Mono-allelic Ly49 NK cell receptor expression

Establishment and maintenance of random monoallelic expression

This Review elucidates the regulatory principles of random monoallelic expression by focusing on two well-studied examples: the X-chromosome inactivation regulator Xist and the olfactory receptor gene family. Although the choice of a single X chromosome or olfactory receptor occurs in different developmental contexts, common gene regulatory principles guide monoallelic expression in both systems. In both cases, an event breaks the symmetry between genetically and epigenetically identical copies of the gene, leading to the expression of one single random allele, stabilized through negative feedback control. Although many regulatory steps that govern the establishment and maintenance of monoallelic expression have been identified, key pieces of the puzzle are still missing. We provide an overview of the current knowledge and models for the monoallelic expression of Xist and olfactory receptors. We discuss their similarities and differences, and highlight open questions and approaches that could guide the study of other monoallelically expressed genes.

Two Lineages of KLRA with Contrasting Transcription Patterns Have Been Conserved at a Single Locus during Ruminant Speciation

Cattle possess the most diverse repertoire of NK cell receptor genes among all mammals studied to date. Killer cell receptor genes encoded within the NK complex and killer cell Ig-like receptor genes encoded within the leukocyte receptor complex have both been expanded and diversified. Our previous studies identified two divergent and polymorphic KLRA alleles within the NK complex in the Holstein-Friesian breed of dairy cattle. By examining a much larger cohort and other ruminant species, we demonstrate the emergence and fixation of two KLRA allele lineages (KLRA*01 and -*02) at a single locus during ruminant speciation. Subsequent recombination events between these allele lineages have increased the frequency of KLRA*02 extracellular domains. KLRA*01 and KLRA*02 transcription levels contrasted in response to cytokine stimulation, whereas homozygous animals consistently transcribed higher levels of KLRA, regardless of the allele lineage. KLRA*02 mRNA levels were also generally higher than KLRA*01 Collectively, these data point toward alternative functional roles governed by KLRA genotype and allele lineage. On a background of high genetic diversity of NK cell receptor genes, this KLRA allele fixation points to fundamental and potentially differential function roles.

Evidence for epigenetic maintenance of Ly49a monoallelic gene expression

Although structurally unrelated, the human killer cell Ig-like (KIR) genes and the rodent lectin-like Ly49 genes serve similar functional roles in NK cells. Moreover, both gene families display variegated, monoallelic expression patterns established at the transcriptional level. DNA methylation has been shown to play an important role in maintenance of expression patterns of KIR genes, which have CpG island promoters. The potential role of DNA methylation in expression of Ly49 genes, which have CpG-poor promoters, is unknown. In this study, we show that hypomethylation of the region encompassing the Pro-2 promoter of Ly49a and Ly49c in primary C57BL/6 NK cells correlates with expression of the gene. Using C57BL/6 x BALB/c F1 hybrid mice, we demonstrate that the expressed allele of Ly49a is hypomethylated while the nonexpressed allele is heavily methylated, indicating a role for epigenetics in maintaining monoallelic Ly49 gene expression. Furthermore, the Ly49a Pro-2 region is heavily methylated in fetal NK cells but variably methylated in nonlymphoid tissues. Finally, in apparent contrast to the KIR genes, we show that DNA methylation and the histone acetylation state of the Pro-2 region are strictly linked with Ly49a expression status.

Roles for HLA and KIR polymorphisms in natural killer cell repertoire selection and modulation of effector function

Interactions between killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIRs) and human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I ligands regulate the development and response of human natural killer (NK) cells. Natural selection drove an allele-level group A KIR haplotype and the HLA-C1 ligand to unusually high frequency in the Japanese, who provide a particularly informative population for investigating the mechanisms by which KIR and HLA polymorphism influence NK cell repertoire and function. HLA class I ligands increase the frequencies of NK cells expressing cognate KIR, an effect modified by gene dose, KIR polymorphism, and the presence of other cognate ligand-receptor pairs. The five common Japanese KIR3DLI allotypes have distinguishable inhibitory capacity, frequency of cellular expression, and level of cell surface expression as measured by antibody binding. Although KIR haplotypes encoding 3DL1*001 or 3DL1*005, the strongest inhibitors, have no activating KIR, the dominant haplotype encodes a moderate inhibitor, 3DL1*01502, plus functional forms of the activating receptors 2DL4 and 2DS4. In the population, certain combinations of KIR and HLA class I ligand are overrepresented or underrepresented in women, but not men, and thus influence female fitness and survival. These findings show how KIR-HLA interactions shape the genetic and phenotypic KIR repertoires for both individual humans and the population.

