Functionalized Calixarenes as Promising Antibacterial Drugs to Face Antimicrobial Resistance

Since the discovery of polyphenolic resins 150 years ago, the study of polymeric compounds named calix[n]arene has continued to progress, and those skilled in the art perfectly know now how to modulate this phenolic ring. Consequently, calix[n]arenes are now used in a large range of applications and notably in therapeutic fields. In particular, the calix[4]arene exhibits multiple possibilities for regioselective polyfunctionalization on both of its rims and offers researchers the possibility of precisely tuning the geometry of their structures. Thus, in the crucial research of new antibacterial active ingredients, the design of calixarenes finds its place perfectly. This review provides an overview of the work carried out in this aim towards the development of intrinsically active prodrogues or metallic calixarene complexes. Out of all the work of the community, there are some excellent activities emerging that could potentially place these original structures in a very good position for the development of new active ingredients.

Enhanced stability and photothermal efficiency of Indocyanine Green J-aggregates by nanoformulation with Calix[4]arene for photothermal therapy of cancers

Photothermal therapy (PTT) is a method of growing attention, owing to its controllable process, high efficiency and minimal side effect. Indocyanine Green (ICG) is as Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved agent that stands on the frontline of further developments of PTT toward clinics. However, the applicability of ICG-mediated PTT is limited by the rapid in vivo clearance and photo-degradation of ICG. To improve those parameters, nanosized ICG-loaded nanoparticles (ICG-J/CX) were fabricated in this study by co-assembly of anionic ICG J-aggregates (ICG-J) with cationic tetraguanidinium calix[4]arene (CX). This very simple approach produces ICG-J/CX with a well-defined nanometer range size and a close to neutral charge. The nanoparticles demonstrate high photothermal conversion efficiency (PCE) and dramatically improved photostability, as compared with ICG. The in vitro cellular uptake and cytotoxicity studies further demonstrated that the ICG-J/CX nanoparticles enhance uptake and photothermal efficiency in comparison with ICG or non-formulated ICG-J, overall demonstrating that ICG-J/CX mediated photothermal therapy have significant potential for attaining cancer treatment.

Modelling the effects of E/Z photoisomerization of a cyclocurcumin analogue on the properties of cellular lipid membranes

The use of photosensitive molecules capable of isomerizing under light stimuli, and thus induce perturbation in biological systems, is becoming increasingly popular for potential light-activated chemotherapeutic purposes. We recently show that a cyclocurcumin derivative (CCBu), may be suitable for light-activated chemotherapy and may constitute a valuable alternative to traditional photodynamic therapy, due to its oxygen-independent mechanism of action, which allows the treatment of hypoxic solid tumors. In particular, we have shown that the E/Z photoisomerization of CCBu correlates with strong perturbations of model lipid bilayers. In this work, we perform all-atom classical molecular dynamics for a more complex bilayer, whose composition is, thus, much closer to eukaryotic outer cell membranes. We have evidenced important differences in the interaction pathway between CCBu and the complex lipid bilayer as compared to previous models, concerning both the membrane penetration capacity and the isomerization-induced perturbations. While we confirm that structural perturbations of the lipid membrane are induced by isomerization, we also show how the use of a simplified membrane model can result in an oversimplification of the system and hinder key physical and biological phenomena. Although, CCBu may be considered as a suitable candidate for light-activated chemotherapy, we also underline how the inclusion of bulkier substituents, inducing larger perturbations upon photoisomerization, may enhance its efficiency.

Perturbation of Lipid Bilayers by Biomimetic Photoswitches Based on Cyclocurcumin

The use of photoswitches which may be activated by suitable electromagnetic radiation is an attractive alternative to conventional photodynamic therapy. Here, we report all-atom molecular dynamics simulation of a biomimetic photoswitch derived from cyclocurcumin and experiencing E/Z photoisomerization. In particular, we show that the two isomers interact persistently with a lipid bilayer modeling a cellular membrane. Furthermore, the interaction with the membrane is strongly dependent on the concentration, and a transition between ordered and disordered arrangements of the photoswitches is observed. We also confirm that the structural parameters of the bilayer are differently affected by the two isomers and hence can be modulated through photoswitching, offering interesting perspectives for future applications.

Biomimetic Photo-Switches Softening Model Lipid Membranes

We report the synthesis and characterization of a novel photo-switch based on biomimetic cyclocurcumin analogous and interacting with the lipid bilayer, which can be used in the framework of oxygen-independent light-induced therapy. More specifically, by using molecular dynamics simulations and free energy techniques, we show that the inclusion of hydrophobic substituents is needed to allow insertion in the lipid membrane. After having confirmed experimentally that the substituents do not preclude the efficient photoisomerization, we show through UV-vis and dynamic light scattering measurements together with compression isotherms that the chromophore is internalized in both lipid vesicles and monomolecular film, respectively, inducing their fluidification. The irradiation of the chromophore-loaded lipid aggregates modifies their properties due to the different organization of the two diastereoisomers, E and Z. In particular, a competition between a fast structural reorganization and a slower expulsion of the chromophore after isomerization can be observed in the kinetic profiles recorded during E to Z photoisomerization. This report paves the way for future investigations in the optimization of biomimetic photoswitches potentially useful in modern light-induced therapeutic strategies.

