Stage-specific responses following infection with Theileria annulata as evaluated using ELISA

Evaluation of sporozoite and macroschizont antigen (Spm2) of Theileria annulata for its diagnostic potential

Theileria are tick-borne apicomplexan parasites, which mainly infect ruminants in tropical and subtropical regions of the world. The present study was directed to investigate the serological methods for the diagnosis of theileriosis in crossbred cattle. Blood samples (n = 176) were collected from the regional cattle populations of Bihar state situated at the Gangetic plains of India. Microscopic examination of blood smears from the cattle revealed the presence of tick-borne infectious organisms (Theileria and Anaplasma) in the region. PCR-based detection of Tams1 (Theileria annulata merozoite surface antigen) gene and the sequencing of 18S rRNA amplicon from the blood samples confirmed T. annulata as the primary causative agent of theileriosis in cattle of the Bihar region. Similarly, the amplification of the msp5 gene confirmed Anaplasma marginale infection. For the large-scale epidemiological investigation, sporozoite and macroschizont (spm2) partial gene from T. annulata was cloned in pET-28a (+) vector and overexpressed in E. coli BL21 cells. Overexpressed recombinant-Spm2 (43 kDa) was purified by Ni-NTA affinity chromatography and was used for immunodetection of theileriosis in cattle serum samples. Sequence analysis of the cloned partial spm2 gene in this study showed multiple SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms) in T. annulata. Recombinant-Spm2 antigen was explicitly recognised by the immunoglobulins (IgG) of the cattle naturally infected with Theileria. Further, an indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed using partial r-Spm2 antigen that exhibited high sensitivity (100 %) and specificity (90.9 %). Thus, this study suggests that partial r-Spm2 can be used as a diagnostic antigen for seroepidemiological studies of T. annulata infection in crossbred cattle.

A review of Theileria diagnostics and epidemiology

•

Serological and molecular assays exist for most economic important Theileria species.

•

Molecular assays are constantly being improved with regard to sensitivity and specificity.

•

The concept of what constitute a Theileria species impacts on accurate diagnostics.

•

Analytical specificity of molecular assays are >800 000 parasites/L blood.

•

Parasitemia ranges may determine practical limits of detection.

An extensive range of serological and molecular diagnostic assays exist for most of the economically important Theileira species such as T. annulata, T. equi, T. lestoquardi, T. parva, T. uilenbergi and other more benign species. Diagnostics of Theileria is considered with regard to sensitivity and specificity of current molecular and serological assays and their use in epidemiology. In the case of serological assays, cross-reactivity of genetically closely related species reduces the use of the gold standard indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT). Development of antigen-specific assays does not necessarily address this problem, since closely related species will potentially have similar antigens. Even so, serological assays remain an important line of enquiry in epidemiological surveys. Molecular based assays have exploded in the last decade with significant improvements in sensitivity and specificity. In this review, the current interpretation of what constitute a species in Theileria and its impact on accurate molecular diagnostics is considered. Most molecular assays based on conventional or real-time PCR technology have proven to be on standard with regard to analytical sensitivity. However, consideration of the limits of detection in regard to total blood volume of an animal indicates that most assays may only detect >400,000 parasites/L blood. Even so, natural parasitaemia distribution in carrier-state animals seems to be above this limit of detection, suggesting that most molecular assays should be able to detect the majority of infected individuals under endemic conditions. The potential for false-negative results can, however, only be assessed within the biological context of the parasite within its vertebrate host, i.e. parasitaemia range in the carrier-state that will support infection of the vector and subsequent transmission.

Detection of Theileria orientalis in Iran by semi-nested PCR

In order to identify and differentiate Theileria orientalis in cattle which may be infected with Theileria annulata simultaneously, a semi-nested PCR was performed. Thus, 160 blood samples were collected from apparently healthy native cattle in Golestan province of northern Iran, during 2009 to 2011. The Tbs-S/Tbs-A primer set derived from the 18S rRNA encoding gene was used for first PCR amplification, and the amplified sequence weight by this primer set for Theileria sp. was 426-430 bp. Then, DNA solution from purified PCR product was used for the semi-nested PCR analysis. The first PCR product amplified using T. orientalis primer set (To-S/Tbs-A) derived from the 18SrRNA encoding gene, and this specific primer weight was 235 bp. Also, the first PCR product amplified using T. annulata primer set (Ta-S/Tbs-A) derived from the 18SrRNA encoding gene and this specific primer weight was 193 bp. Having extracted DNA of each sample, using Tbs-S/Tbs-A primer set for PCR and analyzing the PCR products on the 2% agarose gel electrophoresis, 13 out of 160 blood samples (8.12%) were positive for Theileria sp. Meanwhile, performing semi-nested PCR with T. orientalis-specific primers, 9 out of 13 blood samples (5.62%) were positive and performing semi-nested PCR with T. annulata-specific primers, 12 out of 13 blood samples (7.5%) were also positive. This molecular assay approves the presence of T. orientalis in the native cattle of northern parts of Iran for the first time. In addition, this procedure will detect the concurrent infection of T. orientalis and T. annulata in the cattle too.

