Transcriptional arrest: Escherichia coli RNA polymerase translocates backward, leaving the 3' end of the RNA intact and extruded

Single-molecule study of transcriptional pausing and arrest by E. coli RNA polymerase

Using an optical-trap/flow-control video microscopy technique, we followed transcription by single molecules of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase in real time over long template distances. These studies reveal that RNA polymerase molecules possess different intrinsic transcription rates and different propensities to pause and stop. The data also show that reversible pausing is a kinetic intermediate between normal elongation and the arrested state. The conformational metastability of RNA polymerase revealed by this single-molecule study of transcription has direct implications for the mechanisms of gene regulation in both bacteria and eukaryotes.

The 8-nucleotide-long RNA:DNA hybrid is a primary stability determinant of the RNA polymerase II elongation complex

The sliding clamp model of transcription processivity, based on extensive studies of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, suggests that formation of a stable elongation complex requires two distinct nucleic acid components: an 8-9-nt transcript-template hybrid, and a DNA duplex immediately downstream from the hybrid. Here, we address the minimal composition of the processive elongation complex in the eukaryotes by developing a method for promoter-independent assembly of functional elongation complex of S. cerevisiae RNA polymerase II from synthetic DNA and RNA oligonucleotides. We show that only one of the nucleic acid components, the 8-nt RNA:DNA hybrid, is necessary for the formation of a stable elongation complex with RNA polymerase II. The double-strand DNA upstream and downstream of the hybrid does not affect stability of the elongation complex. This finding reveals a significant difference in processivity determinants of RNA polymerase II and E. coli RNA polymerase. In addition, using the imperfect RNA:DNA hybrid disturbed by the mismatches in the RNA, we show that nontemplate DNA strand may reduce the elongation complex stability via the reduction of the RNA:DNA hybrid length. The structure of a "minimal stable" elongation complex suggests a key role of the RNA:DNA hybrid in RNA polymerase II processivity.

Mapping the bacterial cell architecture into the chromosome

A genome is not a simple collection of genes. We propose here that it can be viewed as being organized as a 'celluloculus' similar to the homunculus of preformists, but pertaining to the category of programmes (or algorithms) rather than to that of architectures or structures: a significant correlation exists between the distribution of genes along the chromosome and the physical architecture of the cell. We review here data supporting this observation, stressing physical constraints operating on the cell's architecture and dynamics, and their consequences in terms of gene and genome structure. If such a correlation exists, it derives from some selection pressure: simple and general physical principles acting at the level of the cell structure are discussed. As a first case in point we see the piling up of planar modules as a stable, entropy-driven, architectural principle that could be at the root of the coupling between the architecture of the cell and the location of genes at specific places in the chromosome. We propose that the specific organization of certain genes whose products have a general tendency to form easily planar modules is a general motor for architectural organization in the bacterial cell. A second mechanism, operating at the transcription level, is described that could account for the efficient building up of complex structures. As an organizing principle we suggest that exploration by biological polymers of the vast space of possible conformation states is constrained by anchoring points. In particular, we suggest that transcription does not always allow the 5'-end of the transcript to go free and explore the many conformations available, but that, in many cases, it remains linked to the transcribing RNA polymerase complex in such a way that loops of RNA, rather than threads with a free end, explore the surrounding medium. In bacteria, extension of the loops throughout the cytoplasm would therefore be mediated by the de novo synthesis of ribosomes in growing cells. Termination of transcription and mRNA turnover would accordingly be expected to be controlled by sequence features at both the 3'- and 5'-ends of the molecule. These concepts are discussed taking into account in vitro analysis of genome sequences and experimental data about cell compartmentalization, mRNA folding and turnover, as well as known structural features of protein and membrane complexes.

Nonequilibrium mechanism of transcription termination from observations of single RNA polymerase molecules

Cessation of transcription at specific terminator DNA sequences is used by viruses, bacteria, and eukaryotes to regulate the expression of downstream genes, but the mechanisms of transcription termination are poorly characterized. To elucidate the kinetic mechanism of termination at the intrinsic terminators of enteric bacteria, we observed, by using single-molecule light microscopy techniques, the behavior of surface-immobilized Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) molecules in vitro. An RNAP molecule remains at a canonical intrinsic terminator for approximately 64 s before releasing DNA, implying the formation of an elongation-incompetent (paused) intermediate by transcription complexes that terminate but not by those that read through the terminator. Analysis of pause lifetimes establishes a complete minimal mechanism of termination in which paused intermediate formation is both necessary and sufficient to induce release of RNAP at the terminator. The data suggest that intrinsic terminators function by a nonequilibrium process in which terminator effectiveness is determined by the relative rates of nucleotide addition and paused state entry by the transcription complex.

