Homozygous variegate porphyria in South Africa: genotypic analysis in two cases

Neurodevelopmental retardation and neurological symptoms in homozygous variegate porphyria: two new cases and a literature review

BACKGROUND

Genetic porphyrias, namely in their homozygous form, may cause a neurodevelopmental disorder which may even be the clinically dominant feature. But few cases have been described so far. The majority of neurodevelopmental disorders has a genetic cause and there is a big overlap of the clinical presentations due to unspecific symptoms. Additional specific clinical symptoms may enable a phenotypically orientated biochemical and genetic diagnostic approach. Skin lesions occurring in the neonatal period or the first years of life in a child with developmental delay may hint at a genetic porphyria.

METHODS

We describe the clinical features, biochemical and genetic findings in two new cases, sister and brother, of biallelic resp. homozygous variegate porphyria and review all case reports published until December 2023 after systematic searches in PubMed, MEDLINE, Cochrane and Web of Science.

RESULTS

A total of 19 patients with biallelic, largely homozygous variegate porphyria have so far been reported of whom 16 were confirmed by genetic testing. In 11 patients, neurodevelopmental problems were reported in addition to skin lesions. Additional symptoms were nystagmus, epileptic seizures as well as sensory neuropathy. Only 2 patients received a brain MRI showing a severe deficit of myelination at the age of 2-3 years suggesting that neurodevelopmental delay in HVP may be associated to hypomyelination. This article adds two cases of a genetic porphyria with developmental delay and epilepsy as well as skin lesions. In our two cases biochemistry revealed a porphyria and consecutive molecular genetic testing showed in each case a homozygous variant in the PPOX gene, which corresponds to a variegate porphyria. Interestingly, magnetic resonance imaging of the brain revealed a severe myelin deficit suggesting hypomyelination in both children.

CONCLUSIONS

In children with a developmental disorder of unknown cause and early childhood epilepsy, an abnormally light-sensitive or fragile skin may indicate a primary genetic porphyria. Especially variegate porphyria with biallelic variants may present as neurodevelopmental disorder with hypomyelination.

A boy with blistering of sun-exposed skin and finger shortening: the first case of Variegate Porphyria with a novel mutation in protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) gene in Iran: a case report and literature review

Variegate Porphyria (VP) is an inherited rare disorder that is caused by mutations in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) gene. This deficiency is associated with the accumulation of porphyrins and porphyrin precursors in the body, which, in turn, can potentially result in a variety of skin and neurological symptoms. Here, we reported a 7-year-old boy with homozygous VP and novel mutation on PPOX gene. He was admitted with three episodes of generalized tonic-clonic seizure in the last 6 months. He was presented with lesions, hyperpigmentation, fragility, and blistering of sun-exposed skin. The weakness of limbs and brachydactyly were observed. In the follow-up, he had aggressive behavior, learning disability and abdominal pain, particularly around the navel. Eventually, the whole exome sequencing (WES) result reported a novel homozygous pathogenic variant (c.1072G > A p.G358R) in PPOX gene which confirmed the VP. He had been advised to be away from the sun and use sunscreen regularly.

The acute hepatic porphyrias

The acute hepatic porphyrias (AHP) are a group of four inherited diseases of heme biosynthesis. They present with similar severe, episodic, acute neurovisceral symptoms due to abnormally elevated levels of porphyrin precursors delta-aminolevulinic acid (ALA). Recently genetic screening indicates that the prevalence of mutation carrier state is more common than previously thought, occurring in 1 in 1,500, though the clinical penetrance of symptomatic AHP is low at ~1%. Symptomatic attacks occur primarily in females during their reproductive years. In an acute porphyria attack, the primary symptom is abdominal pain, due to intestinal dysmotility from autonomic nerve injury. Other manifestations include seizures, weakness and mood changes, point to injury involving peripheral and central nervous system. Due to the non-specific nature of the symptoms and signs in AHP, the diagnosis is often delayed by many years. The diagnosis of AHP depends on biochemical evidence of elevated ALA and PBG levels in urine during symptomatic attacks. Genetic testing is used for confirmation of the gene involved and the exact mutation. Treatment involves administration of heme, which downregulates production of ALA. Long-term management centers on educating genetic carriers on avoiding triggers that increase the risk of acute attacks and screening family members.

