Identity and timing of protist inoculation affect plant performance largely irrespective of changes in the rhizosphere microbial community

Bacterivorous soil protists can have positive impacts on plant performance, making them attractive targets for novel strategies to improve crop production. However, we generally lack the knowledge required to make informed choices regarding the protist species to be used or the optimal conditions for such amendments. Here, we examined how identity, diversity, and timing of inoculation of well-described protists impacted plant development and rhizosphere microbiome assembly. We first studied the impact of individual inoculation of six well-characterized protists on lettuce growth, with Cercomonas sp. S24D2 emerging as the strain with the largest impact on plant growth. In a second step, we created a three-protist species mixture inoculant by adding two protist species (Acanthamoeba sp. C13D2 and a heterolobosean isolate S18D10), based on differences in their feeding patterns. We then inoculated Cercomonas sp. either individually or in the protist mixture to lettuce plants 1 week before, simultaneously with, or 1 week after seedling transfer. We monitored plant growth and nutrient content, as well as impacts on the resident soil and rhizosphere microbiome composition. We found that early protist inoculation provided the greatest increase in aboveground biomass compared to the non-inoculated control. Single- and mixed-species inoculations had similar impacts on plant development and only minor impacts on prokaryotic community composition. While early inoculation seems to be the most promising timing for eliciting the positive effects of protist amendments, further, more systematic studies will be necessary to determine the conditions and ecological interactions that yield consistent and predictable improvements in plant performance.

IMPORTANCE

The application of microorganisms, including bacterivorous soil protists, has been increasingly suggested as a sustainable agricultural approach. While positive impacts of the presence of predatory protists have been generally reported, the effects of the selected species and amendment conditions are largely unknown. Here, we examined how identity, diversity, and timing of inoculation of well-described protists impacted plant development and rhizosphere microbiome assembly. One species emerged as the one having the strongest impact in our specific system. This result highlights the importance of species selection for optimal outcome, but also suggests a huge potential in the barely investigated protist diversity for targeted application. Furthermore, the application of the inoculants before plant transfer showed the strongest effects on plants, providing some useful and new insights on the optimal time for such amendments.

Analysis of the northern pitcher plant (Sarracenia purpurea L.) phytotelm bacteriome throughout a temperate region growing season

The insectivorous Northern Pitcher Plant, Sarracenia purpurea, recruits a dynamic biotic community in the rainwater collected by its pitcher-shaped leaves. Insect capture and degradation within the pitcher fluid (phytotelma) has been well documented as a mechanism for supplementing the plant's nitrogen, phosphorous, and micronutrient requirements. Metagenomic studies have shown a diverse microbiome in this phytotelm environment, including taxa that contribute metabolically to prey digestion. In this investigation, we used high-throughput 16S rDNA sequencing and bioinformatics to analyze the S. purpurea phytotelm bacteriome as it changes through the growing season (May-September) in plants from the north-central region of the species' native range. Additionally, we used molecular techniques to detect and quantify bacterial nitrogenase genes (nifH) in all phytotelm samples to explore the hypothesis that diazotrophy is an additional mechanism of supplying biologically available nitrogen to S. purpurea. The results of this study indicate that while prokaryote diversity remains relatively stable in plants at different locations within our region, diversity changes significantly as the growing season progresses. Furthermore, nifH genes were detected at biologically significant concentrations in one hundred percent of samples, suggesting that nitrogen fixation may be an important contributor to the S. purpurea nutrient budget.

Reciprocal inhibition and competitive hierarchy cause negative biodiversity-ecosystem function relationships

The relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem function (BEF) captivates ecologists, but the factors responsible for the direction of this relationship remain unclear. While higher ecosystem functioning at higher biodiversity levels ('positive BEF') is not universal in nature, negative BEF relationships seem puzzlingly rare. Here, we develop a dynamical consumer-resource model inspired by microbial decomposer communities in pitcher plant leaves to investigate BEF. We manipulate microbial diversity via controlled colonization and measure their function as total ammonia production. We test how niche partitioning among bacteria and other ecological processes influence BEF in the leaves. We find that a negative BEF can emerge from reciprocal interspecific inhibition in ammonia production causing a negative complementarity effect, or from competitive hierarchies causing a negative selection effect. Absent these factors, a positive BEF was the typical outcome. Our findings provide a potential explanation for the rarity of negative BEF in empirical data.

