Composite autologous-allogeneic skin replacement: development and clinical application

Burns (Part 2). Tops and flops using cultured epithelial autografts in children

The goal of this article is to review the status of cultured epithelial autografts in clinical practice with particular focus on the pediatric subset of patients. The current indications include massive deep burns (>60 - 70% total body surface area), resurfacing-type postburn scar revisions, and skin defect coverage following excision of large skin lesions like giant nevi. Although this method can be lifesaving for massively burned patients, and although excellent functional and cosmetic results may be obtained under ideal circumstances, formidable problems continue to exist. Take is inconsistent, cultured grafts are extremely susceptible to infection, and skin breakdown during the first months post grafting may occur due to mechanical instability of the regenerating skin. It may take one more decade of concerted research, jointly performed by clinicians and tissue culture technology experts in order to fabricate more skin-like grafts which are robust, reliable, and less expensive. Then, "cultured skin" will conquer the world and benefit countless patients.

Reduced engraftment and wound closure of cryopreserved cultured skin substitutes grafted to athymic mice

Cryopreservation of cultured skin substitutes is a requirement for establishment of banks of alternative materials for treatment of acute and chronic skin wounds. To determine whether cryopreservation of skin substitutes that contain cultured cells reduces their efficacy for wound closure, cell-biopolymer grafts were frozen, recovered into culture, and grafted to wounds on athymic mice. Grafts consisted of cultured human keratinocytes and fibroblasts attached to collagen-glycosaminoglycan substrates that were frozen in cell culture medium with 20% serum and 10% DMSO at a controlled rate and stored overnight in liquid nitrogen. After recovery into culture for 24 h, frozen or unfrozen (control) skin substitutes were grafted to full-thickness wounds on athymic mice. Wound area and surface electrical capacitance were measured at 2, 3, and 4 weeks after grafting at which time animals were sacrificed. Wounds were scored for presence of human cells by direct immunofluorescence staining with a monoclonal antibody to HLA-ABC. The data demonstrate that cell-biopolymer grafts are less efficacious after controlled-rate cryopreservation using 10% DMSO as a cryoprotectant. Frozen grafts at 4 weeks after surgery have significantly smaller wound areas, higher capacitance (wetter surface), and fewer healed wounds that contain human cells. The results suggest that these conditions for cryopreservation of cultured grafts reduce graft viability. Improved conditions for cryopreservation are required to maintain viability and efficacy of cultured skin substitutes after frozen storage.

A model of corrective gene transfer in X-linked ichthyosis

Single gene recessive genetic skin disorders offer attractive prototypes for the development of therapeutic cutaneous gene delivery. We have utilized X-linked ichthyosis (XLI), characterized by loss of function of the steroid sulfatase arylsulfatase C (STS), to develop a model of corrective gene delivery to human skin in vivo. A new retroviral expression vector was produced and utilized to effect STS gene transfer to primary keratinocytes from XLI patients. Transduction was associated with restoration of full-length STS protein expression as well as steroid sulfatase enzymatic activity in proportion to the number of proviral integrations in XLI cells. Transduced and uncorrected XLI keratinocytes, along with normal controls, were then grafted onto immunodeficient mice to regenerate full thickness human epidermis. Unmodified XLI keratinocytes regenerated a hyperkeratotic epidermis lacking STS expression with defective skin barrier function, effectively recapitulating the human disease in vivo. Transduced XLI keratinocytes from the same patients, however, regenerated epidermis histologically indistinguishable from that formed by keratinocytes from patients with normal skin. Transduced XLI epidermis demonstrated STS expression in vivo by immunostaining as well as a normalization of histologic appearance at 5 weeks post-grafting. In addition, transduced XLI epidermis demonstrated a return of barrier function parameters to normal. These findings demonstrate corrective gene delivery in human XLI patient skin tissue at both molecular and functional levels and provide a model of human cutaneous gene therapy.

Treatment of burns and donor sites with human allogeneic keratinocytes grown on acellular pig dermis

The absence of a dermal component predisposes cultured epidermal sheets to instability, contractibility, and makes them difficult to handle. In order to overcome these drawbacks, we developed recombined human/pig skin (RHPS) composed of human keratinocytes cultured on cell-free pig dermis. The original intention to prepare a permanent skin substitute composed of xenodermis and autologous epidermis was not achieved, but it has been proved that RHPS can serve as an effective, ready to use keratinocyte delivery system when applied 'upside-down', i.e. with epidermal cells facing the wound surface. The keratinocyte layer establishes a direct contact with the wound bed, while the dermal layer mechanically protects the wound. Twenty deep dermal burns were grafted with RHPS: 13 (65%) healed completely in 4-14 days, three (15%) healed partially and four (20%) did not heal. Of five full thickness burn wounds only one healed after repeated RHPS grafting within 18 days. Thirty-one (100%) donor sites treated with any of the three forms of RHPS, subconfluent, confluent meshed or confluent unmeshed, healed within 6-8 days compared with 14-18 days in control sites. Seven donor sites (100%) of immunodeficient patients with prolonged wound healing epithelialized in 7-10 days under RHPS compared with 32-90 days in areas treated with tulle gras and dry gauze.

