clinician to predict accurately the resolution improvement that patients may be expected to achieve. We have measured and tabulated the key optical parameters of 92 stand magnifiers and 53 hand-held magnifiers. For the fixed focus stand magnifiers, the image location and the equivalent power of the lens system have been determined and the enlargement ratio has been derived. For each magnifier, 3 different eye-to-lens distances (2.5, 10, and 25 cm) have been considered and, for each of these, the Equivalent Viewing Distance (EVD), the eye-to-image distance, and the theoretically predicted field width have been computed. The EVD is useful in predicting resolution performance because, for a given patient, the visual resolution limit will be directly proportional to the EVD. The eye-to-image distances allow the clinician to consider whether the patient will be in satisfactory focus or whether adjustments need to be made to the power of any reading addition. The stand magnifiers are listed in order of the EVD they give when the eye is a moderate (10 cm) distance from the magnifier. For the hand-held magnifiers, the equivalent powers have been measured. The EVD for a hand-held magnifier will be the same as the equivalent focal length of the magnifier if the lens is used so that the image is at or close to infinity. The tables include supplementary information on the size of the magnifier lenses and whether the magnifiers incorporate battery, electric, incandescent, or halogen lighting systems. Examples are presented to illustrate how the tables might be used in the selection of magnifiers to meet the resolution and other needs of individual patients.

Visual changes in human immuno-deficiency virus infection

BACKGROUND

Many Human Immuno-Deficiency Virus (HIV) patients develop ocular involvement during the course of the disease, including HIV retinopathy and cytomegalovirus (CMV) retinitis. It is well established that contrast sensitivity and color vision may be affected in other retinal diseases, such as diabetes, before obvious signs and symptoms. We therefore examined patients with early HIV disease for visual involvement.

METHODS

Subjects consisted of 19 HIV-positive patients and 15 controls. None of the HIV-positive patients showed any signs of HIV retinopathy. High and low contrast visual acuity, luminance contrast sensitivity (CS), short wavelength cone (S-cone) CS, and color vision were assessed in the right eye of each subject.

RESULTS

S-cone CS was significantly reduced in the HIV-positive group (HIV mean = 0.91 +/- 0.15 log CS; normal mean = 1.10 +/- 0.09 log CS, t = 4.19, p < 0.001). Consistent with this finding, four of the HIV-positive patients demonstrated tritanopic D-15 results. High and low contrast visual acuity and CS were not significantly different in the HIV-positive and control groups.

CONCLUSION

These findings indicate that HIV-positive patients can have S-cone/tritanopic abnormalities despite normal appearing fundi and that there may be damage to the visual system early in HIV infection.

Diurnal visual changes in radial keratotomy: implications for visual standards. Refractive Surgery Study Group

BACKGROUND

Diurnal variations in vision have been reported in radial keratotomy (RK) patients. Applicants to certain professions may meet an uncorrected vision standard at the time of testing but fail to meet that standard at another time.

METHODS

Ten firefighter applicants who had undergone RK and nine normal subjects attended for two morning visits, and two afternoon visits. At each visit subjective refraction, uncorrected visual acuity, best-corrected visual acuity, automated refraction, and keratometry were measured for each eye. Monocular contrast sensitivity was measured using the Pelli-Robson chart with and without a glare source (brightness acuity tester, BAT) and for both natural and dilated pupils.

RESULTS

The RK group showed a significant myopic shift from morning to afternoon (mean = -0.41 +/- 0.33 D; t = 3.92, p = 0.004), which was well correlated (r = -0.86) with significant steepening of the corneal curvature (mean = +0.41 +/- 0.36 D; t = -3.65, p = 0.005). The controls showed no change in either refractive error (mean change = +0.06 +/- 0.42 D) or corneal curvature (mean change = +0.05 +/- 0.08 D). No significant difference in corrected visual acuity or contrast sensitivity was found between the RK and control groups for natural pupils. For dilated pupils, the RK patients showed significantly poorer log contrast sensitivity both with and without glare (RK mean = 1.49 +/- 0.11; control mean = 1.67 +/- 0.11; t = 3.21, p = 0.005). All RK subjects met the firefighter visual acuity standard on the initial visit, three subjects did not meet the standard at an afternoon examination.

