Recent advances in the chemistry of isolable carbene analogues with group 13-15 elements

Carbenes (R2C:), compounds with a divalent carbon atom containing only six valence shell electrons, have evolved into a broader class with the replacement of the carbene carbon or the RC moiety with main group elements, leading to the creation of main group carbene analogues. These analogues, mirroring the electronic structure of carbenes (a lone pair of electrons and an empty orbital), demonstrate unique reactivity. Over the last three decades, this area has seen substantial advancements, paralleling the innovations in carbene chemistry. Recent studies have revealed a spectrum of unique carbene analogues, such as monocoordinate aluminylenes, nitrenes, and bismuthinidenes, notable for their extraordinary properties and diverse reactivity, offering promising applications in small molecule activation. This review delves into the isolable main group carbene analogues that are in the forefront from 2010 and beyond, spanning elements from group 13 (B, Al, Ga, In, and Tl), group 14 (Si, Ge, Sn, and Pb) and group 15 (N, P, As, Sb, and Bi). Specifically, this review focuses on the potential amphiphilic species that possess both lone pairs of electrons and vacant orbitals. We detail their comprehensive synthesis and stabilization strategies, outlining the reactivity arising from their distinct structural characteristics.

Phosphinidenes: Fundamental Properties and Reactivity

Phosphinidenes are heavy congeners of nitrenes that have been broadly used as in situ reagents in synthetic phosphorus chemistry and also serve as versatile ligands in coordination with transition metals. However, the detection of free phosphinidenes is largely challenged by their high reactivity and also the lack of suitable synthetic methods, rendering the knowledge about the fundamental properties of this class of low-valent phosphorus compounds limited. Recently, an increasing number of free phosphinidenes bearing prototype structural and bonding properties have been prepared for the first time, thus enabling the exploration of their distinct reactivity from the nitrene analogues. This Concept article will discuss the experimental approaches for the generation of the highly unstable phosphinidenes and highlight their distinct reactivity from the nitrogen analogues so as to stimuate future studies about their potential applications in phosphorus chemistry.

Carbene chemistry of arsenic, antimony, and bismuth: origin, evolution and future prospects

The discovery of the first isolable N-heterocyclic carbene in 1991 ushered in a new era in coordination chemistry. The remarkable bonding properties of carbenes have led to their rapid proliferation as auxiliary ligands for a wide range of transition metals and main group elements. In the case of group 15, while carbene-stabilized nitrogen and phosphorus compounds are extensively studied, the scope of research has shrunk significantly from arsenic to bismuth. This is essentially attributed to the decrease in stability of the C-E bond upon descending the group. Even so, modulating the carbene backbone or introducing alternative synthetic strategies not only alleviates the stability issues but also offers promising results in terms of the bonding and reactivities of these compounds. The purpose of the present perspective is to provide a comprehensive overview of the origins and development of carbene chemistry of arsenic, antimony, and bismuth, as well as to highlight the future prospects of this field.

Switching from Heteronuclear Allyl Cations to Vinyl Cations by Using a Chemical Charge Trap

Halide abstraction of the carbene-coordinated pnictinidenes (^MecAAC)EGa(Cl)L (E = As 1, Sb 2, Bi 3, ^MecAAC = [H₂C(CMe₂)₂NDipp]C; L = HC[C(Me)NDipp]₂; Dipp = 2,6-i-Pr₂C₆H₃) yielded the series of cationic group 15 compounds [(^MecAAC)EGaL][Al(OR^F)₄] (E = As 4, Sb 5; Al(OR^F)₄ = Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄) and [(^MecAAC)EGaL][B(Ar^F)₄] (E = Sb 6, Bi 7; B(Ar^F)₄ = B[C₆H₃(CF₃)₂]₄), which were characterized by heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy and sc-XRD. The electronic nature of the cations [(^MecAAC)EGaL]⁺ is controlled by the central pnictogen atom, according to quantum chemical calculations. The calculations furthermore demonstrated that compounds containing the lighter pnictogens (E = N, P) are best described as heteronuclear allyl cations, whereas heavier pnictogen atoms (E = As, Sb, Bi) serve as a trap for the positive charge, resulting in carbene-stabilized heterovinyl-type structures.

