Restricted tissue distribution of Mlsa determinants. Stimulation of Mlsa-reactive T cells by B cells but not by dendritic cells or macrophages

Does negative selection involve accumulation of self-reactive thymocytes in thymic rosettes?

Thymic rosettes, the natural associations between thymocytes and either macrophages or dendritic cells, were isolated from the thymus by collagenase digestion and unit-gravity elutriation. Rosettes from mouse strains where either the V beta 6-bearing thymocytes are deleted because of reactivity with products of the Mlsa allele of the minor lymphocyte stimulating locus, or where V beta 17a-bearing thymocytes are deleted because of reactivity with IE class II MHC molecules, were compared with rosettes from appropriate control strains to test if a selective association with stromal cells preceded deletion. Rosettes from an Mlsa-bearing strain were able to stimulate an Mlsa-reactive T-hybridoma, but much of this stimulatory activity was attributable to the few B cells associated with the rosette preparations; the stromal components of the rosettes appeared to be poor presenters of Mlsa gene products. There was no enrichment of thymocytes bearing high or low levels of V beta 6 TcR in the rosettes from the Mlsa-bearing strain, which might have reflected the poor presentation by the stromal cells. However, nor was there detectable selective association of thymocytes bearing C beta 17a in the rosettes from an IE-positive mouse strain. This argues against binding and immobilisation on stromal cells as part of the deletion process, but not against the stromal cells delivering a rapid signal during a transient association, leading later to deletion.

Signals arising from antigen-presenting cells

It has been customary to consider that antigen-presenting cells provide, in addition to the presented antigen, a second or co-stimulatory signal that leads to T-cell growth and effector function. The recent literature indicates that this two-signal notion oversimplifies the function of antigen-presenting cells. Instead it is useful to consider four groups of events: the formation of peptide-MHC complexes, the role of soluble cytokines, the action of antigen-presenting cell-T cell molecular couples distinct from the receptor for peptide MHC, and the function of antigen-presenting cells in situ.

Genetic studies on experimental autoimmune gastritis induced by neonatal thymectomy using recombinant inbred strains between a high-incidence strain, BALB/c, and a low-incidence strain, DBA/2

Thymectomy on day 3 after birth induced autoimmune gastritis (AIG) at the age of 2 months in 51-73% of BALB/c mice, and in only 3-5% of DBA/2 mice. AIG was detected by histological and serological (immunofluorescence staining for detecting anti-parietal cell autoantibody) examination. However, autoantibody was weakly positive in almost all of these DBA/2 mice when measured by ELISA using extract of murine gastric mucosa as the antigen. To investigate genetically the mechanism controlling the incidence of AIG, II recombinant inbred strains established by brother-sister mating of (BALB/c x DBA/2) F2 mice (C x D2 strains) were used. Among 26 markers tested, the Mls-1 locus on BALB/c chromosome 1 and the Hc locus coding a complement component (C5) on BALB/c chromosome 2 were found to be associated with high susceptibility to AIG. However, if one or both of the loci were of DBA/2 origin, mice showed medium or low susceptibility to AIG. For further analysis, F1, F2 and back-cross generations of these two strains were tested, but segregation of a single susceptibility or insusceptibility gene was not obtained. Taken together, it seems probable that two or more genes are involved in the induction mechanism of AIG. We did not detect C5 deposition in AIG lesions, nor complement-dependent cytotoxic antibody to parietal cells in serum from AIG mice. However, injection of irradiated spleen cells of DBA/2 mice into BALB/c mice thymectomized on day 3 augmented the incidence of AIG from 71 to 100%, but not that of oophoritis (33%). A relationship between Mls-1a determinants and the pathogenesis of AIG was further suggested from the fact that V beta 6 TcR-expressing T cells increased in number in AIG-bearing compared with normal BALB/c mice.

Clonal deletion of V beta 14-bearing T cells in mice transgenic for mammary tumour virus

Autoreactive T lymphocytes are clonally deleted during maturation in the thymus. Deletion of T cells expressing particular receptor V beta elements is controlled by poorly defined autosomal dominant genes. A gene has now been identified by expression of transgenes in mice which causes deletion of V beta 14+ T cells. The gene lies in the open reading frame of the long terminal repeat of the mouse mammary tumour virus.

