Analysis of Cross-sectional and Longitudinal HLA and Anti-viral Responses After COVID Infection in Renal Allograft Recipients: Differences and Correlates

BACKGROUND

Characterization of anti-HLA versus anti-severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (anti-SARS-CoV-2) immune globulin isotypes in organ transplant recipients after coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection has not been reported. We aimed to determine changes in anti-HLA antibodies in renal transplant patients with COVID-19 and compare the immunoglobulin and epitope-binding pattern versus anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.

METHODS

This is a cross-sectional study of 46 kidney transplant recipients including 21 with longitudinal sampling. Using a semi-quantitative multiplex assay, we determined immunoglobulin (Ig) M, IgA, IgG, and IgG1-2-3-4 antibodies against Class I and Class II HLA, and 5 SARS-CoV-2 epitopes including the nucleocapsid protein and multiple regions of the spike protein.

RESULTS

Fourteen of 46 (30%) patients had donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (donor-specific antibody [DSA]), 12 (26%) had non-DSA anti-HLA antibodies and 45 (98%) had anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibodies. Most DSAs targeted HLA-DQ (71%), with a dominant IgG isotype and IgG1 subtype prevalence (93%), and/or IgG3 (64%), followed by IgG2 (36%). Comparatively, there was a higher prevalence of IgA (85% versus 14%, P = 0.0001) and IgM (87%, versus 36%, P = 0.001) in the anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibody profile, when compared to DSAs, respectively. Anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibody profile was characterized by increased prevalence of IgM and IgA, when compared to DSAs. The median calculated panel reactive antibody before COVID-19 diagnosis (24%) tended to decrease after COVID-19 diagnosis (10%) but it was not statistically significant ( P = 0.1).

CONCLUSIONS

Anti-HLA antibody strength and calculated panel reactive antibody in kidney transplant recipients after COVID-19 do not significantly increase after infection. Although the IgG isotype was the dominant form in both HLA and SARS-CoV-2 antigens, the alloimmune response had a low IgA pattern, whereas anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibodies were high IgA/IgM.

A prospective, iterative, adaptive trial of carfilzomib-based desensitization

Proteasome inhibitor-based strategies hold promise in transplant but have yielded varying results. Carfilzomib, a second-generation proteasome inhibitor, may possess advantages over bortezomib, the first-generation proteasome inhibitors. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the safety, toxicity, and preliminary efficacy of carfilzomib in highly HLA-sensitized kidney transplant candidates. Renal transplant candidates received escalating doses of carfilzomib followed by plasmapheresis (group A) or an identical regimen with additional plasmapheresis once weekly before carfilzomib dosing. Thirteen participants received carfilzomib, which was well tolerated with most adverse events classified as low grade. The safety profile was similar to bortezomib desensitization; however, neurotoxicity was not observed with carfilzomib. Toxicity resulted in permanent dose reduction in 1 participant but caused no withdrawals or deaths. HLA antibodies were substantially reduced with carfilzomib alone, and median maximal immunodominant antibody reduction was 72.8% (69.8% for group A, P = .031, 80.1% for group B, P = .938). After depletion, rebound occurred rapidly and antibody levels returned to baseline between days 81 and 141. Bone marrow studies revealed that approximately 69.2% of plasma cells were depleted after carfilzomib monotherapy. Carfilzomib monotherapy-based desensitization provides an acceptable safety and toxicity profile while leading to significant bone marrow plasma cell depletion and anti-HLA antibody reduction.