Novel PPOX exonic mutation inducing aberrant splicing in a patient with homozygous variegate porphyria

INTRODUCTION

Variegate porphyria (VP; OMIM 176200) is one of the acute hepatic porphyrias, and it is characterized by the partial deficiency of protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX). The unusual homozygous variant with mutations on both alleles of PPOX is distinguished with general heterozygous VP by several typical points such as severe defect in PPOX enzyme activity, early onset of photosensitivity before puberty, and skeletal deformity.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

In this study, we describe a very rare case of autosomal recessive form of true homozygous VP found in a Chinese patient with consanguineous parents. Sanger sequencing of the PPOX gene showed a novel homozygous variant located at the first base of exon 8 of the gene, i.e., NM_000309.3c.808G > T. To investigate aberrant splicing induced by the mutant, wild-type exon 8 and mutant exon 8 were expressed in pET01 vector as minigene in cultured-cells and analyzed by RT-PCR.

RESULTS

The wildtype PPOX showed an expected band in the gel electrophoresis after RT-PCR. The PPOX c.808G > T only showed a band similar to the band size of the vector only control. This result suggested c.808G > T mutant is an exonic mutation inducing aberrant splicing of pre-mRNA of the PPOX gene.

CONCLUSION

This study showed a very rare case of homozygous VP with autosomal recessive homoallelic pattern. In comparison with previous cases of homozygous VP presenting brachydactyly, it is notable that our patient did not have any skeletal deformities.

Characterization of variegate porphyria mutations using a minigene approach

Porphyrias are a group of metabolic diseases that affect the skin and/or nervous system. In 2008, three unrelated patients were diagnosed with variegate porphyria at the CIPYP (Centro de Investigaciones sobre Porfirinas y Porfirias). Sequencing of the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene, the gene altered in this type of porphyria, revealed three previously undescribed mutations: c.338+3insT, c.807G>A, and c.808-1G>C. As these mutations do not affect the protein sequence, we hypothesized that they might be splicing mutations. RT-PCRs performed on the patient's mRNAs showed normal mRNA or no amplification at all. This result indicated that the aberrant spliced transcript is possibly being degraded. In order to establish whether they were responsible or not for the patient's disease by causing aberrant splicing, we utilized a minigene approach. We found that the three mutations lead to exon skipping; therefore, the abnormal mRNAs are most likely degraded by a mechanism such as nonsense-mediated decay. In conclusion, these mutations are responsible for the disease because they alter the normal splicing pathway, thus providing a functional explanation for the appearance of disease and highlighting the use of minigene assays to complement transcript analysis.

Quantitative structural insight into human variegate porphyria disease

Defects in the human protoporphyrinogen oxidase (hPPO) gene, resulting in ~50% decreased activity of hPPO, is responsible for the dominantly inherited disorder variegate porphyria (VP). To understand the molecular mechanism of VP, we employed the site-directed mutagenesis, biochemical assays, structural biology, and molecular dynamics simulation studies to investigate VP-causing hPPO mutants. We report here the crystal structures of R59Q and R59G mutants in complex with acifluorfen at a resolution of 2.6 and 2.8 Å. The r.m.s.d. of the Cα atoms of the active site structure of R59G and R59Q with respect to the wild-type was 0.20 and 0.15 Å, respectively. However, these highly similar static crystal structures of mutants with the wild-type could not quantitatively explain the observed large differences in their enzymatic activity. To understand how the hPPO mutations affect their catalytic activities, we combined molecular dynamics simulation and statistical analysis to quantitatively understand the molecular mechanism of VP-causing mutants. We have found that the probability of the privileged conformations of hPPO can be correlated very well with the k(cat)/K(m) of PPO (correlation coefficient, R(2) > 0.9), and the catalytic activity of 44 clinically reported VP-causing mutants can be accurately predicted. These results indicated that the VP-causing mutation affect the catalytic activity of hPPO by affecting the ability of hPPO to sample the privileged conformations. The current work, together with our previous crystal structure study on the wild-type hPPO, provided the quantitative structural insight into human variegate porphyria disease.

