Initiation of cardiac differentiation occurs in the absence of anterior endoderm

Homeobox genes in cardiovascular development

As summarized earlier, a surprisingly large number of different homeobox genes are expressed in the developing heart. Some are clearly important, as demonstrated by mouse gene ablation studies. For example, knockout of Nkx2-5 or Hoxa-3 function is embryonic lethal due to defects in cardiovascular development. However, gene ablation studies indicate that other homeobox genes that show cardiovascular expression are either not required for heart development or their function is effectively complemented by a redundant gene activity. Given the number of closely related homeobox genes that are expressed in the heart (and the rate at which new genes are being discovered), this is very likely to be the case for at least some homeobox gene activities. At present little is known of the precise mechanism of action of homeobox genes in embryonic development. This statement applies to homeobox genes in general, not just to genes involved in cardiovascular development. There is a popular view that homeobox genes are master regulators that control expression of a large number of downstream genes. In at least some cases, e.g., the eyeless gene of Drosophila (Holder et al., 1995), homeobox genes appear to be capable of activating and maintaining a very complex developmental program. Significantly, the eyeless gene is able to initiate eye development at numerous ectopic locations. Increasing evidence, however, suggests that genes of this type may be rather rare. Certainly there is no evidence to date that any of the homeobox genes expressed in the heart are able to initiate the complete heart development pathway. This is probably best understood in the case of the tinman gene in Drosophila, which, although absolutely required for heart development, is not capable of initiating the cardiac development pathway in ectopic locations (Bodmer, 1993). This conclusion is supported by studies of the vertebrate tinman-related gene Nkx2-5. Gene ablation studies show that Nkx2-5 is essential for correct cardiac development (Lyons et al., 1995) but is not able to initiate the regulatory pathway leading to cardiac development when expressed ectopically (Cleaver et al., 1996; Chen and Fishman, 1996). If most homeodomain proteins are not direct regulators of a differentiation pathway, what is their role during organogenesis? The cardiovascular homeobox gene about which most is known at the mechanistic level is gax (Smith et al., 1997). A number of experiments indicate that the Gax protein is involved in the regulation of cell proliferation and that it interacts with components of the cell cycle regulation machinery. Indeed, over recent years, the idea that at least some homeobox genes play their role in organogenesis through regulation of proliferation has been developed in some detail by Duboule (1995). Further evidence that this mechanism of homeobox activity is important, especially during organogenesis, comes from studies of the Hox11 homeobox gene, which is absolutely required for development of the spleen in mouse (Roberts et al., 1994). Studies indicate that Hox11 is able to interact with at least two different protein phosphatases, PP2A and PP1, which in turn, are involved in cell cycle regulation (Kawabe et al., 1997). It is quite clear that research in future years will need to focus on the precise mode of action of the different homeodomain proteins if we are to understand their role in the development of the cardiovascular system.

Early steps in vertebrate cardiogenesis

Heart formation provides an excellent model for studying the molecular basis of cell determination in vertebrate embryos. By combining molecular assays with the experimental approaches of classic embryology, a model for the cell signalling events that initiate cardiogenesis is emerging. Studies of chick, amphibian, and fish embryos demonstrate the inductive role of dorso-anterior endoderm in specifying the cardiac fate of adjacent mesoderm. A consequence of this signalling is the onset of cardiomyogenesis and several transcription factors--Nkx2-5-related, HAND, GATA and MEF-2 families--contribute to these events.