IGG3 anti-HLA donor-specific antibodies and graft function in pediatric kidney transplant recipients

Anti-HLA DSAs are associated with ABMR and graft loss in KT recipients, yet the influence of DSA IgG subclass on outcomes in pediatric KT recipients is not completely understood. We performed a single-center retrospective chart review of pediatric KT recipients with anti-HLA DSAs, aiming to study the association between specific DSA IgG subclasses and graft outcomes, including ABMR and significant graft dysfunction (graft loss or 50% decrease in eGFR). Thirty-six patients (mean age 15.4y) with DSAs initially detected 1 month-14.3 years post-transplantation were followed for a median of 2.8 years. Rates of IgG1, 2, 3, and 4 subclass detection were 92%, 33%, 58%, and 25%, respectively. Twenty-two patients (61%) had clinical ABMR, whereas 19% had subclinical ABMR, and 13 (36%) experienced significant graft dysfunction. Patients with IgG3+ DSAs had a higher risk of graft dysfunction compared with IgG3- patients (52% vs 13%, P = .03). In a multiple Cox proportional regression analysis, the presence of IgG3+ DSA was independently associated with significant graft dysfunction (HR 10.45, 95% CI 1.97-55.55, P = .006). In conclusion, IgG3 subclass DSAs are associated with graft dysfunction and may be useful for risk stratification and treatment decisions in DSA-positive pediatric KT recipients.

Randomized controlled pilot study of B cell-targeted induction therapy in HLA sensitized kidney transplant recipients

Optimal induction regimens for patients at high risk for antibody and/or cell-mediated rejection have not been established. This pilot, prospective, randomized study evaluated addition of B cell/plasma cell-targeting agents to T cell-based induction with rabbit antithymocyte globulin (rATG) in high immunologic risk renal transplant recipients. Patients were randomized to induction with rATG, rATG + rituximab, rATG + bortezomib or rATG + rituximab + bortezomib. Inclusion criteria were: (1) current cytotoxic panel reactive antibody (PRA) ≥20% or peak cytotoxic PRA ≥50% or (2) T or B cell positive flow crossmatch with donor-specific antibody (DSA) or (3) historical positive serologic or cytotoxic crossmatch or DSA to donor or (4) prior allograft loss with more than one acute rejection. Median overall follow-up was 496 days: 1-year and overall acute rejection were 25% and 27.5%, and 25% of patients developed de novo DSA within 1 year. One-year and overall patient survival were 97.5% and 92.5%, and 1-year and overall death-censored allograft survival were 97.5% and 95%. Renal allograft function posttransplant was similar among all arms. Eight of nine cases of peripheral neuropathy were mild, whereas one case was moderate and required a narcotic prescription. In conclusion, addition of rituximab and/or bortezomib to rATG induction has an acceptable safety/toxicity profile in a high immunologic risk renal transplant population.

Alemtuzumab preconditioning with tacrolimus monotherapy-the impact of serial monitoring for donor-specific antibody

BACKGROUND

Antibody preconditioning with tacrolimus monotherapy has allowed many renal allograft recipients to be maintained on spaced weaning.

METHODS

Of 279 renal allograft recipients transplanted between March 2003 and December 2004, 222 (80%) had spaced weaning (i.e., reduction of tacrolimus monotherapy dosing to every other day, three times a week, twice a week, or once a week) attempted. Routine monitoring for donor-specific antibody (DSA) was begun in September 2004. Mean follow-up is 34+/-6.5 months after transplantation and 26+/-8.1 months after the initiation of spaced weaning.

RESULTS

One hundred and twenty-two (44%) patients remained on spaced weaning. One- and 2-year actual patient/graft survival was 99%/99%, and 97%/96%. Fifty-six (20%) patients experienced acute rejection after initiation of spaced weaning. One- and 2-year actual patient/graft survival was 100%/98%, and 94%/78%. Forty-two (15%) patients with stable renal function had spaced weaning stopped because of the development of DSA, which disappeared in 17 (40%). One- and 2-year actual patient and graft survival was 100% and 100%.

CONCLUSION

Adult renal transplant recipients who are able to be maintained on spaced weaning have excellent outcomes. Patients with stable renal function who have reversal of weaning because of the development of DSA also have excellent outcomes. Routine monitoring for DSA may allow patients to avoid late rejection after spaced weaning.

Survival in Allosensitized Children After Listing for Cardiac Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Little is known about the effect of pre-transplant alloantibody in the pediatric cardiac transplant population.