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase translocation is accompanied by periodic bending of the DNA

RNA polymerase was halted in consecutive registers of RNA synthesis ranging from registers 11 to 68. Non-denaturing gel electrophoresis shows that the mobility of the complexes varies (up to 15%), indicating that halted complexes differ in their conformation. The electrophoretic mobility changes with an approximate 10-register periodicity. The change of the mobility can be attributed to relative changes of RNA polymerase-induced bending angle. We suggest that the periodicity of the bending angle reflects periodic changes of the conformation of the halted complexes that might have relevance for the translocation mechanism.

Mapping interactions of Escherichia coli GreB with RNA polymerase and ternary elongation complexes

Escherichia coli GreA and GreB modulate transcription elongation by interacting with the ternary elongation complex (containing RNA polymerase, DNA template, and RNA transcript) to induce hydrolytic cleavage of the transcript and release of the 3'-terminal fragment. Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting and alanine-scanning mutagenesis were used to investigate the interactions of GreB with RNA polymerase alone and in a ternary elongation complex. A major determinant for binding GreB to both RNA polymerase and the ternary elongation complex was identified. In addition, the hydroxyl radical footprinting indicated major conformational changes of GreB, in terms of reorientations of the N- and C-terminal domains with respect to each other, particularly upon interactions with the ternary elongation complex.

Characterization of structural features important for T7 RNAP elongation complex stability reveals competing complex conformations and a role for the non-template strand in RNA displacement

We have characterized the roles of the phage T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) thumb subdomain and the RNA binding activity of the N-terminal domain in elongation complex (EC) stability by evaluating how disrupting these structures affects the dissociation rates of halted ECs. Our results reveal distinct roles for these elements in EC stabilization. On supercoiled or partially single-stranded templates the enzyme with a deletion of the thumb subdomain is exceptionally unstable. However, on linear duplex templates the polymerase which has been proteolytically cleaved within the N-terminal domain is the most unstable. The differences in the effects of these RNAP modifications on the stability of ECs on the different templates appear to be due to differences in EC structure: on the linear duplex templates the RNA is properly displaced from the DNA, but on the supercoiled or partially single-stranded templates an extended RNA:DNA hybrid makes a larger contribution to the conformational state of the EC. The halted EC can therefore exist either in a conformation in which the RNA is displaced from the DNA and forms an interaction with the RNAP, or in a conformation in which a more extended RNA:DNA hybrid is present and the RNA:RNAP interaction is less extensive. The partitioning between these competing conformations appears to be a function of the energetics of template reannealing and the relative strengths of the RNA:RNAP interaction and the RNA:DNA hybrid.

The versatility of paramyxovirus RNA polymerase stuttering

Paramyxoviruses cotranscriptionally edit their P gene mRNAs by expanding the number of Gs of a conserved AnGn run. Different viruses insert different distributions of guanylates, e.g., Sendai virus inserts a single G, whereas parainfluenza virus type 3 inserts one to six Gs. The sequences conserved at the editing site, as well as the experimental evidence, suggest that the insertions occur by a stuttering process, i.e., by pseudotemplated transcription. The number of times the polymerase "stutters" at the editing site before continuing strictly templated elongation is directed by a cis-acting sequence found upstream of the insertions. We have examined the stuttering process during natural virus infections by constructing recombinant Sendai viruses with mutations in their cis-acting sequences. We found that the template stutter site is precisely determined (C1052) and that a relatively short region (approximately 6 nucleotides) just upstream of the AnGn run can modulate the overall frequency of mRNA editing as well as the distribution of the nucleotide insertions. The positions more proximal to the 5' AnGn run are the most important in this respect. We also provide evidence that the stability of the mRNA/template hybrid plays a determining role in the overall frequency and range of mRNA editing. When the template U run is extended all the way to the stutter site, adenylates rather than guanylates are added at the editing site and their distribution begins to resemble the polyadenylation associated with mRNA 3' end formation by the viral polymerase. Our data suggest how paramyxovirus mRNA editing and polyadenylation are related mechanistically and how editing sites may have evolved from poly(A)-termination sites or vice versa.

Characterization of the effects of Escherichia coli replication terminator protein (Tus) on transcription reveals dynamic nature of the tus block to transcription complex progression

We have characterized the blocks to progression of T7 and T3 RNA polymerase transcription complexes created when a Tus protein is bound to the template. The encounter with Tus impedes the progress of the transcription complexes of either enzyme. The duration of the block depends on which polymerase is used and the orientation of Tus on the DNA. Both genuine termination (dissociation of the transcription complex) and halting followed by continued progression after the block is abrogated are observed. The fraction of complexes that terminates depends on which polymerase is used and on the orientation of the Tus molecule. The efficiency of the block to transcription increases as the Tus concentration is increased, even if the concentration of Tus is already many times in excess of what is required to saturate its binding sites on the template in the absence of transcription. The block to transcription is rapidly abrogated if an excess of a DNA containing a binding site for Tus is added to a transcription reaction in which Tus and template have been preincubated. Finally, we find that transcription will rapidly displace Tus from a template under conditions that generate persistent blocks to transcription. These observations reveal that during the encounter with the transcription complex Tus rapidly dissociates from the template but that at sufficiently high concentrations Tus usually rebinds before the transcription complex can move forward. The advantage of a mechanism which can create a persistent block to transcription or replication complex progression, which can nevertheless be rapidly abrogated in response to down regulation of the blocking protein, is suggested.