Requirement of dendritic cells and B cells in the clonal deletion of Mls-reactive T cells in the thymus

The present study was performed to identify cells responsible for the elimination of T cells reactive with minor lymphocyte-stimulating (Mls) antigens during T cell development. Experiments were carried out in a fetal thymus organ culture (FTOC) system. To examine the tolerance-inducing activity, various populations of cells from adult CBA/J (Mls-1a) mice were injected into deoxyguanosine (dGuo)-treated FTOC of C3H/He (Mls-1b) mice with a microinjector, and 2 d later, the thymus lobes were injected with fetal thymus cells from C3H/He mice as T cell precursors. After 14 d of cultivation, cells were harvested and assayed for the expression of the T cell receptor V beta 6 element. The absence or marked reduction of T cells expressing V beta 6 at high levels (V beta 6high) was regarded as indicating the deletion of Mls-1a-reactive T cells. T cell-depleted populations of thymic as well as splenic cells from CBA/J mice were able to induce clonal deletion. Further characterization of the effector cells was carried out by fractionating the spleen cells before injecting them into dGuo-FTOC. None of the dish-adherent population, dish-nonadherent population, or purified B cells alone were able to induce clonal deletion, whereas the addition of purified B cells to adherent cells restored tolerance inducibility. It was further shown that a combination of CBA/J B cells and C3H/He dendritic cells was effective in eliminating Mls-reactive clones. These results indicate that for the deletion of clones reactive with Mls antigens during T cell development in the thymus, both DC and B cells are required.

Distinct mechanisms of neonatal tolerance induced by dendritic cells and thymic B cells

To assess the role of different types of antigen-presenting cells (APC) in the induction of tolerance, we isolated B cells, macrophages, and dendritic cells from thymus and spleen, and injected these into neonatal BALB/c mice across an Mls-1 antigenic barrier. One week after injection of APC from Mls-1-incompatible mice or from control syngeneic mice, we measured the number of thymic, Mls-1a-reactive, V beta 6+ T cells and the capacity of thymocytes to induce a graft-vs.-host (GVH) reaction in popliteal lymph nodes of Mls-1a mice. Injection of thymic but not spleen B cells deleted thymic, Mls-1a-reactive V beta 6+ T cells and induced tolerance in the GVH assay. The thymic B cells were primarily of the CD5+ type, and fluorescence-activated cell sorter-purified CD5+ thymic B cells were active. Injection of dendritic cells from spleen or thymus also induced tolerance, but the V beta 6 cells were anergized rather than deleted. Macrophages from thymus did not induce tolerance. Dendritic cells and thymic B cells were also effective in inducing tolerance even when injected into Mls-, major histocompatibility complex-incompatible, I-E- mice, but only thymic B cells depleted V beta 6-expressing T cells. Therefore, different types of bone marrow-derived APC have different capacities for inducing tolerance, and the active cell types (dendritic cells and CD5+ thymic B cells) can act by distinct mechanisms.

Ontogeny of thymic B cells in normal mice

Ontogeny of thymic B cells and their surface characteristics were analyzed using monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against B220 molecules (CD45, CD45R). A small number of B cells were detected in fetal thymus on Gestation Day 14 (approximately 3.5% of the low-density fraction). Similarly, the percentage of B cells in the low-density fraction was 3.2% on Gestation Day 18, and 3.5% on Day 1 after birth. These were the same level as that of adult mice. CD5+ B cells, which form the major population of thymic B cells, were also found in the fetal life (0.5% on Day 14 and 2.2% on Day 16 in the low-density cells). The percentage of CD5+ B cells in B cell-enriched fraction was about 65% on Day 1 after birth, which is the same level as that in adult mice. These results indicate that a small number of B cells or cells in the B-cell lineage are present in the fetal thymus and also suggest the importance of these thymic B cells in the negative selection of T cells during early developmental stages.

