Molecular detection and identification of an enterovirus during an outbreak of aseptic meningitis

Molecular Epidemiology of Enterovirus in Children with Central Nervous System Infections

Limited recent molecular epidemiology data are available for pediatric Central Nervous System (CNS) infections in Europe. The aim of this study was to investigate the molecular epidemiology of enterovirus (EV) involved in CNS infections in children. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) from children (0–16 years) with suspected meningitis–encephalitis (ME) who were hospitalized in the largest pediatric hospital of Greece from October 2017 to September 2020 was initially tested for 14 common pathogens using the multiplex PCR FilmArray^® ME Panel (FA-ME). CSF samples positive for EV, as well as pharyngeal swabs and stools of the same children, were further genotyped employing Sanger sequencing. Of the 330 children tested with FA-ME, 75 (22.7%) were positive for EV and 50 different CSF samples were available for genotyping. The median age of children with EV CNS infection was 2 months (IQR: 1–60) and 44/75 (58.7%) of them were male. There was a seasonal distribution of EV CNS infections, with most cases detected between June and September (38/75, 50.7%). EV genotyping was successfully processed in 84/104 samples: CSF (n = 45/50), pharyngeal swabs (n = 15/29) and stools (n = 24/25). Predominant EV genotypes were CV-B5 (16/45, 35.6%), E30 (10/45, 22.2%), E16 (6/45, 13.3%) and E11 (5/45, 11.1%). However, significant phylogenetic differences from previous described isolates were detected. No unusual neurologic manifestations were observed, and all children recovered without obvious acute sequelae. Specific EV circulating genotypes are causing a significant number of pediatric CNS infections. Phylogenetic analysis of these predominant genotypes found genetic differences from already described EV isolates.

Molecular characterization of enteroviruses among hospitalized patients in Greece, 2013-2015

BACKGROUND

There are only sporadic data for the circulation of Enteroviruses (EVs) in Greece with previous studies reporting mainly the presence of Echoviruses (E) and Coxsackie viruses (CV) B.

OBJECTIVES

We carried out a surveillance study for the molecular characterization of EVs detected in hospitalized patients throughout Greece as well as a phylogenetic analysis of the most frequently encountered serotypes.

STUDY DESIGN

Stools, cerebrospinal fluids, throat swabs and blood samples were collected from hospitalized patients with suspicion of EV infection. All samples were tested for EVs by rRT-PCR targeting the 5' untranslated region of EV genome. For positive samples, PCR amplification and sequencing targeting a part of VP1 region was performed.

RESULTS

We examined 831 samples and 209 were positive for EVs with Enterovirus B species being the most frequently amplified. E30, CVB5 and E9 were the most frequent serotypes of Enterovirus B species, whereas CVA6 and EV-A71 the most frequent serotypes of Enterovirus A species. Evs were significantly detected more frequently in stool samples compared to other types of specimens. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that most EV-A71 strains clustered in the subgenogroups C2 whereas all the CVA6 strains belonged to sub-genotype D3. Additionally, two different lineages of E30 and three different clusters of E9 viruses circulated simultaneously in Greece. Our data indicated that most EV strains from Greece were similar to strains circulating throughout Europe during the same period.

CONCLUSIONS

We provide a comprehensive picture of EVs circulating in Greece which can be helpful to interpret trends in EV diseases by associating them with circulating serotypes.

An outbreak of aseptic meningitis caused by a distinct lineage of coxsackievirus B5 in China

In 2009, an outbreak of aseptic meningitis caused by coxsackievirus B5 (CVB5) occurred in China. Epidemiological investigations of this outbreak revealed that the proportion of severe cases (14/43, 33%) was higher than in other outbreaks associated with CVB5 in China. Phylogenetic analysis of the entire VP1 sequences demonstrated that the CVB5 isolates from the severe cases form a distinct lineage belonging to genogroup E with the Shandong isolates of 2009. A substitution of serine (S) to asparagine (N) at amino acid 95 in the VP1 region may be a major virulence determinant for the virus. Our findings suggest that this new lineage of CVB5 is circulating in China. Further genetic studies are needed in order to gain a better insight into the genetic variability of CVB5 isolates and the relationship with pathogenicity.

