"Natural" presentation of human papillomavirus type-16 E7 protein to immunocompetent mice results in antigen-specific sensitization or sustained unresponsiveness

T-cell responses to human papillomavirus type 16 among women with different grades of cervical neoplasia

Infection with high-risk genital human papillomavirus (HPV) types is a major risk factor for the development of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and invasive cervical carcinoma. The design of effective immunotherapies requires a greater understanding of how HPV-specific T-cell responses are involved in disease clearance and/or progression. Here, we have investigated T-cell responses to five HPV16 proteins (E6, E7, E4, L1 and L2) in women with CIN or cervical carcinoma directly ex vivo. T-cell responses were observed in the majority (78%) of samples. The frequency of CD4+ responders was far lower among those with progressive disease, indicating that the CD4+ T-cell response might be important in HPV clearance. CD8+ reactivity to E6 peptides was dominant across all disease grades, inferring that E6-specific CD8+ T cells are not vitally involved in disease clearance. T-cell responses were demonstrated in the majority (80%) of cervical cancer patients, but are obviously ineffective. Our study reveals significant differences in HPV16 immunity during progressive CIN. We conclude that the HPV-specific CD4+ T-cell response should be an important consideration in immunotherapy design, which should aim to target preinvasive disease.

Evasion of host immunity directed by papillomavirus-encoded proteins

The nature of the interaction between papillomaviruses (PV) and their infected host has led to the identification of ways in which the viral oncoproteins can transform the infected host cells into cancer cells. As viral persistence is required for malignancy, and persistence requires avoidance of immune attack by the host, defining the relationship between PV and the immune system is also paramount in understanding tumorigenesis. It has emerged that PV have evolved several ways in which to prevent clearance by the host immune system. The limitation of the PV replication cycle to the epithelium, together with low level expression of the virus proteins and an absence of inflammation, minimises the exposure of virus to immune cells. In addition, more recently it has been shown that, like many other viruses, PV can directly subvert the immune response, including interference with the interferon pathway, modulation of antigen presentation, inhibition of interleukin-18 activity and down-regulation of major histocompatibility class I on infected cells. Collectively these mechanisms explain how PV lesions are able to persist for long periods of time in immunocompetent hosts.

Cytokine profile of draining lymph node lymphocytes in mice grafted with syngeneic keratinocytes expressing human papillomavirus type 16 E7 protein

Studies on the immune response to human papillomaviruses are compromised by the extreme host and tissue specificity of these viruses. To circumvent this, a mouse model system has been used in which antigen is presented via a differentiated, syngeneic keratinocyte graft expressing human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) E7 protein. Using this model, previous studies have shown that animals grafted with a high cell inoculum (1x10(7) NEK 16 cells) exhibit a delayed-type hypersensitivity response that is E7-specific and CD4(+)-mediated, but those receiving a low cell inoculum (5x10(5) NEK 16 cells) are rendered unresponsive to subsequent and repeated antigen challenge. To investigate the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon, we have analysed the early changes in the cytokine profile of the graft-draining lymph node (GDLN) after high- or low-dose grafts. At 4 days post-grafting, there was a peak secretion of IL-2 associated with a decreased secretion of IL-4 by gammadelta-TCR(+) cells in the group receiving 1x10(7) NEK 16 cells. At 5 days post-grafting, there was a peak secretion of IL-10 by CD8(+) cells in both the high- and low-dose graft groups compared with controls. In contrast, low dose-grafted animals showed an increase in IL-4 production by CD8(+) cells at this time-point. Low antigen challenge in this model system is associated with the appearance of a CD8(+) population in the GDLN that secretes both IL-4 and IL-10. This population may represent a Tc2 or Ts subset that could induce further unresponsiveness.

The immunology of animal papillomaviruses

Papillomaviruses are species- and tissue-specific double-stranded DNA viruses. These viruses cause epithelial tumours in many animals, including man. Typically, the benign warts undergo spontaneous, immune-mediated regression, most likely effected by T-cells (especially CD4, but also CD8 subsets), whereas humoral immunity can prevent new infections. Some papillomavirus infections fail to regress spontaneously and others progress to malignant epithelial tumours. Additionally, the impact of these lesions is greater in immunosuppressed individuals. Many therapies are ineffective, and there is much interest in the potential for immunological intervention in papillomavirus infections of man and animals. Vaccination can be achieved with 'live' virus, formalin-inactivated virus, synthetic virus-like particles, and DNA vaccination. There has been much recent progress in the development of such vaccines for papillomavirus infections in the rabbit, ox and dog. Success in these animal models suggests that similar approaches may prove useful for prophylactic or therapeutic vaccination against the important human papillomaviruses involved in the development of cutaneous and anogenital warts, laryngeal papillomatosis, and cervical cancer.

