The chromosome complement of first-cleavage mouse embryos after in vitro fertilization

DNA damage in human sperm: The sperm chromosome assay

Background

Sperm DNA damage is a major cause of pre‐ and post‐implantation embryonic loss in humans. However, the factors that control how and when such DNA damage occurs in human sperm are poorly understood.

Methods

Here, I review information relating to sperm DNA damage that can be obtained from the sperm chromosome assays described in the existing literature.

Main findings

The sperm chromosome assays, which consist of interspecific in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection using murine oocytes and subsequent chromosome analysis, indicate that the proportion of sperm showing DNA damage is initially low and there are larger numbers of sperm with potential membrane and DNA damage that are induced after ejaculation and separation from the seminal plasma. Other assays that directly detect sperm DNA (e.g., TUNEL assays, Comet assays, and acridine orange test) are not able to distinguish and detect the initial and potential DNA damage. Furthermore, the positive values in these direct assays are influenced by the frequency of immotile sperm and amorphous sperm populations.

Conclusion

The findings in the sperm chromosome assays show that further improvements in sperm preparation protocols may result in the reduction of sperm DNA damage, followed by more successful outcomes in infertility treatment.

Evaluation of the developmental competence and chromosomal compliment of mouse oocytes derived from in-vitro growth and maturation of preantral follicles

PURPOSE

To evaluate the developmental potential and aneuploidy rates of in-vitro versus in-vivo grown and matured mouse oocytes.

METHODS

Mice were superovulated to obtain in-vivo matured oocytes. Mouse preantral follicles were also mechanically isolated and cultured in-vitro. In-vitro fertilization (IVF) was performed and fertilization, cleavage, and morula/blastocyst formation rates were compared between groups. Cytogenetic analysis was used to compare oocyte aneuploidy rates and aneuploidy characteristics in the developing embryos.

RESULTS

In-vivo oocyte maturation resulted in higher IVF fertilization, cleavage, and morula/blastocyst formation rates versus in-vitro follicle culture (96.4% versus 78.5%, p<0.001; 95.3% versus 77.4%, p<0.001; 94.1% versus 76.9%, p<0.001). Total aneuploidy rates were higher in embryos derived from in-vitro matured oocytes versus those grown in-vivo (4.0% versus 1.3%, p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Results indicate a reduced developmental competency of in-vitro matured oocytes. The data also highlight an increased susceptibility to meiotic errors in early stage follicles undergoing in vitro culture.

Polyploidy in mouse embryos derived from in vivo and in vitro fertilization is dependent on the timing of pregnant mare serum gonadotropin (PMSG) injection

Nine hundred eighty-seven mouse embryos were cytogenetically analyzed at the two-cell stage to compare aneuploidy rates in embryos derived from both in vivo and in vitro fertilization using two different ovarian stimulation protocols. The rate of polyploidy was significantly (P<.001) elevated in both in vivo fertilized (15.6%) and in vitro fertilized (5.9%) embryos when PMSG injection was given in the afternoon instead of the morning (2.1% and 4.0% respectively).

Dynamic changes in microtubules and early development of reconstructed embryos after somatic cell nuclear transfer in a non-human primate

In order to improve somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) efficiency and to understand cellular changes in SCNT, the dynamic changes in microtubules/DNA and early development of SCNT embryos with single or multiple pronuclei were investigated, along with activation timing on efficiency of SCNT, were studied in the Cynomolgus monkey. The confocal images showed that microtubules assembled around condensed DNA at 1h after cell injection; normal or abnormal reconstructed spindle formed at 2 h after cell injection; and reconstructed spindle separated at 2 h after activation. The results of nuclear formation showed that 61.3% of the reconstructed embryos did not form pronuclei; 19.3% formed a single nucleus, and 11.9% and 7.5% formed two and more than two reconstructed pronuclei, respectively. The cleavage and 8-cell development rates of SCNT embryos with pronuclei were significantly higher than those without pronuclei, but there was no difference in development rates among NT embryos with single, two and more then two pronuclei. Activation at 2 h after cell injection yielded more embryos with pronuclei and yielded 8-cell NT embryos more reliably than did activation at 3-4 h. In conclusion, microtubules assembled around condensed DNA at 1-2 h after cell injection, and formed a spindle at 2 h after SCNT, which separated at 2 h after activation; early development was affected by activation time, but no different between single and multiple pronuclei.