Predator dispersal influences predator distribution but not prey diversity in pitcher plant microbial metacommunities

The spatial distribution of predators can affect both the distribution and diversity of their prey. Therefore, differences in predator dispersal ability that affect their spatial distribution, could also affect prey communities. Here, we use the microbial communities within pitcher plant leaves as a model system to test the relationship between predator (protozoa) dispersal ability and distribution, and its consequences for prey (bacteria) diversity and composition. We hypothesized that limited predator dispersal results in clustered distributions and heterogeneous patches for prey species, whereas wide predator dispersal and distribution could homogenize prey metacommunities. We analyzed the distribution of two prominent bacterivore protozoans from a 2-year survey of an intact field of Sarracenia purpurea pitcher plants, and found a clustered distribution of Tetrahymena and homogeneous distribution of Poterioochromonas. We manipulated the sources of protozoan colonists and recorded protozoan recruitment and bacterial diversity in target leaves in a field experiment. We found the large ciliate, Tetrahymena, was dispersal limited and occupied few leaves, whereas the small flagellate Poterioochromonas was widely dispersed. However, the bacterial communities these protozoans feed on was unaffected by clustering of Tetrahymena, but likely influenced by Poterioochromonas and other bacterivores dispersing in the field. We propose that bacterial communities in this system are structured by a combination of well dispersed bacterivores, bacterial dispersal, and bottom-up mechanisms. Clustered predators could become strong drivers of prey communities if they were specialists or keystone predators, or if they exerted a dominant influence on other predators in top-down controlled systems. Linking dispersal ability within trophic levels and its consequences for trophic dynamics can lead to a more robust perspective on trophic metacommunities.

Prey identity affects fitness of a generalist consumer in a brown food web

The use of ever-advancing sequencing technologies has revealed incredible biodiversity at the microbial scale, and yet we know little about the ecological interactions in these communities. For example, in the phytotelmic community found in the purple pitcher plant, Sarracenia purpurea, ecologists typically consider the bacteria as a functionally homogenous group. In this food web, bacteria decompose detritus and are consumed by protozoa that are considered generalist consumers. Here, we tested whether a generalist consumer benefits from all bacteria equally. We isolated and identified 22 strains of bacteria, belonging to six genera, from S. purpurea plants. We grew the protozoa, Tetrahymena sp. with single isolates and strain mixtures of bacteria and measured Tetrahymena fitness. We found that different bacterial strains had different effects on protozoan fitness, both in isolation and in mixture. Our results demonstrate that not accounting for the composition of prey communities may affect the predicted outcome of predator-prey interactions.

Sarracenia pitcher plant-associated microbial communities differ primarily by host species across a longitudinal gradient

Plant-associated microbial communities can profoundly affect plant health and success, and research is still uncovering factors driving the assembly of these communities. Here, we examine how geography versus host species affect microbial community structure and differential abundances of individual taxa. We use metabarcoding to characterize the bacteria and eukaryotes associated with five, often co-occurring species of Sarracenia pitcher plants (Sarraceniaceae) and three natural hybrids along the longitudinal gradient of the U.S. Gulf Coast, as well as samples from S. purpurea in Massachusetts. To tease apart the effects of geography versus host species, we focus first on sites with co-occurring species and then on species located across different sites. Our analyses show that bacterial and eukaryotic community structures are clearly and consistently influenced by host species identity, with geographic factors also playing a role. Naturally-occurring hybrids appear to also host unique communities, that are in some ways intermediate between their parent species. We see significant effects of geography (site and longitude), but these generally explain less of the variation among pitcher communities. Overall, in Sarracenia pitchers, host plant phenotype significantly affects the pitcher microbiomes and other associated organisms. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Protozoa populations are ecosystem engineers that shape prokaryotic community structure and function of the rumen microbial ecosystem

Unicellular eukaryotes are an integral part of many microbial ecosystems where they interact with their surrounding prokaryotic community-either as predators or as mutualists. Within the rumen, one of the most complex host-associated microbial habitats, ciliate protozoa represent the main micro-eukaryotes, accounting for up to 50% of the microbial biomass. Nonetheless, the extent of the ecological effect of protozoa on the microbial community and on the rumen metabolic output remains largely understudied. To assess the role of protozoa on the rumen ecosystem, we established an in-vitro system in which distinct protozoa sub-communities were introduced to the native rumen prokaryotic community. We show that the different protozoa communities exert a strong and differential impact on the composition of the prokaryotic community, as well as its function including methane production. Furthermore, the presence of protozoa increases prokaryotic diversity with a differential effect on specific bacterial populations such as Gammaproteobacteria, Prevotella and Treponema. Our results suggest that protozoa contribute to the maintenance of prokaryotic diversity in the rumen possibly by mitigating the effect of competitive exclusion between bacterial taxa. Our findings put forward the rumen protozoa populations as potentially important ecosystem engineers for future microbiome modulation strategies.

