Comment on "Structure-Correlated Magnetic Resonance Transverse Relaxivity Enhancement in Superparamagnetic Ensembles with Complex Anisotropy Landscape"

In a recent article, Konwar et al. [ Langmuir 2022, 38, 11087-11098.] reported a new relationship between the structure of clusters of superparamagnetic nanoparticles and the proton nuclear magnetic resonance transverse relaxation they induce. In this comment, we would like to express reservations concerning the adequacy of the new relaxation model proposed in this work.

Nuclear magnetic resonance relaxometry to monitor chromium (VI) reduction by hydrogen peroxide, ascorbic acid, and aluminum powder

The reduction of K₂ Cr₂ O₇ solutions by H₂ O₂ was studied by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxometry and UV-vis spectroscopy in HCl/KCl buffer (pH 2), NaCl/glycine/HCl buffer (pH 3), and sodium acetate/acetic acid buffer (pH 4). Because of Cr(III) paramagnetism, 1/T₁ and 1/T₂ of the solutions increase during the reduction of diamagnetic Cr(VI). This increase is proportional to the produced Cr(III) concentration. Using different initial H₂ O₂ concentrations, partially reduced Cr(VI) samples were prepared and studied by T₁ and T₂ relaxometry and by UV-vis spectroscopy. The correlation between the relaxation rates and the concentration of Cr(VI) remaining in the sample, measured by spectroscopy, was excellent. It was possible, thanks to the measurement of T₂ , to study the kinetics of the reduction of K₂ Cr₂ O₇ by H₂ O₂ in the pH 3 and pH 4 buffers. The reduction of Cr(VI) by ascorbic acid was successfully monitored by NMR relaxometry in the pH 2 buffer. The presence of complexing molecules/ions was shown to drastically influence the nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion profiles of reduced K₂ Cr₂ O₇ solutions: Both relaxation rates are divided by ~5 when citrate or acetate ions are present and by ~3 in the presence of ascorbic acid. Therefore, the comparison of relaxation results obtained in different reaction mixtures must be done carefully. When all the solutions are set to pH 0, which prevents any complexation, the longitudinal and transverse relaxation rates of all samples become comparable. Finally, as a proof of concept for a turbid solution, the kinetics of the reduction of a K₂ Cr₂ O₇ solution by aluminum powder in the pH 2 buffer was successfully monitored.

A Nanoparticle Ink Allowing the High Precision Visualization of Tissue Engineered Scaffolds by MRI

Hydrogels are widely used as cell scaffolds in several biomedical applications. Once implanted in vivo, cell scaffolds must often be visualized, and monitored overtime. However, cell scaffolds appear poorly contrasted in most biomedical imaging modalities such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). MRI is the imaging technique of choice for high-resolution visualization of low-density, water-rich tissues. Attempts to enhance hydrogel contrast in MRI are performed with "negative" contrast agents that produce several image artifacts impeding the delineation of the implant's contours. In this study, a magnetic ink based on ultra-small iron oxide nanoparticles (USPIONs; <5 nm diameter cores) is developed and integrated into biocompatible alginate hydrogel used in cell scaffolding applications. Relaxometric properties of the magnetic hydrogel are measured, as well as biocompatibility and MR-visibility (T₁ -weighted mode; in vitro and in vivo). A 2-week MR follow-up study is performed in the mouse model, demonstrating no image artifacts, and the retention of "positive" contrast overtime, which allows very precise delineation of tissue grafts with MRI. Finally, a 3D-contouring procedure developed to facilitate graft delineation and geometrical conformity assessment is applied on an inverted template alginate pore network. This proof-of-concept establishes the possibility to reveal precisely engineered hydrogel structures using this USPIONs ink high-visibility approach.

Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Imaging of Melanin in Honey Bee

Honey bees play a crucial role in the nature by pollinating wild flowers. Over the past years, there has been an increasing concern regarding the honey bee colony decline. Pesticides or environmental effects targeting the biochemistry of insect chitin and cuticle coating may be in part responsible for honey bee pathologies. We here propose the use of electron paramagnetic resonance imaging (EPRI) as a tool to image the melanin-chitin complexes as part of the exoskeleton of the honey bee. EPRI at 9.65 GHz was applied on intact freeze-dried bees. The imaging data were collected on the melanin peak. High-resolution images revealed that this compound is extensively distributed in the periphery of the animal, data consistent with the localization in the cuticle of the bee. While EPR of melanin has been so far explored in the context of melanoma characterization, it may offer new opportunities in research on honey bees and other insects.

NMR relaxation properties of the synthetic malaria pigment β-hematin

200 million patients suffer from malaria, a parasitic disease caused by protozoans of the genus Plasmodium. Reliable diagnosis is crucial since it allows the early detection of the disease. The development of rapid, sensitive and low-cost diagnosis tools is an important research area. Different studies focused on the detection of hemozoin, a major by-product of hemoglobin detoxification by the parasite. Hemozoin and its synthetic analog, β-hematin, form paramagnetic crystals. A new detection method of malaria takes advantage of the paramagnetism of hemozoin through the effect that such magnetic crystals have on Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) relaxation of water protons. Indeed, magnetic microparticles cause a shortening of the relaxation times. In this work, the magnetic properties of two types of β-hematin are assessed at different temperatures and magnetic fields. The pure paramagnetism of β-hematin is confirmed. The NMR relaxation of β–hematin suspensions is also studied at different magnetic fields and for different echo-times. Our results help to identify the best conditions for β–hematin detection by NMR: T₂ must be selected, at large magnetic fields and for long echo-times. However, the effect of β-hematin on relaxation does not seem large enough to achieve accurate detection of malaria without any preliminary sample preparation, as microcentrifugation.

