Selective digestion of mouse metaphase chromosomes

The centromere kinesin-like protein, CENP-E. An autoantigen in systemic sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

Autoantibodies directed against centromere proteins (CENPs) are a serologic feature in some patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc). Previous studies have focused on autoantibodies to CENPs A, B, and C. CENP-E is a recently described 312-kd protein that also localizes to the centromere. Therefore, we studied the presence of autoantibodies to recombinant CENP-E in patients with SSc.

METHODS

Sixty sera from patients with the SSc spectrum of diseases were screened for the presence of autoantibodies against CENP-E, by indirect immunofluorescence and immunoblotting using recombinant CENP-E protein. HLA class II alleles were determined by DNA oligotyping.

RESULTS

Among the SSc sera, 15 of 60 (25%) demonstrated antibody reactivity with recombinant CENP-E, and 14 of these 15 sera (93%) had antibodies directed against another CENP. Anti-CENP-E was seen in 13 of 30 sera with anti-CENP (43%). All patients with anti-CENP-E had a limited form of SSc, known as the CREST variant (calcinosis, Raynaud's phenomenon, esophageal dysmotility, sclerodactyly, telangiectasias). When patients with anti-CENPs A, B, or C were compared with patients with anti-CENP-E, no unique clinical features in the anti-CENP-E positive group were identified. Ninety-three percent of the patients with anti-CENP-E had HLA-DQB1 alleles that had polar amino acids at position 26 (primarily DQB1*05), similar to patients with other CENP autoantibodies.

CONCLUSION

Antibodies to CENP-E are common in patients with SSc, and are seen in higher frequency in sera from patients with a limited form, or CREST variant, of the disease.

Centromeric DNA cloned from functional kinetochore fragments in mitotic cells with unreplicated genomes

Treatment of cells arrested in the cell cycle at the G1/S-phase boundary with 5 mM caffeine induces premature mitosis, resulting in chromosomal fragmentation and detachment of centromere-kinetochore fragments, which are subsequently attached to the mitotic spindle and segregated in anaphase. Taking advantage of this in vivo separation of the centromere, we have developed a procedure for isolation of a centromere-enriched fraction of mitotic chromatin. Using this method, we have isolated and cloned DNA from the centromere-enriched material of Chinese hamster cells. One of the clones thus obtained was characterized in detail. It contains 6 kb of centromere-associated sequence that exhibits no recognizable homology with other mammalian centromeric sequences and is devoid of any extensive repetitive structure. This sequence is present in a single copy on chromosome 1 and is species-specific. Distinctive features of the clone include the presence of several A+T-rich regions and clusters of multiple topoisomerase II consensus cleavage sites and other sequence motifs characteristic of nuclear matrix-associated regions. We hypothesize that these features might be related to the more compact packaging of centromeric chromatin in interphase nuclei and mitotic chromosomes.

High affinity DNA-microtubule interactions: evidence for a conserved DNA-MAP interaction involving unusual high CsCl density repetitious DNA families

We have examined high affinity interactions of chick brain microtubule proteins with 35S labelled tracer DNAs from chick, mouse and D. melanogaster under equilibrium conditions by the nitrocellulose filter binding technique. Ternary reaction mixtures of the above two components and a third component, an excess of unlabelled competitor DNA from either E. coli., mouse, D. melanogaster or chick, were used to measure small fractions of DNA in each case (1-4%) bound to microtubule protein under high stringency- large competitor DNA concentration and 0.5 M NaCl. As seen in part previously (Marx, K.A. and Denial, T. (1985) in The Molecular Basis of Cancer, 172B, 65-75 (Rein, ed), A. Liss, N.Y.) the measured order of competitor DNA strengths was identical for all three tracer DNAs. That is: chick > mouse > D. melanogaster > E. coli competitor DNA. Since the homologous interaction, chick competitor DNA with chick brain microtubule protein, is always the strongest interaction measured, we interpret this as evidence for a conserved protein-DNA sequence interaction. 35S chick DNA tracer sequences, isolated from nitrocellulose filters following the stringent binding in the presence of 0.9 mM-1 E. coli. competitor DNA, was used in driven reassociation reactions with total chick driver DNA. This fraction was found to be significantly enriched in repetitive chick DNA sequences. Since we have observed a similar phenomenon in mouse, we then compared the stringent binding mouse sequences and showed that the bulk of these sequences did not cross-hybridize with total chick DNA. Finally, all three 35S tracer DNAs binding to nitrocellulose were isolated and sedimented to equilibrium on CsCl density gradients. The CsCl density distributions from all three DNAs showed significant (100-fold) enrichment in classical satellite DNAs as well as higher enrichment in two very unusual high CsCl density families of DNA (1.720-1.740 g/cm3; 1.750-1.765 g/cm3). These families are never observed as distinct bands in total DNA CsCl gradients, nor could we isolate them in purified tubulin control binding experiments. This apparently general phenomena may be identifying some of the sequence families involved in the high affinity microtubule interaction, which appears to be conserved in evolution.

