Circular Dichroism in Ion Yields of Femtosecond-Laser Mass Spectrometry

Control of circular dichroism in ion yield of 3-methyl cyclopentanone with femtosecond laser pulses

Circular dichroism (CD) in ion yield in the gas phase is a promising chiral recognition technique. Combining it with broadband ultrafast laser pulses allows us to examine the possibility of coherent control. We used shaped femtosecond laser pulses to control the CD in ion yield of 3-methylcyclopentanone observed from a 1 + 1 + 1 resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionisation around 309 nm. The duration of the pulses is increased via their spectral width or a frequency chirp, and a pulse pair with adjustable delay is employed to study the effect on the CD in ion yield. Furthermore, we used strongly chirped pulses of different central wavelengths to control the observed anisotropy. A clear enhancement of the anisotropy can be achieved, and possible mechanisms are discussed.

Anisotropy Factor Spectra for Weakly Allowed Electronic Transitions in Chiral Ketones

Quantum chemical calculations of one-photon absorption, electronic circular dichroism and anisotropy factor spectra for the A-band transition of fenchone, camphor and 3-methylcyclopentanone (3MCP) are reported. While the only weakly allowed nature of the transition leads to comparatively large anisotropies, a proper theoretical description of the absorption for such a transition requires to account for non-Condon effects. We present experimental data for the anisotropy of 3MCP in the liquid phase and show that corresponding Herzberg-Teller corrections are critical to reproduce the main experimental features. The results obtained with our comprehensive theoretical model highlight the importance of the vibrational degree of freedom, paving the way for a deeper understanding of the dynamics in electronic circular dichroism.

Anisotropic circular dichroism of jet-cooled chiral molecules

Anisotropic circular dichroism (CD) refers to the CD of oriented molecules, which varies with the direction of light propagation toward the molecules. Thus, anisotropic CD spectroscopy has been used to investigate the orientations of molecules in anisotropic media such as liquid crystals and thin films. However, it is unclear whether anisotropic CD results from isolated chromophores or their intermolecular interactions with other atoms or molecules that form anisotropically aligned structures. Herein, anisotropic CD of isolated chiral molecules was observed for the first time. The resonant two-photon ionization CD spectra of jet-cooled pseudoephedrine and styrene oxide indicated a difference between the CD values of the P/R and Q branches of the origin bands of the S0-S1 transition. This difference may have resulted from the anisotropic CD phenomena of these molecules, which are oriented via photoselection. Although jet-cooled molecules may have nearly random orientations, those excited to the P/R or Q branch become oriented because the transition probability to these branches depends on the molecular orientation relative to the direction of light propagation. These results demonstrate that the CD spectra of cold, isolated molecules, such as those in an interstellar medium, may exhibit anisotropic CD values.

Microwave Three-Wave Mixing Spectroscopy of Chiral Molecules in Weakly Bound Complexes

Since the first experimental implementation in 2013, microwave three-wave mixing has emerged as a robust spectroscopic approach for analyzing and controlling chiral molecules in the gas phase. This resonant, coherent, and nonlinear technique is based on the three-dimensional light-matter interaction in the electric dipole approximation, allowing for isomer- and conformer-selective chiral analysis with high resolution. Here we demonstrate the utility of microwave three-wave mixing for analyzing a molecular complex, limonene-H2O, which serves as a compelling example of addressing its potential to improve the chiral sensitivity for only weakly polar chiral molecules. The use of molecular complexes can also extend the applicability of microwave three-wave mixing to chiral systems that are not in the C1 point group.

Dual-Beam Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy of Jet-Cooled Chiral Molecules

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy of jet-cooled molecules provides conformation-specific CD spectra. However, its widespread utilization has been limited by the weak CD effects and the low density of gas-phase molecules. Here, we developed a dual-beam method to improve the sensitivity and accuracy of gas-phase CD measurements. Circularly and linearly polarized pulses were generated from a single laser pulse and used to irradiate a single molecular-beam pulse to produce two ion peaks. The ion peaks induced by linearly polarized pulses were subtracted from those induced by circularly polarized pulses to correct the CD values for the pulse-to-pulse fluctuations in laser power and gas density. The resonant two-photon ionization CD spectrum of (1R,2R)-(-)-pseudoephedrine revealed that the standard deviations of CD values measured using the dual-beam method were three times lower than those measured using a single-beam method. The dual-beam method provides an effective, accurate, and easy-to-use tool to obtain gas-phase CD spectra.