Group 15 and 16 Nitrene-Like Pnictinidenes

Pnictinidenes are an increasingly relevant species in main group chemistry and generally exhibit proclivity for the triplet electronic ground state. However, the elusive singlet electronic states are often desired for chemical applications. We predict the singlet-triplet energy differences (ΔE_ST =E_Singlet -E_Triplet ) of simple group 15 and 16 substituted pnictinidenes (Pn-R; Pn=P, As, Sb, or Bi) with highly reliable focal-point analyses targeting the CCSDTQ/CBS level of theory. The only cases we predict to have favorable singlet states are P-PH₂ (-3.2 kcal mol^-1 ) and P-NH₂ (-0.2 kcal mol^-1 ). ΔE_ST trends are discussed in light of the geometric predictions as well as qualitative natural bond order analysis to elucidate some of the important electronic structure features. Our work provides a rigorous benchmark for the ΔE_ST of fundamental Pn-R moieties and provides a firm foundation for the continued study of heavier pnictinidenes.

Phosphine-Stabilized Pnictinidenes

The reaction of the intramolecular germylene‐phosphine Lewis pair (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄GeAr* (1) with Group 15 element trichlorides ECl₃ (E=P, As, Sb) was investigated. After oxidative addition, the resulting compounds (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)Ge(Cl)ECl₂ (2: E=P, 3: E=As, 4: E=Sb) were reduced by using sodium metal or LiHBEt₃. The molecular structures of the phosphine‐stabilized phosphinidene (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)Ge(Cl)P (5), arsinidene (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)Ge(Cl)As (6) and stibinidene (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)Ge(Cl)Sb (7) are presented; they feature a two‐coordinate low‐valent Group 15 element. After chloride abstraction, a cyclic germaphosphene [(o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)GeP] [B(C₆H₃(CF₃)₂)₄] (8) was isolated. The ³¹P NMR data of the germaphosphene were compared with literature examples and analyzed by quantum chemical calculations. The phosphinidene was treated with [iBu₂AlH]₂, and the product of an Al−H addition to the low‐valent phosphorus atom (o‐PPh₂)C₆H₄(Ar*)Ge(H)P(H)Al(C₄H₉)₂ (9) was characterized.

Phosphorus and Arsenic Atom Transfer to Isocyanides to Form π-Backbonding Cyanophosphide and Cyanoarsenide Titanium Complexes

Decarbonylation along with E atom transfer from Na(OCE) (E=P, As) to an isocyanide coordinated to the tetrahedral Ti^II complex [(Tp^tBu,Me )TiCl], yielded the [(Tp^tBu,Me )Ti(η³ -ECNAd)] species (Ad=1-adamantyl, Tp^tBu,Me- =hydrotris(3-tert-butyl-5-methylpyrazol-1-yl)borate). In the case of E=P, the cyanophosphide ligand displays nucleophilic reactivity toward Al(CH₃ )₃ ; moreover, its bent geometry hints to a reduced Ad-NCP^3- resonance contributor. The analogous and rarer mono-substituted cyanoarsenide ligand, Ad-NCAs^3- , shows the same unprecedented coordination mode but with shortening of the N=C bond. As opposed to Ti^II , V^II fails to promote P atom transfer to AdNC, yielding instead [(Tp^tBu,Me )V(OCP)(CNAd)]. Theoretical studies revealed the rare ECNAd moieties to be stabilized by π-backbonding interactions with the former Ti^II ion, and their assembly to most likely involve a concerted E atom transfer between Ti-bound OCE^- to AdNC ligands when studying the reaction coordinate for E=P.

Carbodicarbene Bismaalkene Cations: Unravelling the Complexities of Carbene versus Carbone in Heavy Pnictogen Chemistry

We report a combined experimental and theoretical study on the first examples of carbodicarbene (CDC)-stabilized bismuth complexes, which feature low-coordinate cationic bismuth centers with C=Bi multiple-bond character. Monocations [(CDC)Bi(Ph)Cl][SbF6 ] (8) and [(CDC)BiBr2 (THF)2 ][SbF6 ] (11), dications [(CDC)Bi(Ph)][SbF6 ]2 (9) and [(CDC)BiBr(THF)3 ][NTf2 ]2 (12), and trication [(CDC)2 Bi][NTf2 ]3 (13) have been synthesized via sequential halide abstractions from (CDC)Bi(Ph)Cl2 (7) and (CDC)BiBr3 (10). Notably, the dications and trication exhibit C ⇉ Bi double dative bonds and thus represent unprecedented bismaalkene cations. The synthesis of these species highlights a unique non-reductive route to C-Bi π-bonding character. The CDC-[Bi] complexes (7-13) were compared with related NHC-[Bi] complexes (1, 3-6) and show substantially different structural properties. Indeed, the CDC ligand has a remarkable influence on the overall stability of the resulting low-coordinate Bi complexes, suggesting that CDC is a superior ligand to NHC in heavy pnictogen chemistry.

