DNA methylation-dependent chromatin fiber compaction in vivo and in vitro: requirement for linker histone

Dynamic alterations in chromatin structure mediated by postsynthetic histone modifications and DNA methylation constitute a major regulatory mechanism in DNA functioning. DNA methylation has been implicated in transcriptional silencing, in part by inducing chromatin condensation. To understand the methylation-dependent chromatin structure, we performed atomic force microscope (AFM) studies of fibers isolated from cultured cells containing normal or elevated levels of m5C. Chromatin fibers were reconstituted on control or methylated DNA templates in the presence or absence of linker histone. Visual inspection of AFM images, combined with quantitative analysis of fiber structural parameters, suggested that DNA methylation induced fiber compaction only in the presence of linker histones. This conclusion was further substantiated by biochemical results.

The archaeal histone-fold protein HMf organizes DNA into bona fide chromatin fibers

BACKGROUND

The discovery of histone-like proteins in Archaea urged studies into the possible organization of archaeal genomes in chromatin. Despite recent advances, a variety of structural questions remain unanswered.

RESULTS

We have used the atomic force microscope (AFM) with traditional nuclease digestion assays to compare the structure of nucleoprotein complexes reconstituted from tandemly repeated eukaryal nucleosome-positioning sequences and histone octamers, H3/H4 tetramers, and the histone-fold archaeal protein HMf. The data unequivocally show that HMf reconstitutes are indeed organized as chromatin fibers, morphologically indistinguishable from their eukaryal counterparts. The nuclease digestion patterns revealed a clear pattern of protection at regular intervals, again similar to the patterns observed with eukaryal chromatin fibers. In addition, we studied HMf reconstitutes on mononucleosome-sized DNA fragments and observed a great degree of similarity in the internal organization of these particles and those organized by H3/H4 tetramers. A difference in stability was observed at the level of mono-, di-, and triparticles between the HMf particles and canonical octamer-containing nucleosomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The in vitro reconstituted HMf-nucleoprotein complexes can be considered as bona fide chromatin structures. The differences in stability at the monoparticle level should be due to structural differences between HMf and core histone H3/H4 tetramers, i.e., to the complete absence in HMf of histone tails beyond the histone fold. We speculate that the existence of core histone tails in eukaryotes may provide a greater stability to nucleosomal particles and also provide the additional ability of chromatin structure to regulate DNA function in eukaryotic cells by posttranslational histone tail modifications.

Unfolding individual nucleosomes by stretching single chromatin fibers with optical tweezers

Single chromatin fibers were assembled directly in the flow cell of an optical tweezers setup. A single lambda phage DNA molecule, suspended between two polystyrene beads, was exposed to a Xenopus laevis egg extract, leading to chromatin assembly with concomitant apparent shortening of the DNA molecule. Assembly was force-dependent and could not take place at forces exceeding 10 pN. The assembled single chromatin fiber was subjected to stretching by controlled movement of one of the beads with the force generated in the molecule continuously monitored with the second bead trapped in the optical trap. The force displayed discrete, sudden drops upon fiber stretching, reflecting discrete opening events in fiber structure. These opening events were quantized at increments in fiber length of approximately 65 nm and are attributed to unwrapping of the DNA from around individual histone octamers. Repeated stretching and relaxing of the fiber in the absence of egg extract showed that the loss of histone octamers was irreversible. The forces measured for individual nucleosome disruptions are in the range of 20-40 pN, comparable to forces reported for RNA- and DNA-polymerases.

Single molecule force spectroscopy in biology using the atomic force microscope

The importance of forces in biology has been recognized for quite a while but only in the past decade have we acquired instrumentation and methodology to directly measure interactive forces at the level of single biological macromolecules and/or their complexes. This review focuses on force measurements performed with the atomic force microscope. A general introduction to the principle of action is followed by review of the types of interactions being studied, describing the main results and discussing the biological implications.

