Macrophages in guided bone regeneration: potential roles and future directions

Guided bone regeneration (GBR) is one of the most widely used and thoroughly documented alveolar bone augmentation surgeries. However, implanting GBR membranes inevitably triggers an immune response, which can lead to inflammation and failure of bone augmentation. It has been shown that GBR membranes may significantly improve in vivo outcomes as potent immunomodulators, rather than solely serving as traditional barriers. Macrophages play crucial roles in immune responses and participate in the entire process of bone injury repair. The significant diversity and high plasticity of macrophages complicate our understanding of the immunomodulatory mechanisms underlying GBR. This review provides a comprehensive summary of recent findings on the potential role of macrophages in GBR for bone defects in situ. Specifically, macrophages can promote osteogenesis or fibrous tissue formation in bone defects and degradation or fibrous encapsulation of membranes. Moreover, GBR membranes can influence the recruitment and polarization of macrophages. Therefore, immunomodulating GBR membranes are primarily developed by improving macrophage recruitment and aggregation as well as regulating macrophage polarization. However, certain challenges remain to be addressed in the future. For example, developing more rational and sophisticated sequential delivery systems for macrophage activation reagents; addressing the interference of bone graft materials and dental implants; and understanding the correlations among membrane degradation, macrophage responses, and bone regeneration.

Osteoinduction and osteoimmunology: Emerging concepts

The recognition and importance of immune cells during bone regeneration, including around bone biomaterials, has led to the development of an entire field termed "osteoimmunology," which focuses on the connection and interplay between the skeletal system and immune cells. Most studies have focused on the "osteogenic" capacity of various types of bone biomaterials, and much less focus has been placed on immune cells despite being the first cell type in contact with implantable devices. Thus, the amount of literature generated to date on this topic makes it challenging to extract needed information. This review article serves as a guide highlighting advancements made in the field of osteoimmunology emphasizing the role of the osteoimmunomodulatory properties of biomaterials and their impact on osteoinduction. First, the various immune cell types involved in bone biomaterial integration are discussed, including the prominent role of osteal macrophages (OsteoMacs) during bone regeneration. Thereafter, key biomaterial properties, including topography, wettability, surface charge, and adsorption of cytokines, growth factors, ions, and other bioactive molecules, are discussed in terms of their impact on immune responses. These findings highlight and recognize the importance of the immune system and osteoimmunology, leading to a shift in the traditional models used to understand and evaluate biomaterials for bone regeneration.

Immune Modulation by Transplanted Calcium Phosphate Biomaterials and Human Mesenchymal Stromal Cells in Bone Regeneration

A wide variety of biomaterials have been developed as both stabilizing structures for the injured bone and inducers of bone neoformation. They differ in chemical composition, shape, porosity, and mechanical properties. The most extensively employed and studied subset of bioceramics are calcium phosphate materials (CaPs). These materials, when transplanted alongside mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), lead to ectopic (intramuscular and subcutaneous) and orthotopic bone formation in preclinical studies, and effective fracture healing in clinical trials. Human MSC transplantation in pre-clinical and clinical trials reveals very low engraftment in spite of successful clinical outcomes and their therapeutic actions are thought to be primarily through paracrine mechanisms. The beneficial role of transplanted MSC could rely on their strong immunomodulatory effect since, even without long-term engraftment, they have the ability to alter both the innate and adaptive immune response which is critical to facilitate new bone formation. This study presents the current knowledge of the immune response to the implantation of CaP biomaterials alone or in combination with MSC. In particular the central role of monocyte-derived cells, both macrophages and osteoclasts, in MSC-CaP mediated bone formation is emphasized. Biomaterial properties, such as macroporosity and surface microstructure, dictate the host response, and the ultimate bone healing cascade. Understanding intercellular communications throughout the inflammation, its resolution and the bone regeneration phase, is crucial to improve the current therapeutic strategies or develop new approaches.

Role of the Complement System in the Response to Orthopedic Biomaterials

Various synthetic biomaterials are used to replace lost or damaged bone tissue that, more or less successfully, osseointegrate into the bone environment. Almost all biomaterials used in orthopedic medicine activate the host-immune system to a certain degree. The complement system, which is a crucial arm of innate immunity, is rapidly activated by an implanted foreign material into the human body, and it is intensely studied regarding blood-contacting medical devices. In contrast, much less is known regarding the role of the complement system in response to implanted bone biomaterials. However, given the increasing knowledge of the complement regulation of bone homeostasis, regeneration, and inflammation, complement involvement in the immune response following biomaterial implantation into bone appears very likely. Moreover, bone cells can produce complement factors and are target cells of activated complement. Therefore, new bone formation or bone resorption around the implant area might be greatly influenced by the complement system. This review aims to summarize the current knowledge on biomaterial-mediated complement activation, with a focus on materials primarily used in orthopedic medicine. In addition, methods to modify the interactions between the complement system and bone biomaterials are discussed, which might favor osseointegration and improve the functionality of the device.