Outbreak of herpangina in the Brazilian Amazon in 2009 caused by Enterovirus B

In October 2009, our laboratory was contacted by a Brazilian Public Health organization regarding a severe community outbreak of an acute exanthematic and febrile disease in the Brazilian Amazon that primarily affected children. A total of 44 patients with febrile disease were identified by the local public health system, 37 of whom were children between 1 and 9 years of age. Molecular virological and phylogenetic characterization revealed that enterovirus B was the etiological agent of this outbreak, which was characterized by a clinical presentation known as herpangina.

Meningitis in children in Fiji: etiology, epidemiology, and neurological sequelae

OBJECTIVES

To describe the etiology, epidemiology, neurological sequelae, and quality of life of children aged 1 month to less than 5 years admitted with meningitis to the Colonial War Memorial Hospital (CWMH), Suva, Fiji.

METHODS

Over a 3-year period, all eligible children with suspected meningitis admitted to CWMH had blood drawn for culture. Of these children, those for whom is was possible were tested for a four-fold rise in antibody titers to Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) and pneumococcal surface adhesin A (PsaA). Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) was taken for bacteriological culture and antigen testing. CSF was also tested by PCR for Streptococcus species, Neisseria meningitidis, Hib, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and enterovirus. Pneumococcal isolates were serotyped using multiplex-PCR reverse-line blot hybridization. Following discharge, cases underwent a neurological assessment, audiometry, and quality of life assessment (Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL) tool).

RESULTS

There were 70 meningitis cases. Meningitis was more common in indigenous Fijian than Indo-Fijian children. Enterovirus was the most common etiological agent and appeared to be outbreak-associated. Streptococcus pneumoniae was the most common bacterial cause of meningitis with an annual incidence of 9.9 per 100 000 under 5 years old (95% confidence interval 4.9-17.7) and a case fatality rate of 36%. With the exception of deafness, neurological sequelae were more frequent in cases of bacterial meningitis than in viral meningitis (18.5% vs. 0%, p=0.04). Quality of life at follow-up was significantly lower in patients with bacterial meningitis than in those with viral meningitis (p=0.003) or meningitis of unknown etiology (p=0.004).

CONCLUSIONS

During the study period an outbreak of enterovirus occurred making it the most common etiological agent identified. However in the absence of this outbreak, S. pneumoniae was the most common cause of childhood meningitis in Fiji. Bacterial meningitis is associated with serious sequelae and a reduced quality of life.

Molecular detection and identification of enteroviruses in children admitted to a university hospital in Greece

Although enteroviral infections occur frequently during childhood, the circulation of particular serotypes has never been studied in Greece. The objectives of the present report were molecular detection and identification of human enteroviruses in children admitted with nonspecific febrile illness or meningitis to a university hospital during a 22-month period. A one-step Real-Time RT-PCR protocol was used for rapid enterovirus detection in genetic material extracted directly from clinical samples, and a sensitive reverse transcription-semi-nested PCR targeting part of the VP1-coding region was used for genotypic identification of the different serotypes. Twenty-one enterovirus strains were detected and identified in 20 stool samples, one cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sample, one whole blood sample and one throat swab from 21 out of 134 febrile patients (15.7%). Ten strains belonged to Human Enterovirus Species B (HEV-B) (six serotypes) and eleven to HEV-A (four serotypes). Most of the strains were closely associated with virulent strains circulating in Europe and elsewhere. Detection of the emerging pathogen enterovirus 71 for a first time in Greece was particularly important.