Initially transcribed sequences strongly affect the extent of abortive initiation by RNA polymerase II

We investigated transcript initiation and early elongation by RNA polymerase II using templates mismatched between -9 and +3 (bubble templates). Highly purified RNA polymerase II alone was able to initiate transcription specifically on these templates in the presence of dinucleotide primers. The length distribution of abortively initiated RNAs was similar for purified RNA polymerase II on bubble templates and polymerase II on double-stranded templates in HeLa nuclear extracts. Increasing the U content in the initial portion of the transcript caused similar increases in abortive initiation for transcription of bubble templates by pure polymerase and double-stranded templates in extracts. Thus, the level of abortive initiation by RNA polymerase II is at least partly determined by interactions of the polymerase with the transcript and/or the template, independent of the general transcription factors. Substitution of 5-bromo-UTP for UTP reduced abortive initiation on bubble templates, consistent with the idea that transcription complex stability during early elongation depends on the strength of the initial RNA-DNA hybrid. Interestingly, transcription of bubble templates in HeLa extracts gave very high levels of abortive initiation, suggesting that inability to reanneal the initially melted template segment inhibits transcript elongation in the presence of the initiation factors.

Transcription elongation: structural basis and mechanisms

A ternary complex composed of RNA polymerase (RNAP), DNA template, and RNA transcript is the central intermediate in the transcription cycle responsible for the elongation of the RNA chain. Although the basic biochemistry of RNAP functioning is well understood, little is known about the underlying structural determinants. The absence of high- resolution structural data has hampered our understanding of RNAP mechanism. However, recent work suggests a structure-function model of the ternary elongation complex, if not at a defined structural level, then at least as a conceptual view, such that key components of RNAP are defined operationally on the basis of compelling biochemical, protein chemical, and genetic data. The model has important implications for mechanisms of transcription elongation and also for initiation and termination.

Mechanism of intrinsic transcription termination and antitermination

Gene expression is modulated by regulatory elements that influence transcription elongation by RNA polymerase: terminators that disrupt the elongation complex and release RNA, and regulators that overcome termination signals. RNA release from Escherichia coli RNA polymerase can be induced by a complementary oligonucleotide that replaces the upstream half of the RNA hairpin stem of intrinsic terminator transcripts, implying that RNA hairpins act by extracting RNA from the transcription complex. A transcription antiterminator inhibits this activity of oligonucleotides and therefore protects the elongation complex from destabilizing attacks on the emerging transcript. These effects illuminate the structure of the complex and the mechanism of transcription termination.

The mechanism of intrinsic transcription termination

In bacteria, an intrinsic transcription termination signal appears in RNA as a hairpin followed by approximately eight uridines (U stretch) at the 3' terminus. This signal leads to rapid dissociation of the ternary elongation complex (TEC) into RNA, DNA, and an RNA polymerase. We demonstrate that the hairpin inactivates and then destabilizes TEC by weakening interactions in the RNA-DNA hybrid-binding site and the RNA-binding site that hold TEC together. Formation of the hairpin is restricted to the moment when TEC reaches the point of termination and depends upon melting of four to five hybrid base pairs that follow the hairpin's stem. The U stretch-induced pausing at the point of termination is crucial, providing additional time for hairpin formation. These results explain the mechanism of termination and aid in understanding of how cellular factors modulate this process.

Two nucleotides immediately upstream of the essential A6G3 slippery sequence modulate the pattern of G insertions during Sendai virus mRNA editing

Editing of paramyxovirus P gene mRNAs occurs cotranscriptionally and functions to fuse an alternate downstream open reading frame to the N-terminal half of the P protein. G residues are inserted into a short G run contained within a larger purine run (AnGn) in this process, by a mechanism whereby the transcribing polymerase stutters (i.e., reads the same template cytosine more than once). Although Sendai virus (SeV) and bovine parainfluenza virus type 3 (bPIV3) are closely related, the G insertions in their P mRNAs are distributed differently. SeV predominantly inserts a single G residue within the G run of the sequence 5' AACAAAAAAGGG, whereas bPIV3 inserts one to six G's at roughly equal frequency within the sequence 5' AUUAAAAAAGGGG (differences are underlined). We have examined how the cis-acting editing sequence determines the number of G's inserted, both in a transfected cell system using minigenome analogues and by generating recombinant viruses. We found that the presence of four rather than three G's in the purine run did not affect the distribution of G insertions. However, when the underlined AC of the SeV sequence was replaced by the UU found in bPIV3, the editing phenotype from both the minigenome and the recombinant virus resembled that found in natural bPIV3 infections (i.e., a significant fraction of the mRNAs contained two to six G insertions). The two nucleotides located just upstream of the polypurine tract are thus key determinants of the editing phenotype of these viruses. Moreover, the minimum number of A residues that will promote SeV editing phenotype is six but can be reduced to five when the upstream AC is replaced by UU. A model for how the upstream dinucleotide controls the insertion phenotype is presented.