Partial protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) gene deletions, due to different Alu-mediated mechanisms, identified by MLPA analysis in patients with variegate porphyria

Variegate porphyria (VP) is an autosomal dominantly inherited hepatic porphyria. The genetic defect in the PPOX gene leads to a partial defect of protoporphyrinogen oxidase, the penultimate enzyme of heme biosynthesis. Affected individuals can develop cutaneous symptoms in sun-exposed areas of the skin and/or neuropsychiatric acute attacks. The identification of the genetic defect in VP families is of crucial importance to detect the carrier status which allows counseling to prevent potentially life threatening neurovisceral attacks, usually triggered by factors such as certain drugs, alcohol or fasting.In a total of 31 Swedish VP families sequence analysis had identified a genetic defect in 26. In the remaining five families an extended genetic investigation was necessary. After the development of a synthetic probe set, MLPA analysis to screen for single exon deletions/duplications was performed.We describe here, for the first time, two partial deletions within the PPOX gene detected by MLPA analysis. One deletion affects exon 5 and 6 (c.339-197_616+320del1099) and has been identified in four families, most probably after a founder effect. The other extends from exon 5 to exon 9 (c.339-350_987+229del2609) and was found in one family. We show that both deletions are mediated by Alu repeats.Our findings emphasize the usefulness of MLPA analysis as a complement to PPOX gene sequencing analysis for comprehensive genetic diagnostics in patients with VP.

Genetic and biochemical studies in Argentinean patients with variegate porphyria

BACKGROUND

A partial deficiency in Protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) produces the mixed disorder Variegate Porphyria (VP), the second acute porphyria more frequent in Argentina. Identification of patients with an overt VP is absolutely important because treatment depends on an accurate diagnosis but more critical is the identification of asymptomatic relatives to avoid acute attacks which may progress to death.

METHODS

We have studied at molecular level 18 new Argentinean patients biochemically diagnosed as VP. PPOX gene was amplified in one or in twelve PCR reactions. All coding exons, flanking intronic and promoter regions were manual or automatically sequenced. For RT-PCR studies RNA was retrotranscripted, amplified and sequenced. PPOX activity in those families carrying a new and uncharacterized mutation was performed.

RESULTS

All affected individuals harboured mutations in heterozygous state. Nine novel mutations and 3 already reported mutations were identified. Six of the novel mutations were single nucleotide substitutions, 2 were small deletions and one a small insertion. Three single nucleotide substitutions and the insertion were at exon-intron boundaries. Two of the single nucleotide substitutions, c.471G>A and c.807G>A and the insertion (c.388+3insT) were close to the splice donor sites in exons 5, 7 and intron 4 respectively. The other single nucleotide substitution was a transversion in the last base of intron 7, g.3912G>C (c.808-1G>C) so altering the consensus acceptor splice site. However, only in the first case the abnormal band showing the skipping of exon 5 was detected. The other single nucleotide substitutions were transversions: c.101A>T, c.995G>C and c.670 T>G that result in p.E34V, p.G332A and W224G aminoacid substitutions in exons 3, 10 and 7 respectively. Activity measurements indicate that these mutations reduced about 50% PPOX activity and also that they co-segregate with this reduced activity value. Two frameshift mutations, c.133delT and c.925delA, were detected in exons 3 and 9 respectively. The first leads to an early termination signal 22 codons downstream (p.S45fsX67) and the second leads to a stop codon 5 codons downstream (p.I309fsX314). One reported mutation was a missense mutation (p.G232R) and 2 were frameshift mutations: c.1082insC and 1043insT. The last mutation was detected in six new apparently unrelated Argentinean families.