PCR-SSCP: a method for the molecular analysis of genetic diseases

Single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) is a reproducible, rapid and quite simple method for the detection of deletions/insertions/rearrangements in polymerase chain reaction amplified DNA. All the details for the use of PCR-SSCP are presented in the direction of genetic diseases (beta-thalassaemia, cystic fibrosis), optimum gel conditions, sensitivity and the latest modifications of the method, which are applied in most laboratories. This non-radioactive PCR-SSCP method can be reliably used to identify mutations in patients (beta-globin, CFTR), provided suitable controls are available. Moreover, it is widely used for mutation identification in carriers (beta-thalassaemia, cystic fibrosis), making it particularly useful in population screening.

Enterovirus meningitis in Greece from 2003-2005: diagnosis, CSF laboratory findings, and clinical manifestations

Enteroviruses (EVs) are the most commonly identified cause of aseptic meningitis. Rapid detection and characterization of EV meningitis is essential in making decisions for patient management and treatment. A total of 52 cases of acute aseptic meningitis that occurred from March 2003 to April 2005 were investigated for EVs using viral culture and/or molecular methods directly in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). EVs were detected in 21 out of 52 (40.4%) patients using reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) and/or tissue culture. EVs were isolated from six out of 37 (16.2%) cultured specimens, while 20 out of 52 (38.4%) specimens yielded positive results when 5'non-coding region (5'NCR) RT-PCR assay was used. One specimen that was culture-positive was RT-PCR-negative. Using the VP1-2A RT-PCR and sequence analysis, 14 of the 21 positive EVs were identified as: four strains of Coxsackie virus B5, five echovirus 11, two echovirus 9, one echovirus 5, one echovirus 14, and one Coxsackie virus A9. Fever, headache, vomiting, and stiff neck were the most pronounced symptoms. Pleocytosis with the predominance of lymphocytes and mild elevated protein levels characterized the CSF specimens. Coxsackie virus B5 and echovirus 11 were the predominant serotypes during the study period. Although there was seasonal enteroviral activity (April-November), cases also occurred in the cold months. The 5'NCR and VP1-2A RT-PCR with sequence analysis were found to be superior to conventional methods for direct diagnosis and the typing of EVs.

FDJS03 isolates causing an outbreak of aseptic meningitis in China that evolved from a distinct Echovirus 30 lineage imported from countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States

We compared echovirus 30 strains (FDJS03) which caused an outbreak of aseptic meningitis in China in 2003 with other human enterovirus B strains. Sequencing of the complete genome of FDJS03_84, a representative strain from this outbreak, revealed a mosaic structure with a putative recombination spot within the 2B gene. It was most similar to a strain of the same serotype, E30-14125-00, in the 5' half of the genome but was almost equidistant to all strains analyzed in most of the 3' half of the genome. Phylogenetic relationships in the 5'-untranslated region and the VP1 gene indicated that the FDJS03 isolates were closely related to a distinct lineage of E30 which circulated in countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States during 1999 and 2000. It is most likely that the ancestor of FDJS03 isolates experienced multiple recombination events in the nonstructural protein coding region, which were partly observed in the phylogenetic analysis of the 3D region.

Genetic variation of coxsackie virus B5 strains associated with aseptic meningitis in Greece

In order to explore the genetic relationships among coxsackie virus B5 strains in Greece, the nucleotide sequences of the partial VP1 gene in strains isolated from aseptic cases of meningitis were determined and compared with those of strains isolated from other countries. Phylogenetic analysis showed a high degree of divergence (25%) among Greek strains isolated in different years, which clustered with high bootstrap values in a different subgroup of viruses, suggesting that enterovirus types vary with time rather than geographical distribution. A non-synonymous mutation present in the strains of this study was not observed in other coxsackie virus B5 strains.