Functional topography of nascent RNA in elongation intermediates of RNA polymerase

To determine the dynamics of transcript extrusion from Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP), we used degradation of the RNA by RNases T1 and A in a series of consecutive elongation complexes (ECs). In intact ECs, even extremely high doses of the RNases were unable to cut the RNA closer than 14-16 nt from the 3' end. Our results prove that all of the cuts detected within the 14-nt zone are derived from the EC that is denatured during inactivation of the RNases. The protected zone monotonously translocates along the RNA after addition of new nucleotides to the transcript. The upstream region of the RNA heading toward the 5' end is cleaved and dissociated from the EC, with no effect on the stability and activity of the EC. Most of the current data suggest that an 8- to 10-nt RNA.DNA hybrid is formed in the EC. Here, we show that an 8- to 10-nt RNA obtained by truncating the RNase-generated products further with either GreB or pyrophosphate is sufficient for the high stability and activity of the EC. This result suggests that the transcript-RNAP interaction that is required for holding the EC together can be limited to the RNA region involved in the 8- to 10-nt RNA.DNA hybrid.

A new model for coronavirus transcription

Coronaviruses contain an unusually long (27-32,000 ribonucleotide) positive sense RNA genome that is polyadenylated at the 3' end and capped at the 5' end. In addition to the genome, infected cells contain subgenomic mRNAs that form a 3' co-terminal nested set with the genome. In addition to their common 3' ends, the genome and the subgenomic mRNAs contain an identical 5' leader sequence. The transcription mechanism that coronaviruses use to produce subgenomic mRNA is not known and has been the subject of speculation since sequencing of the subgenomic mRNAs showed they must arise by discontinuous transcription. The current model called leader-primed transcription has subgenomic mRNAs transcribed directly from genome-length negative strands. It was based on the failure to find in coronavirus infected cells subgenome-length negative strands or replication intermediates containing subgenome-length negative strands. Clearly, these structures exist in infected cells and are transcriptionally active. We proposed a new model for coronavirus transcription which we called 3' discontinuous extension of negative strands. This model predicts that subgenome-length negative strands would be derived directly by transcription using the genome RNA as a template. The subgenome-length templates would contain the common 5' leader sequence and serve as templates for the production of subgenomic mRNAs. Our findings include showing that: 1. Replication intermediates (RIs) containing subgenome-length RNA exist in infected cells and are separable from RIs with genome-length templates. The RFs with subgenome-length templates are not derived by RNase treatment of RIs with genome-length templates. 2. The subgenome-length negative strands are formed early in infection when RIs are accumulating and the rate of viral RNA synthesis is increasing exponentially. 3. Subgenome-length negative strands contain at their 3' ends a complementary copy of the 72 nucleotide leader RNA that is found in the genome only at their 5' end. 4. RIs with subgenomic templates serve immediately as templates for transcription of subgenomic mRNAs. Because subgenomic mRNAs are not replicated, i.e., copied into negative strands that in turn are used as templates for subgenomic mRNA synthesis, we propose that the subgenome-length negative strands must arise directly by transcription of the genome and acquire their common 3' anti-leader sequence after polymerase jumping from the intergenic regions to the leader sequence at the 5' end of the genome. This would make negative strand synthesis discontinuous and subgenomic mRNA synthesis continuous, which is the opposite of what was proposed in the leader primed model.

A surface of Escherichia coli sigma 70 required for promoter function and antitermination by phage lambda Q protein

The sigma initiation factor sigma70 of Escherichia coli acts not only in promoter recognition and DNA strand opening, but also to mediate the transformation of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to an antiterminating form by the phage lambda gene Q protein. Q is able to bind and modify RNAP when alpha70, still present in the initially elongating enzyme, recognizes a repeat of the -10 promoter element and induces a transcription pause. We have isolated mutations in the rpoD gene for sigma70 that impair Q function because they reduce the ability of sigma70 to recognize the downstream pause site. These mutations identify a locus of sigma70 that is important for the formation and stability of open promoter complex, likely because it mediates protein interactions with RNAP core.

Template end-to-end transposition by RNA polymerase II

On 5'-template strand protruding templates, promoter-initiated run-off transcription by RNA polymerase II generates discrete, 15-16-nucleotide (nt) longer than expected products whose production is abrogated by elongation factor SII (Parsons, M. A., Sinden, R. R., and Izban, M. G. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 26998-27008). We demonstrate that template terminal complexes produce these RNAs and that transcript extension is a general and salt-sensitive (250 mM) feature of run-off transcription. On 5'-overhung templates the extended run-off transcripts appear to be retained within an RNA-DNA-enzyme ternary complex, and SII facilitates resumption of transcript elongation via a dinucleotide truncation intermediate. Moreover, on one of the 5-overhung templates, the initially extended complexes spontaneously resumed transcript extension and were uniquely resistant to salt (250 mM) challenge. However, SII did not facilitate this long distance extension on all template ends. Run-off transcripts on a blunt-ended template were initially extended by 2-11 nt (roughly in 2-nt increments); SII addition either before or after extension resulted in the accumulation of a 4-5-nt extension product. Based on these findings, we propose that the initial and continuously extended RNAs reflect intermediates and successful completion of template end-to-end transposition (template switching) by RNA polymerase II, respectively. Both the template end sequence and structure influenced the success of such an event.