From π-Bonded Gallapnictenes to Nucleophilic, Redox-Active Metal-Coordinated Pnictanides

A comprehensive reactivity study of gallapnictenes LGaEGa(Cl)L (E=As, Sb; L=HC[C(Me)N(Ar)]2 , Ar=Dip=2,6-i-Pr2 C6 H3 ) proved the nucleophilic character of the pnictogen and the electrophilic nature of the Ga atom. Reactions of LGaEGa(Cl)L with imidazolium chloride [IPrH][Cl] yielded {[LGa(Cl)]2 E- }{IPrH+ } (E=As 1, Sb 2), and those with HCl and MeI gave pnictanes [LGa(Cl)]2 EH (E=As 5, Sb 6) and L(I)GaE(Me)Ga(Cl)L (E=As 7, Sb 8). Pnictanides 1 and 2 also react with [H(OEt2 )2 ][BArF 4 ] (BArF 4 =B(C6 F5 )4 ) to 5 and 6, while reactions with MeI yielded [LGa(Cl)]2 EMe (E=As 9, Sb 10). Single electron oxidation reactions of pnictanides 1 and 2 gave the corresponding radicals [LGa(Cl)]2 E. (E=As, Sb).

Isolation of Carbene-Stabilized Arsenic Monophosphide [AsP] and its Radical Cation [AsP]+. and Dication [AsP]2

Arsenic monophosphide (AsP) species supported by two different N‐heterocyclic carbenes were prepared by reaction of (IDipp)PSiMe₃ (1) (IDipp=1,3‐bis(2,6‐diisopropylphenyl)imidazolin‐2‐ylidene) with (IMes)AsCl₃ (2) (IMes=1,3‐bis(2,4,6‐trimethylphenyl)imidazolin‐2‐ylidene) to afford the dichloride [(IMes)As(Cl)P(IDipp)]Cl (3), which upon reduction with KC₈ furnished heteroleptic [(IMes)AsP(IDipp)] (4). The corresponding mono‐ and dications [(IMes)AsP(IDipp)][PF₆], [5]PF₆, and [(IMes)AsP(IDipp)][GaCl₄]_2, [6][GaCl₄]₂, respectively, were prepared by one‐electron oxidation of 4 with ferrocenium hexafluorophosphate, [Fc]PF_6, or by chloride abstraction from 3 with two equivalents of GaCl₃, respectively. Compounds 4–6 represent rare examples of heterodiatiomic interpnictogen compounds, and X‐ray crystal structure determinations together with density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal a consecutive shortening of the As−P bond lengths and increasing bond order, in agreement with the presence of an arsenic–phosphorus single bond in 4 and a double bond in 6²⁺. The EPR signal of the cationic radical [5]^+. indicates a symmetric spin distribution on the AsP moiety through strong hyperfine coupling with the ⁷⁵As and ³¹P nuclei.

Antimony(i) → Pd(ii) complexes with the (μ-Sb)Pd2 coordination framework

The reaction of the antimony(i) compound ArSb (1) (where Ar = C₆H₃-2,6-(CH[double bond, length as m-dash]NtBu)₂) with various dimeric allyl palladium(ii) complexes [Pd(η³-allyl)(μ-X)]₂ (where allyl = C₃H₅ or C₃H₄Me; X = Cl or CF₃CO₂) in a 1 : 1 stoichiometric ratio gave unique complexes with the μ-ArSb moiety bridging two palladium fragments, i.e. [{Pd(η³-C₃H₅)Cl}₂(μ-ArSb)] (2), [{Pd(η³-C₃H₄Me)Cl}₂(μ-ArSb)] (3) and [{Pd(η³-C₃H₅)(CF₃CO₂)}₂(μ-ArSb)] (4). Compound 1 serves formally as a 4e donor in 2-4. The treatment of 2 with another equivalent of ArSb led to the formation of the [Pd(η³-C₃H₅)(Cl)(μ-ArSb)] complex (5), proving that 1 is able to function as a 2e donor in target complexes as well. The structures of 2-5 were described in detail both in solution (NMR and mass spectrometry) and in the solid state (single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis). DFT methods were used to compare bonding in the 1 : 1 (5) and 1 : 2 (2) complexes. Furthermore, a comprehensive ¹²¹Sb Mössbauer spectroscopic investigation of complexes 2 and 5 along with parent ArSbCl₂ (6) and 1 was performed. For comparison, complexes [Fe(CO)₄(ArSb)] (7) and [Mo(CO)₅(ArSb)] (8) were also included in this study.

