Expression of myogenic regulatory factors during muscle development of Xenopus: myogenin mRNA accumulation is limited strictly to secondary myogenesis

In utero delivery of mRNA to the heart, diaphragm and muscle with lipid nanoparticles

Nanoparticle-based drug delivery systems have the potential to revolutionize medicine, but their low vascular permeability and rapid clearance by phagocytic cells have limited their medical impact. Nanoparticles delivered at the in utero stage can overcome these key limitations due to the high rate of angiogenesis and cell division in fetal tissue and the under-developed immune system. However, very little is known about nanoparticle drug delivery at the fetal stage of development. In this report, using Ai9 CRE reporter mice, we demonstrate that lipid nanoparticle (LNP) mRNA complexes can deliver mRNA in utero, and can access and transfect major organs, such as the heart, the liver, kidneys, lungs and the gastrointestinal tract with remarkable efficiency and low toxicity. In addition, at 4 weeks after birth, we demonstrate that 50.99 ± 5.05%, 36.62 ± 3.42% and 23.7 ± 3.21% of myofiber in the diaphragm, heart and skeletal muscle, respectively, were transfected. Finally, we show here that Cas9 mRNA and sgRNA complexed to LNPs were able to edit the fetal organs in utero. These experiments demonstrate the possibility of non-viral delivery of mRNA to organs outside of the liver in utero, which provides a promising strategy for treating a wide variety of devastating diseases before birth.

Identification of thyroid hormone response genes in the remodeling of dorsal muscle during Microhyla fissipes metamorphosis

INTRODUCTION

Extensive morphological, biochemical, and cellular changes occur during anuran metamorphosis, which is triggered by a single hormone, thyroid hormone (TH). The function of TH is mainly mediated through thyroid receptor (TR) by binding to the specific thyroid response elements (TREs) of direct response genes, in turn regulating the downstream genes in the cascade. The remodeling of dorsal skeletal muscle during anuran metamorphosis provides the perfect model to identify the immediate early and direct response genes that are important during apoptosis, proliferation, and differentiation of the muscle.

METHODS

In our current study, we performed Illumina sequencing combined with single-molecule real-time (SMRT) sequencing in the dorsal muscle of Microhyla fissipes after TH, cycloheximide (CHX), and TH_CHX treatment.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

We first identified 1,245 differentially expressed transcripts (DETs) after TH exposure, many of which were involved in DNA replication, protein processing in the endoplasmic reticulum, cell cycle, apoptosis, p53 signaling pathway, and protein digestion and absorption. In the comparison of the TH group vs. control group and TH_CHX group vs. CHX group overlapping gene, 39 upregulated and 6 downregulated genes were identified as the TH directly induced genes. Further analysis indicated that AGGTCAnnTnAGGTCA is the optimal target sequence of target genes for TR/RXR heterodimers in M. fissipes. Future investigations on the function and regulation of these genes and pathways should help to reveal the mechanisms governing amphibian dorsal muscle remodeling. These full-length and high-quality transcriptomes in this study also provide an important foundation for future studies in M. fissipes metamorphosis.

Everybody wants to move-Evolutionary implications of trunk muscle differentiation in vertebrate species

In our review we have completed current knowledge on myotomal myogenesis in model and non-model vertebrate species (fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals) at morphological and molecular levels. Data obtained from these studies reveal distinct similarities and differences between amniote and anamniote species. Based on the available data, we decided to present evolutionary implications in vertebrate trunk muscle development. Despite the fact that in all vertebrates muscle fibres are multinucleated, the pathways leading to them vary between vertebrate taxa. In fishes during early myogenesis myoblasts differentiate into multinucleated lamellae or multinucleate myotubes. In amphibians, myoblasts fuse to form multinucleated myotubes or, bypassing fusion, directly differentiate into mononucleated myotubes. Furthermore, mononucleated myotubes were also observed during primary myogenesis in amniotes. The mononucleated state of myogenic cells could be considered as an old phylogenetic, plesiomorphic feature, whereas direct multinuclearity of myotubes has a synapomorphic character. On the other hand, the explanation of this phenomenon could also be linked to the environmental conditions in which animals develop. The similarities observed in vertebrate myogenesis might result from a conservative myogenic programme governed by the Pax3/Pax7 and myogenic regulatory factor (MRF) network, whereas differences in anamniotes and amniotes are established by spatiotemporal pattern expression of MRFs during muscle differentiation and/or environmental conditions.