Cytogenetic analysis and developmental assessment of mouse embryos derived from in vitro fertilization of oocytes reconstructed by meiosis-II chromosome transplantation

An electrofusion methodology for transferring meiosis-II chromosomes (M-II-t) has not been completely established. The present study compared the use of two temperatures (fusion at 37 C for Group A and 25 C for Group B) during an electrofusion procedure for mouse oocyte M-II-t and investigated the cytogenetic normality and developmental competence of embryos derived from in vitro fertilization using oocytes reconstructed by M-II-t. The M-II-t oocytes were fertilized in vitro and cultured to the blastocyst stage; the resultant embryos were analyzed cytogenetically. Subsequently, chromosomal normality of the resultant embryos at the prometaphase stage of first cleavage division and the integrity of the meiosis-II spindles of the reconstructed oocytes were analyzed. The success rate of electrofusion in Group B was 92.1%, which was significantly different from that in Group A (49.2%) (P<0.05). The fertilization rates (A, 80.7%; B, 77.2%) and development rates (A, 70.9%; B, 65.5%) in the M-II-t groups were significantly lower than those in the control group (95.0 and 92.2%, respectively) (P<0.05). The incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in the Group A embryos (20.5%) at the blastocyst stage was significantly higher than that in the control group embryos (8.5%) (P<0.05), but the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in Group B (12.5%) was not significantly different compared with the other groups. A temperature of 25 C during the electrofusion procedure for M-II-t resulted in a good fusion rate, good development rate, and efficient production of chromosomally normal blastocysts. Furthermore, the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in the first cleavage embryos at the prometaphase stage in Group B (9.6%) did not differ significantly from that in the control group (6.6%). The spindle morphology of the M-II-t oocytes in Group B was normal.

Membrane and cortical abnormalities in post-ovulatory aged eggs: analysis of fertilizability and establishment of the membrane block to polyspermy

Fertilization at increased times after ovulation is associated with poor reproductive outcomes. This study examines the effects of post-ovulatory ageing on egg membrane function through analyses of mouse eggs collected at 13 and 22 h post-HCG ('young' and 'aged' eggs, respectively). Experiments in which fertilized zona pellucida-free young and aged eggs are challenged with additional sperm reveal that aged eggs are less able to establish a membrane block to prevent polyspermy, since sperm penetrate 24% of fertilized aged eggs but are unable to penetrate fertilized young eggs. This is not due to a failure of aged eggs to respond to fertilization, as the extent of sperm-induced cortical granule exocytosis is similar in aged and young eggs. Post-ovulatory ageing also affects egg membrane receptivity to sperm as a subset of zona pellucida-free aged eggs are slow to fertilize or resistant to fertilization. Sperm binding to young and aged eggs is similar, but aged eggs develop cytoskeletal abnormalities that may affect membrane/cortical function, such as the ability of the egg membrane to support sperm-egg fusion. These data demonstrate that the poor reproductive outcomes associated with post-ovulatory ageing could be a result of reduced fertilization, due to reduced egg membrane receptivity to sperm, or a result of increased incidence of polyspermy, due to the reduced ability to establish a membrane block to polyspermy. This analysis of egg membrane function deficiencies provides insights into post-ovulatory ageing and has implications for assisted reproductive technologies.