Fluorinated Mesoporous Silica Nanoparticles for Binuclear Probes in 1H and 19F Magnetic Resonance Imaging

The development of molecular and cellular magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) procedures has always represented a challenge because of the fact that conventional MRI contrast agents are not directly detected in vivo; in proton MRI (e.g., with the nucleus ¹H), their local concentration is measured through the effect they exert on the signal of hydrogen protons present in their immediate vicinity. Because the contrast effects generated by conventional MRI probes superpose to and can often impede the anatomical information contained in ¹H MRI images, new probes based on a nucleus other than ¹H, are being developed. In this study, we report on the development of fluorinated mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs), which could represent an interesting dual probe that allows two MRI modes: ¹H for high-resolution anatomical information and ¹⁹F for the detection of MSNs used as drug delivery agents. MSNs were synthesized and covalently functionalized either with fluorosilane (FMSNs) or polyfluorosiloxane (polyFMSNs) to enable their detection in ¹⁹F MRI. Then, gadolinium chelates were grafted on the particles to enhance their detectability in ¹H MRI. The physicochemical, textural, and relaxometric properties (¹H and ¹⁹F relaxation times) of the nanoparticles were measured and compared. The ¹⁹F relaxation properties were found to be dependent on the concentration of fluorine; they were also highly sensitive to the presence of gadolinium. The shortest relaxation times were obtained with polyFMSNs. At clinical magnetic field strengths, high ¹H relaxivities and low relaxometric ratios (r₂/r₁ = 1.45; 2.2 for nanoparticles entrapped in hydrogel) were found for both nanoparticle systems. Finally, the visibility of both systems was confirmed in ¹H, and the detectability of polyFMSNs was confirmed in ¹⁹F MRI. This physicochemical and relaxometric study opens the door to the applications of fluorinated silica nanoparticles as theranostic materials allowing dual MRI (¹H and ¹⁹F).

Magnetic resonance relaxation induced by superparamagnetic particles used as contrast agents in magnetic resonance imaging: a theoretical review

Superparamagnetic nanoparticles are used as contrast agents in magnetic resonance imaging and allow, for example, the detection of tumors or the tracking of stem cells in vivo. By producing magnetic inhomogeneities, they influence the nuclear magnetic relaxation times, which results in a darkening, on the image, of the region containing these particles. A great number of studies have been devoted to their magnetic properties, to their synthesis and to their influence on nuclear magnetic relaxation. The theoretical and fundamental understanding of the behavior of these particles is a necessary step in predicting their efficiency as contrast agents, or to be able to experimentally obtain some of their properties from a nuclear magnetic resonance measurement. Many relaxation models have been published, and choosing one of them is not always easy, many parameters and conditions have to be taken into account. Relaxation induced by superparamagnetic particles is generally attributed to an outersphere relaxation mechanism. Each model can only be used under specific conditions (motional averaging regime, static regime, high magnetic field, etc.) or for a particular sequence (Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill, spin echo, free-induction decay, nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion profile, etc.). The parameters included in the equations must be carefully interpreted. In some more complex conditions, simulations are necessary to be able to predict the relaxation rates. A good agreement is usually observed between the theoretical predictions and the experimental results, although some data still cannot be fully understood, such as the dependence of the transverse relaxation on the magnetic field. WIREs Nanomed Nanobiotechnol 2017, 9:e1468. doi: 10.1002/wnan.1468 For further resources related to this article, please visit the WIREs website.

Ferritin Protein Regulates the Degradation of Iron Oxide Nanoparticles

Proteins implicated in iron homeostasis are assumed to be also involved in the cellular processing of iron oxide nanoparticles. In this work, the role of an endogenous iron storage protein-namely the ferritin-is examined in the remediation and biodegradation of magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles. Previous in vivo studies suggest the intracellular transfer of the iron ions released during the degradation of nanoparticles to endogenous protein cages within lysosomal compartments. Here, the capacity of ferritin cages to accommodate and store the degradation products of nanoparticles is investigated in vitro in the physiological acidic environment of the lysosomes. Moreover, it is questioned whether ferritin proteins can play an active role in the degradation of the nanoparticles. The magnetic, colloidal, and structural follow-up of iron oxide nanoparticles and proteins in lysosome-like medium confirms the efficient remediation of potentially harmful iron ions generated by nanoparticles within ferritins. The presence of ferritins, however, delays the degradation of particles due to a complex colloidal behavior of the mixture in acidic medium. This study exemplifies the important implications of intracellular proteins in processes of degradation and metabolization of iron oxide nanoparticles.

NMR relaxation induced by iron oxide particles: testing theoretical models

Superparamagnetic iron oxide particles find their main application as contrast agents for cellular and molecular magnetic resonance imaging. The contrast they bring is due to the shortening of the transverse relaxation time T 2 of water protons. In order to understand their influence on proton relaxation, different theoretical relaxation models have been developed, each of them presenting a certain validity domain, which depends on the particle characteristics and proton dynamics. The validation of these models is crucial since they allow for predicting the ideal particle characteristics for obtaining the best contrast but also because the fitting of T 1 experimental data by the theory constitutes an interesting tool for the characterization of the nanoparticles. In this work, T 2 of suspensions of iron oxide particles in different solvents and at different temperatures, corresponding to different proton diffusion properties, were measured and were compared to the three main theoretical models (the motional averaging regime, the static dephasing regime, and the partial refocusing model) with good qualitative agreement. However, a real quantitative agreement was not observed, probably because of the complexity of these nanoparticulate systems. The Roch theory, developed in the motional averaging regime (MAR), was also successfully used to fit T 1 nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion (NMRD) profiles, even outside the MAR validity range, and provided a good estimate of the particle size. On the other hand, the simultaneous fitting of T 1 and T 2 NMRD profiles by the theory was impossible, and this occurrence constitutes a clear limitation of the Roch model. Finally, the theory was shown to satisfactorily fit the deuterium T 1 NMRD profile of superparamagnetic particle suspensions in heavy water.