Transcriptional properties of RNA polymerase II within triplet repeat-containing DNA from the human myotonic dystrophy and fragile X loci

Expansion of a (CTG)n segment within the 3'-untranslated region of the myotonic dystrophy protein kinase gene alters mRNA production. The inherent ability of RNA polymerase II to transcribe (CTG)17-255 tracts corresponding to DNA from normal, unstable, and affected individuals, and the normal (CGG)54 fragile X repeat tract, was analyzed using a synchronized in vitro transcription system. Core RNA polymerase II transcribed all repeat units irrespective of repeat length or orientation. However, approximately 50% of polymerases transiently halted transcription (with a half-life of approximately 10 +/- 1 s) within the first and second CTG repeat unit and a more transient barrier to elongation was observed roughly centered within repeats 6-9. Transcription within the remainder of the CTG tracts and within the CCG, CGG, and CAG tracts appeared uniform with average transcription rates of 170, 250, 300, and 410 nucleotides/min, respectively. These differences correlated with changes in the sequence-specific transient pausing pattern within the CNG repeat tracts; individual incorporation rates were slower after incorporation of pyrimidine residues. Unexpectedly, approximately 4% of the run-off transcripts were, depending on the repeat sequence, either 15 or 18 nucleotides longer than expected. However, these products were not produced by transcriptional slippage within the repeat tract.

Sequential hydrolysis of ATP molecules bound in interacting catalytic sites of Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho

Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho, an RNA-dependent ATPase, disrupts transcription complexes, releasing RNA and allowing RNA polymerase to recycle. Homohexameric Rho binds three molecules of MgATP in a single class of catalytically competent sites. In rapid mix chemical quench experiments, when Rho saturated with ATP was mixed with RNA and the reaction was quenched after various times, hydrolysis of the three bound ATP molecules was not simultaneous. A hydrolysis burst of one molecule of ATP per hexamer occurred at >300 s-1, followed by steady-state hydrolysis at 30 s-1 per hexamer. The burst also shows that a step following ATP hydrolysis is rate-limiting for overall catalysis and requires communication among the three catalytic sites during net ATP hydrolysis. The rate of hydrolysis of radiolabeled ATP when one labeled and two unlabeled ATP molecules are bound indicates a sequential pattern of hydrolysis. Positive cooperativity of catalysis occurs among the catalytic sites of Rho; when only one ATP molecule is bound per hexamer, ATP hydrolysis upon addition of RNA is 30-fold slower than when ATP is saturating. These behaviors are comparable to those of F1-type ATPases, with which Rho shares a number of structural features.

Interaction of a nascent RNA structure with RNA polymerase is required for hairpin-dependent transcriptional pausing but not for transcript release

Nascent RNA structures may regulate RNA chain elongation either directly through interaction with RNA polymerase or indirectly by disrupting nascent RNA contacts with polymerase or DNA. To distinguish these mechanisms we tested whether the effects of the his leader pause RNA hairpin could be mimicked by pairing of antisense DNA or RNA oligonucleotides to the nascent transcript. The his pause hairpin inhibits nucleotide addition when it forms 11 nucleotides from the transcript 3' end. It also can terminate transcription when base changes extend its stem to Collapse

Key Words

• rna polymerase
• rna hairpins
• pausing
• termination

Collapse

MESH Headings

• DNA-Directed RNA Polymerases/metabolism
• Escherichia coli
• Models, Genetic
• Molecular Mimicry
• Nucleic Acid Conformation
• Oligonucleotides, Antisense/metabolism
• RNA/metabolism
• RNA, Bacterial/metabolism
• Structure-Activity Relationship
• Transcription, Genetic

Collapse

Grants

• R01 GM038660 NIGMS NIH HHS
• R37 GM038660 NIGMS NIH HHS
• GM38660 NIGMS NIH HHS

Collapse

Affiliation(s)

I Artsimovitch Department of Bacteriology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA
R Landick

Collapse

Collaborators Collapse

Mutations in and monoclonal antibody binding to evolutionary hypervariable region of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase beta' subunit inhibit transcript cleavage and transcript elongation