The affinity of DNA-microtubule protein complexes and their disruption by tubulin binding drugs

Using the gel shift assay system, we have measured the apparent affinity constant for the interaction of two different DNAs with MAP proteins found in both total calf brain microtubules and heat stable brain preparations. Both DNAs studied contained centromere/kinetochore sequences- one was enriched in the calf satellite DNA; the other was a large restriction fragment containing the yeast CEN11 DNA sequence. Complexes formed using both DNAs had similar Kapp values in the range of 2.1 x 10(7) M-1 to 2.0 x 10(8) M-1. CEN11 DNA-MTP complexes had by far the highest Kapp value of 2.0 x 10(8) M-1. The CEN11 DNA sequence is where the yeast kinetochore of chromosome 11 is formed and where the single yeast microtubule is bound in vivo. The CEN11 conserved region II known binding sites-(dA/dT)n runs- for mammalian MAP2 protein, are in good agreement with this higher Kapp value. The effects of the classical tubulin binding drugs colchicine, podophyllotoxin and vinblastine on the DNA-MAP protein complex stability were investigated by determining the drug concentrations where the complexes were destabilized. Only the complexes formed from total microtubule protein (tubulin containing) were destabilized over a wide drug concentration range. Heat stable brain protein complexes (no tubulin) were largely unaffected. Furthermore, it took 10-100 fold higher drug concentrations to disrupt the CEN11 DNA complexes compared to the calf thymus satellite DNA enriched complexes. These data support our previous results suggesting that there is a DNA sequence dependent interaction with MAP proteins that appears to be conserved in evolution (Marx et. al., Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 783, 383-392, 1984; Marx and Denial, Molecular Basis of Cancer 172B, 65-75 1985). In addition, these results imply that the classical tubulin binding drugs may exert their biological effects in cells at least in part by disrupting DNA-Protein complexes of the type we have studied here.

HeT DNA: a family of mosaic repeated sequences specific for heterochromatin in Drosophila melanogaster

HeT DNA is a complex family of repeated DNA found only in pericentric and telomeric heterochromatin. In contrast to other DNA families that have been specifically associated with heterochromatin, HeT DNA is not principally a family of tandemly repeated elements. Much of the HeT DNA family appears to be a mosaic of several different classes of large sequence elements arranged in a scrambled array; however, some elements of the family can be found in tandem repeats. In spite of the variable order of the different elements in HeT DNA, the sequence homology between different members of each class of element is extremely high, suggesting that the members are evolving in a concerted fashion. Sequence analysis suggests that some elements in the HeT family may make up a novel family of heterochromatin-specific transposable elements and that the mosaic organization of the elements may be produced by retroposition and other mechanisms involved in the transposition of mobile elements. We suggest that such mechanisms may be a general feature for the maintenance of chromosome structure.

The organization of the mouse satellite DNA at centromeres

The mouse genome contains a major and a minor satellite DNA family of repetitive DNA sequences. The use of 5-azacytidine has allowed us to demonstrate that these satellite DNAs are organized in two separate domains at the centromeres of mouse chromosomes. The minor satellite is closer to the short arms of the acrocentric chromosomes than the major satellite. The major satellite is farther away, flanking the minor satellite and adjacent to the euchromatic long arm of each mouse chromosome. At the level of resolution afforded by the in situ hybridization technique it would appear that the organization of the centromeric domain of the mouse is similar to that in man. That is, both contain two repetitive DNA sequence families arranged in major blocks.

Sequence organization and cytological localization of the minor satellite of mouse

A complete 120 bp genomic consensus sequence for the mouse minor satellite has been determined from enriched L929 centromeric sequences. The extensive sequence homology existing between the major and minor satellite suggests an evolutionary relationship. Some sequences flanking the minor satellite has also been identified and they provide insight into centromeric DNA organization. Isotopic in situ hybridization analysis of the minor satellite to mouse L929 and Mus musculus metaphase spreads showed that this repetitive DNA class is localized specifically to centromeres of all chromosomes of the karyotype. With the use of high resolution non-isotopic fluorescence in situ hybridization the minor satellite is further localized to the outer surface of the centromere in a discrete region at or immediately adjacent to the kinetochore. Our cytological data suggests that the minor satellite might play a role in the organization of the kinetochore region rather than, as previously suggested, sites for general anchoring of the genome to the nuclear matrix.