Glutaraldehyde crosslinking of collagen substrates inhibits degradation in skin substitutes grafted to athymic mice

Collagen-based implants have been described as vehicles for transplantation of cultured skin cells for treatment of burn wounds. To optimize vascularization and repair of connective tissue, collagen solubility and glutaraldehyde crosslinking were evaluated. Cultured skin substitutes consisted of human keratinocytes and fibroblasts attached to collagen-glycosaminoglycan substrates that were prepared from acid-insoluble, or partially soluble collagen. Substrates were crosslinked with 0% or 0.25% glutaraldehyde, populated with cells, and grafted to full-thickness wounds on athymic mice (n = 6/condition). After 6 weeks, the wound area was measured by planimetry, and healed wounds were scored by histochemistry for immunoreactivity to HLA-ABC and bovine collagen. Data analysis shows that crosslinking of collagen implants with glutaraldehyde is associated (p < 0.001) with detection of the implant. No association was found between solubility of bovine collagen and immunodetection. Epidermis of all wounds was positive for HLA-ABC, and no differences in wound areas were found. These results suggest that glutaraldehyde crosslinking of collagen implants decreases the rate of biodegradation. Delayed degradation of crosslinked collagen may result clinically in reduced engraftment of skin substitutes.

Use of Skin Substitutes in Adult Canadian Burn Centres

Seventeen Canadian adult burn centres were surveyed to determine the pattern of use, cost and availability of nine skin substitutes. An equal number of centres in the United States with comparable bed capacities were approached for comparison. Eighty-eight per cent of the Canadian centres and 76% of the United States centres responded to the questionnaire. Human cadaver skin, pig skin and Biobrane were used by approximately twice as many United States centres as Canadian centres. Cultured epidermal autografts (CEAs) were used by 20% of the Canadian centres and 15% of the American centres. Opsite, Tegaderm and Duoderm were used widely in both countries. Alloderm was used only in the United States, and amnion was not used in either country. The most common use of each substitute varied among centres, however, the pattern of use was comparable between the two countries, with the exception that Biobrane was not used in Canada to cover donor site wounds. In the United States, 60% of cadaver skin and all CEAs were purchased from private companies, whereas use of these two relatively expensive skin substitutes in Canada was restricted to centres with access to hospital-affiliated skin banks or laboratories. With the dependence of Canadian centres on noncommercial sources of biological skin replacements, research development in established skin banks should be encouraged, and regional discrepancies regarding access to these facilities addressed.

Use of a porcine dermis template to enhance widely expanded mesh autologous split-thickness skin graft growth: preliminary report

To answer the question whether a xenograft dermal substitute could enhance skin grafting, we used porcine dermis as a template for a widely expanded mesh autologous split-thickness skin (ASTS) graft in a rat model. Four groups of rats had received widely expanded meshed skin autografts to cover an excised back wound. Group 1 had a bed of autologous dermis, group 2 had porcine xenograft dermis, group 3 had widely expanded meshed autograft alone, and group 4 had no graft with the wound healing by contraction alone. Wounds were studied by clinical inspection for texture and contraction, and by histologic and immunofluorescent techniques. At 2 weeks, there was acceptable ASTS graft take, and most of the wound healed completely by 3 weeks. The integrity of this complex skin graft was maintained for 4 months but wound contraction gradually decreased overall wound size. Size was maintained better in the ASTS-autodermis and ASTS-xenodermis groups at postgraft 4, 5, and 6 weeks when compared with the ASTS graft, and there was no difference between the ASTS-autodermis and ASTS-xenodermis groups. Thus both allodermis and xenodermis provided a similar template to enhance widely expanded mesh skin growth and delay wound contraction. The pathologic studies indicate that the xenodermis collagen was replaced either by fibrosis or by biodegradation to rat collagen. The immunofluorescent study also reflected that anti-porcine antibody activity was hugely diminished in the ASTS-xenodermis graft wound after long-term follow-up. In conclusion, either autodermis or xenodermis enhances widely expanded mesh ASTS survival in a rat model, and could significantly maintain the original wound size better than ASTS graft without a template. In a long-term follow-up study, the porcine dermis was replaced either by fibrosis or biodegradation to rat dermis.

What is new in clinical research in wound healing

Treating the underlying pathophysiology of the wound remains of utmost importance. Several new treatment modalities may soon be available as adjunctive treatments. The efficacy of some remains to be established in well-controlled clinical studies.

Grafting on nude mice of living skin equivalents produced using human collagens

Autologous epidermal transplantation for human burn management is an example of a significant breakthrough in tissue engineering. However, the main drawback with this treatment remains the fragility of these grafts during and after surgery. A new human bilayered skin equivalent (hSE) was produced in our laboratory to overcome this problem. The aim of the present work was to study skin regeneration after hSE grafting onto nude mice. A comparative study was carried out over a period of 90 days, between anchored bovine skin equivalent, hSE and hSE+, the latter containing additional matrix components included at concentrations similar to those in human skin in vivo. The addition of a dermal layer to the epidermal sheet led to successful graft take, enhanced healing, and provided mechanical resistance to the grafts after transplantation. In situ analysis of the grafts showed good ultrastructural organization, including the deposition of a continuous basement membrane 1 week after surgery.

