Circulating IgG antibody to protamine in patients treated with protamine-insulins

Structural principles of insulin formulation and analog design: A century of innovation

BACKGROUND

The discovery of insulin in 1921 and its near-immediate clinical use initiated a century of innovation. Advances extended across a broad front, from the stabilization of animal insulin formulations to the frontiers of synthetic peptide chemistry, and in turn, from the advent of recombinant DNA manufacturing to structure-based protein analog design. In each case, a creative interplay was observed between pharmaceutical applications and then-emerging principles of protein science; indeed, translational objectives contributed to a growing molecular understanding of protein structure, aggregation and misfolding.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Pioneering crystallographic analyses-beginning with Hodgkin's solving of the 2-Zn insulin hexamer-elucidated general features of protein self-assembly, including zinc coordination and the allosteric transmission of conformational change. Crystallization of insulin was exploited both as a step in manufacturing and as a means of obtaining protracted action. Forty years ago, the confluence of recombinant human insulin with techniques for site-directed mutagenesis initiated the present era of insulin analogs. Variant or modified insulins were developed that exhibit improved prandial or basal pharmacokinetic (PK) properties. Encouraged by clinical trials demonstrating the long-term importance of glycemic control, regimens based on such analogs sought to resemble daily patterns of endogenous β-cell secretion more closely, ideally with reduced risk of hypoglycemia.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

Next-generation insulin analog design seeks to explore new frontiers, including glucose-responsive insulins, organ-selective analogs and biased agonists tailored to address yet-unmet clinical needs. In the coming decade, we envision ever more powerful scientific synergies at the interface of structural biology, molecular physiology and therapeutics.

Platelet-activating protamine-heparin-antibodies lead to higher protamine demand in patients undergoing cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVES

Platelet-activating antibodies against protamine-heparin-complexes were described in patients undergoing cardiac surgery, but their clinical consequences remain unclear. This prospective single-center observational study aimed to describe the prevalence and clinical consequences of protamine-heparin-complex antibodies in patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass.

METHODS

A total of 200 patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass were included. Blood samples were collected preoperatively and 1 hour, 24 hours, and 7 days after weaning from cardiopulmonary bypass. All sera were tested for the presence of protamine-heparin-complex antibodies using a modified heparin-induced platelet-activation assay. Specific Fcγ receptor IIa-dependent platelet activation was confirmed by repeated testing in the presence of the Fcγ receptor IIa-blocking antibody IV.3.

RESULTS

Samples from 185 patients were obtained, of whom 24 patients (13%) were positive for protamine-heparin-complex antibodies preoperatively. In all positive samples, functional reactivity was reversible in the presence of IV.3. Although patients with a preoperative presence of protamine-heparin-complex antibodies were significantly older compared with patients negative for protamine-heparin-complex antibodies (73 ± 9.8 years vs 68 ± 10 years, P = .037), no other potential risk factors were identified at 1 day before operation. Patients with protamine-heparin-complex antibodies required significantly more protamine to neutralize heparin (47.66 mg vs 41.67 mg, P = .027). Protamine-heparin-complex antibodies have no significant influence on perioperative platelet numbers, bleeding complications, transfusion requirement, thromboembolic events, major cardiovascular and cerebrovascular events, inflammation parameters, or kidney function.

CONCLUSIONS

Protamine-heparin-complex antibodies occur frequently in patients undergoing cardiac surgery on cardiopulmonary bypass, resulting in specific platelet activation in vitro. Protamine-heparin-complex antibodies are associated with increased protamine requirement after cardiopulmonary bypass and possibly slower recovery of platelet numbers.

