Characterization of structural features important for T7 RNAP elongation complex stability reveals competing complex conformations and a role for the non-template strand in RNA displacement

Probing the legitimate initiation of RNA synthesis by Qβ replicase with oligonucleotide primers

Oligoribonucleotides complementary to the template 3' terminus were tested for their ability to initiate RNA synthesis on legitimate templates capable of exponential amplification by Qβ replicase. Oligonucleotides shorter than the distance to the nearest predicted template hairpin proved able to serve as primers, with the optimal length varying for different templates, suggesting that during initiation the template retains its native fold incorporating the 3' terminus. The priming activity of an oligonucleotide is greatly enhanced by its 5'-triphosphate group, the effect being strongly dependent on Mg2+ ions. This indicates that, unlike other studied RNA polymerases, Qβ replicase binds the 5'-triphosphate of the initiating nucleotide GTP, and this binding is needed for the replication of legitimate templates.

An engineered T7 RNA polymerase that produces mRNA free of immunostimulatory byproducts

In vitro transcription (IVT) is a DNA-templated process for synthesizing long RNA transcripts, including messenger RNA (mRNA). For many research and commercial applications, IVT of mRNA is typically performed using bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP) owing to its ability to produce full-length RNA transcripts with high fidelity; however, T7 RNAP can also produce immunostimulatory byproducts such as double-stranded RNA that can affect protein expression. Such byproducts require complex purification processes, using methods such as reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography, to yield safe and effective mRNA-based medicines. To minimize the need for downstream purification processes, we rationally and computationally engineered a double mutant of T7 RNAP that produces substantially less immunostimulatory RNA during IVT compared with wild-type T7 RNAP. The resulting mutant allows for a simplified production process with similar mRNA potency, lower immunostimulatory content and quicker manufacturing time compared with wild-type T7 RNAP. Herein, we describe the computational design and development of this improved T7 RNAP variant.

Versatile transcription control based on reversible dCas9 binding

The ability to control transcription in a time-dependent manner in vitro promises numerous applications in molecular biology and nanotechnology. Here we demonstrate an approach that enables precise, independent control over the production of multiple RNA transcripts in vitro using single guide RNA (sgRNA)-directed transcription blockades by catalytically dead Streptococcus pyogenes CRISPR-Cas9 enzyme (dCas9). We show that when bound to a DNA template, the dCas9:sgRNA complex forms a robust blockade to transcription by RNA polymerases (RNAPs) from bacteriophages SP6, T3, and T7 (>99.5% efficiency), and a partial blockade to transcription by Escherichia coli RNAP (∼70% efficiency). We find that all three bacteriophage RNAPs dissociate from the DNA template upon encountering the dCas9 blockade, while E. coli RNAP stays bound for at least the 90-min duration of our experiments. The blockade maintains >95% efficiency when four mismatches are introduced into the 5' end of the sgRNA target sequence. Notably, when using such a mismatched blockade, production of specific RNA species can be activated on demand by addition of a double-stranded competitor DNA perfectly matching the sgRNA. This strategy enables the independent production of multiple RNA species in a temporally controlled fashion from the same DNA template, demonstrating a new approach for transcription control.

R-loop generation during transcription: Formation, processing and cellular outcomes

R-loops are structures consisting of an RNA-DNA duplex and an unpaired DNA strand. They can form during transcription upon nascent RNA "threadback" invasion into the DNA duplex to displace the non-template strand. Although R-loops occur naturally in all kingdoms of life and serve regulatory roles, they are often deleterious and can cause genomic instability. Of particular importance are the disastrous consequences when replication forks or transcription complexes collide with R-loops. The appropriate processing of R-loops is essential to avoid a number of human neurodegenerative and other clinical disorders. We provide a perspective on mechanistic aspects of R-loop formation and their resolution learned from studies in model systems. This should contribute to improved understanding of R-loop biological functions and enable their practical applications. We propose the novel employment of artificially-generated stable R-loops to selectively inactivate tumor cells.

A Mechanism for RecA-Promoted Sequence Homology Recognition and Strand Exchange Between Single-Stranded DNA and Duplex DNA, via Triple-Helical Intermediates

Abstract A central function of RecA protein during homologous recombination is to promote sequence recognition and strand exchange between a stretched and unwound single-stranded DNA, to which it is complexed, and a duplex DNA. By studying the properties of DNA under the conditions of deformation imposed by RecA, we propose a model for recognition and strand exchange at the atomic level, via unusual triple-helical intermediates. In this model, association takes place within a stretched and unwound triple helix of a new type, where the invading single strand occupies the minor groove of the duplex in a parallel orientation. Our calculations indicate that strand exchange within this structure is exothermic and results in a triple helix where the third strand interacts in the major groove, the so-called R-DNA triple helix. Preliminary calculations suggest that sequence homology recognition within the triplex of association is partial and that it is completed during strand exchange and product formation.

The thumb subdomain of yeast mitochondrial RNA polymerase is involved in processivity, transcript fidelity and mitochondrial transcription factor binding

Single subunit RNA polymerases have evolved 2 mechanisms to synthesize long transcripts without falling off a DNA template: binding of nascent RNA and interactions with an RNA:DNA hybrid. Mitochondrial RNA polymerases share a common ancestor with T-odd bacteriophage single subunit RNA polymerases. Herein we characterized the role of the thumb subdomain of the yeast mtRNA polymerase gene (RPO41) in complex stability, processivity, and fidelity. We found that deletion and point mutants of the thumb subdomain of yeast mtRNA polymerase increase the synthesis of abortive transcripts and the probability that the polymerase will disengage from the template during the formation of the late initial transcription and elongation complexes. Mutations in the thumb subdomain increase the amount of slippage products from a homopolymeric template and, unexpectedly, thumb subdomain deletions decrease the binding affinity for mitochondrial transcription factor (Mtf1). The latter suggests that the thumb subdomain is part of an extended binding surface area involved in binding Mtf1.

Computational and experimental studies of reassociating RNA/DNA hybrids containing split functionalities

Recently, we developed a novel technique based on RNA/DNA hybrid reassociation that allows conditional activation of different split functionalities inside diseased cells and in vivo. We further expanded this idea to permit simultaneous activation of multiple different functions in a fully controllable fashion. In this chapter, we discuss some novel computational approaches and experimental techniques aimed at the characterization, design, and production of reassociating RNA/DNA hybrids containing split functionalities. We also briefly describe several experimental techniques that can be used to test these hybrids in vitro and in vivo.