DISCUSSION

We propose that, if RK applicants are to be considered for employment, existing visual standards be amended to include visual acuity testing in both the early morning and late afternoon. Clinicians and agencies should also be aware that contrast sensitivity may be reduced at low light levels.

Motion perception in glaucoma

PURPOSE

This study was performed to investigate motion perception in patients with glaucoma.

METHODS

A random dot motion test was used to measure three aspects of central motion perception: minimum displacement threshold (Dmin), maximum displacement threshold (Dmax), and coherence threshold (signal to noise). Motion perception was assessed in 15 patients with primary open-angle glaucoma, 23 low-risk patients in whom glaucoma was suspected, and 24 age-matched normal subjects.

RESULTS

Central motion perception was significantly impaired in patients with glaucoma; in particular, the Dmin was nearly twice that for the normal subjects (glaucoma mean, -0.27 +/- 0.24 log minutes of arc; normal mean, -0.56 +/- 0.13 log minutes of arc; F = 21.79, P < 0.001). Furthermore, Dmin values fell outside the normal range in 10 of the 15 patients with glaucoma, despite normal visual acuity and normal foveal perimetric thresholds. Coherence thresholds and Dmax did not discriminate between patients with glaucoma and normal subjects. Dmin was not correlated with any indices of perimetric sensitivity, and none of the tests of motion perception showed any abnormalities in patients in whom glaucoma was suspected.

CONCLUSIONS

Central motion perception can be affected in glaucoma and may reflect preferential damage to larger retinal ganglion cells. Future work will measure Dmin in a larger population of patients with suspected glaucoma and those with glaucoma, and investigate peripheral motion perception in glaucoma.

Considerations in the subjective assessment of cataract

The subjective classification of lens opacities is a fundamental component in both the clinical evaluation of the individual patient and in large-scale clinical trials. This procedure has been improved substantially by the implementation of standardized photographic systems depicting various levels of nuclear opacity and color, cortical, and posterior-subcapsular cataract. Comparison can also be made with recently developed objective measurements of opacity and color. Further improvements in reliability and sensitivity to change can be achieved by modifying traditional integer scaling systems by interpolating between photographic standards.

Subjective and objective assessment of soft bifocal contact lens performance

Subjective and objective techniques were used to assess the on-eye performance of soft bifocal contact lenses. In the subjective technique a young observer whose accommodation had been paralyzed with a cycloplegic agent was fitted with the contact lens type under investigation and aligned with a Maxwellian view Badal optometer using a bite-bar. Visual acuity was measured as a function of both target vergence (0.00 to -4.00 D) and pupil size (1 to 5 mm). Aspheric, concentric, and diffractive soft bifocal contact lens designs were investigated. Diffractive and concentric bifocal designs with +2.00 D near additions showed "twin peaks" of visual acuity with one peak at 0.00 D target vergence (equivalent to distance viewing) and the second at -2.00 D target vergence (equivalent to a target at 50 cm). Some aspheric designs produced a relatively constant visual acuity across this vergence range, whereas others gave poor acuity at near. Visual acuity with the Echelon diffractive lens was relatively unaffected by pupil size, confirming theoretical predictions. Visual acuity with concentric designs was also relatively free of pupil size effects. In the objective technique, the variation in surface power across the lens was assessed using video-keratography. This technique provided an elegant means of visualizing the power profile of the lens. The location of the zones of increased power and the magnitude of power variations allowed an accurate prediction of the visual performance measured subjectively. Temporal displacement of lenses may explain the occasions where visual performance did not vary with pupil size.