Chromatin structure revisited

Independently of the enormous progress in our understanding of the structure of the core particle, there remain a multitude of structural questions still to be answered. The main points discussed here can be summarized as follows: (1) The meaning of the term 'core particle' should be widened to reflect the fact that the actual length of DNA wrapped around the histone octamer in the context of the chromatin fiber may vary between approximately 100 and approximately 170 bp. (2) In the chromatosome, the linker histone forms a bridge between one terminus of the chromatosomal DNA and a point close to the dyad axis. (3) The particle that contains one molecule of HMG1 may be classified as a bona fide chromatosome. (4) In the extended fiber, the partition of the nucleosomal DNA into core and linker is a dynamic feature, responding to environmental influences; fiber structure-related constraints demand that linker length be beyond a certain minimal value. (5) The compact fiber structure seems to be rather irregular; the precise nature of this structure is still to be determined. Finally, the term 30-nm fiber should be dropped as a designator of the compact or condensed chromatin fiber structure.

The site of binding of linker histone to the nucleosome does not depend upon the amino termini of core histones

Using nucleosomes reconstituted on a defined sequence of DNA, we have investigated the question as to whether the N-terminal tails of core histones play a role in determining the site of binding of a linker histone. Reconstitutes used histone cores of three types: intact, lacking the N-terminal H3 tails, or lacking all tails. In each case the same, single defined position for the histone core was observed, using high-resolution mapping. The affinity for binding of linker histone H1(o) was highest for the intact cores, lowest for the tailless cores. However, the location of the linker histone, as judged by micrococcal nuclease protection, was exactly the same in each case, an asymmetric site of about 17 bp to one side of the core particle DNA.

Proteins that specifically recognize cisplatin-damaged DNA: a clue to anticancer activity of cisplatin

Cisplatin, but not its trans geometric isomer, is a potent anticancer drug whose biological activity is a consequence of the formation of covalent adducts between the platinum compound and certain bases in DNA. Two classes of proteins have recently been identified that bind preferentially to damaged sites: proteins that specifically recognize those sites as a first step in their repair, and those that bind to such sites by virtue of structural similarity between the modified DNA and their own natural binding sites. Both classes of proteins may be involved, perhaps in opposing ways, in the cytotoxic effect of the drug.

Contributions of linker histones and histone H3 to chromatin structure: scanning force microscopy studies on trypsinized fibers

Little is known about the mechanisms that organize linear arrays of nucleosomes into the three-dimensional structures of extended and condensed chromatin fibers. We have earlier defined, from scanning force microscopy (SFM) and mathematical modeling, a set of simple structural determinants of extended fiber morphology, the critical parameters being the entry-exit angle between consecutive linkers and linker length. Here we study the contributions of the structural domains of the linker histones (LHs) and of the N-terminus of histone H3 to extended fiber morphology by SFM imaging of progressively trypsinized chromatin fibers. We find that cleavage of LH tails is associated with a lengthening of the internucleosomal center-to-center distance, and that the somewhat later cleavage of the N-terminus of histone H3 is associated with a flattening of the fiber. The persistence of the "zigzag" fiber morphology, even at the latest stages of trypsin digestion, can be attributed to the retention of the globular domain of LH in the fiber.

Linker histone tails and N-tails of histone H3 are redundant: scanning force microscopy studies of reconstituted fibers

The mechanisms responsible for organizing linear arrays of nucleosomes into the three-dimensional structure of chromatin are still largely unknown. In a companion paper (Leuba, S. H., et al. 1998. Biophys. J. 74:2823-2829), we study the contributions of linker histone domains and the N-terminal tail of core histone H3 to extended chromatin fiber structure by scanning force microscopy imaging of mildly trypsinized fibers. Here we complement and extend these studies by scanning force microscopy imaging of selectively reconstituted chromatin fibers, which differ in subtle but distinctive ways in their histone composition. We demonstrate an absolute requirement for the globular domain of the linker histones and a structural redundancy of the tails of linker histones and of histone H3 in determining conformational stability.

Chromatin fiber structure: morphology, molecular determinants, structural transitions

Despite more than 20 years of research, the structure of the chromatin fiber and its molecular determinants remain enigmatic. Recent developments in high-resolution microscopic techniques, as well as the application of mathematical modeling to chromatin fiber structure, have allowed the acquisition of some new insights into the structure and its determinants. Here we present some of the newest data on the structure of the chromatin fiber in both its extended and compacted states, and bring together this new knowledge with older data in an attempt to provide a unified view of how chromatin components interact with each other to form its various conformations. The structural transitions that are believed to take place during transcriptional activation and its cessation are also discussed. It becomes obvious that despite some progress in our understanding of the fiber structure and its dynamics, huge gaps continue to exist. Bridging these gaps will require further improvements in already available techniques and the introduction of completely new approaches.

