Relationship between sensitivity to natural killer cells and MHC class-I antigen expression in colon carcinoma cell lines

Expression in cytotoxic T lymphocytes of a single-chain anti-carcinoembryonic antigen antibody. Redirected Fas ligand-mediated lysis of colon carcinoma

In the MD45 mouse cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) hybridoma cell line, we have expressed a chimeric receptor, consisting of the single-chain variable domains (scFv) of anti-carcinoma embryonic antigen (CEA) mAb linked to Fcgamma receptor (FcgammaR) chain via a CD8 hinge. Transfected MD45 subclones lysed CEA-positive human colon carcinoma cell lines in an antigen-specific and FasL-dependent manner. The degree of lysis correlated with the level of chimeric receptor expressed on transduced MD45 subclones. The requirement for an intact Y65TGL motif in the signaling gamma chain suggested that interaction of the chimeric receptor with target cell CEA induced the cytotoxicity of MD45-scFv subclones. However, MD45 expressing a Y65F mutant chimera still displayed minor levels of lysis following PMA stimulation, suggesting that PMA could bypass gamma chain induction of functional FasL. Pretreatment of Fas-resistant CEA-positive colon carcinoma target cells with IFN-gamma increased their sensitivity of MD45-scFv subclones and FasL-mediated lysis. This study has demonstrated the successful activation of FasL function via a chimeric receptor introduced into lymphocytes and the susceptibility of human colon carcinoma to combined cytokine and CTL treatment.

Immunization against a rat colon carcinoma by sodium butyrate-treated cells but not by interleukin 2-secreting cells

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Vaccination of patients with colon cancer with irradiated autologous tumor cells and bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) was reported to augment mean survival. It was recently observed that a local treatment combining recombinant interleukin 2 and the differentiation agent sodium butyrate cured rats with colon cancer peritoneal carcinomatosis. To optimize vaccination protocols, the comparison of the efficacy of irradiated tumor cells mixed with BCG with that of interleukin 2-gene-transfected cells and of tumor cells pretreated with sodium butyrate was performed.

METHODS

The poorly immunogenic rat colon carcinoma cells PROb were used in a vaccination assay. Interleukin 2-transfected PROb cells, either proliferating or irradiated, were used. The efficiency of irradiated PROb cells mixed with BCG, of interleukin 2-transfected cells, or of cells pretreated with sodium butyrate was tested.

RESULTS

Vaccination with irradiated parental cells and BCG did not provide protection. Irradiated interleukin 2-transfected cells were poorly efficient in the vaccination assay. Conversely, vaccination with irradiated parental cells pretreated with sodium butyrate before injection provided good protection.

CONCLUSIONS

Interleukin 2-secreting cells efficiently vaccinated animals when injected while replicating but not after irradiation. Conversely, sodium butyrate pretreatment provided a simple and efficient vaccination scheme that generated a long-term immune memory and allowed the use of irradiated cells.

Susceptibility of colorectal-carcinoma cells to natural-killer-mediated lysis: relationship to CEA expression and degree of differentiation

This study addresses the relevance of colorectal-carcinoma-cell (CRC) CEA expression and degree of differentiation in natural-killer(NK)-mediated lysis susceptibility. A 51Cr-release cytotoxicity assay performed with 5 human CRC lines demonstrated that CRC CEA expression was related to resistance to NK lysis. Moreover, the addition of anti-CEA Fab fragments to the assay led to a significant increase of lysability of high-CEA-producing and NK-resistant cells (LS 174-T), whereas purified CEA drastically reduced lysis of low-CEA-producing and NK-susceptible cells (LISP-I) in a dose-dependent manner. These results strongly suggest that CEA plays a causal role in CRC resistance to NK lysis. Nevertheless, our data did not demonstrate CEA binding to effector cell surface, suggesting that CEA expression can protect CRC, possibly by preventing NK-tumor-cell adhesion to occur. Our results also show that CRC susceptibility to NK lysis was related to a less differentiated phenotype. HCT-8, which are poorly differentiated and low-CEA-producing cells, were cultured in vitro in the presence of the differentiation agent sodium butyrate. Treated cells became less susceptible to NK lysis as they progressed towards a more differentiated phenotype. However, CEA production was not altered upon differentiation. Our study thus demonstrates that both features, CEA expression and degree of cellular differentiation, may individually influence CRC susceptibility to NK lysis.