Study on Theileria lestoquardi antigens as potential vaccine candidates

Theileria lestoquardi is the causative agent of malignant theileriosis of sheep and goats, causing morbidity and mortality in these animals worldwide. Western blot analysis based on T. lestoquardi schizont antigens was carried out using sera collected from Iranian sheep, which had been immunized with T. lestoquardi schizont-infected cells. The results of Western blot analysis demonstrated that schizont-immunized animals produced antibodies reacting with protein bands at 73, 42, 20, 14, and 12 kDa. Comparison of the results of the current Western blotting test with earlier studies of Theileria spp. revealed two immunogenic schizont proteins with molecular weights of 73 and 42 kDa shared between T. annulata and T. lestoquardi. Two other proteins with molecular weights of 14 and 12 kDa have not been previously found in other Theileria species. Our results suggest that the 73-kDa protein could be a potential vaccine candidate and that the 14- and 12-kDa proteins could be considered as diagnostic antigens.

Prevalence and distribution of tropical theileriosis in eastern Turkey

This study was carried out to determine the prevalence and distribution of tropical theileriosis in cattle in eastern Turkey by microscopical, serological and molecular methods. A total of 1561 whole blood, 1505 serum and 1483 blood smear samples were collected from cattle of various breeds and ages in 11 towns of Eastern Turkey. Theileria annulata piroplasm DNA extracted from cattle blood was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using species-specific primers. Serum antibodies against T. annulata were investigated by indirect fluorescence antibody test (IFAT). Blood smears were examined for Theileria piroplasms by microscopical examination (ME). In the examination of DNA extracted from 1561 blood samples, an amplicon with the size of 721bp was obtained in 37.8% (590/1561) of these samples. Serum antibodies against T. annulata and piroplasm of Theileria spp. were detected in 34.9% (526/1505) and 19.7% (293/1483) of the samples, respectively. The differences between ME and PCR results and between ME and IFAT results were statistically significant (P < 0.05). In contrast, there was no significant difference between the PCR and IFAT results. A total of 179 ticks (136 female; 43 male) belonging to Hyalomma spp. were collected from cattle from three towns. Ticks were identified to be Hyalomma anatolicum anatolicum on the basis of morphological features.

Characterization of efferent lymph cells and their function following immunization of cattle with an allogenic Theileria annulata infected cell line

Immunization of cattle with in vitro propagated bovine mononuclear cells infected with Theileria annulata induces a protective immune response. Activation and effector function of T cells exiting the lymph node draining the site of cell line immunization were investigated to understand the mechanisms involved in the generation of immunity. Immunized animals exhibited a biphasic immune response in efferent lymph as well as peripheral blood. The first phase corresponded to allogenic responses against MHC antigens of the immunizing cell line and the second was associated with parasite specific responses. An increase in the output of CD2(+) cells and MHC class II(+) cells in efferent lymph was observed after cell line immunization with a corresponding decrease in WC1(+) cells. Although the percentage of CD4(+) T cells did not change significantly over the course of the experiment, they became activated. Both CD25 and MHC class II expressing CD4(+) T cells were detected from day 7 onwards, peaking around day 13. Efferent lymph leukocytes (ELL) exhibited sustained responses to IL-2 in vitro following cell line immunization. Antigen specific proliferation was also detected first to the immunizing cell line and then to parasite antigens. The two peaks of CD2(+) cells were observed, which corresponded to similar peaks of CD8(+) cells. The increase in CD8(+) cells was more pronounced during the second parasite specific phase than the first allogenic phase. Activated CD8(+) T cells mainly expressed MHC class II and some expressed CD25. Significantly the peak of activated CD4(+) T cells preceded the peak of activated CD8(+) T cells, highlighting the role of T. annulata specific CD4(+) T cells in inducing parasite specific CD8(+) cytotoxic responses. A biphasic cytotoxic response also appeared in efferent lymph and peripheral blood, the first directed against MHC antigens of the immunizing cell line followed by MHC class I restricted parasite specific cytotoxicity. The cytotoxic responses in efferent lymph appeared earlier than peripheral blood, suggesting that activated CD8(+) cells exiting the draining lymph node following immunization with T. annulata infected schizonts play an important role in the development of protective immune responses.