Detection of distinct structural domains within the primary constriction using autoantibodies

We report the immunological differentiation of structures within the primary constriction. These include the kinetochore and the connecting strand, a structure which connects sister kinetochores. The location and temporal appearance of the connecting strand antigen suggest that it could play a role in the maintenance of sister chromatid pairing. In addition, we report the identification of a novel epitope that is localized to discrete patches along the entire length of the junction between sister chromatids at metaphase (the junction patch antigen). The patches on the inner surface of the euchromatic arms can be disrupted by Colcemid treatment while those found in the primary constriction remain intact. The apparent heterogeneity of the patches suggests that they may play different roles in the regulation of sister chromatid pairing. Because of their cytological localization and possible functional role, the junction patch and connecting strand antigens have provisionally been collectively termed CLiPs (Chromatid Linking Proteins). All of these antigenic sites are shown to be distinct from centromeric heterochromatin, which can itself be immunologically differentiated from the euchromatic arms. The relationship between the antigenicity of the primary constriction and the unique manner in which chromatin is organized in this region is discussed.

Curvature of mouse satellite DNA and condensation of heterochromatin

Cloned, sequenced mouse satellite DNA exhibits properties characteristic of molecules that possess a stable curvature. Circularly permuted fragments containing the region predicted to bend were used to map the curvature relative to DNA sequence. The altered mobility of these fragments in polyacrylamide gels is reversed when gels are run in the presence of distamycin A, a drug that binds preferentially to AT-rich DNA. Treatment of living mouse cells with this drug dramatically reduces the condensation of centromeric heterochromatin, the exclusive location of satellite sequences. In situ hybridization of satellite probes to extended chromosomes at the electron microscope level shows that satellite does not comprise a single block but is distributed throughout the centromere region. Based on these experiments, we hypothesize that the structure of mouse satellite DNA is an important feature of centromeric heterochromatin condensation.

Organization within the mammalian kinetochore

The organization within the mammalian kinetochore was examined using whole-mount electron microscopic techniques on chromosomes digested with restriction enzymes or micrococcal nuclease. These preparations revealed that a portion of the kinetochore is highly resistant to nuclease digestion and can be visualized as a discrete structure. The relationship of this structure to the remainder of the chromosome suggests that it represents the outer kinetochore plate. The plate is composed of a series of fibrillar loops that are arranged in a parallel array along the plane of the plate. These fibers are 25-30 nm in diameter. The morphology, particulate substructure, and ultimate susceptibility to nuclease digestion suggest that these fibers contain DNA. A model is presented that suggests that the outer plate contains the apexes of chromatin loops that originate within the body of the primary constriction.

Fractionation and initial characterization of the kinetochore from mammalian metaphase chromosomes

We have partially isolated the kinetochore and associated centromeric structures from mammalian metaphase chromosomes. Human autoantibodies from scleroderma CREST (calcinosis, Raynaud's phenomenon, esophageal dysmotility, sclerodactyly, telangiectasia) patients were used as immunofluorescent probes to monitor fractionation. The procedure includes digestion of total chromosomal DNA with micrococcal nuclease, dehistonization with heparin, and dissociation of the remaining material with detergent and urea. We used a density gradient (metrizamide) to obtain an enriched fraction of stained material (kinetochore). When examined by electron microscopy, the kinetochore fraction is seen to contain numerous small immunoperoxidase-positive masses which are morphologically similar to the centromere/kinetochore region of intact metaphase chromosomes. The particulate fraction that contains kinetochore components represents less than 5% of total chromosomal proteins and contains less than 1% of total DNA. Two polypeptides of 18 and 80 kD were identified as kinetochore antigens by immunoblotting with CREST antiserum. In this paper we discuss the distribution of these kinetochore polypeptides with the associated centromeric chromatin.