Improvement of the Off-Resonance Saturation, an MRI sequence for positive contrast with SPM particles: Theoretical and experimental study

The SuperParaMagnetic particles (SPM particles) are used as contrast agents in MRI and produce negative contrast with conventional T2 or T2(∗)-weighted sequences. Unfortunately, the SPM particle detection on images acquired with such sequences is sometimes difficult because negative contrast can be created by artifacts such as air bubbles or calcification. To overcome this problem, new sequences as Off-Resonance Saturation (ORS) were developed to produce positive contrast with SPM particles. This work explores a new way to optimize the contrast generated by the ORS sequence by increasing the number of saturation pulses applied before the imaging sequence. This modified sequence is studied with numerical simulations and experiments on agarose gel phantoms. A theoretical model able to predict the contrast for different values of the sequence parameters is also developed. The results show that the contrast increases with the saturation pulses number with an optimal value of three saturation pulses in order to avoid artifacts and limit the Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) effect. The dependence of the contrast on the SPM particle concentration and sequence parameters is comparable to what was observed for the ORS sequence.

Sample Shuttling Relaxometry of Contrast Agents: NMRD Profiles above 1 T with a Single Device

Nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion (NMRD) profiles are essential tools to evaluate the efficiency and investigate the properties of magnetic compounds used as contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), namely gadolinium chelates and superparamagnetic iron oxide particles. These curves represent the evolution of proton relaxation rates with the magnetic field. NMRD profiles are unparalleled to probe extensively the spectral density function involved in the relaxation of water in the presence of the paramagnetic ion or the magnetic nanoparticles. This makes such profiles an excellent test of the adequacy of a theoretical relaxation model and allow for a predictive approach to the development and optimization of contrast agents. From a practical point of view they also allow to evaluate the efficiency of a contrast agent in a certain range of magnetic fields. Nowadays, these curves are recorded with commercial fast field cycling devices, often limited to a maximum Larmor frequency of 40 MHz (0.94 T). In this article, relaxation data were acquired on a wide range of magnetic fields, from 3.5 × 10-4 to 14 T, for a gadolinium-based contrast agent and for PEGylated iron oxide nanoparticles. We show that the low-field NMRD curves can be completed with high-field data obtained on a shuttle apparatus device using the superconductive magnet of a high-field spectrometer. This allows a better characterization of the contrast agents at relevant magnetic fields for clinical and preclinical MRI, but also refines the experimental data that could be used for the validation of relaxation models.

Bottom-up study of the MRI positive contrast created by the Off-Resonance Saturation sequence

Superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPM particles) are used in MRI to highlight regions such as tumors through negative contrast. Unfortunately, sources as air bubbles or tissues interfaces also lead to negative contrast, which complicates the image interpretation. New MRI sequences creating positive contrast in the particle surrounding, such as the Off-Resonance Saturation sequence (ORS), have thus been developed. However, a theoretical study of the ORS sequence is still lacking, which hampers the optimization of this sequence. For this reason, this work provides a self-consistent analytical expression able to predict the dependence of the contrast on the sequence parameters and the SPM particles properties. This expression was validated by numerical simulations and experiments on agarose gel phantoms on a 11.7 T scanner system. It provides a fundamental understanding of the mechanisms leading to positive contrast, which could allow the improvement of the sequence for future in vivo applications. The influence of the SPM particle relaxivities, the SPM particle concentration, the echo time and the saturation pulse parameters on the contrast were investigated. The best contrast was achieved with SPM particles possessing the smallest transverse relaxivity, an optimal particle concentration and for low echo times.

Theoretical and experimental study of ON-Resonance Saturation, an MRI sequence for positive contrast with superparamagnetic nanoparticles

Superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPM particles) are widely used in MRI as negative contrast agents. Their detection is sometimes difficult because negative contrast can be caused by different artifacts. To overcome this problem, MRI protocols achieving positive contrast specific to SPM particles were developed such as the ON-Resonance Saturation (ONRS) sequence. The aim of the present work is to achieve a bottom-up study of the ONRS sequence by an understanding of the physical mechanisms leading to positive contrast. A complete theoretical modeling, a novel numerical simulation approach and experiments on agarose gel phantoms on a 11.7 T MRI system were carried out for this purpose. The influence of the particle properties and concentration - as well as the effect of the sequence parameters on the contrast - were investigated. It was observed that theory and experiments were in strong agreement. The tools developed in this work allowed to predict the parameters leading to the maximum contrast. For example, particles presenting a low transverse relaxivity can provide an interesting positive contrast after optimization of their concentration in the sample.

Metal chelate grafting at the surface of mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs): physico-chemical and biomedical imaging assessment

A physico-chemical characterization and dual in vivo imaging (PET/MRI) of MSNs functionalized with DTPA and labeled with Gd³⁺ and ⁶⁴Cu²⁺.

Biodegradation mechanisms of iron oxide monocrystalline nanoflowers and tunable shield effect of gold coating

Understanding the relation between the structure and the reactivity of nanomaterials in the organism is a crucial step towards efficient and safe biomedical applications. The multi-scale approach reported here, allows following the magnetic and structural transformations of multicore maghemite nanoflowers in a medium mimicking intracellular lysosomal environment. By confronting atomic-scale and macroscopic information on the biodegradation of these complex nanostuctures, we can unravel the mechanisms involved in the critical alterations of their hyperthermic power and their Magnetic Resonance imaging T1 and T2 contrast effect. This transformation of multicore nanoparticles with outstanding magnetic properties into poorly magnetic single core clusters highlights the harmful influence of cellular medium on the therapeutic and diagnosis effectiveness of iron oxide-based nanomaterials. As biodegradation occurs through surface reactivity mechanism, we demonstrate that the inert activity of gold nanoshells can be exploited to protect iron oxide nanostructures. Such inorganic nanoshields could be a relevant strategy to modulate the degradability and ultimately the long term fate of nanomaterials in the organism.

