Latent inhibition of conditioned dopamine release in rat nucleus accumbens

The effects of excitotoxic lesion of the medial prefrontal cortex on latent inhibition, prepulse inhibition, food hoarding, elevated plus maze, active avoidance and locomotor activity in the rat

Latent inhibition is a measure of retarded conditioning to a previously presented nonreinforced stimulus that is impaired in schizophrenic patients and in rats treated with amphetamine. In terms of neural substrates, latent inhibition depends on the integrity of the nucleus accumbens and the inputs to this structure from the hippocampal formation and adjacent cortical areas. Since another major source of input to the nucleus accumbens is the medial prefrontal cortex, and there are numerous demonstrations that manipulations of this region can modify ventral striatal dopamine, we investigated the effects of N-methyl-D-aspartate lesion to the medial prefrontal cortex on latent inhibition, assessed in an off-baseline conditioned emotional response procedure in rats licking for water. In addition, the effects of the medial prefrontal cortex lesion were assessed on a battery of tasks potentially sensitive to medial prefrontal cortex damage, including spontaneous and amphetamine-induced activity, elevated plus maze exploration, food hoarding, prepulse inhibition, and active avoidance. The lesion decreased hoarding behaviour and increased spontaneous exploratory activity in the open field, while exerting only mild effects on amphetamine-induced activity. Prepulse inhibition, exploration of the elevated plus maze, and the acquisition of two-way active avoidance were unaffected by the lesion. Likewise, latent inhibition was left intact following the lesion, suggesting that neither the destruction of the intrinsic cells of the medial prefrontal cortex nor any potential lesion-induced changes in subcortical dopamine, affect latent inhibition.

Increased extracellular dopamine in the nucleus accumbens of the rat during associative learning of neutral stimuli

Brain microdialysis was used to study changes in dopamine in the nucleus accumbens and the dorsal striatum during associative learning between two neutral stimuli, flashing light and tone, presented on a paired schedule during stage 1 of a sensory preconditioning paradigm. The tone was subsequently paired with mild footshock using standard aversive conditioning procedures and the formation of a conditioned association between the flashing light and the tone in stage 1 was assessed by measuring the ability of the flashing light to elicit the same conditioned response as the tone when presented at test. The first experiment used behavioural monitoring only, to establish stimulus parameters for subsequent microdialysis experiments. Animals receiving paired presentation of the light and tone in stage 1 showed a conditioned suppression of licking to the light as well as to the tone, indicating that associative learning between the flashing light and the tone had occurred during stage 1, whilst in a separate group of animals given the same stimuli over the same time period but on an explicitly non-paired schedule, the conditioned emotional response was seen to the tone, but not to the light, showing that no association had been formed between the two stimuli during stage 1. In dialysis experiments using the same procedure, we measured a two-fold rise in dopamine in the nucleus accumbens during paired presentation of flashing light and tone, but not during non-paired presentation of the two stimuli. On subsequent test presentation of the two stimuli, we saw increases in accumbal dopamine on presentation of the tone in both groups, reflecting the formation of an association with the footshock in both. However the flashing light elicited an increase in dopamine only in the group which had received paired presentation at stage 1. Thus accumbal dopamine release at test is correlated to the ability of the stimulus to evoke a conditioned response measured behaviourally. Hypotheses of the behavioural function of the mesolimbic dopamine system centre on its role in mediating the effects of biological reinforcers, both rewarding and aversive, conditioned and unconditioned. The present results, showing increases in extracellular dopamine in the nucleus accumbens when an association is formed between two stimuli of which neither is a biological reinforcer nor, prior to formation of the association, affects dopamine levels, suggest a role for accumbal dopamine in the modulation of associative learning in general, not only that involving reinforcement.

Dissociations in dopamine release in medial prefrontal cortex and ventral striatum during the acquisition and extinction of classical aversive conditioning in the rat

Dual perfusion in vivo brain microdialysis was used to monitor extracellular levels of dopamine in the medial prefrontal cortex and ventral striatum during the acquisition and extinction of a classical aversive conditioning paradigm in rats. The main finding was a dissociation in the pattern of release in the two brain areas. The first stimulus-footshock pairing elicited large increases in cortical dopamine over baseline levels that were much greater than the increases elicited by different stimuli of equivalent salience that were unpaired with footshock. In contrast, dopamine levels in ventral striatum were unchanged under these conditions. Over the next two pairings, there was a decline in the cortical response and an increase in the response in ventral striatum. The first presentation of the aversive conditioned stimulus in a separate context elicited the largest response in ventral striatum. Post-conditioning, the cortical response to the conditioned stimulus was smaller than that elicited by the initial stimulus-footshock pairing and was equivalent in magnitude to that elicited by stimuli unpaired with footshock. Over the final two conditioned stimuli presentations, in the absence of the footshock reinforcer (extinction), responses declined in both brain areas. Simultaneous monitoring of behaviour indicated that the neurochemical events were accompanied by effective aversive learning, as indexed by conditioned freezing responses. The data are discussed in terms of the hypothesis that medial prefrontal cortex is especially engaged during novel circumstances which may, potentially, require new learning, whilst ventral striatal dopamine more closely follows the expression of conditioned responding during learning and extinction.