The effect of peripheral immunization with Mls-1a on the emigration of antigen-specific cells from the thymus

Mature T cells found in the lymph nodes and spleen have the capacity to become activated and to proliferate in response to foreign antigens. The response of the thymus to such immunization is less well understood. We have examined one aspect of the thymic response by determining the effect of peripheral immunization upon cell emigration from the thymus. BALB/c (Mls-1b) mice were injected with spleen cells from DBA/2 (Mls-1a) mice, and V beta 6+ (Mls-1a-reactive) thymic emigrants were identified 3-30 days after immunization. Neither the rate of total cell migration from the thymus nor the proportion of V beta 6+ cells was altered, even though the immunizing spleen cells elicited an immune response in the draining (parathymic) lymph nodes. The same immunogen caused deletion of V beta 6+ cells in both the thymus and lymph nodes after intraperitoneal injection into the neonate. The inability of DBA/2 splenocytes to modify the development of adult thymocytes after intrathymic injection of the cells precluded the lack of entry into the thymus as the reason for the lack of any observed effect in the adult. Our results, therefore, indicate that the development of adult thymocytes is not modified by immunization, and suggest that the differing thymic response of mice injected as adults or neonates is related to changes in the intrathymic antigen presentation capacity associated with age.

Extrathymic tolerance of mature T cells: clonal elimination as a consequence of immunity

The mechanism by which T lymphocytes are tolerized to self or foreign antigens is still controversial. Clonal deletion is the major mechanism of tolerance for immature thymocytes; for mature T cells, tolerance is considered to reflect anergy rather than deletion, and to be a consequence of defective presentation of antigen. This paper documents a novel form of tolerance resulting when mature T cells encounter antigen in immunogenic form. Evidence is presented that exposure of mature T cells to Mlsa antigens in vivo leads to specific tolerance and disappearance of Mlsa-reactive V beta 6+ T cells. Surprisingly, the clonal elimination of V beta 6+ cells is preceded by marked expansion of these cells. Thus, tolerance induction can be the end result of a powerful immune response. These data raise important questions concerning the relationship of tolerance and memory.

Tolerogenicity of thymic epithelium

To attempt to resolve the controversy on the role of thymic epithelial cells (TEC) in tolerance induction, athymic mice were grafted with allogeneic day-14 fetal thymuses treated with deoxyguanosine in vitro. The data indicate that the tolerogenicity of TEC varies considerably according to the antigen and the subpopulation of T cells studied. For cytotoxic CD8+ cells responding to H-2 class I antigens, TEC induce minimal tolerance. For proliferative responses of CD4+ cells, by contrast, TEC induce significant tolerance to H-2 class II antigens but no detectable tolerance to Mlsa antigens.

Expression of CD4 can confer major histocompatibility complex class II-associated superantigen reactivity upon a T cell receptor derived from a CD8-dependent cytotoxic T lymphocyte clone

It has been shown that reactivity against major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-associated Mlsa determinants is mainly mediated by CD4+ V beta 6+ T cells. 3F9 is a CD8+ CTL clone which is specific for the alloantigen H-2Db. While 3F9 is V beta 6+, it is not Mlsa reactive, presumably because it does not express CD4. 3F9 utilizes the same T cell receptor (TcR) V alpha V beta combination as LB2, a CD4+ T helper clone specific for chicken red blood cells (cRBC)/I-Ab and yet differs from LB2 in the junctional sequences in both TcR chains. CD4+ CD8- and CD4-CD8- hybridomas expressing the 3F9 TcR were tested for reactivity against Mlsa and cRBC/I-Ab. Only the CD4+CD8- hybridomas were Mlsa reactive, and antibody inhibition studies revealed that this reactivity was both CD4 and MHC class II dependent. Therefore the expression of the CD4 molecule can make an MHC class I-restricted TcR Mlsa reactive. Neither type of hybridoma reacted against cRBC, thus the main difference in the antigen reactivity between 3F9 and LB2 lies in the TcR junctional regions.

