1
|
Belpomme D, Carlo GL, Irigaray P, Carpenter DO, Hardell L, Kundi M, Belyaev I, Havas M, Adlkofer F, Heuser G, Miller AB, Caccamo D, De Luca C, von Klitzing L, Pall ML, Bandara P, Stein Y, Sage C, Soffritti M, Davis D, Moskowitz JM, Mortazavi SMJ, Herbert MR, Moshammer H, Ledoigt G, Turner R, Tweedale A, Muñoz-Calero P, Udasin I, Koppel T, Burgio E, Vorst AV. The Critical Importance of Molecular Biomarkers and Imaging in the Study of Electrohypersensitivity. A Scientific Consensus International Report. Int J Mol Sci 2021; 22:7321. [PMID: 34298941 PMCID: PMC8304862 DOI: 10.3390/ijms22147321] [Citation(s) in RCA: 7] [Impact Index Per Article: 2.3] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [MESH Headings] [Track Full Text] [Download PDF] [Figures] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 04/26/2021] [Revised: 06/23/2021] [Accepted: 06/26/2021] [Indexed: 02/07/2023] Open
Abstract
Clinical research aiming at objectively identifying and characterizing diseases via clinical observations and biological and radiological findings is a critical initial research step when establishing objective diagnostic criteria and treatments. Failure to first define such diagnostic criteria may lead research on pathogenesis and etiology to serious confounding biases and erroneous medical interpretations. This is particularly the case for electrohypersensitivity (EHS) and more particularly for the so-called "provocation tests", which do not investigate the causal origin of EHS but rather the EHS-associated particular environmental intolerance state with hypersensitivity to man-made electromagnetic fields (EMF). However, because those tests depend on multiple EMF-associated physical and biological parameters and have been conducted in patients without having first defined EHS objectively and/or endpoints adequately, they cannot presently be considered to be valid pathogenesis research methodologies. Consequently, the negative results obtained by these tests do not preclude a role of EMF exposure as a symptomatic trigger in EHS patients. Moreover, there is no proof that EHS symptoms or EHS itself are caused by psychosomatic or nocebo effects. This international consensus report pleads for the acknowledgement of EHS as a distinct neuropathological disorder and for its inclusion in the WHO International Classification of Diseases.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Dominique Belpomme
- Association for Research Against Cancer (ARTAC), 57/59 rue de la Convention, 75015 Paris, France;
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
| | - George L. Carlo
- The Science and Public Policy Institute, Washington, DC 20006, USA;
| | - Philippe Irigaray
- Association for Research Against Cancer (ARTAC), 57/59 rue de la Convention, 75015 Paris, France;
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
| | - David O. Carpenter
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
- Institute for Health and the Environment, University at Albany, Albany, NY 12222, USA
- Child Health Research Centre, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Queensland, South Brisbane, QLD 4101, Australia
| | - Lennart Hardell
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
- The Environment and Cancer Research Foundation, SE-702 17 Örebro, Sweden
| | - Michael Kundi
- Center for Public Health, Department of Environmental Health, Medical University of Vienna, 1090 Vienna, Austria; (M.K.); (H.M.)
| | - Igor Belyaev
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
- Biomedical Research Center, Slovak Academy of Science, 845 05 Bratislava, Slovakia
| | - Magda Havas
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
- Trent School of the Environment, Trent University, 1600 West Bank Drive, Peterborough, ON K9J 0G2, Canada
| | - Franz Adlkofer
- Verum-Foundation for Behaviour and Environment c/o Regus Center Josephspitalstrasse 15/IV, 80331 München, Germany;
| | - Gunnar Heuser
- Formerly UCLA Medical Center, Department of Medicine, P.O. Box 5066, El Dorado Hills, Los Angeles, CA 95762, USA;
| | - Anthony B. Miller
- Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M5S, Canada;
| | - Daniela Caccamo
- Department of Biomedical Sciences, Dental Sciences and Morpho Functional Imaging, Polyclinic Hospital University, 98122 Messina, Italy;
| | - Chiara De Luca
- Department of Registration & Quality Management, Medical & Regulatory Affairs Manager, MEDENA AG, 8910 Affoltern am Albis, Switzerland;
| | - Lebrecht von Klitzing
- Medical Physicist, Institute of Environmental and Medical Physic, D-36466 Wiesenthal, Germany;
| | - Martin L. Pall
- School of Molecular Biosciences, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164, USA;
| | - Priyanka Bandara
- Oceania Radiofrequency Scientific Advisory Association (ORSAA), P.O. Box 152, Scarborough, QLD 4020, Australia;
| | - Yael Stein
- Faculty of Medicine, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem 91905, Israel;
- Hadassah Medical Center, Department of Anesthesiology, Critical Care and Pain Medicine, Jerusalem 91905, Israel
| | - Cindy Sage
- Sage Associates, Montecito, Santa Barbara, CA 93108, USA;
| | - Morando Soffritti
- Istituto Ramazzini, via Libia 13/A, 40138 Bologna, Italy;
- Collegium Ramazzini, Castello di Bentivoglio, via Saliceto, 3, 40010 Bentivoglio, Italy
| | - Devra Davis
- Environmental Health Trust, P.O. Box 58, Teton Village, WY 83025, USA;
| | - Joel M. Moskowitz
- School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA;
| | - S. M. J. Mortazavi
- Medical Physics and Medical Engineering Department, School of Medicine, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz P.O. Box 71348-14336, Iran;
- Ionizing and Non-ionizing Radiation Protection Research Center (INIRPRC), Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz P.O. Box 71348-14336, Iran
| | - Martha R. Herbert
- A.A. Martinos Centre for Biomedical Imaging, Department of Neurology, MGH, Harvard Medical School, MGH/MIT/Harvard 149 Thirteenth Street, Charlestown, MA 02129, USA;
| | - Hanns Moshammer
- Center for Public Health, Department of Environmental Health, Medical University of Vienna, 1090 Vienna, Austria; (M.K.); (H.M.)
