Circular dichroism and molecular modeling of the E. coli TolA periplasmic domains

Tunable force transduction through the Escherichia coli cell envelope

The outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria is not energised and so processes requiring a driving force must connect to energy-transduction systems in the inner membrane (IM). Tol (Tol-Pal) and Ton are related, proton motive force- (PMF-) coupled assemblies that stabilise the OM and import essential nutrients, respectively. Both rely on proton-harvesting IM motor (stator) complexes, which are homologues of the flagellar stator unit Mot, to transduce force to the OM through elongated IM force transducer proteins, TolA and TonB, respectively. How PMF-driven motors in the IM generate mechanical work at the OM via force transducers is unknown. Here, using cryoelectron microscopy, we report the 4.3Å structure of the Escherichia coli TolQR motor complex. The structure reaffirms the 5:2 stoichiometry seen in Ton and Mot and, with motor subunits related to each other by 10 to 16° rotation, supports rotary motion as the default for these complexes. We probed the mechanism of force transduction to the OM through in vivo assays of chimeric TolA/TonB proteins where sections of their structurally divergent, periplasm-spanning domains were swapped or replaced by an intrinsically disordered sequence. We find that TolA mutants exhibit a spectrum of force output, which is reflected in their respective abilities to both stabilise the OM and import cytotoxic colicins across the OM. Our studies demonstrate that structural rigidity of force transducer proteins, rather than any particular structural form, drives the efficient conversion of PMF-driven rotary motions of 5:2 motor complexes into physiologically relevant force at the OM.

Recruitment of the TolA protein to cell constriction sites in Escherichia coli via three separate mechanisms, and a critical role for FtsWI activity in recruitment of both TolA and TolQ

The Tol-Pal system of Gram-negative bacteria helps maintain integrity of the cell envelope and ensures that invagination of the envelope layers during cell fission occurs in a well-coordinated manner. In E. coli, the five Tol-Pal proteins (TolQ, R, A, B and Pal) accumulate at cell constriction sites in a manner that normally requires the activity of the cell constriction initiation protein FtsN. While septal recruitment of TolR, TolB and Pal also requires the presence of TolQ and/or TolA, each of the the latter two can recognize constriction sites independently of the other system proteins. What attracts TolQ or TolA to these sites is unclear. We show that FtsN attracts both proteins in an indirect fashion, and that PBP1A, PBP1B and CpoB are dispensable for their septal recruitment. However, the β-lactam aztreonam readily interferes with septal accumulation of both TolQ and TolA, indicating that FtsN-stimulated production of septal peptidoglycan by the FtsWI synthase is critical to their recruitment. We also discovered that each of TolA's three domains can recognize division sites in a separate fashion. Notably, the middle domain (TolAII) is responsible for directing TolA to constriction sites in the absence of other Tol-Pal proteins and CpoB, while recruitment of TolAI and TolAIII requires TolQ and a combination of TolB, Pal, and CpoB, respectively. Additionally, we describe the construction and use of functional fluorescent sandwich fusions of the ZipA division protein, which should be more broadly valuable in future studies of the E. coli cell division machinery. IMPORTANCE Cell division (cytokinesis) is a fundamental biological process that is incompletely understood for any organism. Division of bacterial cells relies on a ring-like machinery called the septal ring or divisome that assembles along the circumference of the mother cell at the site where constriction will eventually occur. In the well-studied bacterium Escherichia coli, this machinery contains over thirty distinct proteins. We studied how two such proteins, TolA and TolQ, which also play a role in maintaining integrity of the outer-membrane, are recruited to the machinery. We find that TolA can be recruited by three separate mechanisms, and that both proteins rely on the activity of a well-studied cell division enzyme for their recruitment.