Differential influence of associative and nonassociative learning mechanisms on the responsiveness of prefrontal and accumbal dopamine transmission to food stimuli in rats fed ad libitum

Feeding a novel food (Fonzies) to rats fed ad libitum with standard food increased extracellular dopamine (DA) in the medial prefrontal cortex (PFCX) and in the medial nucleus accumbens (NAc). Previous Fonzies feeding, although it did not affect the increase of extracellular DA in the PFCX in response to Fonzies feeding, blunted that increase in the NAc (habituation); recovery from habituation in the NAc was complete 5 d after previous Fonzies feeding. Predictive association of an otherwise neutral stimulus extrinsic to Fonzies (empty plastic box) with Fonzies feeding resulted in the acquisition by the stimulus of the property to elicit incentive responses directed toward the stimulus and to increase extracellular DA in the PFCX. However, the same stimulus, or a more complex stimulus including intrinsic stimuli (Fonzies-filled plastic box), failed to acquire the ability to modify extracellular DA in the NAc. Pseudoconditioning, i.e., nonpredictive association of the extrinsic stimulus (empty box) with Fonzies feeding, did not result in acquisition by the stimulus of the property to elicit incentive responses and to increase extracellular DA in the PFCX. Repeated nonreinforced presentation of previously conditioned extrinsic stimuli (empty box) resulted in extinction of the property to elicit incentive responses and to increase extracellular DA in the PFCX. These results indicate that in rats fed ad libitum, phasic activation of mesocortical and mesolimbic DA systems by motivational stimuli is differentially influenced by associative (conditioning) and nonassociative (habituation) learning mechanisms and is differentially related to acquisition and expression of incentive motivation.

The Transition from Automatic to Controlled Processing

The transition from automatic (unconscious) to controlled (conscious) processing is described in terms of a neural network model of classical conditioning ([Schmajuk et al., 1996]). In the framework of the network, an environmental stimulus is processed in controlled or conscious mode when Novelty and attention to the stimulus are large, and in automatic or unconscious mode otherwise. In the model, indirect dopamine (DA) agonists, such as amphetamine or nicotine, enhance the DA representation of Novelty, thereby increasing attention and engaging conscious processing of environmental stimuli. By contrast, DA receptor antagonists, such as haloperidol, reduce the DA representation of Novelty, thereby decreasing attention, and engaging unconscious processing of the stimuli.

The switching model of latent inhibition: an update of neural substrates

Organisms exposed to a stimulus which has no significant consequences, show subsequently latent inhibition (LI), namely, retarded conditioning to this stimulus. LI is considered to index the capacity to ignore irrelevant stimuli and its disruption has recently received increasing interest as an animal model of cognitive deficits in schizophrenia. Initial studies indicated that LI is disrupted by systemic or intra-accumbens injections of amphetamine and hippocampal lesions, and potentiated by systemic administration of neuroleptics. On the basis of these findings, the switching model of LI proposed that LI depends on the subicular input to the nucleus accumbens (NAC). Subsequent studies supported and refined this proposition. Lesion studies show that LI is indeed disrupted by severing the subicular input to the NAC, and further implicate the entorhinal/ventral subicular portion of this pathway projecting to the shell subterritory of the NAC. There is a functional dissociation between the shell and core subterritories of the NAC, with lesions of the former but not of the latter disrupting LI. This suggests that the shell is necessary for the expression and the core for the disruption of LI. The involvement of the NAC has been also demonstrated by findings that LI is disrupted by intra-accumbens injection of amphetamine and potentiated by DA depletion or blockade in this structure. Disruption and potentiation of LI by systemic administration of amphetamine and neuroleptics, respectively, have been firmly established, and in addition, have been shown to be sensitive to parametric manipulations of the LI procedure. LI is unaffected by lesions and DA manipulations of medial prefrontal cortex and lesions of basolateral amygdala. The implications of these findings for LI as an animal model of schizophrenia are discussed.

Latent inhibition: the nucleus accumbens connection revisited

It has been proposed that dopaminergic transmission in the nucleus accumbens plays a key role in regulating latent inhibition (LI), i.e. the retardation of conditioning that occurs if a to-be-conditioned stimulus is first presented a number of times ('preexposure') without other consequence. New evidence in support of this hypothesis is presented or reviewed here, showing that: (1) intra-accumbens injection of haloperidol at the time of conditioning potentiates LI; (2) destruction of dopaminergic terminals in the nucleus accumbens potentiates LI; (3) intra-accumbens haloperidol reverses the blockade of LI caused by systemic nicotine; (4) intra-accumbens haloperidol reverses the blockade of LI caused by systemic amphetamine; (5) after a single systemic injection of amphetamine (insufficient on its own to block LI), a subsequent intra-accumbens injection of amphetamine at the time of conditioning blocks LI; and (6) intra-accumbens (like systemic) amphetamine administered 15 min before conditioning, without prior systemic amphetamine, failed to block LI. The difference between the effects on LI of one and two administrations of amphetamine, respectively, is interpreted in terms of the need for sensitisation of the response to amphetamine, with the result that the response to the second administration includes a component of impulse-dependent dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens that is otherwise lacking. Data from dialysis experiments suggest that such impulse-dependent accumbens dopamine release also occurs at relatively long delays after a single systemic administration of amphetamine. It was accordingly predicted, and found, that, although LI is intact 15 min after an i.p. injection (confirming previous results), it is abolished at 90 min after the injection of amphetamine. This finding is consistent with the effects of amphetamine in human subjects, in whom LI is blocked 90 min after a single oral administration. Overall, these results strengthen the case that the blockade of LI by elevated, and potentiation of LI by decreased, dopaminergic transmission are both due specifically to actions in the nucleus accumbens; and also add to the similarities between LI studied in animal and human subjects, respectively.