- Department of Hygiene, Karakalpak Medical University, Nukus 230100, Uzbekistan
| | - Gerard Ledoigt
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
| | - Robert Turner
- Department of Pediatrics, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC 29425, USA;
- Clinical Pediatrics and Neurology, School of Medicine, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC 29209, USA
| | - Anthony Tweedale
- Rebutting Industry Science with Knowledge (R.I.S.K.) Consultancy, Blv. Edmond Machtens 101/34, B-1080 Brussels, Belgium;
| | - Pilar Muñoz-Calero
- Foundation Alborada, Finca el Olivar, Carretera M-600, Km. 32,400, 28690 Brunete, Spain;
| | - Iris Udasin
- EOHSI Clinical Center, School of Public Health, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA;
| | - Tarmo Koppel
- AI Institute, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC 29208, USA;
| | - Ernesto Burgio
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
| | - André Vander Vorst
- European Cancer and Environment Research Institute (ECERI), 1000 Brussels, Belgium; (D.O.C.); (L.H.); (I.B.); (M.H.); (G.L.); (E.B.); (A.V.V.)
- European Microwave Association, Rue Louis de Geer 6, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
| |
Collapse
|
26
|
Kaszkin M, Kinzel V, Maly K, Bichler I, Lang F, Grunicke HH, Pepperkok R, Jakobi R, Lorenz P, Ansorge W, Pyerin W, Borowski P, Harbers M, Ludwig A, Kischel T, Hilz H, Eckert K, Granetzny A, Fischer J, Grosse R, Manch V, Wehner S, Kornhuber B, Ebener U, Müller-Decker K, Fürstenberger G, Vogt I, Marks F, Graschew G, Küsel A, Hull W, Lorenz W, Thielmann HW, Degen GH, Freyberger A, Müller A, Linscheid M, Hindermeier U, Jorritsma U, Golka K, Föllmann W, Peter H, Bolt HM, Monnerjahn S, Phillips DN, Never A, Seidel A, Glatt AR, Wiench K, Frei E, Schroth P, Wiessler M, Schäfer T, Hergenhahn M, Hecker E, Proft D, Bartholmes P, Bagewadikar RS, Bertram B, Frank N, Leibersperger H, Gschwendt M, Marks F, Fasco S, Plein P, Schiess K, Seidler L, Jacobi T, Besemfelder E, Stephan M, Lehmann WD, Grell M, Thoma B, Scheurich P, Meyer M, Grunicke H, Jaques G, Wegmann B, Ravemann K, Popanda O, Thielmann HW, Voss H, Wirkner U, Werner D, Strand D, Kalmes A, Walther HP, Mechler B, Schirrmacher SV, Kinzel V, Hess R, Hanagarth HG, Hässler C, Brandner G, Ertel C, Gückel B, Schirrmacher V, Kyewski BA, Bogdahn U, Jachimczak P, Schneider J, Brysch W, Schlingensiepen W, Drenkard D, Behl C, Winkler J, Apfel R, Meixensberger J, Stulle K, Marquardt P, Vollmers HP, Müller J, Müller-Hermelink HK, Schuermann M, Seemann G, Ptok A, Ptok M, Carey TE, Steffen M, Nitz UC, Everding B, Hölzel F, Kantwerk-Funke G, Boll G, Zänker KS, Everding B, Steffen M, Hölzel P, Heymanns J, Hennig C, Rotsch M, Havemann K, Fischer JR, Stehr S, Lahm H, Drings P, Krammer PH, Kirsch M, Strubel A, Kist A, Hinn R, Fischer H, Buttler A, Schackert G, Friedenauer S, Lindner D, Marczynski B, Karcls H, Goergens HW, Epe B, Müller E, Schütze D, Boiteux