Mutation of Phenylalanine 23 of Newcastle Disease Virus Matrix Protein Inhibits Virus Release by Disrupting the Interaction between the FPIV L-Domain and Charged Multivesicular Body Protein 4B

The matrix (M) protein FPIV L-domain is conserved among multiple paramyxoviruses; however, its function and the associated mechanism remain unclear. In this study, the paramyxovirus Newcastle disease virus (NDV) was employed to study the FPIV L-domain. Two recombinant NDV strains, each carrying a single amino acid mutation at the Phe (F23) or Pro (P24) site of ²³FPIV/I²⁶ L-domain, were rescued. Growth defects were observed in only the recombinant SG10-F23A (rSG10-F23A) strain. Subsequent studies focused on rSG10-F23A revealed that the virulence, pathogenicity, and replication ability of this strain were all weaker than those of wild-type strain rSG10 and that a budding deficiency contributed to those weaknesses. To uncover the molecular mechanism underlying the rSG10-F23A budding deficiency, the bridging proteins between the FPIV L-domain and endosomal sorting complex required for transported (ESCRT) machinery were explored. Among 17 candidate proteins, only the charged multivesicular body protein 4 (CHMP4) paralogues were found to interact more strongly with the NDV wild-type M protein (M-WT) than with the mutated M protein (M-F23A). Overexpression of M-WT, but not of M-F23A, changed the CHMP4 subcellular location to the NDV budding site. Furthermore, a knockdown of CHMP4B, the most abundant CHMP4 protein, inhibited the release of rSG10 but not that of rSG10-F23A. From these findings, we can reasonably infer that the F23A mutation of the FPIV L-domain blocks the interaction between the NDV M protein and CHMP4B and that this contributes to the budding deficiency and consequent growth defects of rSG10-F23A. This work lays the foundation for further study of the FPIV L-domain in NDV and other paramyxoviruses. IMPORTANCE Multiple viruses utilize a conserved motif, termed the L-domain, to act as a cellular adaptor for recruiting host ESCRT machinery to their budding site. Despite the FPIV type L-domain having been identified in some paramyxoviruses 2 decades ago, its function in virus life cycles and its method of recruiting the ESCRT machinery are poorly understood. In this study, a single amino acid mutation at the F23 site of the ²³FPIV²⁶ L-domain was found to block NDV budding at the late stage. Furthermore, CHMP4B, a core component of the ESCRT-III complex, was identified as a main factor that links the FPIV L-domain and ESCRT machinery together. These results extend previous understanding of the FPIV L-domain and, therefore, not only provide a new approach for attenuating NDV and other paramyxoviruses but also lay the foundation for further study of the FPIV L-domain.

Importance of Viral Late Domains in Budding and Release of Enveloped RNA Viruses

Late assembly (L) domains are conserved sequences that are necessary for the late steps of viral replication, acting like cellular adaptors to engage the ESCRT membrane fission machinery that promote virion release. These short sequences, whose mutation or deletion produce the accumulation of immature virions at the plasma membrane, were firstly identified within retroviral Gag precursors, and in a further step, also in structural proteins of many other enveloped RNA viruses including arenaviruses, filoviruses, rhabdoviruses, reoviruses, and paramyxoviruses. Three classes of L domains have been identified thus far (PT/SAP, YPXnL/LXXLF, and PPxY), even if it has recently been suggested that other motifs could act as L domains. Here, we summarize the current state of knowledge of the different types of L domains and their cellular partners in the budding events of RNA viruses, with a particular focus on retroviruses.

Post-ER degradation of misfolded GPI-anchored proteins is linked with microautophagy

Glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored proteins (GPI-APs) are membrane-conjugated cell-surface proteins with diverse structural, developmental, and signaling functions and clinical relevance. Typically, after biosynthesis and attachment to the preassembled GPI anchor, GPI-APs rapidly leave the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and rely on post-ER quality control. Terminally misfolded GPI-APs end up inside the vacuole/lysosome for degradation, but their trafficking itinerary to this organelle and the processes linked to their uptake by the vacuole/lysosome remain uncharacterized. In a yeast mutant that is lacking Pep4, a key vacuolar protease, several misfolded model GPI-APs accumulated in the vacuolar membrane. In the same mutant, macroautophagy and the multi-vesicular body (MVB) pathway were intact, hinting at a hitherto-unknown trafficking pathway for the degradation of misfolded GPI-APs. To unravel it, we used a genome-wide screen coupled to high-throughput fluorescence microscopy and followed the fate of the misfolded GPI-AP: Gas1^∗. We found that components of the early secretory and endocytic pathways are involved in its targeting to the vacuole and that vacuolar transporter chaperones (VTCs), with roles in microautophagy, negatively affect the vacuolar uptake of Gas1^∗. In support, we demonstrate that Gas1^∗ internalizes from vacuolar membranes into membrane-bound intravacuolar vesicles prior to degradation. Our data link post-ER degradation with microautophagy.

Protein Sumoylation Is Crucial for Phagocytosis in Entamoeba histolytica Trophozoites

Posttranslational modifications provide Entamoeba histolytica proteins the timing and signaling to intervene during different processes, such as phagocytosis. However, SUMOylation has not been studied in E. histolytica yet. Here, we characterized the E. histolytica SUMO gene, its product (EhSUMO), and the relevance of SUMOylation in phagocytosis. Our results indicated that EhSUMO has an extended N-terminus that differentiates SUMO from ubiquitin. It also presents the GG residues at the C-terminus and the ΨKXE/D binding motif, both involved in target protein contact. Additionally, the E. histolytica genome possesses the enzymes belonging to the SUMOylation-deSUMOylation machinery. Confocal microscopy assays disclosed a remarkable EhSUMO membrane activity with convoluted and changing structures in trophozoites during erythrophagocytosis. SUMOylated proteins appeared in pseudopodia, phagocytic channels, and around the adhered and ingested erythrocytes. Docking analysis predicted interaction of EhSUMO with EhADH (an ALIX family protein), and immunoprecipitation and immunofluorescence assays revealed that the association increased during phagocytosis; whereas the EhVps32 (a protein of the ESCRT-III complex)-EhSUMO interaction appeared stronger since basal conditions. In EhSUMO knocked-down trophozoites, the bizarre membranous structures disappeared, and EhSUMO interaction with EhADH and EhVps32 diminished. Our results evidenced the presence of a SUMO gene in E. histolytica and the SUMOylation relevance during phagocytosis. This is supported by bioinformatics screening of many other proteins of E. histolytica involved in phagocytosis, which present putative SUMOylation sites and the ΨKXE/D binding motif.

Microautophagy - distinct molecular mechanisms handle cargoes of many sizes

Autophagy is fundamental for cell and organismal health. Two types of autophagy are conserved in eukaryotes: macroautophagy and microautophagy. During macroautophagy, autophagosomes deliver cytoplasmic constituents to endosomes or lysosomes, whereas during microautophagy lytic organelles take up cytoplasm directly. While macroautophagy has been investigated extensively, microautophagy has received much less attention. Nonetheless, it has become clear that microautophagy has a broad range of functions in biosynthetic transport, metabolic adaptation, organelle remodeling and quality control. This Review discusses the selective and non-selective microautophagic processes known in yeast, plants and animals. Based on the molecular mechanisms for the uptake of microautophagic cargo into lytic organelles, I propose to distinguish between fission-type microautophagy, which depends on ESCRT proteins, and fusion-type microautophagy, which requires the core autophagy machinery and SNARE proteins. Many questions remain to be explored, but the functional versatility and mechanistic diversity of microautophagy are beginning to emerge.

"Repair Me if You Can": Membrane Damage, Response, and Control from the Viral Perspective

Cells are constantly challenged by pathogens (bacteria, virus, and fungi), and protein aggregates or chemicals, which can provoke membrane damage at the plasma membrane or within the endo-lysosomal compartments. Detection of endo-lysosomal rupture depends on a family of sugar-binding lectins, known as galectins, which sense the abnormal exposure of glycans to the cytoplasm upon membrane damage. Galectins in conjunction with other factors orchestrate specific membrane damage responses such as the recruitment of the endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery to either repair damaged membranes or the activation of autophagy to remove membrane remnants. If not controlled, membrane damage causes the release of harmful components including protons, reactive oxygen species, or cathepsins that will elicit inflammation. In this review, we provide an overview of current knowledge on membrane damage and cellular responses. In particular, we focus on the endo-lysosomal damage triggered by non-enveloped viruses (such as adenovirus) and discuss viral strategies to control the cellular membrane damage response. Finally, we debate the link between autophagy and inflammation in this context and discuss the possibility that virus induced autophagy upon entry limits inflammation.