Molecular phylogeny of VP1, 2A, and 2B genes of echovirus isolates: epidemiological linkage and observations on genetic variation

Phylogenetic relationships between 37 echovirus clinical isolates, most of them originating from an aseptic meningitis outbreak during 2001 in Greece, were investigated by RT-PCR and sequencing. The generic primers 292 and 222 were used to amplify about 300 bp of the 5' end of VP1 while primers EUG3a, 3b, 3c, and EUC2 amplified the entire coding sequence of the 2A and 2B genes. Phylogenetic trees were constructed for each genomic region using the clinical isolates' sequences and those of the prototype echoviruses in order to investigate the correlation of part of VP1 with the serotype as well as the genetic variation of the echovirus genome in 2A and 2B. The phylogenetic grouping pattern of the clinical isolates revealed that there is a correlation of serotype and genotype in the part of VP1 that was investigated, while this pattern is disrupted in the adjacent genomic regions that were sequenced. Sequence analysis of the adjacent 2A and 2B genes provided a different pattern of phylogenetic relationships and strong evidence of epidemiological linkage of most of the clinical isolates.

Nucleotide analysis and phylogenetic study of the homology boundaries of coxsackie A and B viruses

Modern molecular methods use VP1 coding region as a target for RT-PCR assays followed by sequencing, in order to identify new untyped enteroviruses' strains. In the present study, two different genomic portions of VP1 and the full length of 2A coding region of 53 clinical isolates, mostly belonging to HEV-B species, were amplified and sequenced. Nucleotide analysis of the produced sequences revealed that the values that define an unknown strains serotype vary according to the serotype and the specific part of VP1, which is investigated. The correlation, however, with the serotype was affirmed in both VP1 portions that were studied, as well as in the first 20 bases of 2A region. In the rest of 2A, no correlation with the serotype and disruption of monophyly was observed. Phylogenetic analysis of the same sequences confirmed, in most cases, the results of the nucleotide analysis.

Echovirus 30, Jiangsu Province, China

An outbreak of aseptic meningitis occurred in the northern area of Jiangsu Province in China from January to July in 2003. A total of 1,681 cases were involved in this outbreak, and 99% of patients were <15 years of age. To identify the etiologic agent, 66 cerebrospinal fluid specimens were tested by cell culture. Eighteen showed an enteroviruslike cytopathic effect on MRC-5 human fetal diploid lung cells. An enterovirus primer-mediated reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction, a standard neutralization assay, and sequencing of the complete capsid-encoding (VP1) gene identified the 18 isolates (FDJS03) as echovirus 30. At least a 10% difference was seen in nucleotide sequences of VP1 between FDJS03 isolates and other global strains of echovirus 30. Phylogenetic analysis based on complete sequences of VP1 was performed to further characterize the FDJS03 isolates. This report is the first to identify a distinct lineage of echovirus 30 as a probable cause of this outbreak.

Membrane adsorption with direct cell culture combined with reverse transcription-PCR as a fast method for identifying enteroviruses from sewage

We present a new approach for the detection and identification of enteroviruses concentrated and isolated from sewage. Samples were collected from two study sites located at Nicosia and Limassol sewage treatment plants in Cyprus. Viruses were adsorbed to cellulose nitrate membrane filters, cultured directly from the membrane filters by using the VIRADEN method, and identified by reverse transcription-PCR, followed by 5' untranslated region (5'-UTR) restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis and partial sequencing of the VP1 protein coding region. Initial subgrouping based on the HpaII restriction profile showed that all of the isolates except one belonged to the same genetic subcluster. Partial VP1 sequencing revealed that most isolates belonged to serotypes coxsackie B4 (42.5%) and coxsackie Alpha9 (30%), whereas coxsackie B2 (17.5%) and coxsackie B1 (3%) isolates were less frequently observed. One poliovirus type 2 isolate (2.5%) of vaccine origin was also found. The HpaII digests predicted the genetic subcluster for all isolates. They also accurately differentiated the isolates as nonpolio or polio isolates. This approach seems to be very promising for environmental surveillance of enterovirus circulation and epidemiology, with all of the significant effects that this entails for public health. Partial VP1 sequencing is efficient for molecular serotyping of enteroviruses, while 5'-UTR RFLP analysis with HpaII can also be considered an asset for the initial subclassification of enterovirus isolates.

