Quantitative relationships between motoneuron and muscle development in Xenopus laevis: implications for motoneuron cell death and motor unit formation

Growth at Cold Temperature Increases the Number of Motor Neurons to Optimize Locomotor Function

During vertebrate development, spinal neurons differentiate and connect to generate a system that performs sensorimotor functions critical for survival. Spontaneous Ca²⁺ activity regulates different aspects of spinal neuron differentiation. It is unclear whether environmental factors can modulate this Ca²⁺ activity in developing spinal neurons to alter their specialization and ultimately adjust sensorimotor behavior to fit the environment. Here, we show that growing Xenopus laevis embryos at cold temperatures results in an increase in the number of spinal motor neurons in larvae. This change in spinal cord development optimizes the escape response to gentle touch of animals raised in and tested at cold temperatures. The cold-sensitive channel TRPM8 increases Ca²⁺ spike frequency of developing ventral spinal neurons, which in turn regulates expression of the motor neuron master transcription factor HB9. TRPM8 is necessary for the increase in motor neuron number of animals raised in cold temperatures and for their enhanced sensorimotor behavior when tested at cold temperatures. These findings suggest the environment modulates neuronal differentiation to optimize the behavior of the developing organism.

Spencer et al. discover that Xenopus larvae reared in cold temperature are better equipped to escape upon touch at cold temperature relative to warm-grown siblings. This advantage is dependent on the cold-sensitive channel TRPM8, which is necessary for increased Ca²⁺ spike frequency in embryonic spinal neurons, their differentiation, and survival.

ADAPTIVE ROLES OF PROGRAMMED CELL DEATH DURING NERVOUS SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT

The programmed cell death (PCD) of developing cells is considered an essential adaptive process that evolved to serve diverse roles. We review the putative adaptive functions of PCD in the animal kingdom with a major focus on PCD in the developing nervous system. Considerable evidence is consistent with the role of PCD in events ranging from neurulation and synaptogenesis to the elimination of adult-generated CNS cells. The remarkable recent progress in our understanding of the genetic regulation of PCD has made it possible to perturb (inhibit) PCD and determine the possible repercussions for nervous system development and function. Although still in their infancy, these studies have so far revealed few striking behavioral or functional phenotypes.

Relevance of motoneuron specification and programmed cell death in embryos to therapy of ALS

The molecular cues that generate spinal motoneurons in early embryonic development are well defined. Motoneurons are generated in excess and consequently undergo a natural period of programmed cell death. Although it is not known exactly how motoneurons compete for survival in embryonic development, it is hypothesized that they rely on the ability to access limited amounts of trophic factors from peripheral tissues, a process that is tightly regulated by skeletal muscle activity. Attempts to elucidate the molecular mechanisms that underlie motoneuron generation and programmed cell death in embryos have led to various effective strategies for treating injury and disease in animal models. Such studies provide great hope for the amelioration of human amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), a devastating progressive motoneuron degenerative disease. Here we review the clinical relevance of studying motoneuron specification and death during embryonic development.