The Metabolic Microenvironment Steers Bone Tissue Regeneration

Over the past years, basic findings in cancer research have revealed metabolic symbiosis between different cell types to cope with high energy demands under limited nutrient availability. Although this also applies to regenerating tissues with disrupted physiological nutrient and oxygen supply, the impact of this metabolic cooperation and metabolic reprogramming on cellular development, fate, and function during tissue regeneration has widely been neglected so far. With this review, we aim to provide a schematic overview on metabolic links that have a high potential to drive tissue regeneration. As bone is, aside from liver, the only tissue that can regenerate without excessive scar tissue formation, we will use bone healing as an exemplarily model system.

Nanotopography-based strategy for the precise manipulation of osteoimmunomodulation in bone regeneration

Immune cells play vital roles in regulating bone dynamics. Successful bone regeneration requires a favourable osteo-immune environment. The high plasticity and diversity of immune cells make it possible to manipulate the osteo-immune response of immune cells, thus modulating the osteoimmune environment and regulating bone regeneration. With the advancement in nanotechnology, nanotopographies with different controlled surface properties can be fabricated. On tuning the surface properties, the osteo-immune response can be precisely modulated. This highly tunable characteristic and immunomodulatory effects make nanotopography a promising strategy to precisely manipulate osteoimmunomdulation for bone tissue engineering applications. This review first summarises the effects of the immune response during bone healing to show the importance of regulating the immune response for the bone response. The plasticity of immune cells is then reviewed to provide rationales for manipulation of the osteoimmune response. Subsequently, we highlight the current types of nanotopographies applied in bone biomaterials and their fabrication techniques, and explain how these nanotopographies modulate the immune response and the possible underlying mechanisms. The effects of immune cells on nanotopography-mediated osteogenesis are emphasized, and we propose the concept of "nano-osteoimmunomodulation" to provide a valuable strategy for the development of nanotopographies with osteoimmunomodulatory properties that can precisely regulate bone dynamics.

Osteomacs and Bone Regeneration

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Mounting evidence supporting the critical contribution of macrophages, in particular osteal macrophages, to bone regeneration is reviewed. We specifically examine the potential role of macrophages in the basic multicellular units coordinating lifelong bone regeneration via remodelling and bone regeneration in response to injury. We review and discuss the distinctions between macrophage and osteoclast contributions to bone homeostasis, particularly the dichotomous role of the colony-stimulating factor 1-colony-stimulating factor 1 receptor axis.

RECENT FINDINGS

The impact of inflammation associated with aging and other hallmarks of aging, including senescence, on macrophage function is addressed in the context of osteoporosis and delayed fracture repair. Resident macrophages versus recruited macrophage contributions to fracture healing are also discussed. We identify some of the remaining knowledge gaps that will need to be closed in order to maximise benefits from therapeutically modulating or mimicking the function of macrophages to improve bone health and regeneration over a lifetime.

Functional block of IL-17 cytokine promotes bone healing by augmenting FOXO1 and ATF4 activity in cortical bone defect model

We determine the effect of interleukin (IL)-17 neutralizing antibody on new bone regeneration. Anti-IL-17 antibody promoted new bone regeneration in cortical bone defect model by augmenting FOXO1 and ATF4 activity thereby decreasing oxidative stress. Our study demonstrates the bone healing and regeneration potential of neutralizing IL-17antibody in osteoporotic fractures.

INTRODUCTION

The immune system plays important role in the fracture healing process. However, fracture healing is prolonged in disorders associated with systemic inflammation. Fracture healing is decelerated in osteoporosis, condition linked with systemic inflammation. Bone regeneration therapies like recombinant human BMP2 are associated with serious side effects. Studies have been carried out where agents like denosumab and infliximab enhance bone regeneration in osteoporotic conditions. Our previous studies show the osteoprotective and immunoprotective effects of neutralizing IL-17 antibody. Here, we determine the effect of IL-17 neutralizing antibody on new bone regeneration and compare its efficacy with known osteoporotic therapies.