CONCLUSION

Molecular analysis in available family members revealed 14 individuals who were silent carriers of VP. Molecular techniques represent the most accurate approach to identify unaffected carriers and to provide accurate genetic counselling for asymptomatic individuals. The initial screening includes the insertion search.

Crystal structure of protoporphyrinogen oxidase from Myxococcus xanthus and its complex with the inhibitor acifluorfen

Protoporphyrinogen IX oxidase, a monotopic membrane protein, which catalyzes the oxidation of protoporphyrinogen IX to protoporphyrin IX in the heme/chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway, is distributed widely throughout nature. Here we present the structure of protoporphyrinogen IX oxidase from Myxococcus xanthus, an enzyme with similar catalytic properties to human protoporphyrinogen IX oxidase that also binds the common plant herbicide, acifluorfen. In the native structure, the planar porphyrinogen substrate is mimicked by a Tween 20 molecule, tracing three sides of the macrocycle. In contrast, acifluorfen does not mimic the planarity of the substrate but is accommodated by the shape of the binding pocket and held in place by electrostatic and aromatic interactions. A hydrophobic patch surrounded by positively charged residues suggests the position of the membrane anchor, differing from the one proposed for the tobacco mitochondrial protoporphyrinogen oxidase. Interestingly, there is a discrepancy between the dimerization state of the protein in solution and in the crystal. Conserved structural features are discussed in relation to a number of South African variegate porphyria-causing mutations in the human enzyme.

A Chilean boy with severe photosensitivity and finger shortening: the first case of homozygous variegate porphyria in South America

A 7-year-old Chilean boy presented with severe photosensitivity, blistering, erosions and scarring on sun-exposed areas of the body since the age of 6 months. Additionally, he showed a short stature and shortening of the fingers. Laboratory examination revealed greatly elevated protoporphyrin levels in the blood. Such biochemical findings can be observed in homozygous variants of usually autosomal dominantly inherited acute porphyrias such as variegate porphyria (VP) and hereditary coproporphyria, which usually do not become manifest before the second or third decade of life in heterozygotes. Using polymerase chain reaction-based techniques we identified a missense mutation in exon 7 on the paternal allele and a frameshift mutation in exon 13 on the maternal allele of the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene that harbours the mutations underlying VP. This is the first homozygous case of VP in South America. As VP represents the most frequent type of acute porphyria not only in Chile but also in South Africa, more such cases could be expected in the future, particularly because a founder mutation for this disease has already been described in the Chilean and South African population.

Kinetic and physical characterisation of recombinant wild-type and mutant human protoporphyrinogen oxidases

The effects of various protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) mutations responsible for variegate porphyria (VP), the roles of the arginine-59 residue and the glycines in the conserved flavin binding site, in catalysis and/or cofactor binding, were examined. Wild-type recombinant human PPOX and a selection of mutants were generated, expressed, purified and partially characterised. All mutants had reduced PPOX activity to varying degrees. However, the activity data did not correlate with the ability/inability to bind flavin. The positive charge at arginine-59 appears to be directly involved in catalysis and not in flavin-cofactor binding alone. The K(m)s for the arginine-59 mutants suggested a substrate-binding problem. T(1/2) indicated that arginine-59 is required for the integrity of the active site. The dominant alpha-helical content was decreased in the mutants. The degree of alpha-helix did not correlate linearly with T(1/2) nor T(m) values, supporting the suggestion that arginine-59 is important for catalysis at the active site. Examination of the conserved dinucleotide-binding sequence showed that substitution of glycine in codon 14 was less disruptive than substitutions in codons 9 and 11. Ultraviolet melting curves generally showed a two-state transition suggesting formation of a multi-domain structure. All mutants studied were more resistant to thermal denaturation compared to wild type, except for R168C.

