Increased FGF8 signaling promotes chondrogenic rather than osteogenic development in the embryonic skull

The bones of the cranial vault are formed directly from mesenchymal cells through intramembranous ossification rather than via a cartilage intermediate. Formation and growth of the skull bones involves the interaction of multiple cell-cell signaling pathways, with fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) and their receptors exerting a prominent influence. Mutations within the FGF signaling pathway are the most frequent cause of craniosynostosis, which is a common human craniofacial developmental abnormality characterized by the premature fusion of the cranial sutures. Here, we have developed new mouse models to investigate how different levels of increased FGF signaling can affect the formation of the calvarial bones and associated sutures. Whereas moderate Fgf8 overexpression resulted in delayed ossification followed by craniosynostosis of the coronal suture, higher Fgf8 levels promoted a loss of ossification and favored cartilage over bone formation across the skull. By contrast, endochondral bones were still able to form and ossify in the presence of increased levels of Fgf8, although the growth and mineralization of these bones were affected to varying extents. Expression analysis demonstrated that abnormal skull chondrogenesis was accompanied by changes in the genes required for Wnt signaling. Moreover, further analysis indicated that the pathology was associated with decreased Wnt signaling, as the reduction in ossification could be partially rescued by halving Axin2 gene dosage. Taken together, these findings indicate that mesenchymal cells of the skull are not fated to form bone, but can be forced into a chondrogenic fate through the manipulation of FGF8 signaling. These results have implications for evolution of the different methods of ossification as well as for therapeutic intervention in craniosynostosis.

A morpholino-based screen to identify novel genes involved in craniofacial morphogenesis

BACKGROUND

The regulatory mechanisms underpinning facial development are conserved between diverse species. Therefore, results from model systems provide insight into the genetic causes of human craniofacial defects. Previously, we generated a comprehensive dataset examining gene expression during development and fusion of the mouse facial prominences. Here, we used this resource to identify genes that have dynamic expression patterns in the facial prominences, but for which only limited information exists concerning developmental function.

RESULTS

This set of ∼80 genes was used for a high-throughput functional analysis in the zebrafish system using Morpholino gene knockdown technology. This screen revealed three classes of cranial cartilage phenotypes depending upon whether knockdown of the gene affected the neurocranium, viscerocranium, or both. The targeted genes that produced consistent phenotypes encoded proteins linked to transcription (meis1, meis2a, tshz2, vgll4l), signaling (pkdcc, vlk, macc1, wu:fb16h09), and extracellular matrix function (smoc2). The majority of these phenotypes were not altered by reduction of p53 levels, demonstrating that both p53-dependent and -independent mechanisms were involved in the craniofacial abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

This Morpholino-based screen highlights new genes involved in development of the zebrafish craniofacial skeleton with wider relevance to formation of the face in other species, particularly mouse and human.

Vgll2a is required for neural crest cell survival during zebrafish craniofacial development

Invertebrate and vertebrate vestigial (vg) and vestigial-like (VGLL) genes are involved in embryonic patterning and cell fate determination. These genes encode cofactors that interact with members of the Scalloped/TEAD family of transcription factors and modulate their activity. We have previously shown that, in mice, Vgll2 is differentially expressed in the developing facial prominences. In this study, we show that the zebrafish ortholog vgll2a is expressed in the pharyngeal endoderm and ectoderm surrounding the neural crest derived mesenchyme of the pharyngeal arches. Moreover, both the FGF and retinoic acid (RA) signaling pathways, which are critical components of the hierarchy controlling craniofacial patterning, regulate this domain of vgll2a expression. Consistent with these observations, vgll2a is required within the pharyngeal endoderm for NCC survival and pharyngeal cartilage development. Specifically, knockdown of Vgll2a in zebrafish embryos using Morpholino injection results in increased cell death within the pharyngeal arches, aberrant endodermal pouch morphogenesis, and hypoplastic cranial cartilages. Overall, our data reveal a novel non-cell autonomous role for Vgll2a in development of the NCC-derived vertebrate craniofacial skeleton.

The role of the C-terminal extension (CTE) of the estrogen receptor alpha and beta DNA binding domain in DNA binding and interaction with HMGB

HMGB-1/-2 are coregulatory proteins that facilitate the DNA binding and transcriptional activity of steroid receptor members of the nuclear receptor family of transcription factors. We investigated the influence and mechanism of action of HMGB-1/-2 (formerly known as HMG-1/-2) on estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) and ERbeta. Both ER subtypes were responsive to HMGB-1/-2 with respect to enhancement of receptor DNA binding affinity and transcriptional activity in cells. Responsiveness to HMGB-1/-2 was dependent on the C-terminal extension (CTE) region of the ER DNA binding domain (DBD) and correlated with a direct protein interaction between HMGB-1/-2 and the CTE. Thus the previously reported higher DNA binding affinity and transcription activity of ERalpha as compared with ERbeta is not due to a lack of ERbeta interaction with HMGB-1/-2. Using chimeric receptor DBDs, the higher intrinsic DNA binding affinity of ERalpha than ERbeta was shown to be due to a unique property of the ERalpha CTE, independent of HMGB-1/-2. The CTE of both ER subtypes was also shown to be required for interaction with ERE half-sites. These studies reveal the importance of the CTE and HMGB-1/-2 for ERalpha and ERbeta interaction with their cognate target DNAs.

The C-terminal extension (CTE) of the nuclear hormone receptor DNA binding domain determines interactions and functional response to the HMGB-1/-2 co-regulatory proteins

Previously, we and others reported that the high mobility group proteins, HMGB-1/-2, enhance DNA binding in vitro and transactivation in situ by the steroid hormone subgroup of nuclear receptors but did not influence these functions of class II receptors. We show here that the DNA binding domain (DBD) is sufficient to account for the selective influence of HMGB-1/-2 on the steroid class of receptors. Furthermore, the use of chimeric DBDs reveals that this selectivity is dependent on the C-terminal extension (CTE), amino acid sequences adjacent to the zinc finger core DBD. HMGB-1/-2 interact directly with the DBDs of steroid but not class II receptors, and this interaction requires the CTE. This in vitro interaction correlates with a requirement of the CTE for maximal HMGB-1/-2 enhancement of DNA binding in vitro and transcriptional activation in cells. Finally, class II receptor DBDs have a much higher intrinsic affinity for DNA than steroid receptor DBDs, and this affinity difference is also dependent on the CTE. These results reveal the importance of the steroid receptor CTE for DNA binding affinity and functional response to HMGB-1/-2.

Coregulatory proteins in steroid hormone receptor action: the role of chromatin high mobility group proteins HMG-1 and -2

To directly activate specific gene expression, the progesterone receptor must bind to specific hormone response elements in target promoters. We have previously reported that progesterone receptor requires a nuclear factor, high mobility group 1 or 2 (HMG-1/-2) for high-affinity interaction with DNA in vitro and for full transcriptional activity in vivo. We have also observed that HMG-1/-2 selectively influences the activity of the steroid hormone class of nuclear receptors but does not affect other classes of nuclear receptors. This report is a summary of our published and unpublished studies to determine the effects of HMG-1/-2 on a broad range of nuclear receptor supergene family members and to define the mechanism for the specific effect of HMG-1/-2 on the steroid class of receptors. Our studies and available structural data suggest a model where the DNA binding domains of nonsteroid nuclear receptors contain a minor groove DNA interface, termed the C-terminal extension, that contributes to high-affinity DNA binding. Steroid receptors lack such a minor groove interface and therefore require an additional protein, HMG-1/-2, that functionally substitutes for the C-terminal extension to facilitate high-affinity interactions with DNA.