Linker histone protects linker DNA on only one side of the core particle and in a sequence-dependent manner

The protection against micrococcal nuclease digestion afforded to chromatosomal DNA by the presence of a linker histone (H1(o)) has been quantitatively measured in two reconstituted systems. We have used chromatosomes reconstituted at two distinct positions on a DNA fragment containing the 5S rRNA gene from Lytechinus variegatus and at a specific position on a sequence containing Gal4- and USF-binding sites. In all cases, we find asymmetric protection, with approximately 20 bp protected on one side of the core particle and no protection on the other. We demonstrated through crosslinking experiments that the result is not due to any sliding of the histone core caused by either linker histone addition or micrococcal nuclease cleavage. Because the core particle is itself a symmetric object, the preferred asymmetric location of a linker histone must be dictated by unknown elements in the DNA sequence.

The major chromatin protein histone H1 binds preferentially to cis-platinum-damaged DNA

Both cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II) (cisplatin or cis-DDP) and trans-diamminedichloroplatinum(II) form covalent adducts with DNA. However, only the cis isomer is a potent anticancer agent. It has been postulated that the selective action of cis-DDP occurs through specific binding of nuclear proteins to cis-DDP-damaged DNA sites and that binding blocks DNA repair. We find that a very abundant nuclear protein, the linker histone H1, binds much more strongly to cis-platinated DNA than to trans-platinated or unmodified DNA. In competition experiments, H1 is shown to bind much more strongly than HMG1, which had been previously considered a major candidate for such binding in vivo.

Visualization and analysis of chromatin by scanning force microscopy

The use of the scanning force microscope (SFM) to visualize and analyze chromatin fiber structures is presented. Protocols to prepare chromatin fibers for SFM imaging of fibers in air and in buffer are first discussed. Next, the conditions for acquiring high-quality SFM images such as optimal instrumental parameters, appropriate deposition substrates, and adequate procedures of sample deposition are described. It is shown that analysis and quantitation of the SFM images support an irregular, three-dimensional arrangement of nucleosomes in the native chromatin fiber. This structure is lost in linker histone-depleted fibers, which show, instead, a beads-on-a-string structure. Molecular modeling of the chromatin fiber structures and computer simulation of the SFM imaging process indicate that the natural variability of the linker length may be the major determinant of the structural irregularity of the native chromatin fiber. Removal of linker histones (H1/H5) may change the amount of DNA wrapped around the histone octamer, which in turn may induce the transition from a three-dimensional irregular helix to an extended beads-on-a-string structure. Studies of trinucleosomes indicate that both the average successive nucleosome center-to-center distance and the average angle between two successive linkers increase upon the removal of linker histone.

Three-dimensional structure of extended chromatin fibers as revealed by tapping-mode scanning force microscopy

Unfixed chicken erythrocyte chromatin fibers in very low salt have been imaged with a scanning force microscope operating in the tapping mode in air at ambient humidity. These images reveal a three-dimensional organization of the fibers. The planar "zig-zag" conformation is rare, and extended "beads-on-a-string" fibers are seen only in chromatin depleted of histones H1 and H5. Glutaraldehyde fixation reveals very similar structures. Fibers fixed in 10 mM salt appear somewhat more compacted. These results, when compared with modeling studies, suggest that chromatin fibers may exist as irregular three-dimensional arrays of nucleosomes even at low ionic strength.

Linker DNA accessibility in chromatin fibers of different conformations: a reevaluation