Effect of magnetic field and iron content on NMR proton relaxation of liver, spleen and brain tissues

Iron accumulation is observed in liver and spleen during hemochromatosis and important neurodegenerative diseases involve iron overload in brain. Storage of iron is ensured by ferritin, which contains a magnetic core. It causes a darkening on T2 -weighted MR images. This work aims at improving the understanding of the NMR relaxation of iron-loaded human tissues, which is necessary to develop protocols of iron content measurements by MRI. Relaxation times measurements on brain, liver and spleen samples were realized at different magnetic fields. Iron content was determined by atomic emission spectroscopy. For all samples, the longitudinal relaxation rate (1/T1 ) of tissue protons decreases with the magnetic field up to 1 T, independently of iron content, while their transverse relaxation rate (1/T2 ) strongly increases with the field, either linearly or quadratically, or a combination thereof. The extent of the inter-echo time dependence of 1/T2 also varies according to the sample. A combination of theoretical models is necessary to describe the relaxation of iron-containing tissues. This can be due to the presence, inside tissues, of ferritin clusters of different sizes and densities. When considering all samples, a correlation (r(2)  = 0.6) between 1/T1 and iron concentration is observed at 7.0 T. In contrast the correlation between 1/T2 and iron content is poor, even at high field (r(2)  = 0.14 at 7.0 T). Our results show that MRI methods based on T1 or T2 measurements will easily detect an iron overloading at high magnetic field, but will not provide an accurate quantification of tissue iron content at low iron concentrations.

Manganese-impregnated mesoporous silica nanoparticles for signal enhancement in MRI cell labelling studies

Mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) are used in drug delivery and cell tracking applications. As Mn(2+) is already implemented as a "positive" cell contrast agent in preclinical imaging procedures (in the form of MnCl2 for neurological studies), the introduction of Mn in the porous network of MSNs would allow labelling cells and tracking them using MRI. These particles are in general internalized in endosomes, an acidic environment with high saline concentration. In addition, the available MSN porosity could also serve as a carrier to deliver medical/therapeutic substances through the labelled cells. In the present study, manganese oxide was introduced in the porous network of MCM-48 silica nanoparticles (Mn-M48SNs). The particles exhibit a narrow size distribution (~140 nm diam.) and high porosity (~60% vol.), which was validated after insertion of Mn. The resulting Mn-M48SNs were characterized by TEM, N2 physisorption, and XRD. Evidence was found with H2-TPR, and XPS characterization, that Mn(II) is the main oxidation state of the paramagnetic species after suspension in water, most probably in the form of Mn-OOH. The colloidal stability as a function of time was confirmed by DLS in water, acetate buffer and cell culture medium. In NMR data, no significant evidence of Mn(2+) leaching was found in Mn-M48SNs in acidic water (pH 6), up to 96 hours after suspension. High longitudinal relaxivity values of r1 = 8.4 mM(-1) s(-1) were measured at 60 MHz and 37 °C, with the lowest relaxometric ratios (r2/r1 = 2) reported to date for a Mn-MSN system. Leukaemia cells (P388) were labelled with Mn-M48SNs and nanoparticle cell internalization was confirmed by TEM. Finally, MRI contrast enhancement provided by cell labelling with escalated incubation concentrations of Mn-M48SNs was quantified at 1 T. This study confirmed the possibility of efficiently confining Mn into M48SNs using incipient wetness, while maintaining an open porosity and relatively high pore volume. Because these Mn-labelled M48SNs express strong "positive" contrast media properties at low concentrations, they are potentially applicable for cell tracking and drug delivery methodologies.

High relaxivities and strong vascular signal enhancement for NaGdF4 nanoparticles designed for dual MR/optical imaging

Near-infrared (NIR)-to-NIR upconverting NaY(Gd)F4 :Tm(3+) ,Yb(3+) paramagnetic nanoparticles (NPs) are efficiently detected by NIR imaging techniques. As they contain Gd(3+) ions, they also provide efficient "positive" contrast in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Water-dispersible small (≈25 nm, "S-") and ultrasmall (<5 nm diam., "US-") NaY(Gd)F4 :Tm(3+) ,Yb(3+) NPs are synthesized by thermal decomposition and capped with citrate. The surface of citrate-coated US-NPs shows sodium depletion and high Gd elemental ratios, as confirmed by a comparative X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS)/neutron absorption analysis study. US-NaGd0.745 F4 :Tm0.005 ,Yb0.25 NPs have hydrodynamic diameters close to that measured by TEM, with the lowest relaxometric ratios (r2 /r1 = 1.18) reported for NaGdF4 nanoparticle suspensions (r1 = 3.37 mM(-1) s(-1) at 1.4 T and 37 °C). Strong relaxivity peaks in the range of 20 (0.47 T) - 300 MHz (7.05 T) are revealed in nuclear magnetic resonance dispersion profiles, with high r2 /r1 ratios at increasing field strengths for S-NPs. This indicates the superiority of US-NPs over S-NPs for achieving high positive contrast at clinical MRI field strengths. I.-v. injected citrate-coated US-NPs evidence long blood retention times (>90 min) in mice. Biodistribution studies (48 h, 8 d) show elimination through the reticuloendothelial and urinary systems, similarly to other citrate-capped US-NP systems. In summary, upconverting NaY(Gd)F4 :Tm(3+) ,Yb(3+) nanoparticles have promising luminescent, relaxometric and blood-retention properties for dual MRI/optical imaging.

Imaging: high relaxivities and strong vascular signal enhancement for NaGdF4 nanoparticles designed for dual MR/optical imaging (Adv. Healthcare Mater. 11/2013)

Tripositive gadolinium-ion doped NIR-to-NIR upconverting paramagnetic nanoparticles are efficiently detected are NIR imaging techniques but can also provide efficient "positive" contrast in MRI. On page 1478 John A. Capobianco, Marc-André Fortin, and co-workers show that citrate-coated nanoparticles present the lowest relaxometric ratios reported for NaGdF4 nanoparticle suspensions. IV-injected nanoparticles evidence long blood retention times in mice while biodistribution studies show elimination through the reticuloendothelial and urinary systems.

