A role for complement in the rejection of porcine ventral mesencephalic xenografts in a rat model of Parkinson's disease

Porcine neural xenografts in the immunocompetent rat: immune response following grafting of expanded neural precursor cells

Intracerebral neural xenografts elicit a host immune response that results in their rapid rejection. This forms a key barrier to the therapeutic use of xenogeneic tissue transplantation for conditions such as Parkinson's disease. The current study sought to provide insight into the cellular components of donor cell suspensions that are important in stimulating the host rejection response and thereby to suggest rational manipulations of xenogeneic donor tissue that might ultimately enhance its clinical utility. The neural stem cell mitogens, epidermal growth factor and fibroblast growth factor-2, have been used to isolate and expand populations of primordial neural precursor cells from the embryonic pig brain. The immune response elicited by these cells on transplantation into the non-immunosuppressed rat has been fully characterised. In the first experiments, expanded neural precursors were grafted into the hemi-parkinsonian, non-immunosuppressed Sprague-Dawley rat and graft status and host response examined 10, 21, 35 and 60 days post-transplantation. While equivalent primary tissue grafts were completely eliminated at 35 days, grafts of expanded neural precursors with healthy neurofilament-positive projections were present at all time-points, and two large grafts remained even at 60 days. Some grafts appeared to elicit minimal host immune responses at the time-points they were examined, although most did appear to be undergoing a rejection process since a co-ordinated response involving host cytotoxic T-lymphocytes, microglia/macrophages, immunoglobulin M and complement could be demonstrated to varying degrees. Subsequent experiments went on to demonstrate further that expanded precursor populations and primary tissue suspensions differed in their immunogenic profile. Firstly, when primary tissue was injected intraperitoneally into immunocompetent rats a vigorous primary humoral response was generated. No such response was detected following injection of expanded neural precursors. Secondly, flow cytometric analysis revealed small but significant levels of class II porcine major histocompatibility complex expression in primary cell suspensions but no such expression in expanded precursor populations.The results of this study therefore demonstrate that the immunogenicity of porcine neural cell suspensions used for intracerebral grafting is reduced when neural stem cell mitogens are used to expand precursor cells. The implications of these findings in the development of novel xenogeneic cellular therapies for neurodegenerative conditions such as Parkinson's disease are discussed.

Transgenic pigs designed to express human CD59 and H-transferase to avoid humoral xenograft rejection

Research in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation aims to solve the increasing shortage of organs for human allotransplantation and develop new cell- and tissue-based therapies. Progress towards its clinical application has been hampered by the presence of xenoreactive natural antibodies that bind to the foreign cell surface and activate complement, causing humoral graft rejection. Genetic engineering of donor cells and animals to express human complement inhibitors such as hCD59 significantly prolonged graft survival. Strategies to decrease the deposition of natural antibodies were also developed. Expression of human alpha1,2-fucosyltransferase (H transferase, HT) in pigs modifies the cell-surface carbohydrate phenotype resulting in reduced Galalpha1,3-Gal expression and decreased antibody binding. We have developed transgenic pigs that coexpress hCD59 and HT in various cells and tissues to address both natural antibody binding and complement activation. Functional studies with peripheral blood mononuclear cells and aortic endothelial cells isolated from the double transgenic pigs showed that coexpression of hCD59 and HT markedly increased their resistance to human serum-mediated lysis. This resistance was greater than with cells transgenic for either hCD59 or HT alone. Moreover, transgene expression was enhanced and protection maintained in pig endothelial cells that were exposed for 24 h to pro-inflammatory cytokines. These studies suggest that engineering donor pigs to express multiple molecules that address different humoral components of xenograft rejection represents an important step toward enhancing xenograft survival and improving the prospect of clinical xenotransplantation.

Porcine neural xenografts in rats and mice: donor tissue development and characteristics of rejection

Embryonic ventral mesencephalic tissue from the pig is a potential alternative donor tissue for neural transplantation to Parkinson's disease patients. For stable graft survival, the host immune response has to be prevented. This study was performed in order to analyze the mechanisms and dynamics of neural xenograft rejection, as well as neurobiological properties of the donor tissue. Adult normal mice and rats, and cyclosporin A-treated rats, received intrastriatal transplants of dissociated embryonic ventral mesencephalic pig tissue that was 27 or 29 embryonic days of age (E27 and E29). The animals were perfused at 2, 4, 6, and 12 weeks after grafting and the brains were processed for immunohistochemistry of dopaminergic (tyrosine hydroxylase positive) neurons, CD4(+) and CD8(+) lymphocytes, natural killer cells, macrophages, microglia, and astrocytes. Thirty-five rats received daily injections of BrdU for 5 consecutive days at different time points after transplantation and were perfused at 6 weeks. These animals were analyzed for proliferation of cells in the donor tissue, both in healthy and in rejecting grafts. No tyrosine hydroxylase-positive cells proliferated after grafting. Our results demonstrated that E27 was superior to E29 donor tissue for neurobiological reasons. Cyclosporin A immunosuppression was protective only during the first weeks and failed to protect the grafts in a long-term perspective. Grafts in mice were invariably rejected between 2 and 4 weeks after transplantation, while occasional grafts in untreated rats survived up to 12 weeks without signs of an ongoing rejection process. CD8(+) lymphocytes and microglia cells are most likely important effector cells in the late, cyclosporin A-resistant rejection process.