Potential strategies utilised by papillomavirus to evade host immunity

The co-evolution of papillomaviruses (PV) and their mammalian hosts has produced mechanisms by which PV might avoid specific and non-specific host immune responses. Low level expression of PV proteins in infected basal epithelial cells, together with an absence of inflammation and of virus-induced cell lysis, restricts the opportunity for effective PV protein presentation to immunocytes by dendritic cells. Additionally, PV early proteins, by a range of mechanisms, may restrict the efficacy of antigen presentation by these cells. Should an immune response be induced to PV antigens, resting keratinocytes (KC) appear resistant to interferon-gamma-enhanced mechanisms of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL)-mediated lysis, and expression of PV antigens by resting KC can tolerise PV-specific CTL. Thus, KC, in the absence of inflammation, may represent an immunologically privileged site for PV infection. Together, these mechanisms play a part in allowing persistence of PV-induced proliferative skin lesions for months to years, even in immunocompetent hosts.

Radiation-enhanced expression of E6/E7 transforming oncogenes of human papillomavirus-16 in human cervical carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection represents the most important risk factor for cervical carcinoma. Levels of expression of E6 and E7 transforming oncoproteins of high risk HPV genotypes (i.e., HPV-16 and HPV-18) have been linked specifically to the mitotic activity of cervical carcinoma and appear to be necessary for maintaining the malignant phenotype. However, E6/E7 viral proteins recently have been reported to be effective tumor rejection antigens in animal models and humans. Radiation treatment represents a standardized and effective modality for contemporary cervical carcinoma therapy. However, although the physiologic and cellular changes associated with high doses of irradiation have been well documented it has been shown only recently that an increased synthesis of specific cellular proteins is observed after irradiation. In this study, the authors analyzed the effects of high doses of gamma irradiation on the expression of E6/E7 oncoproteins in HPV-16-infected cervical carcinoma cell lines. In addition, the effects of radiation on major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction elements also were studied.

METHODS

The effect of high doses of gamma irradiation (i.e., 1250, 2500, 5000, and 10,000 centigray [cGy]) on the kinetics of E6/E7 oncoprotein expression in two HPV-16 positive cervical carcinoma cell lines (i.e., CaSki and SiHa) was evaluated by Northern blot analysis. In addition, the effect of radiation on the expression of MHC molecules also was studied by Northern blot and fluorescence activator cell sorter (FACS) analysis.

RESULTS

Dose ranging from 1250 (sublethal) to 10,000 (lethal) cGy significantly increased the expression of E6/E7 oncoproteins as well as MHC Class I molecules in CaSki and SiHa cell lines when compared with untreated tumor cells. Both cell lines showed increased mRNA expression for MHC Class I molecules in a dose-dependent manner. E6/E7 oncoproteins also were up-regulated in a dose-dependent manner in the CaSki cell line, whereas in the SiHa cell line their expression plateau at 5000 cGy. When the kinetics of radiation-induced up-regulation of E6/E7 were studied, persistent up-regulation of the viral oncoproteins was noted for all doses of irradiation, with the lower and sublethal doses (i.e., 1250-2500 cGy) inducing the most significant enhancement.

CONCLUSIONS

High doses of irradiation can induce a significant and long-lasting up-regulation of E6/E7 oncogenes and MHC Class I restriction elements on HPV positive cervical carcinoma cell lines. These effects by themselves suggest that irradiation could enhance local tumor immunogenicity in patients receiving radiation therapy. However, in contrast to this possible beneficial effect, sublethal tumor irradiation (up-regulating E6/E7 transforming oncoproteins) also could confer a significant growth advantage to radiation-resistant tumor cells. These findings, combined with the previously reported acquisition of a radiation-induced drug resistance, could provide a biologic basis for the poor prognosis of patients with cervical carcinoma recurrence after radiation therapy.