New simulation approach using classical formalism to water nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersions in presence of superparamagnetic particles used as MRI contrast agents

Superparamagnetic nanoparticles are used as negative contrast agents in magnetic resonance imaging: owing to their large magnetic moment the water proton spins are dephased, which accelerates the nuclear magnetic relaxation of an aqueous sample containing these particles. Transverse and longitudinal relaxation times depend on several parameters of the nanoparticles such as radius and magnetization and on experimental parameters such as the static magnetic field or echo time. In this work, we introduce a new simulation methodology, using a classical formalism, allowing the simulation of the NMR signal during transverse and longitudinal relaxation induced by superparamagnetic particles in an aqueous solution, which, to our knowledge has never been done before. Nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion profiles are obtained for a wide range of nanoparticle radii and magnetizations. The results can be classified in two regimes--the well-known motional averaging and static regimes. This generalizes previous studies focusing on transverse relaxation at high magnetic field (larger than 1 T). Simulation results correspond to analytical theories in their validity range and so far unknown dependences of the relaxation with magnetization and radii of the NMR dispersions profiles are observed, which could be used to characterize experimental samples containing large superparamagnetic particles.

MnO-labeled cells: positive contrast enhancement in MRI

Manganese oxide (MnO) nanoparticles have been suggested as a promising "positive" MRI contrast agent for cellular and molecular studies. Mn-based contrast agents could enable T(1)-weighted quantitative cell tracking procedures in vivo based on signal enhancement. In this study, ultrasmall MnO particles were synthesized and coated with thiolated molecules (DMSA) and polyethylene glycol (PEG) to allow enhanced cell labeling properties and colloidal stability. This coating allowed the fabrication of individual ultrasmall nanoparticles of MnO (USPMnO) as well as of nanoaggregates of the same material (SPMnO). Particle size was measured by TEM and DLS. Physico-chemical properties were characterized by XPS and FTIR. The relaxometric properties of these aqueous suspensions were measured at various magnetic fields. The suspensions provided strong positive contrast enhancement in T(1)-weighted imaging due to high longitudinal relaxivities (r(1)) and low r(2)/r(1) ratios (USPMnO: r(1) = 3.4 ± 0.1 mM(-1)s(-1), r(2)/r(1) = 3.2; SPMnO: r(1) = 17.0 ± 0.5 mM(-1)s(-1), r(2)/r(1) = 4.0, at 1.41T). HT-1080 cancer cells incubated with the contrast agents were clearly visualized in MRI for Mn contents >1.1 pg Mn/cell. The viability of cells was not affected, contrarily to cells labeled with an equivalent concentration of Mn(2+) ions. A higher signal per cell was found for SPMnO-labeled compared with USPMnO-labeled cells, due to the higher relaxometric properties of the agglomerates. As a result, the "positive" signal enhancement effect is not significantly affected upon agglomeration of MnO particles in endosomes. This is a major requirement in the development of reliable cell tracking procedures using T(1)-weighted imaging sequences. This study confirms the potential of SPMnO and USPMnO to establish more quantitative cell tracking procedures with MRI.

Rapid synthesis of PEGylated ultrasmall gadolinium oxide nanoparticles for cell labeling and tracking with MRI

Ultrasmall paramagnetic Gd(2)O(3) nanoparticles have been developed as contrast agents for molecular and cellular preclinical MRI procedures. These small particles (mean diameter <5 nm) have the highest Gd density of all paramagnetic contrast agents. They generate strong positive contrast enhancement in T(1)-weighted MRI. Signal enhancement is modulated by the interactions of water molecules with Gd, and very small particles provide the optimal surface-to-volume ratios necessary to reach high relaxivities. Conventional Gd(2)O(3) nanocrystal synthesis techniques, and subsequent polyethylene glycol (PEG) grafting procedures are usually time-consuming and recovery losses are also limitative. The present study reports on a new, fast, and efficient one-pot Gd(2)O(3) synthesis technique that provides PEGylated nanoparticles of very small size (mean diameter = 1.3 nm). Readily coated with PEG, the particles are colloidally stable in aqueous media and provide high longitudial relaxivities and small r(2)/r(1) ratios (r(1) = 14.2 mM(-1) s(-1) at 60 MHz; r(2)/r(1) = 1.20), ideal for T(1)-weighted MRI. In this study, F98 brain cancer cells (glioblastoma multiforme) were labeled with the contrast agent and implanted in vivo (mice brains). The labeled cells appeared positively contrasted at least 48 h after implantation. Each one of the implanted animals developed a brain tumor. The performance of PEG-Gd(2)O(3) was also compared with that of commercially available iron oxide nanoparticles. This study demonstrated that ultrasmall PEG-Gd(2)O(3) nanoparticles provide strong positive contrast enhancement in T(1)-weighted imaging, and allow the visualization of labeled cells implanted in vivo.