Effect of haloperidol on nicotine-induced enhancement of vigilance in human subjects

We posed the question whether the cognitive enhancement caused by nicotine in human subjects is mediated by dopamine (DA) release. This issue was addressed by testing performance in the Wesnes and Warburton vigilance task after s.c. nicotine with or without concomitant oral haloperidol. The subjects were moderate (10-14 cigarettes/day) smokers after overnight deprivation of smoking. After an initial practice session, each subject participated in four further sessions spread over 2 weeks, after: placebo/placebo, placebo/haloperidol (5 mg), placebo/nicotine (0.8 mg) or nicotine/haloperidol, double-blind with a balanced ordering of drug combinations. On each occasion, performance was measured on the vigilance task, a finger tapping test, and digit span forward and backward. Nicotine improved detection sensitivity on the vigilance task, and this effect was unchanged by haloperidol; the latter compound reduced forward digit span. Thus, the improved vigilance caused by nicotine does not appear to be mediated by DA systems.

Behavioral functions of nucleus accumbens dopamine: empirical and conceptual problems with the anhedonia hypothesis

Nucleus accumbens (DA) has been implicated in a number of different behavioral functions, but most commonly it is said to be involved in "reward" or "reinforcement". In the present article, the putative reinforcement functions of accumbens DA are summarized in a manner described as the "General Anhedonia Model". According to this model, the DA innervation of the nucleus accumbens is conceived of as a crucial link in the "reward system", which evolved to mediate the reinforcing effects of natural stimuli such as food. The reward system is said to be activated by natural reinforcing stimuli, and this activation mediates the reinforcing effects of these natural stimuli. According to this view, other stimuli such as brain stimulation and drugs can activate this system, which leads to these stimuli being reinforcing as well. Interference with DA systems is said to blunt the reinforcing effects of these rewarding stimuli, leading to "extinction". This general model of the behavioral functions of accumbens DA is utilized widely as a theoretical framework for integrating research findings. Nevertheless, there are several difficulties with the General Anhedonia Model. Several studies have observed substantial differences between the effects of extinction and the effects of DA antagonism or accumbens DA depletions. Studies involving aversive conditions indicate that DA antagonists and accumbens DA depletions can interfere with avoidance behavior, and also have demonstrated that accumbens DA release is increased by stressful or aversive stimuli. Although accumbens DA is important for drug abuse phenomena, particularly stimulant self-administration, studies that involve other reinforcers are more problematic. A large body of evidence indicates that low doses of dopamine antagonists, or depletions of accumbens DA, do not impair fundamental aspects of food motivation such as chow consumption and simple instrumental responses for food. This is particularly important, in view of the fact that many behavioral researchers consider the regulation of food motivation to be a fundamental aspect of food reinforcement. Finally, studies employing cost/benefit analyses are reviewed, and in these studies considerable evidence indicates that accumbens DA is involved in the allocation of responses in relation to various reinforcers. Nucleus accumbens DA participates in the function of enabling organisms to overcome response costs, or obstacles, in order to obtain access to stimuli such as food. In summary, nucleus accumbens DA is not seen as directly mediating food reinforcement, but instead is seen as a higher order sensorimotor integrator that is involved in modulating response output in relation to motivational factors and response constraints. Interfering with accumbens DA appears to partially dissociate the process of primary reinforcement from processes regulating instrumental response initiation, maintenance and selection.

The nature of interactions involving prefrontal and striatal dopamine systems

A number of converging lines of evidence from work in rodents suggest that dopamine (DA) function in the prefrontal cortex (PFC) and striatal terminal fields may be linked, possibly in an 'inverse' manner, whereby a change in prefrontal dopamine transmission in one direction occasions an opposite change in dopamine function in striatal territories. The present article considers the possible functional importance of this concept in the light of recent neuroanatomical data and new data from our own laboratory indicating that, at the neurochemical level, the basic finding of an inverse relationship between dopamine function in prefrontal and striatal regions also holds good in the non-human primate. The main conclusion is that the simple idea of an inverse relationship between prefrontal and striatal dopamine systems emphasizing presynaptic release mechanisms is unlikely to underlie, solely, the full repertoire of functional interactions. Whilst there is evidence consistent with dynamic interactions between prefrontal and striatal dopamine release under some circumstances, specifically, during the early phases of aversive learning, a complete account of possible interactions between prefrontal and striatal dopamine systems requires consideration of additional factors. Such factors include: (1) the precise nature of the psychological function investigated, (2) the possibility of acute, localized changes in striatal postsynaptic function secondary to changes in presynaptic function and (3) the possibility of manipulations of prefrontal cortex leading to adaptive changes in striatal function, at a diffuse, neural systems level.

Effects of local application of dopaminergic drugs into the medial prefrontal cortex of rats on latent inhibition

The involvement of the dopamine (DA) innervation of the medial prefrontal cortex (PFC) in attention was studied in a latent inhibition (LI) paradigm in rats. LI becomes evident by a retardation of conditioning to a stimulus after nonreinforced preexposure to that stimulus. LI is thought to reflect an animal's ability not to attend to irrelevant stimuli and is often used as an animal paradigm modeling schizophreniclike attentional deficits. In the present study the effects of bilateral infusions of the DA receptor agonist apomorphine (APO, 9.0 micrograms/side) and the DA receptor antagonist cis-flupenthixol (FLU, 12.0 micrograms/side) into the medial PFC on LI were assessed. Although in comparison with vehicle both APO and FLU infusions attenuated response suppression in nonpreexposed animals, the drugs differentially affected LI in preexposed animals. After infusions of APO animals failed to show conditioned suppression, whereas FLU-treated animals displayed as much suppression of responding as nonpreexposed animals. The abolition of LI induced by FLU infusions into the medial PFC suggests that prefrontal DA is involved in attentional processes in a way opposite to the established role of subcortical DA systems in these processes.