Surface electrical capacitance as a noninvasive index of epidermal barrier in cultured skin substitutes in athymic mice

Restoration of an epidermal barrier is a definitive requirement for wound closure. To determine formation of an epidermal barrier as a function of hydration of the stratum corneum, we measured surface electrical capacitance (SEC) of the epidermis in cultured skin substitutes (CSS) in vitro and after grafting to athymic mice. CSS were prepared from human keratinocytes and fibroblasts attached to collagen-glycosaminoglycan substrates. On culture days 3, 7, 14, 17, and 21, SEC was measured in situ. CSS (n = 18; mean +/- SEM) showed a time-dependent decrease of SEC (picoFarads, "pF") from 4721 +/- 28 pF on day 3 to 394 +/- 117 pF on day 14, and subsequent increase to 1677 +/- 325 pF on day 21. After 14-d incubation, parallel CSS samples (n = 5) or murine autografts (n = 5) were grafted orthotopically to athymic mice. After grafting, CSS showed decreases in SEC from 910 +/- 315 pF at 2 wk to 40 +/- 10 pF at 4 wk with no significant decreases thereafter. Control values for murine autograft were 870 +/- 245 pF at 2 wk, and 87 +/- 30 pF at 4 wk. SEC values for native murine skin (n = 10) were 91 +/- 18 pF, and for native human skin (n = 10) were 32 +/- 5 pF. The data demonstrate that SEC decreases with time in culture and that healed or intact skin has approximately 10- to 100-fold lower SEC than CSS in vitro. This noninvasive technique provides a quantitative index of epidermal barrier in CSS in vitro and demonstrates the development of functional epidermal barrier during healing of wounds treated with cultured skin substitutes.

Human skin histology as demonstrated by Herovici's stain: a guide for the improvement of dermal substitutes for use with cultured keratinocytes?

The potential for the widespread use of cultured keratinocytes for burns treatment is handicapped by practical problems such as fragility, poor take and, often, unsatisfactory cosmesis. Although dermal equivalents reduce these problems there remains a lack of consensus on what is the best structure of such equivalents. At present the commonest support is type I collagen. This histological study, however, using Herovici's stain, clearly shows that in human skin from a variety of anatomical sites the epidermis is not in direct contact with type I collagen but rather with a distinct layer of type III collagen. We suggest that dermal equivalents may have to be constructed so as to include a layer of type III collagen at the interface between the keratinocytes and a type I collagen neo-dermis, so mimicking normal skin structure more closely.

Comparative assessment of cultured skin substitutes and native skin autograft for treatment of full-thickness burns

OBJECTIVE

Comparison of cultured skin substitutes (CSSs) and split-thickness autograft (STAG) was performed to assess whether the requirement for autologous skin grafts may be reduced in the treatment of massive burns.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Cultured skin substitutes consisting of collagen-glycosaminoglycan substrates populated with autologous fibroblasts and keratinocytes have been demonstrated to close full-thickness skin wounds in athymic mice and to express normal skin antigens after closure of excised wounds in burn patients.

METHODS

Data were collected from 17 patients between days 2 and 14 to determine incidence of exudate, incidence of regrafting, coloration, keratinization, and percentage of site covered by graft (n = 17). Outcome was evaluated on an ordinal scale (0 = worst; 10 = best) beginning at day 14, with primary analyses at 28 days (n = 10) and 1 year (n = 4) for erythema, pigmentation, epithelial blistering, surface roughness, skin suppleness, and raised scar.

RESULTS

Sites treated with CSSs had increased incidence of exudate (p = 0.06) and decreased percentage of engraftment (p < 0.05) compared with STAG. Outcome parameters during the first year showed no differences in erythema, blistering, or suppleness. Pigmentation was greater, scar was less raised, but regrafting was more frequent in CSS sites than STAG. No differences in qualitative outcomes were found after 1 year, and antibodies to bovine collagen were not detected in patient sera.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that outcome of engrafted CSSs is not different from STAG and that increased incidence of regrafting is related to decreased percentage of initial engraftment. Increased rates of engraftment of CSSs may lead to improved outcome for closure of burn wounds, allow greater availability of materials for grafting, and reduce requirements for donor skin autograft.

Effect of glycerol on intracellular virus survival: implications for the clinical use of glycerol-preserved cadaver skin

Glycerol has long been used for the preservation of skin allografts. The antimicrobial activity of glycerol has not been fully documented. This paper reports the results of an investigation of a model studying the effect of glycerol on the inactivation of intracellular viruses. Two viruses--herpes simplex type I (HSV-1) and poliovirus--were cultured within human dermal fibroblasts. These intracellular viruses were incubated with 50 per cent, 85 per cent and 98 per cent glycerol at 4 degrees C and 20 degrees C for 4 weeks. Each week, the cultures in glycerol and controls in fibroblast maintenance medium were assayed for virus infectivity by examining the ability of harvested viruses to infect further fibroblasts. At 4 degrees C, 85 per cent glycerol could not fully inactivate intracellular HSV-I or poliovirus even after 4 weeks; 98 per cent glycerol inactivated intracellular HSV-I (after 3 weeks) but could not fully inactivate intracellular poliovirus after 4 weeks. At 20 degrees C, 85 per cent glycerol inactivated intracellular HSV-I (within 1 week) but could not fully inactivate intracellular poliovirus after 4 weeks; 98 per cent glycerol inactivated intracellular HSV-I (within 1 week) and inactivated intracellular poliovirus (after 2 weeks). It is suggested that, on the basis of this study, glycerol can reduce intracellular virus infectivity but that its effects are very dependent on concentration, time and temperature such that we would recommend that allograft skin be exposed to 98 per cent glycerol for a minimum of at least 4 weeks at a minimum temperature of 20 degrees C before clinical use.