Assessing chromosomal abnormalities in two-cell bovine in vitro-fertilized embryos by using fluorescent in situ hybridization with three different cloned probes

The aim of this study was to assess the efficiency of fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) for detecting chromosomal abnormalities in in vitro-fertilized (IVF) bovine embryos as early as the 2-cell stage. Three different cloned probes were used, two derived from a unique sequence specific to the subtelomeric (D1S48) or subcentromeric regions (19C10) of chromosome 1 and the third (H1A clone) derived from a repetitive sequence that hybridizes to the subcentromeric regions of three other chromosomes (14, 20, 25). Our results show that the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in 2-cell bovine IVF embryos varied from 28% to 44% according to the probes used for the analysis. Whereas the efficiency of FISH was high with somatic nuclei, it appeared to be highly variable with the 2-cell embryos. FISH efficiency depended firstly on the probe sequence (repetitive or unique sequence), secondly on the chromosomal target region (centromeric or telomeric regions), and thirdly on the embryo cell cycle phase. With a unique sequence probe (19C10) specific to the subcentromeric regions, FISH efficiency was better on nuclei in the S-phase cycle than on those in the G-phase. In S-phase 2-cell embryos, the overall incidence of chromosomal abnormalities was more accurately assessed. It reached 13% and was represented by 1n/2n mixoploidies.

Chromosome analysis of BALB/c mouse spermatozoa with normal and abnormal head morphology

To assess the relationship between mouse sperm head morphology and karyotype, sperm heads with either a normal or an abnormal morphology were injected individually into enucleated mouse oocytes that were karyotyped at the metaphase of the first cleavage. BALB/c male mice that produce an unusually high proportion of morphologically abnormal spermatozoa were used as sperm donors. Abnormal karyotypes were found in a significantly higher proportion of eggs injected with severely misshapen sperm heads (36-38%) as compared to those injected with normal and quasi-normal heads (15-21%) (p < 0.01). Most karyotype abnormalities were structural rather than numerical, the most common being breaks and exchanges of chromosome type in both normal and abnormal spermatozoa.

Successful use of a laser for human embryo biopsy in preimplantation genetic diagnosis: report of two cases

PURPOSE

The use of Tyrode's acid to drill the zona pellucida for embryo biopsy is the most widely used methodology in preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Instead of this, we propose the use of a 1.48-micron diode noncontact laser, which is quicker, simpler, and safer.

METHODS

The laser beam was tangentially guided to the zona pellucida of the embryo. Depending on zona pellucida measurement, two to four consecutive shots of 8-22 msec were necessary to drill the zona pellucida of the 13 embryos biopsied for two patients (hemophilia carriers).

RESULTS

Female embryos were replaced into the uterus of the patients (1.5 embryos/replacement). One single pregnancy was established (33.3% implantation rate). Coculture of untransferable embryos showed a blastocyst rate of 66.7% (4/6) for male embryos and 25% (1/4) for abnormal ones.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate the safety and usefulness of laser methodology in preimplantation genetic diagnosis.

Penetration of concanavalin-A-treated Chinese hamster oocytes by golden hamster spermatozoa in vitro, and chromosome analysis of hybrid 1-cell zygotes

Pretreatment of zona-free Chinese hamster (CH) oocytes with three kinds of lectin--concanavalin A (Con-A), phytohaemagglutinin-P (PHA) and wheat germ agglutinin (WGA)--was attempted in order to improve penetration by golden hamster (GH) spermatozoa in vitro. Con-A had no significant effect on penetration at 2 micrograms/ml, adequately facilitated oocyte-sperm fusion at 4 micrograms/ml, and caused excessive sperm binding and resultant severe polyspermy at 10 micrograms/ml. Neither PHA nor WGA had positive effects on sperm penetration at any concentrations (2-10 micrograms/ml) examined. Using the Con-A (4 micrograms/ml) pretreatment, high rates of interspecific fertilisation and subsequent chromosome analysis of hybrid 1-cell zygotes were achieved. Among 258 CH oocytes used, 212 (82.2%) were fertilised and 153 (72.2% of fertilised ova) developed to the first cleavage metaphase. Eventually, 132 CH-derived chromosome complements and 153 GH-derived ones were successfully karyoanalysed. Incidences of aneuploidy and structural anomaly were 3.1% and 2.3% in CH complements, and 1.4% and 6.5% in GH complements, respectively. These incidences were not significantly different from those obtained by intraspecific in vivo fertilisation, suggesting that our interspecific in vitro fertilisation system does not cause chromosome aberrations.