A 190 amino acid-long region centered around position 1050 of the 1407-amino acid-long beta' subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) is absent from homologues in eukaryotes, archaea and many bacteria. In chloroplasts, the corresponding region can be more than 900 amino acids long. The role of this hypervariable region was studied by deletion mutagenesis of the cloned E. coli rpoC, encoding beta'. Long deletions mimicking beta' from Gram-positive bacteria failed to assemble into RNAP. Mutants with short, 40-60-amino acid-long deletions spanning beta' residues 941-1130 assembled into active RNAP in vitro. These mutant enzymes were defective in the transcript cleavage reaction and had dramatically reduced transcription elongation rates at subsaturating substrate concentrations due to prolonged pausing at sites of transcriptional arrest. Binding of a monoclonal antibody, Pyn1, to the hypervariable region inhibited transcription elongation and intrinsic transcript cleavage and, to a lesser degree, GreB-induced transcript cleavage, but did not interfere with GreB binding to RNAP. We propose that mutations in and antibody binding to the hypervariable, functionally dispensable region of beta' inhibit transcript cleavage and elongation by distorting the flanking conserved segment G in the active center.

NTP concentration effects on initial transcription by T7 RNAP indicate that translocation occurs through passive sliding and reveal that divergent promoters have distinct NTP concentration requirements for productive initiation

The hypothesis that active site translocation during initial transcription occurs by a passive sliding mechanism which allows the pre- and post-translocated states to equilibrate on the time scale of bond formation was tested by evaluating the effects of NTP concentration on individual transcript extension steps in the presence of translocation roadblocks created by proteins bound immediately downstream of a T7 promoter, as well as by evaluating the effects of NTP concentration on competing transcript extension pathways (iterative synthesis and "normal" extension). Results are consistent with a passive sliding mechanism for translocation which is driven by NTP binding, and are inconsistent with mechanisms in which the pre- and post-translocated states fail to equilibrate with each other on the time scale of bond formation or in which translocation is driven by NTP hydrolysis. We also find, in agreement with many previous studies, that divergence from consensus in the ITS (initially transcribed sequence) of the T7 promoter decreases productive initiation. However, this appears to be largely due to increases in the NTP concentration requirements for efficient transcription on the divergent ITSs.

Structural changes in the RNA polymerase II transcription complex during transition from initiation to elongation

We obtained exonuclease III (exoIII) footprints for a series of RNA polymerase II transcription complexes stalled between positions +20 to +51. Downstream advance of the exoIII footprint is normally tightly coordinated with RNA synthesis. However, arrested RNA polymerases slide back along the template, as indicated by exoIII footprints in which the last transcribed base is abnormally close to the downstream edge of the footprint. None of the polymerase II complexes stalled between +20 and +51 were arrested. Nevertheless, the exoIII footprints of complexes with 20-, 23-, or 25-nucleotide RNAs resembled those of arrested complexes, with the last transcribed base very close to the footprint's front edge. The exoIII footprint of the +27 complex was displaced downstream by 17 bp compared to the footprint of the +25 complex. Many complexes between +27 and +42 also showed evidence of sliding back along the template. We compared the effects of template sequence and transcript length by constructing a new template in which the initial transcribed sequence was duplicated beginning at +98. The exoIII footprints of transcription complexes stalled between +122 to +130 on this DNA did not resemble those of arrested complexes, in contrast to the footprints of analogous complexes stalled over the same DNA sequences early in transcription. Our results indicate that the RNA polymerase II transcription complex passes through a major, sequence-independent structural transition about 25 bases downstream of the starting point of transcription. The fully mature form of the elongation complex may not appear until more than 40 bonds have been made.

Visualization of the binding site for the transcript cleavage factor GreB on Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

The structure of Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase (RNAP) complexed with the transcript cleavage factor GreB was determined from electron micrographs of negatively stained, flattened helical crystals. A binding assay was developed to establish that GreB was incorporated into the RNA polymerase crystals with high occupancy through interactions between the globular C-terminal domain and the RNA polymerase. Comparison of the core RNAP:GreB structure with the previously determined structure of core RNAP located the GreB binding site on one face of the RNA polymerase, next to but not in the 25 A-diameter channel of RNA polymerase.

An integrated model of the transcription complex in elongation, termination, and editing

Recent findings now allow the development of an integrated model of the thermodynamic, kinetic, and structural properties of the transcription complex in the elongation, termination, and editing phases of transcript formation. This model provides an operational framework for placing known facts and can be extended and modified to incorporate new advances. The most complete information about transcriptional mechanisms and their control continues to come from the Escherichia coli system, upon which most of the explicit descriptions provided here are based. The transcriptional machinery of higher organisms, despite its greater inherent complexity, appears to use many of the same general principles. Thus, the lessons of E. coli continue to be relevant.