Identification and characterization of unconventional membrane protein trafficking regulators in Arabidopsis: A genetic approach

Proper trafficking and subcellular localization of membrane proteins are essential for plant growth and development. The plant endomembrane system contains several membrane-bound organelles with distinct functions including the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Golgi apparatus, trans-Golgi network (TGN) or early endosome, prevacuolar compartment (PVC) or multivesicular body (MVB) and vacuole. Multiple approaches have been successfully used to identify and study the regulators and components important for signal transduction, growth and development, as well as membrane trafficking in the endomembrane system in plants. These include the homologous characterization of the counterparts in mammals or yeast employing both reverse genetic as well as the forward genetic screen approaches. However, the deletion or mutation of membrane trafficking related proteins usually leads to seedling lethality due to their essential roles in plant development and organelle biogenesis. To overcome the limitation of lethal phenotype of the target proteins, we used DEX-inducible RNAi knock-down lines to study their function in plants. More recently, we developed and used both RNAi knock-down and T-DNA insertional lines as starting materials to screen for mutations that could suppress and rescue the lethal phenotype, or a suppressor screening. Further characterization of the newly identified suppressor mutants has resulted in the identification of novel negative regulators in mediating membrane trafficking and organelle biogenesis in plants. In this review, we summarize the current approaches in studying protein trafficking in the endomembrane system. We then describe three examples of suppressor screening with distinct starting materials (i.e. FREE1, MON1, and SH3P2 that are regulators of MVB, vacuole, and autophagosomes, respectively) to discuss the rationale, procedures, advantages and disadvantages, and possible outcomes of such a suppressor screening. We finally propose that these novel screening approaches will lead to the identification of new unconventional players in regulating protein trafficking and organelle biogenesis in plants and discuss their impact on plant cell biology research.

Conidial Melanin of the Human-Pathogenic Fungus Aspergillus fumigatus Disrupts Cell Autonomous Defenses in Amoebae

The human-pathogenic fungus Aspergillus fumigatus is a ubiquitous saprophyte that causes fatal lung infections in immunocompromised individuals. Following inhalation, conidia are ingested by innate immune cells and can arrest phagolysosome maturation. How this virulence trait could have been selected for in natural environments is unknown. Here, we found that surface exposure of the green pigment 1,8-dihydroxynaphthalene-(DHN)-melanin can protect conidia from phagocytic uptake and intracellular killing by the fungivorous amoeba Protostelium aurantium and delays its exocytosis from the nonfungivorous species Dictyostelium discoideum To elucidate the antiphagocytic properties of the surface pigment, we followed the antagonistic interactions of A. fumigatus conidia with the amoebae in real time. For both amoebae, conidia covered with DHN-melanin were internalized at far lower rates than were seen with conidia lacking the pigment, despite high rates of initial attachment to nonkilling D. discoideum When ingested by D. discoideum, the formation of nascent phagosomes was followed by transient acidification of phagolysosomes, their subsequent neutralization, and, finally, exocytosis of the conidia. While the cycle was completed in less than 1 h for unpigmented conidia, the process was significantly prolonged for conidia covered with DHN-melanin, leading to an extended intracellular residence time. At later stages of this cellular infection, pigmented conidia induced enhanced damage to phagolysosomes and infected amoebae failed to recruit the ESCRT (endosomal sorting complex required for transport) membrane repair machinery or the canonical autophagy pathway to defend against the pathogen, thus promoting prolonged intracellular persistence in the host cell and the establishment of a germination niche in this environmental phagocyte.IMPORTANCE Infections with Aspergillus fumigatus are usually acquired by an inhalation of spores from environmental sources. How spores of a saprophytic fungus have acquired abilities to withstand and escape the phagocytic attacks of innate immune cells is not understood. The fungal surface pigment dihydroxynaphtalene-melanin has been shown to be a crucial factor for the delay in phagosome maturation. Here, we show that this pigment also has a protective function against environmental phagocytes. Pigmented conidia escaped uptake and killing by the fungus-eating amoeba Protostelium aurantium When ingested by the nonfungivorous phagocyte Dictyostelium discoideum, the pigment attenuated the launch of cell autonomous defenses against the fungal invader, such as membrane repair and autophagy, leading to prolonged intracellular retention. Membrane damage and cytoplasmic leakage may result in an influx of nutrients and thus may further promote intracellular germination of the fungus, indicating that A. fumigatus has acquired some of the basic properties of intracellular pathogens.