Analysis of the chromosome complement of frozen-thawed mouse oocytes after parthenogenetic activation

Frozen-thawed mouse oocytes were artificially activated with Sr2+ and analyzed cytogenetically at the first cleavage division to examine the behavior of the maternal chromosomes independently of the paternal complement. There was no significant difference in the rate of activation between frozen-thawed and freshly collected oocytes and the majority of oocytes (> 90%) had a normal haploid chromosome constitution. The incidence of second polar body retention in frozen-thawed oocytes was low and did not differ significantly from that observed in fresh oocytes and oocytes exposed to dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) at 0 degree C or 37 degrees C for extended periods beyond those required for protection. The frequency of aneuploidy was similar for frozen-thawed and fresh oocytes but oocytes held at 0 degree C without DMSO or held at 37 degrees C with DMSO for 1 hr showed a 2.5 and 12-fold increase in the frequency of aneuploidy compared with oocytes subjected to a conventional oocyte/embryo freezing regime. It is concluded that the procedures used in successful oocyte cryopreservation do not increase the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities of maternal origin in the resulting embryos.

Cytogenetic studies of oocyte fusion products

We describe for the first time the cytogenetic characteristics of mouse 'embryos' obtained by oocyte fusion (oocyte fusion products; OFP). Our results indicate that, after fusion, meiosis II is resumed correctly, with extrusion of two haploid polar bodies, and that metaphase synchronisation of the two haploid sets and chromosome segregation during the first cleavage are also normal.

The human embryo: a scientist's point of view

...Thus, my judgement is that a human embryo is not a human person, and so we may do experiments on it which involve killing it. But my judgement is also that a human embryo has the potential to become a human being. The consequence of this attribute is that it imposes limits on the kinds of experiments which may be performed on human embryos. It is this which sets the boundaries. Experiments which may harm the embryo while still allowing it subsequently to realise its potential, and become a person, should not be permitted. It is the potentiality of the human embryo which governs our behaviour towards it. Its potential makes it special, and radically different from any other human tissue. This potential which the early embryo has means that great respect must always be accorded it, and great thought and care must surround any dealings with it....

The genetic risks of in vitro fertilization techniques: the use of an animal model

PURPOSE

The influence of some technical and biological parameters on the genetic characteristics of embryos derived from in vitro fertilization (IVF) techniques was studied.

METHOD

Using a murine model, we assessed the effect of gamete manipulation, gamete maturation stage, and maternal age on the chromosome complements of first-cleavage embryos.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

We found a positive correlation between some of these parameters and the incidence of the different chromosome abnormalities studied. Regarding aneuploidy, we observed an influence of maternal age, using both prepubertal and old females. Polyspermy showed a positive correlation with in vitro fertilization, the immaturity and overmaturity of the oocytes employed, and the use of prepubertal females. The appearance of diploid female complements was related to oocyte immaturity and prepubertal females, while diploid male complements were directly related to in vitro fertilization. Premature chromosome condensation (PCC) had a direct relationship with oocyte immaturity and in vitro maturation of the oocyte. Finally, structural abnormalities were associated with the process of sperm aging in vitro.

Numerical chromosome anomalies after fertilization of freeze-thawed mouse oocytes

The chromosome complement of first cleavage stage mouse embryos was analyzed to investigate the effect of slow freezing-fast thawing cryopreservation on chromosome numbers by comparing these numbers with those found fresh after fertilization of control oocytes. Fewer frozen-thawed (34.1%) than control oocytes (75.0%) cleaved to the 2-cell stage after in vitro fertilization. The incidence of hyperploidy was significantly increased by freezing (4.5% vs. 0% in controls). Polyploidy was not significantly affected (17.0% for freeze-thaw embryos vs. 26.2% for controls).