Protamine-containing insulin but not analog insulin and duration of insulin use are risk factors for the production of insulin autoantibodies in insulin-treated patients with diabetes mellitus

Insulin autoantibodies can be produced by insulin injections but rarely cause severe side effects such as glucose instability and insulin allergy. We study the characteristics of insulin autoantibody-positive diabetic patients with a medical history of insulin therapy using single and multiple (adjusted for age, sex, type of diabetes) logistic regression analyses. Associations between insulin autoantibodies and age, sex, type of diabetes, HbA1c, and serum creatinine were not significant, but the association between insulin autoantibodies and duration of insulin use was significant. Unadjusted and adjusted odds ratios were 1.08 (1.02-1.14) and 1.07 (1.01-1.14), respectively. Unadjusted and adjusted odds ratios for protamine-containing insulin were 3.08 (1.49-6.34) and 4.27 (1.90-9.58), respectively. The adjusted odds ratios for premixed biphasic insulin and intermediate-acting insulin were 2.21 (1.03-4.73) and 2.35 (1.01-5.49), respectively. Associations between insulin autoantibodies and any insulin analog were not significant. These results suggest that protamine-containing insulin and duration of insulin use are risk factors for the production of insulin autoantibodies. If patients with poorly controlled diabetes have a history of protamine-containing insulin therapy over a long time, the appearance of insulin autoantibodies should be monitored.

Does an allergy to fish pre-empt an adverse protamine reaction? A case report and a literature review

The operating theatre exposes patients to myriad potential agents which could result in a life-threatening anaphylactic reaction. Anaesthetic drugs, blood products, and latex are only some of the possible allergens. Reactions are deemed to be anaphylactic when immediate sensitivity is combined with cardiovascular collapse. A patient who had a known allergy to shellfish presented for first time cardiopulmonary bypass. The perfusion team were concerned that there was a realistic possibility that an adverse reaction to protamine could occur. Anaphylactic reactions to protamine in patients allergic to fish have been reported. The anaesthetic team were informed and the necessary precautions taken. We report on the outcome for our patient and also discuss other risk factors and the types of reactions that can result when an adverse reaction to protamine occurs.

A case of slowly progressive type 1 diabetes with unstable glycemic control caused by unusual insulin antibody and successfully treated with steroid therapy

A 75-year-old man with type 1 diabetes and history of insulin therapy for previous 3 years using only human recombinant ones was suffering from unstable glycemic control. He had a high level of total insulin and a high titer of insulin antibodies (IA) (bound/total ratio: 89.8%). Low affinity constant (k(1): 0.0312 x 10(8) M(-1)) and high binding capacity (b(1): 51.8 x 10(-8) M) of IA in the patient detected by the Scatchard analysis were not compatible with those of IA associated with exogenous insulin injections in the diabetic patients, but compatible with those of the insulin autoantibodies found in patients with insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS), although he had DRB1*0405, which may have protection against IAS development. The glucose infusion rate during hyperinsulinemic euglycemic clamp was 2.84 mg/kg/min, suggesting a high level of insulin resistance. Steroid pulse therapy (1000 mg for 3 days) aimed at reducing the possible effect of the IA on his insulin resistance and glycemic instability successfully decreased IA titer (from 89.8 to 58.3%), lowered its binding capacity (51.8-9.8 x 10(-8) M), increased glucose infusion rate (from 2.84 to 5.55 mg/kg/min) and improved glycemic control (HbA(1c): from 10.0 to 7.4%) with reduced blood glucose excursion. In conclusion, the alteration in insulin pharmacokinetics induced by IA seemed to be the cause of the brittle diabetes of the present case. Steroid treatment might be useful for the improvement of glycamic control in such patients with high IA levels and unstable blood glucose.

The minimal functional sequence of protamine

Despite its nearly universal applications, protamine, a mixture of four major peptides with different sequences, is associated with clinically significant side effects. Through a well-designed enzyme digestion method, various low molecular weight protamine peptides were obtained. Among them, two low molecular weight protamine peptides with the same or even more potent heparin neutralization abilities as native protamine were identified through both in vitro and in vivo tests. In addition, in vivo experiments showed that compared to native protamine, these two low molecular weight protamine peptides were less toxic and would be safer for clinical use.

Anti-insulin antibodies in dogs with naturally occurring diabetes mellitus

The presence of anti-insulin antibodies was determined by ELISA in serum samples from 30 diabetic dogs receiving bovine insulin therapy and 30 normoglycaemic dogs. Twenty of the diabetic dogs had significant reactivity to both bovine (heterologous) and porcine (homologous) insulin compared to control dogs. In contrast there was no significant difference between the two populations in reactivity to canine distemper virus (CDV) or canine thyroglobulin. The high degree of correlation between anti-bovine insulin and anti-porcine insulin antibodies suggested cross-reactivity which was confirmed by performing a competition ELISA, with antibody binding to bovine insulin inhibited by pre-incubating serum with porcine insulin. The insulin B-chain, rather than the A-chain was the most reactive component of the insulin molecule although in some cases, diabetics with antibody reactivity to whole insulin protein showed minimal reactivity to the individual subunits. The data suggest that treatment of diabetic dogs with bovine insulin can lead to anti-insulin antibody production. These antibodies cross-react with homologous insulin and recognise conformational as well as linear epitopes.