METHODS

All cardiac listings (n = 298) at Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh from January 1990 through February 2006 were reviewed to determine the impact of allosensitization on transplantation outcomes. Analysis focused on: (1) wait list outcomes; (2) survival from the time of listing, regardless of subsequent transplantation; (3) post-transplant graft and patient survival; and (4) post-transplant freedom from graft vasculopathy. Institutional policy required a negative, prospective crossmatch for candidates with panel-reactive antibody >20%.

RESULTS

Alloantibody data were available for 252 (85%) listings. Median time to transplantation was greater for sensitized vs non-sensitized subjects (2.7 months vs 1.3 months; p = 0.02). At 1 year after listing, sensitized subjects had a higher incidence of death (22% vs 8.4%; p = 0.055). Survival at all time-points after listing (regardless of transplantation) was worse for sensitized subjects (p = 0.04). Although no statistically significant differences in post-transplant graft or patient survival were noted, pre-transplant allosensitization was associated with decreased freedom from graft vasculopathy (hazard ratio [HR] 2.76, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.18 to 6.45; p = 0.019).

CONCLUSIONS

A policy requiring a negative, prospective crossmatch for highly sensitized candidates is associated with longer wait list time and higher mortality after listing. The development of graft vasculopathy appears to be influenced by the presence of pre-transplant alloantibody.

Increased lung allograft failure in patients with HLA-specific antibody

In this prospective study we report on a higher prevalence of lung allograft failure in patients with HLA-specific alloantibody, at two and four years of follow-up. Our report follows an increasing number of previous studies which have shown that anti-HLA alloantibody is a major risk factor for worse outcome in lung transplantation. Anti-class I and II HLA antibodies are reported to cause hyperacute rejection in lung allograft which can largely be avoided by a thorough analysis of sensitized candidates. Pre-transplant screening by multiple methods, including solid-phase/ single-antigen assays, can improve the sensitivity and specificity of virtual crossmatches and can identify additional acceptable mismatches resulting in an increased transplantability rate of highly sensitized candidates. Furthermore, posttransplant anti-HLA antibodies were strongly associated with a worse lung allograft outcome. Recipients that exhibited humoral allosensitization experienced an increased frequency of refractory acute rejection. The prevalence of lymphocytic bronchiolitis and decreased pulmonary function was also higher in antibody producers when compared to patients without anti-HLA antibody. The presence of specific C4d deposition in lung capillaries, as well as increased soluble C4d in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, are markers of antibody-mediated rejection and are found especially in patients with mixed forms of rejection. Chronic lung allograft dysfunction, diagnosed as bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome, was higher in patients with anti-HLA antibody and was preceded by circulating antibody. The improved detection and characterization of anti-HLA antibody and the availability of additional therapeutic strategies to target the humoral alloimmune response should improve the clinical management of lung transplant recipients.

Disparate Distribution of 16 Candidate Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Among Racial and Ethnic Groups of Pediatric Heart Transplant Patients

BACKGROUND

Allograft failure in African-Americans remains higher than in Caucasians. Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) have been associated with altered allograft outcomes.

METHODS

In this multi-center study we compared SNP frequencies in 364 pediatric heart recipients from three ethnic/racial groups: Caucasian (n = 243), African-American (n = 39), and Hispanic (n = 82). The target genes were: tumor necrosis factor-alpha, interleukin (IL)-10, IL-6, interferon (IFN)-gamma, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), transforming growth factor-beta1, Fas, FasL, granzyme B, ABCB1, CYP3A5.

RESULTS

Compared to Caucasians, African-Americans exhibited a higher prevalence of genotypes associated with low expression of IFN-gamma (24% vs. 45.7%, P < 0.001) and IL-10 (33% vs. 57.1%, P = 0.052). African-Americans also exhibited an increased prevalence of high IL-6 (82.9% vs. 38.1%; P < 0.001). VEGF -2578 C/C and -460 C/C genotypes were found more frequently in African-Americans and Hispanics as compared to Caucasians (P < 0.001). G/G genotype of Fas and T/T genotype of FasL were expressed more often by African-American recipients. The prevalence of Granzyme B (-295A/G) genotype was differentially distributed in the three groups. Compared with Caucasians, African-Americans were twice as likely to carry the ABCB1 2677 G/G genotype (78.6% vs. 33.7%, P < 0.0025), and they were more frequent carriers of the CYP3A5 *1/*1 genotype (35.7% vs. 0.6% in Caucasians and 7.2% in Hispanics; P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

African-Americans have a genetic background that may predispose to proinflammatory/lower regulatory environment, reduced drug exposure and immunosuppressive efficacy. In this ongoing multicenter study, these gene polymorphisms differences among ethnic/racial groups are being documented so that therapeutic strategies can be devised to optimize outcomes for pediatric transplant recipients.