Influence of male sexual rest and oocyte aging on parthenogenesis frequency in mice: cytogenetic analysis after in vitro fertilization

This study was conducted to evaluate the influence of male sexual rest and oocyte aging on fertilization rate and parthenogenesis frequency after in vitro fertilization of mouse oocytes. We used a comparison between cleavage rates and fertilization rates according to chromosomal analysis of oocytes to estimate the parthenogenesis frequency. Fertilization rate was not impaired by male sexual rest. Parthenogenesis frequency was increased by male sexual rest. This effect was enhanced by a concomitant moderate oocyte aging. It is concluded that cleavage rate could not be considered as a reliable test of fertilization after attempted in vitro fertilization in such conditions.

Cytogenetics of human oocytes, zygotes, and embryos after in vitro fertilization

Chromosome errors, inherited or arising de novo during gametogenesis and transmitted at fertilization to the conceptus, may be a major cause of embryonic mortality. The in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (IVF/ET) procedure provides extra material--oocytes, zygotes, and embryos--to investigate the contribution of chromosomal abnormality to implantation failure. This paper reviews the results of cytogenetic studies on such material. Estimates from a total of 1120 oocytes from 11 studies give an overall proportion of chromosomal abnormality of 35%. Single and multiple nullisomies and disomies are found, involving nonrandom chromosome gain or loss. Hypohaploid complements are more frequent than hyperhaploid complements. The higher rate of chromosome loss of hypohaploid karyotypes was found to be largely artifactual. The estimated overall frequency of aneuploidy is 13%. In embryos the level of chromosomal abnormality is 23%-40%. Errors of fertilization are responsible for a substantial number of triploid embryos, many of which develop into mosaics. Factors extrinsic to the conceptus, such as infertility, advanced maternal age, and ovarian hyperstimulation, may increase the level of chromosomal abnormality. More refined methods for accurately recognizing and selecting chromosomally normal embryos for transfer are needed to improve the success rate of this reproductive technology.

Chromosome constitution of highly motile mouse sperm

In this study, we address the relationship between motility and genetic content of mouse sperm. The chromosome complements of highly motile mouse sperm, selected using the swim-up technique, were analyzed after in vitro fertilization, at the first cleavage state. They were compared to those of unselected sperm. Identification of male and female chromosome sets was possible because of their differential condensation at the first mitotic division. In vitro fertilization, swim-up separation, chromosome preparation, and staining were carried out using standard techniques. The results indicate that highly motile mouse sperm did not differ in types and frequencies of chromosomal abnormalities from those not selected for motility. Moreover, separation of motile sperm does not deviate the sex ratio from the theoretical 1:1.

Significance of structural chromosome aberrations in human sperm: analysis of induced aberrations

A significant increase in the incidence of structural chromosome anomalies has been observed in the sperm of patients treated with radio and/or chemotherapy for different types of cancer when analyzed by the interspecific fertilization of hamster eggs. The analysis of these aberrations shows that while in controls only 9.4% of structural abnormalities are of the stable type, in treated patients this figure increases to 39.3%, thus indicating that the anomalies have not been produced during the fertilization of the hamster egg. However, it is possible that part, or even most, of the breaks appear as a result of a reduced repair capacity of sperm chromosomes in the cytoplasm of the hamster egg.

Effect of the degree of maturation of mouse oocytes at fertilization: a source of chromosome imbalance

It has been suggested that the abnormal maturation of the human oocyte during fertilization in vitro may result in chromosome imbalance and induce embryonic loss. Using a mouse model, we have studied the influence of the degree of oocyte maturation (either immaturity or overmaturity) on the chromosome characteristics of embryos at the first-cleavage division. Immature oocytes were obtained 2-3 h or 3-4 h before the expected ovulation time (b.o.). Overmaturation was induced by aging the newly ovulated oocytes in vitro for 3, 6, and 12 h. Our results show a significant decrease in the fertilization rate in the immature groups (65.53% at 2-3 h b.o. and 16.59% at 3-4 h b.o. vs. 78.22% at control) and after 12 h of in vitro aging (69.39%), while a significant increase of this parameter was found at 3 h of aging (82.59%) as compared to the other groups. No significant differences were found in the occurrence of aneuploidy or hyperhaploidy in embryos obtained from immature, newly ovulated, and overmature oocytes. Finally, an increased incidence of polyploidy was detected in immature, 2-3 h b.o. (31.20%), and overmature, 3 h (23.04%) and 6 h (31.61%), groups as compared to the control group (14.59%).