Distinct fates of self-specific T cells developing in irradiation bone marrow chimeras: clonal deletion, clonal anergy, or in vitro responsiveness to self-Mls-1a controlled by hemopoietic cells in the thymus

Elimination of potentially self-reactive T lymphocytes during their maturation in the thymus has been shown to be a major mechanism in accomplishing self-tolerance. Previous reports demonstrated that clonal deletion of self-Mls-1a-specific V beta 6+ T lymphocyte is controlled by a radiosensitive I-E+ thymic component. Irradiation chimeras reconstituted with I-E- bone marrow showed substantial numbers of mature V beta 6+ T cells despite host Mls-1a expression. Analysis of the functional properties of such chimeric T cells revealed a surprising variability in their in vitro reactivity to host Mls-1a, depending on the H-2 haplotype of stem cells used for reconstitution. In chimeras reconstituted with B10.S (H-2s) stem cells, mature V beta 6+ lymphocytes were present but functionally anergic to host-type Mls-1a in vitro. In contrast, in chimeras reconstituted with B10.G (H-2q) bone marrow, nondeleted V beta 6+ cells were highly responsive to Mls-1a in vitro. These findings suggest that clonal anergy of V beta 6+ cells to self-Mls-1a may be controlled by the affinity/avidity of T cell receptor interactions with bone marrow-derived cells in the thymus depending on the major histocompatibility complex class II molecules involved. Furthermore, chimeras bearing host (Mls-1a)-reactive V beta 6+ cells did not differ clinically from those with anergic or deleted V beta 6+ cells and survived more than one year without signs of autoimmune disease. Interestingly, their spleen cells had no Mls-1a stimulatory capacity in vitro. Therefore, regulation at the level of antigen presentation may be an alternative mechanism for maintenance of tolerance to certain self-antigens such as Mls-1a.

Activation of polyphosphoinositide hydrolysis in T cells by H-2 alloantigen but not MLS determinants

Murine minor lymphocyte-stimulating (Mls) determinants are cell surface antigens that stimulate strong primary T cell responses; the responding T cells display restricted T cell receptor (TCR) V beta gene usage. Interaction of T cells with mitogens or major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens activated the polyphosphoinositide (PI) signaling pathway, but this pathway was not triggered by Mls recognition. However, interleukin-2 (IL-2) secretion and proliferation to all three stimuli were comparable. Thus, although recognition of both allo-H-2 and Mls determinants is thought to be mediated by the TCR, these antigens appear to elicit biochemically distinct signal transduction pathways.

T lymphocyte heterogeneity in the rat. III. Autoreactive T cells are activated by B cells

Evidence has been presented to show that CD4+ autoreactive T cell lines (ATs)2 in the rat require periodic stimulation with syngeneic spleen cells for in vitro proliferation. This proliferation can be blocked by treatment of the stimulator (spleen) cells with mAb to Ia antigens. Although ATs are Ia+ and can activate the allogeneic MLR, they fail to be autostimulatory. Fractionation of the spleen cells revealed that ATs can be stimulated with B cells and not by macrophages, although the latter were efficient in several accessory cell functions, including antigen presentation, lectin-dependent T cell activation and allogenic MLR response. Moreover, B cells proliferated and differentiated in response to AT cells. These data are compatible with a model in which ATs respond to hitherto undetermined B cell membrane antigen(s) in association with MHC class II antigens. These results may have important implications in understanding autoimmune responses.

Induction of neonatal tolerance to Mlsa antigens by CD8+ T cells

Antigen-specific tolerance of T cells to minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) antigens can be induced in mice by neonatal injection of foreign lymphohematopoietic cells. Although immune responses to Mlsa antigens are controlled by B cells, CD8+ T cells were the most effective cell type for induction of Mlsa tolerance. Tolerance was evident in both thymus and lymph nodes and could be induced by as few as 2 x 10(4) CD8+ T cells; these cells were 50 to 100 times as potent as CD4+ cells or B cells in causing functional tolerance and deletion of V beta 6+ T cells. Thus, intrathymic contact with antigens expressed on CD8+ T cells may play an important role in controlling the normal development of tolerance.