Bacterial Recruitment to Carnivorous Pitcher Plant Communities: Identifying Sources Influencing Plant Microbiome Composition and Function

Processes influencing recruitment of diverse bacteria to plant microbiomes remain poorly understood. In the carnivorous pitcher plant Sarracenia purpurea model system, individual pitchers open to collect rainwater, invertebrates and a diverse microbial community, and this detrital food web is sustained by captured insect prey. This study examined how potential sources of bacteria affect the development of the bacterial community within pitchers, how the host plant tissue affects community development and how established vs. assembling communities differ. In a controlled greenhouse experiment, seven replicate pitchers were allocated to five treatments to exclude specific bacterial sources or host tissue: milliQ water only, milliQ + insect prey, rainwater + prey, established communities + prey, artificial pitchers with milliQ + prey. Community composition and functions were examined over 8-40 weeks using bacterial gene sequencing and functional predictions, measurements of cell abundance, hydrolytic enzyme activity and nutrient transformations. Distinct community composition and functional differences between artificial and real pitchers confirm an important influence of host plant tissue on community development, but also suggest this could be partially related to host nutrient uptake. Significant recruitment of bacteria to pitchers from air was evident from many taxa common to all treatments, overlap in composition between milliQ, milliQ + prey, and rainwater + prey treatments, and few taxa unique to milliQ only pitchers. Community functions measured as hydrolytic enzyme (chitinase, protease) activity suggested a strong influence of insect prey additions and were linked to rapid transformation of insect nutrients into dissolved and inorganic sources. Bacterial taxa found in 6 of 7 replicate pitchers within treatments, the "core microbiome" showed tighter successional trajectories over 8 weeks than all taxa. Established pitcher community composition was more stable over 8 weeks, suggesting a diversity-stability relationship and effect of microinvertebrates on bacteria. This study broadly demonstrates that bacterial composition in host pitcher plants is related to both stochastic and specific bacterial recruitment and host plants influence microbial selection and support microbiomes through capture of insect prey.

Selective Bacterial Community Enrichment between the Pitcher Plants Sarracenia minor and Sarracenia flava

The interconnected and overlapping habitats present in natural ecosystems remain a challenge in determining the forces driving microbial community composition. The cuplike leaf structures of some carnivorous plants, including those of the family Sarraceniaceae, are self-contained ecological habitats that represent systems for exploring such microbial ecology questions. We investigated whether Sarracenia minor and Sarracenia flava cultivate distinct bacterial communities when sampled at the same geographic location and time. This sampling strategy eliminates many abiotic environmental variables present in other studies that compare samples harvested over time, and it could reveal biotic factors driving the selection of microbes. DNA extracted from the decomposing detritus trapped in each Sarracenia leaf pitcher was profiled using 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing. We identified a surprising amount of bacterial diversity within each pitcher, but we also discovered bacteria whose abundance was specifically enriched in one of the two Sarracenia species. These differences in bacterial community representation suggest some biotic influence of the Sarracenia plant on the bacterial composition of their pitchers. Overall, our results suggest that bacterial selection due to factors other than geographic location, weather, or prey availability is occurring within the pitchers of these two closely related plant species. This indicates that specific characteristics of S. minor and S. flava may play a role in fostering distinct bacterial communities. These confined, naturally occurring microbial ecosystems within Sarracenia pitchers may provide model systems to answer important questions about the drivers of microbial community composition, succession, and response to environmental perturbations. IMPORTANCE This study uses amplicon sequencing to compare the bacterial communities of environmental samples from the detritus of the leaf cavities of Sarracenia minor and Sarracenia flava pitcher plants. We sampled the detritus at the same time and in the same geographic location, eliminating many environmental variables present in other comparative studies. This study revealed that different species of Sarracenia contain distinct bacterial members within their pitchers, suggesting that these communities are not randomly established based on environmental factors and the prey pool but are potentially enriched for by the plants' chemical or physical environment. This study of these naturally occurring, confined microbial ecosystems will help further establish carnivorous pitcher plants as a model system for answering important questions about the development and succession of microbial communities.