Protamine and protamine-insulins exacerbate the vascular response to injury

Endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells produce heparinlike compounds that are growth inhibitory for vascular smooth muscle cells, and it has been suggested that these compounds play a regulatory role that is perturbed with vascular injury. Indeed, exogenous heparin preparations effectively suppress smooth muscle cell proliferation following injury imposed on vascular endothelium. We now report that protamine, an agent that binds heparin and negates its anticoagulant properties, has potent stimulatory effects on vascular smooth muscle cell proliferation. The administration of protamine, alone or as part of commonly used insulin preparations, stimulated the proliferation of cultured smooth muscle cells, exacerbated vascular smooth muscle cell proliferative lesions in laboratory rats, and interfered with the growth-inhibitory effects of heparin in culture and in vivo. These results confirm the importance of endogenous heparinlike compounds in arterial homeostasis and may require reconsideration of protamine use following vascular reparative procedures and in diabetics.

Bovine and human NPH insulins as T cell immunogens

The aim of this study was to assess the immunocompetence of T cells from patients with poorly controlled diabetes with respect to Candida albicans antigen and to compare the relative immunogenicity of human insulin, bovine insulin and protamine at the T-cell level during 6 months treatment with human or bovine NPH insulins. T-cell proliferation was measured in vitro in response to C. albicans, bovine and human insulin, bovine and human NPH and protamine in 17 patients with newly-diagnosed type 1 (insulin-dependent) and 12 with poorly-controlled type 2 (non-insulin-dependent diabetes) before and after 0.5, 1, 3 and 6 months of treatment with either bovine or human NPH insulin. The following results were found: Baseline responses to C. albicans (as a recall antigen) were similar for patients and controls despite marked hyperglycaemia in the patients. No patient had a response greater than mean + 2 S.D. of controls to human or bovine insulin before starting treatment, or had insulin autoantibodies. Treatment with human NPH insulin did not induce T-cell responses to human or bovine insulin, but 3/13 (23%) patients treated with bovine NPH responded to bovine and human insulin after 6 months, of whom one responded exclusively to human. In contrast, 6 (46%) bovine and 3 (19%) human NPH-treated patients responded to protamine. It was concluded that there is no evidence of T-cell immunosuppression in poorly-controlled diabetes or of T-cell autoimmunity to insulin in newly-diagnosed type 1 diabetes. Treatment with bovine NPH insulin immunizes T cells to insulin, but human NPH does not.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Drug allergy

Although allergic drug reactions are just one type of adverse reaction to medications, they are clinically very important because of the morbidity and mortality they cause. An ever-expanding pharmacopeia increases the potential for allergic drug reactions. An understanding of the types of allergic drug reactions, their immunopathologic mechanisms, and the most likely medications involved; an approach to determine the drug responsible for the reaction; and ways to prevent future allergic drug reactions are important features in minimizing patient morbidity.