Synthesis and Photoswitching Properties of Bioinspired Dissymmetric γ-Pyrone, an Analogue of Cyclocurcumin

Cyclocurcumin (CC), a turmeric curcuminoid with potential therapeutic properties, is also a natural photoswitch that may undergo E/Z photoisomerization under UV light. To be further exploited in relevant biological applications, photoactivation under near-infrared (NIR) irradiation is required. Such requirement can be met through opportune chemical modifications, by favoring two-photon absorption (TPA) probability. Herein, a general and efficient synthesis of a biomimetic 2,6-disubstituted-γ-pyrone analogue of CC is described, motivated by the fact that molecular modeling previews an order of magnitude increase of its NIR TPA compared to CC. Three retrosynthetic pathways have been identified (i) via an aryl-oxazole intermediate or via aryl-diynone through (ii) a bottom-up or (iii) a top-down approach. While avoiding the passage through unstable synthons or low-yield intermediate reactions, only the latest approach could conveniently afford the 2,6-disubstituted-γ-pyrone analogue of CC, in ten steps and with an overall yield of 18%. The photophysical properties of our biomimetic analogue have also been characterized showing an improved photoisomerization yield over the parent natural compound. The potentially improved nonlinear optical properties, as well as enhanced stability, may be correlated to the enforcement of the planarity of the pyrone moiety leading to a quadrupolar D-π-A-π-D system.

trans-cis Photoisomerization of a biomimetic cyclocurcumin analogue rationalized by molecular modelling

Cyclocurcumin is a natural compound extracted from turmeric and showing, in addition to antiinfective, antibacterial, and intinflammatory capabilities, solvent-dependent phtoswitching ability. The solvent-dependent photochemistry of cyclocurcumin has been rationalized on the basis of a competition between π-π* and n-π* states. Recently we have reported the synthesis of a biomimetic analogue showing enhanced photochemical properties and in particular presenting photoswitching capacity in various media. In the present contribution we rely on the use of molecular modeling and simulation, incuding density functional and wavefunction based methods to explore the excited states potential energy surface landscape. We see that the addition of a carbon-carbon double bond to the core of the natural compounds favors the population of the π-π* state, whatever the choice of the solvent, and hence leads to photoisomerisation, with fluorescence reduced to only a minor channel, rationalizing the experimental observations. In addition, the two photon absorption cross section is also strongly increased compared to the parent compound, paving the way to the use in biologically oriented applications.

Trans-to-cis photoisomerization of cyclocurcumin in different environments rationalized by computational photochemistry

Cyclocurcumin is a turmeric component that has attracted much less attention compared to the well-known curcumin. In spite of the less deep characterization of its properties, cyclocurcumin has shown promising anticancer effects when used in combination with curcumin. Especially, due to its peculiar molecular structure, cyclocurcumin can be regarded as an almost ideal photoswitch, whose capabilities can also be exploited for relevant biological applications. Here, by means of state-of-the-art computational methods for electronic excited-state calculations (TD-DFT, MS-CASPT2, and XMS-CASPT2), we analyze in detail the absorption and photoisomerization pathways leading from the more stable trans isomer to the cis one. The different molecular surroundings, taken into account by means of the electrostatic solvent effect and compared with available experimental data, have been found to be critical in describing the fate of irradiated cyclocurcumin: when in non-polar environments, an excited state barrier prevents photoisomerization and favours fluorescence, whereas in polar solvents, an almost barrierless path results in a striking decrease of fluorescence, opening the way toward a crossing region with the ground state and thus funneling the photoproduction of the cis isomer.

The selective interactions of cationic tetra-p-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene with lipid membranes: theoretical and experimental model studies

Behavior of cationic tetra-p-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene (CX1) and its building block, p-guanidinoethylphenol (mCX1) in model monolayer lipid membranes was investigated using all atom molecular dynamics simulations and surface pressure measurements. Members of two classes of lipids were taken into account: zwitterionic 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and anionic 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine sodium salt (DMPS) as models of eukaryotic and bacterial cell membranes, respectively. It was demonstrated that CX1 and mCX1 accumulate near the negatively charged DMPS monolayers. The adsorption to neutral monolayers was negligible. In contrast to mCX1, CX1 penetrated into the hydrophobic part of the monolayer. The latter effect, which is possible due to a flip-flop inversion of the CX1 orientation in the lipid layer compared to the aqueous phase, may be responsible for its antibacterial activity.