S, Eder E, Deininger C, Hoffman C, Scherer E, Vermeulen E, van Kranen HJ, Bax J, Woutersen RA, van Kreijl CF, Schurich B, Hagedorn H, Kamp E, Eisenbrand G, Spiegelhalder B, Bolm-Audorff U, Bienfait HG, Preussmann R, Wacker CD, Preussmann R, Kehl H, Spiegelhalder B, Akkan Z, Ries J, Meger M, Shephard SE, Gunz D, Lutz WK, Tricker AR, Kurnar R, Siddiqi M, Mende P, Pfundstein B, Scholl A, Janzowski C, Jacob D, Goelzer P, Henn I, Zankl H, Zimlich KH, Gansewendt B, Thier R, Schroeder KR, Hallier E, Moeckel G, Heiden W, Waldherr-Teschner M, Brickmann J, Roeser H, Krauter G, Scherer G, Krätschmer A, Hauenstein H, Adlkofer F, Fernando RC, Schmeiser HH, Nicklas W, Pfau W, Phillips DH, Scheckenbach S, Cantoreggi S, Leutbecher M, Ottenwälder H, Föst U, Baumgart PM, Kliem HC, Data S, Pfeiffer C, Fuchs A, Schmezer P, Kuchenmeister F, Pool-Zober BL, Liegibel UM, Pool-Zobel BL, Steeb L, Friesel H, Schneider T, Scherf HR, Buchmann A, Bauer-Hofmann R, Mahr J, Schwarz M, Schmidt R, Rippmann F, Steinbauer B, Zlfu P, Bunk B, Hefter W, Klinga K, Berger MR, Robertson LW, Luebeck G, Moolgavkar S, Torsten U, Kowalczyk-Wagner M, Weitzel H, Zechel C, Peters H, Anders F, Ambs S, Kirchner T, Neumann HG, Einig C, Eigenbrodt E, Oesterle D, Deml E, Weisse G, Gerbracht U, Stumpf H, Filsingcr E, Bannasch P, Muster W, Cikryt P, Münzel P, Röhrdanz E, Bock KW, Lipp HP, Wiesmüller T, Hagenmaier H, Schrenk D, Karger A, Bauer G, Höfler P, Götschl M, Viesel E, Jürgensmeier J, Schaefer D, Picht G, Kiefer J, Krieg P, Schnapke R, Feil S, Wagner E, Schleenbecker U, Anders A, Gross MM, Unger S, Stanbridge EJ, Boukamp P, Pascheberg U, Fusenig NE, Abken H, Weidle UH, Grummt F, Willecke K, Schäfer R, Hajnal A, Balmer I, Klemenz R, Goretzki PE, Reishaus H, Demeure M, Haubruck H, Lyons J, Röher HD, Trouliaris S, Hadwiger-Fangmeier A, Simon E, Niemann H, Tamura T, Westphal G, Turner E, Karels H, Blaszkewicz M, Stopper H, Schiffmann D, De Boni U, Schuler M, Schnitzler R, Metzler M, Pfeiffer E, Aulenbacher R, Langhof T, Schröder KR, Saal K, Müller-Hermelink HK, Henn W, Seitz G, Lagoda P, Christmann A, Blin N, Welter C, Adam D, Fömzler D, Winkler C, Mäueler W, Schartl M, Theisinger B, Schüder G, Rüther U, Nunnensiek C, Müller HAG, Rupp W, Lüthgens M, Jipp P, Kinzler I, Gulich M, Seidel HJ, Clark OH, McCormick F, Bourne HR, Gieseler F, Boege F, Biersack H, Spohn B, Clark M, Wilms K, Boege F, Gieseler F, Biersack H, Clark M, Wllms K, Polack A, Strobl L, Feederle R, Schweizer M, Eick D, Bornkamm GW, Kopun M, Scherthan H, Granzow C, Janiaud P, Rueß D, Mechler BM, Strauss PG, Erfle V, Fritsche M, Haessler C, Christiansen H, Schestag J, Christiansen NM, Lampert F, Schulz WA, Hasse A, Sies H, Orend G, Kuhlmann I, Doerfler W, Behn-Krappa A, Hölker I, Sandaradura de Silva U, Smola U, Hennig D, Hadviger-Fangmeier A, Schütz B, Kerler R, Rabes HM, Dölken G, Fauser AA, Kerkert R, Ragoczy U, Fritzen R, Lange W, Finke J, Nowicki B, Schalipp E, Siegert W, Mertelsmann