Cytogenetic analysis of in vitro fertilization (IVF) failures

Cytogenetic studies were carried out on 150 oocytes obtained in a human in vitro fertilization (IVF) program. Although all cells lacked signs of fertilization at light microscopy, 46 (30.7%) appeared to show cytological evidence of fertilization. At least one-third of these cells (with development arrested before first cleavage) had chromosomal aberrations. An aneuploidy rate of 35% was found in unfertilized oocytes. The results of this study explain some of the fertilization failures and of the failures of postfertilization development.

Analysis of the chromosome complement in outbred mouse sperm fertilizing in vitro

The chromosome complements in a population of mouse sperm from random-bred ICR donors were analyzed at first-cleavage metaphase after in vitro fertilization (IVF) of oocytes from females of the same strain. The sperm were aged as donations occurred within an average of 31 days, either since last mating or at arrival at the animal facility in the case of virgin males. Of a total of 598 sperm complements studied from 22 sexually mature males aged 10-26 weeks old, there was one diploid complement (0.17%). The frequencies of hyperhaploidy and structural aberrations that were studied in 338 complements were 4.4% and 3.6%, respectively, giving an overall frequency of 8.0%. The hyperhaploid complements consisted of n + 1, n + 2, n + 3, and n + 7 counts, while the structural abnormalities were of the chromosome type and included large and small fragments and a possible translocation. This is the highest frequency of sperm chromosome abnormalities reported for mouse sperm obtained from males under physiological conditions and fertilized in vitro or in vivo. Sperm aging, strain, and/or technique differences are among the factors that may be responsible for this high frequency. Since the 8.0% frequency of hyperhaploidy and structural abnormalities is similar to the frequency reported for human sperm after IVF, the outbred murine in vitro fertilization system may be a useful model to study the origin of human sperm chromosome abnormalities.

Effects of aging on the zona pellucida surface of mouse oocytes

In a scanning microscopy study of mouse oocytes from immature, young, and aged females and of oocytes aged in vivo or in vitro, we have observed four types of zona pellucida, which we classify as types A, B, C, and D. Oocyte aging gives rise to a significant increase in predegenerative (type C) oocytes; this type of zona pellucida surface could result from a zona hardening effect and decrease the rate of fertilization of the oocytes affected.

The genotoxic effect of beta-propiolactone on mammalian oocytes

beta-Propiolactone (beta PL) has been tested on preimplantation mouse embryos for possible genotoxic effects. Tests were performed at different stages of meiosis (late prophase I, diakinesis/metaphase I, anaphase I, telophase I/prophase II and metaphase II) by injecting females at various times after the induction of superovulation. Male and female derived chromosome complements from first-cleavage embryos were analysed before syngamy for cytogenetic abnormalities. A higher proportion of diploid oocytes, produced by the non-extrusion of the first or second polar body, was found after fertilization when the compound was administered immediately before metaphase I or II. No obvious effect was detected at any other time of beta PL exposure. Based on these results, several possible modes of action for beta PL are postulated.

Preimplantation development following in vitro fertilization of mouse oocytes: effects of timing of superovulation and preincubation in vitro

The early embryonic development of in vitro fertilized oocytes was assessed following superovulation in F1 hybrid (C57BL/6 X CBA/Ca) mice. Decreasing the time interval between the administration of constant doses of pregnant mare's serum gonadotropin (PMSG) and human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) resulted in decreases in the frequency of development to the blastocyst stage but had no significant effect on development to the two-cell stage. Preincubation of postovulatory oocytes in vitro prior to insemination did not compensate for the reduced preovulatory development in vivo but resulted in decreases in the frequency of development to the blastocyst stage. The results indicate that inadequate preovulatory development of superovulated mouse oocytes can adversely affect the preimplantation development of in vitro fertilized embryos in the absence of a visible inhibitory effect on development to the two-cell stage and also that preincubation of postovulatory oocytes in vitro prior to fertilization reduces subsequent developmental capacity.