METHODS

For the study, female BALB/c mice were ovariectomized or sham operated and left for a month followed by a 0.6-mm drill-hole injury in femur mid-diaphysis. The treatment was commenced next day onwards with anti-IL-17, anti-RANKL (Receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa-B ligand), parathyroid hormone (PTH), or alendronate for a period of 3, 10, or 21 days. Animals were then autopsied, and femur bones were dissected out for micro-CT scanning, confocal microscopy, and gene and protein expression studies.

RESULTS

Micro-CT analysis showed that anti-IL-17 antibody promoted bone healing at days 10 and 21, and the healing effect observed was significantly better than Ovx, anti-RANKL antibody, and ALN, and equal to PTH. Anti-IL-17 also enhanced new bone regeneration as assessed by calcein-labeling studies. Additionally, anti-IL-17 therapy enhanced expression of osteogenic markers and decreased oxidative stress at the injury site.

CONCLUSION

Overall, our study demonstrates bone healing and regeneration potential of neutralizing IL-17 antibody in osteoporotic fractures.

[Immunological aspects of delayed regeneration of mandibular fractures]

The level of complications in patients with the mandibular fractures does not have a tendency to the decline. A research purposes is a study of the basic laws of immunological reactions and possibility of optimizing processes osteogenesis by drugs-cytokines at patients with the mandibular fractures with delayed consolidation of bone tissue. 46 patients with the mandibular fractures were observed. The maintenance of cytokines IL - 1β, TNF - α, IL - 4, SICAM-1 in the blood serum, IgA, IgM, IgG in a mouth liquid was probed. It is set that in pathogenesis of delayed consolidation a basic role is played by changes reactivity of organism, which realized in three directions: immunodeficit of humoral immunity, immunodepression of cellular factors of defence, disbalance in functioning of the cytokines system. It is necessary to count the levels of products SICAM-1 and cytokine IL-1β in the blood serum by the diagnostic criteria of bone repair features at patients with the mandibular fractures: development of delayed consolidation of mandibular fragments is accompanied the increase of their parameters at the control group more than in 2 and in 15 times (668,2±10,3 pg/ml and 363,4 ±6,6 pg/ml relatively). Includding in the complex treatment of the mandibular fractures of immunomodulator Ronkoleukin showed clinico-immunological efficiency for the patients with impaired bone repair.

Biocompatibility of pure and mixed hydroxyapatite and α-tricalcium phosphate implanted in rabbit bone

Calcium phosphates and hydroxyapatite, in particular, are used as substitute materials in experimental implantology. These materials are primarily used in hard tissue replacement because their chemical and crystallographic characteristics are considered to be similar to the mineral content, osteoconductivity and bioactivity of normal bone. Cytokines, such as interleukin (IL)-1, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10 and antimicrobial protein β-defensin-2 (βDef-2), are used as biomarkers of non-specific reactogenicity. Other biomarkers, including bone morphogenetic protein-2/4 (BMP-2/4), bone regeneration protein osteoprotegerin (OPG), bone matrix protein osteopontin (OP) and osteocalcin (OC), are regarded as specific factors of reactogenicity in bone substitution. The aim of our study was to assess the changes in the distribution and expression of the aforementioned proteins in the lower jaws of rabbits following implantation with pure hydroxyapatite (HAP), α-tricalcium phosphate (α-TCP) or a mix of the two (HAP/α-TCP) manufactured under different temperatures. Our results reveal osteoblast proliferation and regions of granulation tissue formation between biomaterial granules close to the original implantation site, but in the control tissue these changes were less noticeable. Our study showed low variability in the distribution of βDef-2, OPG and all of the tested interleukins and these proteins were less expressed than BMP2/4, OP and OC. But across all experiments, no statistically significant difference in mean βDef-2, IL-1, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, OP, OC, BMP-2/4 and OPG expression in osteocytes was detected between experimental and control groups. We concluded that pure and mixed HAP and α-TCP sintered at different temperatures do not affect the production of cytokines and bone-specific proteins; regions with osteoblast proliferation and low levels of anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-10 indicates better biocompatibility for HAP/α-TCP and α-TCP-2 biomaterials and the moderate number of BMP-2/4- and a prevalence of OC- and OP-positive osteocytes in experimental tissues implanted with HAP at 3 months after implantation indicates potential bone regeneration stimulated by pure HAP.