R, Schilling U, Sinn HJ, Maier-Borst W, Friedrich EA, Löhde E, Lück M, Raude H, Schlicker H, Barzen G, Kraas E, Milleck J, Keymer R, Störkel S, Reichert T, Steinbach F, Lippold R, Thoenes W, Wagner W, Reiffen KA, Bardosi A, Brkovic D, Gabius HJ, Brandt B, Jackisch C, Seitzer D, Hillebrand M, Habermann FA, Rabes HM, Zeindl-Eberhart, Evelyn, Robl C, Röttgen V, Nowak C, Richter-Reichhelm HB, Waldmann V, Suchy B, Zietz C, Sarafoff M, Ostermayr R, Rabes HM, Lorenz J, Friedberg T, Paulus W, Ferlinz R, Oesch F, Jähde E, Glüsenkamp KH, Tietze LF, Rajewsky MF, Chen G, Hutter KJ, Bullerdiek J, Zeller WJ, Schirner M, Schneider MR, Zbu P, Gebelein M, Naser-Hijazi B, Hynes NE, Reinhardt M, Heyl P, Schmähl D, Presek P, Liebenhoff U, Findik D, Hartmann GH, Fischer H, Kliesch C, Schackert G, Albert F, Kunze S, Wannnenmacher M, Boese-Landgraf J, Lorenz E, Albrecht D, Dulce M, Aigner KR, Thiem N, Müller H, Leonardi M, Bogdahn U, Justh A, Drenkard D, Lutz M, Apfel R, Behl C, Lang E, Lieth CWVD, Sinn H, Betsch BR, Hengstler JG, Fuchs J, Oesch F, Busch FJ, Cato ABC, Schied G, Tang W, Bogdahn U, Richter B, Schaefer C, Kelleher DK, Vaupel P, Mundt D, Bartsch HH, Meden H, Meyer M, Vehmeyer K, Mull R, Kuhn W, Hoffmann S, Berger D, Fiebig H, Moog C, Luu B, Frühauf S, Keppler BK, Galeano A, Valenzuela-Paz P, Klenner T, Stadler H, Golomb G, Breuer E, Voegeli R, Hilgard P, Nowrousian HR, Aulenbacher P, Winterhalter B, Granson C, Stöhr M, Ponstingl H, Granzow C, Drings P, Osswald H, Sobottka SB, Amtmann E, Sauer G, Hornung B, Volland S, Kahl S, Gerspach R, Matz B, Schmidt J, Lipp M, Brehm G, Luz A, Rüther U, Wendel S, Strauß PG, Erflte V, Greehmann S, Zobel A, Kalkbrenner F, Vorbrüggen G, Moelling K, Iftner T, Müller AH, Fuchs PG, Pfister H, Cichutek K, Treinies I, Lang M, Braun C, Denner J, Norley S, Kurth R, Music L, Wiestler OD, Aguzzi A, von Deimling A, Schneemann M, Elbl R, Kleihues P, Land H, Hohn HP, Höök M, Denker HW, Kemmner W, Zaar K, Jones PA, Kath R, Herlyn M, Maier P, Schawalder HP, Elsner J, Parzefall W, Erber E, Sedivy R, Schulte-Hermann R, Hemmer J, Tomakidi P, Boukamp P, Breitkreutz D, Fusenig NE, Kallinowski F, Strauss W, Brownell AL, Bassukas ID, Vester G, Maurer-Schultze B, Langbein L, Kosmehl H, Katenkamp D, Spiess E, Trefz G, Ebert W, Jordan P, Kübler D, Lichtner RB, Wiedemuth M, Kittmann A, Ullrich A, Khazaie K, Kowitz A, Kadmon G, Altevogt P, Frixen UH, Behrens J, Schipper J, Sachs M, Birchmeier H, Hackenberg R, Hawighorst T, Hofmann J, Beato H, Schulz KD, Erbil C, Maasberg M, Kunz LA, Simm A, Adam G, Mueller-Klieser W, Kaufmann AM, Stoeck M, Hülsen A, Boukamp P, Game S, Donnelly M, Fusenig NE, Stark HJ, Schlingensiepen KH, Kurzik-Dumke U, Phannavong B, Gundacker D, Gateff E, Gabius S, Joshi SS, Franz H, John NJ, Grümmer R, Denker HW, Gross MW, Karbach U. Absract. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol 1991. [DOI: 10.1007/bf01625409] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 11/25/2022]
|