Differential involvement of the shell and core subterritories of the nucleus accumbens in latent inhibition and amphetamine-induced activity

Latent inhibition (LI) consists of retardation in conditioning to a stimulus as a consequence of its prior non-reinforced pre-exposure. In view of findings that LI is disrupted in acute schizophrenic patients and evidence from animal experiments pointing to the involvement of the mesolimbic dopamine (DA) system in this phenomenon, the present study investigated the effects of electrolytic lesions to the shell and core subterritories of the nucleus accumbens on LI in rats (Expt. 1). LI was indexed by the amount of suppression of drinking in the presence of a tone that was either pre-exposed or not prior to its pairing with reinforcement (a foot shock). Expt.2 tested the effects of the DA antagonist, haloperidol, on LI in shell- and core-lesioned animals. Expt. 3 tested the effects of shell and core lesions on spontaneous and amphetamine-induced locomotion. In Expt. 1, LI, i.e., lower suppression of drinking in the pre-exposed as compared to the non-pre-exposed animals, was obtained in the sham-operated condition. Core and shell lesions produced distinct effects on LI. Animals with core lesions developed LI, but exhibited an overall lower suppression of drinking in comparison to the sham-operated animals. In contrast, shell lesions led to a disappearance of LI. Expt. 2 replicated the differential effects of shell and core lesions on LI, although in this experiment, core lesion did not attenuate suppression of drinking. Haloperidol prevented shell-induced abolition of LI. In Expt. 3, shell- but not core-lesioned animals were more active than sham controls following amphetamine administration. These results provide evidence for functional differences between the shell and core subregions, as well as for the involvement of the mesolimbic DA system in LI.

Latent inhibition in conditioned emotional response: c-fos immunolabelling evidence for brain areas involved in the rat

Latent inhibition refers to the fact that the formation of a conditioned association between a conditioned and an unconditioned stimulus is delayed by prior exposure to the conditioned stimulus. Latent inhibition is often investigated in the context of the conditioned emotional response, in which a tone serves as the conditioned and a footshock as the unconditioned stimulus. Such a paradigm was used for the present experiments in which some rats had been pre-exposed to the tone. Two hours after a subsequent exposure to the tone, c-fos immunocytochemistry was used to map activated brain areas. The density of immunoreactive neurones was measured in brain areas involved in audition, fear, stress and memory. For the basic conditioning group, pre-exposure to the tone decreased the density of labelled cells in the auditory system, areas involved in fear and stress and a number of limbic areas, namely the amygdala, the Ammon's horn of the hippocampus and the entorhinal cortex. In contrast, the density increased in three limbic areas: the dentate gyrus, the subiculum and the nucleus accumbens. Taken together, these data suggest that latent inhibition corresponds to alterations of sensory processing which renders difficult to state about the alteration of the transfers of the sensory information to structures involved in the control of emotional responses. As some brain areas show a specific increase of activity in cases of latent inhibition, further studies will investigate how the latter brain areas contribute to the other cell density alterations reported in this study and to the latent inhibition phenomenon itself.

Effects of nicotine and amphetamine on latent inhibition in human subjects

Latent inhibition (LI) is a phenomenon in which repeated non-reinforced exposure to a stimulus retards subsequent conditioning to that stimulus; it reflects a process whereby irrelevant stimuli become ignored, and has been the subject of study concerning attentional abnormalities in schizophrenia. Low doses of the indirect dopamine (DA) agonists, amphetamine and nicotine, disrupt LI in the rat. These drugs are believed to disrupt LI via DA release in the nucleus accumbens; LI in amphetamine- and nicotine-treated rats is reinstated by administration of the DA antagonist haloperidol. In human subjects, low doses of amphetamine abolish LI, and more recently haloperidol has been shown to potentiate LI. The present study investigated the effects of nicotine on LI in human subjects, and also attempted to replicate the abolition of LI by amphetamine. Nicotine failed to affect LI when administered either subcutaneously or by cigarette smoking. LI was, however, abolished in a group of subjects given 5 mg amphetamine 90 min before testing. Supplementary analyses of the data pooled from all three experiments showed that, in contrast to an earlier report, LI was no weaker in smokers than in nonsmokers.

Dissociations in hippocampal 5-hydroxytryptamine release in the rat following Pavlovian aversive conditioning to discrete and contextual stimuli

The experiments examined the release of 5-hydroxytryptamine using in vivo microdialysis methods in the hippocampus of freely moving rats following Pavlovian aversive conditioning to discrete and contextual stimuli. Differential conditioning was achieved by manipulating the interval between the offset of a discrete auditory 'clicker' stimulus and the onset of a mild foot-shock reinforcer (0.5 mA, 0.5 s). Foot-shock occurred either simultaneously with the last second of the discrete auditory stimulus (in short-trace subjects) or 60 s later (long-trace subjects). In this way, subjects were preferentially conditioned to the discrete stimulus and background 'contextual' stimuli respectively. During conditioning subjects also received two identical unpaired visual stimuli. At test, dialysates were collected and behavioural measures taken as all animals experienced (i) the aversive and two other 'neutral' environments, and (ii) the discrete unconditioned and conditioned stimuli presented in both aversive and neutral environments. Exposure to the aversive environment, but not to either of the two neutral environments, was associated with significantly increased hippocampal 5-hydroxytryptamine release in long-trace subjects. There was also a small but non-significant increase in 5-hydroxytryptamine release in short-trace animals. In contrast, hippocampal 5-hydroxytryptamine release was unaffected by presentation of either of the discrete stimuli under all conditions. The last result was obtained despite robust behavioural responses (freezing) to the discrete conditioned stimulus. These data do not agree with the hypothesis that aversive cues generally activate 5-hydroxytryptamine function in the hippocampus. Rather, they suggest a degree of specificity whereby 5-hydroxytryptamine release in the hippocampus was determined primarily by other qualitative properties of the conditioned aversive stimulus, namely whether the aversive cue was discrete or contextual, as well as by the magnitude of conditioning.