The Lens Opacities Classification System III. The Longitudinal Study of Cataract Study Group

OBJECTIVE

To develop the Lens Opacities Classification System III (LOCS III) to overcome the limitations inherent in lens classification using LOCS II. These limitations include unequal intervals between standards, only one standard for color grading, use of integer grading, and wide 95% tolerance limits.

DESIGN AND RESULTS

The LOCS III contains an expanded set of standards that were selected from the Longitudinal Study of Cataract slide library at the Center for Clinical Cataract Research, Boston, Mass. It consists of six slit-lamp images for grading nuclear color (NC) and nuclear opalescence (NO), five retroillumination images for grading cortical cataract (C), and five retroillumination images for grading posterior subcapsular (P) cataract. Cataract severity is graded on a decimal scale, and the standards have regularly spaced intervals on a decimal scale. The 95% tolerance limits are reduced from 2.0 for each class with LOCS II to 0.7 for nuclear opalescence, 0.7 for nuclear color, 0.5 for cortical cataract, and 1.0 for posterior subcapsular cataract with the LOCS III, with excellent interobserver agreement.

CONCLUSION

The LOCS III is an improved LOCS system for grading slit-lamp and retroillumination images of age-related cataract.

Assessing the reliability, discriminative ability, and validity of disability glare tests

PURPOSE

To gather information regarding the reliability, discriminative ability, and validity of disability glare tests.

METHODS

The following glare tests were evaluated: the Miller-Nadler, Vistech MCT8000, Berkeley, van den Berg Straylightmeter, and the Brightness Acuity Tester used with the Pelli-Robson and Regan charts. Three test evaluation criteria were used: (1) repeatability--comparing test scores on two visits; (2) discriminative ability--the tests' ability to differentiate between young and old subjects and between old normal and cataract subjects; (3) validity--comparing cataract test scores with the reference standard of the van den Berg Straylightmeter. Three subject groups were evaluated: young normals (n = 24, mean age 24.3 +/- 3.3 yr), older normals (n = 22, mean age 66.0 +/- 6.2 yr), and early cataract (n = 33, mean age 70.6 +/- 8.1 yr).

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Data indicate that contrast sensitivity or low contrast acuity measured in the presence of glare are superior to disability glare scores in assessing cataract patients with normal neural function. Under glare conditions, contrast sensitivity and low contrast acuity scores from the Pelli-Robson, Regan, and Berkeley tests provide similarly reliable, discriminative, and valid measures of visual assessment in cataract. The Miller-Nadler glare tester poorly detects and measures subtle changes in the ocular media, such as early cataract, because of its large step sizes at low contrast thresholds. The poor reliability of the Vistech MCT8000 limits its usefulness. The study suggests that unless good chart design and psychophysics are used, the geometry and intensity of the glare source are of little importance.

Artificial pupils and Maxwellian view

When control of the pupil size is required, the simplest method is to use a physical artificial pupil or aperture that is placed in the spectacle plane. In some clinical applications (e.g., the potential acuity meter) an optical artificial pupil is imaged in the plane of the natural pupil by a Maxwellian view optical system. We compared visual performance with physical and Maxwellian artificial pupils by measuring the effects of the pupil diameter (0.5-5 mm in range) and defocus (5-D myopia to 4-D hyperopia) on minimum angles of resolution (MAR's) and on angular blur disk diameters. For pupil diameters down to ~ 2.0 mm there were no meaningful differences between the visual resolution that is obtained with the physical and the Maxwellian pupils. At the smallest diameter (0.5 mm) the physical artificial pupils caused the MAR to increase because of the diffraction limitation on resolution, and defocus no longer affected MAR. With the small Maxwellian pupils vision did not become diffraction-limited so that maximum resolution could still be obtained. MAR was still affected by defocus. The angular blur disk diameters measured with the smaller Maxwellian pupils were slightly but significantly larger than those found with physical artificial pupils. For physical artificial pupils, field-of-view restrictions may result from vignetting with the eye pupil. Thus small physical artificial pupils can act as pinholes causing resolution to become impaired but insensitive to defocus. Also vignetting by the eye pupil can restrict the field of view. Small optical artificial pupils from Maxwellian viewing do not impair resolution, and the resolution may remain sensitive to defocus. The eye pupil does not cause any field restriction, although, if small, it may filter higher spatial frequencies out of the retinal image.

