A comparative study on the xenotransplantability of human solid tumors into mice with different genetic immune deficiencies

NSG Mice Provide a Better Spontaneous Model of Breast Cancer Metastasis than Athymic (Nude) Mice

Metastasis is the most common cause of mortality in breast cancer patients worldwide. To identify improved mouse models for breast cancer growth and spontaneous metastasis, we examined growth and metastasis of both estrogen receptor positive (T47D) and negative (MDA-MB-231, SUM1315, and CN34BrM) human breast cancer cells in nude and NSG mice. Both primary tumor growth and spontaneous metastases were increased in NSG mice compared to nude mice. In addition, a pattern of metastasis similar to that observed in human breast cancer patients (metastases to the lungs, liver, bones, brain, and lymph nodes) was found in NSG mice. Furthermore, there was an increase in the metastatic burden in NSG compared to nude mice that were injected with MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells in an intracardiac experimental metastasis model. This data demonstrates that NSG mice provide a better model for studying human breast cancer metastasis compared to the current nude mouse model.

An improved model to study tumor cell autonomous metastasis programs using MTLn3 cells and the Rag2(-/-) gammac (-/-) mouse

The occurrence of metastases is a critical determinant of the prognosis for breast cancer patients. Effective treatment of breast cancer metastases is hampered by a poor understanding of the mechanisms involved in the formation of these secondary tumor deposits. To study the processes of metastasis, valid in vivo tumor metastasis models are required. Here, we show that increased expression of the EGF receptor in the MTLn3 rat mammary tumor cell-line is essential for efficient lung metastasis formation in the Rag mouse model. EGFR expression resulted in delayed orthotopic tumor growth but at the same time strongly enhanced intravasation and lung metastasis. Previously, we demonstrated the critical role of NK cells in a lung metastasis model using MTLn3 cells in syngenic F344 rats. However, this model is incompatible with human EGFR. Using the highly metastatic EGFR-overexpressing MTLn3 cell-line, we report that only Rag2^−/−γc^−/− mice, which lack NK cells, allow efficient lung metastasis from primary tumors in the mammary gland. In contrast, in nude and SCID mice, the remaining innate immune cells reduce MTLn3 lung metastasis formation. Furthermore, we confirm this finding with the orthotopic transplantation of the 4T1 mouse mammary tumor cell-line. Thus, we have established an improved in vivo model using a Rag2^−/− γc^−/− mouse strain together with MTLn3 cells that have increased levels of the EGF receptor, which enables us to study EGFR-dependent tumor cell autonomous mechanisms underlying lung metastasis formation. This improved model can be used for drug target validation and development of new therapeutic strategies against breast cancer metastasis formation.

In vivo biosafety model to assess the risk of adverse events from retroviral and lentiviral vectors

Serious adverse events in some human gene therapy clinical trials have raised safety concerns when retroviral or lentiviral vectors are used for gene transfer. We evaluated the potential for generating replication-competent retrovirus (RCR) and assessed the risk of occurrence of adverse events in an in vivo system. Human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSCs) and mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) transduced with two different Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoMuLV)-based vectors were cotransplanted into a total of 481 immune-deficient mice (that are unable to reject cells that become transformed), and the animals were monitored for 18 months. Animals with any signs of illness were immediately killed, autopsied, and subjected to a range of biosafety studies. There was no detectable evidence of insertional mutagenesis leading to human leukemias or solid tumors in the 18 months during which the animals were studied. In 117 serum samples analyzed by vector rescue assay there was no detectable RCR. An additional 149 mice received HSCs transduced with lentiviral vectors, and were followed for 2-6 months. No vector-associated adverse events were observed, and none of the mice had detectable human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) p24 antigen in their sera. Our in vivo system, therefore, helps to provide an assessment of the risks involved when retroviral or lentiviral vectors are considered for use in clinical gene therapy applications.