Changes in striatal dopamine release in stress-induced conditioned suppression of motility in rats

Rats received a footshock for 10 min in a chamber with a metallic grid floor, and then placed into the chamber for 30 min after 6 days. The motility of the shocked rats showed a significant decrease (conditioned suppression of motility). In addition, the extracellular dopamine (DA) levels in the striatum were also reduced significantly in in vivo microdialysis study. Thus, dysfunction in the striatal DAergic neuronal systems is responsible for mental stress responses such as conditioned fear stress.

Non-psychostimulant drugs of abuse and anxiogenic drugs activate with differential selectivity dopamine transmission in the nucleus accumbens and in the medial prefrontal cortex of the rat

In rats vertically implanted with concentric dialysis probes in the medial prefrontal cortex and in the medial nucleus accumbens, morphine, ethanol and nicotine failed to modify extracellular dopamine in the medial prefrontal cortex at doses that were fully effective in raising extracellular dopamine in the nucleus accumbens. Conversely, the aversive/anxiogenic drugs picrotoxin, pentylenetetrazol and FG 7142, administered at subconvulsant doses, increased extracellular dopamine in the medial prefrontal cortex but failed to do so in the nucleus accumbens. Systemic administration of low doses of the 5HT3 antagonist ICS 205930, previously reported to prevent the increase of extracellular dopamine in the nucleus accumbens elicited by morphine, nicotine, ethanol and haloperidol (Carboni et al. 1989) as well as by stress (Imperato et al. 1990), also prevented the increase of extracellular dopamine elicited in the prefrontal cortex by anxiogenic drugs. Therefore, mesocortical and mesolimbic dopamine neurons show clear-cut differences in the reactivity to drugs of abuse and to aversive drugs but are both modulated by a facilitatory serotonergic input mediated by 5HT3 receptors.

Schizophrenia. A cognitive model and its implications for psychological intervention

It is argued in this article that information-processing models enable us to link psychotic phenomena to their neural bases. The core abnormality is viewed as a disturbance in the integration of sensory input with stored material. The performance of schizophrenic subjects on tasks derived from both animal learning theory and human experimental psychology is consistent with the model. The way in which such a disturbance relates to schizophrenic symptoms is outlined. It may result from an abnormality at one or more points in the neural circuit responsible for generating predictions of subsequent sensory input; in particular the hippocampus and related brain structures are implicated. The potential relevance of the model for psychological intervention is discussed.

Participation of the glutamatergic input of the nucleus accumbens in the regulation of the synaptic release of dopamine during associative learning

The changes in the synaptic release of dopamine in the medial division of the nucleus accumbens in the course of a conditioned emotional response and the influence on this process of the blockade of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors of this structure were investigated in awake Lister-hooded rats, using the method of intravital intracerebral dialysis in combination with high-pressure liquid chromatography and electrochemical detection. It was established that situational stimuli, previously combined with painful reinforcement, but not acoustic conditional signals, lead to a slow increase in the level of dopamine in the extracellular space of the nucleus accumbens. This process reaches a maximum 40 min after the beginning of testing and lasts 80 min. Dialysis perfusion of the nucleus accumbens with a solution of MK-801 (50 mumole/liter) does not alter the magnitude of the slow rise in the synaptic release of dopamine in this structure in the course of the conditioned emotional response, but completely blocks the late components of the release. It is concluded that the glutamatergic input of the nucleus accumbens participates in the regulation of the late components of the synaptic release of dopamine, governed by the conditioned emotional response, in this structure through NMDA receptors.

The behavioral neurochemistry of motivation: methodological and conceptual issues in studies of the dynamic activity of nucleus accumbens dopamine

Considerable experimental and clinical evidence links forebrain dopamine (DA) systems to the performance of motor activities and to motivational processes. Much of the support for this conclusion was obtained from studies utilizing lesions or drugs to manipulate aspects of central dopaminergic function. Although such experiments yield important information concerning the behavioral consequences of interference with DA systems in brain, they do not demonstrate any relation between the dynamic activity of DA neurons and the level or type of motor function exhibited by the organism. This review discusses the emerging field of behavioral neurochemistry, and provides an overview of recent studies investigating the relation between nucleus accumbens DA release and behavior. Particular emphasis is placed upon current research involving microdialysis, voltammetry and electrophysiology. These different methods are viewed as complementary techniques for investigating the activity of DA systems in behaving animals. Evidence indicates that DA activity is most reliably activated by stimuli that trigger instrumental behavior and during the preparatory or instrumental phase of motivated behavior. The effects of consummatory reactions to positive reinforcers are somewhat equivocal; with food consumption, dialysis studies have yielded inconsistent results, while some voltammetric and electrophysiological studies have shown that DA activity in accumbens or ventral tegmental area actually decreases during consumption of food reinforcement. Moreover, the responsiveness of accumbens DA activity during behavioral stimulation is not unique to appetitive conditions, as several studies have shown that aversive or stressful conditions also stimulate accumbens DA release or metabolism. It is reasonable to suggest at this time that accumbens DA neurons are activated by a variety of different motivational conditions, but that the consequence of that activation is to modulate the behavioral reactivity of the organism. This type of function is seen as representing an area of overlap between motor and motivational processes.