A universal scaling law to predict the efficiency of magnetic nanoparticles as MRI T(2)-contrast agents

Magnetic particles are very efficient magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) contrast agents. In recent years, chemists have unleashed their imagination to design multi-functional nanoprobes for biomedical applications including MRI contrast enhancement. This study is focused on the direct relationship between the size and magnetization of the particles and their nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation properties, which condition their efficiency. Experimental relaxation results with maghemite particles exhibiting a wide range of sizes and magnetizations are compared to previously published data and to well-established relaxation theories with a good agreement. This allows deriving the experimental master curve of the transverse relaxivity versus particle size and to predict the MRI contrast efficiency of any type of magnetic nanoparticles. This prediction only requires the knowledge of the size of the particles impermeable to water protons and the saturation magnetization of the corresponding volume. To predict the T(2) relaxation efficiency of magnetic single crystals, the crystal size and magnetization - obtained through a single Langevin fit of a magnetization curve - is the only information needed. For contrast agents made of several magnetic cores assembled into various geometries (dilute fractal aggregates, dense spherical clusters, core-shell micelles, hollow vesicles…), one needs to know a third parameter, namely the intra-aggregate volume fraction occupied by the magnetic materials relatively to the whole (hydrodynamic) sphere. Finally a calculation of the maximum achievable relaxation effect - and the size needed to reach this maximum - is performed for different cases: maghemite single crystals and dense clusters, core-shell particles (oxide layer around a metallic core) and zinc-manganese ferrite crystals.

Monte Carlo simulation and theory of proton NMR transverse relaxation induced by aggregation of magnetic particles used as MRI contrast agents

Superparamagnetic particles are widely used in MRI as R2 contrast agents. In this last decade, different studies have focused on aggregation of superparamagnetic particles for important applications such as multimodal agents. A complete study--via simulations--of the influence of aggregation on the MR efficiency of these particles at high magnetic field is presented here. First, an empirical expression is proposed for R2 in the presence of uniformly distributed nanoparticles, taking into account two regimes at once (motional averaging and slow motion regimes). Three cluster shapes are simulated: Sphere, shell and line. An analytical model is proposed to understand water transverse relaxation induced by spherical and shell aggregates. Simulations lead to the conclusion that, in the motional averaging regime, the most efficient aggregate contrast agent is the densest sphere or shell.

Impact of agglomeration on the relaxometric properties of paramagnetic ultra-small gadolinium oxide nanoparticles

Ultra-small gadolinium oxide nanoparticles (US-Gd(2)O(3)) are used to provide 'positive' contrast effects in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and are being considered for molecular and cellular imaging applications. However, these nanoparticles can aggregate over time in aqueous medium, as well as when internalized into cells. This study is aimed at measuring in vitro, in aqueous medium, the impact of aggregation on the relaxometric properties of paramagnetic US-Gd(2)O(3) particles. First, the nanoparticle core size as well as aggregation behaviour was assessed by HRTEM. DLS (hydrodynamic diameter) was used to measure the hydrodynamic diameter of nanoparticles and nanoaggregates. The relaxometric properties were measured by NMRD profiling, as well as with (1)H NMR relaxometers. Then, the positive contrast enhancement effect was assessed by using magnetic resonance scanners (at 1.5 and 7 T). At every magnetic field, the longitudinal relaxivity (r(1)) decreased upon agglomeration, while remaining high enough to provide positive contrast. On the other hand, the transverse relaxivity (r(2)) slightly decreased at 0.47 and 1.41 T, but it was enhanced at higher fields (7 and 11.7 T) upon agglomeration. All NMRD profiles revealed a characteristic relaxivity peak in the range 60-100 MHz, suggesting the possibility to use US-Gd(2)O(3) as an efficient 'positive-T(1)' contrast agent at clinical magnetic fields (1-3 T), in spite of aggregation.

NMR relaxation and magnetic properties of superparamagnetic nanoworms

Maghemite particles are used as T₂ contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging, especially for molecular and cellular imaging. Linear clusters of particles - called nanoworms - were recently developed to enhance the targeting efficiency. In this work, the magnetic and NMR relaxation properties of these nanoworms are studied at multiple magnetic fields. After the usual saturation at 0.5 T, the magnetization of the worms is still increasing, which results in an appreciable increase of the transverse relaxivity at high magnetic fields. The obtained relaxivities are typical of superparamagnetic particles of iron oxide (SPIOs). The transverse relaxation of the worms is clearly more efficient than for the isolated grains, which is confirmed by computer simulations. At high field, the longitudinal relaxation of the worms is less pronounced than for the grains, as expected for SPIOs. The nanoworms thus constitute a promising T₂ agent for cellular and molecular imaging.

Variable-field relaxometry of iron-containing human tissues: a preliminary study

Excess iron is found in brain nuclei from neurodegenerative patients (with Parkinson's, Alzheimer's and Huntington's diseases) and also in the liver and spleen of cirrhosis, hemochromatosis and thalassaemia patients. Ferritin, the iron-storing protein of mammals, is known to darken T(2)-weighted MR images. Understanding NMR tissue behavior may make it possible to detect those diseases, to follow their evolution and finally to establish a protocol for non-invasive measurement of an organ's iron content using MRI methods. In this preliminary work, the MR relaxation properties of embalmed iron-containing tissues were studied as well as their potential correlation with the iron content of these tissues. Relaxometric measurements (T(1) and T(2)) of embalmed samples of brain nuclei (caudate nucleus, dentate nucleus, globus pallidus, putamen, red nucleus and substantia nigra), liver and spleen from six donors were made at different magnetic fields (0.00023-14 T). The influence of the inter-echo time on transverse relaxation was also studied. Moreover, iron content of tissues was determined by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy. In brain nuclei, 1/T(2) increases quadratically with the field and depends on the inter-echo time in CPMG sequences at high fields, both features compatible with an outer sphere relaxation theory. In liver and spleen, 1/T(2) increases linearly with the field and depends on the inter-echo time at all fields. In our study, a correlation between 1/T(2) and iron concentration is observed. Explaining the relaxation mechanism for these tissues is likely to require a combination of several models. The value of 1/T(2) at high field could be used to evaluate iron accumulation in vivo. In the future, confirmation of those features is expected to be achieved from measurements of fresh (not embalmed) human tissues.