Effects of fibroblasts of different origin on long term maintenance of xenotransplanted human epidermal keratinocytes in immunodeficient mice

We examined effects of fibroblasts of different origin on long-term maintenance of xenotransplanted human epidermal keratinocytes. A suspension of cultured epidermal cells, originating from adult human trunk skin, was injected into double mutant immunodeficient (BALB/c nu/scid) mice subcutaneously, with or without cultured fibroblastic cells of different origin. At one week after transplantation, the epidermal cells generated epidermoid cysts consisting of human epidermis-like tissue. When the epidermal cells were injected alone or together with fibroblastic cells derived from human bone marrow, muscle fascia, or murine dermis, organized epidermoid cysts regressed within 6 weeks. In contrast, when the epidermal cells were injected together with human dermal fibroblasts, generated epidermoid cysts were maintained in vivo for more than 24 weeks. Histological examination showed that the reorganized epidermis, after injection of both epidermal keratinocytes and dermal fibroblasts, retained normal structures of the original epidermis during 6 to 24 weeks after transplantation. The results indicate that human dermal fibroblasts facilitate the long-term maintenance of the reorganized epidermis after xenotransplantation of cultured human epidermal keratinocytes by supporting self renewal of the human epidermal tissue in vivo.

Cultured epithelial autograft: five years of clinical experience with twenty-eight patients

Cultured epithelial autograft (CEA) has been used as an adjunct in burn wound coverage at the Vancouver Hospital and Health Sciences Centre since 1988, and has been available to all patients admitted with significant burn injuries. During the 5-year period from 1988 to 1992 inclusive, 28 patients treated with CEA survived long enough for assessment. The mean age was 35.3 years with a mean total body surface area burn of 52.2% and a mean total full thickness injury of 42.4%. CEA was applied to wounds covering between 2% and 35% body surface area (BSA; mean 10.4%) after excision to fat or fascia. Most wounds had interim homograft coverage. Preservation of homograft dermis was attempted in three patients at the time of removal without effect. The mean CEA "take" was 26.9% of the grafted area. Eight patients had 50% or greater take and were discharged with between 1 and 19% BSA covered with CEA. Thirteen patients had no take on wounds between 2 and 16% BSA. Overall mortality in burn patients treated at the Vancouver Hospital and Health Sciences Centre from 1988 to 1992 was not significantly different from 1983 to 1987 with the populations being similar in terms of total BSA burns, age, inhalation injury, and homograft availability. When compared to a matched control population from the preceding 5 years, when CEA was not available, there was no significant difference in duration of hospital stay or number of autograft harvests. However, approximately one more debridement without autograft harvest per CEA patient occurred. Timing and depth of wound excision, interim coverage, type of dressing, and wound microbiology were not found to influence good versus poor take. The anterior trunk and thighs were the best recipient sites. Subjective differences between CEA and meshed autograft were noted. The results show that after 5 years of use, CEA engraftment continues to be unpredictable and inconsistent, and hence, it should be used as only a biologic dressing and experimental adjunct to conventional burn wound coverage with split thickness autograft.

Transplantation of keratinocytes in the treatment of wounds

BACKGROUND

Keratinocyte grafting can be used to treat acute traumatic and chronic non-healing wounds. The keratinocyte sheets are fragile and clinical "take" is difficult to assess, especially as activated keratinocytes secrete many growth factors, which have effects on wound healing apart from take. We have developed animal models of grafting that allow us to examine factors influencing autologous keratinocyte graft take. Results show clearly that pretreatment of the wound bed with viable dermis greatly increases the take of keratinocyte grafts.

DATA SOURCES

International literature.

CONCLUSIONS

As a greater understanding of the complex interactions of cell and matrix evolve, so will potential therapeutic maneuvers, not just in the field of cultured keratinocyte grafts, but clearly in that of benign tumors, for example, keloids, and that of oncology. There is now overwhelming evidence of the requirement for a dermal substitute for cultured keratinocyte autografts, and the sheet complexity of the situation demands that this should approximate live human dermis as closely as possible. The stumbling blocks relate to avoiding the risks of viral transmission, tissue matching of host and donor, providing early epithelial cover, and improving delivery systems for fragile keratinocyte grafts.

Use of an acellular allograft dermal matrix (AlloDerm) in the management of full-thickness burns

Scarring and contracture are major long-term sequelae of meshed split-thickness autografting for full-thickness skin injury. In the absence of dermis, mature fibroblasts secrete collagen in the altered pattern of scar. This case report illustrates the use of an acellular dermal matrix processed from human allograft skin (AlloDerm) in the treatment of a full-thickness burn injury. The processing technique results in an acellular dermal matrix with normal collagen bundling and organization and an intact basement membrane complex. In these patients, AlloDerm exhibited a high percentage 'take' and supported an overlying meshed split-thickness skin autograft, applied simultaneously. The clinical observations of 'take' were confirmed with histological and electron-microscopic evaluation of biopsies which demonstrated host cell infiltration and neovascularization of the AlloDerm. No specific immune response was detected, either by histology or by lymphocyte proliferation assay. By providing a dermal replacement, the grafted dermal matrix permitted the use of a thin, widely meshed autograft from the donor site, without the undesirable scarring and contracture at the wound site that commonly results from this technique. If effective, this approach would markedly reduce the amount of donor skin required for split-thickness autografts in full-thickness burn injuries.