Adsorbed fibrinogen leads to improved bone regeneration and correlates with differences in the systemic immune response

Designing new biomaterials that can modulate the inflammatory response instead of attempting just to reduce it constitutes a paradigm change in regenerative medicine. This work aimed to investigate the capacity of an immunomodulatory biomaterial to enhance bone regeneration. For that purpose we incorporated a molecule with well-established pro-inflammatory and pro-healing roles, fibrinogen, in chitosan scaffolds. Two different incorporation strategies were tested, leading to concentrations of 0.54±0.10mg fibrinogen g(-1) scaffold immediately upon adsorption (Fg-Sol), and 0.34±0.04mg fibrinogen g(-1) scaffold after washing (Fg-Ads). These materials were implanted in a critical size bone defect in rats. At two months post-implantation the extent of bone regeneration was examined by histology and the systemic immune response triggered was evaluated by determining the percentages of myeloid cells, T and B lymphocytes in the draining lymph nodes. The results obtained indicate that the fibrinogen incorporation strategy conditioned the osteogenic capacity of biomaterials. Fg-Ads scaffolds led to more bone formation, and the presence of Fg stimulated angiogenesis. Furthermore, animals implanted with Fg-Ads scaffolds showed significant increases in the percentages of B lymphocytes and myeloid cells in the draining lymph nodes, while levels of T lymphocytes were not significantly different. Finally, a significant increase in TGF-β1 was detected in the plasma of animals implanted with Fg-Ads. Taken together the results presented suggest a potential correlation between the elicited immune response and biomaterial osteogenic performance.

The role of recipient T cells in mesenchymal stem cell-based tissue regeneration

Significant progress has been made in stem cell biology, regenerative medicine, and stem cell-based tissue engineering. Such scientific strides highlight the potential of replacing or repairing damaged tissues in congenital abnormalities, diseases, or injuries, as well as constructing functional tissue or organs in vivo. Since mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are capable of differentiating into bone-forming cells, they constitute an appropriate cell source to repair damaged bone tissues. In addition, the immunoregulatory property of MSCs provides a foundation for their use in treating a variety of autoimmune diseases. However, the interaction between MSCs and immune cells in cell-based tissue regeneration is largely unknown. In this review, we will discuss the current understanding of MSC-based tissue regeneration, emphasizing the role of the immune microenvironment in bone regeneration.

[Immunoregulatory role of mesenchymal stem cells in bone reparation processes]

Bone marrow contains mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) including osteoblast progenitor cells. When culturedunder conditions promoting an osteoblastic phenotype,MSC proliferate to form colonies that produce alkaline phosphatase and, subsequently, a mature osteoblastic phenotype. Transplantation of cultured autologous MSC to patients with non-healing bone fractures gives a good result leading to complete bone fracture consolidation. The aim of the study is to determine a quantitative production of IL-1beta, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-8 and TNF-alpha by cultured uncommitted and committed osteogenic MSC. The results showed that the cytokine profile consisting of IL-1beta, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-8 and TNF-alpha is secreted by cultured MSC. The secretion of IL-1beta and IL-2 by cultured MSC together with hyper production of IL-6 (up to 276.5 pg/ml, p<0.05) and IL-8 (up to 106.6 ng/ml, p<0.05) by osteoinducted MSC are firstly shown. The immunoregulatory role of transplanted autologous cells in inflammation and own bone reparation processes during posttraumatic bone fracture healing is highlighted. In conclusion, the data obtained allow examining of cultured autologous MSC as effective activators of bone resorption, inflammation and some immunological reactions in the process of altered osteoreparation.

Roles of neutrophil-mediated inflammatory response in the bony repair of injured growth plate cartilage in young rats

