Murine leukemia virus-induced neurodegeneration of rats: enhancement of neuropathogenicity correlates with enhanced viral tropism for macrophages, microglia, and brain vascular cells

Splicing of Friend Murine Leukemia Virus env-mRNA Enhances Its Ability to Form Polysomes

Friend murine leukemia virus (MLV) belongs to the gamma retroviruses of the Retroviridae family. The positive-sense RNA of its genome contains a 5' long terminal repeat (LTR), 5' leader sequence, gag, pol, env, and 3' LTR. Transcription from proviral DNA begins from the R region of the 5' LTR and ends at the polyadenylation signal located at the R region of the other end of the 3' LTR. There is a 5' splice site in the 5' leader sequence and a 3' splice site at the 3' end of the pol region. Both full-length unspliced mRNAs and a singly spliced mRNA (env-mRNA) are produced in MLV-infected cells. The MLV Env protein plays important roles both in viral adsorption to host cells and in neuropathogenic disease in MLV-infected mice and rats. Understanding the regulatory mechanisms controlling Env expression is important for determining the functions of the Env protein. We have previously shown that splicing increases env-mRNA stability and translation efficiency. Generally, mRNA polysome formation correlates with translation efficiency. Therefore, here we investigated the effects of env-mRNA splicing on polysome formation to identify mechanisms for Env up-regulation due to splicing. We performed polysome profile analyses using Env-expression plasmids producing spliced or unspliced env-mRNA and showed that the former formed polysomes more efficiently than the latter. Thus, splicing of env-mRNA facilitated polysome formation, suggesting that this contributes to up-regulation of Env expression. We replaced the env region of the expression plasmids with a luciferase (luc) gene, and found that in this case both unspliced and spliced luc-mRNA formed polysomes to a similar extent. Thus, we conclude that whether mRNA polysome formation is affected by splicing depends on the structure of gene in question.

Kinetic studies of the effect of a 17-nucleotide difference in the 0.3-kb region containing the R-U5-5' leader sequence of Friend murine leukemia virus on viral gene expression

In addition to the env gene, a 0.3-kb fragment containing the R-U5-5' leader sequence is essential for the induction of spongiform neurodegeneration by Friend murine leukemia virus (Fr-MLV) clone A8 and it also influences expression of the Env protein. Kinetic studies were carried out using two recombinant viruses, R7f, carrying the A8 0.3-kb fragment, and Rec5, carrying the 0.3-kb fragment of the non-neuropathogenic Fr-MLV clone 57. These analyses suggested that the 0.3-kb fragment influenced the expression level of the Env protein by regulating the amount of spliced env-mRNA rather than the amount of total viral mRNA or viral production.

Narrowing down the critical region within env gene for determining neuropathogenicity of murine leukemia virus A8

Friend murine leukemia virus clone A8 causes spongiform neurodegeneration in the rat brain, and the env gene of A8 is a primary determinant of neuropathogenicity. In order to narrow down the critical region within the env gene that determines neuropathogenicity, we constructed chimeric viruses having chimeric env between A8 and non-neuropathogenic 57 on the background of A8 virus. After replacement of the BamHI (at nucleotide 5715)-AgeI (at nucleotide 6322) fragment of A8 virus with the corresponding fragment of 57, neuropathogenicity was lost. In contrast, the chimeric viruses that have the BamHI (5715)-AgeI (6322) fragment of A8 induced spongiosis in 100% of infected rats at the same or slightly lower intensity than A8 virus. These results indicate that the BamHI (5715)-AgeI (6322) fragment of A8, which contains the signal sequence and the N-terminal half of RBD, is crucial for the induction of spongiform neurodegeneration. In the BamHI (5715)-AgeI (6322) fragment, seven amino acids differed between A8 and 57, one in the signal sequence and six in RBD, which suggests that these amino acids significantly contribute to the neuropathogenicity of A8.