The multifarious roles of Tol-Pal in Gram-negative bacteria

In the 1960s several groups reported the isolation and preliminary genetic mapping of Escherichia coli strains tolerant towards the action of colicins. These pioneering studies kick-started two new fields in bacteriology; one centred on how bacteriocins like colicins exploit the Tol (or more commonly Tol-Pal) system to kill bacteria, the other on the physiological role of this cell envelope-spanning assembly. The following half century has seen significant advances in the first of these fields whereas the second has remained elusive, until recently. Here, we review work that begins to shed light on Tol-Pal function in Gram-negative bacteria. What emerges from these studies is that Tol-Pal is an energised system with fundamental, interlinked roles in cell division – coordinating the re-structuring of peptidoglycan at division sites and stabilising the connection between the outer membrane and underlying cell wall. This latter role is achieved by Tol-Pal exploiting the proton motive force to catalyse the accumulation of the outer membrane peptidoglycan associated lipoprotein Pal at division sites while simultaneously mobilising Pal molecules from around the cell. These studies begin to explain the diverse phenotypic outcomes of tol-pal mutations, point to other cell envelope roles Tol-Pal may have and raise many new questions.

Antibacterial toxin colicin N and phage protein G3p compete with TolB for a binding site on TolA

Most colicins kill Escherichia coli cells by membrane pore formation or nuclease activity and, superficially, the mechanisms are similar: receptor binding, translocon recruitment, periplasmic receptor binding and membrane insertion. However, in detail, they employ a wide variety of molecular interactions that reveal a high degree of evolutionary diversification. Group A colicins bind to members of the TolQRAB complex in the periplasm and heterotrimeric complexes of colicin–TolA–TolB have been observed for both ColA and ColE9. ColN, the smallest and simplest pore-forming colicin, binds only to TolA and we show here that it uses the binding site normally used by TolB, effectively preventing formation of the larger complex used by other colicins. ColN binding to TolA was by β-strand addition with a K_D of 1 µM compared with 40 µM for the TolA–TolB interaction. The β-strand addition and ColN activity could be abolished by single proline point mutations in TolA, which each removed one backbone hydrogen bond. By also blocking TolA–TolB binding these point mutations conferred a complete tol phenotype which destabilized the outer membrane, prevented both ColA and ColE9 activity, and abolished phage protein binding to TolA. These are the only point mutations known to have such pleiotropic effects and showed that the TolA–TolB β-strand addition is essential for Tol function. The formation of this simple binary ColN–TolA complex provided yet more evidence of a distinct translocation route for ColN and may help to explain the unique toxicity of its N-terminal domain.

The physiology of bacterial cell division

Bacterial cell division is facilitated by the divisome, a dynamic multiprotein assembly localizing at mid-cell to synthesize the stress-bearing peptidoglycan and to constrict all cell envelope layers. Divisome assembly occurs in two steps and involves multiple interactions between more than 20 essential and accessory cell division proteins. Well before constriction and while the cell is still elongating, the tubulin-like FtsZ and early cell division proteins form a ring-like structure at mid-cell. Cell division starts once certain peptidoglycan enzymes and their activators have moved to the FtsZ-ring. Gram-negative bacteria like Escherichia coli simultaneously synthesize and cleave the septum peptidoglycan during division leading to a constriction. The outer membrane constricts together with the peptidoglycan layer with the help of the transenvelope spanning Tol-Pal system.

Energetics of colicin import revealed by genetic cross-complementation between the Tol and Ton systems

Colicins are bacterial toxins that parasitize OM (outer membrane) receptors to bind to the target cells, use an import system to translocate through the cell envelope and then kill sensitive cells. Colicins classified as group A (colicins A, E1–E9, K and N) use the Tol system (TolA, TolB, TolQ and TolR), whereas group B colicins (colicins B, D, Ia, M and 5) use the ExbB–ExbD–TonB system. Genetic evidence has suggested that TolQ and ExbB, as well as TolR and ExbD, are interchangeable, whereas this is not possible with TolA and TonB. Early reports indicated that group B colicin uptake requires energy input, whereas no energy was necessary for the uptake of the pore-forming colicin A. Furthermore, energy is required to dissociate the complex formed with colicin E9 and its cognate immunity protein during the import process. In the present paper, we detail the functional phenotypes and colicin-sensitivity results obtained in tolQ and exbB mutants and cross-complementation data of amino acid substitutions that lie within ExbB or TolQ TMHs (transmembrane helices). We also discuss on a specific phenotype that corresponds to group A colicin-sensitivity associated with a non-functional Tol system.