In silico design and enzymatic synthesis of functional RNA nanoparticles

CONSPECTUS: The use of RNAs as scaffolds for biomedical applications has several advantages compared with other existing nanomaterials. These include (i) programmability, (ii) precise control over folding and self-assembly, (iii) natural functionalities as exemplified by ribozymes, riboswitches, RNAi, editing, splicing, and inherent translation and transcription control mechanisms, (iv) biocompatibility, (v) relatively low immune response, and (vi) relatively low cost and ease of production. We have tapped into several of these properties and functionalities to construct RNA-based functional nanoparticles (RNA NPs). In several cases, the structural core and the functional components of the NPs are inherent in the same construct. This permits control over the spatial disposition of the components, intracellular availability, and precise stoichiometry. To enable the generation of RNA NPs, a pipeline is being developed. On one end, it encompasses the rational design and various computational schemes that promote design of the RNA-based nanoconstructs, ultimately producing a set of sequences consisting of RNA or RNA-DNA hybrids, which can assemble into the designed construct. On the other end of the pipeline is an experimental component, which takes the produced sequences and uses them to initialize and characterize their proper assembly and then test the resulting RNA NPs for their function and delivery in cell culture and animal models. An important aspect of this pipeline is the feedback that constantly occurs between the computational and the experimental parts, which synergizes the refinement of both the algorithmic methodologies and the experimental protocols. The utility of this approach is depicted by the several examples described in this Account (nanocubes, nanorings, and RNA-DNA hybrids). Of particular interest, from the computational viewpoint, is that in most cases, first a three-dimensional representation of the assembly is produced, and only then are algorithms applied to generate the sequences that will assemble into the designated three-dimensional construct. This is opposite to the usual practice of predicting RNA structures from a given sequence, that is, the RNA folding problem. To be considered is the generation of sequences that upon assembly have the proper intra- or interstrand interactions (or both). Of particular interest from the experimental point of view is the determination and characterization of the proper thermodynamic, kinetic, functionality, and delivery protocols. Assembly of RNA NPs from individual single-stranded RNAs can be accomplished by one-pot techniques under the proper thermal and buffer conditions or, potentially more interestingly, by the use of various RNA polymerases that can promote the formation of RNA NPs cotransciptionally from specifically designed DNA templates. Also of importance is the delivery of the RNA NPs to the cells of interest in vitro or in vivo. Nonmodified RNAs rapidly degrade in blood serum and have difficulties crossing biological membranes due to their negative charge. These problems can be overcome by using, for example, polycationic lipid-based carriers. Our work involves the use of bolaamphiphiles, which are amphipathic compounds with positively charged hydrophilic head groups at each end connected by a hydrophobic chain. We have correlated results from molecular dynamics computations with various experiments to understand the characteristics of such delivery agents.

Transcription blockage by homopurine DNA sequences: role of sequence composition and single-strand breaks

The ability of DNA to adopt non-canonical structures can affect transcription and has broad implications for genome functioning. We have recently reported that guanine-rich (G-rich) homopurine-homopyrimidine sequences cause significant blockage of transcription in vitro in a strictly orientation-dependent manner: when the G-rich strand serves as the non-template strand [Belotserkovskii et al. (2010) Mechanisms and implications of transcription blockage by guanine-rich DNA sequences., Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 107, 12816–12821]. We have now systematically studied the effect of the sequence composition and single-stranded breaks on this blockage. Although substitution of guanine by any other base reduced the blockage, cytosine and thymine reduced the blockage more significantly than adenine substitutions, affirming the importance of both G-richness and the homopurine-homopyrimidine character of the sequence for this effect. A single-strand break in the non-template strand adjacent to the G-rich stretch dramatically increased the blockage. Breaks in the non-template strand result in much weaker blockage signals extending downstream from the break even in the absence of the G-rich stretch. Our combined data support the notion that transcription blockage at homopurine-homopyrimidine sequences is caused by R-loop formation.

DNA slip-outs cause RNA polymerase II arrest in vitro: potential implications for genetic instability

The abnormal number of repeats found in triplet repeat diseases arises from 'repeat instability', in which the repetitive section of DNA is subject to a change in copy number. Recent studies implicate transcription in a mechanism for repeat instability proposed to involve RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) arrest caused by a CTG slip-out, triggering transcription-coupled repair (TCR), futile cycles of which may lead to repeat expansion or contraction. In the present study, we use defined DNA constructs to directly test whether the structures formed by CAG and CTG repeat slip-outs can cause transcription arrest in vitro. We found that a slip-out of (CAG)(20) or (CTG)(20) repeats on either strand causes RNAPII arrest in HeLa cell nuclear extracts. Perfect hairpins and loops on either strand also cause RNAPII arrest. These findings are consistent with a transcription-induced repeat instability model in which transcription arrest in mammalian cells may initiate a 'gratuitous' TCR event leading to a change in repeat copy number. An understanding of the underlying mechanism of repeat instability could lead to intervention to slow down expansion and delay the onset of many neurodegenerative diseases in which triplet repeat expansion is implicated.

Anchoring nascent RNA to the DNA template could interfere with transcription

During normal transcription, the nascent RNA product is released from the DNA template. However, in some cases, the RNA remains bound or can become reattached to the template DNA duplex (for example, through R-loop formation). We have analyzed the effect on transcription elongation of nascent RNA anchoring to the template DNA duplex. Because the RNA polymerase follows a helical path along DNA duplex during transcription, the anchoring would result in wrapping the nascent RNA around the DNA in the region between the anchoring point and the translocating polymerase. This wrapping would cause an unfavorable loss of conformation entropy of the nascent RNA. It consequently would create an apparent force to unwrap the RNA by disrupting either the transcription complex or the anchoring structure. We have estimated that this force would be comparable to those required to melt nucleic acid duplexes or to arrest transcription elongation in single-molecule experiments. We predict that this force would create negative supercoiling in the DNA duplex region between the anchoring point and the transcribing RNA polymerase: this can promote the formation of unusual DNA structures and facilitate RNA invasion into the DNA duplex. Potential biological consequences of these effects are discussed.

