European quality system for tissue banking

AIM

The aims of this project were to analyze the factors that influence quality and safety of tissues for transplantation and to develop the method to ensure standards of quality and safety in relation to tissue banking as demanded by European Directive 2004/23/EC and its technical annexes. It is organized in 4 Working Groups, the objectives of each one being focused in a specific area.

STANDARDS

The Guide of Recommendations for Tissue Banking is structured into 4 parts: (1) quality systems that apply to tissue banking and general quality system requirements, (2) regulatory framework in Europe, (3) standards available, and (4) recommendations of the fundamental quality and safety keypoints.

REGISTRY

This Working Group handled design of a multinational musculoskeletal tissue registry prototype.

TRAINING

This Working Group handled design and validation of a specialized training model structured into online and face-to-face courses. The model was improved with suggestions from students, and 100% certification was obtained.

AUDIT

The Guide for Auditing Tissue Establishments provides guidance for auditors, a self-assessment questionnaire, and an audit report form. The effectiveness and sustainability of the outputs were assessed. Both guides are useful for experienced tissue establishments and auditors and also for professionals that are starting in the field. The registry prototype proves it is possible to exchange tissues between establishments throughout Europe. The training model has been effective in educating staff and means having professionals with excellent expertise. Member states could adapt/adopt it. The guides should be updated periodically and perhaps a European organization should take responsibility for this and even create a body of auditors.

Evaluation of transplant procurement management courses: an educational project as a tool for the optimization of transplant coordination

The process of obtaining organs and tissues includes a series of procedures and skills that are fundamental to obtain a large number and high quality of transplants. Health professionals involved in transplant coordination require robest and comprehensive training to integrate the donation-transplantation process within the clinical health care field. Based on a learning-through-experience model, Transplant Procurement Management (TPM) designed various courses adapted to local educational need to train transplant coordinators, to increase active donor detection, and to promote a positive attitude towards donation; namely, Advanced, Introductory and New Life Cycle courses respectively. Moreover, TPM has coordinated international programs (INTERCATT and INTERITALY). Since 1991, the model has included 29 Advanced courses (1215 participants), 22 Introductory courses (575 pupils), and 7 New Life Cycle courses (more than 400 attendees). The Advanced courses were attended by medical (intensive care unit, nephrology, and others) and nursing professionals. Assessment of the educational program showed achievement of teaching objectives. The evaluation averages above 3.5 (scale, 1-5) for content, presentation, and ability to answer questions. Likewise, the program's organization showed an average score of 4.4. The acquired knowledge was assessed by means of a self-evaluation test (correct answers >69%). Practical skills assessed through direct observation showed an average of 7 (scale, 1-10). The TPM educational program offers a range of necessary knowledge and skills to increase organ donation. Health professionals concerned about the organ shortage may find TPM training useful to increase their knowledge.

Persistence of intracranial diastolic flow in transcranial Doppler sonography exploration of patients in brain death

OBJECTIVE

The persistence of cerebral blood flow (CBF) in patients with whole brain death (BD) diagnosis is an unusual phenomenon. We describe patients with whole BD diagnosed despite persistence of intracranial blood flow on transcranial Doppler sonography (TDS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From January 2001 to December 2002, we reviewed the records of 11 patients. Etiology of BD was craniocephalic trauma in 2 cases, schemic cerebrovascular accident (CVA) in 4 cases, Hemorrhagic CVA in 3 cases, subaracnoid hemorrhage in 1 case, and acute hydrocephalus in 1 case. Six patients had a cerebral decompressive mechanism. In all patients, TDS was used to confirm BD after clinical diagnosis. Additionally, all patients underwent an electroencephalogram (EEG). In 3 patients cerebral angiography (CA) and in 2 others radionuclide angiography (RA) with Tc99m HMPAO were done.

RESULTS

All TDS studies showed persistent telediastolic positive flow in at least 1 artery. Because the TDS did not confirm the clinical diagnosis of BD, EEG tests were performed showing silence of bioelectrical activity. Those cases showed CA or RA results with a complete absence of CBF.

CONCLUSION

The TDS technique directly evaluates the intracranial but not the intracerebral circulation. For this reason, during the BD diagnosis for patients with previous decompressive techniques, it was possible to find persistence of intracranial telediastolic flow using TDS. In those cases, it is advisable to use other tests to confirm the clinical diagnosis of BD.

The living kidney donation process: the donor perspective

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the living kidney donation (LKD) process using donors' opinions on the impact on social, emotional, and financial aspects affecting donor quality of life.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From May 2000 to December 2002, we studied 22 donors of living kidneys at the Hospital Clinic, Barcelona, Spain, who completed an anonymous survey 6 months after donation.

RESULTS

Most donors (86%) had themselves informed the recipient about their wish to donate, the other 14% were asked by family members. Eighty-eight percent stated that the information provided to the donor about the evaluation process was well explained and understood whereas 12% disagreed with the statement. At the time of thin decision, 90.5% of donors understood the vital risk. For 95%, the explanations about the process corresponded with the actual experience. One hundred percent of donors stated after donation that they would again favor it. Mean hospital stay was 6 days (range, 3-9 days). Those donors with a labor contract have been out of work for an average of 57.8 days (range, 18 days to 6 months). Twenty-five percent of donors admitted financial effects as a result of donation. All but 1 felt completely recovered with the same quality of life after donation.