Correlating mind and body

Gray's integration of the different levels of description and explanation in his theory is problematic: (1) The introduction of consciousness into his theorising consists of the mind-brain identity assumption, which tells us nothing new. (2) There need not be correlations between levels of description. (3) Gray's account does not extend beyond “brute” correlation. Integration must be achieved in a principled, mutually constraining way.

Reversal of amphetamine-induced behaviours by MDL 100,907, a selective 5-HT2A antagonist

MDL 100,907 is a potent and selective antagonist of the 5-HT2A receptor which, unlike other antagonists at this receptor, has little affinity for the 5-HT2C receptor. We have investigated the antipsychotic potential of MDL 100,907 by examining its ability to antagonise different behavioural effects of amphetamine in rats. MDL 100,907 reversed the locomotor stimulant effects of amphetamine in rats without itself having any effect on locomotor activity. It also antagonised the disruptive effects of amphetamine on the development of latent inhibition. In contrast, MDL 100,907 had no effect on the discriminative stimulus properties of amphetamine, nor did it affect the ability of amphetamine to reduce the threshold required to sustain rewarding brain stimulation in the ventral tegmental area. This profile is different from that of typical and atypical neuroleptics, and also from other 5-HT2 receptor antagonists, which lack the selectivity of MDL 100,907. These results suggest that MDL 100,907 may have a unique interaction with dopaminergic systems and support the further development of selective 5-HT2 receptor antagonists as a novel therapeutic strategy for schizophrenia.

Consciousness beyond the comparator

Gray's comparator model fails to provide an adequate explanation of consciousness for two reasons. First, it is based on a narrow definition of consciousness that excludes basic phenomenology and active functions of consciousness. Second, match/mismatch decisions can be made without producing an experience of consciousness. The model thus violates the sufficiency criterion.

Ultimate differences

Gray unwisely melds together two distinguishable contributions of consciousness: one to epistemology, the other to evolution. He also renders consciousness needlessly invisible behaviorally.

Human consciousness: One of a kind

To avoid teleological interpretations, it is important to make a distinction between functions and uses of consciousness, and to address questions concerning the consequences of consciousness. Assumptions about the phylogenetic distribution of consciousness are examined. It is concluded that there is some value in identifying consciousness an exclusively human attribute.

Context and consciousness

The commentary argues (1) that we cannot be sure that human consciousness has survival value and (2) that in order to understand the origins and, perhaps, the function of consciousness, we should examine the behavioural and neural precursors to consciousness in nonhumans. An example is given of research on the role of context in decisions regarding fleeing from probable predators in the Mongolian gerbil.

Extracellular glutamate in the nucleus accumbens during a conditioned emotional response in the rat

In vivo microdialysis combined with HPLC-EC analysis was used to monitor extracellular glutamate and GABA in the medial nucleus accumbens of Lister hooded rats during acquisition and expression of a conditioned emotional response. Footshock paired with tone (acquisition of conditioned emotional response) causes a significant decrease in extracellular glutamate during the period of footshock followed by a marked, but short lasting increase when the rats return to their home cage. Expression of the conditioned emotional response on exposure to the contextual cue produces no change in glutamate during exposure to the contextual cue, but a short lasting increase after. Thus, both the conditioned emotional response and footshock are associated with marked, but short lasting, increases in extracellular glutamate in the nucleus accumbens which, in both cases, occurred after the aversive stimuli, i.e., when the rats are returned to their home cage. In contrast, when control rats are exposed to the testing box without giving footshock there is an increase in extracellular glutamate during the exposure period and this is accompanied by exploratory behaviour. The conditioned emotional response (contextual cue), footshock and exposure of the control rats to the test box all resulted in increased extracellular GABA during exposure to the test situation. These results suggest that increases in extracellular glutamate in the medial nucleus accumbens caused by the conditioned emotional response or footshock are probably associated with relief from, rather than response to danger.

The role of mesolimbic dopaminergic and retrohippocampal afferents to the nucleus accumbens in latent inhibition: implications for schizophrenia

Latent inhibition (LI) consists in a retardation of conditioning seen when the to-be-conditioned stimulus is first presented a number of times without other consequence. Disruption of LI has been proposed as a possible model of the cognitive abnormality that underlies the positive psychotic symptoms of acute schizophrenia. We review here evidence in support of the model, including experiments tending to show that: (1) disruption of LI is characteristic of acute, positively-symptomatic schizophrenia; (2) LI depends upon dopaminergic activity; (3) LI depends specifically upon dopamine release in n. accumbens; (4) LI depends upon the integrity of the hippocampal formation and the retrohippocampal region reciprocally connected to the hippocampal formation; (5) the roles of n. accumbens and the hippocampal system in LI are interconnected.

Central nervous stimulants facilitate sexual behavior in male rats with medial prefrontal cortex lesions

Male rats with lesions of the cerebral cortex near the midline in the frontal region destroying most of the cingulate cortex and producing some damage to adjacent frontal areas have very long mount and intromission latencies. Otherwise their sexual behavior is essentially normal. The dopamine releasers amfonelic acid, 0.5 mg/kg, and amphetamine, 1 mg/kg, reduced the mount and intromission latencies in males with such lesions. Caffeine, 30 mg/kg, had similar effects. None of the drugs modified sexual behavior in intact males. It has been suggested that medial prefrontal lesions reduce the animal's reactivity to environmental stimuli, and hence renders the activation of sexual behavior difficult. Present results show that stimulant drugs are capable of compensating for this reduced reactivity. The possible mechanisms behind this effect are discussed. The lesion had also a small but consistent effect on the intromission ratio, suggesting some motor impairment. The effect on intromission ratio was not reduced by the drugs, suggesting that the lesion's motor consequences are mediated by mechanisms different from those controlling behavioral reactivity. The noradrenaline precursor dl-threo-dihydroxyphenylserine, 10 mg/kg, in combination with carbidopa, 50 mg/kg, increased mount and intromission latencies in both intact and lesioned males. Thus, activation of noradrenergic neurotransmission had effects opposite to those found after activation of dopaminergic transmission. Noradrenergic stimulation cannot, therefore, be important for the effects of amphetamine or amfonelic acid.