Allergy to protamine

Recent advances in medicine, such as cardiac catheterization, phoresis, dialysis, and cardiopulmonary bypass technology, have increased the need for heparin anticoagulation. To antagonize heparin's effect and prevent hemorrhagic complications after the procedure, protamine has likewise been used more frequently. With its increased use have come increased reports of adverse protamine reactions consisting of rash, urticaria, elevation of pulmonary artery pressure, systemic hypotension, and, at times, death. The elevation of pulmonary artery pressure, which appears to be a rather common occurrence in animals, may be an isolated finding without clinical consequences in humans. However, this pulmonary vasoconstriction may, when severe, lead to acute right-sided heart failure and systemic hypotension. Other protamine reactions involve a decrease in systemic vascular resistance and systemic hypotension without changes in pulmonary artery pressure. Causes of acute protamine reactions may involve the generation of anaphyatoxins and prostanoids either from protamine-heparin complexes or complement-fixing antiprotamine IgG antibodies, from inhibition of plasma Carboxypeptidase N, from crosslinking of cell-surface antiprotamine IgE on mast cells and basophils with subsequent mediator release, or from potentiation of IgE-mediated release of histamine through a polycationin-recognition site. Although we have come a long way in understanding the mechanisms by which protamine can cause its ill effects in humans, more work is clearly needed to define, in prospective studies, the incidence of and risk factors for protamine reactions in various patient groups, and to delineate more clearly which mechanisms are involved in each clinical type of acute protamine reaction. Hopefully, this will lead to strategies and protamine alternatives that will prevent or diminish, in frequency or severity, adverse protamine reactions. Alternatively, a clearer picture of the risk factors important for protamine reactions and the predictive value of diagnostic tests (e.g., protamine IgE antibody) can also minimize the clinical impact of this increasingly common adverse event.

Purification and analysis of the major components of chum salmon protamine contained in insulin formulations using high-performance liquid chromatography

A simple high-performance liquid chromatographic method has been developed for the rapid purification and analysis of protamine components contained in insulin formulations. Only a single step is needed to separate peptides whose compositions, sizes, and unusual isoelectric points (pI 13.8) are nearly identical. The method involves their isocratic separation on a reversed-phase column using a pH 2 phosphate buffer and a low acetonitrile content as an eluant. The purified chum salmon components were analyzed by amino acid analysis, solid-phase amino acid sequencing, carboxypeptidase B digests, insulin complexation analysis, and a mass spectrophotometric procedure which gives an accurate mass of the intact peptides. This HPLC purification technique may also be applicable to protamines and other highly basic peptides isolated from other sources.

Protamine antibody production in diabetic subjects treated with NPH insulin

Treatment with neutral protamine Hagedorn (NPH) insulin predisposes individuals with diabetes to anaphylactoid reactions when given bolus protamine for heparin reversal during cardiovascular procedures. To prospectively examine production of protamine antibodies, 30 patients with non-insulin dependent diabetes were followed for 12 months from initiation of therapy with porcine NPH or Lente insulin. Twenty-one subjects were randomly assigned to NPH (protamine containing) and nine controls to Lente (protamine free) insulin. Protamine specific IgG antibody was produced by 6/21 (29%) of NPH-treated subjects and 0/9 controls. Among NPH treated subjects, there was no difference between protamine antibody producers and non-producers with regard to age, race, weight, or pre-treatment glycosylated hemoglobin. Both producer and non-producer groups received similar amounts of insulin and protamine and achieved similar glycemic control. Insulin antibodies were made by 4/6 (67%) of protamine antibody producers and by 6/15 (40%) of non-producers (NS). The authors conclude that one of three new diabetics who are treated with porcine NPH insulin will make IgG protamine antibodies. These antibodies do not affect insulin requirements, glycemic control, or insulin antibody production. Because of the frequency of protamine antibody production and the risk of anaphylaxis to bolus protamine administration in NPH treated diabetics, the authors suggest that NPH insulin-treated individuals should avoid heparin reversal by protamine.

In vitro activity of biosynthetic human diarginylinsulin

In diarginylinsulin two arginine residues are located at the C-terminal end of the B-chain (ArgB31 and ArgB32). This accounts for a shift of the isoelectric point from pH 5.4 in native insulin to pH 7.0 in diarginylinsulin leading to pharmacodynamic characteristics of an intermediate acting insulin when administered s.c. as pH 4.0-5.0 solution. We have investigated insulin receptor binding and biological activity of biosynthetic human diarginylinsulin in human adipocytes and compared to native insulin and proinsulin. Association- and dissociation studies of insulin receptor binding revealed no differences for diarginylinsulin and native insulin. In competition studies under steady-state binding conditions, half-maximal displacement of tracer occurred at 352 +/- 33 pmol/l, 337 +/- 32 pmol/l and 3640 +/- 480 pmol/l for diarginylinsulin, insulin and proinsulin, respectively. The biologic potency of human diarginylinsulin was evaluated by the ability to stimulate D-glucose transport and by the assessment of the antilipolytic activity. Activation of D-glucose transport was half-maximal at 49.6 +/- 5.4 pmol/l (diarginylinsulin), 44.8 +/- 5.8 pmol/l (insulin) and at 476.7 +/- 134.3 pmol/l (proinsulin). Half-maximal inhibition of lipolysis occurred at 13.9 +/- 3.4 pmol/l, 15.4 +/- 2.9 pmol/l and 138.4 +/- 38.6 pmol/l, respectively. In conclusion, diarginylinsulin has almost identical insulin receptor binding characteristics and full biological activity in vitro compared to native insulin. This pharmacodynamically intermediate acting insulin preparation is therefore of potential therapeutical value.