Colicin biology

Colicins are proteins produced by and toxic for some strains of Escherichia coli. They are produced by strains of E. coli carrying a colicinogenic plasmid that bears the genetic determinants for colicin synthesis, immunity, and release. Insights gained into each fundamental aspect of their biology are presented: their synthesis, which is under SOS regulation; their release into the extracellular medium, which involves the colicin lysis protein; and their uptake mechanisms and modes of action. Colicins are organized into three domains, each one involved in a different step of the process of killing sensitive bacteria. The structures of some colicins are known at the atomic level and are discussed. Colicins exert their lethal action by first binding to specific receptors, which are outer membrane proteins used for the entry of specific nutrients. They are then translocated through the outer membrane and transit through the periplasm by either the Tol or the TonB system. The components of each system are known, and their implication in the functioning of the system is described. Colicins then reach their lethal target and act either by forming a voltage-dependent channel into the inner membrane or by using their endonuclease activity on DNA, rRNA, or tRNA. The mechanisms of inhibition by specific and cognate immunity proteins are presented. Finally, the use of colicins as laboratory or biotechnological tools and their mode of evolution are discussed.

Tol-dependent macromolecule import through the Escherichia coli cell envelope requires the presence of an exposed TolA binding motif

The Tol-Pal proteins of the cell envelope of Escherichia coli are required for maintaining outer membrane integrity. This system forms protein complexes in which TolA plays a central role by providing a bridge between the inner and outer membranes via its interaction with the Pal lipoprotein. The Tol proteins are parasitized by filamentous bacteriophages and group A colicins. The N-terminal domain of the Ff phage g3p protein and the translocation domains of colicins interact directly with TolA during the processes of import through the cell envelope. Recently, a four-amino-acid sequence in Pal has been shown to be involved in Pal's interaction with TolA. A similar motif is also present in the sequence of two TolA partners, g3p and colicin A. Here, a mutational study was conducted to define the function of these motifs in the binding activity and import process of TolA. The various domains were produced and exported to the bacterial periplasm, and their cellular effects were analyzed. Cells producing the g3p domain were tolerant to colicins and filamentous phages and had destabilized outer membranes, while g3p deleted of three residues in the motif was affected in TolA binding and had no effect on cell integrity or colicin or phage import. A conserved Tyr residue in the colicin A translocation domain was involved in TolA binding and colicin A import. Furthermore, in vivo and in vitro coprecipitation analyses demonstrated that colicin A and g3p N-terminal domains compete for binding to TolA.

Tol-Pal proteins are critical cell envelope components of Erwinia chrysanthemi affecting cell morphology and virulence

The tol-pal genes are necessary for maintaining the outer-membrane integrity of Gram-negative bacteria. These genes were first described in Escherichia coli, and more recently in several other species. They are involved in the pathogenesis of E. coli, Haemophilus ducreyi, Vibrio cholerae and Salmonella enterica. The role of the tol-pal genes in bacterial pathogenesis was investigated in the phytopathogenic enterobacterium Erwinia chrysanthemi, assuming that this organism might be a good model for such a study. The whole Er. chrysanthemi tol-pal region was characterized. Tol-Pal proteins, except TolA, showed high identity scores with their E. coli homologues. Er. chrysanthemi mutants were constructed by introducing a uidA-kan cassette in the ybgC, tolQ, tolA, tolB, pal and ybgF genes. All the mutants were hypersensitive to bile salts. Mutations in tolQ, tolA, tolB and pal were deleterious for the bacteria, which required high concentrations of sugars or osmoprotectants for their viability. Consistent with this observation, they were greatly impaired in their cell morphology and division, which was evidenced by observations of cell filaments, spherical forms, membrane blebbing and mislocalized bacterial septa. Moreover, tol-pal mutants showed a reduced virulence in a potato tuber model and on chicory leaves. This could be explained by a combination of impaired phenotypes in the tol-pal mutants, such as reduced growth and motility and a decreased production of pectate lyases, the major virulence factor of Er. chrysanthemi.