ESCRTing endoplasmic reticulum to microautophagic degradation

Changing conditions necessitate cellular adaptation, which frequently entails adjustment of organelle size and shape. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is an organelle of exceptional morphological plasticity. In budding yeast, ER stress triggers the de novo formation of ER subdomains called ER whorls. These whorls are selectively degraded by a poorly defined type of microautophagy. We recently showed that ESCRT proteins are essential for microautophagic uptake of ER whorls into lysosomes, likely by mediating the final scission of the lysosomal membrane. Furthermore, ER-selective microautophagy acts in parallel with ER-selective macroautophagy. The molecular machineries for these two types of autophagy are distinct and their contributions to ER turnover vary according to conditions, suggesting that they serve different functions. Our study provides evidence for a direct role of ESCRTs in microautophagy and extends our understanding of how autophagy promotes organelle homeostasis.

ESCRT machinery mediates selective microautophagy of endoplasmic reticulum in yeast

ER‐phagy, the selective autophagy of endoplasmic reticulum (ER), safeguards organelle homeostasis by eliminating misfolded proteins and regulating ER size. ER‐phagy can occur by macroautophagic and microautophagic mechanisms. While dedicated machinery for macro‐ER‐phagy has been discovered, the molecules and mechanisms mediating micro‐ER‐phagy remain unknown. Here, we first show that micro‐ER‐phagy in yeast involves the conversion of stacked cisternal ER into multilamellar ER whorls during microautophagic uptake into lysosomes. Second, we identify the conserved Nem1‐Spo7 phosphatase complex and the ESCRT machinery as key components for micro‐ER‐phagy. Third, we demonstrate that macro‐ and micro‐ER‐phagy are parallel pathways with distinct molecular requirements. Finally, we provide evidence that the ESCRT machinery directly functions in scission of the lysosomal membrane to complete the microautophagic uptake of ER. These findings establish a framework for a mechanistic understanding of micro‐ER‐phagy and, thus, a comprehensive appreciation of the role of autophagy in ER homeostasis.

Vps28 Is Involved in the Intracellular Trafficking of Awd, the Drosophila Homolog of NME1/2

The Awd (abnormal wing discs) gene is the Drosophila homolog of human NME1 and NME2 metastasis suppressor genes. These genes play a key role in tumor progression. Extensive studies revealed that intracellular NME1/2 protein levels could be related to either favorable or poor prognosis depending on tissue context. More recently, extracellular activities of NME1/2 proteins have also been reported, including a tumor- promoting function. We used Drosophila as a genetic model to investigate the mechanism controlling intra- and extracellular levels of NME1/2. We examined the role of several components of the ESCRT (endosomal sorting complex required for transport) complex in controlling Awd trafficking. We show that the Vps28 component of the ESCRT-I complex is required for maintenance of normal intracellular level of Awd in larval adipocytes. We already showed that blocking of Shibire (Shi)/Dynamin function strongly- lowers Awd intracellular level. To further investigate this down regulative effect, we analyzed the distribution of endosomal markers in wild type and Shi-defective adipocytes. Our results suggest that Awd does not enter CD63-positive endosomes. Interestingly, we found that in fat body cells, Awd partly- colocalizes with the ESCRT accessory component ALiX, the ALG-2 (apoptosis-linked gene 2)-interacting protein X. Moreover, we show that the intracellular levels of both proteins are downregulated by blocking the function of the Dynamin encoded by the shibire gene.