Split tolerance to a viral antigen expressed in thymic epithelium and keratinocytes

When expressed as a transgene from the keratin 14 (K14) promoter in an MHC class II-deficient mouse, I-Ab expressed in thymic cortical epithelium promotes positive but not negative selection of I-Ab-restricted CD4+ T cells (Laufer, T. M. et al., Nature 1996. 383:81-85). Transgenic mice expressing the E7 protein of human papilloma virus 16 from the K14 promoter were studied to determine the consequence of expression of a cytoplasmic/ nuclear protein from the K14 promoter. K14E7-transgenic mice express E7 in the thymus and skin without evidence for autoimmunity to E7. Repeated immunization of FVB(H-2q) or F1(C57BL/6JxFVB) mice with E7 elicited similar antibody responses to the defined B cell epitopes of E7 in K14E7-transgenic and non-transgenic animals. In contrast, for each genetic background, a single immunization with E7 elicited demonstrable T cell proliferative responses to the major promiscuous T helper epitope of E7 in the transgenic but not the non-transgenic animals. Further, E7-immunized non-transgenic F1 (FVBxC57BL/6J) animals developed strong E7-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses and were protected against challenge with E7+ tumors, whereas similarly immunized K14E7-transgenic animals had a markedly reduced CTL response to E7 and no E7-specific tumor protection was observed, although the antibody and CTL response to ovalbumin was normal. Expression of E7 protein as a transgene from the K14 promoter in the skin and thymus thus induces E7-specific tolerance in the cytotoxic T effector repertoire, together with expansion of the E7-specific T helper repertoire. These findings demonstrate that limited tissue distribution of an autoantigen may result in "split" tolerance to that autoantigen.

Immunomanipulative strategies for the control of human papillomavirus associated cervical disease

Three vaccine strategies that target human papillomavirus (HPV) are likely to be effective in the control of HPV-associated preneoplastic and neoplastic lesions of the uterine cervix. 1. Immunotherapy for HPV-associated cervical cancer targeted at two nonstructural PV proteins expressed in cancer cells (E6 and E7). 2. Vaccines against existing HPV infection and early premalignant lesions targeted at early viral proteins expressed in suprabasal stem cells of infected anogenital epithelium. 3. Prophylactic vaccines to prevent HPV infection involving immunization with genetically engineered virus-like particles to elicit neutralizing antibody. Strategies 1 and 2 will need to evoke cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) mediated responses.

Immunology of papillomavirus infection

Studies of the immunology of papillomavirus infection have come of age. Synthetic virus-like particles have been validated as vaccines for several animal papillomaviruses, and have been used to map the sero-epidemiology of human papillomavirus infection and to define papillomavirus neutralizing antibodies. Induction of cell-mediated immunity to papillomavirus early proteins is poised to become a therapeutic approach to papillomavirus infection. Studies on the immune response to papillomavirus proteins in keratinocytes are shedding light on the immunological consequences of antigen presentation by epithelial cells.

The interaction between human papillomavirus type 16 E1 and E2 proteins is blocked by an antibody to the N-terminal region of E2

Replication of papillomavirus DNA requires two virally encoded proteins, E1 and E2. We expressed human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16 E1 and E2 in bacteria and showed that purified full-length E2 protein interacted directly with E1, in the absence of HPV16 DNA. It was established that the first 142 amino acids of E1 were not required for binding as E2 protein was able to interact with E1 devoid of this region. The interaction of E2 with E1 could be blocked by a monoclonal antibody that bound E2 in the region of amino acids 18-41 of E2 whereas a monoclonal antibody reactive with a nearby part of the molecule (amino acids 2-17) only partially blocked this interaction. These results suggest that a region in the N-terminus of E2 around amino acids 18-41 is a site of interaction with the E1 protein.

Immunology of the human papilloma virus in relation to cancer

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) have been associated with benign and malignant epithelial proliferations in either skin or mucosa. Two HPV oncogenic proteins, E6 and E7, are important in the induction and maintenance of cellular transformation and are co-expressed in the majority of HPV-containing carcinomas. Therefore, vaccines targeted to these proteins may provide an opportunity to prevent and treat HPV-associated malignancies. The encouraging results from recent experimental vaccination systems in animal models suggest that continued exploration in these systems might lead to trials on human subjects and might allow us to prevent HPV infection or control its potentially life-threatening consequences.