Biological Equivalence of GGTA-1 Glycosyltransferase Knockout and Standard Porcine Pericardial Tissue Using 90-Day Mitral Valve Implantation in Adolescent Sheep

Objective

There is growing interest in the application of genetically engineered reduced antigenicity animal tissue for manufacture of bioprosthetic heart valves (BHVs) to reduce antibody induced tissue calcification and accelerated structural valve degeneration (SVD). This study tested biological equivalence of valves made from Gal-knockout (GalKO) and standard porcine pericardium after 90-day mitral valve implantation in sheep.

Methods

GalKO (n = 5) and standard (n = 5) porcine pericardial BHVs were implanted in a randomized and blind fashion into sheep for 90-days. Valve haemodynamic function was measured at 30-day intervals. After explantation, valves were examined for pannus, vegetation, inflammation, thrombus, and tissue calcification.

Results

Nine of 10 recipients completed the study. There was no difference between study groups for haemodynamic performance and no adverse valve-related events. Explanted BHVs showed mild pannus integration and minimal thrombus, with no difference between the groups. Limited focal mineral deposits were detected by x-ray. Atomic spectroscopy analysis detected tissue calcium levels of 1.0 µg/mg ± 0.2 for GalKO BHVs and 1.9 µg/mg ± 0.9 for standard tissue BHVs (p = 0.4), considered to be both low and equivalent.

Conclusions

This is the first demonstration of biological equivalence between GalKO and standard pig pericardium. The GalKO mutation causes neither intrinsic detrimental biological nor functional impact on BHV performance. Commercial adaptation of GalKO tissue for surgical or transcatheter BHVs would remove the clinical disparity between patients producing anti-Gal antibody and BHVs containing the Gal antigen. GalKO BHVs may reduce accelerated tissue calcification and SVD, enhancing patient choices, especially for younger patients.

Graphical Abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13239-021-00585-0.

A Durable Porcine Pericardial Surgical Bioprosthetic Heart Valve: a Proof of Concept

Bioprosthetic leaflets made from animal tissues are used in the majority of surgical and transcatheter cardiac valve replacements. This study develops a new surgical bioprosthesis, using porcine pericardial leaflets. Porcine pericardium was obtained from genetically engineered pigs with a mutation in the GGTA-1 gene (GTKO) and fixed in 0.6% glutaraldehyde, and used to develop a new surgical valve design. The valves underwent in vitro hydrodynamic test in a pulse duplicator and high-cycled accelerated wear testing and were evaluated for acute haemodynamics and thrombogenicity in a juvenile sheep implant study for 48 h. The porcine surgical pericardial heart valves (pSPHVs) exhibited excellent hydrodynamics and reached 200 million cycles of in vitro durability, with no observable damage. Juvenile sheep implants demonstrated normal valve function with no acute thrombogenic response for either material. The pSPHV incorporates a minimalistic construction method using a tissue-to-tissue design to cover the stent. This new design is a proof of concept alternative to the use of bovine pericardium and synthetic fabric in surgical bioprosthetic heart valves.

Physical equivalency of wild type and galactose α 1,3 galactose free porcine pericardium; a new source material for bioprosthetic heart valves

Humans make high levels of antibody to carbohydrates with terminal galactose α 1,3 galactose (Gal) modifications. This Gal antigen is widely expressed in other mammals and is present on an array of current animal derived biomedical devices including bioprosthetic heart valves. There is growing interest in using Gal-free animal tissues from Gal knockout pigs (GTKO) as these tissues would not be affected by anti-Gal antibody mediated injury. In this study we compare the composition and biophysical characteristics of glutaraldehyde fixed porcine pericardium from standard and GTKO pigs. We show that with the exception of the Gal antigen which is only present in standard pig tissue both GTKO and standard pig tissue have the same general morphology and collagen content. Moreover uniaxial stress testing and suture retention testing indicate the tissues are equivalent in tensile strength. These studies indicate that genetic disruption of the α-galactosyltransferase (GGTA-1) which blocks synthesis of the Gal antigen has no significant impact on the structural integrity of porcine pericardium and suggest that this tissue could be directly substituted for standard pig pericardium in biomedical devices such as bioprosthetic heart valves.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Surgical heart valve replacement is a proven life saving therapy to treat heart valve dysfunction due to birth defects, infection and the effects of aging. Bioprosthetic heart valves (BHV) made from glutaraldehyde fixed animal tissues are an effective durable therapy in older patients (>60years) but exhibit age-dependent structural valve degeneration (SVD) in younger patients (<60years). SVD is principally caused by BHV calcification. Immune injury contributes to age-dependent SVD through the interaction of galactose α 1,3 galactose (Gal) a dominant xenogeneic antigen present on commercial BHVs and universally abundant human anti-Gal antibody. This study measures the tissue equivalency between standard pig pericardium and Gal-free pericardium from genetically modified pigs as a first step towards making Gal-free BHVs.

Sustained function of genetically modified porcine lungs in an ex vivo model of pulmonary xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Xenotransplantation could provide a solution to the donor shortage that is currently the major barrier to solid-organ transplantation. The ability to breed pigs with multiple genetic modifications provides a unique opportunity to explore the immunologic challenges of pulmonary xenotransplantation.

METHODS

Explanted lungs from wild-type and 3 groups of genetically modified pigs were studied: (i) α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene knockout (GTKO); (ii) GTKO pigs expressing the human complementary regulatory proteins CD55 and CD59 (GTKO/CD55-59); and (iii) GTKO pigs expressing both CD55-59 and CD39 (GTKO/CD55-59/CD39). The physiologic, immunologic and histologic properties of porcine lungs were evaluated on an ex vivo rig after perfusion with human blood.

RESULTS

Lungs from genetically modified pigs demonstrated stable pulmonary vascular resistance and better oxygenation of the perfusate, and survived longer than wild-type lungs. Physiologic function was inversely correlated with the degree of platelet sequestration into the xenograft. Despite superior physiologic profiles, lungs from genetically modified pigs still showed evidence of intravascular thrombosis and coagulopathy after perfusion with human blood.

CONCLUSIONS

The ability to breed pigs with multiple genetic modifications, and to evaluate lung physiology and histology in real-time on an ex vivo rig, represent significant advances toward better understanding the challenges inherent to pulmonary xenotransplantation.