Making muscle: Morphogenetic movements and molecular mechanisms of myogenesis in Xenopus laevis

Xenopus laevis offers unprecedented access to the intricacies of muscle development. The large, robust embryos make it ideal for manipulations at both the tissue and molecular level. In particular, this model system can be used to fate map early muscle progenitors, visualize cell behaviors associated with somitogenesis, and examine the role of signaling pathways that underlie induction, specification, and differentiation of muscle. Several characteristics that are unique to X. laevis include myogenic waves with distinct gene expression profiles and the late formation of dermomyotome and sclerotome. Furthermore, myogenesis in the metamorphosing frog is biphasic, facilitating regeneration studies. In this review, we describe the morphogenetic movements that shape the somites and discuss signaling and transcriptional regulation during muscle development and regeneration. With recent advances in gene editing tools, X. laevis remains a premier model organism for dissecting the complex mechanisms underlying the specification, cell behaviors, and formation of the musculature system.

Differential muscle regulatory factor gene expression between larval and adult myogenesis in the frog Xenopus laevis: adult myogenic cell-specific myf5 upregulation and its relation to the notochord suppression of adult muscle differentiation

During Xenopus laevis metamorphosis, larval-to-adult muscle conversion depends on the differential responses of adult and larval myogenic cells to thyroid hormone. Essential differences in cell growth, differentiation, and hormone-dependent life-or-death fate have been reported between cultured larval (tail) and adult (hindlimb) myogenic cells. A previous study revealed that tail notochord cells suppress terminal differentiation in adult (but not larval) myogenic cells. However, little is known about the differences in expression patterns of myogenic regulatory factors (MRF) and the satellite cell marker Pax7 between adult and larval myogenic cells. In the present study, we compared mRNA expression of these factors between the two types. At first, reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction analysis of hindlimb buds showed sequential upregulation of myf5, myogenin, myod, and mrf4 during stages 50-54, when limb buds elongate and muscles begin to form. By contrast, in the tail, there was no such increase during the same period. Secondary, these results were duplicated in vitro: adult myogenic cells upregulated myf5, myod, and pax7 in the early culture period, followed by myogenin upregulation and myotube differentiation, while larval myogenic cells did not upregulate these genes and precociously started myotube differentiation. Thirdly, myf5 upregulation and early-phase proliferation in adult myogenic cells were potently inhibited by the presence of notochord cells, suggesting that notochord cells suppress adult myogenesis through inhibiting the transition from Myf5(-) stem cells to Myf5(+) committed myoblasts. All of the data presented here suggest that myf5 upregulation can be a good criterion for the activation of adult myogenesis during X. laevis metamorphosis.

The evolutionary history of the development of the pelvic fin/hindlimb

The arms and legs of man are evolutionarily derived from the paired fins of primitive jawed fish. Few evolutionary changes have attracted as much attention as the origin of tetrapod limbs from the paired fins of ancestral fish. The hindlimbs of tetrapods are derived from the pelvic fins of ancestral fish. These evolutionary origins can be seen in the examination of shared gene and protein expression patterns during the development of pelvic fins and tetrapod hindlimbs. The pelvic fins of fish express key limb positioning, limb bud induction and limb outgrowth genes in a similar manner to that seen in hindlimb development of higher vertebrates. We are now at a point where many of the key players in the development of pelvic fins and vertebrate hindlimbs have been identified and we can now readily examine and compare mechanisms between species. This is yielding fascinating insights into how the developmental programme has altered during evolution and how that relates to anatomical change. The role of pelvic fins has also drastically changed over evolutionary history, from playing a minor role during swimming to developing into robust weight-bearing limbs. In addition, the pelvic fins/hindlimbs have been lost repeatedly in diverse species over evolutionary time. Here we review the evolution of pelvic fins and hindlimbs within the context of the changes in anatomical structure and the molecular mechanisms involved.

Myogenic waves and myogenic programs during Xenopus embryonic myogenesis

Although Xenopus is a key model organism in developmental biology, little is known about the myotome formation in this species. Here, we assessed the expression of myogenic regulatory factors of the Myod family (MRFs) during embryonic development and revealed distinct MRF programs.

RESULTS

The expression pattern of each MRF during embryonic development highlights three successive myogenic waves. We showed that a first median and lateral myogenesis initiates before dermomyotome formation: the median cell population expresses Myf5, Myod, and Mrf4, whereas the lateral one expresses Myod, moderate levels of Myogenin and Mrf4. The second wave of myoblasts arising from the dermomyotome is characterized by the full MRF program expression, with high levels of Myogenin. The third wave is revealed by Myf5 expression in the myotome and could contribute to the formation of plurinucleated fibers at larval stages. Furthermore, Myf5- or Myod-expressing anlagen are identified in craniofacial myogenesis.