Modeling embryogenesis and cancer: an approach based on an equilibrium between the autostabilization of stochastic gene expression and the interdependence of cells for proliferation

A large amount of data demonstrating the stochastic nature of gene expression and cell differentiation has accumulated during the last 40 years. These data suggest that a gene in a cell always has a certain probability of being activated at any time and that instead of leading to on and off switches in an all-or-nothing fashion, the concentration of transcriptional regulators increases or decreases this probability. In order to integrate these data in an appropriate theoretical frame, we have tested the relevance of the selective model of cell differentiation by computer simulation experiments. This model is based on stochastic gene expression controlled by cellular interactions. Our results show that it is readily able to produce tissue organization. A model involving only two cells generated a bi-layer cellular structure of finite growth. Cell death was not a drawback but an advantage because it improved the viability of this bi-layer structure. However, our results also show that cellular interactions cannot be simply based on raw selection between cells. Instead, tissue coordination includes at least two basic components: phenotypic autostabilization (differentiated cells stabilize their own phenotype) and interdependence for proliferation (differentiated cells stimulate the proliferation of alien phenotypes). In this modified autostabilization-selection model, cellular organization and growth arrest result from a quantitative equilibrium between the parameters controlling these two processes. An imbalance leads to tissue disorganization and invasive cancer-like growth. These findings suggest that cancer does not result solely from mutations in the cancerous cell but from the progressive addition of several small alterations of the equilibrium between autostabilization and interdependence for proliferation. In this frame, it is not solely the cancerous cell that is abnormal. The whole organism is involved. Tumor growth is a local effect of an imbalance between all the factors involved in tissue organization.

Initiation and limitation of Ly-49A NK cell receptor acquisition by T cell factor-1

The establishment of clonally variable expression of MHC class I-specific receptors by NK cells is not well understood. The Ly-49A receptor is used by approximately 20% of NK cells, whereby most cells express either the maternal or paternal allele and few express simultaneously both alleles. We have previously shown that NK cells expressing Ly-49A were reduced or almost absent in mice harboring a single or no functional allele of the transcription factor T cell factor-1 (TCF-1), respectively. In this study, we show that enforced expression of TCF-1 in transgenic mice yields an expanded Ly-49A subset. Even though the frequencies of Ly-49A(+) NK cells varied as a function of the TCF-1 dosage, the relative abundance of mono- and biallelic Ly-49A cells was maintained. Mono- and biallelic Ly-49A NK cells were also observed in mice expressing exclusively a transgenic TCF-1, i.e., expressing a fixed amount of TCF-1 in all NK cells. These findings suggest that Ly-49A acquisition is a stochastic event due to limiting TCF-1 availability, rather than the consequence of clonally variable expression of the endogenous TCF-1 locus. Efficient Ly-49A acquisition depended on the expression of a TCF-1 isoform, which included a domain known to associate with the TCF-1 coactivator beta-catenin. Indeed, the proximal Ly-49A promoter was beta-catenin responsive in reporter gene assays. We thus propose that Ly-49A receptor expression is induced from a single allele in occasional NK cells due to a limitation in the amount of a transcription factor complex requiring TCF-1.

The NK cell receptor repertoire: formation, adaptation and exploitation

The identification of NK cell receptors specific for MHC class I molecules has greatly improved our knowledge of NK cell reactivity and specificity. Inhibitory receptors prevent NK cell activation directed against cells expressing self-MHC class I molecules. Consequently, diseased cells that do not express self-MHC class I molecules become susceptible to NK cell-mediated attack. Because of the specificity and distribution of inhibitory NK cell receptors, cells that express non-self (allogeneic) MHC class I molecules are also susceptible to NK cell reactions. This feature has been exploited in a clinical setting to treat leukemia patients.

Function of CMV-encoded MHC class I homologues

Homologues of MHC class I proteins have been identified in the genomes of human, murine and rat cytomegaloviruses (CMVs). Given the pivotal role of the MHC class I protein in cellular immunity, it has been postulated that the viral homologues subvert the normal antiviral immune response of the host, thus promoting virus replication and dissemination in an otherwise hostile environment. This review focuses on recent studies of the CMV MHC class I homologues at the molecular, cellular and whole animal level and presents current hypotheses for their roles in the CMV life cycle.

Stochastic patterns in globin gene expression are established prior to transcriptional activation and are clonally inherited

We have undertaken a detailed characterization of mouse globin gene expression patterns in the nucleus and cytoplasm of single erythroid cells. We demonstrate an imbalance of alpha- versus beta-globin expression in a significant proportion of cells both in nuclear transcription patterns and cytoplasmic mRNA levels. Clonal cell analysis showed these expression patterns to be clonally inherited, while analysis of a multicopy transgenic locus showed an all-or-none effect in the activation of all the genes in one locus. These data provide strong evidence for a stochastic basis of globin gene activation resulting in heritable all-or-none expression patterns.

Splenocytes cultured in low concentrations of IL-2 generate NK cell specificities toward syngenic and allogenic targets

Splenocytes cultured in the presence of 30-60 units/ml IL-2 for 5 days develop natural killer activity toward syngeneic and allogeneic tumor cell targets. The IL-2 activated splenocytes, themselves, are partially resistant, whereas concanavalin A-activated T blast cells are completely resistant to killing. Surprisingly, major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-I-negative target cells are also resistant to natural killer (NK)-cell-mediated killing. Cells resistant to killing were unable to block NK-cell-mediated killing of sensitive targets as judged from cold target cell inhibition experiments, and one type of target cells sensitive to killing did generally not cross-block killing of other killing-sensitive target cell types. Alloantigen exposure of splenocytes, i.e., one-way mixed lymphocyte cultures, partially prevents the development of NK-cell activity. Our data suggest that target structures which trigger killing activity of NK cells are determined by the phenotype of the target cell and are dependent on its MHC class I expression disregarding the haplotype of the cell.