New studies on chromatin fiber morphology, using the technique of scanning force microscopy (SFM), have caused us to reexamine recent analysis of nuclease digestion of chromatin. Chicken erythrocyte chromatin fibers, glutaraldehyde-fixed at 0, 10, and 80 mM NaCl, were imaged with the help of SFM. The chromatin fibers possessed a loose three-dimensional 30-nm structure even in the absence of added salt. This structure slightly condensed upon addition of 10 mM NaCl, and highly compacted, irregularly segmented fibers were observed at 80 mM NaCl. This sheds new light upon our previously reported analysis of the kinetics of digestion by soluble and membrane-immobilized micrococcal nuclease [Leuba, S. H., Zlatanova, J. & van Holde, K. (1994) J. Mol. Biol. 235, 871-880]. While the low-ionic-strength fibers were readily digested, the highly compacted structure formed at 80 mM NaCl was refractory to nuclease attack, implying that the linkers were fully accessible in the low-ionic-strength conformation but not in the condensed fibers. We now find that cleavage of the linker DNA by a small molecule, methidiumpropyl-EDTA-Fe(II), proceeds for all types of conformations at similar rates. Thus, steric hindrance is responsible for the lack of accessibility to micrococcal nuclease in the condensed fiber. Taken in total the data suggest that reexamination of existing models of chromatin conformation is warranted.

Binding of histones H1 and H5 and their globular domains to four-way junction DNA

We have compared chicken erythrocyte linker histones H1 and H5 binding to a synthetic four-way DNA junction. Each histone binds to form a single complex, with an affinity which permits competition against a large excess of linear duplex DNA. The affinity of H5 is higher than that of H1. The globular domain from either protein will also bind strongly, but in this case multiple binding occurs. Binding of intact H1 is inhibited by cations: Mg2+ and spermidine are very effective, Na+ much less so. This inhibition is not likely to be a general ion-competition effect, for Mg2+ is much less effective in inhibiting the binding of H1 to linear DNA. Instead, the inhibition of binding may be due to ion-dependent changes in the conformation of the four-way junction, which are known to occur under similar conditions. These results strongly suggest that the angle formed between the arms of the DNA junction could be a major determinant in the interaction of H1 with DNA crossovers.

On the location of linker DNA in the chromatin fiber. Studies with immobilized and soluble micrococcal nuclease

The structure of chicken erythrocyte chromatin fibers has been probed using micrococcal nuclease, both membrane-immobilized and free in solution. Under the extremely mild digestion conditions used, the linker DNA is almost completely protected against digestion with either immobilized or free enzyme in the 30 nm fibers, whereas it is readily accessible in the more extended structures. Control experiments with glutaraldehyde-fixed chromatin fibers gave essentially the same results. Experiments with fibers of intermediate degree of condensation revealed a direct relationship between the degree of compaction and the resistance of linker DNA to digestion. Our results favor models in which access to the linkers is limited by local steric hindrance due to the high compaction, rather than by internalization in the center of the fibers.

On the location of histones H1 and H5 in the chromatin fiber. Studies with immobilized trypsin and chymotrypsin

The location of linker histones H1 and H5 in chicken erythrocyte chromatin was studied as a function of the fiber structure by the use of proteolytic enzymes immobilized onto Immobilon membranes. The immobilization of trypsin and chymotrypsin creates proteolytic probes, specific respectively to the terminal portions of the molecules or to the phenylalanine in the globular domain, that are incapable of penetrating into the interior of the condensed fiber. The chromatin fiber was studied in three different conformations: open zig-zag (in Tris buffer), closed zig-zag (upon addition of 10 mM-NaCl), or 30 nm fiber (upon addition of 0.35 mM-MgCl2). The results from digestion experiments performed on linker histones either in chicken erythrocyte chromatin, or free in solution or bound in mononucleosomes revealed several features relevant to linker histone location: (1) histone H5 is more protected than histone H1 in the fiber; (2) the N and C-terminal portions of histone H1 do not change their accessibility, and hence their location, upon compaction of the fiber; this behavior of H1 is in contrast to that of histone H5, whose tails become significantly internalized in the 30 nm fiber; (3) phenylalanine in the globular domain of both H1 and H5 is inaccessible (buried) both in the fiber and in the mononucleosomal particle. Sedimentation velocity measurements performed during the course of trypsin digestion demonstrate that the conformation of the fiber is highly sensitive to even a few cuts in some of the linker histone molecules; hence, the linker histones are an important factor in the organization of the fiber in all its different condensation states.

One-step fractionation method for isolating H1 histones from chromatin under nondenaturing conditions

By combining conventional methods of chromatin preparation with ion-exchange chromatography in CM-Sephadex C-25, we have been able to isolate and fractionate histone H1 variants from different sources. This method of fractionation is very simple and allows one to obtain, very rapidly, large amounts of these histones in a native nondenatured conformation.