Oligodendrocytes are a major target of the toxicity of spongiogenic murine retroviruses

The neurovirulent retroviruses FrCasE and Moloney MLV-ts1 cause noninflammatory spongiform neurodegeneration in mice, manifested clinically by progressive spasticity and paralysis. Neurons have been thought to be the primary target of toxicity of these viruses. However the neurons themselves appear not to be infected, and the possible indirect mechanisms driving the neuronal toxicity have remained enigmatic. Here we have re-examined the cells that are damaged by these viruses, using lineage-specific markers. Surprisingly, these cells expressed the basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor Olig2, placing them in the oligodendrocyte lineage. Olig2+ cells were found to be infected, and many of these cells exhibited focal cytoplasmic vacuolation, suggesting that infection by spongiogenic retroviruses is directly toxic to these cells. As cytoplasmic vacuolation progressed, however, signs of viral protein expression appeared to wane, although residual viral RNA was detectable by in situ hybridization. Cells with the most advanced cytoplasmic effacement expressed the C/EBP-homologous protein (CHOP). This protein is up-regulated as a late event in a cellular response termed the integrated stress response. This observation may link the cellular pathology observed in the brain with cellular stress responses known to be induced by these viruses. The relevance of these observations to oligodendropathy in humans is discussed.

Cerebral metabolism in brains of rats infected with neuropathogenic murine leukemia viruses

Friend murine leukemia virus A8 and PVC211 cause spongiform neurodegeneration in rat brains. Glutamate is an important neurotransmitter synthesized from alpha-ketoglutaric acid, an intermediate product of the citric acid cycle, and glutamine is synthesized from glutamate. To examine the brain metabolism of rats infected with neuropathogenic viruses, the amount of glutamate and glutamine in the brains of rats infected with A8, PVC211, and non-neuropathogenic 57 was measured using high performance liquid chromatography, and the (13)C-label incorporation into the C4 position of glutamate and glutamine from [1-(13)C] glucose was measured with (13)C nuclear magnetic resonance. In the cerebral hemisphere and region containing the brain stem and basal ganglia of rats infected with A8 and PVC211 at 8-9 weeks post-infection (wpi), the amount of glutamine was decreased compared with the 57-infected rats. The amount of glutamate was decreased in the cerebral hemisphere of the A8-infected rats and the region containing the brain stem and basal ganglia of PVC211-infected rats at 8-9 wpi. The amount of [4-(13)C] glutamine and [4-(13)C] glutamate in the cerebral hemisphere and region containing the brain stem and basal ganglia of rats infected with A8 and PVC211 at 8-9 wpi was equivalent to that of the 57-infected rats. These results suggest that in the brains of rats infected with neuropathogenic viruses, de novo synthesis of glutamate and glutamine is not decreased, but the ability to maintain quantitative levels of glutamate and glutamine is decreased compared with the brains of rats infected with non-neuropathogenic virus.

A 0.3-kb fragment containing the R-U5-5' leader sequence is essential for the induction of spongiform neurodegeneration by A8 murine leukemia virus

Friend murine leukemia virus (Fr-MLV) clone A8 causes spongiform neurodegeneration in the rat brain. The A8-env gene is a primary determinant of neuropathogenicity, and the 1.5-kb ClaI-HindIII fragment containing the LTR and 5' leader from A8 are additionally required for spongiosis. After replacement of the A8 enhancer region of the neuropathogenic chimera with the enhancer region of non-neuropathogenic 57, viral titer in the brain was reduced by two orders of magnitude. However, the A8 enhancer region was not responsible for the induction of spongiosis. The region responsible for neuropathogenesis was located in the 0.3-kb KpnI-AatII fragment of A8 containing the R-U5-5' leader. The chimeric virus possessing this 0.3-kb fragment of A8 and the A8-env in the 57 background induced a high rate of spongiform neurodegeneration within 7 weeks (9/9 of infected rats). Studies using cultured cells suggest that the 0.3-kb fragment influences the expression of Env protein. Furthermore, these neuropathogenic chimerae, despite low viral replication in the brain, exhibited a stronger expression of Env protein compared with that of non-neuropathogenic viruses.

The Other Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies

Murine leukemia viruses may produce encephalopathies that have the same characteristics as those induced by infectious proteins or prions: neuronal loss, astrocytosis, and absence of inflammatory response. The pathogenic mechanism is still poorly understood but it seems that it involves the envelope proteins (Env), which may be misprocessed in the cell, giving rise to pathogenic isoforms that trigger oxidative damage. Env may also affect the cytokine pattern in the central nervous system and thus, induce encephalopathy.