Anti-HLA alloantibodies in pediatric solid organ transplantation

An increasing number of studies demonstrate the clinical impact of preformed and de novo anti-human leucocyte antigen alloantibody (HLA-Ab) in solid organ transplantation (Tx). The screening of HLA-Ab in candidates and transplant recipients has evolved over time, with continuous improvement in the sensitivity and specificity of assays for HLA-Ab detection. Furthermore, histologic markers of complement activation pathways are currently implemented in the diagnosis of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). Therapeutic strategies, including depletion of HLA-Ab and B cells, have allowed Tx across antibody barriers, or have rescued patients with AMR. The purpose of the present review is to summarize the state-of-the-art of HLA-Ab detection, clinical significance and therapeutic strategies in pediatric solid organ Tx.

Antibody-mediated rejection in lung transplantation: case reports

We present two cases of lung-transplanted patients who exhibited: (1) donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies at multiple times after transplantation; (2) continuous, linear, and sub-endothelial C4d deposition concomitantly with detection of anti-HLA antibodies; and (3) biopsy-proven rejections that were refractory to augmented anti-T-cell therapy. In both patients, the pulmonary function progressively diminished, ultimately ending with allograft failure. One patient received a second lung transplant, which allowed us to detect additional donor-specific antibodies directed towards the previous allograft (sponge effect). The presence of donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies in the context of vascular C4d deposition and refractory acute rejection fulfills the criteria for antibody-mediated rejection in these two lung-transplanted patients.

C4d deposition in lung allografts is associated with circulating anti-HLA alloantibody

The complement activation demonstrated by vascular C4d deposition is used to diagnose antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in renal allografts, but remains controversial in lung transplantation (LTX).

METHODS

C4d deposition was assessed by immunohistochemistry in 192 lung transplant biopsies from 32 patients. ELISA analysis was performed on 415 serum samples in those 32 temporally and rejection-grade matched LTX patients; 16 patients developed HLA-Ab, while the other 16 patients remained negative. The specificity of C4d staining was further compared in 18 additional LTX patients without HLA-Ab or acute cellular rejection (ACR), but in the presence of CMV-pneumonitis or reperfusion injury.

RESULTS

Specific subendothelial C4d deposition was seen in 5 of 16 (31%) patients with HLA-Ab and was absent in 16 patients without HLA-Ab (p<0.05). All patients with specific C4d deposition exhibited donor-specific HLA-Ab. There were 13 patients with bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome in the group of 16 HLA-Ab positive patients, versus 2/16 in ELISA-negative patients (p<0.005). One of 7 patients with CMV pneumonitis and 2 of 11 patients with reperfusion injury also showed C4d positivity (not statistically significant).

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, specific subendothelial C4d deposition was a marker for the involvement of HLA-Ab in lung allograft rejection. The patchy nature, low sensitivity, and specificity of C4d staining might limit clinical use in protocol biopsies. However, in patients with decreasing pulmonary function, refractory ACR and/or HLA-Ab, specific C4d deposition may serve as a marker of coexistent AMR.