Cardiomyocyte differentiation by GATA-4-deficient embryonic stem cells

In situ hybridization studies, promoter analyses and antisense RNA experiments have implicated transcription factor GATA-4 in the regulation of cardiomyocyte differentiation. In this study, we utilized Gata4−/− embryonic stem (ES) cells to determine whether this transcription factor is essential for cardiomyocyte lineage commitment. First, we assessed the ability of Gata4−/− ES cells form cardiomyocytes during in vitro differentiation of embryoid bodies. Contracting cardiomyocytes were seen in both wild-type and Gata4−/− embryoid bodies, although cardiomyocytes were observed more often in wild type than in mutant embryoid bodies. Electron microscopy of cardiomyocytes in the Gata4−/− embryoid bodies revealed the presence of sarcomeres and junctional complexes, while immunofluorescence confirmed the presence of cardiac myosin. To assess the capacity of Gata4−/− ES cells to differentiate into cardiomyocytes in vivo, we prepared and analyzed chimeric mice. Gata4−/− ES cells were injected into 8-cell-stage embryos derived from ROSA26 mice, a transgenic line that expresses beta-galactosidase in all cell types. Chimeric embryos were stained with X-gal to discriminate ES cell- and host-derived tissue. Gata4−/− ES cells contributed to endocardium, myocardium and epicardium. In situ hybridization showed that myocardium derived from Gata4−/− ES cells expressed several cardiac-specific transcripts, including cardiac alpha-myosin heavy chain, troponin C, myosin light chain-2v, Nkx-2.5/Csx, dHAND, eHAND and GATA-6. Taken together these results indicate that GATA-4 is not essential for terminal differentiation of cardiomyocytes and suggest that additional GATA-binding proteins known to be in cardiac tissue, such as GATA-5 or GATA-6, may compensate for a lack of GATA-4.

Induction of cardiac myogenesis in avian pregastrula epiblast: the role of the hypoblast and activin

An in vitro assay has been developed to investigate tissue interactions regulating myocardial cell specification in birds. Explants from the posterior region of stage XI-XIV blastulas were found to form heart muscle at high frequency with a timing that corresponded to onset of cardiac myocyte differentiation in vivo. Isolation and recombination experiments demonstrated that a signal from the hypoblast was required to induce cardiac myogenesis in the epiblast, and regional differences in epiblast responsiveness and hypoblast inductiveness restrict appearance of cardiac myocytes to the posterior region. Explantation studies provided evidence that myocardial cell specification is underway by stage 3, indicating that the hypoblast-derived signal occurs shortly before specification is detected. Recombinations were also performed to compare cardiac-inducing capacities of pregastrula hypoblast and stage 5 anterior lateral endoderm. The hypoblast possessed broad capacity to induce heart muscle cells in pregastrula and mid-gastrula epiblast, and modest ability to induce cardiac myogenesis in stage 4 posterior primitive streak. Stage 5 anterior lateral endoderm, in contrast, showed no ability to induce heart development in epiblast cells but was a potent inducer of cardiac myogenesis in cells from stage 4 posterior primitive streak. These findings suggest that the hypoblast-derived signal likely acts upstream of proposed heart-inducing signals provided by anterior lateral endoderm. Experiments were also performed to investigate whether activin, or an activin-like molecule, is involved in regulating cardiac myogenesis. Follistatin blocked cardiac myogenesis in stage XI-XIV posterior region explants and activin induced cardiac myogenesis in a dose-dependent fashion in posterior epiblast. These findings indicate that activin, or an activin-like molecule, is required for and is sufficient to stimulate cardiac myogenesis in posterior region pregastrula epiblast. Three models are presented to explain these results.

Fashioning the vertebrate heart: earliest embryonic decisions

Our goal here is to set out the types of unitary decisions made by heart progenitor cells, from their appearance in the heart field until they form the simple heart tube. This provides a context to evaluate cell fate, lineage and, finally, morphogenetic decisions that configure global heart form and function. Some paradigms for cellular differentiation and for pattern generation may be borrowed from invertebrates, but neither Drosophila nor Caenorhabditis elegans suffice to unravel higher order decisions. Genetic analyses in mouse and zebrafish may provide one entrance to these pathways.

The allocation of epiblast cells to the embryonic heart and other mesodermal lineages: the role of ingression and tissue movement during gastrulation

The cardiogenic potency of cells in the epiblast of the early primitive-streak stage (early PS) embryo was tested by heterotopic transplantation. The results of this study show that cells in the anterior and posterior epiblast of the early PS-stage embryos have similar cardiogenic potency, and that they differentiated to heart cells after they were transplanted directly to the heart field of the late PS embryo. That the epiblast cells can acquire a cardiac fate without any prior act of ingression through the primitive streak or movement within the mesoderm suggests that neither morphogenetic event is critical for the specification of the cardiogenic fate. The mesodermal cells that have recently ingressed through the primitive streak can express a broad cell fate that is characteristic of the pre-ingressed cells in the host when they were returned to the epiblast. However, mesoderm cells that have ingressed through the primitive streak did not contribute to the lateral plate mesoderm after transplantation back to the epiblast, implying that some restriction of lineage potency may have occurred during ingression. Early PS stage epiblast cells that were transplanted to the epiblast of the mid PS host embryos colonised the embryonic mesoderm but not the extraembryonic mesoderm. This departure from the normal cell fate indicates that the allocation of epiblast cells to the mesodermal lineages is dependent on the timing of their recruitment to the primitive streak and the morphogenetic options that are available to the ingressing cells at that instance.