Analysis of T cell receptor V beta gene usage in primary mixed lymphocyte reactions: evidence for directive usage by different antigen-presenting cells and Mls-like determinants on T cell blasts

The usage of four different T cell receptor (TcR) V beta gene families within normal, non-primed T cell populations in response to various types of antigen-presenting cells (APC) in primary mixed lymphocyte reaction has been studied. We demonstrate that distinct patterns of V beta gene usage are obtained within a given T cell population in response to different types of APC with the same allo-H-2. When responder T cells are stimulated with one type of allogeneic APC, from various H-2-disparate mice, the same V beta gene preference is observed. Furthermore, when H-2- and Mls-mismatched APC gene used as stimulators, the Mls-associated V beta 6 and V beta 8.1 gene families are highly elevated in response to both B and T cell blasts from certain Mls-positive strains. The results demonstrate that different types of allogeneic APC have the capacity to generate biases in TcR V beta gene usage and imply that functional Mls-like determinants are presented by T cell blasts. The findings are discussed with respect to TcR-major histocompatibility complex interactions in allostimulation.

Autoreactive T cells in normal mice: unrestricted recognition of self peptides on dendritic cell I-A molecules by CD4-CD8- T cell receptor alpha/beta+ T cell clones expressing V beta 8.1 gene segments

CD4-CD8- double-negative (DN) and CD4+CD8- T cell clones were derived from splenic precursors resistant to killing by anti-Thy-1, -CD5, -CD4 and -CD8 monoclonal antibodies and complement. Both DN and CD4+ clones express functional T cell receptor (TcR) alpha/beta and exhibit strong autoreactivity in vitro. DN cells can be induced to proliferate by dendritic cells (DC) of all haplotypes tested, although this activation is inhibited by antibodies specific for I-A determinants expressed on the stimulatory DC. In contrast, CD4+ clones only respond to syngeneic or I-Ad-compatible DC. Both DN and CD4+ autoreactive clones do not proliferate when cultured with class II+ H-2d normal or tumor macrophages and B cell lines or with class II-transfected L cells, suggesting that these cells recognize self peptides only present on the surface of DC. Despite their phenotype resembling that of immature thymocytes and their inability to interact directly with B lymphocytes, DN cloned T cells, like CD4+ T cells, exhibit nonspecific helper functions and can induce polyclonal B cell proliferation and differentiation. DN TcR alpha/beta+ peripheral T cells represent, like TcR gamma/delta+ lymphocytes, a new T cell subset physiological role whose remains to be defined.

Cell components required for deletion of an autoreactive T cell repertoire

T cells become tolerant to self antigens during their development in the thymus. Clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing T cell receptor (TcR) which recognize self antigens is a major mechanism for generating tolerance. In the present study we have used allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras, prepared with various combinations of mouse strains and focusing especially on expressions of I-E molecules and Mls-1a antigens on the cell surface, to investigate both immunohistochemically and by flow cytometry the cell components that contribute to the clonal deletion of T cells positive for V beta 6 TcR. The V beta 6 TcR expression is strongly associated with T cell recognition of both I-E and Mls-1a antigens. We found that I-E+ cells derived from donor BM (and thus not of recipient lineage) represented a primary requirement for deletion of Mls-1a-reactive thymocytes which bear V beta 6 TcR. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that the donor-derived I-E+ cells were distributed mainly to the thymic medulla and that the V beta 6+ cells were eliminated from the thymic medulla between 2 and 3 weeks following BM transplantation. In contrast, Mls-1a+ cells of either donor or recipient origin might be responsible for the deletion, even though cortical epithelial cells appeared not to express Mls-1a antigens.

Clonal deletion of self-Mls-reactive thymocytes at the early stage in H-2-compatible but Mls-disparate radiation chimeras