Influences of IGF-I gene disruption on the cellular profile of the diaphragm

The impact of a targeted disruption of the Igf1 gene, encoding the insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I), on diaphragm (DIA) cellularity was studied in 2-mo-old homozygous mutant [IGF-I(-/-)] mice and their wild-type [WT; i.e., IGF-I(+/+)] littermates. DIA fiber types were classified histochemically. DIA fiber cross-sectional areas (CSA) were determined from digitized muscle sections, and fiber succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) activity was determined histochemically using a microdensitometric procedure. An acidic ATPase reaction was used to visualize capillaries. Myosin heavy chain (MyHC) isoforms were identified by SDS-PAGE, and their proportions were determined by scanning densitometry. The body weight of IGF-I(-/-) animals was 32% that of WT littermates. DIA fiber type proportions were unchanged between the groups. The CSAs of types I, IIa, and IIx DIA fibers of IGF-I(-/-) mutants were 63, 68, and 65%, respectively, those of WT animals (P < 0.001). The DIA thickness and the number of fibers spanning its entire thickness were reduced by 36 and 25%, respectively, in IGF-I(-/-) mice (P < 0. 001). SDH activity was significantly increased in all three types of DIA fibers of IGF-I(-/-) mutants (P < 0.05). The number of capillaries per fiber was reduced approximately 30% in IGF-I(-/-) animals, whereas the capillary density was preserved. The proportions of MyHC isoforms were similar between the groups. Muscle hypoplasia likely reflects the importance of IGF-I on cell proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis (alone or in combination) during development, although reduced cell size highlights the importance of IGF-I on rate and/or maintenance of DIA fiber growth in the postnatal state. Reduced capillarity may result from both direct and indirect influences on angiogenesis. Improved oxidative capacity likely reflects DIA compensatory mechanisms in IGF-I(-/-) mutants.

Extensive motor neuron survival in the absence of secondary skeletal muscle fiber formation

Mice with a null mutation in the myogenic basic helixloop-helix regulatory gene myogenin have severe developmental muscle defects resulting in loss of secondary muscle fibers and perinatal death. In this study, we used the myogenin mutant mouse as a model to study the effects of the loss of secondary muscle fibers and the contribution of primary muscle fibers on the survival of motor neurons during programmed cell death. We demonstrate that in the absence of secondary skeletal muscle fibers there is complete survival of facial motor nucleus motor neurons and approximately 60% survival of spinal lumbar motor neurons in the myogenin mutant mouse. The surviving spinal motor neurons maintain axonal projections into the hindlimb and display aspects of synaptic contact into the remaining rudimentary fibers. These findings suggest that primary muscle fibers, representing approximately 10% of normal muscle mass, contribute significantly to the control of motor neuron cell survival in mammals.

Sixth Annual Stuart Reiner Memorial Lecture: embryonic development of nerve and muscle

This article provides a basic scheme of sequential anatomic and some physiologic events occurring during the course of embryonic development of motor neurons and muscles, leading to the establishment of mature nerve-muscle relationships. Motor neurons and muscles begin their development independently and during embryogenesis they become dependent on each other for further development and survival. Aspects of development which occur independently and those requiring mutual interactions are identified. The development of motor neurons is discussed with respect to their production, projection, neuromuscular transmission, myelination, sprouting, survival, and death. The development of muscles is discussed with respect to the origin, differentiation, and muscle fiber types. Discussion on the development of neuromuscular junction includes differentiation of presynaptic nerve terminal, postsynaptic components, and elimination of multiple axons.

The role of target size in neuronal survival

A loss of about half of the trochlear motor neurons occurs during the course of normal development in duck and quail embryos. The role of the size of the target muscle in controlling the number of surviving motor neurons was examined by making motor neurons innervate targets either larger or smaller in size than their normal target. In one experiment the smaller trochlear motor neuron pool of the quail embryo was forced to innervate the larger superior oblique muscle of the duck embryo. This was accomplished by grafting the midbrain of a quail embryo in the place of the midbrain of a duck embryo. Results indicated that no additional quail trochlear motor neurons were rescued in spite of a considerable increase in target size. In another experiment the larger trochlear motor neuron pool of the duck embryo was made to innervate the smaller superior oblique muscle of the quail embryo. This resulted in loss of some additional neurons; however, the number of surviving motor neurons was not proportionate to the reduction in target size. These experiments failed to provide support for the hypothesis that the size of the target muscle controls the number of surviving motor neurons. Although contact with target is necessary for survival of neurons, factors other than the number or size of target cells are involved in the control of motor neuron numbers during development.