Noncytotoxic combinations of topical antimicrobial agents for use with cultured skin substitutes

Cultured skin grafts are destroyed more easily than split-thickness skin grafts by common burn wound organisms, including gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria and fungi. To increase the survival and engraftment of cultured skin grafts, formulations of antimicrobial agents were tested for cytotoxicity to cultured human keratinocytes and fibroblasts and for activity against common organisms from burn wounds. On the basis of previous studies, a base formulation containing neomycin (40 micrograms/ml), polymyxin B (700 U/ml), and mupirocin (40 micrograms/ml) was prepared, to which ciprofloxacin (20 micrograms/ml) or norfloxacin (20 micrograms/ml) and amphotericin B (0.25 microgram/ml) or nystatin (100 U/ml) were added. Toxicity to cultured human cells was determined by the growth response of cell cultures (n = 6) to each drug combination over 4 days. Activity against clinical isolates (n = 40) of Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, other gram-negative bacteria, and Candida spp. was determined by the wet disc assay. Analysis of variance testing showed no significant differences in the growth of keratinocytes or fibroblasts under control or experimental conditions. Medium without antimicrobial agents was not effective against any of the 40 microbial strains tested. The base formulation was effective against all bacterial strains tested but against none of the fungi, while all experimental formulations were effective against all microbial strains tested. These findings suggest that neomycin, mupirocin, and polymyxin B may be combined with a quinolone and an antimycotic agent to provide broad antimicrobial activity for a formulation for topical use with cultured skin on burns. However, the formulations described here are strictly experimental and are not recommended for clinical use without further evaluation.

Culturing skin in vitro for wound therapy

Current tissue-culture techniques enable keratinocytes from a small piece of skin to be grown into sheets of epithelium, or cultured keratinocyte grafts, that are suitable for treating wounds. Serial subculture enables rapid expansion of a cell population, such that grafts of a total area equivalent to that of the surface of an adult can be obtained from an initial skin biopsy of approximately 2 cm2 in under one month. In this article, the methods currently used for culturing keratinocytes, the search for a fully functional replacement for the dermal elements of skin, and the prospects for clinical development of these technologies in the near future are discussed.

An investigation into the mechanisms by which human dermis does not significantly contribute to the rejection of allo-skin grafts

The dermis is an important element in skin substitutes and in allo- or xeno-skin grafts. However, the reason(s) why dermis does not significantly induce the immune rejection reaction in vivo remain(s) hitherto unknown. To clarify the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon, we undertook the evaluation of: (i) the response of the peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) to isolated allo-dermal cells or to pieces of or to whole allo-dermis, (ii) the migration and homing of the PBM inside allo-dermis or split thickness allo-skin, (iii) the distribution of the ICAM-1 protein within skin, and (iv) the features expressed by the PBM that migrate into allo-skin. The results herein presented show that (1) the isolated allo-dermal cells had the highest and the whole allo-dermis the lowest capacity to initiate the reactive proliferation of the PBM in vitro; (2) in an allo-skin/PBM co-culture model, most of the PBM slowly, yet preferentially, migrated to and homed inside the allo-epidermal compartment, instead of staying in the allo-dermis; (3) under the conditions employed, rather little ICAM-1 could be immunohistochemically detected within the epidermis, conversely, both the dermal cells and the dermal matrix were ICAM-1 positive; and (4) most of the PBM migrating into the allo-skin pieces expressed either the CD18 or the CD19 or the CD8 molecule, yet very few of them exhibited the LFA-1-antigen, and none of them were found to be CD4 positive.2+Therefore, we conclude that because

Cultured autologous epithelium in patients with burns of ninety percent or more of the body surface

OBJECTIVE

The increasing survival of patients with very large burns has driven an interest in innovative permanent wound closure techniques, one of which is the use of cultured autologous epithelium (CAE). To document our ability to achieve wound closure with CAE in patients with very large burns, we report our 19-month experience with this technology in five patients with burns of 90% or more of the body surface.

DESIGN

A retrospective review.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Over a 19-month period five patients with burns in excess of 90% of the body surface had skin biopsies taken for epithelial culture. The clinical course of these five patients was reviewed in detail.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

These five patients had an average age of 11.5 years (range 7 months to 37 years), and an average total body surface area burn of 94% (range 90%-96%). Four of the five patients had inhalation injury. All wounds had vascularized allograft present at the time of CAE engraftment. Forty-five percent of the CAE was placed on vascularized allodermis and 55% on fascia (range on allodermis 20%-75%). Initial take of CAE was 51% (range 20%-80%). Delayed loss in percent of initial take averaged 60% (range 20%-100%). Delayed loss averaged 33% (range 20%-50%) when two patients who lost all of their CAE were excluded. Three patients had gram-negative bacteremia within 7 days of CAE placement, and two of these had 100% graft loss. Definitive closure rates with CAE averaged 7.5% (range 0%-15%) of the body surface, increasing to 12.5% (range 11.2%-15%) when two patients who lost all of their CAE are excluded.