The kinetochore of mammalian chromosomes: structure and function in normal mitosis and aneuploidy

The kinetochore is a structurally differentiated site on mitotic chromosomes to which spindle microtubules (MTs) are attached. In mammalian cells, the kinetochore is organized into a trilamellar plate and is morphologically distinct from the centromere. Although kinetochores and centromeres are morphologically and biochemically distinct regions, they are functionally linked and necessary for normal chromosome movement and segregation. Recent biochemical and immunocytochemical studies suggest that the kinetochore is composed of several polypeptides, DNA, and possibly RNA. The kinetochore plates are composed of tubulin and two antigens of 17 Kd and 80 Kd, as detected by scleroderma CREST antiserum. Colcemid, a MT inhibitor, also causes reversible rearrangements of kinetochore structure. Mitomycin C binds to heterochromatin and causes the trilamellar plates to become detached from the chromosome. Diethylstilbestrol (DES), a synthetic estrogen, inhibits mitosis in mammalian cells and causes chromosome lagging or malorientation during recovery. Electron microscopy indicates that DES causes disruption of the mitotic spindle, centriole elongation, and unusual chromosome associations due to interkinetochore microtubules. No apparent damage to kinetochores was noted in lagging or maloriented chromosomes.

High-affinity microtubule protein-higher organism DNA complexes. Many-fold enrichment in repetitive mouse DNA sequences comprised of satellite DNAs

We have examined aspects of the interaction of cycled microtubule protein preparations with 35S-labeled mouse DNA tracer in a competition system with unlabelled competitor E. coli or mouse DNA. The nitrocellulose filter binding assay was used to measure interaction by scintillation counting. DNA molecular weight affected the levels of filter retained 35S-labelled mouse tracer DNA. Filter retention levels increased if 35S-labelled mouse DNA tracer size was increased, and the filter binding level decreased if competitor DNA size was increased. There was a sizeable, reproducible difference in the 35S-labelled mouse DNA tracer binding level of about 1% when E. coli or mouse DNA competitors were compared. Mouse DNA more effectively competed with 35S-labelled mouse DNA for microtubule protein binding than did E. coli DNA, suggesting that a small class of higher-organism DNA sequences interacts very strongly with microtubule protein. From other studies we know this to be the MAP fraction (Marx, K.A. and Denial, T. (1984) in The Molecular Basis of Cancer (Rein, R., ed.), Alan R. Liss, New York, in the press; and Villasante, E., Corces, V.G., Manso-Martinez, R. and Avila, J. (1981) Nucleic Acids Res. 9, 895-908). We find that this difference in competitor DNA strength is qualitatively similar under high-stringency conditions (0.5 M NaCl, high competitor [DNA]) we developed for examining high-affinity complexes. Under high-stringency conditions we isolated 1.2% and 0.6% of 35S-labelled mouse DNA at 4200 and 350 bp respective sizes as nitrocellulose filter bound DNA-protein complexes. At both molecular weights these high-affinity DNA sequences, isolated from the filters, were shown to be significantly enriched in repetitive DNA sequences by S1 nuclease solution reassociation kinetics. The kinetics are consistent with about a 4-fold mouse satellite DNA enrichment as well as enrichment in other repetitious DNA sequence classes. The high molecular weight filter-bound DNA samples were sedimented to equilibrium in CsCl buoyant density gradients and found to contain primarily mouse satellite DNA density sequences (1.691 g/cm3) with some minor fractions at other density positions (1.670, 1.682, 1.705, 1.740, 1.760 g/cm3) similar to those observed by our laboratory in previous investigations of micrococcal nuclease-resistant chromatin (Marx, K.A. (1977) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 78, 777-784). That the high-affinity microtubule-bound DNA was some 3-5-fold enriched in mouse satellite sequences was demonstrated by its characteristic BstNI restriction enzyme cleavage pattern.

The kinetochore is part of the metaphase chromosome scaffold

We used antisera from patients with the CREST syndrome of scleroderma (calcinosis, Raynaud's phenomenon, esophageal dysmotility, sclerodactyly, telangiectasia) to show that an antigenic component of the kinetochore present in metaphase chromosomes is also present in nonhistone chromosome scaffolds isolated following extensive digestion of the DNA and extraction of the bulk of chromosomal protein. All sera from 12 scleroderma CREST patients previously shown by immunofluorescence microscopy to have circulating antikinetochore antibodies recognise a protein of Mr 77,000 (CREST-77) in an immunoblotting assay. 9 of the 12 sera also recognise an antigen of Mr 110,000 (CREST-110). These proteins are present in isolated chromosomes and nonhistone scaffolds derived from them by two different procedures. Sera of five scleroderma CREST patients who are antikinetochore negative (by immunofluorescence) bind to neither protein in immunoblots. These data suggest that CREST-77 (and possibly CREST-110) is a component of the human kinetochore, and that the kinetochore is an integral part of the mitotic chromosome scaffolding.