CONCLUSIONS

The first median and lateral myogenesis and their associated MRF programs have probably disappeared in mammals. However, some aspects of Xenopus myogenesis have been conserved such as the development of somitic muscles by successive myogenic waves and the existence of Myf5-dependent and -independent lineages.

Development and evolution of the muscles of the pelvic fin

Locomotor strategies in terrestrial tetrapods have evolved from the utilisation of sinusoidal contractions of axial musculature, evident in ancestral fish species, to the reliance on powerful and complex limb muscles to provide propulsive force. Within tetrapods, a hindlimb-dominant locomotor strategy predominates, and its evolution is considered critical for the evident success of the tetrapod transition onto land. Here, we determine the developmental mechanisms of pelvic fin muscle formation in living fish species at critical points within the vertebrate phylogeny and reveal a stepwise modification from a primitive to a more derived mode of pelvic fin muscle formation. A distinct process generates pelvic fin muscle in bony fishes that incorporates both primitive and derived characteristics of vertebrate appendicular muscle formation. We propose that the adoption of the fully derived mode of hindlimb muscle formation from this bimodal character state is an evolutionary innovation that was critical to the success of the tetrapod transition.

A conserved MRF4 promoter drives transgenic expression in Xenopus embryonic somites and adult muscle

The muscle regulatory factor MRF4 is expressed in both embryonic and adult vertebrate skeletal muscle cells. In mammals the MRF4 gene has a complex cis-regulatory structure, with many kilobases (kb) of upstream sequence required for embryonic expression in transgenic mice. Here, initial functional comparison between Xenopus and mammalian MRF4 genes revealed that 610 base pairs (bp) of the XMRF4a proximal promoter drove substantial transgenic expression in X. laevis myogenic cells, from somites of neurula embryos through adult myofibers, and as little as 180 bp gave detectable expression. Over 300 bp of XMRF4a proximal promoter sequence is highly conserved among three X. laevis and X. tropicalis MRF4 genes, but only about 150 bp shows significant identity to mammalian MRF4 genes. This most-conserved XMRF4a region contains a putative MEF2 binding site essential for expression both in transgenic embryos and in transfected mouse muscle cells. A rat MRF4 minimal promoter including the conserved region also was active in transgenic X. laevis embryos, demonstrating a striking difference between the mouse and Xenopus transgenic systems. The longest XMRF4a promoter construct tested, with 9.5 kb of 5'-flanking sequence, produced significantly greater expression in transfected mouse cells than did promoters 4.3-kb or shorter, suggesting that the intervening region contains an enhancer, although no increased expression was evident when this region was included in transgenic X. laevis embryos. Further identification and analysis of Xenopus MRF4 transcriptional control elements will offer insights into the evolution of this gene and of the myogenic gene regulatory network.

Xenopus oocytes reactivate muscle gene transcription in transplanted somatic nuclei independently of myogenic factors

Transplantation into eggs or oocytes is an effective means of achieving the reprogramming of somatic cell nuclei. We ask here whether the provision of gene-specific transcription factors forms part of the mechanism by which a gene that is repressed in somatic cells is transcribed in oocytes. We find that M1 oocytes have an extremely strong transcription-inducing activity. They cause muscle genes of nuclei from non-muscle somatic cells, after injection into oocytes, to be transcribed to nearly the same extent as muscle genes in muscle cells. We show, surprisingly, that the myogenic factor MyoD and other known myogenic factors are not required to induce the transcription of muscle genes in a range of non-muscle somatic cell nuclei after transplantation to Xenopus oocytes. The overexpression of Id, a dominant-negative repressor of MyoD, prevents maternal MyoD from binding to its consensus sequences; nevertheless, muscle genes are activated in somatic nuclei to the same extent as without Id. We conclude that M1 oocytes can reprogram somatic nuclei in a different way to other experimental procedures: oocytes do not suppress the transcription of inappropriate genes and they activate a gene without the help of its known transcription factors. We suggest that these characteristics might be a special property of amphibian oocytes, and possibly of oocytes in general.

