Type II odontoid fractures in the elderly presenting to the emergency department: an assessment of factors affecting in-hospital mortality and discharge to skilled nursing facilities

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Type II odontoid fractures (OF) are among the most common cervical spine injuries in the geriatric population. However, there is a paucity of literature regarding their epidemiology. Additionally, the optimal management of these injuries remains controversial, and no study has evaluated the short-term outcomes of geriatric patients presenting to emergency departments (ED).

PURPOSE

This study aims to document the epidemiology of geriatric patients presenting to EDs with type II OFs and determine whether surgical management was associated with early adverse outcomes such as in-hospital mortality and discharge to skilled nursing facilities (SNF).

STUDY DESIGN

This is a retrospective cohort study.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Data was used from the 2016-2020 Nationwide Emergency Department Sample. Patient encounters corresponding to type II OFs were identified. Patients younger than 65 at the time of presentation to the ED and those with concomitant spinal pathology were excluded.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The association between the surgical management of geriatric type II OFs and outcomes such as in-hospital mortality and discharge to SNFs.

METHODS

Patient, fracture, and surgical management characteristics were recorded. A propensity score matched cohort was constructed to reduce differences in age, comorbidities, and injury severity between patients undergoing operative and nonoperative management. Additionally, to develop a positive control for the analysis of geriatric patients with type II OFs and no other concomitant spinal pathology, a cohort of patients that had been excluded due to the presence of a concomitant spinal cord injury (SCI) was also constructed. Multivariate regressions were then performed on both the matched and unmatched cohorts to ascertain the associations between surgical treatment and in-hospital mortality, inpatient length of stay, encounter charges, and discharge to SNFs.

RESULTS

A total of 11,325 encounters were included. The mean total charge per encounter was $60,221. 634 (5.6%) patients passed away during their encounters. In total, 1,005 (8.9%) patients were managed surgically. Surgical management of type II OFs was associated with a 316% increase in visit charge (95% CI: 291%-341%, p<.001), increased inpatient length of stay (IRR: 2.87, 95% CI: 2.62-3.12, p<.001), and increased likelihood of discharge to SNFs (OR=2.62, 95% CI: 2.26-3.05, p<.001), but decreased in-hospital mortality (OR=0.32, CI: 0.21-0.45, p<.001). The propensity score matched cohort consisted of 2,010 patients, matching each of the 1,005 that underwent surgery to 1,005 that did not. These cohorts were well balanced across age (78.24 vs 77.91 years), Elixhauser Comorbidity Index (3.68 vs 3.71), and Injury Severity Score (30.15 vs 28.93). This matching did not meaningfully alter the associations determined between surgical management and in-hospital mortality (OR=0.34, CI=0.21-0.55, p<.001) or SNF discharge (OR=2.59, CI=2.13-3.16, p<.001). Lastly, the positive control cohort of patients with concurrent SCI had higher rates of SNF discharge (50.0% vs 42.6%, p<.001), surgical management (32.3% vs 9.7%, p<.001), and in-hospital mortality (28.9% vs 5.6%, p<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This study lends insight into the epidemiology of geriatric type II OFs and quantifies risk factors influencing adverse outcomes. Patient informed consent should include a discussion of the protective association between definitive surgical management and in-hospital mortality against potential operative morbidity, increased lengths of hospital stay, and increased likelihood of discharge to SNFs. This information may impact patient treatment selection and decision making.

Treatment of the dens fractures in children

The anatomical and biomechanical features of the immature cervical spine make the upper segments at C1-3 especially susceptible to injury.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

From 2000 to 2016, 10 patients (3 boys, 7 girls) with C2 dens fractures were treated. The average age of each child was 11 years (3-17). According to the Anderson classification, there were 6 patients with a type III fracture and 4 with a type II. 4 patients were treated conservatively using the Minerva cervical brace for 75 days (66-125) and 6 patients by means of the Halo-Vest for 79 days (64-87) and followed by the Schantz collar for 17 days (2-35).

RESULTS

The follow up lasted 78 months (12-180). The NDI (Neck Disability Index) score was calculated for each patient, except for section 8 (driving the car). The scores ranged from 1/45 (2.22%) to 20/45 (44.44%). The mean score for 9 out of the 10 patients (one patient died) was 4.77 (10.61%).

CONCLUSION

The C2 dens fracture is a rare injury in children. The classification system of dens fractures developed by Anderson is useful in choosing the mode of treatment of dens fractures.

Elderly patients are at increased risk for mortality undergoing surgical repair of dens fractures

OBJECTIVE

Dens fractures are common cervical injuries in advanced aged patients. The presented study was undertaken to analyze the clinical results and risks of surgically treated patients with dens fractures over 70 years.

METHODS

Data of 28 patients (17 female, 11 male) over 70 years treated from September 2004 to October 2009 were recorded. Clinical and radiological parameters were obtained including type of fracture, associated cervical and/or other injuries, comorbidities, symptoms, neurological condition, surgical strategy, postoperative course and complications.

RESULTS

89% were in a good neurological condition before surgery (ASIA E or D). In most cases, surgery was performed at an early stage after trauma (21 patients within 5 days). Ventral screw fixation was the preferred surgical strategy (64%). A slight worsening of neurological functions immediately after operation was only seen in one patient. Five patients died in the early and 2 in the late postoperative course which means a treatment mortality of 25%. Among the surviving patients two had general medical complications.

CONCLUSION

Type II dens fractures are a common fracture of elderly patients. Our results are good concerning the neurological functions. Surgical and general medical complications were acceptable. However, the study also underlines that mortality rate is high and therefore treatment options should be well-considered in this high risk group.