Increasing ion yield circular dichroism in femtosecond photoionisation using optimal control theory

We investigate how optimal control theory can be used to improve Circular Dichroism (CD) signals for the A-band of fenchone measured via the photoionization yield upon further excitation. These transitions are electric dipole forbidden to first order, which translates into low population transfer to the excited state but allows for a clearer interplay between electric and magnetic transition dipole moments, which are of the same order of magnitude. Using a model including the electronic ground and excited A state as well as all permanent and transition multipole moments up to the electric quadrupole, we find that the absolute CD signal of randomly oriented molecules can be increased by a factor of 2.5 when using shaped laser pulses, with the anisotropy parameter g increasing from 0.06 to 1. We find that this effect is caused by the interference between the excitation pathways prompted by the different multipole moments of the molecule.

Detecting chirality in mixtures using nanosecond photoelectron circular dichroism

We report chirality detection of structural isomers in a gas phase mixture using nanosecond photoelectron circular dichroism (PECD). Combining pulsed molecular beams with high-resolution resonance enhanced multi-photon ionization (REMPI) allows specific isolated transitions belonging to distinct components in the mixture to be targeted.

Coincident measurement of photo-ion circular dichroism and photo-electron circular dichroism on 1-Phenylethylamine

Here we report the coincident measurement of the PICD and PECD effect in 1-Phenylethylamine upon multiphoton ionisation. Photo-ion circular dichroism (PICD) and photo-electron circular dichroism (PECD) are both methods to...

Photoelectron Circular Dichroism in the Photodetachment of Amino Acid Anions

The chirality of chemical compounds is of undisputed importance in science and technology. In particular with respect to pharmacological application most molecules of interest cannot be accessed by the powerful techniques developed in recent years for gas phase analytes. Here, we demonstrate that the combination of electrospray ionization (ESI) with the detection of photoelectron circular dichroism (PECD) provides access to chirality information applicable to molecular materials with negligible vapor pressure, for example, amino acids. To this end, glutamic acid and 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA) have been electrosprayed into the source of a chirality spectrometer, where photodetachment is enforced and the PECD is detected. The technique can be expected to be conceptually applicable to all chemical systems with chirality based on molecular properties.

Self-referencing circular dichroism ion yield measurements for improved statistics using femtosecond laser pulses

The combination of circular dichroism with laser mass spectrometry via the measurement of ion yields is a powerful tool in chiral recognition, but the measured anisotropies are generally weak. The method presented in this contribution reduces the measurement error significantly. A common path optical setup generates a pair of counter-rotating laser foci in the interaction region of a time-of-flight spectrometer. As the space focus condition is fulfilled for both foci individually, this becomes a twin-peak ion source with well separated and sufficiently resolved mass peaks. The individual control of polarization allows for in situ correction of experimental fluctuations measuring circular dichroism. Our robust optical setup produces reliable and reproducible results and is applicable for dispersion sensitive femtosecond laser pulses. In this contribution, we use 3-methyl-cyclopentanone as a prototype molecule to illustrate the evaluation procedure and the measurement principle.

Strong Differential Photoion Circular Dichroism in Strong-Field Ionization of Chiral Molecules

We investigate the differential ionization probability of chiral molecules in the strong-field regime as a function of the helicity of the incident light. To this end, we analyze the fourfold ionization of bromochlorofluoromethane (CHBrClF) with subsequent fragmentation into four charged fragments and different dissociation channels of the singly ionized methyloxirane. By resolving for the molecular orientation, we show that the photoion circular dichroism signal strength is increased by 2 orders of magnitude.