Brain microdialysis and its application for the study of animal behaviour

Microdialysis is a sampling method that is used to determine the extracellular concentration of neurotransmitters in the brain. The method can be applied to conscious and unrestrained animals and is very suitable for the study of the chemistry of endogenous behaviour. This article reviews the contribution that microdialysis made to our understanding of the chemistry of behaviour. Methodological and practical considerations such as the implantation time and the use of guide cannulas are reviewed. The question whether neurotransmitters and related metabolites in dialysates reflect true synaptic release is critically discussed. There is much evidence that dopamine, noradrenaline, acetylcholine and serotonin in dialysates are related to neurotransmission, but there is serious doubt whether this is the case with amino acid transmitters such as GABA, glutamate and aspartate. Until now far over 100 papers appeared that used microdialysis in behavioural studies. Behavioural activation, the sleep-awake cycle and diurnal rhythms were subject of several of these studies. Various workers have described neurochemical changes in the brain that are related to feeding. Other studies were concerned with sexual behaviour and the sexual cycle in females. Parturition, maternal behaviour and offspring recognition have been studied in a series of microdialysis studies carried out in sheep. An overview is given of the microdialysis studies that were carried out to understand the biochemistry of stress. In this respect dopamine and noradrenaline have received much attention. A great number of microdialysis studies dealt with the role of dopamine in self-stimulation, reward and aversive emotions. It is concluded that microdialysis is at presently the most versatile and practical method to study the chemistry of behaviour and it is to be expected that it will soon be a routine methodology in behavioural research. Finally, perspectives and possible future developments of the methods are discussed.

Asymmetrical involvement of mesolimbic dopaminergic neurons in affective perception

Pharmacological studies suggest that increases and decreases in dopamine levels in the nucleus accumbens contribute to positive and negative affective states, respectively. In vivo neurochemical investigations have led to contradictory conclusions, since increases and decreases in dopamine release have been observed in aversive situations. Clinical and experimental observations argue for a hemispheric asymmetry in the processing of appetitive and aversive stimuli. Mesolimbic dopaminergic neurons are part of integrative networks which appear specifically organized in the right and left hemispheres. Dopaminergic neurons may thus be involved in affective processes but in a different manner in the two hemispheres. We tested this hypothesis in the nucleus accumbens of male rats using in vivo voltammetry and a conditioned aversion paradigm to an olfactory stimulus. We found that dopaminergic responses were similar in the two hemispheres following the initial encounter with the stimulus. After conditioning, however, dopaminergic responses to a naturally attractive olfactory stimulus were more elevated in the right nucleus accumbens and responses to an aversive stimulus more marked in the left nucleus. In addition, dopaminergic responses displayed an intraaccumbal regionalization, in particular opposite variations were obtained in the core and shell subterritories in response to the aversive situation. These results may provide new insights in the understanding of the relative contribution of the two hemispheres in affective perception in normal and psychopathological conditions.

Dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens: the perspective from aberrations of consciousness in schizophrenia

Studies of the cognitive abnormalities that underlie positive symptoms in acute schizophrenia, and animal experiments that attempt to model similar cognitive abnormalities and to elucidate the brain mechanisms underlying them, suggest that the release of dopamine from A 10 terminals in the nucleus (n.) accumbens, in interaction with the projection to n. accumbens from the retrohippocampal region, is closely related to stimulus salience and perhaps to the heightened states of awareness reported by schizophrenics.

Latent inhibition in drug naive schizophrenics: relationship to duration of illness and dopamine D2 binding using SPET

The dual aims of the study were (1) to examine the effect of neuroleptic medication on the expression of latent inhibition (LI) by studying LI in drug naive schizophrenic patients, and (2) to investigate the relationship between LI and dopamine D2 receptor binding in the basal ganglia using single photon emission tomography (SPET). Subjects constituted a sub-set of patients investigated in a major study of in vivo D2 receptor binding in schizophrenia (Pilowsky et al., 1993). Striatal D2 receptor binding was assessed in 15 neuroleptic naive schizophrenic patients and 13 healthy volunteers. The performance of subjects on a within-subject auditory latent inhibition paradigm was also assessed. There was found to be no significant difference in LI between schizophrenic patients and normal controls, both groups showing a strong within-subject LI effect. There was also found to be no association between LI and dopamine D2 receptor binding in either the left or the right basal ganglia. This lack of association indicates that LI is not directly related to post-synaptic D2 receptor levels in the striatum. LI was, however, found to be correlated with duration of illness in the schizophrenic group. Patients with a relatively short duration of illness (< 12 months) tended to show reversed, or absent, LI whereas patients with a longer illness duration (> 12 months) showed intact LI. The effect on LI of duration of illness is consistent with previous findings that LI is disrupted specifically in acute, but not chronic, schizophrenia. Previous studies have assumed that this pattern of results is due to the stabilising effect of long-term neuroleptic medication. The present findings in a sample of neuroleptic naive schizophrenic patients indicate that this is unlikely to be the case. Rather, it appears that the reinstatement of LI in schizophrenic patients over time is due to a factor(s) intrinsic to the evolution of the schizophrenic illness.