Bending the rules of transcriptional repression: tightly looped DNA directly represses T7 RNA polymerase

From supercoiled DNA to the tight loops of DNA formed by some gene repressors, DNA in cells is often highly bent. Despite evidence that transcription by RNA polymerase (RNAP) is affected in systems where DNA is deformed significantly, the mechanistic details underlying the relationship between polymerase function and mechanically stressed DNA remain unclear. Seeking to gain additional insight into the regulatory consequences of highly bent DNA, we hypothesize that tightly looping DNA is alone sufficient to repress transcription. To test this hypothesis, we have developed an assay to quantify transcription elongation by bacteriophage T7 RNAP on small, circular DNA templates approximately 100 bp in size. From these highly bent transcription templates, we observe that the elongation velocity and processivity can be repressed by at least two orders of magnitude. Further, we show that minicircle templates sustaining variable levels of twist yield only moderate differences in repression efficiency. We therefore conclude that the bending mechanics within the minicircle templates dominate the observed repression. Our results support a model in which RNAP function is highly dependent on the bending mechanics of DNA and are suggestive of a direct, regulatory role played by the template itself in regulatory systems where DNA is known to be highly bent.

Mechanisms and implications of transcription blockage by guanine-rich DNA sequences

Various DNA sequences that interfere with transcription due to their unusual structural properties have been implicated in the regulation of gene expression and with genomic instability. An important example is sequences containing G-rich homopurine-homopyrimidine stretches, for which unusual transcriptional behavior is implicated in regulation of immunogenesis and in other processes such as genomic translocations and telomere function. To elucidate the mechanism of the effect of these sequences on transcription we have studied T7 RNA polymerase transcription of G-rich sequences in vitro. We have shown that these sequences produce significant transcription blockage in an orientation-, length- and supercoiling-dependent manner. Based upon the effects of various sequence modifications, solution conditions, and ribonucleotide substitutions, we conclude that transcription blockage is due to formation of unusually stable RNA/DNA hybrids, which could be further exacerbated by triplex formation. These structures are likely responsible for transcription-dependent replication blockage by G-rich sequences in vivo.

Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) binding and its effect on in vitro transcription in friedreich's ataxia triplet repeats

Peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) are DNA mimics in which peptide-like linkages are substituted for the phosphodiester backbone. Homopyrimidine PNAs can invade double-stranded DNA containing the homologous sequence by displacing the homopyrimidine strand from the DNA duplex and forming a PNA/DNA/PNA triplex with the complementary homopurine strand. Among biologically interesting targets for triplex-forming PNA are (GAA/CTT)(n) repeats. Expansion of these repeats results in partial inhibition of transcription in the frataxin gene, causing Friedreich's ataxia. We have studied PNA binding and its effect on T7 RNA polymerase transcription in vitro for short repeats (n = 3) and for long repeats (n = 39), placed in both possible orientations relative to the T7 promoter such that either the GAA-strand, or the CTT-strand serves as the template for transcription. In all cases PNA bound specifically and efficiently to its target sequence. For the short insert, PNA binding to the template strand caused partial transcription blockage with well-defined sites of RNA product truncation in the region of the PNA-binding sequence, whereas binding to the nontemplate strand did not block transcription. However, PNA binding to long repeats, whether in the template or the nontemplate strand, resulted in a dramatic reduction of the amount of full-length transcription product, although in the case of the nontemplate strand there were no predominant truncation sites. Biological implications of these results are discussed.

X-ray crystal structure of the polymerase domain of the bacteriophage N4 virion RNA polymerase

Coliphage N4 virion RNA polymerase (vRNAP), which is injected into the host upon infection, transcribes the phage early genes from promoters that have a 5-bp stem-3 nt loop hairpin structure. Here, we describe the 2.0-A resolution x-ray crystal structure of N4 mini-vRNAP, a member of the T7-like, single-unit RNAP family and the minimal component having all RNAP functions of the full-length vRNAP. The structure resembles a "fisted right hand" with Fingers, Palm and Thumb subdomains connected to an N-terminal domain. We established that the specificity loop extending from the Fingers along with W129 of the N-terminal domain play critical roles in hairpin-promoter recognition. A comparison with the structure of the T7 RNAP initiation complex reveals that the pathway of the DNA to the active site is blocked in the apo-form vRNAP, indicating that vRNAP must undergo a large-scale conformational change upon promoter DNA binding and explaining the highly restricted promoter specificity of vRNAP that is essential for phage early transcription.

Mechanism of T7 RNAP pausing and termination at the T7 concatemer junction: a local change in transcription bubble structure drives a large change in transcription complex architecture

The T7RNA polymerase (RNAP) elongation complex (EC) pauses and is destabilized at a unique 8 nucleotide (nt) sequence found at the junction of the head-to-tail concatemers of T7 genomic DNA generated during T7 DNA replication. The paused EC may recruit the T7 DNA processing machinery, which cleaves the concatemerized DNA within this 8 nt concatemer junction (CJ). Pausing of the EC at the CJ involves structural changes in both the RNAP and transcription bubble. However, these structural changes have not been fully defined, nor is it understood how the CJ sequence itself causes the EC to change its structure, to pause, and to become less stable. Here we use solution and RNAP-tethered chemical nucleases to probe the CJ transcript and changes in the EC structure as the polymerase pauses and terminates at the CJ. Together with extensive mutational scanning of regions of the polymerase that are likely to be involved in recognition of the CJ, we are able to develop a description of the events that occur as the EC transcribes through the CJ and subsequently pauses. In this process, a local change in the structure of the transcription bubble drives a large change in the architecture of the EC. This altered EC structure may then serve as the signal that recruits the processing machinery to the CJ.