Regulation of desmin expression in adult-type myogenesis and muscle maturation during Xenopus laevis metamorphosis

Isoforms of myosin heavy chain and tropomyosin convert during metamorphosis of Xenopus laevis with larval-to-adult remodeling of dorsal muscle (Nishikawa and Hayashi, 1994 , Dev. Biol. 165: 86-94). In the present study, other markers for muscle remodeling during metamorphosis were determined by SDS-PAGE analysis. The amounts of twelve muscle proteins changed remarkably during metamorphosis. Among these, a 54-kDa molecule was found to be desmin, and the relative content/total proteins decreased dramatically through metamorphosis. In hindlimb muscle, desmin content increased fourfold during prometamorphosis, when myoblast proliferation and fusion occurred. With further myotube maturation, this content decreased by 1/2 while that of muscle actin continued to increase. Thus, desmin up- and down-regulation in hindlimbs mark early and late phases of myogenesis, respectively. In tall muscle, the desmin content decreased continuously to (1/8) before and during metamorphosis, due to tall muscle growth and maturation. In dorsal muscle, three desmin changes occurred: a pre-metamorphic decrease, a transient increase at prometamorphosis, and a rapid decrease at the climax stage. Immunohistochemical analysis showed desmin+ cells to be present between young (adult-type) myotubes and replicating (PCNA+) cells in dorsal muscles, correlating the transient desmin upregulation in dorsal muscle with the initiation of adult-type myogenesis. After the upregulation, dorsal muscle desmin decreased to (1/8). This rapid down-regulation was replicated by administration of triiodothyronine (T3) to tadpoles, suggesting a significant role for T3 in dorsal muscle remodeling during metamorphosis. Collectively, these results show that analysis of desmin expression and PCNA-immunohistochemistry are good tools for determining the sites and timing of larval-to-adult muscle remodeling during Xenopus laevis metamorphosis.

Induced early expression of mrf4 but not myog rescues myogenesis in the myod/myf5 double-morphant zebrafish embryo

Muscle regulatory factors activate myogenesis in all vertebrates, but their role has been studied in great detail only in the mouse embryo, where all but myogenin – Myod, Myf5 and Mrf4 – are sufficient to activate (albeit not completely) skeletal myogenesis. In the zebrafish embryo, myod and myf5 are required for induction of myogenesis because their simultaneous ablation prevents muscle development. Here we show that mrf4 but not myog can fully rescue myogenesis in the myod/myf5 double morphant via a selective and robust activation of myod, in keeping with its chromatin-remodelling function in vitro. Rescue does not happen spontaneously, because the gene, unlike that in the mouse embryo, is expressed only at the onset of muscle differentiation, Moreover, because of the transient nature of morpholino inhibition, we were able to investigate how myogenesis occurs in the absence of a myotome. We report that in the complete absence of a myotome, subsequent myogenesis is abolished, whereas myogenesis does proceed, albeit abnormally, when the morpholino inhibition was not complete. Therefore our data also show that the early myotome is essential for subsequent skeletal muscle differentiation and patterning in the zebrafish.

A p38 MAPK-CREB pathway functions to pattern mesoderm in Xenopus

Dorsal-ventral patterning is specified by signaling centers secreting antagonizing morphogens that form a signaling gradient. Yet, how morphogen gradient is translated intracellularly into fate decisions remains largely unknown. Here, we report that p38 MAPK and CREB function along the dorsal-ventral axis in mesoderm patterning. We find that the phosphorylated form of CREB (S133) is distributed in a gradient along the dorsal-ventral mesoderm axis and that the p38 MAPK pathway mediates the phosphorylation of CREB. Knockdown of CREB prevents chordin expression and mesoderm dorsalization by the Spemann organizer, whereas ectopic expression of activated CREB-VP16 chimera induces chordin expression and dorsalizes mesoderm. Expression of high levels of p38 activator, MKK6E or CREB-VP16 in embryos converts ventral mesoderm into a dorsal organizing center. p38 MAPK and CREB function downstream of maternal Wnt/beta-catenin and the organizer-specific genes siamois and goosecoid. At low expression levels, MKK6E induces expression of lateral genes without inducing the expression of dorsal genes. Loss of CREB or p38 MAPK activity enables the expansion of the ventral homeobox gene vent1 into the dorsal marginal region, preventing the lateral expression of Xmyf5. Overall, these data indicate that dorsal-ventral mesoderm patterning is regulated by differential p38/CREB activities along the axis.

Muscle development in a biphasic animal: the frog

Knowledge of muscle development in a vertebrate reflects strengths of the particular model system. For example, the origin of mesoderm is very well characterized in Xenopus laevis, where development of somites is less well understood. The major problem in muscle development, presented by frogs, is the complete replacement of larval muscles by adult muscles at thyroid hormone-dependent metamorphosis. All tail muscles die, all leg muscles form de novo, and muscles in the jaw and trunk show both processes. The nature of adult muscle progenitors remains unclear. Comparison of X. laevis development with divergent amphibian patterns, such as direct developers, which lack the larval tadpole, should highlight important steps in adult muscle formation.