Conditioned dopamine release: dependence upon N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors

The study have investigated the effect of a conditioned emotional response using a contextual cue on dopamine release in the rat nucleus accumbens, measured with in vivo microdialysis, and its inhibition by N-methyl-D-aspartate antagonist dizocilpine maleate. The extracellular level of dopamine in the medial nucleus accumbens markedly increased for up to 40 min when rats were given mild footshock in the testing box. When the rats were returned to the testing box, but not given footshock (conditioned emotional response), there was an immediate and long-lasting (80 min) increase in extracellular dopamine. Dizocilpine maleate (50 mumol/l) administered into the nucleus accumbens through the dialysis probe had no significant effect on the immediate increase in dopamine induced by conditioned emotional response but completely prevented the later phase. Dizocilpine maleate had no effect on basal dopamine release in control rats but decreased basal dopamine in rats exposed to footshock 2 h previously. The alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazoleproprionate/kainate antagonist 6-cyano-7-nitroquinnoxaline-2,3-dione (100 mumol/l) had no effect on the increase in dopamine release in response to conditioned emotional response. The results indicate that the acquisition of conditioned emotional response causes long-lasting changes in the mechanisms involved in the glutamatergic control of dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens. Furthermore glutamate inputs into the nucleus accumbens may also regulate the delayed phase of conditioned dopamine release during expression of conditioned emotional response to a contextural cue through activation of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors.

The role of dopamine in drug abuse viewed from the perspective of its role in motivation

Drugs of abuse share with conventional reinforcers the activation of specific neural pathways in the CNS that are the substrate of their motivational properties. Dopamine is recognized as the transmitter of one such neural pathway, being involved in at least three major aspects of motivation: modulation of motivational state, acquisition (incentive learning) and expression of incentive properties by motivational stimuli. Drugs of abuse of different pharmacological classes stimulate in the low dose range dopamine transmission particularly in the ventral striatum. Apart from psychostimulants, the evidence that stimulation of dopamine transmission by drugs of abuse provides the primary motivational stimulus for drug self-administration is either unconvincing or negative. However, stimulation of dopamine transmission is essential for the activational properties of drugs of abuse and might be instrumental for the acquisition of responding to drug-related incentive stimuli (incentive learning). Dopamine is involved in the induction and in the expression of behavioural sensitization by repeated exposure to various drugs of abuse. Sensitization to the dopamine-stimulant properties of specific drug classes leading to facilitation of incentive learning of drug-related stimuli might account for the strong control over behaviour exerted by these stimuli in the addiction state. Withdrawal from drugs of abuse results in a reduction in basal dopamine transmission in vivo and in reduced responding for conventional reinforcers. Although these changes are likely to be the expression of a state of dependence of the dopamine system their contribution to the motivational state of drug addiction is unclear.

A cognitive model for schizophrenia and its possible neural basis

It is proposed that the basic disturbance in schizophrenia corresponds to a disruption of the normal relationship between stored material and current sensory input. The link between information processing disturbances and their biological bases may be facilitated by the use of paradigms derived from animal learning theory. A model for the emergence of schizophrenic symptoms is presented. The core cognitive abnormality may result from a disturbance at any point in the neural circuit involved in the prediction of subsequent sensory input.

Antagonism of amphetamine-induced disruption of latent inhibition in rats by haloperidol and ondansetron: implications for a possible antipsychotic action of ondansetron

Latent inhibition (LI) is a behavioural phenomenon whereby preexposure to a stimulus without reinforcement interferes with the formation of subsequent associations to that stimulus. Using preexposure to a tone stimulus which subsequently serves as a conditioned stimulus for suppression of licking, we have confirmed that LI is disrupted by a low dose of amphetamine. Haloperidol was able to prevent this effect of amphetamine. Ondansetron, a selective and potent 5HT3 receptor antagonist, was also shown to be effective at blocking the amphetamine-induced disruption of LI at a dose of 0.01 mg/kg, but not at 0.1 mg/kg. In addition, it was demonstrated that ondansetron could enhance LI; using only ten preexposures, no LI was obtained in the saline group, but was apparent in animals given ondansetron, an effect which has been previously shown with haloperidol. Haloperidol, at the higher dose used, reduced suppression of licking, however, ondansetron at the effective dose had no such effect. It is concluded that ondansetron is able to attenuate increases in dopamine activity, produced pharmacologically with amphetamine without affecting baseline dopamine activity. The implications of these findings for a possible antipsychotic action of ondansetron are discussed.

The involvement of nucleus accumbens dopamine in appetitive and aversive motivation

In recent years, considerable emphasis has been placed upon the putative role of nucleus accumbens dopamine systems in appetitive motivation and positive reinforcement. However, considerable evidence indicates that brain dopamine in general, and nucleus accumbens dopamine in particular, is involved in aspects of aversive motivation. Administration of dopamine antagonists or localized interference with nucleus accumbens dopamine systems has been shown to disrupt active avoidance behavior. In addition, accumbens dopamine release and metabolism is activated by a wide variety of stressful conditions. A review of the literature indicates that there are substantial similarities between the characteristics of dopaminergic involvement in appetitive and aversive motivation. There is conflicting evidence about the role of dopamine in emotion, and little evidence to suggest that the profound and consistent changes in instrumental behavior produced by interference with DA systems are due to direct dopaminergic mediation of positive affective responses such as hedonia. It is suggested that nucleus accumbens dopamine is involved in aspects of sensorimotor functions that are involved in both appetitive and aversive motivation.