Preparation of centromeric heterochromatin by restriction endonuclease digestion of mouse L929 cells

When L929 cells in metaphase are digested with either Eco RI or Alu I, chromatin containing about 85% of the DNA is released. DNA from the Alu I- and Eco RI-resistant chromatin is enriched 6.8- and 3.7-fold, respectively, in satellite sequences. Analysis by electron microscopy of these digests reveals the existence of structures containing condensed heterochromatin and kinetochores. When these preparations are incubated with anticentromere serum from a human CREST scleroderma patient and then with rhodamine-conjugated antihuman IgG, fluorescence appears in the form of paired dots, the same pattern found in whole metaphase chromosomes. The fluorescent staining pattern, the electron microscopy, and the enrichment of satellite DNA sequences together support the conclusion that the Eco RI- and Alu I-resistant structures contain centromeres. We anticipate that these preparations will be useful in studies of the interactions between centromeric heterochromatin, kinetochores, and microtubules.

In situ hybridization at the electron microscope level: hybrid detection by autoradiography and colloidal gold

In situ hybridization has become a standard method for localizing DNA or RNA sequences in cytological preparations. We developed two methods to extend this technique to the transmission electron microscope level using mouse satellite DNA hybridization to whole mount metaphase chromosomes as the test system. The first method devised is a direct extension of standard light microscope level using mouse satellite DNA hybridization to whole mount metaphase chromosomes as the test system. The first method devised is a direct extension of standard light microscope in situ hybridization. Radioactively labeled complementary RNA (cRNA) is hybridized to metaphase chromosomes deposited on electron microscope grids and fixed in 70 percent ethanol vapor; hybridixation site are detected by autoradiography. Specific and intense labeling of chromosomal centromeric regions is observed even after relatively short exposure times. Inerphase nuclei present in some of the metaphase chromosome preparations also show defined paatterms of satellite DNA labeling which suggests that satellite-containing regions are associate with each other during interphase. The sensitivity of this method is estimated to at least as good as that at the light microscope level while the resolution is improved at least threefold. The second method, which circumvents the use of autoradiogrphic detection, uses biotin-labeled polynucleotide probes. After hybridization of these probes, either DNA or RNA, to fixed chromosomes on grids, hybrids are detected via reaction is improved at least threefold. The second method, which circumvents the use of autoradiographic detection, uses biotin-labeled polynucleotide probes. After hybridization of these probes, either DNA or RNA, to fixed chromosomes on grids, hybrids are detected via reaction with an antibody against biotin and secondary antibody adsorbed to the surface of over centromeric heterochromatin and along the associated peripheral fibers. Labeling is on average ten times that of background binding. This method is rapid and possesses the potential to allow precise ultrastructual localization of DNA sequences in chromosomes and chromatin.

Tubulin nucleation and assembly in mitotic cells: evidence for nucleic acids in kinetochores and centrosomes

A lysed cell system was used to study the organelle structure and nucleation of exogenous tubulin at kinetochores and centrosomes in mitotic PtK2 cells. We have used this lysed cell system in conjunction with nuclease digestion experiments to determine which specific nucleic acids (DNA or RNA) are involved in either the structure and/or microtubule-initiating capacity of kinetochores and centrosomes. The results indicate that DNase I specifically decondenses the kinetochore plate structure, with the eventual loss in the ability of the chromosomes to nucleate microtubule assembly. DNase I had no effect on either the structure or nucleating capacity of centrosomes. Both RNase T1 and RNase A specifically attacked the amorphous pericentriolar material of the centrosomes, with a concomitant loss in the ability of this material to nucleate microtubule formation. Neither RNase appeared to affect the structure or nucleating capacity of the kinetochore. Therefore, the two types of nucleases appear to exert preferential effects on the different types of microtubule initiation sites in mitotic mammalian cells. The results suggest that DNA is a major component of the kinetochore, while RNA is a major component of the amorphous pericentriolar material. These findings support the concept that microtubule initiation sites in mitotic cells contain nucleic acids which are essential for the structural and functional integrity of the sites.

Higher order structure in metaphase chromosomes. I. The 250 A fiber

Metaphase chromosomes released from cells in the presence of Joklik's suspension media by vortex-mixing with 0.5 mm glass beads have been analyzed by electron microscopy. In these preparations the chromosomes are composed of series of loops (200-300 A in diameter) which are, in turn, composed of closely-apposed arrays of nucleosomes. Negative-staining of these preparations has allowed the identification of several distinct patterns within the loop which appear to arise from variations in nucleosome packing. Analogous patterns are also observed in chromatin fragments generated by brief micrococcal nuclease digestion. From these data we have deduced certain features of nucleosome-nucleosome interactions in higher-ordered chromatin fibers.