Xenopus laevis POU91 protein, an Oct3/4 homologue, regulates competence transitions from mesoderm to neural cell fates

Cellular competence is defined as a cell's ability to respond to signaling cues as a function of time. In Xenopus laevis, cellular responsiveness to fibroblast growth factor (FGF) changes during development. At blastula stages, FGF induces mesoderm, but at gastrula stages FGF regulates neuroectoderm formation. A Xenopus Oct3/4 homologue gene, XLPOU91, regulates mesoderm to neuroectoderm transitions. Ectopic XLPOU91 expression in Xenopus embryos inhibits FGF induction of Brachyury (Xbra), eliminating mesoderm, whereas neural induction is unaffected. XLPOU91 knockdown induces high levels of Xbra expression, with blastopore closure being delayed to later neurula stages. In morphant ectoderm explants, mesoderm responsiveness to FGF is extended from blastula to gastrula stages. The initial expression of mesoderm and endoderm markers is normal, but neural induction is abolished. Churchill (chch) and Sip1, two genes regulating neural competence, are not expressed in XLPOU91 morphant embryos. Ectopic Sip1 or chch expression rescues the morphant phenotype. Thus, XLPOU91 epistatically lies upstream of chch/Sip1 gene expression, regulating the competence transition that is critical for neural induction. In the absence of XLPOU91 activity, the cues driving proper embryonic cell fates are lost.

Characteristics of initiation and early events for muscle development in the Xenopus limb bud

In Xenopus laevis, limb buds start to develop at a later point of the larval stage, prior to metamorphosis. This onset of limb development in Xenopus is totally different from that in amniotes such as birds and mammals, in which limb buds emerge at an early stage of embryogenesis, in parallel with other organogenesis. We investigated limb myogenesis in Xenopus, focusing on myogenic gene expression, myogenic ability of limb bud cells in the early stage, and the origin of myogenic precursor cells in the limb bud. The Xenopus early limb bud contains myoD/cardiac actin-positive and pax3/pax7-negative cells. Interestingly, results of transplantation experiments have revealed that this early limb bud contains myogenic precursor cells. In order to know the contribution of myogenic cells in somites to myogenic precursor cells in the early limb bud, we used a Cre-LoxP system for tracing over a long period. The results of fate tracing for myogenic cells in somites of the Xenopus embryo suggested that early-specified myogenic cells in somites do not contribute to limb muscle in Xenopus. Taken together, the results suggest that limb muscle development in Xenopus has characteristics of initiation and early events distinct from those of other vertebrate clades.

Spatio-temporal expression of MRF4 transcripts and protein duringXenopus laevis embryogenesis

Whereas there have been extensive studies of the expression of XMyf5 and XMyoD during Xenopus embryogenesis, nothing is known about the spatio-temporal accumulation of XMRF4 transcripts and protein. In this report, we describe the cloning and characterization of two full-length MRF4 cDNAs and of their proximal promoters in Xenopus laevis. The comparison of the relative transcript levels of the XMRF4-a and -b genes in developing and adult muscles is highly suggestive of specific functions for the corresponding XMRF4 proteins. Whole-mount embryo in situ hybridization revealed the first XMRF4 transcripts in the more differentiated anterior myocytes of the embryo when the myosin heavy chain E3 mRNA begins to be detectable. XMRF4 mRNA accumulation later extended posteriorly but was never detected in the posterior unsegmented mesoderm, in contrast to XMyoD and XMyf-5. Whole-mount embryo immunohistochemistry revealed that XMRF4 protein accumulated in somite nuclei slightly after XMRF4 transcripts.

p38 MAP kinase regulates the expression of XMyf5 and affects distinct myogenic programs during Xenopus development

The p38 MAPK signaling pathway is essential for skeletal muscle differentiation in tissue culture models. We demonstrate a novel role for p38 MAPK in myogenesis during early Xenopus laevis development. Interfering with p38 MAPK causes distinct defects in myogenesis. The initial expression of Myf5 is selectively blocked, while expression of MyoD is unaffected. Expression of a subset of muscle structural genes is reduced. Convergent extension movements are prevented and segmentation of the paraxial mesoderm is delayed, probably due to the failure of cells to withdraw from the cell cycle. Myotubes are properly formed; however, at later stages, they begin to degenerate, and the boundaries between somites disappear. Significant apoptotic cell death occurs in most parts of the somites. The ventral body wall muscle derived from migratory progenitor cells of the ventral somite region is poorly formed. Our data indicate that the developmental defects caused by p38alpha-knockdown were mediated by the loss of XMyf5 expression. Thus, this study identifies a specific intracellular pathway in which p38 MAPK and Myf5 proteins regulate a distinct myogenic program.