Lumbar lateral motor columns and hindlimbs of two Xenopus laevis chromosome mosaics

Two chromosome mosaic Xenopus laevis, one tadpole and one metamorphic animal, both with different sizes of neurons on the left and right sides of their brains and spinal cords, have left and right lumbar lateral motor columns (L-LMCs) of equal lengths but composed of strikingly different numbers of motoneurons (40% fewer motoneurons on the side composed of larger cells). One portion of the lumbar cord in the metamorphic animal is bilaterally symmetrical; the cells on both sides are small and the numbers of motoneurons per section are the same. The mosaics demonstrate that column length and motoneuron density (number per section) are, or can be, regulated bilaterally and that changing cell size affects factors controlling cell density but not column length. Except for the peripheral nerves, there is no evidence of any side-to-side differences in the hindlimb tissues. Whether the side-to-side difference in L-LMC motoneuron number in the stage 66 mosaic corresponds to any feature of the hindlimbs is unknown, but similar side-to-side differences in an early and a late stage mosaic animal support the idea that whatever creates the initial number may also determine the final number of motoneurons.

E and F alpha series prostaglandins in developing muscles

Prostaglandins are known to affect myoblast proliferation and fusion in vitro and are putative regulators of in vivo myogenesis. The levels of E and F alpha series prostaglandins in the thigh muscles of chicken embryos were measured by radioimmunoassays and correlated with indicators of muscle development. Just prior to the onset of secondary myogenesis, the amounts of PGE1, PGE2 and PGF1 alpha plus PGF2 alpha per mg of protein were high. In temporal association with myotube formation, the amount of PGE1 and PGE2 per mg of protein decreased. PGF alpha levels also fell, but at a slower rate than observed with the E series prostaglandins. The decreases in the amounts of prostaglandins per mg protein appeared to be due to a decline in the total amount of prostaglandin within each muscle. These observations are consistent with prostaglandins being one of the factors that controls in vivo muscle formation.

Influence of grafting a smaller target muscle on the magnitude of naturally occurring trochlear motor neuron death during development

About half of the motor neurons produced by some neural centers die during the course of normal development. It is thought that the size of the target muscle determines the number of surviving motor neurons. Previously, we tested the role of target size in limiting the number of survivors by forcing neurons to innervate a larger target (Sohal et al., '86). Results did not support the size-matching hypothesis because quail trochlear motor neurons innervating duck superior oblique muscle were not rescued. We have now performed the opposite experiment, i.e., forcing neurons to innervate a smaller target. By substituting the embryonic forebrain region of the duck with the same region of the quail before cell death begins, chimera embryos were produced that had a smaller quail superior oblique muscle successfully innervated by the trochlear motor neurons of the duck. The number of surviving trochlear motor neurons in chimeras was significantly higher than in the normal quail but less than in the normal duck. The smaller target resulted in some additional loss of neurons, suggesting that the target size may regulate neuron survival to a limited extent. Failure to achieve neuron loss corresponding to the reduction in target size suggests that there must be other factors that regulate neuron numbers during development.

Motoneuron and muscle fibre counts in normal and bilaterally innervated Xenopus hindlimbs

Motoneurons of the Lumbar Lateral Motor Column (LMC) and muscle fibres of gastrocnemius and tibialis anterior were counted in juvenile Xenopus frogs, including normal animals and those reared with a single bilaterally innervated hindlimb (monopodal frogs). In many monopodal frogs, the single hind limb becomes hyperinnervated by a large number of motoneurons on the contralateral side in addition to the normal ipsilateral number, even after the completion of cell death. In frogs with hyper-innervated limbs, muscle fibre number was evaluated beyond that expected for a normal population, but this increase was not commensurate with the quantity of extra innervation. When taken together with previous findings which showed that the supporting capacity of individual fibres was not elevated, the conclusion is that the ability of the single limb to support extra motoneurons cannot be completely explained by a commensurate increased proliferation of muscle fibres resulting from the operation or the bilateral innervation. The results give further evidence against the hypothesis that motoneuron numbers are controlled solely by peripheral competition. The study also provides evidence that muscle fibre numbers are regulated in part by the quantity of motor innervation received by the limb.