The Dynamics of TGF-β Signaling Are Dictated by Receptor Trafficking via the ESCRT Machinery

Signal transduction pathways stimulated by secreted growth factors are tightly regulated at multiple levels between the cell surface and the nucleus. The trafficking of cell surface receptors is emerging as a key step for regulating appropriate cellular responses, with perturbations in this process contributing to human diseases, including cancer. For receptors recognizing ligands of the transforming growth factor β (TGF-β) family, little is known about how trafficking is regulated or how this shapes signaling dynamics. Here, using whole genome small interfering RNA (siRNA) screens, we have identified the ESCRT (endosomal sorting complex required for transport) machinery as a crucial determinant of signal duration. Downregulation of ESCRT components increases the outputs of TGF-β signaling and sensitizes cells to low doses of ligand in their microenvironment. This sensitization drives an epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) in response to low doses of ligand, and we demonstrate a link between downregulation of the ESCRT machinery and cancer survival.

Cis and trans interactions between genes encoding PAF1 complex and ESCRT machinery components in yeast

Saccharomyces cerevisiae is a commonly used model organism for understanding eukaryotic gene function. However, the close proximity between yeast genes can complicate the interpretation of yeast genetic data, particularly high-throughput data. In this study, we examined the interplay between genes encoding components of the PAF1 complex and VPS36, the gene located next to CDC73 on chromosome XII. The PAF1 complex (Cdc73, Paf1, Ctr9, Leo1, and Rtf1, in yeast) affects RNA levels by affecting transcription, histone modifications, and post-transcriptional RNA processing. The human PAF1 complex is linked to cancer, and in yeast, it has been reported to play a role in telomere biology. Vps36, part of the ESCRT-II complex, is involved in sorting proteins for vacuolar/lysosomal degradation. We document a complex set of genetic interactions, which include an adjacent gene effect between CDC73 and VPS36 and synthetic sickness between vps36Δ and cdc73Δ, paf1Δ, or ctr9Δ. Importantly, paf1Δ and ctr9Δ are synthetically lethal with deletions of other components of the ESCRT-II (SNF8 and VPS25), ESCRT-I (STP22), or ESCRT-III (SNF7) complexes. We found that RNA levels of VPS36, but not other ESCRT components, are positively regulated by all components of the PAF1 complex. Finally, we show that deletion of ESCRT components decreases the telomere length in the S288C yeast genetic background, but not in the W303 background. Together, our results outline complex interactions, in cis and in trans, between genes encoding PAF1 and ESCRT-II complex components that affect telomere function and cell viability in yeast.

Resolving ESCRT-III Spirals at the Intercellular Bridge of Dividing Cells Using 3D STORM

The ESCRT machinery mediates membrane fission in a variety of processes in cells. According to current models, ESCRT-III proteins drive membrane fission by assembling into helical filaments on membranes. Here, we used 3D STORM imaging of endogenous ESCRT-III component IST1 to reveal the evolution of the structural organization of ESCRT-III in mammalian cytokinetic abscission. Using this approach, ESCRT-III ring and spiral assemblies were resolved and characterized at different stages of abscission. Visualization of IST1 structures in cells lacking the microtubule-severing enzyme spastin and in cells depleted of specific ESCRT-III components or the ATPase VPS4 demonstrated the contribution of these components to the organization and function of ESCRTs in cells. This work provides direct evidence that ESCRT-III proteins form helical filaments to mediate their function in cells and raises new mechanistic scenarios for ESCRT-driven cytokinetic abscission.

Viral journeys on the intracellular highways

Viruses are obligate intracellular pathogens that are dependent on cellular machineries for their replication. Recent technological breakthroughs have facilitated reliable identification of host factors required for viral infections and better characterization of the virus–host interplay. While these studies have revealed cellular machineries that are uniquely required by individual viruses, accumulating data also indicate the presence of broadly required mechanisms. Among these overlapping cellular functions are components of intracellular membrane trafficking pathways. Here, we review recent discoveries focused on how viruses exploit intracellular membrane trafficking pathways to promote various stages of their life cycle, with an emphasis on cellular factors that are usurped by a broad range of viruses. We describe broadly required components of the endocytic and secretory pathways, the Endosomal Sorting Complexes Required for Transport pathway, and the autophagy pathway. Identification of such overlapping host functions offers new opportunities to develop broad-spectrum host-targeted antiviral strategies.