Myogenic regulatory factors: Redundant or specific functions? Lessons fromXenopus

The discovery, in the late 1980s, of the MyoD gene family of muscle transcription factors has proved to be a milestone in understanding the molecular events controlling the specification and differentiation of the muscle lineage. From gene knock-out mice experiments progressively emerged the idea that each myogenic regulatory factor (MRF) has evolved a specialized as well as a redundant role in muscle differentiation. To date, MyoD serves as a paradigm for the MRF mode of function. The features of gene regulation by MyoD support a model in which subprograms of gene expression are achieved by the combination of promoter-specific regulation of MyoD binding and MyoD-mediated binding of various ancillary proteins. This binding likely includes site-specific chromatin reorganization by means of direct or indirect interaction with remodeling enzymes. In this cascade of molecular events leading to the proper and reproducible activation of muscle gene expression, the role and mode of function of other MRFs still remains largely unclear. Recent in vivo findings using the Xenopus embryo model strongly support the concept that a single MRF can specifically control a subset of muscle genes and, thus, can be substituted by other MRFs albeit with dramatically lower efficiency. The topic of this review is to summarize the molecular data accounting for a redundant and/or specific involvement of each member of the MyoD family in myogenesis in the light of recent studies on the Xenopus model.

Specific activation of the acetylcholine receptor subunit genes by MyoD family proteins

Whether the myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) of the MyoD family can discriminate among the muscle gene targets for the proper and reproducible formation of skeletal muscle is a recurrent question. We have previously shown that, in Xenopus laevis, myogenin specifically transactivated muscle structural genes in vivo. In the present study, we used the Xenopus model to examine the role of XMyoD, XMyf5, and XMRF4 for the transactivation of the (nicotinic acetylcholine receptor) nAChR genes in vivo. During early Xenopus development, the expression patterns of nAChR subunit genes proved to be correlated with the expression patterns of the MRFs. We show that XMyf5 specifically induced the expression of the delta-subunit gene in cap animal assays and in endoderm cells of Xenopus embryos but was unable to activate the expression of the gamma-subunit gene. In embryos, overexpression of a dominant-negative XMyf5 variant led to the repression of delta-but not gamma-subunit gene expression. Conversely, XMyoD and XMRF4 activated gamma-subunit gene expression but were unable to activate delta-subunit gene expression. Finally, all MRFs induced expression of the alpha-subunit gene. These findings strengthen the concept that one MRF can specifically control a subset of muscle genes that cannot be activated by the other MRFs.

MRF4 gene expression in Xenopus embryos and aneural myofibers

Vertebrate embryos express the transcription factor MRF4 during skeletal muscle differentiation. Previous studies of MRF4 expression in embryonic Xenopus laevis and its response to muscle denervation in adults have led to the suggestion that its transcription may be activated in myotomes and in multinucleate myofibers through an interaction with the motor nerves. We tested this hypothesis by assaying for MRF4 gene transcripts in early neurula stage embryos, beginning before the appearance of neurons. MRF4 transcripts were detectable by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) from at least stage 13-14, well before the differentiation of either nerves or myocytes. We also tested the nerve-dependence of MRF4 gene expression in multinucleate myofibers by comparing transcript levels between interhyoideus muscles in normal larvae and muscles whose motor innervation had been prevented through surgical removal of the brain before cranial motor axon outgrowth. RT-PCR demonstrated similar MRF4 transcript levels in the aneural muscles and controls. These results fail to support the hypothesis that MRF4 gene expression is triggered or is significantly up-regulated in myogenic cells by signals from motor axons.

Xenopus muscle development: from primary to secondary myogenesis

Xenopus myogenesis is characterized by specific features, different from those of mammalian and avian systems both at the cellular level and in gene expression patterns. During early embryogenesis, after the initial molecular signals inducing mesoderm, the myogenic determination factors XMyoD and XMyf-5 are activated in presomitic mesoderm in response to mesoderm-inducing factors. After these first inductions of the myogenic program, forming muscles in Xenopus can have different destinies, some of these resulting in cell death before adulthood. In particular, it is quite characteristic of this species that, during metamorphosis, the primary myotomal myofibers completely die and are progressively replaced by secondary "adult" multinucleated myofibers. This feature offers the unique opportunity to totally separate the molecular analysis of these two distinct types of myogenesis. The aim of this review is to summarize our knowledge on the cellular and molecular events as well as the epigenetic regulations involved in the construction of Xenopus muscles during development.