Prenatal development of the human nucleus ambiguus during the embryonic and early fetal periods

The ontogenetic development of the nucleus ambiguus was studied in a series of human embryos and fetuses ranging from 3 to 12.5 weeks of menstrual age (4 to 66 mm crown-rump length). They were prepared by Nissl and silver methods. Nucleus ambiguus neuroblasts, whose neurites extend towards and into the IXth and rostral Xth nerve roots, appear in the medial motor column of 4-6-week-old embryos (4.25-11 mm). These cells then migrate laterally (6.5 weeks, 14 mm) to a position near the dorsal motor nucleus of X. At 7 weeks (15 mm), nucleus ambiguus cells begin their migration, which progresses rostrocaudally, into their definitive ventrolateral position. The basic pattern of organization of the nucleus is established in its rostral region at 8 weeks (22.2-24 mm) and extends into its caudal region by 9 weeks (32 mm), when its nearly adult organization is evident. Cells having the characteristics of mature neurons first appear rostrally in the nucleus during the 8.5-9-week period (24.5-32 mm), gradually increase in number, and constitute the entire nucleus at 12.5 weeks (65.5 mm). Definitive neuronal subgroups first appear at 10 weeks (37.5 mm) in the large rostral nuclear region. These features suggest that the human nucleus ambiguus develops along a rostrocaudal temporospatial gradient. Evidence indicates that function of nucleus ambiguus neurons, manifested by fetal reflex swallowing, occurs after the cells migrate into their definitive position, establish the definitive nuclear pattern, and exhibit mature characteristics.

Development and survival of thoracic motoneurons and hindlimb musculature following transplantation of the thoracic neural tube to the lumbar region in the chick embryo: anatomical aspects

Thoracic spinal cord transplanted to the lumbar region at the time of neural tube closure in the chick embryo survives and initially differentiates normally similar to in situ thoracic cord. Normal numbers of motoneurons are produced that innervate the host hindlimb musculature. In control thoracic cord approximately 70% of the motoneurons are lost by normal cell death between embryonic day (E) 6 and E11-E12. By contrast, the transplanted thoracic cord loses only about 30% of the motoneurons during this period. Transplantation of one hindlimb to the thoracic region also reduces the normal loss of in situ thoracic motoneurons. We conclude that some factor(s) associated with the increased target size provided by the hindlimbs promotes the survival of thoracic motoneurons. In contrast, by E16-E18 motoneuron numbers in the thoracic transplants decrease to below control levels. Dorsal root ganglion cells in the transplant were also initially increased (on E8) but later decreased to below control values. Hindlimb muscles innervated by thoracic motoneurons in the transplant also differentiated normally up to E10 to E12. Myotube size and numbers, muscle size and myotube types (fast versus slow) all developed normally in several thoracically-innervated hindlimb muscles. However, beginning on E14 myotube numbers and muscle size were markedly decreased resulting in muscle atrophy. Injections of horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into the thoracic transplants labelled neurons in the host spinal cord and brainstem rostral to the transplant thereby indicating an anatomical continuity between host and transplant neural tube. Injections of HRP into specific thoracically innervated hindlimb muscles on E8 labelled distinct pools of motoneurons in the transplants.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Variation and symmetry in the lumbar and thoracic dorsal root ganglion cell populations of newly metamorphosed Xenopus laevis