Chirality detection of surface desorption products using photoelectron circular dichroism

Chirality detection of gas-phase molecules at low concentrations is challenging as the molecular number density is usually too low to perform conventional circular dichroism absorption experiments. In recent years, new spectroscopic methods have been developed to detect chirality in the gas phase. In particular, the angular distribution of photoelectrons after multiphoton laser ionization of chiral molecules using circularly polarized light is highly sensitive to the enantiomeric form of the ionized molecule [multiphoton photoelectron circular dichroism (MP-PECD)]. In this paper, we employ the MP-PECD as an analytic tool for chirality detection of the bicyclic monoterpene fenchone desorbing from a Ag(111) crystal. We record velocity-resolved kinetics of fenchone desorption on Ag(111) using pulsed molecular beams with ion imaging techniques. In addition, we measure temperature-programmed desorption spectra of the same system. Both experiments indicate weak physisorption of fenchone on Ag(111). We combine both experimental techniques with enantiomer-specific detection by recording MP-PECD of desorbing molecules using photoelectron imaging spectroscopy. We can clearly assign the enantiomeric form of the desorption product fenchone in sub-monolayer concentration. The experiment demonstrates the combination of MP-PECD with surface science experiments, paving the way for enantiomer-specific detection of surface reaction products on heterogeneous catalysts for asymmetric synthesis.

Mass-resolved electronic circular dichroism ion spectroscopy

DNA and proteins are chiral: Their three-dimensional structures cannot be superimposed with their mirror images. Circular dichroism spectroscopy is widely used to characterize chiral compounds, but data interpretation is difficult in the case of mixtures. We recorded the electronic circular dichroism spectra of DNA helices separated in a mass spectrometer. We studied guanine-rich strands having various secondary structures, electrosprayed them as negative ions, irradiated them with an ultraviolet nanosecond optical parametric oscillator laser, and measured the difference in electron photodetachment efficiency between left and right circularly polarized light. The reconstructed circular dichroism ion spectra resembled those of their solution-phase counterparts, thereby allowing us to assign the DNA helical topology. The ability to measure circular dichroism directly on biomolecular ions expands the capabilities of mass spectrometry for structural analysis.

Chiral and Isomeric Discrimination of Chiral Molecular Ions by Cold Ion Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy

Circular dichroism (CD) spectra contain information about absolute configurations and conformations of chiral compounds. However, extracting this information from CD spectra in solution is challenging, because the spectra exhibit only the averaged CD values of all different conformers. CD spectroscopy of jet-cooled molecules can provide conformation-specific CD spectra, but its application to biomolecules has been limited due to the difficulty of their production in the gas phase. Here, we obtained the first CD spectra of chiral molecular ions produced by electrospray ionization (ESI) using cold ion CD spectroscopy. Protonated l- or d-phenylalanine ions produced by ESI were stored in a cold quadrupole ion trap and irradiated by multiple laser pulses with left or right circular polarization. The CD spectra exhibited well-resolved CD bands of two conformers, whose signs were opposite to each other. This study will broaden the scope of conformation-resolved CD spectroscopy to large molecular ions without size limitations.

High-resolution resonance-enhanced multiphoton photoelectron circular dichroism

Photoelectron circular dichroism (PECD) is a highly sensitive enantiospecific spectroscopy for studying chiral molecules in the gas phase using either single-photon ionization or multiphoton ionization. In the short pulse limit investigated with femtosecond lasers, resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization (REMPI) is rather instantaneous and typically occurs simultaneously via more than one vibrational or electronic intermediate state due to limited frequency resolution. In contrast, vibrational resolution in the REMPI spectrum can be achieved using nanosecond lasers. In this work, we follow the high-resolution approach using a tunable narrow-band nanosecond laser to measure REMPI-PECD through distinct vibrational levels in the intermediate 3s and 3p Rydberg states of fenchone. We observe the PECD to be essentially independent of the vibrational level. This behaviour of the chiral sensitivity may pave the way for enantiomer specific molecular identification in multi-component mixtures: one can specifically excite a sharp, vibrationally resolved transition of a distinct molecule to distinguish different chiral species in mixtures.

