Exploring the kinetic selectivity of drugs targeting the β1 -adrenoceptor

Time-evolved metrics for safety pharmacological assessments of small molecules and biologics

Safety of a small-molecule drug is oftentimes a more important criterion than efficacy in determining drug approval. Aspects of safety pharmacological and toxicological liabilities, often resulting from dose-dependent undesirable interaction with either the primary target of interest or secondary targets, have a huge role to play in determining 'first-in-human' dosage and phase I clinical trials. Given the open thermodynamic nature of the human subjects, it is mandatory that kinetics of drug-target and drug-off-target interactions govern the way selectivity margins are assessed, and dose is decided. However, lack of sufficient thrust on kinetics in guiding early drug discovery decisions has resulted in an overreliance on IC50 measure (a proxy for thermodynamic Ki) as a means of computing safety across the target of interest and potential off-targets. Moreover, based on established practises and known weight of evidence of targets with safety adverse events, the primary panel of secondary pharmacology targets are biased with greater preference for G-protein coupled receptors, transporters and ion-channels with a paucity of enzymes. This can pose unique challenges in assessing safety, especially for advancing and emergent modalities. In this perspective, the critical role kinetic margins should play in assessing safety is emphasised given the myriad assay conditions that can modulate the equilibrium thermodynamic measure as embodied in the proxy report of IC50. Further, it advocates selective and judicious expansion of primary safety panels with greater representation of enzymes and reduced redundancy in eventual read-outs based on potential for correlative output among the off-target classes assessed.

A universal cannabinoid CB1 and CB2 receptor TR-FRET kinetic ligand-binding assay

Introduction

The kinetics of ligand binding to G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is an important optimization parameter in drug discovery. Traditional radioligand assays are labor-intensive, preventing their application at the early stages of drug discovery. Fluorescence-based assays offer several advantages, including a possibility to develop a homogeneous format, continuous data collection, and higher throughput. This study sought to develop a fluorescence-based binding assay to investigate ligand-binding kinetics at human cannabinoid type 1 and 2 receptors (CB1R and CB2R).

Methods

We synthesized D77, a novel tracer derived from the non-selective cannabinoid Δ8-THC. Using time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET), we developed an assay to study ligand-binding kinetics at physiological temperatures. For CB1R, we truncated the first 90 amino acids of its flexible N-terminal domain to reduce the FRET distance between the terbium cryptate (donor) and the fluorescent ligand (acceptor). The full-length CB2R construct was functional without modification due to its shorter N-terminus. The Motulsky-Mahan competition binding model was used to analyze the binding kinetics of the endocannabinoids and several other non-fluorescent ligands.

Results

The D77 tracer showed nanomolar-range affinity for truncated CB1R (CB1R91-472) and full-length CB2R (CB2R1-360), displaying competitive binding with orthosteric ligands. D77 exhibited rapid dissociation kinetics from both CB1R and CB2R, which were similar to the fastest dissociating reference compounds. This was critical for accurately determining the on- and off-rates of the fastest dissociating compounds. Using D77, we measured the kinetic binding properties of various CB1R and CB2R agonists and antagonists at physiological temperature and sodium ion concentration.

Discussion

The k on values for molecules binding to CB1R varied by three orders of magnitude, from the slowest (HU308) to the fastest (rimonabant). A strong correlation between k on and affinity was observed for compounds binding to CB1R, indicating that the association rate primarily determines their affinity for CB1R. Unlike CB1R, a stronger correlation was found between the dissociation rate constant k off and the affinity for CB2R, suggesting that both k on and k off dictate the overall affinity for CB2R. Exploring the kinetic parameters of cannabinoid drug candidates could help drug development programs targeting these receptors.

High-throughput kinetics in drug discovery

The importance of a drug's kinetic profile and interplay of structure-kinetic activity with PK/PD has long been appreciated in drug discovery. However, technical challenges have often limited detailed kinetic characterization of compounds to the latter stages of projects. This review highlights the advances that have been made in recent years in techniques, instrumentation, and data analysis to increase the throughput of detailed kinetic and mechanistic characterization, enabling its application earlier in the drug discovery process.

β-blockers are not all the same: pharmacologic similarities and differences, potential combinations and clinical implications

β-blockers are a heterogeneous class, with individual agents distinguished by selectivity for β1- vs. β2- and α-adrenoceptors, presence or absence of partial agonist activity at one of more β-receptor subtype, presence or absence of additional vasodilatory properties, and lipophilicity, which determines the ease of entry the drug into the central nervous system. Cardioselectivity (β1-adrenoceptor selectivity) helps to reduce the potential for adverse effects mediated by blockade of β2-adrenoceptors outside the myocardium, such as cold extremities, erectile dysfunction, or exacerbation of asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. According to recently updated guidelines from the European Society of Hypertension, β-blockers are included within the five major drug classes recommended as the basis of antihypertensive treatment strategies. Adding a β-blocker to another agent with a complementary mechanism may provide a rational antihypertensive combination that minimizes the adverse impact of induced sympathetic overactivity for optimal blood pressure-lowering efficacy and clinical outcomes benefit.