Disparate regions of envelope protein regulate syncytium formation versus spongiform encephalopathy in neurological disease induced by murine leukemia virus TR

The murine leukemia virus (MLV) TR1.3 provides an excellent model to study the wide range of retrovirus-induced central nervous system (CNS) pathology and disease. TR1.3 rapidly induces thrombotic events in brain microvessels and causes cell-specific syncytium formation of brain capillary endothelial cells (BCEC). A single amino acid substitution, W102G, in the MLV envelope protein (Env) regulates the pathogenic effects. The role of Env in determining this disease phenotype compared to the induction of spongiform encephalomyelitis with a longer latency, as seen in several other MLV and in human retroviruses, was determined by studying in vitro-attenuated TR1.3. Virus cloned from this selection, termed TRM, induced progressive neurological disease characterized by ataxia and paralysis and the appearance of spongiform neurodegeneration throughout the brain stem and spinal cord. This disease was associated with virus replication in both BCEC and highly ramified glial cells. TRM did not induce syncytium formation, either in vivo or in vitro. Sequence and mutational analyses demonstrated that TRM contained a reversion of Env G102W but that neurological disease mapped to the single amino acid substitution Env S159P. The results demonstrate that single nucleotide changes within disparate regions of Env control dramatically different CNS disease patterns.

Unique three-repeat sequences containing FVa, LVb/C4, and CORE motifs in LTR-U3 of Friend murine leukemia virus clone A8 accelerate the induction of thymoma in rat

Friend murine leukemia virus (Fr-MLV) clone A8 causes thymoma 7 weeks postinfection in rats with a more rapid progression than clone 57. The U3 region of A8-LTR contains a unique structure of enhancer motifs consisting of three repeats of a 38-bp sequence containing FVa, LVb/C4, and CORE motifs. Replacement or deletion of the 38-bp sequence in the A8-U3 resulted in a marked reduction in tumorigenicity. Furthermore, the virus with 57-U3 gained high tumorigenicity after construction of the three 38-bp repeats in the U3 region. These findings indicated that the repeats of the 38-bp sequence of A8-LTR are essential for the rapid induction of thymoma. Interestingly, the repeat of the 38-bp sequence did not accelerate the amount of integrated viral DNA in the thymus during the early phase of infection, although it contributed to higher production of infectious virus. Thus, it was demonstrated that the ability to induce thymoma, which correlates with virus titer in the thymus, is not determined by the rate of viral DNA integration into the host genome.

Protection against murine leukemia virus-induced spongiform myeloencephalopathy in mice overexpressing Bcl-2 but not in mice deficient for interleukin-6, inducible nitric oxide synthetase, ICE, Fas, Fas ligand, or TNF-R1 genes

Some murine leukemia viruses (MuLVs), among them Cas-Br-E and ts-1 MuLVs, are neurovirulent, inducing spongiform myeloencephalopathy and hind limb paralysis in susceptible mice. It has been shown that the env gene of these viruses harbors the determinant of neurovirulence. It appears that neuronal loss occurs by an indirect mechanism, since the target motor neurons have not been found to be infected. However, the pathogenesis of the disease remains unclear. Several lymphokines, cytokines, and other cellular effectors have been found to be aberrantly expressed in the brains of infected mice, but whether these are required for the development of the neurodegenerative lesions is not known. In an effort to identify the specific effectors which are indeed required for the initiation and/or development of spongiform myeloencephalopathy, we inoculated gene-deficient (knockout [KO]) mice with ts-1 MuLV. We show here that interleukin-6 (IL-6), inducible nitric oxide synthetase (iNOS), ICE, Fas, Fas ligand (FasL), and TNF-R1 KO mice still develop signs of disease. However, transgenic mice overexpressing Bcl-2 in neurons (NSE/Bcl-2) were largely protected from hind limb paralysis and had less-severe spongiform lesions. These results indicate that motor neuron death occurs in this disease at least in part by a Bcl-2-inhibitable pathway not requiring the ICE, iNOS, Fas/FasL, TNF-R1, and IL-6 gene products.