Clonal deletion of T cells capable of recognizing both host-type Mls and donor-type Mls occurred in the peripheral mature T-cell pool in radiation bone marrow chimeras of two H-2-compatible Mls-disparate strain combinations of AKR/J(H-2k,Thy-1.1,Mls-1a) and C3H/He(H-2k,Thy-1.2,Mls-1b). In order to determine further the stage at which the clonal deletion occurs in thymus, we examined the kinetics of thymocytes bearing V beta 6 capable of recognizing Mls-1a in both C3H/He----AKR/J and AKR/J----C3H/He chimeras. An almost complete replacement from host-derived cells to donor-derived cells occurred by Day 21 after reconstitution in both chimeras. At this stage, CD4+CD8+ double-positive thymocytes contained an appreciable number of cells that expressed V beta 6 on their surface, albeit at low intensity, whereas CD4 or CD8 single-positive thymocytes which expressed a high density of V beta 6 were virtually abolished in both C3H----AKR and AKR----C3H chimeras on Day 21. These results suggest that clonal deletion of self-Mls-reactive T cells begins at an early stage when the thymocytes interact with the early appearing donor-derived haemotopoietic cells and relatively radio-resistant host-derived cells in thymus of radiation bone marrow chimeras.

Thymic dendritic cells and B cells: isolation and function

The thymus is the primary organ in which T cells undergo rearrangement of T cell receptor alpha and beta genes, positive selection for affinity to self MHC products, and elimination (negative selection) of reactivity to self antigens. These events require an interaction of the developing T cell with other cell types in the thymus. The latter include epithelial cells, macrophages, dendritic cells, and the recently described thymic B cells the majority of which are CD5+. Here we review the identification and isolation of thymic dendritic cells and CD5+ B cells. We consider phenotype, ontogeny, and function, including possible contributions to the induction of self tolerance. Thymic dendritic cells are similar to spleen dendritic cells, but are larger and exhibit a few differences in phenotype. Dendritic cells from both organs are equally potent accessory cells for the MLR and lectin-induced, T cell proliferation. Thymic dendritic cells have higher levels of Fc receptors and support anti-CD3 dependent mitogenesis. Thymic CD5+ B cells share phenotypic features with peritoneal CD5+ B cells. However thymic B cells neither proliferate nor form antibody producing cells in response to the stimulation with LPS or anti-IgM plus IL-4, but do respond to stimulation with MHC class II-restricted helper T cells. Thymic dendritic cells and CD5+ B cells both appear at a similar time in ontogeny, about 14 d of gestation, which is the time T cell differentiation begins to take place. Dendritic cells from spleen, which are potent activators for peripheral T cells, are also potent inactivators for thymic-derived cytotoxic T cells. A correlation between reactivity to MIs products and the expression of TCR-V beta genes is well documented, and B cells are the primary APC for this antigen. Therefore, thymic CD5+ B cells may be a good tool for the investigation of tolerance to M1s products.

Deletion of Mls-reactive T cells in H-2-compatible but Mls-incompatible bone marrow chimeras

The cellular basis of tolerance induction to Mls-encoded antigens in radiation bone marrow (BM) chimeras has been investigated in two H-2-compatible strain combinations of AKR/J (H-2k, Thy-1.1, Mls-Ia) and C3H/He (H-2k, Thy-1.2, Mls-IIa). Sequential appearance of host- and donor-derived T cell subsets and T cell receptor gene messages occurred in the peripheral lymphoid organs of both irradiated AKR/J mice reconstituted with C3H/He BM cells (C3H/He-AKR/J chimera) and irradiated C3H/He mice reconstituted with AKR/J BM cells (AKR/J-C3H/He chimera). A large number of cells expressing T cell receptor gamma genes were detected in spleen on day 21 after reconstitution, while the normal level of alloreactivity was first detected in the spleen on day 56 after reconstitution in correlation with the appearance of appreciable levels of Thy-1 high cells and T cell receptor alpha and beta gene transcripts. T cells bearing V beta 6, that is strongly correlated with reactivity to antigens encoded by the Mls-Ia genetic locus, were virtually abolished in spleen on day 56 in both C3H/He-AKR/J chimera and AKR/J-C3H/He chimera. Furthermore, expression of V beta 3 gene transcripts, that are important for recognizing Mls-IIa, was undetected either in the peripheral lymphoid cells of AKR/J-C3H/He chimera or in those of C3H/He-AKR/J chimera. These results suggested that clonal elimination of self-reactive T cells bearing V beta 3 or V beta 6 was induced by both host-derived radioresistant cells and donor-derived repopulating cells in the thymus of radiation BM chimeras.