Analysis of the relationship between stage of differentiation and NK/LAK susceptibility of colon carcinoma cells

NK and LAK cells which are able to lyse tumor target cells in an MHC-unrestricted manner are not equally effective against targets of the same nature. In the case of colorectal tumors, some cells are highly sensitive, whereas others are resistant to NK and can even be quite resistant to LAK-mediated lysis. In the present paper, we tried to correlate the stage of differentiation of 17 human colorectal tumor cell lines with their NK- or LAK-cell susceptibility. It was observed that NK cells killed colorectal target cells independently from their stage of differentiation defined according to histopathological criteria from xenografting in nude mice. NK susceptibility was not correlated either with in vitro-defined criteria of differentiation, such as cell polarity and morphology, brush-border enzyme expression and CEA production. A LAK-resistant HT-29 sub-line (HT-29 LAK) was selected which could not be distinguished from HT-29 in terms of features of differentiation. It was further observed that HT-29 Glc-/+ cell line, a highly differentiated enterocytic-like variant of HT-29, obtained after glucose starvation, was killed by LAK cells as efficiently as the moderately differentiated parental HT-29, and that Caco-2 cells, which differentiate spontaneously after confluence in standard culture conditions, were equally sensitive to NK-mediated lysis whatever their stage of differentiation. In contrast, HT29 MTX10(-5), a highly differentiated mucus-secreting variant of HT29 obtained by methotrexate selection, was much more resistant to LAK cells than parental HT29 cells.

Modulatory effect of cytokines on natural killer and antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity directed to squamous cell carcinoma targets by lymphocytes from oral cancer patients

Cells from solid tumours are generally poor targets for natural killer (NK) cytotoxicity and antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC). In this paper, we have analysed NK cytotoxicity and ADCC mediated by peripheral blood mononuclear cells from healthy individuals and oral cancer patients before and after modulation with recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2), on target cells derived from two squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) cell lines prior to and after treatment with recombinant interferon-alpha (rIFN alpha). Target SCC cell directed monoclonal antibody 3F8E3 was used in ADCC. The results showed that the unmodulated SCC cells were poor targets for NK and ADCC compared to standard targets (K562 cells and chicken red blood cells, respectively). Modulation of targets alone with rIFN alpha showed moderate increase in their susceptibility while rIL-2 treated effectors could significantly lyse even unmodulated targets. Combined treatment of targets with rIFN alpha and effectors with rIL-2 showed additive enhancement in NK and ADCC activity against SCC cells. Lymphocytes from treated patients with recurrent disease could not efficiently lyse SCC targets even after combined modulation.

Analysis of factors associated with the tumorigenic potential of 12 tumor clones derived from a single rat colon adenocarcinoma

We analyzed several factors which could influence the immunogenicity of colon tumor cells, using a series of clones derived from a single chemically induced rat adenocarcinoma cell line. These clones display variable tumorigenic potential in syngeneic immunocompetent animals, and it has been established that in this model the tumorigenicity of the cells depends on their ability to escape immune surveillance. The results show an absence of relationship between tumorigenicity and expression of MHC-class-I antigens, cell adhesion to rat fibroblasts or fibroblast extracellular matrix. The secretion of latent and active TGF beta I appeared to be quite variable from one clone to the other, but was unrelated to tumorigenicity. Unexpectedly, some regressive clones produced elevated levels of this cytokine, suggesting that in this model, spontaneous secretion of TGF beta I is not sufficient to impair the immune system of the host. In contrast, the more tumorigenic clones were more resistant than less tumorigenic ones to cytotoxicity mediated by NK or LAK cells. They also showed arrest of cell proliferation after reaching confluence, something not observed in the less tumorigenic clones. Finally, the strongest relationship with tumorigenicity was found for expression of blood-group carbohydrate antigens. Increased expression of blood-group-H antigen and, conversely, decreased expression of beta-galactoside precursors of this antigen correlated with increased tumorigenicity.

Involvement of histo-blood-group antigens in the susceptibility of colon carcinoma cells to natural killer-mediated cytotoxicity

The susceptibility to natural-killer-cell lysis and expression of histo-blood-group antigens of 2 clones from a rat colon adenocarcinoma, of variants derived from them and of 17 human colon carcinoma cell lines were assessed in an attempt to determine if the major glycosidic tissue antigens of epithelial cells could influence the NK susceptibility of tumor target cells of epithelial origin. The rat REGb clone, which is relatively NK-sensitive, expressed higher levels of precursor structures T and Tn and lower levels of H antigenic determinants than the PROb clone, which displays higher resistance to NK-cell lysis. Cell variants were obtained from these 2 clones; it appeared that whether the cell variants were selected on the basis of expression of a blood-group antigenic determinant or on the basis of altered susceptibility to NK-cell lysis, there was a link between increased resistance and higher expression of cell-surface A and H histo-blood-group antigens, or conversely, between increased sensitivity and higher expression of precursor structures. Similar conclusions were obtained upon study of the human cell lines, since a significant correlation was found between the level of expression of T or Tn antigens and sensitivity to NK-cell lysis. A significant relationship was found between the expression of Lewis antigens and increased resistance to NK-cell-mediated cytotoxicity.