Coincident measurement of photo-ion circular dichroism and photo-electron circular dichroism

Photo-ion circular dichroism (PICD) and photo-electron circular dichroism (PECD) have been measured for the first time simultaneously in a coincidence experiment detecting the chirality of R- and S-Methyloxirane.

Induced Circular Dichroism of Jet-Cooled Phenol Complexes with (R)-(-)-2-Butanol

The induced circular dichroism (ICD) of phenol complexed with (R)-(-)-2-butanol [PhOH-(-)BOH] in a supersonic jet is investigated using resonant two-photon ionization circular dichroism (R2PICD) spectroscopy. The R2PICD spectrum of PhOH-(-)BOH exhibits nonzero ICD bands near the absorption region of bare PhOH, where (-)BOH is transparent. Two different conformers containing a single hydrogen bond between PhOH and (-)BOH are identified using ultraviolet-ultraviolet hole-burning and infrared ion-dip spectroscopy combined with quantum theoretical calculations. The ICD values of the two conformers are similar to each other. To understand these similar ICD effects of the conformers, the geometrical asymmetry of the PhOH moiety bound to (-)BOH and the coupling strength of the electric transition dipole moments between PhOH and (-)BOH are estimated. Comparing the ICD values of PhOH-(-)BOH with those of PhOH-(-)-l-methyl lactate in the previous report [ Hong , A. ; J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2018 , 9 , 476 -480 ], we investigate the physical properties that may govern the differences of the ICD values between the two complexes.

Spectroscopy for model heterogeneous asymmetric catalysis

Heterogeneous catalysis has vastly benefited from investigations performed on model systems under well-controlled conditions. The application of most of the techniques utilized for such studies is not feasible for asymmetric reactions as enantiomers possess identical physical and chemical properties unless while interacting with polarized light and other chiral entities. A thorough investigation of a heterogeneous asymmetric catalytic process should include probing the catalyst prior to, during, and after the reaction as well as the analysis of reaction products to evaluate the achieved enantiomeric excess. I present recent studies that demonstrate the strength of chiroptical spectroscopic methods to tackle the challenges in investigating model heterogeneous asymmetric catalysis covering all the abovementioned aspects.

Photochemical Chiral Symmetry Breaking in Alanine

We introduce a general theoretical approach for the simulation of photochemical dynamics under the influence of circularly polarized light to explore the possibility of generating enantiomeric enrichment through polarized-light-selective photochemistry. The method is applied to the simulation of the photolysis of alanine, a prototype chiral amino acid. We show that a systematic enantiomeric enrichment can be obtained depending on the helicity of the circularly polarized light that induces the excited-state photochemistry of alanine. By analyzing the patterns of the photoinduced fragmentation of alanine we find an inducible enantiomeric enrichment up to 1.7%, which is also in good correspondence to the experimental findings. Our method is generally applicable to complex systems and might serve to systematically explore the photochemical origin of homochirality.

Mass-Selected Circular Dichroism of Supersonic-Beam-Cooled [D4 ]-(R)-(+)-3-Methylcyclopentanone

UV spectroscopy and electronic circular dichroism (ECD) experiments on supersonic-beam-cooled deuterated (R)-(+)-3-methylcyclopentanone ([D₄ ]-(R)-(+)-3-MCP) have been performed by using a laser mass spectrometer. The spectral resolution not only allowed excitation and CD measurements for single vibronic transitions but also for the rotational P, Q, and R branches of these transitions. The investigated n→π*18042501 transition showed the largest anisotropy factor ever observed for chiral molecules in the gas phase, which, due to residual saturation of the excited transition, represents only a lower limit for the real anisotropy factor. Furthermore, one-color (1+1+1) and two-color (1+1') resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization (REMPI) measurements were performed and the effusive-beam (room temperature) and supersonic-beam results for [D₄ ]-(R)-(+)-3-MCP were compared. These results allowed a differentiation between single-step ECD (comparable to conventional ECD) and cumulative ECD (only possible in multiphoton excitation) under supersonic-beam conditions.