Recognition of a human arrest site is conserved between RNA polymerase II and prokaryotic RNA polymerases

DNA sequences that arrest transcription by either eukaryotic RNA polymerase II or Escherichia coli RNA polymerase have been identified previously. Elongation factors SII and GreB are RNA polymerase-binding proteins that enable readthrough of arrest sites by these enzymes, respectively. This functional similarity has led to general models of elongation applicable to both eukaryotic and prokaryotic enzymes. Here we have transcribed with phage and bacterial RNA polymerases, a human DNA sequence previously defined as an arrest site for RNA polymerase II. The phage and bacterial enzymes both respond efficiently to the arrest signal in vitro at limiting levels of nucleoside triphosphates. The E. coli polymerase remains in a template-engaged complex for many hours, can be isolated, and is potentially active. The enzyme displays a relatively slow first-order loss of elongation competence as it dwells at the arrest site. Bacterial RNA polymerase arrested at the human site is reactivated by GreB in the same way that RNA polymerase II arrested at this site is stimulated by SII. Very efficient readthrough can be achieved by phage, bacterial, and eukaryotic RNA polymerases in the absence of elongation factors if 5-Br-UTP is substituted for UTP. These findings provide additional and direct evidence for functional similarity between prokaryotic and eukaryotic transcription elongation and readthrough mechanisms.

Crucial role of the RNA:DNA hybrid in the processivity of transcription

We present an approach for studying the role of complementary nucleic acid interactions in transcription elongation by E. coli RNA polymerase (RNAP). The method involves in vitro reconstitution of a catalytically active elongation complex (EC) by the addition of RNAP to a single-strand DNA oligonucleotide containing the preannealed RNA primer, followed by incorporation of the complementary nontemplate DNA oligonucleotide. In all parameters tested, the reconstituted complex is indistinguishable from normal EC obtained by promoter-specific initiation. Using RNA primers of different lengths, which were fully or partially complementary to the DNA, we determined the minimal transcript length and the degree of its template pairing that is required to stabilize protein/ nucleic acid interactions in EC to the high level characteristic of normal transcription. Our data show that a hybrid at least 9 nt long, formed between the template DNA and 3'-proximal RNA transcript, is necessary for the high processivity of EC during RNA chain elongation.

Transcriptional fidelity and proofreading by RNA polymerase II

We have addressed whether the intrinsic 3'-->5' nuclease activity of human RNA polymerase II (pol II) can proofread during transcription in vitro. In the presence of SII, a protein that stimulates the nuclease activity, pol II quantitatively removed misincorporated nucleotides from the nascent transcript during rapid chain extension. The basis of discrimination between the correct and incorrect base was the slow addition of the next nucleotide to the mismatched terminus. Incorporation of inosine monophosphate inhibited next nucleotide addition by a similar magnitude as a mismatched base. We used this finding to demonstrate that addition of SII to a transcription reaction dramatically altered the RNA base content, reflecting the stable incorporation of more "correct" (GMP) and fewer "incorrect" (IMP) nucleotides.

Motion of RNA polymerase along DNA: a stochastic model

RNA polymerase is a key transcription enzyme that moves along a DNA double helix to polymerize an RNA transcript. Recent progress in micromechanical experiments permits quantitative studies of forces and motion generated by the enzyme. We present in this paper a chemical kinetics description of RNA polymerase motion. The model is based on a classical chemical kinetics description of polymerization reactions driven by a free energy gain that depends on forces applied externally at the catalytic site. The RNA polymerase controlled activation barrier of the reaction is assumed to be strongly dependent on inhibitory internal strains of the RNA polymerase molecule. The sequence sensitivity of RNA polymerase is described by a linear coupling between the height of the activation barrier and the local DNA sequence. Our model can simulate optical trap experiments and allows us to study the dynamics of chemically halted complexes that are important for footprinting studies. We find that the effective stall force is a sequence-dependent, statistical quantity, whose distribution depends on the observation time. The results are consistent with the experimental observations to date.

Distinct functions of N and C-terminal domains of GreA, an Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factor

The prokaryotic transcription factors GreA and GreB are involved in the regulation of transcript elongation by RNA polymerase (RNAP). Their known activities include suppression of transcription arrest, enhancement of transcription fidelity, and facilitation of the transition from abortive initiation to productive elongation. Presumably, Gre proteins exert their functions by altering the conformation of the enzyme in ternary elongation complexes (TEC) and inducing the cleavage of nascent RNA. GreA and GreB have a similar structural organization and consist of two domains: a C-terminal globular and an extended N-terminal coiled-coil domain. To investigate the functional roles of Gre domains, we expressed separately the N and C-terminal domains of GreA (NTD and CTD, respectively) and characterized their activities with in vitro assays. We demonstrate that the NTD possesses the residual transcript cleavage activity of the wild-type GreA. The CTD does not display any nucleolytic activity; however, it substantially increases the cleavage activity of the NTD. In contrast to NTD, the CTD competes with GreA and GreB for binding to RNAP and inhibits their transcript cleavage and antiarrest activities. Both domains individually and together inhibit transcription elongation. From these results we conclude that the NTD is responsible for the GreA induction of nucleolytic activity while the CTD determines the binding of GreA to RNAP. Both domains are required for full functional activity of GreA.