CONCLUSIONS

The initial enthusiasm for CAE has been tempered by demonstrations of low-initial engraftment rates, graft fragility, delayed graft loss, and cost. Such liabilities become more tolerable as usable donor site decreases below 5% to 10% of the body surface. CAE can materially contribute to wound closure in patients with very extensive burns, but gram-negative sepsis is associated with complete graft loss.

Composite grafts of autogenic cultured epidermis and glycerol-preserved allogeneic dermis for definitive coverage of full thickness burn wounds: case reports

In patients with extensive deep burns and scarce donor sites autogenic cultured epithelial grafts (auto-CEG) have become a real alternative. In deep burns the 'take' rate of auto-CEG applied directly on subcutaneous fat, fascia or muscle is unreliable and frequently disappointing. The auto-CEG seems to need a dermal base. Improved results have been reported when auto-CEG were applied to the dermal base of a viable cryopreserved donor skin. We extended this principle by using the dermal layer of non-viable glycerol-preserved donor skin (GPDS). We report on two patients with deep burns of 55 and 80 per cent TBSA in whom we used the composite grafting of auto-CEG on non-viable allogeneic dermis from GPDS. The estimated 'take' rates were 70 and 77 per cent. The grafted areas remained stable for 4 and 8 months respectively. The two-layer skin substitute gave a permanent cover for full thickness burn wounds of higher quality and better 'take' rate than previous results, where the auto-CEG had been grafted directly onto the debrided wounds.

Mid-term results with cultured epidermal autografts, allogenic skin transplants and cyclosporin A medication

Transplantation of allogenic split thickness skin grafts (STSG) and immunosuppression with cyclosporin A enable early and definitive skin replacement of extensive, deep partial and full thickness burns. Covering burn defects with definitely engrafted, allogenic dermis and cultivated epithelial autografts (CEA) permits the subsequent withdrawal of cyclosporin A medication. Light-microscopy examination of biopsies, taken 12 and 24 months postgrafting, and electron microscopy of biopsies taken 12 months postgrafting, demonstrates a re-established, but somewhat reduced anchoring of the CEA as compared with a normal epidermal-dermal junction. Clinical inspection, 20 months postgrafting, confirms the histological observations that epifascial transplantation is qualitatively inferior to placing the allogenic STSG on the subcutaneous tissue. In the first situation, the dermis is inelastic and collagen deposition is excessive, whereas in the second case collagen deposition is comparatively reduced and the dermis shows clinically some elasticity.

Cultured autologous keratinocytes in fibrin glue suspension, exclusively and combined with STS-allograft (preliminary clinical and histological report of a new technique)

The use of cultured epidermal cell sheets has become a recognized method for the coverage of extensive burns. The disadvantages are a long time-lag until the cells are available, the fragility and difficult handling of the grafts, an unpredictable 'take' and extremely high costs. In three patients with deep partial and full skin thickness burns we have applied cultured autologous keratinocytes suspended in fibrin glue. In two of these patients the keratinocyte culture in the fibrin matrix (KFGS) was overgrafted with allogeneic, glycerine-preserved split thickness cadaver skin. The area thus covered ranged from 3 to 15 per cent TBSA. Cultured grafts were available between 2.5 and 3 weeks. The non-confluent cells developed a continuous epithelial layer within the 4 days until the first dressing change. Histological examination showed a stratified neoepidermis. Clinically the new skin had satisfactory stability and mechanical quality. The epidermis of the allogeneic overgrafts desquamated within a few days without signs of inflammation, but there are indications that the STS-allograft dermis is at least partly integrated into the new skin and may serve as a scaffold for the grafted cell culture. The fibrin glue matrix seems to give sufficient adherence stability to keratinocytes that are grafted in an actively proliferating state. Further advantages are the easy repetition and application, as well as a reduction in operating time and costs in these severely injured patients.

Cologne Burn Centre experience with glycerol-preserved allogeneic skin: Part II: Combination with autologous cultured keratinocytes

Autologous keratinocytes cultured in vitro from skin biopsies of patients with deep partial and full skin thickness burns were grafted onto nine necrectomized wound surfaces between 17 and 25 days after injury. The cells were applied as nonconfluent single cells suspended in fibrin glue. In four wounds, this cell-fibrin suspension was used to attach an additional glycerolized allogeneic split thickness skin graft (STSG). Re-epithelialization was very rapid as demonstrated clinically and histologically. Keratinocyte grafted areas without cadaver skin overgraft showed less mechanical stability than when the keratinocyte-fibrin glue suspension was combined with allogeneic STSG. There is clinical and histological evidence that the allodermis may be partially integrated into the new skin.