Identification of genetic determinants that regulate tumorigenicity of Friend murine leukemia virus in rats

A neuropathogenic variant of Friend murine leukemia virus (FrMLV), clone A8, has been shown to cause thymoma and infiltration of leukemic cells to organs at 7-8 weeks post-infection in rats with a more rapid progression than clone 57. We have previously reported that the determinant for induction of aggressive leukemia in rats is located in the ClaI-AatII fragment containing the long terminal repeat (LTR) and the 5' half of the 5' leader sequence of A8 virus. Further studies of chimeric viruses restricted the determinant for the induction of thymoma to only the 0.6-kb ClaI-KpnI fragment of A8. This fragment contains a 0.1 kb region of the 3' terminus of the env gene, the intergenic region, the U3, and the 5' half of the R region in the LTR. Major differences in the fragment between A8 and 57 viruses were found in the U3 region, especially in the enhancer motifs. These results indicate that the enhancer region of A8-LTR contributes to the manifestation of thymoma with rapid progression in rats.

Activation of microglia cells is dispensable for the induction of rat retroviral spongiform encephalopathy

In the course of retroviral CNS infections, microglia activation has been observed frequently, and it has been hypothesized that activated microglia produce and secrete neurotoxic products like proinflammatory cytokines, by this promoting brain damage. We challenged this hypothesis in a rat model for neurodegeneration. In a kinetic study, we found that microglia cells of rats neonatally inoculated with neurovirulent murine leukemia virus (MuLV) NT40 became infected in vivo to maximal levels within 9-13 days postinoculation (d.p.i.). Beginning from 13 d.p.i., degenerative alterations, i.e., vacuolization of neurons and neuropil were found in cerebellar and other brain-stem nuclei. Elevated numbers of activated microglia cells--as revealed by immunohistochemical staining with monoclonal antibody ED1--were first detected at 19 d.p.i. and were always locally associated with degenerated areas but not with nonaltered, yet infected, brain regions. Both neuropathological changes and activated microglia cells increased in intensity and numbers, respectively, with ongoing infection but did not spread to other than initially affected brain regions. By ribonuclease protection assays, we were unable to detect differences in the expression levels of tumor-necrosis-factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta), and interleukin-6 (IL-6) in microglia cells nor in total brains from infected versus uninfected rats. Our results suggest that the activation of microglia in the course of MuLV neurodegeneration is rather a reaction to, and not the cause of, neuronal damage. Furthermore, overt expression of the proinflammatory cytokines TNF-alpha, IL-1beta, and IL-6 within the CNS is not required for the induction of retroviral associated neurodegeneration in rats.

Distribution of ecotropic retrovirus receptor protein in rat brains detected by immunohistochemistry

Friend murine leukaemia virus (FrMLV) FrC6 clone A8 causes spongiform degeneration in the central nervous system (CNS) of newborn but not 3-week-old rats. To assess whether expression of the ecotropic MLV receptor (CAT-1) in the CNS correlates with the pathogenicity of the A8 virus, we generated an anti-CAT-1 antibody raised against a synthetic peptide that corresponds to the carboxyl-terminal amino acid sequence of CAT-1. In the CNS of newborn and 3 to 4-week-old rats, a strong immunoreactivity against the antibody was detected in most of the endothelial cells. However, almost no expression of CAT-1 was detected in the CNS of 21-week-old rats. In newborn rats, many parenchymal cells in the brain as well as the vascular wall expressed CAT-1 antigen. These findings suggest that retrovirus receptor-bearing glial cells contribute to the neuropathogenesis of MLV, including clone A8, which induces spongiosis in rats only when inoculated into newborns.