A single cdk inhibitor, p27Xic1, functions beyond cell cycle regulation to promote muscle differentiation in Xenopus

The molecular basis of the antagonism between cellular proliferation and differentiation is poorly understood. We have investigated the role of the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p27(Xic1) in the co-ordination of cell cycle exit and differentiation during early myogenesis in vivo using Xenopus embryos. In this report, we demonstrate that p27(Xic1) is highly expressed in the developing myotome, that ablation of p27(Xic1) protein prevents muscle differentiation and that p27(Xic1) synergizes with the transcription factor MyoD to promote muscle differentiation. Furthermore, the ability of p27(Xic1) to promote myogenesis resides in an N-terminal domain and is separable from its cell cycle regulation function. This data demonstrates that a single cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor, p27(Xic1), controls in vivo muscle differentiation in Xenopus and that regulation of this process by p27(Xic1) requires activities beyond cell cycle inhibition.

Two myogenin-related genes are differentially expressed in Xenopus laevis myogenesis and differ in their ability to transactivate muscle structural genes

Among the myogenic regulatory factors, myogenin is a transcriptional activator situated at a crucial position for terminal differentiation in muscle development. It is unclear at present whether myogenin exhibits unique specificities to transactivate late muscular markers. During Xenopus development, the accumulation of myogenin mRNA is restricted to secondary myogenesis, at the onset of the appearance of adult isoforms of beta-tropomyosin and myosin heavy chain. To determine the role of myogenin in the isoform switch of these contractile proteins, we characterized and directly compared the functional properties of myogenin with other myogenic regulatory factors in Xenopus embryos. Two distinct cDNAs related to myogenin, XmyogU1 and XmyogU2, were differentially expressed during myogenesis and in adult tissues, in which they preferentially accumulated in oxidative myofibers. Animal cap assays in Xenopus embryos revealed that myogenin, but not the other myogenic regulatory factors, induced expression of embryonic/larval isoforms of the beta-tropomyosin and myosin heavy chain genes. Only XmyogU1 induced expression of the adult fast isoform of the myosin heavy chain gene. This is the first demonstration of a specific transactivation of one set of muscle structural genes by myogenin.

MAP kinase converts MyoD into an instructive muscle differentiation factor in Xenopus

In amphibian development, muscle is specified in the dorsal lateral marginal zone (DLMZ) of the gastrula embryo. Two critical events specify the formation of skeletal muscle: the expression of the myogenic transcription factor, XMyoD, and the secretion of bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) antagonists by the adjacent Spemann organizer. Inhibition of BMP signaling during early gastrula stages converts XMyoD protein into an instructive differentiation factor in the DLMZ. Yet, the intracellular signaling factors connecting BMP antagonism and activation of XMyoD remain unknown. Our data show that BMP antagonism induces the activity of mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), and that the activity of MAPK is necessary for muscle-specific differentiation. Treatment of gastrula-stage DLMZ explants with MAPK pathway inhibitors ventralized mesoderm and prevented muscle differentiation. Expression of XMyoD in ventral mesoderm weakly induced muscle formation; however, the coexpression of a constitutively active MEK1 with XMyoD efficiently induced muscle differentiation. Activation of the MAPK pathway did not induce the transcription of XMyoD, but increased its protein levels and transcriptional activity. Thus, MAPK activation is subsequent to BMP antagonism, and participates in the dorsalization of mesoderm by converting the XMyoD protein into a potent differentiation factor.

Hedgehog signalling is required for maintenance of myf5 and myoD expression and timely terminal differentiation in zebrafish adaxial myogenesis