Cultured epidermal autografts and allodermis combination for permanent burn wound coverage

Cultured epidermal autografts (CEA) have been shown to be an effective permanent skin replacement for major burn injuries, but are more sensitive to adverse conditions than split thickness grafts (Clarke et al., 1988). Cuono et al. (1986, 1987) have described the successful use of engrafted allodermis as a wound bed for cultured grafts. We report on a method of preparing allodermis and grafting CEA in five patients with major burns (48-70 per cent TBSA, average 59.6 per cent). The average age was 38.8 years (20-60 years). All full thickness wounds were excised down to fat within 7 days of admission, and covered with meshed split thickness cryopreserved homograft. Over the ensuing 2-3 weeks, the homograft became engrafted. At surgery, the allo-epidermis was removed, leaving the dermal components as a viable bed for the CEA. Keratinocytes derived from a full thickness biopsy were grown to confluence by the method of Rheinwald and Green (1975), and 25 cm2 sheets were stapled to Vaseline gauze backings and applied to freshly excised wounds. Seven to 10 days after surgery, the gauze backings were removed. The average take ranged from 87-100 per cent (average 93.6 per cent). Follow-up for up to 4 years shows supple skin that has been durable, and resistant to trauma and infection.

What role does the extracellular matrix serve in skin grafting and wound healing?

Recent research on the structure and composition of the extracellular matrix (ECM) now strongly indicates that the major role of this matrix is in regulating cell/cell communication rather than in passively supporting cells. A wealth of structural data on the ECM suggests that there are specific arrangements of sequences within these proteins which profoundly influence the behaviour of the cells moving in that area, with respect to attachment, migration, differentiation and proliferation. In the skin, the ECM can be argued to promote 'appropriate' communication between the keratinocyte and the fibroblast. Skin ECM can be considered to consist both of the large insoluble proteins produced primarily by the fibroblasts, and soluble proteins which may be produced by fibroblasts or keratinocytes and become attached to the ECM. Both the large insoluble and the smaller soluble proteins may constitute signals which influence the behaviour of the keratinocytes. The clinical awareness of the need for a dermal component in skin grafting highlights the need for further research into the way in which the ECM influences keratinocyte/fibroblast biology. Such research will prove relevant to understanding the problems of graft take, graft contracture and scarring.

A dermal substrate made of collagen--GAG--chitosan for deep burn coverage: first clinical uses

In cases of severe burns, it seems necessary to excise burnt tissues as soon as possible and to cover the excised area immediately with a skin substitute, when few autografts are available. We report here the first clinical uses of a dermal substrate made of collagen--GAG--chitosan grafted immediately after early excision, then epidermalized either with autologous meshed autograft or with autologous cultured epidermis. The dermal substrate replaces the excised dermis by adhering to the underlying tissue, promoting fibrovascular ingrowth. Then after 15 days it can be epidermalized. The quality of the underlying dermis obtained permitted 100% take after epidermalization with large-meshed autograft, and tended to avoid the usual typical diamond aspect of the meshed skin. After epidermalization with autologous cultured autograft, the quality of the underlying dermis permits a good take. The best aspect is obtained by combining dermal substrate and autologous cultured epidermis. Even if it still does not replace the high quality of a homograft, this dermal substrate is a promising solution for replacement of dermis. It is always available, can be stored and is exempt from micro-organism transmission.

Direct comparison of a cultured composite skin substitute containing human keratinocytes and fibroblasts to an epidermal sheet graft containing human keratinocytes on athymic mice

This study compares two techniques for making cultured skin substitutes: a composite graft made of human fibroblasts and keratinocytes on a collagen-glycosaminoglycan membrane (CG) and a cultured epidermal cell sheet graft (CEG), without a dermal component. The "take" and quality of these cultured skin substitutes were evaluated by placing them on full-thickness, excised wounds of athymic mice. These cultured skin substitutes were placed onto 2-X-2-cm wounds created on athymic mice. Mice were sacrificed at days 10, 20, and 42 with histologic sections obtained for light, electron, immunofluorescent, and immunohistochemical microscopy. "Take" was determined separately by a direct immunofluorescent stain for human leukocyte ABC antigens. There were ten mice of each graft type with at least two animals sacrificed at each time point. Results showed positive "take" for all animals. Grossly, there was little difference between the two graft types, with the CEG having occasional blister formation. By light microscopy, the CEG had a dissociation of dermis from epidermis until day 42, which was never apparent with the CG. By day 42, the CG had increased dermoepidermal interdigitations similar to rete ridges, with a mature epithelium. Neither of these findings were seen with the CEG. Immunofluorescent and immunohistochemical microscopy for type IV collagen and laminin, as well as electron microscopy, showed similar retardation of basement membrane formation with the CEG. Using this model, the composite graft had significant advantages over the epidermal sheet graft in the closure of full-thickness wounds.

Cultured keratinocyte allografts and wound healing in severe recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa

BACKGROUND

Patients with recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (RDEB) frequently have painful erosions that are slow to heal. There is no definitive treatment; therefore any therapy that improves wound healing would be beneficial to these patients.

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to assess the effects of cultured allogeneic keratinocytes on wound healing in RDEB.

METHODS

Ten patients with RDEB and dermatome-induced superficial dermal wounds were studied. Cultured keratinocyte grafts were applied to part of the wound, with another part left ungrafted. Both sites were assessed clinically and microscopically, particularly with regard to basement membrane zone reconstitution.

RESULTS

Apart from minor differences in keratinocyte differentiation and a moderate analgesic effect induced by the graft, there were no other distinguishing findings in wound healing in the grafted and nongrafted sites.

CONCLUSION

There was little clinical benefit from cultured keratinocyte allografts in wound healing in RDEB. However, this study showed that RDEB keratinocytes have an inherent capacity to express some type VII collagen epitopes transiently during wound healing, although this was not associated with the detection of anchoring fibrils.