Human capping enzyme promotes formation of transcriptional R loops in vitro

Cap formation is the first step of pre-mRNA processing in eukaryotic cells. Immediately after transcription initiation, capping enzyme (CE) is recruited to RNA polymerase II (Pol II) by the phosphorylated carboxyl-terminal domain of the Pol II largest subunit (CTD), allowing cotranscriptional capping of the nascent pre-mRNA. Recent studies have indicated that CE affects transcription elongation and have suggested a checkpoint model in which cotranscriptional capping is a necessary step for the early phase of transcription. To investigate further the role of the CTD in linking transcription and processing, we generated a fusion protein of the mouse CTD with T7 RNA polymerase (CTD-T7 RNAP). Unexpectedly, in vitro transcription assays with CTD-T7 RNAP showed that CE promotes formation of DNA.RNA hybrids or R loops. Significantly, phosphorylation of the CTD was required for CE-dependent R-loop formation (RLF), consistent with a critical role for the CTD in CE recruitment to the transcription complex. The guanylyltransferase domain was necessary and sufficient for RLF, but catalytic activity was not required. In vitro assays with appropriate synthetic substrates indicate that CE can promote RLF independent of transcription. ASF/SF2, a splicing factor known to prevent RLF, and GTP, which affects CE conformation, antagonized CE-dependent RLF. Our findings suggest that CE can play a direct role in transcription by modulating displacement of nascent RNA during transcription.

A triplex-forming sequence from the human c-MYC promoter interferes with DNA transcription

Naturally occurring DNA sequences that are able to form unusual DNA structures have been shown to be mutagenic, and in some cases the mutagenesis induced by these sequences is enhanced by their transcription. It is possible that transcription-coupled DNA repair induced at sites of transcription arrest might be involved in this mutagenesis. Thus, it is of interest to determine whether there are correlations between the mutagenic effects of such noncanonical DNA structures and their ability to arrest transcription. We have studied T7 RNA polymerase transcription through the sequence from the nuclease-sensitive element of the human c-MYC promoter, which is mutagenic in mammalian cells (Wang, G., and Vasquez, K. M. (2004) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 101, 13448-13453). This element has two mirror-symmetric homopurine-homopyrimidine blocks that potentially can form either DNA triplex (H-DNA) or quadruplex structures. We detected truncated transcription products indicating partial transcription arrest within and closely downstream of the element. The arrest required negative supercoiling and was much more pronounced when the pyrimidine-rich strand of the element served as the template. The exact positions of arrest sites downstream from the element depended upon the downstream flanking sequences. We made various nucleotide substitutions in the wild-type sequence from the c-MYC nuclease-sensitive element that specifically destabilize either the triplex or the quadruplex structure. When these substitutions were ranked for their effects on transcription, the results implicated the triplex structure in the transcription arrest. We suggest that transcription-induced triplex formation enhances pre-existing weak transcription pause sites within the flanking sequences by creating steric obstacles for the transcription machinery.

Impairment of transcription elongation by R-loops in vitro

Transcription elongation causes a local change in DNA superhelicity. An excess of negative supercoiling may lead to opening of DNA strands that could allow formation of R-loops. In yeast, mutants of the THO complex are impaired in transcription elongation and this defect has been linked to co-transcriptional formation of R-loops, which could constitute roadblocks for RNA polymerases. In this study, we found that stably formed 300-nt long DNA-RNA hybrids in a negatively supercoiled transcription template reduced the efficiency of transcription elongation by half, providing a first experimental evidence that transcription elongation is impaired by R-loops in vitro.

Synthesis-mediated release of a small RNA inhibitor of RNA polymerase

Noncoding small RNAs regulate gene expression in all organisms, in some cases through direct association with RNA polymerase (RNAP). Here we report that the mechanism of 6S RNA inhibition of transcription is through specific, stable interactions with the active site of Escherichia coli RNAP that exclude promoter DNA binding. In fact, the DNA-dependent RNAP uses bound 6S RNA as a template for RNA synthesis, producing 14-to 20-nucleotide RNA products (pRNA). These results demonstrate that 6S RNA is functionally engaged in the active site of RNAP. Synthesis of pRNA destabilizes 6S RNA-RNAP complexes leading to release of the pRNA-6S RNA hybrid. In vivo, 6S RNA-directed RNA synthesis occurs during outgrowth from the stationary phase and likely is responsible for liberating RNAP from 6S RNA in response to nutrient availability.

The Role of the Lid Element in Transcription by E. coli RNA Polymerase

The recently described crystal structures of multi-subunit RNA polymerases (RNAPs) reveal a conserved loop-like feature called the lid. The lid projects from the clamp domain and contacts the flap, thereby enclosing the RNA transcript in RNAP's RNA-exit channel and forming the junction between the exit channel and the main channel, which holds the RNA:DNA hybrid. In the initiating form of bacterial RNAP (holoenzyme containing sigma), the lid interacts with sigma region 3 and encloses an extended linker between sigma region 3 and sigma region 4 in place of the RNA in the exit channel. During initiation, the lid may be important for holding open the transcription bubble and may help displace the RNA from the template DNA strand. To test these ideas, we constructed and characterized a mutant RNAP from which the lid element was deleted. Deltalid RNAP exhibited dramatically reduced activity during initiation from -35-dependent and -35-independent promoters, verifying that the lid is important for stabilizing the open promoter complex during initiation. However, transcript elongation, RNA displacement, and, surprisingly, transcriptional termination all occurred normally in Deltalid RNAP. Importantly, Deltalid RNAP behaved differently from wild-type RNAP when transcribing single-stranded DNA templates where it synthesized long, persistent RNA:DNA hybrids, in contrast to efficient transcriptional arrest by wild-type RNAP.

Downstream boundary of chromosomal R-loops at murine switch regions: implications for the mechanism of class switch recombination

R-loops form at Sgamma3 and Sgamma2b Ig class switch regions in the chromosomes of stimulated murine primary B cells and are suspected to be a general feature of mammalian class switch regions. The in vivo upstream boundary of the R-loops is known to begin within the switch repeats. To determine how precisely the R-loop structure conforms to the repetitive zone of the murine Sgamma3 and Sgamma2b switch regions, a chemical probing method was used to obtain structural information on the downstream boundary. We find that only 61-67% of the R-loops terminate within the Sgamma3 and the Sgamma2b repetitive zones, and the remainder terminate downstream, usually within the first 600 bp immediately downstream of the core switch repeats. Interestingly, the nontemplate strand G density falls to the random level gradually through this same region. Hence, the R-loops terminate as the G-richness of the nascent RNA strand falls. This finding is consistent with thermodynamic predictions for RNA:DNA duplex strength relative to that of DNA:DNA duplexes. This result contrasts with the location of known recombination breakpoints, which correlate not with G-richness and R-loop location but rather with AGCT density. The implications of these findings are discussed in the context of models for the targeting of class switch recombination.