Transcription termination by bacteriophage T3 and SP6 RNA polymerases at Rho-independent terminators

Transcription termination of T3 and SP6 DNA-dependent RNA polymerases have been studied on the DNA templates containing the threonine (thr) attenuator and its variants. The thr attenuator is from the regulatory region of the thr operon of Escherichia coli. The DNA template, encoding the thr attenuator, contains specific features of the rho-independent terminators. It comprises a dG + dC rich dyad symmetry, encoding a stem-and-loop RNA, which is followed by a poly(U) region at the 3'-end. Thirteen attenuator variants have been analyzed for their ability to terminate transcription and the results indicated that the structure as well as the sequence in the G + C rich region of RNA hairpin affect termination of both RNA polymerases. Also, a single base change in the A residues of the hairpin failed to influence termination, whereas changes in the poly(U) region significantly reduced the termination of both T3 and SP6 RNA polymerases. The requirement of a poly(U) region for termination by T3 and SP6 RNA polymerases was studied with nested deletion mutants in this region. The minimum number of U residues required for termination of SP6 and T3 RNA polymerases was five and three, respectively. However, both RNA polymerases needed at least eight U residues to reach a termination efficiency close to that achieved by wild-type thr attenuator encoding nine U residues. In addition, the orientation of the loop sequences of the RNA hairpin did not affect the transcription termination of either of the bacteriophage RNA polymerases.

Regulation of upp expression in Escherichia coli by UTP-sensitive selection of transcriptional start sites coupled with UTP-dependent reiterative transcription

Expression of the upp gene of Escherichia coli, which encodes the pyrimidine salvage enzyme uracil phosphoribosyltransferase, is negatively regulated by pyrimidine availability. In this study, we demonstrate that this regulation occurs mainly by UTP-sensitive selection of alternative transcriptional start sites, which produces transcripts that differ in the ability to be productively elongated. The upp initially transcribed region contains the sequence GATTTTTTTTG (nontemplate strand). Transcription is initiated primarily at the first two bases in this sequence, designated G6 and A7 (counting from the promoter -10 region). High intracellular levels of UTP favor initiation at position A7; however, the resulting transcripts are subject to reiterative transcription (i.e., repetitive nucleotide addition) within the run of T residues in the initially transcribed region. The resulting AUUUUn (where n = 1 to >50) transcripts are not extended to include downstream upp sequences. In contrast, low intracellular levels of UTP strongly favor initiation at position G6, which results in transcripts that generally do not engage in reiterative transcription and thus can be normally elongated. This mechanism ensures that high levels of uracil phosphoribosyltransferase are produced only under conditions of pyrimidine limitation. The mechanisms that account for UTP-sensitive start site selection and different fates of upp transcripts, as well as the general use of UTP-dependent reiterative transcription in gene regulation, are discussed in detail.

Preferential interaction of the his pause RNA hairpin with RNA polymerase beta subunit residues 904-950 correlates with strong transcriptional pausing

RNA secondary structures (hairpins) that form as the nascent RNA emerges from RNA polymerase are important components of many signals that regulate transcription, including some pause sites, all rho-independent terminators, and some antiterminators. At the his leader pause site, a 5-bp-stem, 8-nt-loop pause RNA hairpin forms 11 nt from the RNA 3' end and stabilizes a transcription complex conformation slow to react with NTP substrate. This stabilization appears to depend at least in part on an interaction with RNA polymerase. We tested for RNA hairpin interaction with the paused polymerase by crosslinking 5-iodoUMP positioned specifically in the hairpin loop. In the paused conformation, strong and unusual crosslinking of the pause hairpin to beta904-950 replaced crosslinking to beta' and to other parts of beta that occurred in nonpaused complexes prior to hairpin formation. These changes in nascent RNA interactions may inhibit reactive alignment of the RNA 3' end in the paused complex and be related to events at rho-independent terminators.

RNA polymerase switches between inactivated and activated states By translocating back and forth along the DNA and the RNA

Important regulatory events in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic transcription are currently explained in terms of an inchworming model of elongation. In this model, RNA extension is carried out by a mobile catalytic center that, at certain DNA sites, advances within stationary RNA polymerase. This idea emerged from the observation that footprints of individual elongation complexes, halted in vitro at consecutive DNA positions, can remain fixed on the template for several contiguous nucleotide additions. Here, we examine in detail the structural transitions that occur immediately after the enzyme stops at sites where discontinuous advancement of RNA polymerase is observed. We demonstrate that halting at such special sites does not "freeze" RNA polymerase at one location but induces it to leave its initial position and to slide backward along the DNA and the RNA without degrading the transcript. The resulting loss of contact between the RNA 3'-hydroxyl and the enzyme's catalytic center leads to temporary loss of the catalytic activity. This process is equilibrated with enzyme return to the original location, so that RNA polymerase is envisaged as an oscillating object switching between catalytically active and inactive states. The retreated isoform constitutes a principal intermediate in factor-induced endonucleolytic RNA cleavage. These oscillations of RNA polymerase can explain its apparent discontinuous advancement, which had been interpreted as indicating flexibility within the enzyme.