Hedgehog proteins have been implicated in the control of myogenesis in the medial vertebrate somite. In the mouse, normal epaxial expression of the myogenic transcription factor gene myf5 is dependent on Sonic hedgehog. Here we examine in zebrafish the interaction between Hedgehog signals, the expression of myoD family genes, including the newly cloned zebrafish myf5, and slow myogenesis. We show that Sonic hedgehog is necessary for normal expression of both myf5 and myoD in adaxial slow muscle precursors, but not in lateral paraxial mesoderm. Expression of both genes is initiated normally in rostral presomitic mesoderm in sonic you mutants, which lack all Sonic hedgehog. Similar initiation continues during tailbud outgrowth when the cells forming caudal somites are generated. However, adaxial cells in sonic you embryos are delayed in terminal differentiation and caudal adaxial cells fail to maintain myogenic regulatory factor expression. Despite these defects, other signals are able to maintain, or reinitiate, some slow muscle development in sonic you mutants. In the cyclops mutant, the absence of floorplate-derived Tiggywinkle hedgehog and Sonic hedgehog has no discernible effect on slow adaxial myogenesis. Similarly, the absence of notochord-derived Sonic hedgehog and Echidna hedgehog in mutants lacking notochord delays, but does not prevent, adaxial slow muscle development. In contrast, removal of both Sonic hedgehog and a floorplate signal, probably Tiggywinkle hedgehog, from the embryonic midline in cyclops;sonic you double mutants essentially abolishes slow myogenesis. We conclude that several midline signals, likely to be various Hedgehogs, collaborate to maintain adaxial slow myogenesis in the zebrafish embryo. Moreover, the data demonstrate that, in the absence of this required Hedgehog signalling, expression of myf5 and myoD is insufficient to commit cells to adaxial myogenesis.

Regulation and functions of myogenic regulatory factors in lower vertebrates

The transcription factors of the MyoD family have essential functions in myogenic lineage determination and muscle differentiation. These myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) activate muscle-specific transcription through binding to a DNA consensus sequence known as the E-box present in the promoter of numerous muscle genes. Four members, MyoD, myogenin, myf5 and MRF4/herculin/myf6, have been identified in higher vertebrates and have been shown to exhibit distinct but overlapping functions. Homologues of these four MRFs have also been isolated in a variety of lower vertebrates, including amphibians and fish. Differences have been observed, however, in both the expression patterns of MRFs during muscle development and the function of individual MRFs between lower and higher vertebrates. These differences reflect the variety of body muscle formation patterns among vertebrates. Furthermore, as a result of an additional polyploidy that occurred during the evolution of some amphibians and fish, MyoD, myogenin, myf5 and MRF4 may exist in lower vertebrates in two distinct copies that have evolved separately, acquiring specific roles and resulting in increased complexity of the myogenic regulatory network. Evidence is now accumulating that many of the co-factors (E12, Id, MEF2 and CRP proteins) that regulate MRF activity in mammals are also present in lower vertebrates. The inductive signals controlling the initial expression of MRFs within the developing somite of lower vertebrate proteins are currently being elucidated.

Evolutionary history of vertebrate appendicular muscle

The evolutionary history of muscle development in the paired fins of teleost fish and the limbs of tetrapod vertebrates is still, to a large extent, uncertain. There has been a consensus, however, that in the vertebrate clade the ancestral mechanism of fin and limb muscle development involves the extension of epithelial tissues from the somite into the fin/limb bud. This mechanism has been documented in chondrichthyan, dipnoan, chondrostean and teleost fishes. It has also been assumed that in amniotes, in contrast, individual progenitor cells of muscles migrate from the somites into the limb buds. Neyt et al. now present the exciting finding that in zebrafishes this presumably derived mechanism involving individual cell migration, is present. They conclude, based on data on sharks, zebrafishes, chickens, quails and mice that the derived mechanism was present in the sarcopterygians. This conclusion, however, may be premature in the light of further data available in the literature, which show a highly mosaic distribution of this character in the vertebrate clade. Furthermore, a developmental mode exists that is intermediate between the supposed ancestral and derived modes in teleosts, reptiles and possibly amphibians.

Neural and hormonal control of expression of myogenic regulatory factor genes during regeneration of Xenopus fast muscles: myogenin and MRF4 mRNA accumulation are neurally regulated oppositely

With the aim to investigate the influence of both innervation and thyroid hormone, on the expression of the MRFs during muscle regeneration, we performed cardiotoxin injury-induced regeneration experiments on fast muscles of adult Xenopus laevis subjected to different experimental conditions, including denervation and T3 treatment, and analyzed the accumulation of the four myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) using RT-PCR and in situ hybridization. We show here that manipulation of hormone levels or innervation resulted in differential alterations of MRF expression. Denervation and T3 treatment transiently down-regulated Myf-5 mRNA levels at the beginning of the regeneration process. Myf-5 was the only myogenic factor subject to thyroid hormone influence. Muscle denervation persistently reduces the levels of MRF4 transcripts as early as the first stages of regeneration, whereas the levels of myogenin mRNA were increased in the late stages of regeneration. This suggests that MRF4 expression may be induced by innervation and hence may be involved in mediating transcriptional responses to innervation and that myogenin expression may compensate for the down-regulation of MRF4 gene. This switch in MRF gene expression following denervation could have important consequences for the ability of Xenopus regenerating muscles to recover function after denervation.