Microbial biofilm community dynamics in five lowland streams

Stream biofilms are complex aggregates of diverse organism groups that play a vital role in global carbon and nitrogen cycles. Most of the current studies on stream biofilm focus on a limited number of organism groups (e.g., bacteria and algae), and few have included both prokaryote and eukaryote communities simultaneously. In this study, we incubated artificial substrates in five Danish lowland streams exhibiting different hydrological and physico-chemical conditions and explored the dynamics of community composition and diversity of the benthic biofilm, including both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. We found that few phyla in the prokaryote (Gammaproteobacteria and Bacteroidetes) and eukaryote (Cercozoa) communities accounted for over two-thirds of the total abundance at most of the sites. Both prokaryotic and eukaryotic diversity displayed the same temporal patterns, i.e., diversity peaked in July and January. We also found that hydrological and physico-chemical variables significantly explained the variation in the community composition at phylum level for both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. However, a large proportion of variation remained unexplained, which can be ascribed to important but unmeasured variables like light intensity and biological factors such as trophic and non-trophic interactions as revealed by network analysis. Therefore, we suggest that use of a multitrophic level perspective is needed to study biofilm i.e., the "microbial jungles", where high occurrences of trophic and non-trophic interactions are expected.

Disparities in the analysis of morphological disparity

Analyses of morphological disparity have been used to characterize and investigate the evolution of variation in the anatomy, function and ecology of organisms since the 1980s. While a diversity of methods have been employed, it is unclear whether they provide equivalent insights. Here, we review the most commonly used approaches for characterizing and analysing morphological disparity, all of which have associated limitations that, if ignored, can lead to misinterpretation. We propose best practice guidelines for disparity analyses, while noting that there can be no 'one-size-fits-all' approach. The available tools should always be used in the context of a specific biological question that will determine data and method selection at every stage of the analysis.

Diverse microbial communities hosted by the model carnivorous pitcher plant Sarracenia purpurea: analysis of both bacterial and eukaryotic composition across distinct host plant populations

BACKGROUND

The pitcher plant Sarracenia purpurea supplements nutrient acquisition through carnivory, capturing insect prey which are digested by a food web community of eukaryotes and bacteria. While the food web invertebrates are well studied, and some recent studies have characterized bacteria, detailed genetic analysis of eukaryotic diversity is lacking. This study aimed to compare eukaryotic and bacterial composition and diversity of pitcher communities within and between populations of host plants in nearby but distinct wetland habitats, and to characterize microbial functions across populations and in comparison with another freshwater community.

METHODS

Pitcher fluid was sampled from the two wetlands, Cedarburg and Sapa Bogs, community DNA was extracted, and 16S and 18S rRNA amplicons were sequenced and data processed for community-level comparisons.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Bacterial diversity in the small pitcher volume rivaled that of larger aquatic communities. Between pitcher plant populations, several bacterial families (Kiloniellaceae, Acetobacteraceae, Xanthobacteraceae, Sanguibacteraceae, Oligoflexaceae, Nitrosomonadaceae, Chromatiaceae, Saprospiraceae) were significantly higher in one population. However, although predicted pitcher bacterial functions were distinct from other freshwater communities, especially for some amino acid metabolism, functions were similar across all the pitchers in the two populations. This suggests some functional redundancy among bacterial taxa, and that functions converge to achieve similar food web processes. The sequencing identified a previously under-appreciated high diversity of ciliates, Acari mites, fungi and flagellates in pitcher communities; the most abundant sequences from eukaryotic taxa were Oligohymenophorea ciliates, millipedes and Ichthyosporea flagellates. Two thirds of taxa were identified as food web inhabitants and less than one third as prey organisms. Although eukaryotic composition was not significantly different between populations, there were different species of core taxonomic groups present in different pitchers-these differences may be driven by wetland habitats providing different populations to colonize new pitchers. Eukaryotic composition was more variable than bacterial composition, and there was a poor relationship between bacterial and eukaryotic composition within individual pitchers, suggesting that colonization by eukaryotes may be more stochastic than for bacteria, and bacterial recruitment to pitchers may involve factors other than prey capture and colonization by eukaryotic food web inhabitants.