Degradation of p53 by human Alphapapillomavirus E6 proteins shows a stronger correlation with phylogeny than oncogenicity

Background

Human Papillomavirus (HPV) E6 induced p53 degradation is thought to be an essential activity by which high-risk human Alphapapillomaviruses (alpha-HPVs) contribute to cervical cancer development. However, most of our understanding is derived from the comparison of HPV16 and HPV11. These two viruses are relatively distinct viruses, making the extrapolation of these results difficult. In the present study, we expand the tested strains (types) to include members of all known HPV species groups within the Alphapapillomavirus genus.

Principal Findings

We report the biochemical activity of E6 proteins from 27 HPV types representing all alpha-HPV species groups to degrade p53 in human cells. Expression of E6 from all HPV types epidemiologically classified as group 1 carcinogens significantly reduced p53 levels. However, several types not associated with cancer (e.g., HPV53, HPV70 and HPV71) were equally active in degrading p53. HPV types within species groups alpha 5, 6, 7, 9 and 11 share a most recent common ancestor (MRCA) and all contain E6 ORFs that degrade p53. A unique exception, HPV71 E6 ORF that degraded p53 was outside this clade and is one of the most prevalent HPV types infecting the cervix in a population-based study of 10,000 women. Alignment of E6 ORFs identified an amino acid site that was highly correlated with the biochemical ability to degrade p53. Alteration of this amino acid in HPV71 E6 abrogated its ability to degrade p53, while alteration of this site in HPV71-related HPV90 and HPV106 E6s enhanced their capacity to degrade p53.

Conclusions

These data suggest that the alpha-HPV E6 proteins' ability to degrade p53 is an evolved phenotype inherited from a most recent common ancestor of the high-risk species that does not always segregate with carcinogenicity. In addition, we identified an amino-acid residue strongly correlated with viral p53 degrading potential.

CLLD8/KMT1F is a lysine methyltransferase that is important for chromosome segregation

Proteins bearing a SET domain have been shown to methylate lysine residues in histones and contribute to chromatin architecture. Methylation of histone H3 at lysine 9 (H3K9) has emerged as an important player in the formation of heterochromatin, chromatin condensation, and transcriptional repression. Here, we have characterized a previously undescribed member of the histone H3K9 methyltransferase family named CLLD8 (or SETDB2 or KMT1F). This protein contributes to the trimethylation of both interspersed repetitive elements and centromere-associated repeats and participates in the recruitment of heterochromatin protein 1 to centromeres. Consistently, depletion in CLLD8/KMT1F coincides with a loss of CENP proteins and delayed mitosis, suggesting that this protein participates in chromosome condensation and segregation. Altogether, our results provide evidence that CLLD8/KMT1F is recruited to heterochromatin regions and contributes in vivo to the deposition of trimethyl marks in concert with SUV39H1/KMT1A.

E6 proteins from diverse papillomaviruses self-associate both in vitro and in vivo

Papillomavirus E6 oncoproteins bind and often provoke the degradation of many cellular proteins important for the control of cell proliferation and/or cell death. Structural studies on E6 proteins have long been hindered by the difficulties of obtaining highly concentrated samples of recombinant E6. Here, we show that recombinant E6 proteins from eight human papillomavirus strains and one bovine papillomavirus strain exist as oligomeric and multimeric species. These species were characterized using a variety of biochemical and biophysical techniques, including analytical gel filtration, activity assays, surface plasmon resonance, electron microscopy and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The characterization of E6 oligomers is facilitated by the fusion to the maltose binding protein, which slows the formation of higher-order multimeric species. The proportion of each oligomeric form varies depending on the viral strain considered. Oligomers appear to consist of folded units, which, in the case of high-risk mucosal human papillomavirus E6, retain binding to the ubiquitin ligase E6-associated protein and the capacity to degrade the proapoptotic protein p53. In addition to the small-size oligomers, E6 proteins spontaneously assemble into large organized multimeric structures, a process that is accompanied by a significant increase in the beta-sheet secondary structure content. Finally, co-localisation experiments using E6 equipped with different tags further demonstrate the occurrence of E6 self-association in eukaryotic cells. The ensemble of these data suggests that self-association is a general property of E6 proteins that occurs both in vitro and in vivo and might therefore be functionally relevant.