Vaccination against tropical theileriosis

Theileria annulata, the cause of tropical theileriosis is propagated in cattle with stage-to-stage transmission by Hyalomma ticks. Three stages in the life cycle of the parasite--tick-derived sporozoites, intramononuclear schizonts, and erythrocytic merozoites--infect cattle. When cattle are inoculated with schizont-infected cells, the parasite is transferred from the donor cell to the recipient. The main pathological damage in cattle is induced by the schizont stage. Each development stage of T. annulata elicits a specific immune response. Schizont-infected lymphoid cells can be grown indefinitely in culture and prolonged cultivation results in loss of virulence. Blood-derived schizonts induce stronger immunity than culture-derived schizonts, which suggests that restrictions on the parasite population or antigenic variation occur during prolonged cultivation. The duration of immunity following sporozoite or schizont infections has not yet been determined, but does not appear to be lifelong. The attenuated, culture-derived anti-theileria vaccine proved to be safe and effective in prevention of field theileriosis in large enzootic areas.

Characterization of attenuated Theileria annulata vaccines from Spain and the Sudan

Theileriosis caused by Theileria annulata can be effectively prevented by vaccination with attenuated, cultured schizonts. Although these attenuated vaccines have been applied for a long time, not much is known about the fate of the vaccine strain in the field. Here, two experimental Spanish vaccine strains originating in Cádiz and Cáceres, and one Sudanese strain are studied to address the development of a carrier status and the infectivity for Hyalomma ticks. Moreover, the heterogeneity of the merozoite surface protein, Tams1, was analyzed in search for an attenuation marker. Using the sensitive reverse line blot (RLB) hybridization, the development of a low level carrier status was demonstrated in the Cáceres and Sudanese line vaccinated calves. Although no signal was detected in the Cádiz line vaccinated calves, seroconversion against the schizont stage was observed, as it was in all other calves. The experimental transmission of T. annulata by Hyalomma ticks to naïve calves was unsuccessful for all cell line inoculated calves. Tams1 heterogeneity indicated a clonal selection of parasites during the process of attenuation, but the Tams1 sequence itself has no connection with the attenuation status. In conclusion, a carrier status develops in attenuated schizont culture vaccinated calves, but is not infective for Hyalomma ticks. Based on these data, the risk for spread of the vaccine strains in the field may be very low.

Development of an indirect Tams1 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for diagnosis of Theileria annulata infection in cattle

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed based on a recombinant major Theileria annulata merozoite surface antigen, Tams1. Four different recombinant proteins derived from two different Tams1 alleles, both in two different truncated forms, were tested for their performance in the ELISA. Furthermore, antigen concentration, various buffers, washing protocol, and the choice of anti-total-immunoglobulin G (IgG), anti-IgG1, or anti-IgG2 as second antibody were evaluated. The performance of the resulting ELISA was analyzed by measuring the coefficient of variation (CV). A total of 22 sera were analyzed over the measurement range, resulting in a CV of ca. 10%, whereas 30% variation is the maximum acceptable. The cutoff value was determined by the two-graph receiver operating characteristic (TG-ROC), using the indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT) as a reference. It was shown that up to 3 months postinfection (p.i.) IFAT is more sensitive and specific, whereas beyond 3 months p.i. ELISA performed as well as IFAT. The cutoff was determined at maximal sensitivity, based on the TG-ROC after 3 months p.i. Nine calves experimentally infected with four different T. annulata stocks remained positive in the ELISA for at least 1 year p.i. Finally, limited cross-reaction was found only with T. parva antisera, but not with any other Theileria or Babesia species. Since the T. parva endemic area hardly overlaps with T. annulata, the Tams1 ELISA has the potential to become a useful tool in the epidemiology of tropical theileriosis.

Comparison of cellular schizont, soluble schizont and soluble piroplasm antigens in ELISA for detecting antibodies against Theileria annulata

The efficacy and suitability of cellular schizont, soluble schizont and soluble piroplasm antigens was compared for detecting antibodies against Theileria annulata. Fifty bovine sera of known identity were evaluated in ELISA using the above mentioned antigens. Antibody titres of 1:100 to 1:51,200 were detected while using soluble piroplasm and cellular schizont antigen in ELISA. The titres ranged between 1:100 to 1:25,600 with the soluble schizont antigen. Soluble piroplasm antigen exhibited the highest antibody titres followed by cellular schizont and soluble schizont antigens. Cellular schizont antigen proved to be better than soluble schizont antigen for detecting anti-schizontal antibodies. Antibody titres obtained by the three antigens exhibited a good linear correlation amongst each other. The study showed that soluble piroplasm and cellular schizont antigens can be used successfully for detecting antibodies against piroplasm and schizont stages of T. annulata, respectively in bovine sera.