ESCRT-dependent cargo sorting at multivesicular endosomes

The endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery is composed of five multi-subunit protein complexes, which act cooperatively at specialized endosomes to facilitate the movement of specific cargoes from the limiting membrane into vesicles that bud into the endosome lumen. Over the past decade, numerous proteins, lipids, and RNAs have been shown to be incorporated into intralumenal vesicles (ILVs), but the mechanisms by which these unique cargoes are captured are only now becoming better understood. Here, we discuss the potential roles that the ESCRT machinery plays during cargo sorting at multivesicular endosomes (MVEs).

Plant ESCRT Complexes: Moving Beyond Endosomal Sorting

The endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery is an ancient system that deforms membrane and severs membrane necks from the inside. Extensive evidence has accumulated to demonstrate the conserved functions of plant ESCRTs in multivesicular body (MVB) biogenesis and MVB-mediated membrane protein sorting. In addition, recent exciting findings have uncovered unique plant ESCRT components and point to emerging roles for plant ESCRTs in non-endosomal sorting events such as autophagy, cytokinesis, and viral replication. Plant-specific processes, such as abscisic acid (ABA) signaling and chloroplast turnover, provide further evidence for divergences in the functions of plant ESCRTs during evolution. We summarize the multiple roles and current working models for plant ESCRT machinery and speculate on future ESCRT studies in the plant field.

Membrane manipulations by the ESCRT machinery

The endosomal sorting complexes required for transport (ESCRTs) collectively comprise a machinery that was first known for its function in the degradation of transmembrane proteins in the endocytic pathway of eukaryotic cells. Since their discovery, however, ESCRTs have been recognized as playing important roles at the plasma membrane, which appears to be the original site of function for the ESCRT machinery. This article reviews some of the major research findings that have shaped our current understanding of how the ESCRT machinery controls membrane dynamics and considers new roles for the ESCRT machinery that might be driven by these mechanisms.

Dual roles of an Arabidopsis ESCRT component FREE1 in regulating vacuolar protein transport and autophagic degradation

Protein turnover can be achieved via the lysosome/vacuole and the autophagic degradation pathways. Evidence has accumulated revealing that efficient autophagic degradation requires functional endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery. However, the interplay between the ESCRT machinery and the autophagy regulator remains unclear. Here, we show that FYVE domain protein required for endosomal sorting 1 (FREE1), a recently identified plant-specific ESCRT component essential for multivesicular body (MVB) biogenesis and plant growth, plays roles both in vacuolar protein transport and autophagic degradation. FREE1 also regulates vacuole biogenesis in both seeds and vegetative cells of Arabidopsis. Additionally, FREE1 interacts directly with a unique plant autophagy regulator SH3 domain-containing protein2 and associates with the PI3K complex, to regulate the autophagic degradation in plants. Thus, FREE1 plays multiple functional roles in vacuolar protein trafficking and organelle biogenesis as well as in autophagic degradation via a previously unidentified regulatory mechanism of cross-talk between the ESCRT machinery and autophagy process.

The PacC-family protein Rim101 prevents selenite toxicity in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by controlling vacuolar acidification

Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rim101 is a member of the fungal PacC family of transcription factors involved in the response to alkaline pH stress. Further studies have also implicated Rim101 in the responses to other stresses, and have shown its genetic interaction with the iron deprivation-responsive factor Aft1. The present study shows that the absence of Rim101 leads to hypersensitivity to oxidants such as t-butyl hydroperoxide and diamide, and also to the prooxidant agent selenite. The protective role of Rim101 against selenite requires the sensing complex component Rim8, the ESCRT-I/II/III complexes and the Rim13 protease involved in proteolytic activation of Rim101. The Nrg1 transcriptional repressor is a downstream effector of Rim101 in this response to selenite, as occurs in the responses to alkaline pH, Na(+) and Li(+) stresses. Deletion of RIM101 causes downregulation of the vacuolar ATPase genes VMA2 and VMA4, which becomes accentuated compared to wild type cells upon selenite stress, and activation of the Rim101 protein prevents inhibition of vacuolar acidification caused by selenite. These observations therefore support a role of Rim101 in modulation of vacuolar acidity necessary for selenite detoxification. In addition, a parallel Rim101-independent pathway requiring the complete ESCRT machinery (including the ESCRT-0 complex) also participates in protection against selenite.