Structural and functional analysis of E6 oncoprotein: insights in the molecular pathways of human papillomavirus-mediated pathogenesis

Oncoprotein E6 is essential for oncogenesis induced by human papillomaviruses (HPVs). The solution structure of HPV16-E6 C-terminal domain reveals a zinc binding fold. A model of full-length E6 is proposed and analyzed in the context of HPV evolution. E6 appears as a chameleon protein combining a conserved structural scaffold with highly variable surfaces participating in generic or specialized HPV functions. We investigated surface residues involved in two specialized activities of high-risk genital HPV E6: p53 tumor suppressor degradation and nucleic acid binding. Screening of E6 surface mutants identified an in vivo p53 degradation-defective mutant that fails to recruit p53 to ubiquitin ligase E6AP and restores high p53 levels in cervical carcinoma cells by competing with endogeneous E6. We also mapped the nucleic acid binding surface of E6, the positive potential of which correlates with genital oncogenicity. E6 structure-function analysis provides new clues for understanding and counteracting the complex pathways of HPV-mediated pathogenesis.

siRNA targeting of the viral E6 oncogene efficiently kills human papillomavirus-positive cancer cells

The targeted inhibition of antiapoptotic factors in tumour cells may provide a rational approach towards the development of novel anticancer therapies. Using human papillomavirus (HPV)-transformed cells as a model system, we investigated if RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated gene silencing can be employed in order to overcome the apoptosis resistance of cancer cells. We found that both vector-borne and synthetic small interfering (si)RNAs, specifically directed against the antiapoptotic HPV E6 oncogene, restored dormant tumour suppressor pathways in HPV-positive cancer cells that are otherwise inactive in the presence of E6. This ultimately resulted in massive apoptotic cell death, selectively in HPV-positive tumour cells. These findings show that RNAi provides a powerful molecular strategy to inactivate intracellular E6 function efficiently. Moreover, they define E6 as a most promising therapeutic target to eliminate HPV-positive tumour cells specifically by RNAi. Thus, by sequence-specific targeting of antiapoptotic genes, siRNAs may be developed into novel therapeutics that can efficiently correct the apoptosis deficiency of cancer cells.

Domain substructure of HPV E6 oncoprotein: biophysical characterization of the E6 C-terminal DNA-binding domain

E6 is a viral oncoprotein implicated in cervical cancers, produced by high-risk human papillomaviruses (HPVs). Structural data concerning this protein are scarce due to the difficulty of producing recombinant E6. Recently, we described the expression and purification of a stable, folded, and biologically active HPV16 E6 mutant called E6 6C/6S. Here, we analyzed the domain substructure of this mutated E6. Nonspecific proteolysis of full-length E6 6C/6S (158 residues) yielded N-terminal and C-terminal fragments encompassing residues 7-83 and 87-158, respectively. The C-terminal fragment of residues 87-158 was cloned, overexpressed, and purified at concentrations as high as 1 mM. The purified domain retains the selective four-way DNA junction recognition activity of the full-length E6 protein. Using UV absorption, UV fluorescence, circular dichroism, and nuclear magnetic resonance, we show that the peptide is primarily monomeric and folded with equal proportions of alpha-helix and beta-sheet secondary structure.

Protein mutagenesis with monodispersity-based quality probing: selective inactivation of p53 degradation and DNA-binding properties of HPV E6 oncoprotein

Interpretation of protein mutagenesis experiments requires the ability to distinguish functionally relevant mutations from mutations affecting the structure. When a protein is expressed soluble in bacteria, properly folded mutants are expected to remain soluble whereas misfolded mutants should form insoluble aggregates. However, this rule may fail for proteins fused to highly soluble carrier proteins. In a previous study, we analysed the biophysical status of HPV oncoprotein E6 fused to the C-terminus of maltose-binding protein (MBP) and found that misfolded E6 moieties fused to MBP formed soluble aggregates of high molecular weight. By contrast, preparations of properly folded E6 fused to MBP were monodisperse. Here, we have used this finding to evaluate the quality of 19 MBP-fused E6 site-directed mutants by using a light scattering assay performed in a fluorimeter. This assay guided us to rule out structurally defective mutants and to obtain functionally relevant E6 mutants selectively altered for two molecular activities: degradation of tumour suppressor p53 and DNA recognition.