Translocation by T7 RNA polymerase: a sensitively poised Brownian ratchet

Studies of halted T7 RNA polymerase (T7RNAP) elongation complexes (ECs) or of T7RNAP transcription against roadblocks due to DNA-bound proteins indicate that T7RNAP translocates via a passive Brownian ratchet mechanism. Crystal structures of T7RNAP ECs suggest that translocation involves an active power-stroke. However, neither solution studies of halted or slowed T7RNAP ECs, nor crystal structures of static complexes, are necessarily relevant to how T7RNAP translocates during rapid elongation. A recent single molecule study of actively elongating T7RNAPs provides support for the Brownian ratchet mechanism. Here, we obtain additional evidence for the existence of a Brownian ratchet during active T7RNAP elongation by showing that both rapidly elongating and halted complexes are equally sensitive to pyrophosphate. Using chemical nucleases tethered to the polymerase we achieve sub-ångström resolution in measuring the average position of halted T7RNAP ECs and find that the positional equilibrium of the EC is sensitively poised between pre-translocated and post-translocated states. This may be important in maximizing the sensitivity of the polymerase to sequences that cause pausing or termination. We also confirm that a crystallographically observed disorder to order transition in a loop formed by residues 589-612 also occurs in solution and is coupled to pyrophosphate or NTP release. This transition allows the loop to make interactions with the DNA that help stabilize the laterally mobile, ligand-free EC against dissociation.

Growth inhibition mediated by excess negative supercoiling: the interplay between transcription elongation, R-loop formation and DNA topology

It has been known for a long time that supercoiling can affect gene expression at the level of promoter activity. Moreover, the results of a genome-wide analysis have recently led to the proposal that supercoiling could play a role in the regulation of gene expression at this level by acting as a second messenger, relaying environmental signals to regulatory networks. Although evidence is lacking for a regulatory role of supercoiling following transcription initiation, recent results from both yeast and bacteria suggest that the effect of supercoiling on gene expression can be considerably more dramatic after this initiation step. Transcription-induced supercoiling and its associated R-loops seem to be involved in this effect. In this context, one major function of topoisomerases would be to prevent the generation of excess negative supercoiling by transcription elongation, to inhibit R-loop formation and allow gene expression. This function would be especially evident when substantial and rapid gene expression is required for stress resistance, and it may explain, at least in part, why topoisomerase I synthesis is directed from stress-induced promoters in Escherichia coli. Growth inhibition mediated by excess negative supercoiling might be related to this interplay between transcription elongation and supercoiling.

Weakening of the T7 promoter-polymerase interaction facilitates promoter release

During transcription initiation, RNA polymerases retain interactions with their promoters until the RNA is extended to 8-13 nucleotides, at which point the polymerase releases the promoter and moves downstream. It has been shown that release of the T7 promoter is inhibited when the T7 RNA polymerase-promoter interaction is strengthened. Here we asked whether release would be facilitated when the T7 promoter-polymerase interaction is weakened by the introduction of promoter mutations known to reduce promoter activity. Using chemical and enzymatic probes to monitor the position of the polymerase as a function of RNA length, we found that promoter mutations upstream of -4 facilitated release of the polymerase from the promoter, but more downstream mutations did not have such effects. We also found that released complexes turn over more slowly than promoter-bound complexes, indicating that retention of promoter interactions contributes to the dissociation of short RNAs during initial transcription.

RNase HI overproduction is required for efficient full-length RNA synthesis in the absence of topoisomerase I in Escherichia coli

It has long been known that Escherichia coli cells deprived of topoisomerase I (topA null mutants) do not grow. Because mutations reducing DNA gyrase activity and, as a consequence, negative supercoiling, occur to compensate for the loss of topA function, it has been assumed that excessive negative supercoiling is somehow involved in the growth inhibition of topA null mutants. However, how excess negative supercoiling inhibits growth is still unknown. We have previously shown that the overproduction of RNase HI, an enzyme that degrades the RNA portion of an R-loop, can partially compensate for the growth defects because of the absence of topoisomerase I. In this article, we have studied the effects of gyrase reactivation on the physiology of actively growing topA null cells. We found that growth immediately and almost completely ceases upon gyrase reactivation, unless RNase HI is overproduced. Northern blot analysis shows that the cells have a significantly reduced ability to accumulate full-length mRNAs when RNase HI is not overproduced. Interestingly, similar phenotypes, although less severe, are also seen when bacterial cells lacking RNase HI activity are grown and treated in the same way. All together, our results suggest that excess negative supercoiling promotes the formation of R-loops, which, in turn, inhibit RNA synthesis.

Multiple roles for the T7 promoter nontemplate strand during transcription initiation and polymerase release

Transcription initiation begins with recruitment of an RNA polymerase to a promoter. Polymerase-promoter interactions are retained until the nascent RNA is extended to 8-12 nucleotides. It has been proposed that accumulation of "strain" in the transcription complex and RNA displacement of promoter-polymerase interactions contribute to releasing the polymerase from the promoter, and it has been further speculated that too strong a promoter interaction can inhibit the release step, whereas a weak interaction may facilitate release. We examined the effects of partial deletion of the nontemplate strand on release of T7 RNA polymerase from the T7 promoter. T7 polymerase will initiate from such partially single-stranded promoters but binds them with higher affinity than duplex promoters. We found that release on partially single-stranded promoters is strongly inhibited. The inhibition of release is not due to an indirect effect on transcription complex structure or loss of specific polymerase-nontemplate strand interactions, because release on partially single-stranded templates is recovered if the interaction with the promoter is weakened by a promoter base substitution. This same substitution also appears to allow the polymerase to escape more readily from a duplex promoter. Our results further suggest that template-nontemplate strand reannealing drives dissociation of abortive transcripts during initial transcription and that loss of interactions with either the nontemplate strand or duplex DNA downstream of the RNA lead to increased transcription complex slippage during initiation.

