[Maternal mortality, adequation of care and preventability, France 2016-2018]

OBJECTIVE

To describe, for the 2016-2018 period, the adequacy of care provided to women who died of maternal death in France, as well as the possible preventability of these deaths.

METHOD

National data from the Enquête Nationale Confidentielle sur les Morts Maternelles for 2016-2018. For each maternal death identified, the National Expert Committee on Maternal Mortality (CNEMM) assesses the adequacy of the care provided and whether the death was probably, possibly or not preventable.

RESULTS

For 2016-2018, 272 maternal deaths (considered up to 1 year after the end of pregnancy) occurred in France. Of these, 265 had sufficient information collected by the confidential survey and could be assessed by the CNEMM. In total, care was judged to be "sub-optimal" for 66% of deaths assessed for all causes, a proportion similar to that for previous periods. In addition to the obstetric and anaesthetic care provided at the time of the acute complication, which was judged to be sub-optimal for 45% (obstetric care) and 38% (anaesthetic care) of maternal deaths, this report highlights the scope for improvement in other types of care, more related to prevention and screening: "sub-optimal" preconception care for 51% of the women who died for whom it was justified, particularly notable for deaths linked to a preexisting condition (52%) and for suicides (67%); prenatal surveillance judged to be "sub-optimal" in 30% of cases, a sub-optimality also more frequent among deaths linked to a preexisting condition (35%) and suicides (34%). In all, 59.7% of maternal deaths assessed were judged to be "probably" (17%) or "possibly" (42.7%) preventable, a profile that remained stable. Suicide and other psychiatric causes, the leading cause of maternal death, were considered to be potentially preventable in 79% of cases. Deaths from haemorrhage remained largely preventable (95%, the highest proportion by cause). The factor most often implicated was inadequate care, and preventability linked to this factor was identified in 53% of deaths, all causes combined. Gap in organization of care was a preventability factor identified in 24% of deaths, and poor interaction between the woman and the healthcare system in 22% of deaths.

CONCLUSION

This proportion of more than half of potentially preventable maternal deaths shows that a reduction in maternal mortality in France is still possible and must be achieved, the objective being to prevent all preventable deaths. Analysis of the factors involved, overall and by cause of death, suggests areas for improvement.

[Maternal Mortality, Frequency, causes, women's profile and preventability of deaths in France, 2013-2015]

OBJECTIVE

To describe, for the 2013-2015 period, the frequency, causes, risk factors, adequacy of care and preventability of maternal deaths in France.

METHOD

Data from the National Confidential Enquiry into Maternal Deaths for 2013-2015.

RESULTS

For the period 2013-2015, 262 maternal deaths occurred in France, one every four days, i.e a maternal mortality ratio of 10.8 per 100,000 live births (95 % CI 9.5-12.1), stable compared to 2010-2012. Compared to women aged 25-29, the risk is multiplied by 1.9 for women aged 30-34, by 3 for women aged 35-39 and by 4 for women aged 40 and over. Obese women are twice as frequent among maternal deaths (24 %) than in the general population of parturients (11 %). There are territorial disparities - the maternal mortality ratio in the French overseas departments is 4 times higher than in metropolitan France -, and social disparities - the mortality of migrant women remains higher than that of women born in France, particularly for women born in sub-Saharan Africa whose risk is 2.5 times higher than that native women. A striking result of the 2013-2015 period is the preponderance of suicides and cardiovascular diseases, the two leading causes of maternal mortality, each responsible for approximately one death per month. These two etiologies are not only the most frequent, but also among those with the highest proportion of preventable deaths, 91.3 % and 65.7 % respectively. Another important result is the continued decrease in mortality from obstetric haemorrhage, halved in 15 years, particularly the decrease n hemorrhages due to uterine atony. Overall, 57.8 % of maternal deaths are considered probably or possibly preventable and in 66 % of cases, the care provided was not optimal.

CONCLUSION

While the overall maternal mortality ratio remains stable overall, and territorial and social inequalities unchanged, the profile of the causes of maternal mortality is changing. Some developments are a success, such as the continued decrease in maternal mortality due to haemorrhage, the result of the general mobilisation of health actors on this issue. Others point to new priorities for mobilisation, in particular on the mental and cardiovascular health of women during pregnancy or in the year following childbirth. In order to go further in understanding the mechanisms involved, and to identify precise avenues for prevention, it is necessary to analyse in detail the stories of each maternal death in order to identify the opportunities for improvement repeatedly found in the series of deaths. This is what the following articles in this issue propose, with an analysis by cause of death.

[Epidemiology of maternal mortality in France, 2010-2012]

OBJECTIVE

To describe, for the period 2010-2012, the frequency, the causes, the risk factors, the adequacy of care and the avoidability of maternal deaths in France.

METHOD

Data from the National Confidential Enquiry into Maternal Deaths for 2010-2012.

RESULTS

For the period 2010-2012, 256 maternal deaths occurred in France, a maternal mortality ratio of 10.3 per 100,000 live births (95% CI: 9.1-11.7), stable compared to 2007-2009. Compared to women aged 25-29, the risk is multiplied by 2.4 for women aged 35-39, and by 3 for women over 40 years. There are territorial disparities: 1 out of 7 maternal deaths occurs in the French overseas departments, and the maternal mortality ratio in those departments is 4 times that of metropolitan, France; and social disparities: the mortality of migrant women remains 2.5 times higher than that of women born in France, particularly for women born in sub-Saharan Africa whose RMM is 3.5 times that native women. A major finding is the 1/3 decrease in direct maternal mortality over the last 10 years, mainly due to for the first time the statistically significant decrease in mortality from obstetric hemorrhage, the frequency of which was divided by 2 in 10 years. However, almost all of the remaining deaths from hemorrhage are considered preventable and this is still the leading cause of maternal mortality in France (11% of deaths). Overall, 56% of these maternal deaths are considered "avoidable" or "possibly avoidable" and in 59% of cases the care provided was not optimal.

CONCLUSION

Direct maternal mortality and in particular maternal mortality from hemorrhage has decreased significantly over the past 10 years, indicating improved obstetric care. However, territorial and social inequalities persist, and the majority of deaths remain preventable, which shows that the identification of opportunities for improvement must continue. To go even further in understanding the mechanisms involved, and to identify precise avenues of prevention, it is necessary to analyze in detail the stories of each maternal death in order to identify the repetitive elements in the series of deaths. This is what the following articles in this issue propose, with an analysis by cause of death, according to the idea that the same cause produces the same effects.

[Analysis of the evitability of intrapartum asphyxia with a peers review]

OBJECTIVE

To assess the quality of intrapartum care in birth asphyxia cases.

METHODS

Prospective analysis of all cases of birth asphyxia in nine maternity units during one year (2010). Birth asphyxia was defined as the combination of at least one clinical factor (Apgar≤7 at 5 minutes, signs of encephalopathy at birth) and at least one biological factor in cord (pH≤7, BD≥12 mmol/L, lactates>10 mmol/L). These cases were analyzed with a peer review from French guidelines 2007.

RESULTS

Fifty cases of birth asphyxia were identified. After peer-review, they were defined as 46% non preventable, 27% possibly preventable, 24% definitely preventable and 3% not established. The main causes have been described as (i) misinterpretation of CTG during the first and second stages of labour, (ii) delayed response time to CTG anomalies and (iii) prolonged second stage.

CONCLUSION

In half of the cases of birth asphyxia, this dreaded event was considered as preventable by a group of peers.