Studies of tissue cultured sliced dermis as a skin substitute

A dermis slicer designed by the authors enabled us to prepare about 10 sheets of sliced dermal grafts (SDG), 300 micron(s) thick, from the dermis harvested from the back or buttocks of adult patients during operations. Such a sliced dermal sheet was stretched with one surface stuck on the base of a culture dish. It was then incubated in Dulbecco's essential medium for tissue culture, to which epidermal growth factor had been added. By the first week only its upper side was epithelialized from epithelial components in sliced dermis. The formation of basement membrane with anchoring fibrils was confirmed by electron microscopy. The appearance of type IV collagen and laminin was observed between epithelialized basal cells and the dermal layer. Thus, it is thought that the SDG is useful not only for immediate grafting, when epithelialization follows, but also as a substitute for free split thickness skin grafts following tissue culture.

Restoration of basement membrane structure in pigs following keratinocyte autografting

The attachment of grafts of keratinocyte sheets is mediated in part by the presence and organisation of basement membrane components. The reappearance of basement membrane following keratinocyte autografting was examined in pigs. These studies showed that there was rapid expression of anchoring fibrils and hemidesmosomes, which reached normal numbers at 10 days. However, the length of hemidesmosomes did not reach normal size during the period of study. Weakness of attachment of keratinocyte autografted epidermis was found to lie between the basement membrane and the granulation tissue. This suggests that reported clinical problems with keratinocyte graft attachment may be mediated not only by delay in maturation of the basement membrane but also by its poor integration with collagen of the wound bed.

New techniques in burn wound management

The critical care management of the burn patient has advanced such that those patients with larger burned surface areas are surviving for longer periods. Wound management and closure thus become critical to the patient's ultimate outcome. New techniques for modifying the extent of the burn injury and for replacing the skin cover are described in this article.

A recombined skin composed of human keratinocytes cultured on cell-free pig dermis

Treatment of full skin thickness burns requires replacement of both the dermal and the epidermal components of the skin. We describe a method of preparing recombined human/pig skin (RHPS) by cultivating human keratinocytes on dried cell-free pig dermis (CFPD). CFPD dried on a tissue culture dish forms a thin collagen film which behaves like a firm substrate for cell cultures. HK were grown on the epidermal side of the CFPD using lethally irradiated 3T3 cells as feeders. After reaching confluency of human keratinocytes, human fibroblasts can be cultured on the dermal side of the RHPS. It was possible to obtain approximately 500 cm2 of the RHPS from 1 cm2 human split-skin graft in 3 weeks. RHPS is easy to handle, is similar in structural, mechanical and adhesive properties to the normal skin, and can be meshed. This RHPS might be advantageous for permanent covering of wounds in major burns.

Expression of basement membrane components in skin equivalents--influence of dermal fibroblasts

We have made a skin equivalent constructed of fibroblasts embedded in a type I collagen, with an overlying stratified keratinocyte epithelium to examine formation of the basement membrane. We assessed the influence of the existence and species of fibroblasts in the collagen gel. Cultured human keratinocytes were well attached to the dermal equivalent. Plating efficiency was not clearly different among several types of gel. On the control and mouse fibroblast gel, sheet formation was delayed and epithelial stratification on the human fibroblast gel was more remarkable than on the control gel. On the human fibroblast gel, we observed the expression of basement membrane components (bulbous phemphigoid antigen, laminin, type IV collagen and fibronectin) between the sheet of cultured keratinocytes and the human fibroblast gel earlier than those on the control gel and mouse fibroblast gel. Type VIII collagen was not observed in any of the models at 4 weeks.

Chemiluminescent restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis (DNA fingerprinting) to identify keratinocytes from two donors in co-culture

The transplantation of allogeneic cells such as pancreatic islet cells, bone marrow, and keratinocytes for skin replacement is in growing use clinically. Present techniques which are used to distinguish transplanted allogeneic cells from phenotypically identical host cells in chimeric tissue have serious limitations. This study assesses the feasibility of using chemiluminescent restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis to distinguish between keratinocyte cell lines from 2 different donors grown in co-culture. We evaluated the sensitivity of this technique in tissue cultured cells in order to define its usefulness in clinical situations. RFLP analysis readily detects heterologous DNA comprising only 10% of a 5 micrograms sample. This was a detection threshold of 500 ng of high molecular weight DNA. With standard extraction methods, this represents the DNA obtained from 4000 cells. This new chemiluminescent technique is as sensitive as older techniques which employ radioactive probes, but avoids the hazards of handling radioactive material. Using this RFLP analysis, the presence of transplanted allogeneic cells can be readily detected in small biopsy specimens. This technique has wide potential application in allogeneic cellular transplantation investigations.

The use of cultured epithelial autografts in the wound care of severely burned patients

Commercially prepared cultured epithelial autografts permit closure of deep burn wounds when insufficient uninjured skin is available for split-thickness grafting. This technique was used in seven patients with a mean total body surface area (TBSA) burn of 66% and full-thickness burn of 52%. All patients survived with a mean initial take of 69% and final take of 80% for the cultured epithelial autografts. Patients with a TBSA burn greater than 80% required at least a second application of the grafts. We feel our approach to wound preparation and postoperative wound care has contributed to our success with this technique.