RNA displacement and resolution of the transcription bubble during transcription by T7 RNA polymerase

Unlike DNA polymerases, RNA polymerases (RNAPs) must displace the nascent product from the template and restore the DNA to duplex form after passage of the transcription complex. To accomplish this, RNAPs establish a locally denatured "bubble" that encloses a short RNA:DNA hybrid. As the polymerase advances along the template, the RNA is displaced at the trailing edge of the bubble and the two DNA strands are reannealed. Structural analyses have revealed a number of elements that are likely to be involved in this process in T7 RNAP. In this work, we used genetic and biochemical methods to explore the roles of these elements during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex. The results indicate that the transition is a multistep process and reveal a critical role for the nontemplate strand of the DNA.

Initial bubble collapse plays a key role in the transition to elongation in T7 RNA polymerase

RNA polymerases bind to specific sequences in DNA, melt open duplex DNA around the start site, and start transcription within the initially melted bubble. The initially transcribing complex is relatively unstable, releasing short abortive products. After synthesis of a minimal length of RNA (approximately 10-12 bases in the T7 system), RNA polymerases complete the transition to a processive (highly stable) elongation phase and lose the initial promoter contacts. The current study strongly supports a model for T7 RNA polymerase in which initial bubble collapse from position -4 to position +3 is responsible for initiating RNA displacement in the transition process. More specifically, collapse of the bubble from position -4 to position -1 indirectly and energetically facilitates the direct strand invasion offered by collapse at positions +1 to +3. Parallel work shows that promoter release, another key event occurring during this stage of transcription, begins after translocation to position +8 and is largely complete upon translocation to about position +12. The timing of promoter release agrees with the timing of initial bubble collapse determined by our previous fluorescence studies, suggesting that these two events are closely related.

The functional anatomy of an intrinsic transcription terminator

To induce dissociation of the transcription elongation complex, a typical intrinsic terminator forms a G.C-rich hairpin structure upstream from a U-rich run of approximately eight nucleotides that define the transcript 3' end. Here, we have adapted the nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) approach to identify the critical RNA atoms and functional groups of an intrinsic terminator during transcription with T7 RNA polymerase. The results show that discrete components within the lower half of the hairpin stem form transient termination-specific contacts with the RNA polymerase. Moreover, disruption of interactions with backbone components of the transcript region hybridized to the DNA template favors termination. Importantly, comparative NAIM of termination events occurring at consecutive positions revealed overlapping but distinct sets of functionally important residues. Altogether, the data identify a collection of RNA terminator components, interactions and spacing constraints that govern efficient transcript release. The results also suggest specific architectural rearrangements of the transcription complex that may participate in allosteric control of intrinsic transcription termination.

Major conformational changes occur during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex by T7 RNA polymerase

To examine changes that occur during the transition from an initiation complex (IC) to an elongation complex (EC) in T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP), we used nucleic acid-protein cross-linking methods to probe interactions of the RNAP with RNA and DNA in a halted EC. As the RNA is displaced from the RNA-DNA hybrid approximately 9 bp upstream from the active site (at -9) it interacts with a region within the specificity loop (residues 744-750) and is directed toward a positively charged surface that surrounds residues Lys-302 and Lys-303. Surprisingly, the template and non-template strands of the DNA at the upstream edge of the hybrid (near the site where the RNA is displaced) interact with a region in the N-terminal domain of the RNAP (residues 172-191) that is far away from the specificity loop before isomerization (in the IC). To bring these two regions of the RNAP into proximity, major conformational changes must occur during the transition from an IC to an EC. The observed nucleic acid-protein interactions help to explain the behavior of a number of mutant RNAPs that are affected at various stages in the initiation process and in termination.

Structure of a T7 RNA polymerase elongation complex at 2.9 A resolution

The single-subunit bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase carries out the transcription cycle in an identical manner to that of bacterial and eukaryotic multisubunit enzymes. Here we report the crystal structure of a T7 RNA polymerase elongation complex, which shows that incorporation of an 8-base-pair RNA-DNA hybrid into the active site of the enzyme induces a marked rearrangement of the amino-terminal domain. This rearrangement involves alternative folding of about 130 residues and a marked reorientation (about 130 degrees rotation) of a stable core subdomain, resulting in a structure that provides elements required for stable transcription elongation. A wide opening on the enzyme surface that is probably an RNA exit pathway is formed, and the RNA-DNA hybrid is completely buried in a newly formed, deep protein cavity. Binding of 10 base pairs of downstream DNA is stabilized mostly by long-distance electrostatic interactions. The structure implies plausible mechanisms for the various phases of the transcription cycle, and reveals important structural similarities with the multisubunit RNA polymerases.

A one-step method for in vitro production of tRNA transcripts

Sequencing of a large number of microbial genomes has led to the discovery of new enzymes involved in tRNA biosynthesis and tRNA function. Preparation of a great variety of RNA molecules is, therefore, of major interest for biochemical characterization of these proteins. We describe a fast, cost-effective and efficient method for in vitro production of tRNA transcripts. T7 RNA polymerase requires a double-stranded DNA promoter in order to initiate transcription; however, elongation does not require a double-stranded DNA template. A partially double-stranded transcription template formed by annealing of a short oligonucleotide, complementary to the T7 promoter, to a larger oligonucleotide is shown to be a good substrate for in vitro transcription. This method allows rapid production of a variety of tRNA transcripts which can be aminoacylated well. This eliminates the need for cloning of tRNA genes, large-scale plasmid preparation and enzymatic digestion.

Structural Basis for the Transition from Initiation to Elongation Transcription in T7 RNA Polymerase

To make messenger RNA transcripts, bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP) undergoes a transition from an initiation phase, which only makes short RNA fragments, to a stable elongation phase. We have determined at 2.1 angstrom resolution the crystal structure of a T7 RNAP elongation complex with 30 base pairs of duplex DNA containing a "transcription bubble" interacting with a 17-nucleotide RNA transcript. The transition from an initiation to an elongation complex is accompanied by a major refolding of the amino-terminal 300 residues. This results in loss of the promoter binding site, facilitating promoter clearance, and creates a tunnel that surrounds the RNA transcript after it peels off a seven-base pair heteroduplex. Formation of the exit tunnel explains the enhanced processivity of the elongation complex. Downstream duplex DNA binds to the fingers domain, and its orientation relative to upstream DNA in the initiation complex implies an unwinding that could facilitate formation of the open promoter complex.