Nine novel mutations in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in Swedish families with variegate porphyria

Variegate porphyria (VP) is an autosomal-dominant disorder that is caused by inheritance of a partial deficiency of the enzyme protoporphyrinogen oxidase (EC 1.3.3.4). It is characterized by cutaneous photosensitivity and/or various neurological manifestations. Protoporphyrinogen oxidase catalyses the penultimate step of haem biosynthesis, and mutations in the PPOX gene have been coupled to VP. In the present study, sequencing analysis revealed 10 different mutations in the PPOX gene in 14 out of 17 apparently unrelated Swedish VP families. Six of the identified mutations, 3G > A (exon 2), 454C > T (exon 5), 472G > C (exon 6), 614C > T (exon 6), 988G > C (exon 10) and IVS12 + 2T > G (intron 12), are single nucleotide substitutions, while 604delC (exon 6), 916-17delCT (exon 9) and 1330-31delCT (exon 13) are small deletions, and IVS12 + 2-3insT (intron 12) is a small insertion. Only one of these 10 mutations has been reported previously. Three of the mutations were each identified in two or more families, while the remaining mutations were specific for an individual family. In addition to the 10 mutations, one previously unreported single nucleotide polymorphism was identified. Mutation analysis of family members revealed two adults and four children who were silent carriers of the VP trait. Genetic analysis can now be added to the conventional biochemical analyses and used in investigation of putative carriers of a VP trait in these families.

Clinical and biochemical characteristics and genotype-phenotype correlation in Finnish variegate porphyria patients

Variegate porphyria (VP) is an inherited metabolic disease resulting from the partial deficiency of protoporphyrinogen oxidase, the penultimate enzyme in the heme biosynthetic pathway. We have evaluated the clinical and biochemical outcome of 103 Finnish VP patients diagnosed between 1966 and 2001. Fifty-two per cent of patients had experienced clinical symptoms: 40% had photosensitivity, 27% acute attacks and 14% both manifestations. The proportion of patients with acute attacks has decreased dramatically from 38 to 14% in patients diagnosed before and after 1980, whereas the prevalence of skin symptoms had decreased only subtly from 45 to 34%. We have studied the correlation between PPOX genotype and clinical outcome of 90 patients with the three most common Finnish mutations I12T, R152C and 338G-->C. The patients with the I12T mutation experienced no photosensitivity and acute attacks were rare (8%). Therefore, the occurrence of photosensitivity was lower in the I12T group compared to the R152C group (P=0.001), whereas no significant differences between the R152C and 338G-->C groups could be observed. Biochemical abnormalities were significantly milder suggesting a milder form of the disease in patients with the I12T mutation. In all VP patients, normal excretion of protoporphyrin in faeces in adulthood predicted freedom from both skin symptoms and acute attacks. The most valuable test predicting an increased risk of symptoms was urinary coproporphyrin, but only a substantially increased excretion exceeding 1,000 nmol/day was associated with an increased risk of both skin symptoms and acute attacks. All patients with an excretion of more than 1,000 nmol/day experienced either skin symptoms, acute attacks, or both.

Identification of the first variegate porphyria mutation in an indigenous black South African and further evidence for heterogeneity in variegate porphyria

Variegate porphyria is an autosomal dominant disorder of haem metabolism resulting from reduced levels of the penultimate enzyme in the pathway, protoporphyrinogen oxidase. Here we investigate the molecular basis of variegate porphyria in four non-R59W South African families. We report the identification of the first mutation in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in a black South African individual (V290M). In addition, we document three further mutations, a missense mutation (L15F), a deletion followed by a substitution [c769delG;770T > A], and a nonsense mutation (Q375X), in individuals of European or mixed ancestry. Our data provide further evidence of genetic heterogeneity in South Africa.