Electronic Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy of Jet-Cooled Phenylalanine and Its Hydrated Clusters

We obtained resonant two-photon ionization circular dichroism (R2PICD) spectra of jet-cooled phenylalanine (Phe) and its hydrated clusters (Phe(H₂O)_n, n = 1-2) near the origin band of the S₀-S₁ transition. The R2PICD spectra of Phe exhibit well-resolved CD bands of six different conformers present in the jet, which vary in sign and magnitude depending on their conformations. We revised the previous structural assignments of the Phe conformers based on the comparison between the experimental and theoretical CD signs, infrared spectra, and rotational band contours. The R2PICD spectra of Phe(H₂O)_n reveal that hydration with one or two water molecule(s) does not affect the CD signs of Phe conformers but significantly increases their CD magnitudes. Furthermore, conformational selection by solvation alters relative populations of Phe conformers, leading to a sign inversion in the CD spectra of Phe(H₂O)_n compared with that of Phe monomer.

Mass-Selective Chiral Analysis

Three ways of realizing mass-selective chiral analysis are reviewed. The first is based on the formation of diastereomers that are of homo- and hetero- type with respect to the enantiomers of involved chiral molecules. This way is quite well-established with numerous applications. The other two ways are more recent developments, both based on circular dichroism (CD). In one, conventional or nonlinear electronic CD is linked to mass spectrometry (MS) by resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization. The other is based on CD in the angular distribution of photoelectrons, which is measured in combination with MS via photoion photoelectron coincidence. Among the many important applications of mass-selective chiral analysis, this review focuses on its use as an analytical tool for the development of heterogeneous enantioselective chemical catalysis. There exist other approaches to combine chiral analysis and mass-selective detection, such as chiral chromatography MS, which are not discussed here.

Fluorescence-detected circular dichroism spectroscopy of jet-cooled ephedrine

The resonant two-photon ionization circular dichroism (R2PICD) spectrum represents the cumulative circular dichroism (CD) of one-photon excitation and the subsequent one-photon ionization, whereas the fluorescence-detected circular dichroism (FDCD) spectra exhibit only the CD of one-photon excitation, similar to conventional CD spectra. We obtained the FDCD spectra of jet-cooled ephedrine (EPD) near the origin band of the S0-S1 transition to measure the CD of one-photon absorption and thus the CD of the ionization process in R2PI in comparison with the R2PICD spectra. The CD effects of the ionization following excitation of the A (0-0) and C (930 cm(-1)) bands in the spectrum are small, whereas those of the B band (530 cm(-1)) are anomalously large, leading to opposite CD signs for the FDCD and R2PICD spectra. Based on the intermediate state-selective fragmentation patterns in the R2PI spectra, this large CD effect is attributed to the state-selective isomerization that occurs after excitation of the B band. By comparing the experimental and theoretical spectra, we determined that the B band corresponds to an asymmetric ring distortion mode that involves torsional motions of the side chain, which may facilitate the isomerization process. This study demonstrates that FDCD spectroscopy combined with R2PICD spectroscopy provides a powerful tool to measure the CD effects of the excitation and ionization processes separately in R2PI and thus probe the structural changes that occur during the ionization process following excitation to an intermediate state.

Circular Dichroism in Mass Spectrometry: Quantum Chemical Investigations for the Differences between (R)-3-Methylcyclopentanone and Its Cation

In mass spectrometry enantiomers can be distinguished by multiphoton ionization employing circular polarized laser pulses. The circular dichroism (CD) is detected from the normalized difference in the ion yield after excitation with light of opposite handedness. While there are cases in which fragment and parent ions exhibit the same sign of the CD in the ion yield, several experiments show that they might also differ in sign and magnitude. Supported by experimental observations it has been proposed that the parent ion, once it has been formed, is further excited by the laser, which may result in a change of the CD in the ion yield of the formed fragments compared to the parent ion. To gain a deeper insight in possible excitation pathways we calculated and compared the electronic CD absorption spectra of neutral and cationic (R)-3-methylcyclopentanone, applying density functional theory. In addition, electron wavepacket dynamics were used to compare the CD of one- and two-photon transitions. Our results support the proposed subsequent excitation of the parent ion as a possible origin of the difference of the CD in the ion yield between parent ion and fragments.