Injured growth plate cartilage is often repaired by bony tissue, resulting in impaired bone growth in children. Previously, injury-induced, initial inflammatory response was shown to be an acute inflammatory event containing predominantly neutrophils. To examine potential roles of neutrophils in the bony repair, a neutrophil-neutralizing antiserum or control normal serum was administered systemically in rats with growth plate injury. The inflammatory response was found temporally associated with increased expression of neutrophil chemotactic chemokine cytokine-induced neutrophil chemoattractant-1 and cytokines TNF-alpha and IL-1beta. Following the inflammatory response, mesenchymal infiltration, chondrogenic and osteogenic responses, and bony repair were observed at the injury site. Neutrophil reduction did not significantly affect infiltration of other inflammatory cells and expression of TNF-alpha and IL-1beta and growth factors, platelet-derived growth factor-B and TGF-beta1, at the injured growth plate on Day 1 and had no effects on mesenchymal infiltration on Day 4. By Day 10, however, there was a significant reduction in proportion of mesenchymal repair tissue but an increase (although statistically insignificant) in bony trabeculae and a decrease in cartilaginous tissue within the injury site. Consistently, in antiserum-treated rats, there was an increase in expression of osteoblastic differentiation transcription factor cbf-alpha1 and bone matrix protein osteocalcin and a decrease in chondrogenic transcription factor Sox-9 and cartilage matrix collagen-II in the injured growth plate. These results suggest that injury-induced, neutrophil-mediated inflammatory response appears to suppress mesenchymal cell osteoblastic differentiation but enhance chondrogenic differentiation, and thus, it may be involved in regulating downstream chondrogenic and osteogenic events for growth plate bony repair.

Presence of IFN-gamma and IL-4 in human periapical granulation tissues and regeneration tissues

To study mediators associated with the progression of disease and the process of bone regeneration in human apical periodontitis, we examined samples of periapical granulation tissues and regeneration tissues obtained from five patients by use of immunohistochemical methods. Periapical granulation tissues were found to contain a large number of CD4-positive T cells and CD68-positive monocytes/macrophages (CD4: 35.2%, CD68: 32.7%). The CD4-positive T cells and CD68-positive monocytes/macrophages were predominantly present in regeneration tissues (CD4: 62.1%, CD68: 16.0%). In these the percentages of CD4-positive T cells were higher as compared with periapical granulation tissues (from 35.2% to 62.1%). In periapical granulation tissues, CD4-positive T cells stained positively for interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and negatively for interleukin-4 (IL-4). In regeneration tissues, IL-4-producing cells could be detected. However, IFN-gamma-producing cells could not be detected. These results suggest that IFN-gamma and IL-4 may modulate the pathogenesis of infectious disease and the process of bone regeneration in local inflammation sites such as human apical periodontitis.

[Laboratory monitoring of distraction bone formation]

The course of the early period of bone formation during distraction osteosynthesis can be safely, rapidly, and objectively monitored and predicted by hematological and immunological parameters (lymphocytes, rosette-forming cells, monocytes, immunoglobulin A, heterophilic hemagglutinins), which are tested before and after surgery on days 1 and 7-10 and on day 10 of distraction.

[Experimental studies of healing and antigenicity of sterilized bone transplants]

The aim of our study was to observe the incorporation and induced immune response of sterilized bone allografts. We performed an orthotopical tibial segment transplantation using two different inbred rat strains. We compared irradiated (25 kGy), autoclaved (134 degrees C) and cryopreserved (-80 degrees C) bone grafts. The observation took place 6 and 12 weeks post-operatively.

RESULTS

The incorporation of irradiated grafts took longer than cryopreserved transplants. Autoclaved grafts were not incorporated and only bridged by new callus formation. A cell-mediated immune response against the cryopreserved grafts could be demonstrated. Irradiated grafts induced a major immune response; autoclaved grafts did not.

CONCLUSION

There seems to be a correlation between loss of antigenicity and failure of graft incorporation. Therefore, it seems probable, that some bone antigenicity is necessary for the induction of cellular mechanisms during graft incorporation.

Allogeneic transplants of rib cartilage preserved in 98% glycerol or 70% alcohol into the malar process of rats: a comparative histological study

A comparative study was made of two methods of cartilage preservation, 98% glycerol and 70% alcohol. Rib cartilage was treated by either of these methods and transplanted into the malar process of rats. Cartilage grafts preserved by both methods were equally well tolerated. Resorption and bone substitution were similar in both groups after 120 days, although resorption was greater for the alcohol-preserved cartilage up until day 30. The possible reduction in antigenicity by the 98% glycerol did not produce any difference of behavior from the cartilage preserved in 70% alcohol.

Inflammatory mediators and the destruction of bone

Bone is remodelled by the coordinated actions of osteoclasts and osteoblasts. Cellular remodelling occurs in discrete packets of bone, and is regulated by local cytokines produced in the environment of the remodelling cells. These cytokines are secreted by immune cells and by bone cells. In addition, some growth regulatory factors are incorporated into the noncollagenous bone matrix and are released in an active form when bone is stimulated to resorb. Complex interactions between these cytokines and their target cells are responsible for the normal delicate balance between bone resorption and bone formation, and disorders of bone loss are due to imbalances between the rates of resorption and formation.