Deletion analyses of the peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein Pal reveals three independent binding sequences including a TolA box

The Tol-Pal system of the Escherichia coli cell envelope is composed of five proteins. TolQ, TolR and TolA form a complex in the inner membrane, whereas TolB is a periplasmic protein interacting with Pal, the peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein anchored to the outer membrane. This system is required for outer membrane integrity and has been shown to form a trans-envelope bridge linking inner and outer membranes. The TolA-Pal interaction plays an important role in the function of this system and has been found to depend on the proton motive force and the TolQ and TolR proteins. The Pal lipoprotein interacts with many components, such as TolA, TolB, OmpA, the major lipoprotein and the murein layer. In this study, six pal deletions were constructed. The analyses of the resulting Pal protein functions and interactions defined an N-terminal region of 40 residues, which can be deleted without any cell-damaging effect, and three independent regions required for its interaction with TolA, OmpA and TolB or the peptidoglycan. The analyses of the integrity of the cells producing the various Pal lipoproteins revealed strong outer membrane destabilization only when binding regions were deleted. Furthermore, a conserved polypeptide sequence located downstream of the peptidoglycan binding motif of Pal was required for the TolA-Pal interaction and for the maintenance of outer membrane stability.

Structure of the periplasmic domain of Pseudomonas aeruginosa TolA: evidence for an evolutionary relationship with the TonB transporter protein

The crystal structure of the C-terminal domain III of Pseudomonas aeruginosa TolA has been determined at 1.9 A resolution. The fold is similar to that of the corresponding domain of Escherichia coli TolA, despite the limited amino acid sequence identity of the two proteins (20%). A pattern was discerned that conserves the fold of domain III within the wider TolA family and, moreover, reveals a relationship between TolA domain III and the C-terminal domain of the TonB transporter proteins. We propose that the TolA and TonB C-terminal domains have a common evolutionary origin and are related by means of domain swapping, with interesting mechanistic implications. We have also determined the overall shape of the didomain, domains II + III, of P.aeruginosa TolA by solution X-ray scattering. The molecule is monomeric-its elongated, stalk shape can accommodate the crystal structure of domain III at one end, and an elongated helical bundle within the portion corresponding to domain II. Based on these data, a model for the periplasmic domains of P.aeruginosa TolA is presented that may explain the inferred allosteric properties of members of the TolA family. The mechanisms of TolA-mediated entry of bateriophages in P.aeruginosa and E.coli are likely to be similar.

The Tol proteins of Escherichia coli and their involvement in the translocation of group A colicins

The Tol proteins are involved in outer membrane stability of Gram-negative bacteria. The TolQRA proteins form a complex in the inner membrane while TolB and Pal interact near the outer membrane. These two complexes are transiently connected by an energy-dependent interaction between Pal and TolA. The Tol proteins have been parasitized by group A colicins for their translocation through the cell envelope. Recent advances in the structure and energetics of the Tol system, as well as the interactions between the N-terminal translocation domain of colicins and the Tol proteins are presented.

The Tol/Pal system function requires an interaction between the C-terminal domain of TolA and the N-terminal domain of TolB

The Tol/Pal system of Escherichia coli is composed of the YbgC, TolQ, TolA, TolR, TolB, Pal and YbgF proteins. It is involved in maintaining the integrity of the outer membrane, and is required for the uptake of group A colicins and DNA of filamentous bacteriophages. To identify new interactions between the components of the Tol/Pal system and gain insight into the mechanism of colicin import, we performed a yeast two-hybrid screen using the different components of the Tol/Pal system and colicin A. Using this system, we confirmed the already known interactions and identified several new interactions. TolB dimerizes and the periplasmic domain of TolA interacts with YbgF and TolB. Our results indicate that the central domain of TolA (TolAII) is sufficient to interact with YbgF, that the C-terminal domain of TolA (TolAIII) is sufficient to interact with TolB, and that the amino terminal domain of TolB (D1) is sufficient to bind TolAIII. The TolA/TolB interaction was confirmed by cross-linking experiments on purified proteins. Moreover, we show that the interaction between TolA and TolB is required for the uptake of colicin A and for the membrane integrity. These results demonstrate that the TolA/TolB interaction allows the formation of a trans-envelope complex that brings the inner and outer membranes in close proximity.

Pore-forming colicins and their relatives

The pore-forming colicins, the first proteins that were capable of forming voltage-dependent ion channels to be sequenced, have turned out to be both less tractable and more mysterious than imagined; yet they have proved interesting at every step of their short journey from producing cell to vanquished target cell. Starting out as a remarkably extended water-soluble protein, the colicin molecule is designed to interact simultaneously with several components of the complex membrane of the target cell, transform itself into a membrane protein, and become an ion channel with inscrutable properties. Unraveling how it does all this appears to be leading us into the dark recesses of protein/protein and protein/membrane interaction, where lurk fundamental processes reluctantly waiting to be revealed.