Bacteriophilic tetra-p-guanidinoethyl-calix[4]arene derived polymers. Syntheses and E. coli sequestration studies

New resins functionalized by the antibacterial tetra-p-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene were synthesized, and their bacteriophilic properties were evaluated (E. coli) by capillary electrophoresis.

A bacteriophilic resin, synthesis and E. coli sequestration study

The polycationic pyridinium-Merrifield resinIwas prepared and subjected to bacteria sequestration studies. Its efficiency was demonstrated by capillary electrophoresis titrations, and the effectiveness of the sequestration was shown by confocal microscopy.

Intramolecular interactions versus hydration effects on p-guanidinoethyl-phenol structure and pKa values

We analyze the structure, hydration, and pK(a) values of p-guanidinoethyl-phenol through a combined experimental and theoretical study. These issues are relevant to understand the mechanism of action of the tetrameric form, the antibacterial compound tetra-p-guanidinoethyl-calix[4]arene (Cx1). The investigated system can also be useful to model other pharmaceutical drugs bearing a guanidine function in the vicinity of an ionizable group and the effect of arginine on the pK(a) of vicinal ionizable residues (in particular tyrosine) in peptides. The p-guanidinoethyl-phenol monomer (mCx1) has two ionizable groups. One important particularity of this system is that it exhibits high molecular flexibility that potentially leads to enhanced stabilization in folded structures by direct, strong Coulombic interactions between the ionizable groups. The first pK(a) corresponding to ionization of the -OH group has experimentally been shown to be only slightly different from usual values in substituted phenols. However, because of short-range Coulombic interactions, the role of intramolecular interactions and solvation effects on the acidities of this compound is expected to be important and it has been analyzed here on the basis of theoretical calculations. We use a discrete-continuum solvation model together with quantum-mechanical calculations at the B3LYP level of theory and the extended 6-311+G(2df,2p) basis set. Both intra- and intermolecular effects are very large (~70 kcal/mol) but exhibit an almost perfect compensation, thus explaining that the actual pK(a) of mCx1 is close to free phenol. The same compensation of environmental effects applies to the second pK(a) that concerns the guanidinium group. Such a pK(a) could not be determined experimentally with standard titration techniques and in fact the theoretical study predicts a value of 14.2, that is, one unit above the pK(a) of the parent ethyl-guanidinium molecule.

Nanoscale analysis of the effects of antibiotics and CX1 on a Pseudomonas aeruginosa multidrug-resistant strain

Drug resistance is a challenge that can be addressed using nanotechnology. We focused on the resistance of the bacteria Pseudomonas aeruginosa and investigated, using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM), the behavior of a reference strain and of a multidrug resistant clinical strain, submitted to two antibiotics and to an innovative antibacterial drug (CX1). We measured the morphology, surface roughness and elasticity of the bacteria under physiological conditions and exposed to the antibacterial molecules. To go further in the molecules action mechanism, we explored the bacterial cell wall nanoscale organization using functionalized AFM tips. We have demonstrated that affected cells have a molecularly disorganized cell wall; surprisingly long molecules being pulled off from the cell wall by a lectin probe. Finally, we have elucidated the mechanism of action of CX1: it destroys the outer membrane of the bacteria as demonstrated by the results on artificial phospholipidic membranes and on the resistant strain.

Antiseptic properties of two calix[4]arenes derivatives on the human coronavirus 229E

Facing the lack in specific antiviral treatment, it is necessary to develop new means of prevention. In the case of the Coronaviridae this family is now recognized as including potent human pathogens causing upper and lower respiratory tract infections as well as nosocomial ones. Within the purpose of developing new antiseptics molecules, the antiseptic virucidal activity of two calix[4]arene derivatives, the tetra-para-sulfonato-calix[4]arene (C[4]S) and the 1,3-bis(bithiazolyl)-tetra-para-sulfonato-calix[4]arene (C[4]S-BTZ) were evaluated toward the human coronavirus 229E (HCoV 229E). Comparing these results with some obtained previously with chlorhexidine and hexamidine, (i) these two calixarenes did not show any cytotoxicity contrary to chlorhexidine and hexamidine, (ii) C[4]S showed as did hexamidine, a very weak activity against HCoV 229E, and (iii) the C[4]S-BTZ showed a stronger activity than chlorhexidine, i.e. 2.7 and 1.4log₁₀ reduction in viral titer after 5min of contact with 10⁻³mol L⁻¹ solutions of C[4]S-BTZ and chlorhexidine, respectively. Thus, the C[4]S-BTZ appeared as a promising virucidal (antiseptic) molecule.