The Chemistry of Yellow Arsenic

The generation and handling of the light-sensitive and metastable yellow arsenic (As₄) is extremely challenging. In view of recent breakthroughs in synthesizing As₄ storage materials and transfer reagents, the more intensive use of yellow arsenic as a source for further reactions can be expected. Given these aspects, the current stage of knowledge of the direct use of As₄ is comprehensively summarized in the present review, which lists the activation of As₄ by main group elements as well as transition metal compounds (including the f-block elements). Moreover, it also partly compares the reaction outcomes in relation to the corresponding reactions of P₄. The possibility of using alternative sources for generating arsenic moieties and compounds is also discussed. The release of As₄ molecules from precursor compounds and the use of transfer reagents for polyarsenic entities open up new synthetic pathways to avoid the direct generation of yellow arsenic solutions and to ensure its smooth usage for subsequent reactions.

Cyaarside (CAs- ) and 1,3-Diarsaallendiide (AsCAs2- ) Ligands Coordinated to Uranium and Generated via Activation of the Arsaethynolate Ligand (OCAs- )

Reaction of the trivalent uranium complex [((^Ad,Me ArO)₃ N)U(DME)] with one molar equiv [Na(OCAs)(dioxane)₃ ], in the presence of 2.2.2-crypt, yields [Na(2.2.2-crypt)][{((^Ad,Me ArO)₃ N)U^IV (THF)}(μ-O){((^Ad,Me ArO)₃ N)U^IV (CAs)}] (1), the first example of a coordinated η¹ -cyaarside ligand (CAs^- ). Formation of the terminal CAs^- is promoted by the highly reducing, oxophilic U^III precursor [((^Ad,Me ArO)₃ N)U(DME)] and proceeds through reductive C-O bond cleavage of the bound arsaethynolate anion, OCAs^- . If two equiv of OCAs^- react with the U^III precursor, the binuclear, μ-oxo-bridged U₂ ^IV/IV complex [Na(2.2.2-crypt)]₂ [{((^Ad,Me ArO)₃ N)U^IV }₂ (μ-O)(μ-AsCAs)] (2), comprising the hitherto unknown μ:η¹ ,η¹ -coordinated (AsCAs)^2- ligand, is isolated. The mechanistic pathway to 2 involves the decarbonylation of a dimeric intermediate formed in the reaction of 1 with OCAs^- . An alternative pathway to complex 2 is by conversion of 1 via addition of one further equiv of OCAs^- .

Electrophilic terminal arsinidene-iron(0) complexes with a two-coordinated arsenic atom

The electrophilic arsinidene complexes 5 and 6 featuring a two-coordinated arsenic atom have been isolated as crystalline solids. Complex 5 readily reacts with an NHC nucleophile (IMe₄) to give the Lewis adduct 7.

The Dawn of Functional Organoarsenic Chemistry

Organoarsenic chemistry was actively studied until the middle of 20th century. Although various properties of organoarsenic compounds have been computationally predicted, for example, frontier orbital levels, aromaticity, and inversion energies, serious concern to the danger of their synthetic processes has restricted experimental studies. Conventional synthetic routes require volatile and toxic arsenic precursors. Recently, nonvolatile intermediate transformation (NIT) methods have been developed to safely access functional organoarsenic compounds. Important intermediates in the NIT methods are cyclooligoarsines, which are prepared from nonvolatile inorganic precursors. In particular, the new approach has realized experimental studies on conjugated arsenic compounds: arsole derivatives. The elucidation of their intrinsic properties has triggered studies on functional organoarsenic chemistry. As a result, various kinds of arsenic-containing π-conjugated molecules and polymers have been reported for the last few years. In this minireview, progress of this recently invigorated field is overviewed.