Physico-chemical and NMR relaxometric characterization of gadolinium hydroxide and dysprosium oxide nanoparticles

Gadolinium hydroxide and dysprosium oxide nanoparticles, which constitute a new interesting class of magnetic nanoparticles, are characterized by different methods, using x-ray diffraction, magnetometry and NMR relaxometry at multiple fields. The rod-like particles are first shown to have a simple paramagnetic behavior, like the bulk compound, without any influence of the nanometric size of the particles. Because of their paramagnetic moment, these particles considerably shorten water relaxation times, especially the transverse relaxation time at high fields. The relaxation induced by gadolinium hydroxide particles is due to a proton exchange between the particle surface and bulk water, while the transverse relaxation caused by dysprosium oxide particles is governed by the diffusion of water protons around the magnetized particles. 1/T(2) increases linearly with the magnetic field for gadolinium hydroxide particles while a quadratic increase is observed for dysprosium oxide nanoparticles. The relaxation results are compared with those from previous studies and interpreted using different theories for the relaxation induced by magnetic particles.

Relaxation by clustered ferritin: a model for ferritin-induced relaxation in vivo

Ferritin, the iron-storing protein of mammals, is known to darken T(2)-weighted MR images. This darkening could be used for the non-invasive measurement of an organ's iron content. Unexplained discrepancies exist between T(2) data obtained in ferritin-containing tissues and aqueous solutions of ferritin. The clustering of the protein induced by trypsin is used to evaluate the effect of ferritin agglomeration on the relaxation rates. Although the longitudinal relaxation is not significantly influenced by clustering, T(2) depends greatly on the stage of agglomeration: the transverse relaxation rate is higher for a clustered sample than for an unclustered sample. Moreover, the field and inter-echo time dependences of the relaxation rate indicate that the relaxation mechanism may be different between small clusters -- where a linear dependence of 1/T(2) on B(0) is observed -- and large clusters -- where a quadratic dependence is observed. These results help to explain the relaxation induced by ferritin in tissues.

Comparative analysis of the 1H NMR relaxation enhancement produced by iron oxide and core-shell iron-iron oxide nanoparticles

Physicochemical and magnetorelaxometric characterization of the colloidal suspensions consisting of Fe-based nanoparticles coated with dextran have been carried out. Iron oxide and iron core/iron oxide shell nanoparticles were obtained by laser-induced pyrolysis of Fe(CO)5 vapours. Under different magnetic field strengths, the colloidal suspension formed by iron oxide nanoparticles showed longitudinal (R1) and transverse (R2) nuclear magnetic relaxation suspension (NMRD) profiles, similar to those previously reported for other commercial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) contrast agents. However, colloidal suspension formed by ferromagnetic iron-core nanoparticles showed a strong increase of the R1 values at low applied magnetic fields and a strong increase of the R2 measured at high applied magnetic field. This behaviour was explained considering the larger magnetic aggregate size and saturation magnetization values measured for this sample, 92 nm and 31 emu/g Fe, respectively, with respect to those measured for the colloidal suspensions of iron oxide nanoparticles (61 nm and 23 emu/g Fe). This suspension can be used both as T1 and T2 contrast agent.

Relaxivities of human liver and spleen ferritin

Ferritin, the iron-storing protein of mammals, is known to darken T2-weighted magnetic resonance images. This darkening can be used to noninvasively measure an organ's iron content. Significant discrepancies exist between T2 data obtained with ferritin-containing tissues and with aqueous solutions of horse spleen ferritin (HSF). The NMR properties of stable human ferritin have never been studied in aqueous solutions. Relaxometry results on human liver and spleen ferritin are reported here, showing that the relaxation induced in aqueous solutions by human ferritins is comparable to that induced by HSF. As a consequence, the differences between ferritin-containing human tissues and ferritin solutions cannot be attributed to different NMR properties of human and horse ferritins, but probably to a clustering of the protein in vivo.

Looking for biogenic magnetite in brain ferritin using NMR relaxometry

Mammalian cellular iron is stored inside the multisubunit protein ferritin, normally taking the structure of a ferrihydrite-like mineral core. It has been suggested that biogenic magnetite, which has been detected in the brain and may be related to neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases, could initially form in ferritin. Indeed, as ferritin is present in the brain, the ferrihydrite core could be a precursor for biogenic magnetite formation--particularly in cases where the normal functioning of the ferritin protein is disrupted. In this work, NMR relaxometry was used to detect magnetite inside samples of ferritin extracted from normal and Alzheimer-diseased brains. The method was first calibrated with different fractions of horse spleen ferritin and synthetic magnetite particles. The relaxometry results suggest that the proportion of iron contained in brain ferritin in the form of well-crystallized magnetite instead of ferrihydrite must be <1%, which is much less than that reported for 'magnetite-like' phase in recent transmission electron microscopy studies of similar samples. Consequently, the magnetization of this 'magnetite-like' phase must be very low compared with that of magnetite.

Ferritin-induced relaxation in tissues: an in vitro study

PURPOSE

To study in vitro the proton relaxation induced in tissues by ferritin, the iron-storing protein of mammals.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion (NMRD) profiles of liver and spleen from control and iron-overloaded mice are compared with NMRD profiles of ferritin and Fercayl-a ferritin-like akaganeite particle-in aqueous solutions or in 1% agarose gel.

RESULTS

The relaxation of water protons induced by ferritin and Fercayl in 1% agarose gel is comparable with the relaxation of aqueous solutions of the same compounds, but slower than the relaxation of liver and spleen. The gel is not a good model of tissues containing ferritin. The longitudinal NMRD profiles of control and iron-overloaded liver and spleen are almost identical: ferritin accumulation has only a slight effect on longitudinal relaxation. The transverse NMRD profiles of liver and spleen tissues are linear, but the slope of the linear regression is larger for iron-loaded organs than for control ones, which is a consequence of a higher ferritin concentration in the former. However, the correlation between the slope of the transverse NMRD profiles and the iron concentration is not very good, probably because transverse relaxation is modified by the clustering of ferritin in cells.

CONCLUSION

It could be difficult to develop a general technique for the accurate quantification of ferritin-bound iron by nuclear magnetic resonance or magnetic resonance imaging.