Serum analysis after transplant nephrectomy reveals restricted antibody specificity patterns against structurally defined HLA class I mismatches

This study deals with HLA-mismatched kidney transplants that have been removed following rejection. Sera from 27 patients were screened for HLA-specific antibodies by direct complement-dependent lymphocytotoxicity with HLA-typed cell panels. Circulating donor-specific antibodies were detected in 3 cases (11%) before and in 26 cases (97%) after allograft nephrectomy. These findings demonstrate the production of donor-specific antibodies in patients with rejected transplants, but in most cases, they were undetectable before nephrectomy, because the graft had adsorbed them. With an HLAMatchmaker-based serum analysis program, we observed restricted antibody specificity patterns against amino acid triplet-defined epitopes on donor HLA-A,B antigens. Many donor triplets were non-reactive while others were apparently recognized by antibodies. In some patients, the donor triplet specific antibodies persisted for a long time whereas in many other patients, they became undetectable after a few months. The characterization of the antibody specificity profiles of post-allograft nephrectomy sera is clinically useful in defining criteria of HLA mismatch acceptability for sensitized patients awaiting another transplant. It provides also opportunities for determining the relative immunogenicity of mismatched triplets.

HLA-specific antibodies are risk factors for lymphocytic bronchiolitis and chronic lung allograft dysfunction

Bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS) represents a major limitation in lung transplantation. While acute rejection is widely considered the most important risk factor for BOS, the impact of HLA-specific antibodies is less understood. Of 51 lung recipients who were prospectively tested during a 4.2 +/- 1.6-year period, 14 patients developed HLA-specific antibodies. A multi-factorial analysis was performed to correlate the prevalence of BOS with HLA antibodies, persistent-recurrent acute rejection (ACR-PR), lymphocytic bronchiolitis, and HLA-A, -B, and -DR mismatches. HLA-specific antibodies were associated with ACR-PR (10/14 vs. 11/37 with no antibodies, p < 0.05), lymphocytic bronchiolitis (8/14 vs. 10/37, p < 0.05), and BOS (10/14, vs. 9/37, p < 0.005). Other risk factors for BOS were: lymphocytic bronchiolitis (13/18 vs. 6/33 with no lymphocytic bronchiolitis, p < 0.0001), ACR-PR (12/21 vs. 7/30 with no ACR-PR, p < 0.05), and the number of HLA-DR mismatches (1.7 +/- 0.48 in BOS vs. 1.2 +/- 0.63 without BOS, p < 0.05). The presence of antibodies exhibited a cumulative effect on BOS when it was associated with either lymphocytic bronchiolitis or ACR-PR. The complex relationship between the development of HLA antibodies and acute and chronic lung allograft rejection determines the importance of post-transplant screening for HLA-specific antibodies as a prognostic element for lung allograft outcome.

HLA-Specific antibodies are associated with high-grade and persistent-recurrent lung allograft acute rejection

BACKGROUND

The impact of HLA-specific antibodies is not well established in the acute rejection of lung allografts. Acute rejection represents the most important risk factor for the development of chronic lung allograft dysfunction.

METHODS

We analyzed the pattern of HLA antibodies before and after transplantation in 54 patients, and correlated our data with the presence and frequency of high-grade and persistent-recurrent acute rejection, during the first 18 post-operative months. The diagnosis of acute rejection was based on histologic International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation (ISHLT)-published criteria.

RESULTS

Ten of 54 patients had a positive enzyme-linked immunoassay (ELISA) post-transplantation. In 90% of ELISA-positive patients, the presence of HLA antibodies was associated with persistent-recurrent acute rejections, compared with 34% in the ELISA-negative group (p < 0.005). There were 28 high-grade acute rejection episodes in the ELISA-positive group, compared with 36 in the ELISA-negative group (p < 0.0001). The ELISA-positive patients required a greater intensity of immunosuppressive therapy. The patients with ELISA-detected anti-HLA antibodies were at least 3-fold more likely to develop high-grade acute rejection and persistent-recurrent acute rejection, and 7-fold more likely to develop multiple episodes of persistent-recurrent acute rejection, compared with ELISA-negative patients.

CONCLUSIONS

ELISA-based screening for the development of HLA antibodies is a reliable method that can identify lung transplant recipients at increased risk for high-grade and persistent-recurrent acute rejection. Although bronchiolitis obliterans appears as a point of no return in the evolution of lung-transplanted patients, early detection of risk factors for acute rejection could indirectly decrease the incidence of bronchiolitis obliterans. These lung-transplanted patients may benefit from an altered strategy of immunosuppression.