Xenotransplantation for brain repair: reduction of porcine donor tissue immunogenicity by treatment with anti-Gal antibodies and complement

BACKGROUND

Transplantation of embryonic neural tissue is a potential treatment for Parkinson's disease. Because human donor material is in short supply, porcine xenografts are considered a useful alternative. Current immunosuppressive therapies fail, however, to protect intracerebral neural xenografts from host CD4 T lymphocytes. To reduce the immunogenicity of porcine donor tissue, we attempted to remove microglial cells with antibodies against the alpha-galactosyl epitope (Galalpha1,3Galbeta1,4GlcNAc-R), or anti-Gal, and complement, and studied whether this pretreatment can reduce direct and indirect T-cell responses to the tissue.

METHODS

Brain tissue from 27-day-old pig embryos was dissociated and treated with human anti-Gal and rabbit complement. The microglial content was analyzed by flow cytometry. [3H]thymidine incorporation in cocultures of the brain cells and purified human CD4 T cells was used to determine direct T-cell responses. Indirect T-cell responses were studied by grafting pretreated and control-pretreated (no anti-Gal) nigral tissue into the lesioned striatum of immunocompetent rats with 6-hydroxydopamine-induced hemiparkinsonism. Amphetamine-induced circling behavior was used to measure graft function.

RESULTS

Anti-Gal and complement reduced the microglial content to 11-24% of control and abolished the ability of the brain cells to induce human CD4 T-cell proliferation. Pretreated nigral tissue reduced hemiparkinsonism by more than 50% in five of eight rats at some point during the 10-week follow-up. Rats receiving control-pretreated nigral tissue did not display this degree of improvement.

CONCLUSIONS

Pretreatment with anti-Gal and complement can reduce the immunogenicity of porcine neural tissue, and might, therefore, be a valuable alternative or supplement to immunosuppression in neural xenotransplantation.

Normalization of markers for dopamine innervation in striatum of MPTP-lesioned miniature pigs with intrastriatal grafts

As part of the DaNeX study, the uptake and binding of several positron emitting tracers was recorded in brain of healthy Göttingen minipigs, in minipigs with a syndrome of parkinsonism due to MPTP intoxication, and in parkinsonian minipigs which had received intrastriatal grafts of mesencephalic neurons from fetal pigs. The specific binding of [11C]NS 2214 to catecholamine uptake sites was reduced by two thirds in striatum of the intoxicated animals, while the rate constant for the decarboxylation of [18F]fluorodopa was reduced by 50% in the intoxicated animals. Several months after grafting, both pre-synaptic markers of dopamine fibres were normal in striatum. Dopamine depletion or grafting were without effect on the cerebral perfusion rate, measured with [15O]-water, did not alter the rate of oxygen metabolism (CMRO2) in brain, and did not alter the binding potential of tracers for dopamine D1 or D2 receptors in pig striatum. However, the grafting was associated with a local increase in the binding of [11C]PK 11195, a tracer for reactive gliosis, suggesting that an immunological reaction occurs at the site of graft, which might potentially have reduced the graft patency. However, this apparent immunological response did not preclude the re-establishment of normal [18F]fluorodopa and [11C]NS 2214 uptake in the allografted striatum.

Different mechanisms mediate the rejection of porcine neurons and endothelial cells transplanted into the rat brain

In order to investigate the early cellular responses mediating xenograft rejection in the brain, porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC) or porcine fetal mesencephalic neurons (PNEU) were transplanted into the striatum of LEW.1A rats. PAEC were detected with a specific anti-beta1 integrin antibody, and PNEU with an anti-porcine neurofilament antibody, or an antibody recognizing the NeuN antigen. PAEC grafts were massively infiltrated within 24 h by OX42-positive cells, which may correspond to polymorphonuclear (PMN) cells or macrophages. At that moment, the graft contained numerous cells expressing the inducible isoform of NO-synthase (iNOS). Infiltration by ED1-positive macrophages was effective after three days. The beta1-integrin labeling decreased from that time-point to day 7 post-implantation, and vanished after 11 days. Although some OX8-positive cells were present around the graft as soon as 3 days after transplantation, cells expressing the T-cell receptor (TCR)-beta chain infiltrated the graft after 7 days and their number remained low. A strong, diffuse OX8-and ED1-positive immunoreactive material remained in the scar up to the third week. In striking contrast, PNEU grafts remained poorly infiltrated by OX42- or ED1-positive cells during the first two weeks. A massive infiltration by macrophages and TCRbeta-positive lymphocytes occurred after 3 weeks. Natural killer (NK) cells were more scarce. The inflammation territory enlarged, and blood vessels were overloaded with macrophages or lymphocytes. Nevertheless, the graft contained NeuN-positive nuclei and neurites harbouring the porcine neurofilament protein. Hence, rejection was not completed at this time-point. These results suggest that the rapid rejection of PAEC is mainly driven by macrophages and possibly PMN cells, unlike PNEU, whose rejection is delayed and also involves lymphocytes. Differences in immunogenicity of grafted cells and/or patterns of production of pro-inflammatory cytokines may account for these contrasted rejection kinetics.

Xenotransplantation for CNS repair: immunological barriers and strategies to overcome them

Neural transplantation holds promise for focal CNS repair. Owing to the shortage of human donor material, which is derived from aborted embryos, and ethical concerns over its use, animal donor tissue is now considered an appropriate alternative. In the USA, individuals suffering from Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease, focal epilepsy or stroke have already received neural grafts from pig embryos. However, in animal models, neural tissue transplanted between species is usually promptly rejected, even when implanted in the brain. Some of the immunological mechanisms that underlie neural xenograft rejection have recently been elucidated, but others remain to be determined and controlled before individuals with neurological disorders can benefit from xenotransplantation.