GATA4 transcription factor is required for ventral morphogenesis and heart tube formation

Previous studies have suggested that the GATA4 transcription factor plays an important role in regulating mammalian cardiac development. In the studies described in this report we have used gene targeting to produce GATA4-deficient mice. Homozygous GATA4-deficient (GATA4-/-) mice died between 8.5 and 10.5 days post coitum (dpc). GATA4-/- embryos displayed severe defects in both rostral-to-caudal and lateral-to-ventral folding, which were reflected in a generalized disruption of the ventral body pattern. This resulted in the defective formation of an organized foregut and anterior intestinal pore, the failure to close both the amniotic cavity and yolk sac, and the uniform lack of a ventral pericardial cavity and heart tube. Analysis of cardiac development in the GATA4-/- mice demonstrated that these embryos developed splanchnic mesoderm, which differentiated into primitive cardiac myocytes that expressed contractile proteins. However, consistent with the observed defect in ventral morphogenesis, these GATA4-/- procardiomyocytes failed to migrate to the ventral midline to form a linear heart tube and instead formed aberrant cardiac structures in the anterior and dorsolateral regions of the embryo. The defect in ventral migration of the GATA4-/- procardiomyocytes was not cell intrinsic because GATA4-/- cardiac myocytes and endocardial cells populated the hearts of GATA4-/- -C57BL/6 chimeric mice. Taken together, these results demonstrated that GATA4 is not essential for the specification of the cardiac cell lineages. However, they define a critical role for GATA4 in regulating the rostral-to-caudal and lateral-to-ventral folding of the embryo that is needed for normal cardiac morphogenesis.

Molecular cloning and expression of two novel avian cytochrome P450 1A enzymes induced by 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin

Transcriptional regulation by the aryl hydrocarbon receptor, for which the environmental toxin 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) is the most potent ligand, leads in mammalian liver to the induction of genes for two distinct cytochrome P450 (CYP)1A enzymes, CYP1A1 and -1A2. Fish seem to have only one CYP1A enzyme. CYP1A enzymes have been regarded as injurious largely because of their ability to activate chemical carcinogens. We report here the cloning and sequencing of cDNAs for two catalytically distinct TCDD-induced CYP enzymes in chick embryo liver. One mediates classic CYP1A1 activities. The other has some -1A2-like activities and is also responsible for TCDD-induced arachidonic acid epoxygenation, a much more conspicuous effect in liver of chicks than of mammalian species. Amino acid sequence analysis shows that although each chick enzyme can be classified in the CYP1A family, both are more like CYP1A1 than -1A2, and neither can be said to be directly orthologous to CYP1A1 or -1A2. Phylogenetic analysis shows that the two chick enzymes form a separate branch in the CYP1A family tree distinct from mammalian CYP1A1 and -1A2 and from fish CYP1A enzymes. The findings suggest that CYP1A progenitors split into two CYP enzymes with some parallel functions independently in two evolutionary lines, evidence for convergent evolution in the CYP1A family. Northern analysis shows that the chick enzymes have a different tissue distribution from CYP1A1 and -1A2. Polymerase chain reaction and in situ hybridization data show that both chick enzymes are expressed in response to TCDD even before organ morphogenesis. The findings further suggest that beyond their role in activating carcinogens, CYP1A enzymes have conferred evolutionary and developmental advantages, perhaps as defenses in maintaining homeostatic responses to toxic chemicals.

Vertebrate heart development

This review summarizes recent studies of the cellular and molecular events involved in the determination and differentiation of cardiac myocytes in vertebrate embryos. Fate-mapping studies in mouse, chick, amphibian and zebrafish embryos suggest that cardiac muscle precursors are specified shortly before or at the time of gastrulation. Nuclear factors, such as dHAND, aryl hydrocarbon receptor, GATA-6, Nkx-2.3, growth arrest homeobox (Gax) and cardiac adriamycin responsive protein (CARP), which have recently been described as playing a role in the commitment and/or differentiation of cardiac myocytes are discussed.