Pharmacological effects on accommodative adaptation

We review the research which has attempted to determine whether the characteristics of autonomic innervation of ciliary smooth muscle are relevant to the process of accommodative adaptation. The effect of various topical autonomic drugs on the three phases of adaptation were analyzed: pre-task tonic accommodation (open-loop); within-task accommodative response (closed-loop); and post-task regression of accommodation to pre-task tonic levels. Although it is clear that parasympathetic innervation predominates, there is evidence that some individuals utilize supplementary inhibitory sympathetic innervation. When sympathetic innervation is augmented by substantial levels of concurrent parasympathetic accommodative activity, it may serve to attenuate the magnitude and duration of post-task shifts in tonic accommodation. It is proposed that individuals with a deficit in sympathetic inhibition may therefore be predisposed to anomalies of accommodative adaptation. However, the mechanism by which the oculomotor system responds to such predisposition is at present obscure.

Steady-state accommodation and ocular biometry in late-onset myopia

The steady-state accommodative responses of emmetropes and late-onset myopes was measured for an array of numbers located at -1, -3 and -5 dioptres using an objective infra-red optometer. Responses were compared for passive (reading numbers) and active (adding numbers) conditions. For the passive condition, the late-onset myopes showed a significantly lower accommodative response than the emmetropic group. No significant differences were found between the two groups for the active condition. Ocular biometric characteristics were also measured in emmetropes, late-onset myopes and early-onset myopes using keratometry and ultrasonography. No significant differences in corneal curvature, anterior chamber depth and crystalline lens thickness were found between the groups. Late-onset myopes exhibited significantly deeper vitreous chambers than emmetropes, which more than accounted for the difference in refractive error between the two refractive groups. We conclude that, while significant differences exist in the accommodative responses of late-onset myopes and emmetropes, late-onset myopia is due predominantly to elongation of the vitreous chamber.

A new test for the evaluation of disability glare

We describe a new glare test that uses low contrast letters and a variable surround glare source. The test is easy to administer clinically and all test targets, luminance levels, glare geometry, and viewing conditions are well controlled. We found the most useful index of disability glare to be the difference in visual acuity scores for the low contrast chart in the no-glare and high-glare conditions and refer to this as the disability glare index (DGI). We tested a group of normal subjects who were divided into younger (age 15 to 41 years) and older (age 50 to 82 years) groups. The mean DGI value for the older group (10.2 +/- 4.8) was significantly higher than that for the younger group (2.3 +/- 1.9). The DGI is a better discriminator between the two groups than either high or low contrast visual acuity. We attribute the significantly higher DGI values in the older group to increased intraocular light scatter. We find DGI is poorly correlated with high contrast visual acuity (r = 0.33). Our findings suggest that this test of disability glare is sensitive to relatively modest changes in the ocular media. It is a potentially useful tool in detection and assessment of subtle media disturbances and in monitoring changes in the ocular media over a period of time.

Face recognition in age-related maculopathy

Patients with age-related maculopathy (ARM) complain frequently of difficulty with face recognition. The authors attempted to quantify the level of impairment by comparing face recognition with clinical tests of visual function, namely contrast sensitivity, grating acuity, letter-chart acuity, and word-reading acuity. For face recognition, we used 32 black-and-white photographs that had been cropped to remove the outline of hair so that identification was predominantly dependent on the facial features. The observer's distance from the screen on which the photographs were projected was varied. The angular size of the faces was indicated by the equivalent viewing distance (EVD). Four male and four female models were used, and for each model, there were four photographs with different facial expressions--happy, sad, angry, and afraid. For each photograph, the subject's task was to name the model and identify the facial expression. Threshold EVD (50%) was determined for correct identity recognition and expression recognition. For eight subjects all experimental procedures were repeated at a lower luminance level. For ARM subjects, increasing task complexity (grating/letters/words) substantially decreased resolution. Face-recognition abilities were most closely related to word-reading acuity when comparisons were made either across subjects or across luminances within subjects. Contrast sensitivity was associated poorly with face-recognition thresholds. In some subjects with more advanced ARM, identity recognition was substantially poorer than expression recognition.