Role of natural killer cells in hormone-independent rapid tumor formation and spontaneous metastasis of breast cancer cells in vivo

Natural killer (NK) cells play a central role in host defense against tumor and virus-infected cells. Direct role of NK cells in tumor growth and metastasis remains to be elucidated. We here demonstrated that NOD/SCID/gammac(null) (NOG) mice lacking T, B and NK cells inoculated with breast cancer cells were efficient in the formation of a large tumor and spontaneous organ-metastasis. In contrast, breast cancer cells produced a small tumor at inoculated site in T and B cell knock-out NOD/SCID mice with NK cells while completely failed to metastasize into various organs. Immunosupression of NOD/SCID by treatment with an anti-murine TM-beta1 antibody, which transiently abrogates NK cell activity in vivo, resulted in enhancing tumor formation and organ-metastasis in comparison with non-treated NOD/SCID mice. Activated NK cells inhibited tumor growth in vivo. The rapid and efficient engraftment of the breast cancer cells in NOG mice suggests that this new animal model could provide a unique opportunity to understand and investigate the mechanism of tumor cell growth and metastasis. Our results suggest that NK cells play an important role in cancer growth and metastasis and could be a promising immunotherapeutic strategy against cancer either alone or in combination with conventional therapy.

Natural killer cells in breast cancer cell growth and metastasis in SCID mice

Natural killer (NK) cell is an important component of the innate immune system and plays a central role in host defense against tumor and virus-infected cells. This review briefly summarizes the role of murine NK cells in tumor growth and metastasis of breast cancer cells in severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice. Conventional SCID and NOD-SCID strains have been used to study for xenotransplantion of human tumors. SCID mice models of cancer mimic human diseases and have provided valuable information. However, these mice strains have some residual immunity such as NK cells that somewhat limit post-transplantation growth and metastasis of human xenografts. In contrast, NOD/SCID/gammac(null) (NOG) mice without common gamma-chain inoculated with breast cancer cells were most efficient in the formation of a large tumor and metastasis. NOG mouse strain without NK activity appears to be more promising as tool for xenotransplantion of human cancer. This new xenotransplant model is relevant and can be recommended for use in clarifying the mechanism of growth of cancer cells as well as for developing new therapeutic strategies against cancer.

Hodgkin's lymphoma cells are efficiently engrafted and tumor marker CD30 is expressed with constitutive nuclear factor-kappaB activity in unconditioned NOD/SCID/gammac(null) mice

As there are very few reproducible animal models without conditioning available for the study of human B-cell-type Hodgkin's lymphoma (HL), we investigated the ability of HL cells to induce tumors using novel NOD/SCID/gammac(null) (NOG) mice. Four human Epstein-Barr virus-negative cell lines (KM-H2 and L428 originated from B cells, L540 and HDLM2 originated from T cells) were inoculated either subcutaneously in the postauricular region or intravenously in the tail of unmanipulated NOG mice. All cell lines successfully engrafted and produced tumors with infiltration of cells in various organs of all mice. Tumor cells had classical histomorphology as well as expression patterns of the tumor marker CD30, which is a cell surface antigen expressed on HL. Tumor progression in mice inoculated with B-cell-type, but not T-cell-type, HL cells correlated with an elevation in serum human interleukin-6 levels. Tumor cells from the mice also retained strong nuclear factor (NF)-kappaB DNA binding activity, and the induced NF-kappaB components were indistinguishable from those cultured in vitro. The reproducible growth behavior and preservation of characteristic features of both B-cell-type and T-cell-type HL in the mice suggest that this new xenotransplant model can provide a unique opportunity to understand and investigate the mechanism of pathogenesis and malignant cell growth, and to develop novel anticancer therapies.

Efficient engraftment of human primary breast cancer transplants in nonconditioned NOD/Scid mice

We describe a new human tumor xenotransplant animal model that is highly efficient for engraftment, does not need host conditioning and is suitable for in vivo studies of human tumors. Pieces of 61 freshly operated primary breast tumors were implanted into 172 irradiated and 228 nonconditioned NOD/Scid mice. A high mortality was observed in irradiated but not in nonconditioned recipients. More than 90% of analyzed implanted breast cancer specimens engrafted in the NOD/Scid mice irrespective of pretreatment. The tumors were vascularized within 3 days of implantation and maintained original histomorphology as well as expression patterns of tumor markers (cytokeratin and MUC1) and cytokines (tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin-4 (IL-4) and IL-10) released by adjacent stromal cells. A majority of tumors grew slowly, locally infiltrating host tissue, whereas some grew aggressively, developing large, fatal tumor masses and metastases within regional lymph nodes. Tumor progression in mice correlated with stage, grade, proliferation index and hormone receptor status of primary tumors. The reproducible growth behavior and preservation of characteristic features suggest that this new xenotransplant model is relevant and can be recommended for testing new anticancer therapies.