The role of T-cell-mediated mechanisms in virus infections of the nervous system

T lymphocytes play a decisive role in the course and clinical outcome of viral CNS infection. Summarizing the information presented in this review, the following sequence of events might occur during acute virus infection: After invasion of the host and a few initial rounds of replication, the virus reaches the CNS in most cases by hematogeneous spread. After passage through the BBB, CNS cells are infected and replication of virus in brain cells causes activation of the surrounding microglia population. Moreover, local production of IFN-alpha/beta induces expression of MHC antigens on CNS cells, and microglial cells start to phagocytose cellular debris, which accumulates as a result of virus-induced cytopathogenic effects. Upon phagocytosis, microglia becomes more activated; they up-regulate MHC molecules, acquire antigen presentation capabilities and secrete chemokines. This will initiate up-regulation of adhesion molecules on adjacent endothelial cells of the BBB. Transmigration of activated T lymphocytes through the BBB is followed by interaction with APC, presenting the appropriate peptides in the context of MHC antigens. It appears that CD8+ T lymphocytes are amongst the first mononuclear cells to arrive at the infected tissue. Without a doubt, their induction and attraction is deeply influenced by natural killer cells, which, after virus infection, secrete IFN-gamma, a cytokine that stimulates CD8+ T cells and diverts the immune response to a TH1-type CD4+ T cell-dominated response. Following the CD8+ T lymphocytes, tissue-penetrating, TH1 CD4+ T cells contact local APC. This results in a tremendous up-regulation of MHC molecules and secretion of more chemotactic and toxic substances. Consequently an increasing number of inflammatory cells, including macrophages/microglia and finally antibody-secreting plasma cells, are attracted to the site of virus infection. All trapped cells are mainly terminally differentiated cells that are going to enter apoptosis during or shortly after exerting their effector functions. The clinical consequences and the influence of the effector phase on the further course of the infection depends on the balance and fine-tuning of the contributing lymphoid cell populations. Generally, any delay in the recruitment of effector lymphocytes to the tissue or an unbalanced combination of lymphocyte subsets allows the virus to spread in the CNS, which in turn will cause severe immune-mediated tissue effects as well as disease. If either too late or partially deficient, the immune system response may contribute to a lethal outcome or cause autosensitization to brain-specific antigens by epitope spreading to the antigen-presenting system in peripheral lymphoid tissue. This could form the basis for subsequent booster reactions of autosensitized CD4+ T cells--a process that finally will end in an inflammatory autoimmune reaction, which in humans we call multiple sclerosis. In contrast, a rapid and specific local response in the brain tissue will result in efficient limitation of viral spread and thereby a subclinical immune system-mediated termination of the infection. After clearance of virus-infected cells, downsizing of the local response probably occurs via self-elimination of the contributing T cell populations and/or by so far unidentified signal pathways. However, much of this is highly speculative, and more data have to be collected to make decisive conclusions regarding this matter. Several strategies have been developed by viruses to escape T cell-mediated eradication, including interference with the MHC class I presentation pathway of the host cell or "hiding" in cells which lack MHC class I expression. This may result in life-long persistence of the virus in the brain, a state which probably is actively controlled by T lymphocytes. Under severe immunosuppression, however, reactivation of viral replication can occur, which is a lethal threat to the host.

Abundant defective viral particles budding from microglia in the course of retroviral spongiform encephalopathy

A pathogenetic hallmark of retroviral neurodegeneration is the affinity of neurovirulent retroviruses for microglia cells, while degenerating neurons are excluded from retroviral infections. Microglia isolated ex vivo from rats peripherally infected with a neurovirulent retrovirus released abundant mature type C virions; however, infectivity associated with microglia was very low. In microglia, viral transcription was unaffected but envelope proteins were insufficiently cleaved into mature viral proteins and were not detected on the microglia cell surface. These microglia-specific defects in envelope protein translocation and processing not only may have prevented formation of infectious virus particles but also may have caused further cellular defects in microglia with the consequence of indirect neuronal damage. It is conceivable that similar events play a role in neuro-AIDS.

Microglial activation varies in different models of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

Progressive changes in host mRNA expression can illuminate crucial pathogenetic pathways in infectious disease. We examined general and specific approaches to mRNA expression in three rodent models of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD). Each of these models displays distinctive neuropathology. Although mRNAs for the chemokine receptor CCR5, the lysosomal protease cathepsin S, and the pleiotropic cytokine transforming growth factor beta1 (TGF-beta1) were progressively upregulated in rodent CJD, the temporal patterns and peak magnitudes of each of these transcripts varied substantially among models. Cathepsin S and TGF-beta1 were elevated more than 15-fold in mice and rats infected with two different CJD strains, but not in CJD-infected hamsters. In rats, an early activation of microglial transcripts preceded obvious deposits of prion protein (PrP) amyloid. However, in each of the three CJD models, the upregulation of CCR5, cathepsin S, and TGF-beta1 was variable with respect to the onset of PrP pathology. These results show glial cell involvement varies as a consequence of the agent strain and species infected. Although neurons are generally assumed to be the primary sites for agent replication and abnormal PrP formation, microglia may be targeted by some agent strains. In such instances, microglia can both process PrP to become amyloid and can enhance neuronal destruction. Because microglia can participate in agent clearance, they may also act as chronic reservoirs of infectivity. Finally, the results here strongly suggest that TGF-beta1 can be an essential signal for amyloid deposition.