Regulation of avian precardiac mesoderm development by insulin and insulin-like growth factors

Endoderm within the heart forming regions of vertebrate embryos has pronounced effects on myocardial cell development. Previous studies have suggested that these effects are mediated by soluble growth factors, in particular fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) and activin-A. Since both insulin and insulin-like growth factors (IGFs) are present in developing avian embryos at the time of heart formation, we have investigated the potential role of these molecules in promoting development of premyocardial cells in quail. Culture of precardiac mesoderm explants from stage 5 quail embryos in medium containing insulin, IGF-I, or IGF-II increased proliferation of premyocardial cells, with maximal stimulation observed at approximately 25 nM for each ligand. A direct comparison of the proliferative response of precardiac mesoderm to endoderm, fetal calf serum, insulin, IGF-I, IGF-II, activin-A, and FGF-2 showed that FGF-2 and activin-A increased proliferation of premyocardial cells approximately 2-fold, while insulin, IGF-I, and IGF-II stimulated proliferation approximately 3-fold. Insulin and IGF-I enhanced the rate of myocyte differentiation, similar to previously reported effects of endoderm. In contrast, exposure of precardiac mesoderm explants to transforming growth factor beta (TGF beta) reduced proliferation of premyocardial cells and moderated the proliferative effects of IGF-I. TGF beta did not block the differentiation of stage 5 premyocardial cells. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analyses showed that mRNAs encoding insulin, IGF-II, insulin receptor, and IGF-I receptor were present in both precardiac mesoderm and endoderm, as well as in the forming heart at stage 8. Since premyocardial cells can survive and differentiate in a defined medium lacking these factors, precardiac mesoderm may produce IGF-II and insulin at levels that are sufficient to stimulate myocyte development. Taken together, these results suggest that insulin and/or IGF-II may promote cardiac development in vivo by both autocrine and paracrine mechanisms. Cardiogenesis may therefore be promoted by the combined action of several classes of growth factors.

Hepatic specification of the gut endoderm in vitro: cell signaling and transcriptional control

We have studied the initial development of pluripotent gut endoderm to hepatocytes using a tissue explant system from mouse embryos. We not only find cellular interactions that specify hepatic differentiation but also those that block hepatogenesis in regions of the endoderm that normally give rise to other tissues. The results implicate both positive and negative signaling in early hepatic specification. In vivo footprinting of the albumin enhancer in precursor gut endoderm shows that the transcriptionally silent but potentially active chromatin is characterized by occupancy of an HNF-3 site. Upon hepatic specification, a host of other factors bind nearby sites as the gene becomes active. Genes in pluripotent cells therefore may be marked for potential expression by entry points in chromatin, where additional factors bind during cell type specification. The findings also provide insight into the evolutionary origin of different endodermal cell types.

Induction of avian cardiac myogenesis by anterior endoderm

An experimental system was devised to study the mechanisms by which cells become committed to the cardiac myocyte lineage during avian development. Chick tissues from outside the fate map of the heart (in the posterior primitive streak (PPS) of a Hamburger & Hamilton stage 4 embryo) were combined with potential inducing tissues from quail embryos and cultured in vitro. Species-specific RT-PCR was employed to detect the appearance of the cardiac muscle markers chick Nkx-2.5 (cNkx-2.5), cardiac troponin C and ventricular myosin heavy chain in the chick responder tissues. Using this procedure, we found that stage 4–5 anterior lateral (AL) endoderm and anterior central (AC) mesendoderm, but not AL mesoderm or posterior lateral mesendoderm, induced cells of the PPS to differentiate as cardiac myocytes. Induction of cardiogenesis was accompanied by a marked decrease in the expression of rho-globin, implying that PPS cells were being induced by anterior endoderm to become cardiac myocytes instead of blood-forming tissue. These results suggest that anterior endoderm contains signaling molecules that can induce cardiac myocyte specification of early primitive streak cells. One of the cardiac muscle markers induced by anterior endoderm, cNkx-2.5, is here described for the first time. cNkx-2.5 is a chick homeobox-containing gene that shares extensive sequence similarity with the Drosophila gene tinman, which is required for Drosophila heart formation. The mesodermal component of cNkx-2.5 expression from stage 5 onward, as determined by in situ hybridization, is strikingly in accord with the fate map of the avian heart. By the time the myocardium and endocardium form distinct layers, cNkx-2.5 is found only in the myocardium. cNkx-2.5 thus appears to be the earliest described marker of avian mesoderm fated to give rise to cardiac muscle.