The sizes of the lumbar and thoracic dorsal root ganglion cell populations in normally developing newly metamorphosed Xenopus laevis were measured in order to determine whether these neuron populations have the same characteristics as the hindlimb motoneuron population (i.e., large individual as well as sibling group differences, striking bilateral symmetry, and a rough correspondence between neuron number and body size that suggests some peripheral control of cell number during normal development (Sperry, J. Comp. Neurol. 264:250-267). Among animals from three sibling groups, the total numbers of thoracic and lumbar ganglion cells are highly variable and symmetrical, although symmetry is not uniformly present at the level of individual ganglion pairs. Significant sibling group differences in neuron number are also present. Metamorphic body size and cell number in the thoracic but not in the lumbar ganglia are significantly correlated. The motoneurons innervating the hindlimbs were also counted and measured in the same animals. While variable as well as symmetrical, motoneuron number and metamorphic body size are correlated in only two of the three sibling groups. Interestingly, the numbers of motoneurons and lumbar ganglion cells, two populations of neurons whose sizes one might predict would be significantly correlated in normally developing animals, are not correlated. The relationship between these observations and currently held views concerning how neuron numbers might be controlled during normal development is discussed.

Effects of an ectopic hindlimb on the brachial motoneurons in Xenopus

A forelimb bud of Xenopus tadpoles was replaced with the much larger hindlimb but at developmental stage 50, prior to the onset of the normal period of motoneuron death. At the conclusion of the motoneuron death period, there were generally no significant differences between the total numbers and nuclear area distributions of the brachial motoneurons supplying the ectopic hindlimb, and the remaining forelimb. It was concluded that factors in addition to the amount of muscle, or premuscle in the limb may be important in determining the totals and sizes of surviving motoneurons.

Regenerative specificity of motor axons when reinnervation is partially suppressed

We asked whether regenerating hindlimb motor axons would innervate inappropriate hindlimb regions if competition from appropriate innervation were prevented. The three ventral roots that innervate the hindlimb in the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) tadpole were transected, and the two more rostral roots were ligated to prevent regeneration. The most caudal root, which primarily supplies more distal limb musculature in unoperated tadpoles, was left free to regenerate. The specificity of regeneration was assessed by retrogradely labeling spinal motoneurons with HRP placed in the ventral thigh, a region that receives most of its innervation from the ligated roots. Despite the lack of competition from appropriate innervation, the regenerating root did not provide substantial innervation to proximal limb musculature. The same result was obtained in tadpoles operated upon at stages when regeneration of motor axons is specific and in tadpoles at stages when regenerating motor axons do not reinnervate their appropriate targets (Farel and Bemelmans, 1986), although the mechanisms in each case are likely different.

Nerve and muscle development in paralysé mutant mice

Nerve and muscle development was studied in paralysé mutant mice. The mutant phenotype is first recognizable 6-7 days after birth (PN 6-PN 7) as cessation of muscle growth and weakness and incoordination of movement. Mutant animals die between 2 and 3 weeks of age. Muscle fibers from paralysé mutants had a unimodal distribution of diameters and normal numbers and distributions of acetylcholine receptors. The only structural abnormality seen was a reduced extracellular space within muscle fascicles. Total muscle choline acetyltransferase activity was reduced compared with that of control muscles, indicating that synaptic terminal development was impaired. Light and electron microscopy showed that polyneuronal innervation was retained in mutant endplates, and the normal process of withdrawal of redundant innervation did not occur. The paralysé muscles reacted to experimental denervation with an increase in extrajunctional acetylcholine receptor numbers. Intramuscular axons failed to become myelinated in mutant animals, although sciatic nerve axons were myelinated with a normal myelin thickness/axon diameter ratio. Nodes of Ranvier were elongated and myelin lamellae in the paranodal regions were poorly fused. Sciatic nerves in mutant animals retained the neonatal unimodal distribution of axon diameters, whereas in control animals it became bimodal by 2 weeks of age. Our results are not consistent with a previous suggestion that paralysé mutant muscle endplates are progressively denervated. We conclude that the major expression of the paralysé mutant phenotype is an arrest in development of both nerve and muscle during the first week after birth. The paralysé mutant gene most likely is involved in the general support of development of many or all body tissues from 1 week of age. We found no regression of any aspect of differentiation, once achieved.