A comparative amplification of five different genomic regions on Coxsackie A and B viruses. Implications in clinical diagnostics

Modern molecular approaches in Human Enterovirus detection rely on the designing of generic and often degenerate primers in order to amplify specific sequences within the enterovirus genome. In the present study a comparative application of primer sets targeting 5'UTR, the VP1 region, the 3D region as well as a long genomic fragment including the 3'end of VP1, the full length of 2A and 2B, and the 5' moiety of the 2C-coding region was attempted, in order to evaluate their specificity and suitability. The best amplification results from the investigation of 21 CAV reference strains, all six CBV reference strains and 44 clinical strains varying in origin and time of isolation, arose using primer sets 292-222 and UC53-UG52. Based on the above results we conclude that some of the published protocols need to be improved so as to fulfill the demands of an accurate detection and typing of Coxsackie A and B viruses. Contrarily, two of the protocols applied were proved to be more accurate in terms of specificity and general applicability, suggesting that RT-PCR followed by a simple RFLP assay in the case of primer pair UC53-UG52 or by sequencing and sequence analysis in the case of primer set 292-222 should constitute alternative means of modern typing and diagnostics against conventional immunological classification methods.

Amplification of Echoviruses genomic regions by different RT-PCR protocols--a comparative study

In the present report, the results of a comparative study in the detection of all Echoviruses reference strains as well as of 38 clinical isolates are presented. Using RT-PCR with already published primer pairs (UG(52)-UC(53), 292-222, 012-011 and EUG2a, 2b, 2c-EUC2) from the 5'UTR, the VP1 region as well as a long genomic fragment including the VP1 3' end, the entire coding sequence of 2A, 2B, and the 5' moiety of the 2C-coding region amplification was effective with all reference and clinical Echovirus isolates with primer pair UG(52)-UC(53) while with 292-222 and 012-011 were amplified 27/28 reference Echovirus strains and all clinical isolates. As far as EUG2a,2b,2c-EUC2 is concerned, the RT-PCR gave a positive result for 26/28 reference Echovirus strains and 34/38 clinical isolates. The sequence analysis of a large part of the 5'UTR has revealed that there is no correlation between 5'UTR identity and the currently recognized human enterovirus species. It has been suggested that part of VP1 coding sequence would correlate well with serotype since a number of important neutralization epitopes, as well as receptor recognition sequences, lie within the VP1 coding sequence. Therefore, UG(52)-UC(53) and 292-222 primer pairs seem to be the most appropriate for Echovirus detection and, moreover, UG(52)-UC(53) is useful for the classification of enteroviruses into genetic clusters (sub-groups) while 292-222 for the identification of enteroviruses by amplicon sequencing.

Molecular identification of enteroviruses responsible for an outbreak of aseptic meningitis; implications in clinical practice and epidemiology

An outbreak of aseptic meningitis was recorded in Greece during the year 2001. Detection of the clinical strains was achieved by performing reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) on RNA isolated from cell cultures inoculated with treated faecal material from the patients. Serotypic identification of the isolates with mixed equine antisera pools followed and the RT-PCR amplicons were further studied by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis and sequencing. Fifty-three clinical enterovirus strains were isolated from respective cases of suspected enterovirus infection, most of which showed the clinical symptoms of aseptic meningitis. Echovirus (ECV) 6 was the most frequently isolated serotype, followed by coxsackie B viruses, ECV13, poliovirus type 1 (PV1) vaccine strain and ECV30. Nucleotide sequence analysis showed the existence of different genetic groups on the basis of the 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) of the genome, which circulated in the population during the same time period. Different serotypes belonged to the same genetic group and vice versa. The 5'-UTR seems to be appropriate for the investigation of enterovirus evolution and epidemiology.