Microélectrophorèse et microscopie à force atomique: deux nouveaux outils d'évaluation de l'effet pariétal d'antibactériens

Microbial cell surface properties play a central role in controlling phenomena such as bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation (on stent or on prosthesis for example). The quantification of these properties and the understanding of interactions with antibacterial compounds remain difficult, in view of the complex and dynamic nature of the cell wall constituents. Various approaches, macroscopic, microscopic or molecular, have been developed. Two of them interest us today: (i) microelectrophoresis, which permits to evaluate surface modifications by measuring eletrophoretic mobility; and (ii) atomic force microscopy (AFM), a high resolution imaging device, which allows investigations at nanometric scale. After brief presentation of principles and instrumentations, the aim of this article is to present the different applications of these techniques in Microbiology, and to discuss interest of these tools in order to investigate mechanism of action of antibacterial compounds.

In vitro activity of para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene against susceptible and antibiotic-resistant Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria

OBJECTIVES

Emergence of multidrug-resistant bacteria has encouraged vigorous efforts to develop antimicrobial agents with new mechanisms of action. In this study, the in vitro antibacterial activity of para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene was evaluated and compared with that of its constitutive monomer, para-guanidinoethylphenol. Hexamidine, a widely used antiseptic, and synthalin A, an old antidiabetic and anti-trypanosomal compound, were chosen as references.

METHODS

MIC and MBC were determined for five reference strains (Escherichia coli ATCC 25922, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 and ATCC 29213, Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212 and Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853), as well as five antibiotic-resistant clinical isolates. Toxicity on MRC-5 and HaCaT eukaryotic cell lines was also evaluated by MTT and Neutral Red assays.

RESULTS

No antibacterial activity was observed for para-guanidinoethylphenol (MIC >or= 512 mg/L) and synthalin A (MIC >or= 64 mg/L). Conversely, para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene and hexamidine: (i) showed a broad antibacterial spectrum, both on Gram-positive and on Gram-negative bacteria (MIC = 4 mg/L against E. coli and 8 mg/L against S. aureus for para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene), to a lesser degree against E. faecalis and P. aeruginosa (MIC = 32 mg/L); (ii) were bacteriostatic (MBC >or= 256 mg/L); and (iii) MICs and MBCs obtained for clinical isolates were similar to those obtained with reference strains. Both compounds, the monomer and the calixarene, showed no apparent cytotoxicity, whereas hexamidine and synthalin A had significant toxic effects that increased with time and concentration and in a range of 100-1000 times that for calixarene.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, results confirm para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene as a broad-spectrum new agent or an auxiliary in antimicrobial chemotherapy.

Vers de nouvelles molécules antibactériennes. Intérêt du para-guanidinoéthylcalix[4]arène

We present here the results concerning the antibacterial properties evaluation of para-guanidinoethylcalix[4]arene, compared with its constitutive monomer, the para-guanidinoethylphenol, and hexamidine (Hexomédine), an antiseptic from the diamidine family widely used in therapeutic, chosen as a reference in this study for its resemblance in terms of functional groups. Antibacterial activities of those three compounds were evaluated by microdilution methods, in Mueller Hinton broth, onto 5 bacterial strains: Escherichia coli ATCC 25922, Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 & ATCC 29213 and Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212, according to CA-SFM and CLSI (formerly NCCLS) approved standards. In parallel, the effects of these three compounds on MRC-5 eukaryotic cell viability were evaluated with MTT assay. The results obtained here confirm a lack of activity for the monomer compound (MIC> or =512 mg/l) and a real antibacterial activity for the calixarene, comparable to hexamidine. This activity is expressed, both on Gram+and Gram- bacteria (MIC=4 mg/l for E. coli, 8 mg/l on both S. aureus strains) and at a lesser degree on E. faecalis and P. aeruginosa (MIC=32 mg/l). Similarly, both compounds, monomer and calixarene, slightly induce any modification on MRC-5 cells viability, and this until 168 h of treatment for concentrations reaching 10(-4) mol/L while hexamidine demonstrates a significant and increasing effect during the time of experiment and this for 100 to 1000 times lower concentrations. Thus, this study tends to confirm the significance of the organization of the para-guanidinoethylphenol monomer into its cyclic calixarenic tetramer for the gain of an antibacterial activity, similar to a widely used antiseptic one.

Functional organisation and gain of activity: The case of the antibacterial tetra-para-guanidinoethyl-calix[4]arene

The antibacterial activities of the para-guanidinoethylphenol and of its cyclic tetramer, the tetra-para-guanidinoethyl-calix[4]arene, have been evaluated on reference gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. Antibiotic disk diffusion assays completed by micromethod technique were employed to determine if a synergistic effect could be expected from the spatial organisation of the monomer into its cyclic tetrameric analogue. Disk diffusion assays and microdilution experiments revealed better properties for the calixarene species, with a real and important gain of activity with regards to the monomer.