DISCUSSION

LKD is a good therapeutic alternative. Some aspects should be developed, such as more information about living donation and the need to considering donors as healthy persons without loss of earnings. Recognition of the benefits of living donation requires more wide participation of all citizens nationally.

Cold chain monitoring during cold transportation of human corneas for transplantation

BACKGROUND

As recommended by international standards the cornea should be maintained in a specific temperature range (2 degrees -8 degrees C) to guarantee its viability. However, there is no standard packaging method to maintain these conditions during transport. Our packaging system is similar to those used by the main eye banks in Spain and elsewhere in Europe. The objective is to monitor the cold chain in the current packaging method to validate the maintenance of temperature within the adequate range for a minimum 24-hour period.

METHODS

The effects of the following variables were studied: number and freezing temperature of the cold packs; air volume in the packaging system; position of the cornea in the packaging system; and the wall section of the container. Exterior temperature was maintained constant at 20 degrees to 24 degrees C. The cold chain was monitored using a device that measures temperature continuously and for which a histogram of temperature variation can be downloaded to a computer for further analysis.

RESULTS

When the cold packs were frozen to -40 degrees C or the number of cold packs increased to four, the temperature decreased quickly to 0 degrees C and the transport period was not prolonged. The main objective was to improve isolation by reducing inner air volume, and maintaining the position of the cornea in the container.

CONCLUSIONS

The currently used cold packaging systems (not frozen, 4 degrees C) do not maintain the temperature within the accepted range for the required distribution period. The improved system maintains the cornea at between 2 degrees C and 6 degrees C for a minimum of 24 hours.

Normothermic recirculation reduces primary graft dysfunction of kidneys obtained from non-heart-beating donors

Our aim was to analyze the short- and long-term function of kidneys procured from non- heartbeating donors (NHBD) by means of three techniques: in situ perfusion (ISP), total body cooling (TBC) and normothermic recirculation (NR). Fifty-seven potential NHBD were included. Mean warm ischemia time was 68.9 +/- 35.6 min. Forty-four kidneys were obtained from donors perfused with ISP, 8 with TBC, and 8 with NR. Eighteen kidneys (32%) started functioning immediately, 29 (52%) showed delayed graft function (DGF) and 9 (16%) showed primary non function (PNF). The actuarial graft survival rate was 76.4% at 1 year and 56% at 5 years. The patient survival rate was 89.3% at 5 years. Incidence of DGF and PNF was significantly lower in kidneys perfused with NR than those with ISP or TBC (P < 0.01). Duration of DGF was shorter in kidneys obtained through TBC than in kidneys obtained with ISP (P < 0.05). In conclusion, NR reduces the incidence of DGF and may be considered the method of choice for kidney procurement from NHBD.

[Laryngeal amyloidosis: treatment vs. abstention]

Four cases of laryngeal amyloidosis diagnosed between 1986 and 1992 are reported. Two cases had supraglottic localization and the remaining two involved both glottis and subglottis. CT was performed in all cases. Diagnosis was made in the four cases by biopsy. All of them were classified as localized laryngeal amyloidosis after doing immunoelectrophoretic study in blood and urine, and rectal biopsy in two cases. Surgical excision by carbon dioxide laser was performed in one patient, while in the remaining three patients, a preservative attitude was taken. Results of both attitudes are presented, as well as a literature review on the topic.

Abnormalities in growth hormone and insulin release in short but otherwise normal patients. The arginine-insulin-glucose (AIGT) stimulation and suppression test

Arginine-insulin stimulation and IV glucose suppression (AIGT) tests were used to evaluate release of insulin and growth hormone. Adult patients responded normally. Hypopituitary patients showed no hGH response. One third of short normal patients showed abnormal hGH responses to glucose suppression. Two thirds of the short normal patients showed poor insulin responses to either amino acid or glucose stimulation. Such patients might have abnormalities in release mechanisms for insulin and suppression mechanisms for hGH and this might contribute to their growth failure.

Primary hypothyroidism. Differentiation from primary hypopituitarism

Five patients with growth failure but few other abnormal clinical signs are presented. Two were shown to have primary hypopituitarism, three had primary hypothyroidism. All received levothyroxine sodium and grew 7.0 to 12.5 cm during the first year and 6.2 to 8.7 cm during the second year of treatment. Three of the adolescent patients developed signs of signs of puberty within six to nine months of initiation of levothyroxine therapy. One hypopituitary patient had femoral epiphysial dysgenesis, hypopglycemia, and undescended testes. One hypothyroid patient had been treated for diabetes mellitus for 8.5 years and may be the youngest patient reported with such a disease combination. We conclude that in a few patients with growth failure without specific clinical signs, diagnosis and differentiation between primary hypothyroidism and primary hypopituitarism can only be made by specific endocrinologic testing.

Down's syndrome. Study of carbohydrate metabolism

Eight adolescent patients with Down's syndrome and short stature were studied. Three of the 8 patients had inadequate plasma insulin response to glucose or to arginine stimulation. The glucose disappearance rate in one of them followed a diabetic pattern. Exogenous insulin disappeared with a mean t½ of 13 min, and the Kt for glucose was 2.276. We conclude that the abnormalities in insulin production and glucose disappearance in a few of the patients suggests a possible diabetic tendency. The short stature and delayed puberty were not due to pituitary deficiency of growth hormone or of gonadotrophins.