Possible retroviral origin of prion disease: could prion disease be reconsidered as a preleukemia syndrome?

A retroviral etiology might explain why amyloid plaque and/or spongiosis are or are not associated with neuronal death in prion diseases. While retroviral genes themselves may be responsible for neuronal death, a retrovirus may also cause mutations in cellular genes. Hence, the prion gene may be altered by a retrovirus in the same way as a cellular proto-oncogene is altered to produce an oncogene, either by transduction or by integration of the provirus in its vicinity. In both cases, the resulting abnormal prion protein, acting as a catalyst, may induce the formation of amyloid plaques. In addition, a wild type retrovirus may recombine to the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) to give rise to a pseudotyped retrovirus able to induce spongiosis. It is reported here that in scrapie, a blood monocytoid cell proliferates in vitro. If confirmed in other species, this raises the question of the potential link between prion disease and leukemia. Indeed neurovirulent strains of murine leukemia virus, a slow acting retrovirus, are known to induce spongiform encephalopathies. A preliminary attempt to purify reverse transcriptase by chromatography, using the classical protocol, failed because of the presence of a prion-like protein secreted by the blood mononuclear cells which stuck to the phosphocellulose column. Therefore, if a retrovirus is present in prion diseases, it would be evidenced only in animals developing the disease in the absence of prion protein. From this point of view, mice obtained in 1997 by the group of D. Dormont in France, offer a unique opportunity to test the retroviral hypothesis.

Suppression of rat bone marrow cells by Friend murine leukemia virus envelope proteins

In a retroviral rat model, we have investigated the nontransforming effects of murine leukemia virus FB29 on the bone marrow. Upon intraperitoneal inoculation with murine leukemia virus FB29 of either neonatal or adult rats, bone marrow cells became massively infected within the first 12 days postinoculation. In neonatally inoculated rats, a persistent productive bone marrow infection was established, whereas in rats inoculated as adults, no infected bone marrow cells could be detected beyond 12 days postinoculation. Retroviral infection was most likely cleared by an antiviral immune response (Hein et al., 1995, Virology 211, 408-417). Exposure to virus irreversibly decreased numbers of bone marrow cells staining with monoclonal antibody OX7 by 10-30%. Reduction of OX7+ bone marrow cells by 20% was also observed in vitro, after bone marrow cells from uninfected adult rats had been co-incubated with virus. FB29-envelope proteins were sufficient alone to reduce numbers of OX7+ bone marrow cells, both in vivo and in vitro. According to results on incorporation of propidium iodide, decreased numbers of OX7+ cells were due to cell death. By flow cytometric analyses OX7+ bone marrow cells as well as monocytes/macrophages were identified to be major target cells for infection with FB29 within the bone marrow. Thus, the mechanism(s) responsible for death of OX7+ bone marrow cells might be due to direct toxicity of viral envelope proteins and/or to interactions of viral envelope proteins with cells of the monocytic lineage.

Sequences regulating tropism of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 for brain capillary endothelial cells map to a unique region on the viral genome

Two infectious molecular clones of human immunodeficiency virus type 1, NL4-3 and JR-CSF, differ in their abilities to productively infect human brain capillary endothelial (HBCE) cells. The phenotypes of recombinants between these two molecular strains were examined to identify viral sequences responsible for the difference in HBCE cell tropism between the two parental strains. Our results indicate that HBCE cell tropism maps to a region that encompasses the C1 region of env and includes overlapping reading frames for the accessory genes vpr, vpu, tat, and rev. This region was unique for HBCE cell tropism and did not cosegregate with either macrophage or T-cell line tropism. However, several recombinant clones displayed dual tropism for both HBCE cells and macrophages. These endothelial cell- and macrophage-tropic strains may have a unique pathogenic advantage by entering the brain via HBCE cells and subsequently infecting microglial cells with high efficiency, leading to the induction of human immunodeficiency virus dementia.