Molecular sub-grouping of enterovirus reference and wild type strains into distinct genetic clusters using a simple RFLP assay

RFLP analysis and sequencing of RT-PCR amplicons in previous studies revealed the existence of intra-serotypic variability in the 5'-UTR of human enteroviruses, complicating the use of this method to serotype isolates. During the present study, the available sequences of many enterovirus reference and wild type strains were analysed in an attempt to discover restriction sites that would rapidly and reliably aid the classification of human enteroviruses into specific sub-groups on the basis of their 5'-UTR for diagnostic and/or epidemiological purposes. Despite intratypic genetic variability in the 5'-UTR, the results of the sequence analysis, as well as data from the RFLP analysis of 61 enterovirus reference strains from 60 different serotypes and 123 clinical isolates showed that one restriction endonuclease, HpaII, may contribute to a reliable sub-classification of CAVs and the rest of enteroviruses, on the basis of 5'-UTR, into five genetic groups, which could be particularly useful in clinical and epidemiological studies. Although more sequence data from enterovirus reference and wild type strains may be required for the elaboration of a precise molecular identification system, the more possible genotypic classification into distinct clusters, as shown with the restriction enzyme HpaII, and the determination of the biological significance of this grouping (pathogenesis, epidemiology) might constitute an alternative means of enterovirus identification against conventional classification into distinct serotypes.

A reliable RT-PCR/RFLP assay for the molecular classification of enterovirus reference and wild type strains to either of the two genetic clusters on the basis of 5'-UTR

The available sequence data from a large segment of the 5'-UTR of all enterovirus reference and wild type strains were analysed in an attempt to discover possible restriction sites for reliable, serotypic identification of wild type isolates. No combination of restriction endonucleases, though, was found to produce serotype-, or group-specific haplotypes. Thirteen restriction enzymes were predicted to differentiate between representatives of the two enterovirus genetic clusters on the basis of 5'-UTR. One of these enzymes, BstOI, was tested in practice for the differentiation of 61 enterovirus reference strains from 56 different serotypes and 82 wild type strains which belong to the two genetic clusters on the basis of 5'-UTR. All the representatives of the two clusters were successfully differentiated with the specific restriction enzyme. Consequently, the simple RFLP-based assay presented here could be used as a very rapid and reliable means for the initial determination of whether a clinical isolate of unknown identity belongs to either of the 'poliovirus-like', or the 'CBV-like' genetic cluster on the basis of 5'-UTR classification of human enteroviruses.

Variability in molecular typing of Coxsackie A viruses by RFLP analysis and sequencing

The aim of the present study was to develop an assay capable of classifying the Coxsackie A virus (CAV) prototype strains on the basis of restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of 5'-UTR-derived reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) amplicons, and to determine how these data could be used for typing wild-type CAV isolates. Moreover, sequencing of the amplified genomic fragments of the clinical isolates, and comparison with all the published sequences of the respective genomic region of enterovirus reference and wild-type strains were attempted for typing of the isolates. Twenty-four prototype CAV strains from the 23 currently recognized serotypes were studied; most of them were successfully differentiated with the aid of four restriction endonucleases: HaeIII, HpaII, DdeI, and StyI. It was not possible to differentiate between CAV5, 7, and 16, or between CAV15 and 18 in this way, but the members of each of these two groups were satisfactorily differentiated with the aid of single-strand conformational polymorphism (SSCP) analysis of their RT-PCR amplicons. Fifteen clinical isolates, 13 of them of known CAV serotype, were also studied with the same four endonucleases and the results were compared with the data obtained from the RFLP analysis of the reference strains. The experimental results showed that only two clinical samples of previously known identity had an identical restriction pattern with the respective prototype strains. The sequences of the amplicons of the clinical isolates had the greatest percentage of alignment with enterovirus strains of a different serotype, indicating variability in the 5'-UTR and the inability to use the whole sequence of the amplicons for typing CAVs. The significance of the findings in relation to the possible usefulness of the RFLP-based method is discussed.