Clinical grading and the effects of scaling

In clinical practice, there has been a need to grade the magnitude or the severity of the functions and qualities that are assessed in the examination. It is popular to use a four-step grading scale to categorize the severity of clinical findings. The authors discuss clinical grading scales and their influence on the clinician's ability to detect change. These principles have been applied to grades or measures derived from either objective measuring instruments, subjective tests, or techniques in which the clinician makes subjective judgments. A hypothetical data set was used to show the problems associated with using grading scales that are too coarse. The authors presented a mathematic model that helps to estimate the benefits of using use of a finer scale. Data were presented from two separate studies, one on visual acuity measurement and the other on grading nuclear opacity, to show the advantages of using finer scales to enhance the sensitivity of clinical measurement. High levels of concordance between independent observations indicated that the grading scale was too coarse and that these scales needlessly reduced the clinician's ability to detect change in the parameter being assessed. For moderate sensitivity, the size of the scale increments should not exceed one standard deviation of the discrepancy so that the concordance of paired comparisons would not exceed 37%. For fine clinical sensitivity, the size of the scale increments should not exceed one third of the standard deviation of the discrepancy, in which case the concordance of paired comparisons would not exceed 13%. The theory and evidence presented here could prompt re-evaluations of common methods of clinical grading.

Adaptation of tonic accommodation to sustained visual tasks in emmetropia and late-onset myopia

The study complements and extends our previous investigation and reports that late-onset myopes (LOM's, N = 15) exhibit differences in adaptation of tonic accommodation (TA) to sustained visual tasks when compared to emmetropes (EMM's, N = 15). Pre- and post-task TA was measured with a modified Canon R-1 objective infra-red optometer under darkroom conditions. Post-task TA was measured immediately after a 10-min counting task and at 1-s intervals over a period of 90 s; the task was located at distances equivalent to 1, 3, and 5 D. The pattern of regression back to the pre-task TA level was used to assess the degree of adaptation generated by the task. The data indicate substantial differences between regression patterns for EMM's and for LOM's which were enhanced as accommodation stimulus levels increased. Using a two-factor split-plot analysis of variance, statistically significant differences between EMM's and LOM's could be attributed to the rates of change of post-task accommodative levels to pre-task TA levels for both the 3 and 5 D tasks.

Stand magnifiers: an evaluation of new optical aids from COIL

This paper discusses stand magnifiers and the optical parameters that clinicians should know in order to understand the viewing requirements and the expected resolution for low vision patients. We report on measurements made of key optical parameters of a new series of stand magnifiers from Combined Optical Industries Limited (COIL) and comparison is made to the previous series of stand magnifiers from the same manufacturer. These results illustrate that manufacturers' specifications of optical parameters are generally inaccurate and misleading. We urge manufacturers to provide clinically relevant information about their optical products.

Myopia in optometry students: family history, age of onset and personality

The relationship between refractive error and family history, age of onset and personality was investigated in 189 optometry students. Subjects completed a questionnaire requesting details of their refractive history, type of correction and their family history. Subjects also completed an Eysenck Personality Inventory (EPI). Subjects were categorized as hyperopes, emmetropes or myopes on the basis of their questionnaire responses. No significant relationship was found between refractive group and the prevalence of myopia in parents. Myopic subjects, however, showed a significantly higher prevalence of myopic siblings. Furthermore, late-onset myopes showed a higher prevalence of myopic siblings than early-onset myopes. No significant personality differences were found between the refractive groups.