A longitudinal study of insulin antibodies and anti-insulin cytotoxicity in type I diabetes mellitus

Insulin antibodies and T-cell lymphocyte cytotoxic reactivity against insulin and its related peptides were studied longitudinally in 3 groups of patients with type I diabetes mellitus (DM). Group 1 patients were those in whom the diagnosis was made within 1 week of the initiation diagnosis. They were subdivided into those receiving MC porcine (A) or MC bovine (B) insulin. Group 2 patients were those with a duration of DM for 2-6 years who were receiving either MC porcine (A) or MC bovine (B) insulins. Group 3 subjects were those who had been on conventional recrystallized insulin and then switched to MC porcine (A) or MC bovine (B) insulins for 2 weeks before the start of the study. The incidence of cytotoxic reactions and insulin antibodies were approximately 40-50% for group 1 (either 1A or 1B) at the initiation of the study. At 3-month follow up all patients in group 1B developed insulin antibodies (p less than 0.02) and a significant increase in the frequency of cytotoxic reactions (p less than 0.01). By contrast there was a decline in the frequency of cytotoxic reactions in group 1A (p less than 0.01 at 1 year) and the increase in insulin antibodies was non-significant. Group 2B had higher frequency in cytotoxic reactions (p less than 0.005) and of insulin antibodies (p less than 0.05) than group 2A. A significant decrease (p less than 0.01) in cytotoxic reactions was observed at 3 months following the switch of patients from conventional bovine insulin preparations to 'A' but not to 'B'. However in both subgroups insulin antibodies persisted for at least 12 months. Cross-reactivity between antibodies to human, porcine and bovine insulins was evident in all groups. The early cellular and humoral immune phenomena were positively correlated in both group 1A and 1B suggesting their common involvement in the pathogenesis of DM.

The human cellular immune response to insulin: a study in unexposed control subjects and type I diabetic patients on acute and chronic treatment

Using a cellular cytotoxicity assay, we have investigated the antigenicity of pharmaceutical insulins and of highly purified insulin constituents (unformulated monocomponent (MC) insulin, insulin B-component and C-peptide) in control, insulin naive, subjects and in three groups of type I diabetic patients. These were: Group 1, newly diagnosed patients receiving either porcine or bovine MC insulins for less than one week; Group 2, established patients receiving porcine or bovine MC insulin for 2-6 years; Group 3, established patients receiving conventional bovine insulin for 2-6 years, and tested within two weeks of switching to either porcine or bovine MC insulins. In control subjects, there was a higher incidence of cytotoxic reactions with beef (72%) than with porcine (33%) pharmaceutical preparations (p less than 0.01) but there was a similar incidence of reactions with the purified beef and pork constituents. All patients, except those Group 3 patients receiving bovine MC insulins, had a significantly increased incidence of aggregate reactions to the spectrum of antigens. In porcine treated patients, there was an increase in the incidence of reactions to pharmaceutical preparations in Group 1 (p less than 0.05) and Group 3 (p less than 0.001), but this was absent from each of the bovine treated groups. All patient groups showed significant increases in the incidence of reactions against insulin constituents of their therapeutic analog. In Groups 1 and 2, but not 3, there was significant analog cross reactivity. We deduce that the reactivity seen in control subjects is principally directed against unidentified formulation constituents of bovine pharmaceutical preparations. Patients on both acute and chronic therapy with insulin show T-cell sensitization to MC insulin and its components. Chronic therapy with conventional bovine insulin induces tolerogenesis, but this is reversed on exposure to a fresh insulin analog.