Formation of soluble inclusion bodies by hpv e6 oncoprotein fused to maltose-binding protein

Many polypeptides overexpressed in bacteria are produced misfolded and accumulate as solid structures called inclusion bodies. Inclusion-body-prone proteins have often been reported to escape precipitation when fused to maltose-binding protein (MBP). Here, we have examined the case of HPV 16 oncoprotein E6. The unfused sequence of E6 is overexpressed as inclusion bodies in bacteria. By contrast, fusions of E6 to the C-terminus of MBP are produced soluble. We have analyzed preparations of soluble MBP-E6 fusions by using three independent approaches: dynamic light scattering, lateral turbidimetry, and sandwich ELISA. All three methods showed that MBP-E6 preparations contain highly aggregated material. The behavior of these soluble aggregates under denaturating conditions suggests that they are formed by agglomeration of misfolded E6 moieties. However, precipitation is prevented by the presence of the folded and highly soluble MBP moieties, which maintain the aggregates in solution. Therefore, the fact that a protein or protein domain is produced soluble when fused to the C-terminus of a carrier protein does not guarantee that the protein of interest is properly folded and active. We suggest that aggregation of fusion proteins should be systematically assayed, especially when these fusions are to be used for binding measurements or activity tests.

A strategy for optimizing the monodispersity of fusion proteins: application to purification of recombinant HPV E6 oncoprotein

Recombinant production of HPV oncoprotein E6 is notoriously difficult. The unfused sequence is produced in inclusion bodies. By contrast, fusions of E6 to the C-terminus of carrier proteins such as maltose-binding protein or glutathione-S-transferase are produced soluble. However, it has not yet been possible to purify E6 protein from such fusion constructs. Here, we show that this was due to the biophysical heterogeneity of the fusion preparations. We find that soluble MBP-E6 preparations contain two subpopulations. A major fraction is aggregated and contains exclusively misfolded E6 moieties ('soluble inclusion bodies'). A minor fraction is monodisperse and contains the properly folded E6 moieties. Using monodispersity as a screening criterion, we optimized the expression conditions, the purification process and the sequence of E6, finally obtaining stable monodisperse MBP-E6 preparations. In contrast to aggregated MBP-E6, these preparations yielded fully soluble E6 after proteolytic removal of MBP. Once purified, these E6 proteins are stable, folded and biologically active. The first biophysical measurements on pure E6 were performed. This work shows that solubility is not a sufficient criterion to check that the passenger protein in a fusion construct is properly folded and active. By contrast, monodispersity appears as a better quality criterion. The monodispersity-based strategy presented here constitutes a general method to prepare fusion proteins with optimized folding and biological activity.

Specific recognition of four-way DNA junctions by the C-terminal zinc-binding domain of HPV oncoprotein E6

E6 is an oncoprotein implicated in cervical cancers produced by " high risk " human papillomaviruses. E6 binds specifically to several cellular proteins, including the tumour suppressor p53 and the ubiquitin ligase E6-AP. However, E6 is also a DNA-binding protein which recognizes a structural motive present in four-way junctions. Here, we demonstrate that the C-terminal zinc-binding domain of E6, expressed separately from the rest of the protein, fully retains the selective four-way junction recognition activity. The domain can bind to two identical and independent sites on a single junction, whereas full-length E6 can only bind to one site. The junction bound to either one or two domains adopts an extended square conformation. These results allow us to assign the structure-dependent DNA recognition activity of E6 to its C-terminal domain, which therefore represents a new class of zinc-stabilized DNA-binding module. Comparison with the binding characteristics of other junction-specific proteins enlightens the rules which govern protein-induced deformation of four-way DNA junctions.

HPV oncoprotein E6 is a structure-dependent DNA-binding protein that recognizes four-way junctions

E6 is an oncoprotein implicated in cervical cancers, produced by "high-risk" human papillomaviruses. E6 is thought to promote tumorigenesis by stimulating cellular degradation of the tumour suppressor p53, but it might display other activities. Sequence similarity was recently detected between E6 and endonuclease VII, a protein of phage T4 that recognizes and cleaves four-way DNA junctions. Here, we purified recombinant E6 proteins and demonstrated that high-risk E6 s bind selectively to four-way junctions in a structure-dependent manner. Several residues in the C-terminal zinc-binding domain, the region of E6 similar to endonuclease VII, are necessary for the junction-binding activity. E6 binds to the junction as a monomer. Comparative electrophoresis shows that E6-bound junctions migrate in an extended square conformation. Magnesium inhibits the electrophoretic migration of the complexes but does not seem to influence their formation at equilibrium. This work is the first demonstration of specific binding of purified active E6 to a well-characterized DNA ligand, and suggests new modes of action of E6 in oncogenesis.