Myogenic cell proliferation and generation of a reversible tumorigenic phenotype are triggered by preirradiation of the recipient site

Environmental influences have profound yet reversible effects on the behavior of resident cells. Earlier data have indicated that the amount of muscle formed from implanted myogenic cells is greatly augmented by prior irradiation (18 Gy) of the host mouse muscle. Here we confirm this phenomenon, showing that it varies between host mouse strains. However, it is unclear whether it is due to secretion of proliferative factors or reduction of antiproliferative agents. To investigate this further, we have exploited the observation that the immortal myogenic C2 C12 cell line forms tumors far more rapidly in irradiated than in nonirradiated host muscle. We show that the effect of preirradiation on tumor formation is persistent and dose dependent. However, C2 C12 cells are not irreversibly compelled to form undifferentiated tumor cells by the irradiated muscle environment and are still capable of forming large amounts of muscle when reimplanted into a nonirradiated muscle. In a clonal analysis of this effect, we discovered that C2 C12 cells have a bimodal propensity to form tumors; some clones form no tumors even after extensive periods in irradiated graft sites, whereas others rapidly form extensive tumors. This illustrates the subtle interplay between the phenotype of implanted cells and the factors in the muscle environment.

Metastatic behavior of human tumors in congenitally athymic nude mice: intrinsic properties of the tumor cells and host immune reactivity

Congenitally athymic nude (nu/nu) mice have been used extensively as hosts to study the metastatic properties of xenografted human tumors. It has not been fully explored to what extent the metastatic behavior of human tumor xenografts reflects the intrinsic properties of the tumor cells and to what extent it is influenced artificially by the host. The purpose of the work reported here was to evaluate the potential usefullness of athymic mice for qualitative and quantitative assessment of the intrinsic metastatic properties of human tumor cells. Four human melanoma cell lines (A-07, D-12, R-18, U-25) were included in the study. Quantitative intradermal and intracranial transplantation assays were used to determine the tumorigenicity and immunogenicity of the cell lines. The metastatic behavior of the cell lines was studied by inoculating cells intra-arterially or intravenously (artificial metastases) or intradermally (spontaneous metastases). The influence of the host on the incidence of metastases was assessed by inoculating cells intravenously in immunologically modified athymic mice. Both the intradermal and intracranial tumorigenicity differed substantially between the cell lines. The host immune reactivity against heterotransplantation was significantly lower for D-12 than for A-07, R-18 and U-25 cells. The incidence of metastases was influenced significantly by the host immune reactivity. The cell lines showed organ-specific metastatic patterns in athymic mice. The organs of preference were lungs for A-07 and D-12 cells, lymph nodes for R-18 cells, and brain for U-25 cells. The organ-specific metastatic pattern in athymic mice reflected the pattern of distant metastases in the donor patients. In addition, all cell lines gave rise to metastases in abdominal organ sites, but without organ specificity. The incidence of abdominal metastases was influenced significantly by the tumorigenicity of the cell lines. In conclusion, athymic mice appear to be excellent hosts for assessment of the organ specificity in the metastatic behavior of human tumors. The metastasis frequency of human tumors in athymic mice, however, might be a misleading quantitative measure of the intrinsic metastatic propensity of the tumor cells, owing to the cell-line-dependent host immune reactivity.

Tissue response to particulate polymethylmethacrylate in mice with various immune deficiencies

We examined the tissue response to subcutaneous injections of particulate polymethylmethacrylate powder in fully immunocompetent C3Hf/Sed mice as well as three strains of mice with different levels of lymphocyte dysfunction. Five weeks after the injection, we found clearly demarcated granulomas. Histological and immunohistochemical studies showed that these granulomas were similar among all strains, with either paucity or absence of lymphoid cells. In situ hybridization with use of complementary RNA probes indicated that macrophages were synthesizing interleukin-1 beta messenger RNA (mRNA), a marker of macrophage activation, and a cytokine implicated in pathological bone resorption. We concluded that, in mice, there is a lymphocyte-independent pathway of macrophage activation in response to particulate polymethylmethacrylate. This suggests that the foreign-body response to particulate orthopaedic biomaterials is macrophage-initiated and maintained and that lymphocytes are not essential to this response, although they may modulate it.