Energy-dependent conformational change in the TolA protein of Escherichia coli involves its N-terminal domain, TolQ, and TolR

TolQ, TolR, and TolA inner membrane proteins of Escherichia coli are involved in maintaining the stability of the outer membrane. They share homology with the ExbB, ExbD, and TonB proteins, respectively. The last is involved in energy transduction between the inner and the outer membrane, and its conformation has been shown to depend on the presence of the proton motive force (PMF), ExbB, and ExbD. Using limited proteolysis experiments, we investigated whether the conformation of TolA was also affected by the PMF. We found that dissipation of the PMF by uncouplers led to the formation of a proteinase K digestion fragment of TolA not seen when uncouplers are omitted. This fragment was also detected in Delta tolQ, Delta tolR, and tolA(H22P) mutants but, in contrast to the parental strain, was also seen in the absence of uncouplers. We repeated those experiments in outer membrane mutants such as lpp, pal, and Delta rfa mutants: the behavior of TolA in lpp mutants was similar to that observed with the parental strain. However, the proteinase K-resistant fragment was never detected in the Delta rfa mutant. Altogether, these results suggest that TolA is able to undergo a PMF-dependent change of conformation. This change requires TolQ, TolR, and a functional TolA N-terminal domain. The potential role of this energy-dependent process in the stability of the outer membrane is discussed.

Characterization of in vitro interactions between a truncated TonB protein from Escherichia coli and the outer membrane receptors FhuA and FepA

High-affinity iron uptake in gram-negative bacteria depends upon TonB, a protein which couples the proton motive force in the cytoplasmic membrane to iron chelate receptors in the outer membrane. To advance studies on TonB structure and function, we expressed a recombinant form of Escherichia coli TonB lacking the N-terminal cytoplasmic membrane anchor. This protein (H(6)-'TonB; M(r), 24,880) was isolated in a soluble fraction of lysed cells and was purified by virtue of a hexahistidine tag located at its N terminus. Sedimentation experiments indicated that the H(6)-'TonB preparation was almost monodisperse and the protein was essentially monomeric. The value found for the Stokes radius (3.8 nm) is in good agreement with the value calculated by size exclusion chromatography. The frictional ratio (2.0) suggested that H(6)-'TonB adopts a highly asymmetrical form with an axial ratio of 15. H(6)-'TonB captured both the ferrichrome-iron receptor FhuA and the ferric enterobactin receptor FepA from detergent-solubilized outer membranes in vitro. Capture was enhanced by preincubation of the receptors with their cognate ligands. Cross-linking assays with the purified proteins in vitro demonstrated that there was preferential interaction between TonB and ligand-loaded FhuA. Purified H(6)-'TonB was found to be stable and thus shows promise for high-resolution structural studies.

The TolA-recognition site of colicin N. ITC, SPR and stopped-flow fluorescence define a crucial 27-residue segment

Colicins translocate across the Escherichia coli outer membrane and periplasm by interacting with several receptors. After first binding to the outer membrane surface receptors via their central region, they interact with TolA or TonB proteins via their N-terminal region. Colicin N residues critical to TolA binding have been discovered, but the full extent of any colicin TolA site is unknown. We present, for the first time, a fully mapped TolA binding site for a colicin. It was determined through the use of alanine-scanning mutants, glutathione S-transferase fusion peptides and Biacore/fluorescence binding studies. The minimal TolA binding region is 27 residues and of similar size to the TolA binding region of bacteriophage g3p-D1 protein. Stopped-flow kinetic studies show that the binding to TolA follows slow association kinetics. The role of other E. coli Tol proteins in colicin translocation was also investigated. Isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) and in vivo studies conclusively show that colicin N translocation does not require the presence of TolB. ITC also demonstrated colicin A interaction with TolB, and that colicin A in its native state does not interact with TolAII-III. Colicin N does not bind TolR-II. The TolA protein is shown to be unsuitable for direct immobilisation in Biacore analysis.