Relaxation induced by ferritin: a better understanding for an improved MRI iron quantification

Ferritin, the iron storing protein, is known to darken T2-weighted MRI. This darkening can be used to non-invasively measure iron content. However, ferritin's behavior is not the same in tissue as in solution, a discrepancy that remains unexplained by the recently developed theory matching the NMR properties of ferritin solutions. A better understanding of the relaxation induced by ferritin in tissue could help for the development of new MRI protocols of iron quantification. In this short review, the main relaxation properties of ferritin in solution and in tissue are presented together with a discussion of the possible reasons for the faster transverse relaxation observed in tissues.

Anomalous nuclear magnetic relaxation of aqueous solutions of ferritin: an unprecedented first-order mechanism

Ferritin, the iron-storing protein, speeds up proton transverse magnetic relaxation in aqueous solutions. This T(2) shortening is used in MRI to quantify iron in the brain and liver. Current theoretical models underestimate the relaxation enhancement by ferritin at imaging fields, and they do not predict the measured dependence of the rate enhancement on the magnetization of the particles. Here it is shown that a proton exchange dephasing model (PEDM) overcomes these limitations by allowing a first-order relaxation mechanism. The PEDM considers proton exchange between bulk water and exchangeable protons located at the surface of the hydrated iron oxide nanometric core of the protein. Relaxation is shown to depend on the distribution of the frequency shifts of the adsorption sites; the observed properties agree with a Lorentzian distribution. Computer simulations utilizing recent Mössbauer spectroscopy data show that the distribution of these shifts is effectively Lorentzian.

An evaluation of the contributions of diffusion and exchange in relaxation enhancement by MRI contrast agents

Magnetic compounds are known to enhance water proton relaxation, either by diffusion or by proton exchange. An experimental procedure to distinguish both mechanisms is proposed and validated by relaxation measurements made in water-methanol solutions of Dy(3+), Ni(2+), Gd(3+), Tempo, and AMI-25. The test discriminates according to the character of the transverse relaxation in water-methanol solutions: a mono-exponential decay corresponds to diffusion, while a bi-exponential decay indicates the contribution of a proton exchange. The study of ferritin and akaganeite particle solutions confirms the occurrence of a proton exchange between protons belonging to hydroxyl groups of the particle surface and free water protons.

Cesium adsorption in hydrated iron oxide particles suspensions: an NMR study

137Cs is an important component of nuclear waste which may pollute water. Its migration in natural environments is slowed down by adsorption on minerals. Cesium adsorption on akaganeite (beta-FeOOH) particles, dextran-coated ferrihydrite (5 Fe(2)O(3)-9H(2)O) particles, and ferritin in aqueous solutions is studied with (133)Cs nuclear magnetic resonance measurements. The longitudinal relaxation time (T(1)) of (133)Cs in the presence of such magnetic particles depends on whether the ions bind to the particle or not. T(1) of (133)Cs ions in aqueous solutions containing the same amount of magnetized particles will not depend on cesium concentration if relaxation is governed by diffusion (when cesium is not able to bind), but it will depend on cesium concentration if exchange governs relaxation (when cesium is able to bind). The method is successfully tested using TEMPO, a nitroxide stable free radical whose relaxation is due to diffusion. (133)Cs relaxation in solutions of ferritin, akaganeite, and dextran-coated ferrihydrite particles is found to result from a cationic exchange of cesium ions between particles surface and bulk ions, owing to adsorption. The effect of pH on (133)Cs relaxation in solutions of the particles is consistent with the adsorption properties of cations on hydrated iron oxides.

Susceptibility-induced T(2)-shortening and unrestricted diffusion

In this work, discrepancies between recent theories for susceptibility-induced T(2)-shortening and classical results, namely outer sphere theory and diffusion through local fields with random gradients, are considered. These discrepancies are assigned to the use of unrestricted diffusion in the new theories.

Nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion of ferritin and ferritin-like magnetic particle solutions: a pH-effect study

The relaxation mechanism of water protons in the presence of ferritin is still being debated. In this work, the pH dependence of the relaxation induced by ferritin and Fercayl, a ferritin-like akaganeite particle, is studied through T1 and T2 nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion (NMRD) profiles. To differing extents, the relaxation brought about by both systems is significantly affected by pH. A proton exchange time of 33 ns (at pH 6 and 37 degrees C) is deduced from the fittings of Fercayl T1 NMRD profiles. The linearity of the relationship between 1/T2 and the magnetic field B0 for ferritin and Fercayl solutions is not altered by changes in pH. The parameters of this linearity strongly depend on pH for the latter, while remaining unchanged for the former. These results are interpreted in terms of an exchange between protons belonging to hydroxyl groups at the surface of the particle and bulk water protons.

Relaxation induced by ferritin and ferritin-like magnetic particles: the role of proton exchange

Proton T1 and T2 in solutions of ferritin and fercayl (a ferritin-like iron-dextran particle) solutions were measured, over a wide range of various parameters (Bo, temperature, interecho-time and pH). The window of the previously referred linear dependence of 1/T2 on the static field was increased, up to 500 MHz, and the independence of T2 on the echo time was confirmed. Correlation times were extracted from T1 nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion profiles. In the pH range studied, no strong variation of the relaxivities of ferritin solutions was noticed. Fercayl, which, unlike ferritin, remains stable under large pH variations, is characterized by strongly pH-dependent relaxation rates. This feature is interpreted as due to the effect of proton exchange in the water relaxation process. Outer sphere theory, which ignores proton binding, is shown to be unable to describe the relaxation of ferritin and ferritin-like particles solutions, first because it predicts a quadratic rate dependence on Bo, but also because it severely underestimates the relaxation rate. Explaining relaxation induced by ferritin and ferritin-like particle solutions will likely require a model that accounts for proton binding.