Cytotoxic cells in immunodeficient athymic mice

A studies of cytotoxic cells in athymic nude mice demonstrate higher cytotoxic activity of NK cells and macrophages than in their euthymic counterparts. The higher level of endogenous cytotoxic activity can be considered as complementary to the deficiency or lack of thymus dependent T lymphocytes and their functions. However, with increased age of mice some T lymphocytes and their functions can be demonstrated. By stimulation of splenocytes and lymph node cells in vitro with IL-2 or anti CD3 antibody cytotoxic activity towards P-815 (NK resistant, LAK sensitive) target cells can be generated. There exist data, which indicate that the cytotoxic activity is exerted by extrathymic pre-T lymphocytes with TcR gamma delta antigenic phenotype. The differences in transplantability of human tumors in athymic nude mice cannot be explained by defect in antigen recognition and in immune response of athymic nude mice, recipients of the xenografted material. The biological relevance in vivo of high endogenous cytotoxicity of NK cells observed in many strains of athymic nude mice remains obscure. The availability of new immunodeficient mouse models, e.g. scid mice deficient in B and T lymphocytes and with low level of NK cells, in which not only xenografted human tumor grow but human lymphoid cell can be transplanted as well, opens new and broader experimental possibilities, in which new preclinical immunotherapeutical approaches can be applied.

Comparative studies between nude and scid mice on the growth and metastatic behavior of xenografted human tumors

The growth and metastatic behavior of three human tumor cell lines and a human colon carcinoma previously passaged in vivo were compared between nude mice and scid mice after xenotransplantation. The three human tumor lines included a bladder carcinoma (T24B), a melanoma (RPMI 7931) and a lacZ gene-transduced breast cancer (MDA-MB-435 BAG). The lacZ gene codes for beta-galactosidase, which can be stained blue with chromogenic substrate X-gal, thus allowing the highly sensitive detection and quantitative examination of human cancer metastasis in host mice. Adult (7-14 weeks) NMRI nude and C.B-17 SCID mice were inoculated with 0.5-5 x 10(6) tumor cells s.c. Comparable take rate, latent period and growth rate of implanted tumors were observed in nude and scid mice for each of the cell lines tested. At the time of autopsy, which varied from 6 to 11 weeks after inoculation, a significantly higher incidence of spontaneous lung metastasis was discovered in scid mice (96%) than in age-matched nude mice (27%, total P less than 0.001). In vitro assays for NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity revealed no significant differences between the two strains of mice. Our results suggest that nude and scid mice are equally suitable for propagating human tumors. However, the metastatic capacity of human tumor cells appears to be better expressed in scid mice. Scid mice may therefore provide an advantageous model for the study of human tumor metastasis.

Role of transfection and clonal selection in mediating radioresistance

Transfected oncogenes have been reported to increase the radioresistance of rodent cells. Whether transfected nononcogenic DNA sequences and subsequent clonal selection can result in radioresistant cell populations is unknown. The present set of experiments describe the in vitro radiosensitivity and tumorigenicity of selected clones of primary rat embryo cells and human glioblastoma cells, after transfection with a neomycin-resistance marker (pSV2neo or pCMVneo) and clonal selection. Radiobiological data comparing the surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) and the mean inactivation dose show the induction of radioresistance in two rat embryo cell clones and one glioblastoma clone, as compared to untransfected cells. Wild-type and transfectant clones were injected into three strains of immune-deficient mice (scid, NIH, and nu/nu) to assay for tumorigenicity and metastatic potential. Only the glioblastoma parent line and its transfectant clones were tumorigenic. None of the cells produced spontaneous or experimentally induced metastases. Flow cytometric analyses indicated that the induction of radioresistance could not be attributed to changes in cell kinetics at the time of irradiation. Our results show that transfection of a neomycin-resistance marker and clonal selection can impart radioresistance on both normal and tumor cells. The work also indicates that altered radiation sensitivity does not necessarily correlate with changes in cell-cycle kinetics at the time of irradiation, tumorigenicity, or altered metastatic potential. Our findings have critical implications for transfection studies investigating determinants of cellular radiosensitivity.