Effects of substitutions in a conserved DX(2)GR sequence motif, found in many DNA-dependent nucleotide polymerases, on transcription by T7 RNA polymerase

The region in bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) comprising residues 421-425 contains a sequence motif (DX(2)GR) that is conserved among many DNA-dependent nucleotide polymerases. We have found that alterations in this motif result in enzymes that display weaker retention of the RNA product during transcript initiation, a decreased ability to make the transition to a stable elongation complex, and changes in substrate binding and catalytic activity. Many of these defects are coupled with an altered response to the presence or absence of the non-template strand. The observed constellation of defects supports a role for the motif in interacting with and stabilizing the RNA:DNA hybrid during the early stages of transcript initiation. This is consistent with the position of the motif in a T7 RNAP initiation complex. Although a conserved DX(2)GR sequence motif is also observed in multisubunit RNAPs, the structural organization of the motif and the manner in which it interacts with the RNA:DNA hybrid in the latter enzymes is different from that in T7 RNAP. However, another element in the multisubunit RNAPs that contains a highly conserved arginine residue may play the same role as R425 in T7 RNAP. (c) 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd.

Fluorescence characterization of the transcription bubble in elongation complexes of T7 RNA polymerase

The various kinetic and thermodynamic models for transcription elongation all require an understanding of the nature of the melted bubble which moves with the RNA polymerase active site. Is the general nature of the bubble system-dependent or are there common energetic requirements which constrain a bubble in any RNA polymerases? T7 RNA polymerase is one of the simplest RNA polymerases and is the system for which we have the highest-resolution structural information. However, there is no high-resolution information available for a stable elongation complex. In order to directly map melted regions of the DNA in a functionally paused elongation complex, we have introduced fluorescent probes site-specifically into the DNA. Like 2-aminopurine, which substitutes for adenine bases, the fluorescence intensity of the new probe, pyrrolo-dC, which substitutes for cytosine bases, is sensitive to its environment. Specifically, the fluorescence is quenched in duplex DNA relative to its fluorescence in single-stranded DNA, such that the probe provides direct information on local melting of the DNA. Placement of this new probe at specific positions in the non-template strand shows clearly that the elongation bubble extends about eight bases upstream of the pause site, while 2-aminopurine probes show that the elongation bubble extends only about one nucleotide downstream of the last base incorporated. The positioning of the active site very close to the downstream edge of the bubble is consistent with previous studies and with similar studies of the promoter-bound, pre-initiation complex. The results show clearly that the RNA:DNA hybrid can be no more than eight nucleotides in length, and characterization of different paused species suggests preliminarily that these dimensions are not sequence or position dependent. Finally, the results confirm that the ternary complex is not stable with short lengths of transcript, but persists for a substantial time when paused in the middle or at the (runoff) end of duplex DNA.

The T7 RNA polymerase intercalating hairpin is important for promoter opening during initiation but not for RNA displacement or transcription bubble stability during elongation

The recently described crystal structures of a T7RNAP-promoter complex and an initial transcription complex reveal a beta-hairpin which inserts between the template and nontemplate strands of the promoter [Cheetham, G. M., et al. (1999) Nature 399, 80; Cheetham, G. M., et al. (1999) Science 286, 2305]. A stacking interaction between the exposed DNA bases and a valine at the tip of this hairpin may be especially important for stabilizing the opened promoter during initiation. It has been suggested that this hairpin may also be important for holding the transcription bubble open during transcript elongation, and a proposed model for how the RNA exits the transcription complex implies that this hairpin may also help displace the RNA from the template strand. To test these hypotheses, we have characterized both point and deletion mutants of this element. We find that these mutants exhibit reduced activity on linear, double-stranded templates but not on supercoiled or partially single-stranded templates. Probing of promoter-polymerase complexes, initial transcription complexes, and elongation complexes with KMnO(4) and a single-strand specific endonuclease reveals that the mutants have greatly reduced promoter unwinding activity during initiation. However, the structure and stability of the transcription bubble during elongation are not altered in the mutant enzymes, and RNA displacement activity is also normal. Thus, the T7RNAP intercalating hairpin is important, though not essential, for stabilizing the opened promoter during initiation, but is not important for RNA displacement or for transcription bubble structure or stability during elongation.

Scanning mutagenesis reveals roles for helix n of the bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase thumb subdomain in transcription complex stability, pausing, and termination

Deletions within the thumb subdomain (residues 335-408) of T7 RNA polymerase decrease elongation complex stability and processivity, but the structure of a T7RNAP initial transcription complex containing a 3-nucleotide RNA reveals no interactions between the thumb and the RNA or DNA. Modeling of a longer RNA in this structure, using a T7DNAP-primer-template structure as a guide, suggests that the phosphate ribose backbone of the RNA contacts a stretch of mostly positively charged side chains between residues 385 and 395 of helix N of the thumb. Scanning mutagenesis of this region reveals that alanine substitutions of Arg(391), Ser(393), and Arg(394) destabilize elongation complexes and that substitutions at 393 and 394 increase termination of transcripts 5 or more bases in length. The alpha-carbons of all 3 of these residues lie on the side of helix N, which faces into the template-binding cleft of the RNA polymerase, and modeling suggests that they can contact the RNA 4-5 bases away from the 3'-end. Alanine substitutions of other residues within 385-395 do not have marked effects on transcription complex stability, but alanine substitutions of Asp(388) and Tyr(385) reduce pausing and termination at the T7 concatemer junction. Both of these side chains lie on the outer side of helix N, pointing away from the template binding cleft. The thumb subdomain of T7RNAP therefore has roles both in transcription complex stabilization and in pausing and termination at the T7 concatemer junction.

T7 RNA polymerase elongation complex structure and movement

We have characterized T7RNAP elongation complexes (ECs) halted at different positions on a single template using a combination of digestion with exonuclease III, lambda exonuclease, RNAse T1, and treatment with KMnO(4). Our results indicate that the transcription bubble is approximately nine bases long and that the RNA:DNA hybrid is 7-8 bp in size. An additional four to six bases of RNA immediately 5' to the hybrid interact with the RNAP, probably with a site on the N-terminal domain. When ECs with transcripts of different length were probed in the presence or absence of the incoming NTP we found that the position of the EC on the template and the RNA shifted downstream upon NTP binding. NTP binding also restricted the lateral mobility of the complex on the template. Our results indicate that, in the absence of bound NTP, the RNAP is relatively free to slide on the template around a position that usually lies one to two bases upstream of the position from which NTP binding and bond formation occur. NTP binding stabilizes the RNAP in the post-translocated position and keeps it from sliding upstream, either due directly to RNAP:NTP:template interactions, or to an isomerization which causes the fingers subdomain of the RNAP to clamp down on the downstream end of the template strand.