Laser-driven electron dynamics for circular dichroism in mass spectrometry: from one-photon excitations to multiphoton ionization

The distinction of enantiomers is a key aspect of chemical analysis. In mass spectrometry the distinction of enantiomers has been achieved by ionizing the sample with circularly polarized laser pulses and comparing the ion yields for light of opposite handedness. While resonant excitation conditions are expected to be most efficient, they are not required for the detection of a circular dichroism (CD) in the ion yield. However, the prediction of the size and sign of the circular dichroism becomes challenging if non-resonant multiphoton excitations are used to ionize the sample. Employing femtosecond laser pulses to drive electron wavepacket dynamics based on ab initio calculations, we attempt to reveal underlying mechanisms that determine the CD under non-resonant excitation conditions. Simulations were done for (R)-1,2-propylene oxide, using time-dependent configuration interaction singles with perturbative doubles (TD-CIS(D)) and the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set. Interactions between the electric field and the electric dipole and quadrupole as well as between the magnetic field and the magnetic dipole were explicitly accounted for. The ion yield was determined by treating states above the ionization potential as either stationary or non-stationary with energy-dependent lifetimes based on an approved heuristic approach. The observed population dynamics do not allow for a simple interpretation, because of highly non-linear interactions. Still, the various transition pathways are governed by resonant enantiospecific n-photon excitation, with preferably high transition dipole moments, which eventually dominate the CD in the ionized population.

Chiral distinction by ultrashort laser pulses: electron wavepacket dynamics incorporating magnetic interactions

The qualitative and quantitative distinction of enantiomers is one of the key issues in chemical analysis. In the last years, circular dichroism (CD) has been combined with laser ionization mass spectrometry (LIMS), applying resonance enhanced multiphoton ionization (REMPI) with ultrashort laser pulses. We present theoretical investigations on the CD in the populations of the first electronic excited state of the REMPI process, caused by the interaction of 3-methyl-cyclopentanone with either left or right circular polarized fs-laser pulses. For this we performed multistate laser driven many electron dynamics based on ab initio electronic structure calculations, namely, TD-CIS(D)/6-311++(2d,2p). For a theoretical description of these experiments, a complete description of the field-dipole correlation is mandatory, including both electric field-electric dipole and magnetic field-magnetic dipole interactions. The effect of various pulse parameters on the CD are analyzed and compared with experimental results to gain further understanding of the key elements for an optimal distinction of enantiomers.

Circular Dichroism in Ion Yields in Multiphoton Ionization of (R)-Propylene Oxide Employing Femtosecond Laser Pulses

The feasibility of measuring circular dichroism (CD) in ion yields is demonstrated in multiphoton ionization employing femtosecond laser radiation for the first time. CD values for (R)-propylene oxide are reported at 738 nm, 810 nm and 878 nm. The data suggest the possibility of resonance contributions at 810 nm. At the other wavelengths the CD appears to originate from non-resonant multiphoton ionization. Possible implications of measuring non-resonant CD are discussed.

Progress in circular dichroism laser mass spectrometry

Circular dichroism in ion yield has promising new potentials for chiral analysis. Our progress of its development is described here. Circular dichroism in ion yield is achieved by resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization. The feasibility of circular dichroism spectroscopy and quantitative determination of circular dichroism by this method is demonstrated. Several excitation schemes have been applied using different types of lasers, which vary in wavelength and repetition rate. Progress to improve the statistical error and thus the lower limit of measurable circular dichroism is described. This is achieved by adding achiral compounds or racemic mixtures of chiral compounds to the sample gas as reference substances and ionizing them by the same laser pulse. Therefore, in the mass spectrum of every single laser pulse, ion signals of sample and reference species appear both being subject to the same kind of instrumental fluctuations (in particular of laser pulse energy). In another approach, a laser repetition rate of 200 Hz allowed averaging of large numbers of laser pulses.