Characterization of halted T7 RNA polymerase elongation complexes reveals multiple factors that contribute to stability

We have constructed a series of plasmid templates that allow T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) to be halted at defined intervals downstream from its promoter in a preserved sequence context. While transcription complexes halted at +3 to +6 are highly unstable, complexes halted at +10 to +14 dissociate very slowly and gradually lose their capacity to extend transcripts. Complexes halted at +18 and beyond dissociate more readily, but the stability of the these complexes is enhanced significantly in the presence of the next incoming nucleotide. Unexpectedly, the stability of complexes halted at +14 and beyond was found to be lower on supercoiled templates than on linear templates. To explore this further, we used synthetic DNA templates in which the nature of the non-template (NT) strand was varied. Whereas initiation complexes are less stable in the presence of a complementary NT strand, elongation complexes are more stable in the presence of a complementary NT strand, and the presence of a non-complementary NT strand (a mismatched bubble) results in even greater stability. The results suggest that the NT strand plays an important role in displacing the nascent RNA, allowing its interaction with an RNA product binding site in the RNAP. The NT strand may also contribute to stabilization by interacting directly with the enzyme. A mutant RNAP that has a deletion in the flexible "thumb" domain responds to changes in template topology in a manner that is similar to that of the wild-type (WT) enzyme, but halted complexes formed by the mutant enzyme are particularly dependent upon the presence of the NT strand for stability. In contrast, an N-terminal RNAP mutant that has a decreased capacity to bind single-stranded RNA forms halted complexes with much lower levels of stability than the WT enzyme, and these complexes are not stabilized by the presence of the NT strand. The distinct responses of the mutant RNAPs to changes in template structure indicate that the N-terminal and thumb domains have quite different functions in stabilizing the transcription complex.

Misincorporation by wild-type and mutant T7 RNA polymerases: identification of interactions that reduce misincorporation rates by stabilizing the catalytically incompetent open conformation

We have characterized the misincorporation properties of wild-type (wt) T7 RNAP and of 45 T7RNAP point mutants. The wt enzyme selects strongly against incorporation of an incorrect nucleotide. From the measured rates of misincorporation, an average error frequency of 1 in 2 x 10(4) is estimated. RNAs bearing 3'-mismatches are extended more slowly than correctly paired 3'-termini, and mismatches one or two bases away from the RNA 3'-end can also slow extension severely even when the 3'-base is correctly paired. Though it has been reported that T7RNAP has a 3' --> 5' nuclease activity, we were unable to detect any endogenous T7RNAP RNase activity in elongation complexes. Pyrophosphorolysis was detected but does not appear to contribute to proofreading. Therefore, unlike other RNAPs, T7RNAP fidelity appears to depend entirely on discrimination against incorporation of the incorrect nucleotide and not on post-misincorporation proofreading. Alanine substitution of the H784 side chain, which interacts with the 3' RNA.template base pair, increases both misincorporation and mismatch extension, while substitutions at G640, F644, and G645 increase misincorporation, but not mismatch extension. The latter three amino acids are in a part of the RNAP which interacts with the templating base and with the base immediately 5' to the templating base. Mutation of these amino acids not only increases misincorporation, but also eliminates pausing during promoter clearance. The effects of these mutations and the interactions observed in a crystal structure of a transcribing complex indicate that these mutations disrupt interactions which limit misincorporation rates by stabilizing the catalytically incompetent open conformation of the RNAP.

Insights into transcription: structure and function of single-subunit DNA-dependent RNA polymerases

Single-subunit RNA polymerases are widespread throughout prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms, and also viruses. T7 RNA polymerase is one of the simplest DNA-dependent enzymes, capable of transcribing a complete gene without the need for additional proteins. During the past two years, three illuminating crystal structures of T7 RNA polymerase complexed to either T7 lysozyme, which is a transcription inhibitor, an open promoter DNA fragment or a promoter DNA fragment being transcribed into RNA at initiation have been determined. For the first time, these structures describe in detail the intricate mechanism of transcription initiation by T7 RNA polymerase, which is likely to be a general model for other related RNA polymerases.

Mechanisms by which T7 lysozyme specifically regulates T7 RNA polymerase during different phases of transcription

Bacteriophage T7 lysozyme binds to T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) and regulates its transcription by differentially repressing initiation from different T7 promoters. This selective repression is due in part to a lysozyme-induced increase in the KNTP of the initiation complex (IC) and to intrinsically different NTP concentration requirements for efficient initiation from different T7 promoters. While lysozyme represses initiation, once the enzyme has left the promoter and formed an elongation complex (EC) it is generally resistant to the effects of lysozyme. The mechanism by which the inhibitory effects of lysozyme are largely restricted to the initiation phase of transcription is not well understood. We find that T7 lysozyme destabilizes initial transcription complexes (ITCs) and increases the rate of release of transcripts from these complexes but does not destabilize ECs. However, if the RNA:RNAP interaction proposed to be important for EC stability is disrupted by proteolysis of the RNA-binding domain or use of templates which interfere with establishment of this RNA:RNAP interaction, the EC becomes sensitive to lysozyme. Comparison of the X-ray structures of T7RNAP and of a T7RNAP:T7 lysozyme complex reveals that lysozyme causes the C terminus of the polymerase to flip out of the active site. Experiments in which carboxypeptidase A is used to probe the lysozyme-induced exposure of the C terminus reveal a large decrease in carboxypeptidase sensitivity following transcription initiation, suggesting that interactions with the 3'-end of the RNA help stabilize the active site in a functional (carboxypeptidase protected) conformation. Thus, the resistance of the EC to lysozyme appears to be due to the consecutive establishment of two sets of RNA:RNAP interactions. The first is made with the 3'-end of the RNA and helps stabilize a functional conformation of the active site, thereby suppressing the effects of lysozyme on KNTP. The second is made with a more upstream element of the RNA and keeps the EC from being destabilized by lysozyme binding.